New Culture Forum - October 26, 2020


Is Government Reaction To Covid A Threat To Civil Liberties? A Price Worth Paying Or Too High?

David Kurten: Why I Launched The Heritage Party To Combat The Progressive & Globalist Agenda How Significant Is The 2020 US Election & What Might A Trump Or Biden Victory Mean?

Episode Stats


Length

41 minutes

Words per minute

173.8

Word count

7,137

Sentence count

232


Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
00:00:00 hello and welcome to counterculture I'm Peter Whittle now over the past few weeks we've seen
00:00:19 three demonstrations in London which are protesting about the lockdown and indeed
00:00:26 the removal of civil liberties. Is this a real thing? Are we in fact seeing the gradual erosion
00:00:35 of centuries worth of civil liberties or is this an overreaction? In fact, should we in fact give
00:00:44 up some of those liberties in the face of this pandemic? Now with me to discuss this today I'm
00:00:50 very pleased we have four guests. First of all, Mark Sidwell, who is the author of the New Culture
00:00:57 Forum book, The Long March. Nigel Jones, historian and author. Dr. Kevin Corbett, who is a health
00:01:06 scientist and retired nurse of 36 years standing. And the New Culture Forum's Rafe Hadelman,
00:01:14 coup historian and commentator um thank you for joining us can i ask first of all as i did in the
00:01:20 title there um are we basically seeing our civil liberties being eroded in a way that means that
00:01:28 they are gone forever nigel could be they're certainly being eroded and they could be gone
00:01:34 forever but i think once governments take a modicum of power they're very reluctant to release it
00:01:40 again and I think that's the big danger that all these restrictions and rules have been imposed
00:01:45 without parliamentary consent largely they've been nodded through because parliament was absent
00:01:51 because of the pandemic and I don't know when they're going to be given back to us and I think
00:01:58 that's the big danger. Would you agree with that? Yeah I mean you know it's the classic saying isn't
00:02:04 it that there's nothing so permanent as a temporary government program. The famous example might be
00:02:09 like the pub restrictions that were put in place in 1914 to aid the war effort in World
00:02:14 War I, not repealed until the 1980s. So whatever you think in the short term about the new
00:02:22 curfew, the 10pm closing time for pubs, even if it's a good idea in the short term, that
00:02:29 doesn't mean that it's easy to get rid of. And this general concern I think that I have,
00:02:33 and I have some sympathy for the need for the emergency action, but that everything
00:02:38 seems to be done not on a sort of emergency basis with sunset clauses in a real sense that this is
00:02:43 just temporary and we're going to get back to a more liberal society but but simply on the basis
00:02:48 that we might need this for forever or just until we come up with a system of repeal and none of
00:02:54 that's built in and that that is a real reason for concern even if you think in the short term
00:02:58 that this is worth doing. Kevin have you been surprised at basically how compliant people have
00:03:06 been extremely concerned about it and as somebody who's been involved in two of those protests in
00:03:15 london over the last couple of months you can see at a granular level what we've just said you know
00:03:21 in terms of the removal of rights and freedoms on the basis of a quite a hysterical response
00:03:29 to what we're told is a public health issue.
00:03:33 And at a granular level,
00:03:36 you can see also the arbitrary nature of this as it impacts.
00:03:41 For example, the BLM demonstrated all the way through the summer
00:03:46 and the police knelt to them in London.
00:03:50 And the two protests that I was involved in,
00:03:52 the police didn't kneel to us.
00:03:54 They were actually sent in to do baton charges against peaceful protests.
00:03:59 We saw this particularly with the last one, didn't we?
00:04:01 Yes, and that was the last one that was coordinated by Louise Crefield and Piers Corbyn on the 26th.
00:04:09 The one I was involved in as a speaker, as an invited speaker on the 19th,
00:04:14 the TSG, the Territorial Support Group, which is a riot police, were sent in to clear people.
00:04:22 And these were people that were there.
00:04:24 They were advised about social distancing.
00:04:27 There had been a risk assessment. All the requirements had been carried out, and yet it was a disproportionate response.
00:04:36 And when you see that at a grassroots level, you can understand what's happening.
00:04:41 And these were doctors, nurses talking to the public.
00:04:46 And the question you have to ask is, OK, we're told there's a public health emergency.
00:04:52 the public can see the flaws in the science from a very grassroots level.
00:05:00 They see the tests have no accuracy.
00:05:02 They see the track and trace doesn't work.
00:05:05 They see QR codes being forced on them through trading standards,
00:05:09 which will be used to shut their businesses and stop their income.
00:05:13 So at a very basic level, this has got to add up for people.
00:05:18 And people may have become compliant very quickly because of the globalist mantra, the globalist nature of the emergency.
