New Culture Forum - August 28, 2022


"I've Been Called a Traitor to Islam by Islamists & the Left". Islamist Threat to Western Democracy

Former Trump Advisor: Trump Will Run in 2024. The Crazies Have Taken Over the Democrat White House. Fired By Childline For My Child Safety Concerns. Abusive Practices Are Damaging Our Children.

Episode Stats


Length

44 minutes

Words per minute

163.15

Word count

7,256

Sentence count

—


Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
00:00:00 Hello and welcome to So What You're Saying is, I'm Peter Whittle. Now it's just over two weeks
00:00:24 ago that Salman Rushdie was attacked in New York. I'm delighted that my guest this week
00:00:31 is an expert in radicalisation and terrorism. Wasik Wasik is a fellow of the Henry Jackson
00:00:40 Society. He's also a specialist in anti-Semitism. Thank you very much for joining us. I wanted
00:00:48 to start because this week just gone you held a kind of event didn't you for Salman Rushdie can
00:00:58 you tell me what that was sure well thank you for having me on it's a pleasure i think the first
00:01:03 thing is that my thoughts go out to Salman Rushdie and and his family and i wish him all the best in
00:01:10 a quick recovery now the event that we i was part of is known as the i stand with Salman event and
00:01:18 this is essentially a symbolic event to show solidarity to Salman Rushdie in the face of
00:01:23 religious fundamentalists who are seeking to prevent those from expressing themselves
00:01:31 freely in a free society and so I delivered a speech there to push back against some of these
00:01:38 religious fundamentalists who I believe are a threat to our democracy a threat to the west and
00:01:46 the threat that they pose in my view is not one of legality but it's one through the back door
00:01:53 so essentially what they're trying to do is to threaten people from being able to express
00:01:57 themselves without needing to have a blasphemy law so essentially it's blasphemy through the
00:02:02 back door and this is essentially what my um speech was about well i think it's sort of almost
00:02:08 undeniable that we are living with an unofficial blasphemy i mean were you when it came to the
00:02:15 instant uh the attack on sam rush have you been uh encouraged or discouraged by the general
00:02:24 response to it i think there's two things that we need to put into perspective yes of course
00:02:31 uh the fatwa which is a religious edict that was um assigned to sam and rushti has uh since 1988
00:02:39 been um applied to to salmon and it hasn't been rescinded um so i'm disappointed that we haven't
00:02:46 had religious leaders um actually rescinding this or negating this fatwa so this life so this fatwa
00:02:53 is essentially been life for all this time and therefore salmon's life has always been on the
00:02:59 line as a result of this yeah but also i am encouraged by other things and what i have seen
00:03:05 at least in the muslim community and it's a diverse community we're not a homogenous block
00:03:10 we're not a monolith is that when it does come to matters of blasphemy what we don't see is the
00:03:16 whole of the muslim community out there protesting against it what we do see however is a minority
00:03:22 of religious fundamentalists who are out there protesting against it now the problem with some
00:03:27 of these protests is that there are elements of extremism there where they're threatening violence
00:03:33 where they're threatening to do things against people who um do um or express themselves freely
00:03:39 whether it's reading the book or promoting it or or selling it and so it is mixed and i think there
00:03:46 is a lot of work that needs to be done uh in terms of um free freedom of speech and freedom of
00:03:52 expression you know i i saw actually a tweet you put out which caught my eye this is a while ago
00:03:58 um and it was basically during the time where the various groups were um uh picketing
00:04:06 cine world over the the the film recently that they thought was insulting um and indeed there
00:04:15 was a guy there was a clip of a guy i think it was in birmingham um talking about how there will
00:04:20 be repercussions we have been trained to make sure you know and it was a very much like a threat
00:04:27 and you said something along the lines of that this is what we are up against i mean do you
00:04:34 how widespread do you think that is i think it's widespread amongst a minority of fundamentalists
00:04:43 within the muslim community and they are shouting the loudest and what they are doing is essentially
00:04:51 uh representing themselves as the the go-to people the spokespeople for a community and
00:04:59 when i saw that clip it was quite troubling because as far as i know nothing has been done
00:05:05 about it and as far as i could tell from that clip it very much appears to be a threat yeah and when
00:05:11 we put it into con into context the film that you're referring to the lady of heaven this was
00:05:17 made by a minority shia sect so it's a minority within the sector of shia and shia are a sect
00:05:24 within the muslim community and so they got to push push back within their own community and
00:05:31 also from the sunni community which is the the biggest muslim sect that we currently have globally
00:05:38 and as part of that what what we saw was that although we didn't see a lot of pushback from
00:05:46 the whole of the muslim community a minority of that community were allowed to speak on behalf of
00:05:52 them and to get that film taken down from cinemas and so similar cinemas across the country weren't
00:05:58 able to actually show this movie because they weren't aware or at least apart they would have
00:06:05 done some sort of risk assessment and assessed that this risk of violence or intimidation or
00:06:11 threats is too high for us to put this on and so as a result the muslim community are being tarnished
