New Culture Forum - September 02, 2022


Fired By Childline For My Child Safety Concerns. Abusive Practices Are Damaging Our Children.

"I've Been Called a Traitor to Islam by Islamists & the Left". Islamist Threat to Western Democracy The Queen Is Dead Long Live The King The New Culture Forum Reflects On The Old Reign The New

Episode Stats


Length

36 minutes

Words per minute

181.32

Word count

6,606

Sentence count

79


Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
00:00:00 Hello and welcome to So What You're Saying Is, I'm Peter Whittle. Now the trans debate which
00:00:24 we have looked at so many times on this channel seems to have been reaching a pitch lately whether
00:00:31 we like it or not and indeed recently it would appear that there has been some real fight back
00:00:39 first of all the infamous Tavistock clinic is going to close there have been various victories
00:00:45 with people who are what is known as gender critical in the courts and indeed in the sports
00:00:51 industry there has also been pushback when it comes to uh trans participants uh this all seems
00:00:58 very good but is it really um i'm very glad that uh my guest today is james estes uh james is the
00:01:06 founder of thoughtful therapists and he's also a campaigner and a social commentator um james you
00:01:14 pointed this out recently that it appears to have been a good week i think as you put it
00:01:19 uh with all these various things happening um it appears to have been a good week what do you think
00:01:26 well i tend to be cynical about these things but you know as a matter of fact it has been
00:01:30 objectively quite a good week as you've touched upon some of these things you know we've had the
00:01:34 Alison Bailey victory in her case could you explain Alison Bailey for obvious what that was
00:01:39 about yes so she was she's a barrister she was suing her chambers for discrimination based on
00:01:46 an investigation that they launched into her off the back of complaints made by Stonewall she was
00:01:50 also suing Stonewall for discrimination she lost on that ground but what it did was it uncovered
00:01:56 the way in which Stonewall bully and try and cancel people and you know ruin their livelihoods
00:02:03 their reputations so that brought that to light and you know she she was found to have been
00:02:08 discriminated against by her barrister's chambers which is quite big you've mentioned sports yes
00:02:14 we're seeing more and more sporting bodies coming on board with the way of thinking that actually
00:02:18 biological males should not be competing against women we've seen the rugby and football union
00:02:23 doing this which is particularly important for rugby being a contact sport because you know
00:02:27 women's health and safety is very much at risk if men are allowed to play in those sports um
00:02:33 the tavistock closure as well has been a long time coming i mean there's been significant concerns
00:02:38 from whistleblowers for many years about the safety of the way in which children are being
00:02:42 medicalized at the tavistock so its closure is also good and equally you know in the leadership
00:02:49 uh competition for the conservative party the the trans debate has been on the agenda
00:02:54 and we've seen both liz truss and rishi sunak make some positive soundings around protecting
00:03:00 women's rights and safeguarding children so it's been a good week um but the tide is turning far
00:03:06 too slowly in my opinion overall the is that's presumably because the ideology now is so
00:03:14 embedded is it not i mean on in every area i mean you are a is it right to say trainee therapist
00:03:23 in various different industries i mean obviously and certainly in the i'd say that the media as
00:03:29 well has a hand in this and that they sort of tend to push a kind of a narrative too um but
00:03:35 But can I ask you, with the Tavistock Clinic, can you just give us a synopsis of quite what was happening there?
00:03:44 Well, as I say, there's been whistleblowers raising concerns about the clinic since, I think, 2005.
00:03:50 But basically what's come out in the Hillary Cass interim report,
00:03:54 this is a government commissioned report into gender services in the UK,
00:03:57 is that the clinicians there seem to have a completely nonchalant attitude towards capturing
00:04:05 any sort of data or research into the long-term outcomes of these children who have been prescribed
00:04:11 what is experimental medication at a very young age and then simply not following them down the
00:04:18 path to see actually is the regret you know what are the long-term physical mental effects on them
00:04:24 from this medication. Equally there's been concerns from clinicians at the Tavistock who have left
00:04:30 who are saying that basically they feel pressured or forced into affirming transitioning so if
00:04:35 somebody comes in if a child comes in and says that they're trans that they want to transition
00:04:39 that that clinician should not challenge or explore other options or contributing factors
00:04:45 but should simply say yes you are trans and you should medically transition. Which is sort of
00:04:50 pretty unique isn't it surely i mean in the sense that i think you've pointed this out that in fact
00:04:56 if it's if it's a mental condition you don't you generally go through quite a lot of therapy
00:05:02 before any kind of decision is made well this is it i mean you know the the principles underlying
00:05:08 therapy is with all the medical professionals is about you know the hippocratic oath and not doing
00:05:12 any harm but crucially you know a therapist or a counselor should never sit down in front of a
00:05:20 But what we're having these days is the therapeutic bodies basically pressuring therapists into affirming.