00:05:28 But at a grassroots level now, I think you're finding people are pushing back.
00:05:33 And people are realizing that a lot of things don't add up about the science and the tests.
00:05:39 And that what they've been told is not necessarily the truth.
00:05:43 For example, the situation in the nursing homes.
00:05:46 We heard a lot about the tests not being done and people being pushed into nursing homes from the hospital acute sector.
00:05:53 What we didn't hear about was what the Queen's Nursing Institute came out with a few weeks ago,
00:05:59 which is the results of a survey that showed that people, whole groups of people, and I'm quoting here,
00:06:06 were coded not for resuscitation on the basis of advice from hospitals and clinical commissioning groups.
00:06:13 So patients and residents were coded not for resuscitation, not through negotiation with their clinicians, which is the normal way of doing things, but through diktat from faceless bureaucrats.
00:06:27 And that's quite concerning, and that was a report by Professor Alison Leary from Southbank University, he's a professor of community nursing, and it was commissioned by the Queen's Nursing Institute, which is not a conspiratorial organisation, it is a very, very credible research organisation for community nursing.
00:06:47 So when the public were coming up to me at rallies up and down the country
00:06:51 for the last couple of months saying to me,
00:06:54 Kevin, my mother had a form put in front of her in the nursing home
00:06:58 and she's told to sign it, which coded her not for resuscitation.
00:07:02 We were concerned that nobody picked up the phone to us.
00:07:06 It wasn't a decision that was negotiated with the doctor or nurse.
00:07:10 It's something that came down from above.
00:07:13 And now we have evidence of that in this report.
00:07:16 And it's those sorts of things, Peter, that people are very concerned about.
00:07:21 Ralph, do you think that civil liberties, the implication being ancient ones actually, have really been affected?
00:07:33 Or do you think this is hyperbole?
00:07:35 It's not hyperbole at all.
00:07:37 History shows us that liberty is lost not always at the hands of a tyrant, but through well-intentioned measures, albeit misplaced measures.
00:07:44 and there's this gentle and gradual erosion that we're seeing and we know full well from
00:07:51 history that institutions as we've seen with the supreme court once institutions acquire power
00:07:56 they want to acquire more power even if they don't intend to do so and certainly in terms of
00:08:02 this government that's precisely what we've seen and you know history has also shown us as you've
00:08:08 just said well one of the benefits of being a historian is you can actually look at things
00:08:13 in perspective and take a broader picture and put things into context and so in terms of global
00:08:18 pandemics throughout history this is perhaps the mildest we have ever seen and yet we're employing
00:08:23 and engaging the most extreme measures that we've ever seen we're talking about measures which even
00:08:28 in wartime we haven't seen why in order solely to protect people who are essentially above 65 or
00:08:35 above 70 with comorbidities that the entire population has now got to suffer the same
00:08:40 sorts of shielding protections and it is a case that this is being affected through fear without
00:08:47 any scientific justification it's the policy of fear that has been basically causing the British
00:08:52 public to acquiesce into this because as you said there has to be justification for these
00:08:57 policies and as we've seen the government may say that it's following the science but it's not
00:09:02 following the science. Well you know I think it's important when we look at this that we try and
00:09:07 steel man the arguments you know we try and say what's what's the you know the best argument for
00:09:11 the other side and and you know i am deeply concerned about what might be the long-term
00:09:16 implications of the changes in this sort of uh of liberties i mean i remember it it's not that
00:09:22 long ago that the idea of you know a traditional idea of the government stays out of people's
00:09:27 bedrooms was a sort of basic idea of liberalism and now suddenly casual sex or outside an
00:09:32 established relationship Matt Hancock is telling us it's illegal these are bizarre times in those
00:09:37 ways very normal everyday liberties but at the same time it's not entirely uncontroversial to
00:09:43 say that this is a very mild pandemic and it's worth saying what do we do if there are real
00:09:50 dangers here not the same dangers as might have been if it was the black death or if it was a
00:09:54 more severe one but given that large numbers of people potentially could still die at a population
00:10:00 level given that it's very very hard to shield these vulnerable populations given that large
00:10:06 numbers of the population come into contact with them or if they're younger you know so i'm just
00:10:11 saying it's important that we don't just because we care about the liberties give ourselves an easy
00:10:17 time on thinking about the disease but mark we discussed this in in april and in april i made
00:10:22 the very same argument that we have to actually balance lives with quality of life which now
00:10:27 people are calling livelihoods but back then i called it quality of life and also you know people
00:10:33 dying from other diseases be it cancer be it heart disease and stroke heart attacks rather
00:10:37 people being too scared to present themselves and you know hospitals know full well the policies of
00:10:43 triaging right triaging is making a choice as to who is actually going to merit certain medical
00:10:48 interventions and unfortunately we have a government following feelings rather than facts
00:10:54 And we are at a point where actually the nation needs to consider triaging the nation and realizing there are consequences at play here.