00:06:18 because of a minority of religious fundamentalists and cinemas are not allowed to then put on things
00:06:24 that other people want to be able to watch yes this censorship that it what the the atmosphere
00:06:33 of censorship um which basically if you talk about take for example since 1988 um it does appear to
00:06:42 have been internalized i mean to the extent people say oh well we've you know you hear this a lot
00:06:48 um oh well we sort of uh we've moved on and and that wouldn't happen anymore you sort of think
00:06:53 well no because basically people now keep their mouth shut i mean would you do you think that is
00:06:59 is a true picture as i paint it there i think there's some truth to that i think when we look
00:07:06 at when the fatwa was initially um put out against saman we had some politicians uh saying that
00:07:14 saman perhaps should take some of the blame for why this is happening and and i think that's
00:07:20 disgraceful especially in a western liberal democracy we should be standing up for um those
00:07:26 who are who or who want to express themselves and to push back against religious theocrats
00:07:32 such as those who are in Iran and so there is some truth to that and when we think about
00:07:38 how that's progressed over time well it hasn't progressed what we've seen it's regressed over
00:07:43 time a classic example and the most recent one is that of Batli grammar school a teacher all he had
00:07:50 done was shown a caricature of the prophet Muhammad now what happened as a result of that
00:07:57 is that we saw a bunch of religious fundamentalists who were there uh picketing him and we even had
00:08:04 in fact a charity naming him um on social media the teacher as a result that teacher had to go
00:08:11 into hiding now we didn't get much pushback from the government at the time no um i think
00:08:19 the right-wing media were very good at actually pushing back against this the left-wing media were
00:08:24 a bit hesitant they were it appeared that they didn't know where to place their position should
00:08:31 they be with the teacher in terms of freedom of expression and to show these sorts of caricatures
00:08:38 or was it with the fundamentalists who were essentially saying that muslims can't behave
00:08:44 themselves when they see this and therefore we have to actually prevent these things from happening
00:08:49 and this then speaks to a bigotry of low expectations and it's quite patronizing to
00:08:54 assume that we can't handle ourselves when something offensive is shown in front of us
00:08:59 so does that mean actually we think that for example you have no problem with say cartoons
00:09:03 being shown in in the Batney case no absolutely not there's no child protection issue showing a
00:09:11 cartoon so what is the issue the issue is only um those who are offended who now want to apply their
00:09:18 offense to everyone else so their standards of offense and that is unfair to anyone else who then
00:09:23 wants to see um this caricature or not see this character people should have the choice to be
00:09:28 able to do that so if the teacher chooses to show this and a student chooses not to see it they
00:09:34 should be able to leave the classroom no one should be forced to look at it but then no one
00:09:38 should be forced not to look and that's the situation that the religion religious
00:09:43 fundamentalists seem to want to take control of why do you think it is that
00:09:48 for example take that school badly grammar school but let's face it it
00:09:52 could be a whole number of other instances we've had they wouldn't invite
00:09:57 somebody like you along is it were to put the other case I mean from what I
00:10:03 can see the guys were outside there pretty much one hands down the teacher
00:10:07 is still in hiding um as you said virtually i well i i don't think anyone in the government
00:10:14 said anything about it but why don't they have someone like you along and talk about the other
00:10:20 way of looking i think um because they're they're worried about the tension that it could create
00:10:25 that um when you've got a muslim who is uh standing up for free speech standing up for
00:10:31 freedom of expression against then a mob who are completely uh against that this creates tension
00:10:40 and they don't want to be part of that um that sort of debate even though by nature they are part
00:10:46 of it and they have to take a stand against it and so and i think that's one of the issues that
00:10:52 we're facing is that there are voices progressive voices within the muslim community who want to
00:10:59 stand up for free speech who are not being given that platform i mean of course new culture forum
00:11:04 are giving me that platform and that's fantastic but then what about some of these platforms on
00:11:09 the left where we find lots of muslims who subscribe to that political ideology we don't
00:11:17 hear those voices and we need to hear more of those voices we need to amplify the other side
00:11:24 because at the moment we're only seeing the fundamentalist side yeah yeah so how would you
00:11:30 characterize yourself then once you can in on this sphere on this uh this line of uh from
00:11:38 fundamentalism right to you to what to you call it progressive muslim what i'm not entirely sure
00:11:43 what to call it but um i i mean i call myself a british muslim and i fully subscribe to the
00:11:50 the British values that we have, whether it's free speech, freedom of expression, the rule
00:11:58 of law. I'm perfectly comfortable with having non-Muslim friends. And so I don't bring cultural
00:12:06 baggage from other areas where some of these fundamentalists do. So in fact, there are
00:12:14 lots of progressive Muslims who don't consider homosexuality to negate their belief in Islam
00:12:21 or belief in God, because within Islam there's only one way of coming into Islam, and that's
00:12:27 to declare faith in one God and that the Prophet Muhammad is the messenger.