00:05:28 And we wouldn't treat any other mental health condition in this way where we would affirm the distressing thoughts inside somebody's head or prescribe medication to change someone's body or surgery.
00:05:38 I mean, I often compare it to body dysmorphia or anorexia.
00:05:42 We don't prescribe liposuction for that.
00:05:45 There's another condition called body integrity identity disorder.
00:05:48 this is a condition in which people feel that one of their limbs is wrong it doesn't belong to them
00:05:53 in this country if somebody goes to a doctor and says i don't like my arm it doesn't belong to me
00:05:58 can you chop it off the answer of course is no and yes there are young women out there young
00:06:03 girls and women who are being given double mastectomies simply because they're saying
00:06:07 that they feel that they're trapped in the wrong body so would you say that the nhs for example
00:06:12 is also now in thrall to this general ideology i i would say so i've i've come across nhs guidance
00:06:20 online which is using scientifically inaccurate language for example saying that somebody's sex
00:06:26 is assigned at birth which we know is not true it's simply observed and recorded but this is
00:06:31 ideological language making its way into the nhs and yes i mean children young people can avail of
00:06:37 this irreversible treatment on the nhs i'm particularly concerned about private clinics
00:06:42 that have been springing up because there's huge commercialization here um and the use of
00:06:48 euphemistic language i've come across clinics websites who refer to double mastectomies as
00:06:53 gender affirming procedures you know which is trying to in some way take away from the fact
00:07:00 that this is a a significant irreversible medical procedure and there's a lot of money to be made
00:07:04 out of this worryingly you mentioned money though as being a possible with these clinics as being a
00:07:11 possible motive but what do you think is the motive behind people whether it is at the
00:07:17 tavistock clinic or people who teach kids in schools about gender ideology or all of these
00:07:24 areas what what is motivating them i've asked myself that quite a lot i think i think there
00:07:29 has to be a diverse range of reasons i think i think for some people there are malicious or even
00:07:35 ulterior motives but i think for most actually it's a combination of having been taken in by
00:07:40 this ideology i mean as you alluded to yourself peter this is everywhere we're surrounded by it
00:07:45 in the media you know we've just come out of pride month in which companies and the government are
00:07:49 literally ramming this ideology down our throats um and children and teenagers and university
00:07:56 students are being brought up with this ideology you know forefront of their mind so i think people
00:08:01 have been taken in by it i think for a lot of people they're just terrified of saying the wrong
00:08:06 thing they're terrified of offending somebody they're terrified of being cancelled and having
00:08:10 the mob come for them to try and cancel them effectively i think it's um it's a perfect storm
00:08:16 in that in that respect but ultimately to me the the motive is irrelevant because the outcome
00:08:24 which is damage to children is the same yes i mean it's just outright child abuse isn't it
00:08:30 well at the very least it's i mean it's it's neglectful but i i would say that a lot of the
00:08:34 practices that are going on are are abusive um in a sense we've robbed children of of childhood
00:08:41 which is to be able to make mistakes and grow without facing irreversible regret i mean children
00:08:46 have always had fads um and been rebellious and you know often the comparison is made with kind
00:08:54 of goth or emo culture which seems to have died down over recent years but you know children would
00:08:59 go off and experiment with different ways of being and acting and talking and dressing and that was
00:09:04 fine and then usually a few years later they'd realize that actually it wasn't that cool after
00:09:07 all and they'd go and do something else you know and that's one of the wonders of childhood but
00:09:10 nowadays this fad of being trans or non-binary and having your pronouns and transitioning socially
00:09:17 can lead to irreversible regret and i've spoken to so many of these detransitioners who have lost
00:09:22 parts of their body that they can never get back yeah what worries me really is that it's
00:09:29 we're discussing this just before we came came on on air that we're regressing aren't we in the
00:09:37 sense that essentially if a kid now displays you know certain characteristics like you know
00:09:46 boy playing with a doll or not being that rowdy being kind of quiet or possibly quite feminine
00:09:52 or or a tomboy as they used to be called um i remember growing up that basically uh people say
00:09:59 oh well they'll grow out of it or whatever or something like that now uh basically uh they
00:10:05 might go on for example to become to be gay adults but now it's oh no this person really is in the
00:10:11 wrong body and i often wonder you know when you occasionally see these clips on social media of
00:10:17 parents who are claiming this of their tiny kids i mean i find it horrifying well you're right
00:10:24 we're regressing back to old stereotypes which i thought we were trying to move away from as a
00:10:29 liberal society but yeah i mean i come across materials which tell young boys that if they
00:10:33 like flowers they could be a girl trapped in the wrong body but again we have to go back to the