00:11:00 And as I said again in April, it's the old philosophical argument of the trolley, you know, the trolley quandary.
00:11:05 If you have a trolley going down the tracks and you have the ability to divert the track to save one person, but by doing so it may kill other people, what do you do?
00:11:13 And unfortunately, my view then was that we have made the wrong decision.
00:11:16 And I think, unfortunately, that, you know, the past few months are now bearing that out.
00:11:19 Well, I think you make a good point there, but I mean, to qualify it a little bit more, I'd say that the issue about triage and what doctors call the differential diagnosis when somebody presents to hospital with symptoms is key to this.
00:11:37 And we've had mislabelling of people as COVID cases who have a set of generic symptoms that could be hundreds of different things.
00:11:47 And because of the tsunami of propaganda that went ahead of this whole hysterical approach to COVID, doctors and nurses themselves have become victims, perhaps, or infected with, perhaps that's the wrong word, this propaganda.
00:12:06 so they interpret a set of generic symptoms
00:12:09 what the government says is COVID
00:12:10 as COVID before they even have a test
00:12:14 and therefore people have been labelled as COVID
00:12:17 and fast-tracked down the pathway of ventilation
00:12:22 and we know where that ended up.
00:12:25 Mark, but if I remember when we discussed before
00:12:27 you wouldn't necessarily have thought it was hysterical, would you?
00:12:32 You were a little bit more nuanced in your attitude
00:12:34 to to the disease to the pandemic yeah and i think even though we know much more about it now
00:12:41 um it still seems to me that if you look at the numbers and if you're trying to make these
00:12:46 decisions under tremendous uncertainty potentially still it's not implausible that very large numbers
00:12:51 of people could die this winter of covid in amongst all of the um the mislabeling and so
00:12:58 forth this is a very serious disease for certain people we do have large enough numbers of those
00:13:03 people in the UK if we don't get lucky on t-cell immunity and things like that if we don't get
00:13:08 lucky on a low level of herd immunity there's plenty of people who could still get it and it
00:13:13 could still kill them who are going to be in hospital for a very long time even if they don't
00:13:17 the these are serious effects to worry about the organ damage long covid in the young and healthy
00:13:23 so so i think there are real problems then you do have to balance that and and simply the fact
00:13:28 that we just don't know the answers and it's moving all the time and you have to act early
00:13:33 In the nature of pandemics, you have to act before you have the information,
00:13:35 before all the cases are there.
00:13:37 Or you have what we had the first time around, where Boris waited to act.
00:13:41 But is it really a pandemic?
00:13:42 The global statistic is something like a 99% recovery rate.
00:13:50 But I think these are just games with words.
00:13:53 If there's a new virus to which most people don't have any immunity,
00:13:57 which is spreading around the world potentially at exponential rates
00:14:00 that can kill large numbers of people and has been declared a pandemic by the who you know i
00:14:06 have my own problems with but you know at least that's one definition of it we can play games
00:14:10 with words but that's that's a pandemic on on most normal well who didn't declare it a pandemic
00:14:16 initially and there's a lot of uncertainty over that and i think people die every year from flu
00:14:24 i mean where's the flu epidemic this year have you thought about that every year is a flu epidemic
00:14:29 and lots of people die older people die everybody's worked in the nhs and i've worked in it for 36
00:14:36 years know about flu epidemics and yet the numbers were greater in previous years when you add them
00:14:44 up not just flu but bronchopneumonia and other chest conditions which would really dwarf this
00:14:51 covid pandemic into a nutshell really when you look at it in the global so you know i mean that's
00:14:57 But what seems to be happening here is basically judging whether this is a pandemic or not,
00:15:05 is there a definite connection between one's concern about civil liberties
00:15:11 and your scepticism or not about the pandemic?
00:15:15 That's the point.
00:15:16 You can actually believe in the fact there's a pandemic,
00:15:18 but actually be surely very concerned about what seems to be arbitrary
00:15:25 in position of various restrictions, wouldn't you say no?
00:15:29 Well, I would say that.
00:15:30 And my concerns as a historian, as Rafe said,
00:15:34 being a historian, you do get to look back
00:15:37 at certain crises that have happened before.
00:15:41 And the obvious ones are the two world wars
00:15:44 and the Spanish flu pandemic in 1918-19,
00:15:48 which is probably the most recent pandemic
00:15:52 on the scale of COVID.
00:15:53 It was much, much worse than COVID, and 50 million people across the world died of it, 20 million in Europe alone.
00:16:01 But there was nothing like these measures.
00:16:04 People did wear masks. There was a lot of disinfecting of public transport, buses and so on in those days.