00:12:32 Anything beyond that cannot necessarily negate your identity as a Muslim.
00:12:37 And so we do know that there's lots of progressive Muslims who think like this, but we just don't
00:12:42 hear them enough.
00:12:43 Yes. Where does this leave you?
00:12:48 Does this put you in a dangerous position at all?
00:12:52 Potentially. I get a lot of abuse on social media.
00:12:56 From?
00:12:57 From fundamentalists, from Islamists, from those on the left
00:13:02 who believe I'm giving cover to the extreme right wing, for example.
00:13:07 So some of the abuse that I get is I'll be called coconut
00:13:10 or a traitor to Muslims and this is essentially falling into the territory of identity politics
00:13:19 so that they're happy to have a brown person there to essentially propagate white supremacist
00:13:26 ideas and things like that so as a result of that then people are then making threats and
00:13:32 uh um on social media and so i have to be very careful where i go who i speak to um
00:13:40 who i see because you never know who could be out there and this is a threat that a lot of those
00:13:47 of us who are in that progressive scene who consider ourselves muslims even though others
00:13:53 don't um who are uh facing oh i see so you mean basically the they're saying to you you're not
00:13:59 even a muslim really there are cases where they are and it's known as the feeding so the food
00:14:04 means to excommunicate this is um this is an essential tool within the salafi jihadi ideology
00:14:11 this is something that isis actually use and al-qaeda were said of isis that even you're too
00:14:19 extreme for us when you're using this and applying this to some sunni muslims so the idea is that if
00:14:26 you're able to declare someone a non-muslim then that person becomes a legitimate target
00:14:31 and so this is what some of these individuals are seeking to do i see um it's one thing that
00:14:39 that uh in the feedback we get in the from the show when we talk about these issues um
00:14:46 and that is you use the term islamism um and i suppose you would say that sort of
00:14:53 religious fundamentalists and islamists roughly the same i suppose there is a kind of if you like
00:15:00 violent islamist and a non-violent islamist so in fact would it be right to say that the people who
00:15:07 try to close down a film are non-violent islamists would you say to an extent yes uh so there are
00:15:14 actually three types of islamists first um islamism is distinct from islam islamism is a
00:15:20 political ideology whereas islam is a religion of peace and within islamism there are three types
00:15:28 there are the violent types so those are the isis al-qaeda boko haram those sorts of people then
00:15:36 you've got the non-violent islamists and so these guys they believe everything that the violent
00:15:42 islamists do but they don't carry out anything in terms of violence and then you've got the
00:15:48 participationalist islamists and so these guys actually use the machinery of democracy to achieve
00:15:54 their aims now the violent islamists are the ones who are essentially those who are out picketing
00:16:00 and using that violent rhetoric to have things closed down and and they stop at the point of
00:16:07 violence but that's not to say that they don't subscribe to violence they're quite happy for
00:16:12 someone else to do that for them if it's going to achieve their aims so that's essentially so
00:16:18 those people who um are seeking to shut down um the the lady of heaven yeah i would consider them
00:16:26 to be non-violent islamists yes i see um because one of the things it is brought up and i i'm sure
00:16:33 you've discussed this many times is some people will say using the term islamism is a is a cop-out
00:16:41 it's actually Islam what would you say to that? I think that well look Islamism comes from Islam
00:16:48 so you can't deny that and so Islamism because it's a political ideology they draw from Islamic
00:16:57 tradition and Islamic teachings and they hope to use that to then implement it into their way of
00:17:04 life in terms of not just their private self but also the public and so when we think about
00:17:10 islamism especially in the west what they're hoping to do is to make society sharia compliant
00:17:16 now sharia means um the root word of sharia is to mean way a way of doing things and for them
00:17:23 is the islamic way of doing things and one of the islamic way of doing things is to prevent people
00:17:29 from critiquing or ridiculing religion or the prophet muhammad and so they're hoping to achieve
00:17:36 a sharia compliant freedom of expression and speech that is in line with their beliefs and
00:17:44 the only way that they can do that is by essentially threatening people from actually
00:17:50 being able to express themselves do you think that when you look at the british establishment
00:17:55 i'm sure you have lots of interaction don't you i mean if you're you know associated with henry
00:18:00 New Jackson Society, et cetera, and your work.