00:10:38 source of this which is the fundamental message children have been told about themselves in the
00:10:43 world i've come across primary school books and teaching resources which tell children that when
00:10:49 they were born the doctor made a guess that's the word in the book made a guess at who they were
00:10:54 whether they were a boy or a girl and that the doctor could have made a mistake now immediately
00:10:59 what what type of message is that sending to a young vulnerable child immediately they're going
00:11:03 to start thinking well could my doctor have made a mistake you know who am i and if you're constantly
00:11:09 being fed this diatribe of well if you like things that the other sex tends to like then
00:11:13 maybe you are trapped in the wrong body we're leading children down this this one-way path
00:11:17 ultimately i think you know essentially there's you know gay people in the past you know fought
00:11:24 against this idea that oh you know you're obviously a woman in a man's body and sort of
00:11:30 fought against that no we we are masculine men i know i certainly fought against that um but here
00:11:36 we are seemingly back to square one um and uh it's quite quite extraordinary and alarming um can i
00:11:44 just go back to that point actually you asked you what is the motive um and you said there's a whole
00:11:50 number of them and i suppose that one of those might well be that there are some people who are
00:11:55 well-meaning uh you know we have to sort of say this you know and think that they are being
00:12:00 inclusive and all this i can't help feeling that it's it's something a bit more than that
00:12:05 you know that there is a political motivation behind so much of this you know in the sense
00:12:12 i don't know what you think of that but in the sense that it's sort of good old march should
00:12:17 institutions in a way that if you can destabilize people's sense of themselves if you can destabilize
00:12:24 their belief in biology and science then you sort of you've got them right as it were for
00:12:30 whatever that might be but it seems to me that there is a political motive
00:12:34 in the broadest sense i mean well there are many aspects of this ideology that are cult-like
00:12:41 you know putting out this information particularly to the youngest in society so again there's a
00:12:46 charity i mean i use that term loosely they're called mermaids i'm sure you've heard of and they
00:12:53 have a podcast for the young listeners and they will say things like quote uh there are men who
00:12:59 have ovaries there are women who have prostates it's just fact that's it they just put it out
00:13:03 there and of course you know a child who knows no better is going to believe that so there's a lot
00:13:07 of misinformation being put out there there has been this kind of controlling of society i mean
00:13:11 stoneworn and other organizations have played this strategically very well because they've managed
00:13:15 to infiltrate almost every area of society including government departments again we touched
00:13:20 on pride month the way in which this takes over our society for a month which is ironic given that
00:13:26 these individuals are claiming to be one of the most marginalized groups in society and yes they
00:13:30 are out everywhere to be seen and you know you can't avoid the ideology being pushed in your face
00:13:38 there's also the cult-like behavior in terms of those who stray away from the crowd so we spoke
00:13:42 about detransitioners earlier i've spoken to some of those individuals and as soon as they
00:13:48 spoke out and said actually i shouldn't have been transitioned what happened to me was wrong
00:13:53 they are completely ostracized by the trans community even bullied thrown abuse and slurs
00:13:59 and vitriol very much this kind of if you're not with us you're against us type attitude very very
00:14:05 divisive and again no wonder why people are terrified of stepping out of line and saying
00:14:08 something that could offend yes speaking of stonewall are they in retreat do you think or not
00:14:16 i mean people i think the average person would not have known what so more was before you know
00:14:20 obviously it was a highly respected sort of you know organization to try to advance gay rights
00:14:27 i'm going way back now but uh now it's something else entirely and the public actually are
00:14:35 indirectly paying for it in many ways aren't they i mean do you when it comes to you know going
00:14:41 becoming consultants and government departments and they're not cheap um to some extent it does
00:14:48 seem like a kind of money-making exercise um but are they sort of is there pushback against stonewall
00:14:56 or not there is and it's all their own doing actually you know as somebody who speaks out
00:15:02 quite strongly against stonewall they're doing a better job of undermining themselves than i
00:15:07 ever could i mean just last week they posted this tweet saying that two-year-olds could be trans
00:15:13 and they said that there was research to back this up whereas in fact there is absolutely
00:15:16 no research whatsoever to back this up and then they kind of fudged this and kind of
00:15:20 it wasn't really a retraction but they basically fudged it but that caused a huge alienation
00:15:27 between a lot of the departments and companies that held them in good esteem actually i mean i
00:15:31 I saw a tweet from a minister for the Department of Business, Energy and Industrial Strategy who said that he was delighted to announce that his department would no longer be affiliated with Stonewall.