00:16:09 But we recovered very, very quickly.
00:16:12 I mean, there's been hundreds and thousands of books written on the First World War.
00:16:18 there's been about 10 written on the pandemic, which killed three times more or four times more
00:16:24 people than the war. And that gives you an idea. So I do think we have overreacted to this because
00:16:31 even in a worst case scenario, COVID is going to be nothing like, nothing like the scale of
00:16:38 the Spanish flu. And we recovered from that within two, three years after in the early 20s.
00:16:45 So what really concerns me is the fact that we had a war cabinet in both world wars, a very narrow number, a small number of people conducting a world war.
00:16:57 We now have a very, very small number of people, possibly even smaller than Churchill's and Lloyd George's war cabinets, conducting the war against COVID.
00:17:07 And that does worry me, that the government is taking its advice from a very small group of scientists whose scientific advice is contested.
00:17:15 But they're also hiding it not only from the public, the reasons for what they're doing, they're hiding it from Parliament as well.
00:17:23 Which is, if we are a democratic society, that is where it should be discussed and thrashed out.
00:17:28 And it hasn't been. And that is gravely worrying.
00:17:30 It's interesting, isn't it?
00:17:32 because look you know there's been brexit and there's been the campaign for brexit and the
00:17:37 sovereignty of parliament and what has actually been extraordinary about this is the parliament
00:17:41 seems entirely irrelevant and no one's really protesting about it uh on left or right well
00:17:48 it's quite perverse isn't it we've gone from a situation a few months ago where parliament was
00:17:52 thwarting the democratic will of of the people that the government was trying to install to now
00:17:58 we've got the opposite situation where the government is acting irrespective of the wishes
00:18:03 of parliament or get the whole government to account to it's an extremely perverse dichotomy
00:18:06 here um but speaking of dichotomy i also think there's a false dichotomy being set up here in
00:18:10 terms of it's a question of liberty to the point of letting coronavirus rip through society without
00:18:16 any checks at all i don't think anyone is saying that um so it's not a question of basically having
00:18:20 you know liberty or death quite literally in that context and we look at the asian flu of 56 57 and
00:18:26 And you look at America, particularly under Eisenhower, a very comparable situation, far worse in many respects.
00:18:33 Nothing like we had no lockdown at all.
00:18:35 The economy was able to bounce back and so forth.
00:18:37 You know, scientists at the time in Sweden were saying, look, the three basic things are wash your hands, keep social distance.
00:18:43 I mean, that's basically all that you need to do.
00:18:46 And that was the policy.
00:18:47 We have to remember, Britain was embarked upon a similar policy to Sweden.
00:18:51 and the Swedes were really encouraged by the fact
00:18:54 that they weren't going to be the only ones
00:18:56 going down this radical path
00:18:57 they were so heartened by the fact
00:18:59 that we were coming along with them
00:19:00 and Chris Whitty if you remember
00:19:02 originally had said
00:19:03 this is going to be mild effects
00:19:05 for most people who will get over it
00:19:07 the people who needed to be cocooned
00:19:10 were those people who were over 70
00:19:11 the rest of society should go about their business
00:19:14 and it was only when you had
00:19:15 the mention of herd immunity
00:19:17 and you had this panic in the media
00:19:19 and this outrage in the media
00:19:20 followed by Neil Ferguson's ridiculous notions
00:19:24 of 500,000 dead in the Imperial College modelling
00:19:27 that the government panicked and changed course.
00:19:31 And, of course, they believed for some reason
00:19:33 that the Brits wouldn't actually be following any lockdown.
00:19:37 They expected that there would only be about a 70% or so adherence
00:19:41 to the lockdown, and so they exaggerated beyond belief
00:19:44 with this fear system, and they used their effective slogans.