00:18:02 If you look at the people who run the government,
00:18:05 I get the impression that they are quite ignorant, actually,
00:18:10 of various different nuances, if that's the right word.
00:18:15 Do you think that's the case?
00:18:16 I mean, you know, if they don't say anything about a teacher
00:18:21 in the Batley Grammar School, if they don't really make comments
00:18:25 about some other thing that might have happened,
00:18:27 it's because they're worried about offending almost is that right there's some truth to that
00:18:33 um but it's there's something deeper to this um and this goes to something known as community
00:18:40 tension i remember recently a few years ago there was a um a christian um woman from pakistan and
00:18:47 she was seeking refuge here in britain um she wasn't able to come here and the reason the
00:18:54 government gave was because it would cause community tension and so the question then i
00:19:01 have then for the government is either you cannot handle the community tension you cannot control it
00:19:07 or you've just to prioritize them over someone who needed refuge so there there is it's so there's
00:19:16 two things one there's the ignorance so sometimes they're aware of it and they're not doing it
00:19:21 anything about it and the other thing is that even when they are aware of it they still
00:19:25 don't seem to be able to do enough about it and so we're in a situation now where the
00:19:30 government seem to be on the back foot against some of these islamist extremists you see
00:19:36 you say that they don't seem to be able to do anything about it uh i'd agree um it's
00:19:41 a question of why they don't in the sense that the government when it wants to do things
00:19:45 can move remarkably fast um is it just that there's cowardice that i mean for the same reason that
00:19:53 you know the situation in rotherham was allowed to go on for a long time all of those sorts of
00:19:58 things is simply because they are more frightened actually as if you put it off community tension
00:20:05 it's as simple as that i think so i think um because they don't want to um we we had riots
00:20:12 in in the 80s uh the race riots and you know it was very difficult to deal with that we had rights
00:20:18 then in the early 2000s in in those northern towns again race rights and so they they've had bad
00:20:24 experiences of of these sorts of rights and they're worried that similar rights are going to happen
00:20:29 and they don't know what to do with it and so that means that actually the the influence that they
00:20:34 have in the community is quite weak because and they also um need to rely on the community to
00:20:41 know that that actually that's not going to happen what's you know the thing is when we even when we
00:20:45 look at lockdown they were able to lock down the whole country so quickly yet they can't seem to
00:20:51 contain a problem like this and so i i don't know what what the block is and uh they need to show
00:20:57 some courage well you know i think it's that you've just said it um i think that they are cowards
00:21:03 um because they absolutely could um i wonder where do you stand on the term islamophobia
00:21:12 would you say that it is i mean do you think this thing is exists or would you say like the
00:21:19 late christopher hitchens that it's a made-up term which is basically there to stop people
00:21:24 criticizing islam i think there's um i think it's a mixture of of both we know that um anti-muslim
00:21:31 bigotry hatred prejudice exists so people are treating muslims differently because they're
00:21:37 muslims but when it comes to islamophobia there is a definition that we we currently have at the
00:21:44 moment that's gained a lot of momentum from all of the political parties except the conservative
00:21:48 party who are seeking to define their own this definition that we currently have is very
00:21:57 problematic it seems to be rooted in critical race theory which essentially says that all muslims
00:22:04 belong to a race and there are some problems with this because what we know and i mentioned this
00:22:10 earlier that anyone can become a muslim just by reciting the shahada the the declaration of faith
00:22:15 and then all you have to do is to reject the shahada to then no longer be a muslim and so
00:22:21 So you can be white, but you cannot not be white at the same time, you can't come out
00:22:27 of your race.