00:15:42 This is actually quite revolutionary because a few years ago, these departments were hook, line and sinker in Stonewall's clutches.
00:15:49 And if they were ever to kind of distance themselves from it, it would be done under the radar for fear of attracting abuse or attacks online.
00:15:55 But here, ministers are coming out saying, thank God we're leaving Stonewall.
00:15:59 so i think stonewall are on their way out but again the tide is turning too slowly on that as
00:16:04 well well this is what i mean go back to my i know i'm rather uh like a dog with a bone on on this
00:16:10 point what would make somebody put out something with no evidence saying that two-year-olds can be
00:16:17 trans right something absurd and incredibly damaging and all the rest of it what would make
00:16:26 make them do that you said it's there's some people who may be are malicious for them or
00:16:32 it could just be they've got to keep going along on this track because it's very lucrative
00:16:37 to them or that you know all the rest of it or is it again some kind of attempt to completely
00:16:44 sexualize children in some way i think it could be all of the above i mean there's a
00:16:50 A child can't be trans.
00:16:53 Well, even this term trans child we see being used a lot.
00:16:57 Again, I come back to the point that in order to transition in this country,
00:17:01 you have to be diagnosed with a mental health condition.
00:17:03 So, you know, why are we not saying child with gender dysphoria?
00:17:07 Why are we saying trans child as if there's something immutable about them
00:17:10 that can never be changed?
00:17:11 Again, you wouldn't call them an anorexic child.
00:17:14 You would say a child with anorexia is a condition.
00:17:17 But there's a lot of money to be made in it.
00:17:18 I mean, we've seen organisations like Stonewall, every company and corporation has a diversity champion now.
00:17:24 And we've seen a huge increase in these kind of equity and equality roles springing up.
00:17:29 So it is very lucrative. On the sexualisation point, I mean, it's clearly there for us to see.
00:17:35 Again, we were speaking about this before we came on in terms of the kind of drag queen.
00:17:39 Yes, I was going to ask because this comes under the umbrella, presumably, of inclusivity.
00:17:44 does it know the drag queen story time i think there was actually a protest by some people
00:17:50 against one of these events last week um but does that come under the young people will ask why
00:17:57 suddenly what's behind this why is there this whole program in here and in america
00:18:03 um and uh once he's offering these kind of very disturbing clips on social media nowhere else
00:18:09 um is that under the banner of inclusivity is that why this is happening with kids
00:18:15 well i think partly it's been conflated with entertainment i mean we've seen this kind of
00:18:19 the drag stuff the RuPaul drag race etc kind of popping up so that's it's become
00:18:24 more of a model of entertainment although i wouldn't particularly think it's that entertaining
00:18:28 um that's just a personal view on it but uh yes i think people are fearful of of offending again
00:18:34 um but it's it's a bizarre situation i mean what relevance is it i'm all for children being read
00:18:41 stories before bedtime why does it need to be from a drag queen i mean i saw recently and thankfully
00:18:47 they rode back on this after myself and others spoke out about it but the the college of nursing
00:18:52 in midwifery was running a drag time story event for children and i i sent a message to them on
00:18:59 twitter saying firstly what is the relevance of this to your work on you know at all it's got
00:19:05 nothing to do with what you do so why are you pushing this and secondly you know have you
00:19:08 carried out risk assessments and safeguarding assessments and and why do you feel it's
00:19:12 appropriate to have children being influenced by this type of material again some of the videos
00:19:17 that you know you've referred to uh i saw one the other day i think it was from america in which
00:19:22 there's a drag queen on the stage and they invited a young child up to basically dance for money
00:19:28 and the child is dancing and gyrating this child cannot be more than five six years old and people
00:19:33 are throwing money at the stage of this child and the drag queen at the end says look how much money
00:19:37 you've made off this isn't it excellent i mean this is the very definition of sexualizing our
00:19:42 children but also i saw one of a drag queen just then open his legs completely and display
00:19:50 his genitals on stage you know this i think this was it was in somewhere in middle america
00:19:56 I'm just always, I'm just, you know, bewildered by seeing all of these young parents sitting around clapping and whatever.