00:19:48 You know, we had take back control,
00:19:50 we had let's get brexit done and then they put in this new slogan about about the lockdown and it
00:19:55 worked too much and once you've been still fearing people it's very hard then to backtrack and say
00:20:00 actually we weren't really that serious it wasn't that bad and to save their own backs they haven't
00:20:04 been able to admit that and so this lockdown that only was put into place for one reason
00:20:09 to flatten the curve not to stop a single death we were told it was simply to enable the nhs
00:20:15 to gather its resources build up these hospitals which had space for 4 000 people in the nightingale
00:20:20 hospital here only had 60 patients in any bedrooms and yet after that we're told that now the
00:20:26 parameters have changed and they couldn't backtrack on the fear quota but you see therefore i mean
00:20:31 people watching this or watching the news will be thinking you know these ridiculous figures that
00:20:36 you mentioned from neil ferguson the fact that when he's done this before for other pandemics
00:20:43 have been equally bad uh why are they why are they taking notice again will you explain to me what
00:20:51 is your why are they particularly as neil ferguson himself promptly flouted the rules that he had
00:20:57 recommended for his own um nefarious purposes um going in them screwing another man's wife but um
00:21:04 um that is that is part of what i was saying that the terrible mistake is to take this advice from
00:21:12 such a small group of people who had a dubious previous record because um neil ferguson's
00:21:19 record foot and mouth uh all the other things that he got so hopelessly wrong why did the government
00:21:26 then do a u-turn and change its policy which had been as rafe said following the swedes on the say
00:21:32 so of this man it's it's absurd it's mad haven't you been surprised we're talking about civil
00:21:37 liberties remember um i take that as well to be uh freedom of assembly you know the englishman
00:21:44 englishman's mat uh home is his castle all of this sort of thing one characteristic of the
00:21:50 british and english was always a kind of truculence about freedom and and not just simply going under
00:21:57 the cosh you know i haven't seen that much of that characteristic around this time would you say
00:22:04 Well I mean Boris did did actually mention it when he did his broadcast the other week and he said
00:22:08 well we're a freedom loving people and that's maybe that's why we've had some difficulty we
00:22:13 haven't behaved maybe um Europeans would have been more more tractable so from his point of view he
00:22:18 has he has at least referenced that I thought was something I mean something that though that is
00:22:23 worth saying um because obviously it's somewhat against the the spirit around this particular
00:22:28 table and and I suspect among those listening too but uh there is vast support in the country
00:22:33 for these measures and you can call it fear but I mean these are people thinking for themselves
00:22:40 and able to access the evidence and so I wouldn't be that dismissive about it there is a vast
00:22:48 majority in in the British people to to follow these measures now I think they may not be that
00:22:55 well informed on what the long-term economic consequences are maybe on what the the long-term
00:23:00 prospect of getting traditional liberties back out of that but for the moment at least that is there
00:23:05 and it has to be considered as well we can't just say this is just sort of the government versus the
00:23:11 public or the people the public are are behind these measures in in consideration that's hardly
00:23:16 surprising because of the vast propaganda campaign that that happened at the beginning to terrify and
00:23:22 scare people and then as someone said hang on hang on yes that's true hang on we sort of can't have
00:23:28 our cake and eat it on the polls i mean first of all it's true it's something like 63 percent of
00:23:33 higher higher and indeed some people want even tougher uh clothes within that we managed not
00:23:40 to get frightened by project fear with the referendum campaign did we not so therefore
00:23:47 you know i mean how do you account for this compliance but it's worth remembering that
00:23:50 britain's are statistically the most scared people in europe if not the world and that's
00:23:54 So I think about COVID, and that is because of the fear project and the reason the fear project was installed was because Boris Johnson did believe that we were a nation of liberty lovers. And that unless there was the fear of God put into us, that we would actually resist all of this. He was proved wrong. And then the fear had adverse effects, but there was that policy. But of course, and you're quite right, Johnson did say recently, it's because we're an independent liberty loving people that we have got worse results than in Germany.
00:24:23 but then to use that logic spain is a much more liberty loving place than we are so i'm not really
00:24:27 quite sure but the point being is that i mean we were all of us probably involved in some way in
00:24:32 the brexit campaign or something i mean the fact is from every single angle of our establishment
00:24:38 every single one uh was saying this is going to be well world war three actually at one point
00:24:44 and yet people still had the guts i mean that's why we were so inspired to go against that why
00:24:50 Why are they not having the guts to this time? Is it because it's about death?
00:24:53 Well, I think one point that's been raised is the word establishment and also the mainstream media
00:25:01 and the way the government put this information out in a very propagandist way.
00:25:06 And you had really saturation coverage in the media.
00:25:11 You could actually look at the medical officer every five minutes on the TV with that poe face of him
00:25:19 telling people that they're going to be dead and you know so people responded to that you know and
00:25:25 people soaked that up and they weren't exposed to alternative views on what was happening and if
00:25:31 you go up and down the country i have to take issue really there are alternatives there are
00:25:37 groups organizing in every town in this country and organizing against the lockdown measures
00:25:43 meeting in private, sometimes subversively, really, undercover.
00:25:48 So this is an alternative narrative that you don't hear in the mainstream.
00:25:52 Well, I think the real problem, in part, there wasn't so much about the government
00:25:55 as the sheer lack of quality in the mainstream or the traditional media.
00:26:00 I mean, they had the traditional lobby correspondents.
00:26:04 Yeah, not health correspondents.
00:26:04 They didn't know anything.
00:26:06 They were interested in the political stories,
00:26:08 and that kind of suited the government,
00:26:09 because why would they have effective people to question them?
00:26:12 But that was a disaster.
00:26:13 And they weren't allowed to ask certain questions.