00:22:28 So the idea that you can conflate race with religion is palpably false.
00:22:33 But it's not just that, even when we look at the Lady of Heaven as an example, the Islamophobia
00:22:39 definition that we currently have actually ignores sectarianism.
00:22:45 So you have Sunni Muslims who, or some Sunni Muslims who hate some Shia Muslims because
00:22:51 they're Shia, because they have a different theology.
00:22:54 And so if we're talking about critical race theory and it's about colour and whiteness
00:23:00 and power, privilege, then how can one group who essentially look the same be racist to
00:23:08 another group who essentially look the same?
00:23:10 One group can't be white and the other group everyone else.
00:23:13 And so it ignores that.
00:23:15 there are lots of problems with this uh definition of islamophobia and so when we uh and the question
00:23:20 that you asked is does it exist well according to this definition i'm not entirely sure what exists
00:23:26 it's just very muddled up yes i i mean i've always seemed quite clear to me that you know
00:23:33 islamophobia is incorrect simply because it's a religion i think you've just made that point
00:23:39 and not a race and and that basically therefore everyone should be able to criticize religion
00:23:44 um that's the way we've kind of grown up uh in in democracies like ours um do you think because
00:23:52 it sort of crept in a little bit lately that islamists use the whole new woke language is
00:23:59 that happening i kind of heard it a little bit around the edges yes i do think i do think so
00:24:06 they're they're using this language where they're essentially using the the language of diversity
00:24:16 and inclusion and they're hoping to create Muslims into this homogenous block and so all Muslims
00:24:25 should think the same all Muslims should look the same and speak the same and believe in the same
00:24:29 thing and and this this woke language is very much the same and so for example we know that in in the
00:24:38 gender wars for people are finding it difficult to now describe what a woman is but Islamists what
00:24:44 they're what they're hoping to do now is that they're trying to do the reverse and be and say
00:24:49 well actually you can describe what a Muslim is a Muslim should look like this so a Muslim woman
00:24:54 should be uh wearing a hijab or or a niqab or or something like that so they're using that language
00:25:00 or or the tactics at least that we've seen in the in in this woke ideology and identity politics
00:25:06 to then apply it to themselves and to achieve some of those aims that they're that they're hoping to
00:25:11 get i see i see how did you start out you know it's led you to this point actually you personally
00:25:19 obviously i mean you know your um i mean you grew up here didn't you when did these issues start to
00:25:26 really become important to you i think the turning point wasn't uh the salmon rush do you think because
00:25:34 i was only six years old at the time i i wasn't cognizant to what was actually going on there
00:25:39 it was actually 9 11 in in 2001 i was at college and in our canteen we had um screens up on uh
00:25:47 up on the wall and they were showing the the planes going into the twin towers where was this
00:25:53 where was this this this was in london and um and when that was happening there was lots of
00:26:00 muslim students there and many of my friends and what they were saying was yes you know they were
00:26:06 cheering this on and and i looked at them and said why and they're like you know it's america who
00:26:11 cares we don't care and i couldn't understand what led them to that but um and my response
00:26:20 was that well america's not going to take this lying down they're going to do something about it
00:26:24 and um and not just that my response was what about the victims in in in those towers but
00:26:32 they didn't seem to care and this was really worrying for me because um although we had the
00:26:38 Salman Rushdie event we also had lots of people going to Afghanistan and fighting as part of the
00:26:46 Majahideen against the occupation from Russia and so they saw them as freedom fighters
00:26:53 and so essentially they and bin Laden was of course involved in that and so they saw this as
00:27:01 heroic point for them and this really led me to reconsider what was happening within my community
00:27:10 within some of my my own peers and what can we do about it so as a result i started reading
00:27:17 up a lot about why this stuff was taking place and which then led me to then start working in
00:27:24 this area so i used to work in education and i work in in terrorism and and extremism and um and
00:27:30 what i saw there hasn't necessarily dissipated now we still see those elements of extremism and
00:27:37 they're being given a free pass and something needs to be done about that um you said you were
00:27:43 in uh education what were you teaching or so i was a teacher yes i was a teacher for over 10 years
00:27:47 um i i taught music really what uh in uh london school yes in in london secondary schools um
00:27:55 and uh i taught i taught music i taught drama uh even taught a bit of maths which i was terrible