00:20:06 I just, I don't get it.
00:20:08 Well, there's an inconsistency there because we know that the government, for example, are looking to clamp down on underage use of pornography.
00:20:16 That would seem to be, you know, a good ambition and aim to try and avoid sexualising children too young.
00:20:22 and yet i've come across many mps who are willing to speak out in favor of drag queen story time for
00:20:29 these children it's fundamentally inconsistent so yes we do need to ask well what why is this what
00:20:33 is going on here have you i mean you have had consequences haven't you for you know your
00:20:41 beliefs in this and and for speaking out i mean really quite serious ones james aren't they i
00:20:47 I mean, can you explain what's happened to you?
00:20:50 Yes, so I was training as a psychotherapist.
00:20:53 I was doing a master's degree.
00:20:55 I'd been a children's counsellor at Childline for about five years.
00:20:59 I was on the cusp of setting up a private practice last year.
00:21:01 This is basically what I wanted to spend the rest of my life doing.
00:21:04 But I became concerned about this gender ideology, about medicalising children.
00:21:10 I wrote a petition to the government as part of this ban on conversion therapy
00:21:14 that they were speaking of, and I basically said to them,
00:21:16 if you're going to ban this please can you safeguard explorative therapy for children
00:21:20 who are struggling with the gender um and for that in may of last year out of nowhere i received an
00:21:27 email from the the deputy ceo of my my university institution telling me that i was expelled from
00:21:32 my master's degree with immediate effect for bringing the profession into disrepute really
00:21:38 and well what about you know the as it were regulatory bodies in the area what what about
00:21:46 them did they not come to your aid or uh the the exact opposite actually uh i i put in a data
00:21:54 subject access request and i saw communications between my regulatory body to my training
00:22:01 institution basically saying we're very concerned about this student um you know reading between the
00:22:07 lines can you do something about it and within a few days of that email being sent i was expelled
00:22:13 so it seems as if they may have been in cahoots with one another
00:22:17 this basically you know you can't you cancel essentially a sort of cancellation cancellation
00:22:24 but where does this leave you then does this mean that you can't for example go on to be a therapist
00:22:30 or you know has it stymied your career well at the moment i'm in limbo i mean i'm taking
00:22:36 litigation against these institutions which we can come to in a moment but yes i'm i at the moment
00:22:41 i've got no training course in fact it was the only training course that i was able to do because
00:22:45 it was on weekends and it allowed me to keep a roof over my head with my job and pay my bills
00:22:50 um there isn't really any other suitable course that i can do um and as i said the regulatory
00:22:55 bodies that i need to be registered with seem to have been completely captured by this ideology
00:23:01 but it was very i mean it was immediate cancellation i remember the email dropped into my inbox
00:23:06 And I thought this has to be some sort of awful mistake and I went to respond to the
00:23:09 email and I discovered that my university email address had already been blocked within
00:23:13 a second of them having sent the email to me.
00:23:16 I tried to go onto the online portal to look at policies because no one had supplied me
00:23:19 with policies or evidence.
00:23:21 My access to that had been blocked as well.
00:23:23 And then the same evening I went onto my institution's Twitter account and they had publicised my
00:23:28 expulsion for everyone to see as if, as if.
00:23:31 You discouraged the others almost.
00:23:33 Well, it must have been because alongside it, they put out what they called a statement of solidarity with the LGBT community, you know, setting me against them in some way, trying to portray me as some sort of enemy of the LGBT community.
00:23:48 But it was, I mean, it was bizarre. I still can't quite believe it happened because they flouted all their policies.