00:26:16 For example, like the tests, the tests have no known accuracy.
00:26:20 They have no gold standard, an independent method of verifying their effectiveness and their performance.
00:26:27 And that's why there's so many false positives.
00:26:29 And all these test positives you're getting now are inflated false positives.
00:26:35 They're not people with symptoms.
00:26:36 They're people who've tested positive.
00:26:39 And that doesn't necessarily mean they have a virus.
00:26:41 That means they've tested positive.
00:26:43 for all sorts of other reasons.
00:26:46 I do think that Project Fear at the moment is breaking down, actually.
00:26:49 And I think this is particularly so with young people.
00:26:52 I mean, I've got a 20-year-old daughter, second year at university,
00:26:56 ha, ha, ha, since she didn't have a first year because of COVID, effectively.
00:27:01 And her and her friends, and I just see it myself,
00:27:04 travelling around on trains.
00:27:07 OK, they're doing the mask wearing.
00:27:10 They're minimal, minimal requirements.
00:27:14 But basically, as we saw in the summer, they're assembling in great numbers in the parks when it was so hot and so on
00:27:21 because young people have seen the statistics and they know that, by and large, they're not threatened by this disease.
00:27:29 And therefore, I think the project fear and the compliance is beginning to crack and crumble.
00:27:35 One thing that's very important here is that we're talking very much in a British context,
00:27:39 But when one says, oh, this is overstated and we're giving up liberties, you know, as a result of it, the argument that comes back so often is, yes, but it's the whole world doing it.
00:27:51 Well, that's true.
00:27:53 And I think, you know, an approach to this is people are very happy to give up liberties if they understand the rationale for that and that it makes sense on a day-to-day level.
00:28:05 But when they see inconsistencies, when they see the information's like a sieve that water goes right through, you know, it doesn't make sense to ordinary people.
00:28:17 They see, you know, this scientist ignoring the information and going off with somebody's wife.
00:28:24 They see this politician testing positive and travelling up and down the country.
00:28:29 You know, when they see that level of non-compliance from the experts and people that are supposed to be role modelling it, then of course it's going to undo all the good, inverted commas, that's been done.
00:28:43 And at a basic level, people then become aware of, well, actually, why should I wear a mask?
00:28:48 What is the evidence for masking?
00:28:50 And when you look at the advice from the experts that convinced the government to promote masking, they said there is no good evidence, there's no randomised controlled trials that show masking works.
00:29:02 So why should we be using it?
00:29:04 And it's actually the global example of erosion of civil liberties is another reason to be concerned because there's been an international report put out showing that there are 80 countries around the world where this is happening.
00:29:15 And there's a great concern about how COVID is being used as a smokescreen in undemocratic regimes, in repressive regimes, to actually stamp down on the press, to limit liberties, to actually have a reason to actually not hold elections.
00:29:29 People don't realise the laws in this country now permit the government to actually stop elections taking place as well and to close down borders.
00:29:35 And that's happening globally.
00:29:37 So you even have Greenpeace and Liberty speaking out about this erosion of civil liberties globally.
00:29:42 This is not just some sort of right-wing conspiracy sort of thing.
00:29:45 People on all levels are concerned about it.
00:29:47 But conspiracies are a danger.
00:29:49 I think one of the problems is, I think we could probably all agree,
00:29:51 there are issues going on about civil liberties.
00:29:54 There are, I would argue, at least some issues going on
00:29:57 around the dangerousness of the virus that we should think about.
00:30:01 But the problem is when people start to see these problems
00:30:03 and they use the internet and they're trying to work it out for themselves,
00:30:06 it can generate a sort of tremendous negation,
00:30:09 a sort of nihilism and paranoia in which there are plenty of conspiracy theories out there that are nonsense that are being spread.
00:30:17 And that can lead people towards a sort of reaction against any kind of sensible action.
00:30:23 You know, we could say that what's going on may be too much, an overreaction, but that doesn't mean there aren't things we should be doing.
00:30:29 And there is a danger that a move to say, well, it's all rubbish and we all need to listen to all of the rumours on the internet and go against all of this.
00:30:38 means that we might throw everything out in the process.
00:30:41 Well, you know, you talk about listening to rumours on the internet.
00:30:44 The paper that developed the tests, the PCR test,
00:30:49 from a sage scientist, Maria Zambon,
00:30:52 who's head of the Public Health England's testing for PCR for COVID,
00:30:57 was a paper shared across all the European health agencies in January.
00:31:02 So all the PHEs in each country
00:31:05 contributed to developing the workflow methodology for the covid PCR test and in that paper they used
00:31:13 rumour to develop the test because they went on the internet to find out whether the genetic
00:31:20 sequence was a SARS-CoV sequence by looking at the internet in in in China so they used rumour
00:31:28 to develop the test so when you talk about the public developing conspiracy theories and wild
00:31:34 things from the internet. The scientists themselves use rumour to develop the text.