00:28:01 at but um but i was already um and many of my community tend to go into into law or into
00:28:09 accountancy so it was quite different for me to go into an industry where i don't see you don't
00:28:14 see a brown muslim devout muslim in fact who prays five times a day and you know fast and and gives
00:28:20 to charity so it was really interesting to see that and and but i was very much welcomed in in
00:28:27 those spaces and and and you know that's that's something that i think um we don't find in some
00:28:33 muslim communities where they're very welcoming of necessarily the other right right you spoke quite
00:28:41 recently as well about um the situation that we might face in our prisons right um now again this
00:28:49 is something that sort of glancingly referred to it becomes a bit of an issue and then it sort of
00:28:55 just goes away you know what what would you you would say it's pretty dire right yes it is very
00:29:03 dire there was a recent report that came out from uh by jonathan hawke you see um it was a government
00:29:10 report on islamists in prison and what he found was that islamists are actually controlling some
00:29:18 elements of prison and making them sharia compliant essentially they were making them
00:29:23 muslim friendly or muslim focused and islam friendly and so what they what he found in the
00:29:28 evidence is that prison staff would distribute leadership to emirs emirs are essentially
00:29:37 commanders within an army but within the prison there would be prison emir so these these guys
00:29:44 would be controlling the muslim inmates right and and this is problematic because the distribution
00:29:51 of power from the prison staff to the so-called uh emirs the so-called commanders then actually
00:29:58 relieves the prison staff of their duty of actually being able to control the prison and so
00:30:05 what's the uh the prison for what they're essentially doing is rewarding these prisoners
00:30:09 and instead of punishing them which is why they're there and this was a catastrophic catastrophic
00:30:15 failure that we were finding in um our our prison system yeah and so um it wasn't just that there
00:30:22 were also elements where um some islamist extremists were essentially intimidating staff
00:30:30 using threats of violence to get their way so uh whether so muslims are uh can pray five times a
00:30:37 day but it's not essential for them to pray in a congregation five times a day but this is what
00:30:42 some of these islamists were seeking to do they were they wanted concessions that no other um
00:30:48 religious uh community were getting within those prisons so being able to come out of their cells
00:30:53 to pray in a congregation because that was their right but when it's not essential for them to
00:30:58 need to do that they could quite easily pray within their prison cell so it was quite dire now
00:31:04 not just that um the last four completed terrorist attacks that have taken place
00:31:11 have taken place from those who were in prison and so what we're finding is that the prisons are
00:31:18 actually failing at what they're meant to be doing which is preventing some of these guys from
00:31:23 carrying out these attacks so once they're released from prison they're out there carrying
00:31:26 out uh the attacks of the streatham attack was uh someone who was um who was recently imprisoned
00:31:31 fishmongers hall and also the reading attack and the other attack was one that took place within
00:31:38 prisons and what's interesting about this one the one that took place within prison is that that's
00:31:43 the first terrorist attack to take place within a prison and and this is uh extraordinary to see
00:31:49 what's actually happening but the thing is it might be the same answer but when i asked you
00:31:55 why do you think this is happening would it be the same weakness that you talked about before
00:32:02 in the authorities i think so i think i think there is uh uh now i i think we're talking about
00:32:08 fundamental system systemic weakness that we have in our um in our bodies that are meant to be
00:32:15 protecting us and uh this has uh come about through in my view at least through an environment where
00:32:23 you know we have to think of not offending people before actually dealing with an issue and
00:32:30 that then creates more and more issues and and when these start compounding you start seeing
00:32:37 systemic flaws and a rot within some of our institutions that are meant to be doing something
00:32:43 else but are now at the back foot because they're being held hostage to some of these extremists
00:32:49 i mean i mentioned yes i connected to this really i talked a little bit before we came on air about
00:32:54 this um i mean what is your view of the prevent program because i mean frankly it's had a hell
00:33:00 of a lot of criticism either sort of excuse me either from the the from one side because it's
00:33:08 basically too lily livered from the other side basically from people who essentially don't want
00:33:13 anybody to be under any form of surveillance for whatever reason i mean what what do you