00:23:54 when I finally got hold of a policy I saw that the grains for immediate expulsion from this
00:23:59 institution without appeal or hearing included sexually assaulting another student on campus
00:24:06 or defrauding the institution. I mean that's what they were comparing what I was doing to
00:24:11 and all I was doing was simply saying I have concerns about children's welfare can we talk
00:24:15 about this. Do you think that you are quite unusual in your beliefs in that field or not or
00:24:24 did other people, did you think are other people pretty much on your side but wouldn't say anything?
00:24:31 I mean there's there's a lot of the therapeutic community that have been taken in by this
00:24:36 ideology. I've come across online groups and fora where when they discovered that I'd been
00:24:42 expelled they were having mini celebrations about that fact so there are therapists out there who
00:24:47 are very happy to push this ideology um there's others who are just too scared to speak out i
00:24:53 there are a number of individuals from my course who i know think a similar way to the way that i
00:24:59 do but they don't say anything because they want to qualify and and they want to practice so they're
00:25:05 having to keep their heads down and i i understand that you know if everyone who spoke out was
00:25:12 cancelled then there wouldn't be any decent therapist left so we do need some good therapist
00:25:16 to make it through kind of under the radar as it were but i mean it's a disgrace you know therapy
00:25:20 of all professions when we're dealing with mental health complex controversial sensitive topics we
00:25:25 need to be able to talk about these things but for a training institution to throw a student under
00:25:30 the bus for raising concerns about children i think is a disgrace the thing you founded uh
00:25:36 thoughtful therapist is i mean i don't i'm just a genuine question i don't know but is it a sort of
00:25:42 an attempt to maybe build something alternative to what you might call the establishment
00:25:48 yeah it's it's look it's a small grassroots initiative it's primarily there to raise
00:25:53 concerns about gender ideology seeping into the therapeutic community we mentioned the conversion
00:25:58 therapy legislation that the government were looking to pass you know at one point they were
00:26:02 looking to include gender identity in the definition of the legislation that still might
00:26:07 happen we don't know the legislation hasn't reached the house of commons yet but if that
00:26:11 happened it could risk criminalizing ethical therapists who simply want to explore rather
00:26:16 than affirm children who say that they're trans so we're concerned about that we're trying to speak
00:26:21 out against the ideological capture of the therapeutic bodies that regulate us again i
00:26:26 know a number of qualified therapists long-standing therapists who have been dragged through
00:26:30 disciplinary processes for speaking out about these things as well. So we're concerned about
00:26:34 the direction that therapy in general is going. And I'm trying to also build more of a database
00:26:41 for want to better words for therapists who are going to behave ethically and exploratively rather
00:26:47 than simply affirmatively. I have parents reach out to me on an almost daily basis saying,
00:26:51 do you know any therapists who are not simply going to tell my child that yes, they should
00:26:55 take irreversible hormones you know there's parents out there are desperate to find some
00:27:01 some balanced uh help for their children um so i'm i've lost a lot of faith in the therapeutic
00:27:07 community in this country when did you originally decide you wanted to be a therapist
00:27:13 um well i practiced as a barrister in crime and i'd worked in civil service in crime and justice
00:27:19 for many years uh it started when i began volunteering at childline as a counselor
00:27:24 which is something that i'd always wanted to do and i found it so fulfilling you know helping young
00:27:28 people with whatever they might be struggling with in life i decided that i wanted to basically
00:27:33 spend the rest of my life doing that um interestingly a few weeks after i was
00:27:38 expelled from my university chart line also gave me the boot after five years of volunteering for
00:27:43 them um it's it's it's really quite concerning but and you know some of the the abuse that i
00:27:52 get online I mean look I'm not the only one but it's particularly painful because I went into this
00:27:59 field and I spoke out because I care about children's welfare and I've got people online
00:28:05 saying to me that by speaking out I'm a child abuser I've had people call me that
00:28:12 that's particularly painful to read I mean it's possibly in these situations a good thing to
00:28:18 stay off social media isn't it because I mean you know the amount particularly with the trans
00:28:24 people the amount of disgusting abuse people get if they cross them is quite extraordinary isn't
00:28:31 it it is and I mean I know others who've had it far worse the death threats um the vitriol I mean
00:28:40 but in some ways it washes over me more and more these days you know it's very easy to throw the
00:28:45 word transphobic or bigot around those have become two a penny really they've kind of almost lost all