00:31:38 But that's my point. I'm not saying that the internet isn't a tool. The problem is that as well as being a very
00:31:42 valuable tool, it has all sorts of fringe nonsense that get talked as well, and that there is a danger
00:31:48 that valuable things might be thrown out in the process, or paranoia might develop, and that can
00:31:54 have all sorts of unforeseen consequences. Well, I think the public's had a lot of paranoia and hysteria
00:31:59 from the government and from the safe scientists of the corona hysteria really yeah i think that
00:32:06 what is a lot of it comes down to sure is why people say well if this is you know if there
00:32:11 are ulterior motives or something what are they you know if this is happening all over the world
00:32:16 you mentioned you know elections you know what actually is behind it then i mean we've heard
00:32:23 heard of Bill Gates, we've heard of this, that and the other. Why would this be so uniformly
00:32:30 being done by most governments? What is behind it?
00:32:34 Who wants to be caught being wrong? Who wants to be the person who says, it's fine, we'll
00:32:38 stand back, and then suddenly in six months, hundreds of thousands of people are dead.
00:32:43 And that can be blamed on you if you're doing what everyone else is doing, safety in numbers.
00:32:46 I mean, okay, it might be wrong, but you know, I mean, Sweden got a lot of stick, right?
00:32:50 And let's face it, the death count is very bad.
00:32:54 It does seem to have gone down or sort of moderated in cases,
00:32:57 but that might change.
00:32:58 But, you know, if Sweden had gone even worse,
00:33:01 how much trouble would they be in?
00:33:03 I mean, this is a case that's slightly going off the civil liberties thing,
00:33:07 but the hysteria seems to have taken hold,
00:33:10 particularly in countries which no longer have very much of a religious framework,
00:33:14 that actually don't really think very much about death.
00:33:17 Well, that's a good point.
00:33:19 And I think that the backdrop to this, the terrain on which the seeds have fallen, the terrain on which they've grown, is one where medicine and biomedicine has become secular science.
00:33:35 And, you know, the position in which religion and spirituality had traditionally sat has gone.
00:33:44 You know, it's empty, and the position's been taken by biomedicine and people in white coats.
00:33:50 I think partly this explains the government's response to SAGE and to Imperial College.
00:33:57 And, you know, the paper that Imperial College published with the 500,000 projection,
00:34:02 they said that they're only dealing with the projections.
00:34:07 They're not looking at the ethical and economic impact of their projections.
00:34:12 And as an academic, I would fail an undergraduate student in a dissertation who did not address the economic, the cost-effective issues with the science, the nursing science, the medical science that I was testing, that they were putting forward in their dissertation.
00:34:29 And on this same point, it's very true. We were told for the first three months that there was only the science, as if there was only the one true faith. And for the first three months, the media gave absolutely no exposure to contrarian scientists.
00:34:46 Professor Carl Hennigan was only being touted by Peter Hitchens in March and April and May.
00:34:51 You know, Dr. Gupta from Oxford University, Professor Woolhouse,
00:34:54 all of these learned authorities.
00:34:56 And also in Sweden, you know,
00:34:58 not once were these people given platforms on the mainstream media,
00:35:01 people who had actual clinicians' experience in this,
00:35:05 and they were treated as if they were heathens, you know, apostates.
00:35:08 You know, in April, Carl Hennigan said, you know, when you look at it overall,
00:35:12 you look at the reality
00:35:15 and not the model
00:35:16 the reality as it unfolds
00:35:19 it is an ILE
00:35:20 an influenza like episode
00:35:23 on the back of an
00:35:25 influenza like episode which we had
00:35:27 every year
00:35:27 we have every year
00:35:29 some are worse than others
00:35:31 and so this was
00:35:33 a really very expert
00:35:36 scientist saying this from Oxford University
00:35:39 and it just did not get picked up
00:35:41 except for Toby Young in Lockdown Skeptics.
00:35:43 I think it's absolutely right what you were saying, Peter,
00:35:46 about a society in which death has become the last enemy,
00:35:51 the great unmentionable.
00:35:53 I mean, the whole push of our medical science
00:35:57 over the last, since the Second World War,
00:35:59 has been to extend life no matter what the quality of that life is.
00:36:04 So you get people who, if left to nature, would have died.