00:33:18 think it's effective or not well i think the the thing we've got actually at the moment it is um
00:33:24 it's uh it's the best thing that we've got and it's a well-intentioned um initiative that we have
00:33:30 and um at the beginning when it first started it was bound to have some um flaws and it was bound
00:33:37 to have some mistakes in its implementation of course that's going to happen because we were in
00:33:42 a situation this came about after the seven seven bombings where four homegrown terrorists turned
00:33:49 their backs on our country and killed 52 of our British citizens and over 100 hundreds of people
00:33:57 were injured as a result of this so we have to think about the context in which it came about
00:34:02 and so we and that that gave us the our first realization that we've got an Islamist extremist
00:34:07 problem and so we had to do something about it now prevent came about and prevents not perfect
00:34:12 but it came about as a way to deal with that now as it came about then you had lots of islamists
00:34:19 who were talking about uh scrapping it because it unfairly targeted the muslim community and it was
00:34:26 so-called islamophobic it was anti-muslim in nature because most of the people who were being
00:34:32 referred to were Muslims but we were in a situation where we didn't know who was an extremist and who
00:34:38 wasn't and there were examples where I think a child had said I live in a terrorist house
00:34:43 and it was interpreted as a terrorist house even though he said terrorist and so they would amplify
00:34:49 these examples as look this is Islamophobic we know that the most referrals currently to prevent
00:34:55 are for the extreme right wing and actually there's a decrease in referrals for islamist
00:35:03 extremism now there's two reasons why that could be the case it could be that the far right are the
00:35:08 fastest rising threat that we're currently facing which is why we're seeing a high number of
00:35:14 referrals for extreme right wing or it could be that we're there's some sense of cowardice now
00:35:20 and that we're a bit scared to refer muslims to the prevent program for being um accused of
00:35:28 islamophobia so that's that's something that we're facing um so i don't think it's islamophobic i
00:35:35 think it's a well-intentioned um initiative and i think anyone who thinks that there is an
00:35:40 alternative needs to come up with it and it needs to come under scrutiny and it can't just be that
00:35:47 oh it's better because it's not islamophobic well we don't know that yours isn't going to be
00:35:51 any better you need to show that it's going to work in practice oh of course i i think that you
00:35:57 you know you you said it's with preventive mode it's either one thing or the other because there's
00:36:02 been this supposed uh increased reporting of right-wing issue yes that has happened um i
00:36:09 I would incline to go with your latter view.
00:36:12 When I've had any contact with police about preventable,
00:36:17 it seems to me that they want to equivocate,
00:36:23 they want to somehow take the onus off the fact
00:36:27 that the vast majority of attacks are Islamist.
00:36:30 And so basically, it's almost like they almost overplay
00:36:34 the right-wing part of it.
00:36:37 And I think, as you say, that there are also cases where people report actually what you wouldn't even consider to be extreme statements, actually, but these suddenly become far-right.
00:36:52 what would you say is the lookout in the next 10 years when it comes to the terrorist threat
00:37:02 when it comes to the terrorist is a mystery are you do you think we have
00:37:07 are we in the same position we were seven seven i don't think we're in the same position i think
00:37:16 we're in a unique position now i think the position's different slightly uh in terms of
00:37:21 terrorist attacks they're less complicated now so with the 77 there was months of planning that took
00:37:26 place and they had to learn how to create these bombs and to know when to detonate them how and
00:37:33 where when we look at some of the terrorist attacks that have taken place now they are very
00:37:38 much low effort terrorist attacks so it's whether it's the use of a van to run people over or the
00:37:46 use of a knife um to do that and so we're seeing a different type um not necessarily type actually
00:37:54 a different way of carrying out terrorist attacks but the threat from terrorism hasn't declined in
00:38:00 fact it's increased and we've seen more and more terrorist attacks in fact from the period of 2001
00:38:07 up to 2019 we saw above average deaths as a result of terrorism compared to any other period
00:38:14 And this is excluding, of course, the Lockerbie and the IRA when we were engaged in the Troubles.
00:38:22 So we have a unique threat. But our threat isn't just that violent threat.
00:38:27 It's also that nonviolent threat. And so when we're thinking about the nonviolent Islamists and the participationist Islamists,
00:38:34 and the latter are the ones who use the machinery of democracy, they use that language, they use votes,
00:38:39 they use free speech to be able to propagate their ideas.
00:38:44 So essentially, they're using the tools that we have against us. And so that's the threat that we're now facing, is that we are facing a nonviolent threat. And they're finding allies within that woke wing of people, the identity politics, those sorts of people who are trying to cancel people by calling them racist or Islamophobic, overplaying things.
00:39:08 so you could have someone who's white and a conservative and he might say well I believe
00:39:16 in the institution of a family well automatically he's a white supremacist so it's those overplaying
00:39:22 of some statements and and things like that that we're now seeing and it's how does it manifest
00:39:28 is it going to manifest necessarily into acts of violence or is it going to manifest itself
00:39:34 into something else whether it's cancel culture or um people just self-censoring so we are facing
00:39:40 a threat in different ways and i think we need to work out a sensible and intelligent approach to
00:39:46 deal with it um absolutely but um there's nothing forthcoming from the party political establishment
00:39:53 i think you'd agree would you yes i i think i would in i mean the the online harms bill
00:39:59 seems to be an overreach in terms of tackling some of what we're talking about because it
00:40:06 essentially limits some aspects of free speech and freedom of expression and one of the key things
00:40:12 that terrorists want to do is that they want governments to be to overreach in how they deal
00:40:19 with threats that they're faced against and so the online harm bills in my view is one of those ways
00:40:27 that instead of responding to extremists in a proportionate way this is now a disproportionate
00:40:33 way which is limiting some of those allies that we have who who could actually take some of these
00:40:39 guys on yeah well thank you very very much you know for today and coming on um it's great to uh
00:40:47 to speak to you um and uh is there anything else that people can do do you think when it comes to
00:40:54 Salman Rushdie is there any other way in which they can sort of make their voices known you
00:41:01 know to sort of people say we've got to stand uh with Salman Rushdie and and it's absolutely right
00:41:08 we have got to but okay you had this event but how can people generally do it just as a way
00:41:15 if you could just think of any well i think um i think we need to especially online when um
00:41:22 charlie hebdo when the attacks against charlie hebdo happened we saw the hashtag jessui charlie
00:41:27 even with black lives matter we saw the hashtag black lives matter or blm and so we need to have
00:41:33 things like that these symbolic um events taking place where we have jessui salman
00:41:39 from something like that we need to show that actually we are standing with him and against
00:41:45 a minority of fundamentalists who are seeking to do something that is completely against our
00:41:50 british values of free speech and one of the arguments that they always make is free speech is
00:41:55 not absolute well nobody has ever said it's absolutely we have laws here against hate speech
00:42:02 and speech against violence there are boundaries and if you want to and i think what we need to do
00:42:08 is we need to invite some of these guys onto a level playing field and to debate them where they
00:42:14 get to say what they want and we can actually change their minds because i do believe we can
00:42:18 change their minds with with logic and with reason because all they bring is emotion and
00:42:23 that's not enough to uh convince everyone else to your um point of view but we can do something
00:42:31 to convince others to us would you uh have you debated these guys in public no i i haven't um
00:42:37 i don't think they'll share a platform with me potentially uh i don't know uh but i'd be happy
00:42:43 to debate them um but i think we we need to get the rules of our debates right and uh you know we
00:42:50 we shouldn't allow them to shout us down uh because we should either shout back at them
00:42:55 or we sit down and behave in in a civilized way in in a british way and and actually do this
00:43:03 properly thank you again once again we see very much uh that's it for so what you're saying is
00:43:10 this week we shall see you next time thank you very much hello if you're enjoying the new culture
00:43:16 forum channel and you believe in our mission may i invite you to join our membership scheme
00:43:23 at the link below or on our website newcultureforum.org.uk our work is more important
00:43:31 now than ever and we have great plans ahead for the future but we can't do it without your support
00:43:37 from as little as three pounds per month you can help ensure that we continue on our mission.
00:43:43 As a member you'll receive a range of benefits including access to exclusive content,
00:43:49 invitations to our private events including here at our studios, free copies of our books
00:43:57 and much much more including of course our famous NCF mug. If you aren't able to become a member
00:44:04 then please help us by clicking this button and subscribing to our channel. It's completely free,
00:44:11 just remember to also click the bell icon so that you can get notifications when we post
00:44:18 new videos. Thank you.