00:36:08 their knife is being prolonged
00:36:11 you know, dementia
00:36:13 ridden people in old people's homes
00:36:14 and so on
00:36:15 and therefore I think a lot of
00:36:19 the government's
00:36:20 attitude towards it has been this
00:36:23 death is the great fear
00:36:25 death is, we're a secular society
00:36:27 by and large we don't believe in
00:36:29 life after death or immortality or anything like that
00:36:31 we're terrified of death
00:36:32 push it away
00:36:34 extend life at all purposes
00:36:36 and I think that is the big
00:36:38 project fear also surely isn't it that uh we've terrified of deaths uh we have no framework for
00:36:43 deaths anymore and also we trust emotions more than rational thought don't we yes i mean it's
00:36:49 all about how do you feel yes you know how do you feel yes though i think that can probably go both
00:36:54 ways i think there's a lot of motivated reasoning on both sides with people not wanting it to be
00:36:58 true or fearing in either case there's a lot of generating of of uh theories or supporting of
00:37:04 theories that support their emotional state but I think one of the interesting things not quite
00:37:08 about death but it was the shock of the vulnerability because lots of everyone knew
00:37:12 the pandemic at some point was coming in some form and but all of the thinking and the planning
00:37:18 that went on about it assumed that the vulnerable were going to be in the mega cities of uh of
00:37:23 Africa of South Asia and that we were in the West were going to be relatively okay but actually
00:37:29 turns out that we had hidden vulnerabilities that we didn't even see we didn't think about
00:37:32 the huge numbers of people who are overweight, the huge numbers of people who are relatively
00:37:36 old in our populations, and the very great difficulty of protecting those groups.
00:37:42 So it was sort of out of nowhere, even for people who were thinking about these things
00:37:46 ahead, that they suddenly looked around and thought, oh God, we're actually much more
00:37:50 vulnerable to this than we thought we were going to be.
00:37:53 And that was a shock even to people who were thinking ahead.
00:37:55 Of course, that was in the early days when people were thinking it was much more dangerous
00:37:59 potentially than it turned out to be, but even so.
00:38:02 But also, it has shown the weaknesses in our apparently extraordinary economic prosperity, hasn't it?
00:38:09 I mean, you know, the speed with which London seems to have just collapsed is finding, actually, is it not?
00:38:18 It is, and when you go into the City of London on a Monday and stand there at Bank Station above ground,
00:38:24 and you can count on one hand people around you, when normally it'd be huge numbers.
00:38:30 350,000 people would come into the City of London every day
00:38:34 and there's nothing like, there's less than 20% footfall
00:38:38 and so the markets have collapsed
00:38:41 you know, the housing markets that depend on the city have collapsed
00:38:44 or collapsing
00:38:45 but I think that aside, the economic impact
00:38:50 the profound way that this hysteria has taken hold
00:38:56 and I think the hysteria and the fear that goes with it
00:38:59 because I think they're a unit, really, that works together.
00:39:05 And that perception, the way fear and hysteria have impacted our assessment of risk,
00:39:11 you know, is quite profound.
00:39:13 So risks have been magnified, you know.
00:39:16 People die all the time in hospitals.
00:39:19 People always do die in hospitals and nursing homes every year.
00:39:23 And there's nothing unusual about that.
00:39:25 and flu, influenza, chest infections always take people off.
00:39:30 It's always the end stage in many diseases
00:39:33 and there's nothing different about that
00:39:35 but I think the way the risk has been magnified here
00:39:38 has had a sinister appeal.
00:39:41 Yes, a sinister one indeed
00:39:42 and why I think this project fear has broadly worked
00:39:46 whereas the Brexit project fear didn't
00:39:49 is that even if you take the Remainer's worst example
00:39:54 Brexit is not going to kill you.
00:39:56 But the suggestion is that COVID, certainly at the beginning,
00:39:59 that COVID very likely will kill you.
00:40:01 And that terrified people.
00:40:02 Also, I think maybe we shouldn't underestimate the fact
00:40:06 that we are blighted by short-term merchants.
00:40:10 The politicians are short-term merchants.
00:40:12 As you say, they don't want to be seen to want to have blood on their hands.
00:40:16 And it's the short-termism that actually is the other issue here,
00:40:19 because it's not only sinister, it's perverse,
00:40:21 that people in the short term are trying to save the lives
00:40:24 or extend the lives of people
00:40:25 who would be dying within the next few years anyway
00:40:27 at the risk of actually having many, many more people die
00:40:30 who have a quality of years of life ahead of them
00:40:34 of potentially decades that they will now never get to enjoy.
00:40:38 Well, gentlemen, look, I mean, I think this one, as they say,
00:40:41 is going to run and run.
00:40:42 I think we're going to be talking about this for some time,
00:40:45 certainly in the new year.
00:40:47 How much is going to change by then is anyone's guess.
00:40:50 I've got my guests, but anyway.
00:40:52 Thank you very much to Nigel, to Mark, to Rafe, and to Kevin.
00:40:58 Do subscribe to Counter Culture, won't you?
00:41:00 And we will see you next week.
00:41:03 Thank you.