00:28:52 all meaning but I find the bigot insult very interesting because these individuals obviously
00:28:57 haven't looked up the dictionary definition of what a bigot is which is an intolerance to other
00:29:01 people's beliefs and opinions and I would always advise those people to read a dictionary and
00:29:06 possibly have a long hard look in the mirror because they may well be describing themselves
00:29:10 oh yes yes they are the very thing they accuse you of it's becoming quite a saying isn't it um
00:29:18 would you say that i mean were you a political person before or would you say this is
00:29:22 has this politicized you in any way do you think well it's kind of taken over my life i mean prior
00:29:28 to this i just wanted to keep my head down get my qualification and and do a vocation that i
00:29:34 was extremely passionate about but i found with this topic that once you have your eyes open to
00:29:39 it you cannot unsee it you know when i speak to the parents who have been alienated from their
00:29:45 children through these online communities when i speak to de-transitioners who have had their
00:29:50 breasts cut off and can never have them replaced again um when i come across some of the horrific
00:29:55 materials that have been taught in schools to our young children uh i i don't see how i can ever
00:30:02 stop campaigning and advocating and speaking out against this because the stakes are far too high
00:30:07 mean I say that this is the issue of our time and there's a hell of a lot of dangerous and worrying
00:30:13 things going on in the world at the moment but to have an ideology sweep the globe and have such
00:30:19 profound impacts on women's safety on children's well-being on fairness in sports on freedom of
00:30:24 speech I think this is the issue of our time yes and also the fact that sort of amazingly enough we
00:30:31 We have this situation where people find it so hard to define a woman.
00:30:37 Oh, actually, no, it's been even crazier than that.
00:30:41 A Labour frontbench spokesman, Dawn Butler, I think it was,
00:30:44 once talked about kids being assigned birth.
00:30:48 This is assigned sex at birth.
00:30:50 This is a would-be minister.
00:30:54 I think extraordinary.
00:30:56 With one big exception, as we've just had the lionesses,
00:31:01 winning you know the football suddenly everyone knows what a woman is
00:31:09 it's um it's pathetic really it demonstrates the utter hypocrisy that they've got uh and in many
00:31:13 ways i think a lot of these individuals these politicians uh go whatever way the wind blows
00:31:18 whatever they feel paint them in the best light with their supporters even if it means avoiding
00:31:23 you know absolute truths even if it means flouting evidence biology and science
00:31:29 they'll say whatever they have to in that moment.
00:31:32 You mentioned earlier litigation, what stage are you at at the moment?
00:31:38 Well litigation is very expensive and I had to crowdfund the money for it, I mean the
00:31:43 the response I got was incredible, the generosity of complete strangers who know nothing about me
00:31:48 other than this. I've managed to raise currently around £100,000 towards this.
00:31:54 I'm not the only one, there's many other cases have been crowdfunded, it demonstrates the strength
00:31:58 the feeling that exists out there um and people who don't have a voice themselves i'm kind of i
00:32:04 think in many ways a vehicle for their voice to be heard um so i'm i'm suing my training institution
00:32:10 which is called the metanoia institute it's a standalone therapeutic institution
00:32:15 and my former regulatory body which are called the united kingdom council for psychotherapy i'm
00:32:19 suing them both for discrimination um against my beliefs my gender critical beliefs um i'm taking
00:32:25 them to the employment tribunal um we had a preliminary hearing a month ago and we're
00:32:30 waiting for the outcome of that um but this one way the other is going to be going to trial um
00:32:35 possibly not until next year yeah um but i will have my day in court absolutely uh in the meantime
00:32:42 it's a little bit a stressful thing isn't it living with waiting for you or not um it's good
00:32:49 to know that so many people are going to put their money with their mouth you know and support you
00:32:53 well i you know being truthful that has added the pressure of it because
00:32:59 you know if this were privately funded okay it's my money um but now i feel that i am representing
00:33:06 other people you know i don't want to let them down i'm taking this action as much to stand up
00:33:13 for all the other people out there and to say to educational institutes and employers you cannot
00:33:17 treat people like this you cannot curtail the free speech as as much as i'm doing it for my
00:33:22 own personal justice. So I want to get the right outcome for all of my supporters, but I'm just
00:33:31 happy I'm going to have my day in court and be able to, you know, stare at these people from
00:33:36 across the room who've done this to me and seek justice because unfortunately litigation should
00:33:43 be the last resort. But for many of us these days, it is the only resort and it's the only way that
00:33:49 these people are going to be taught less
00:33:50 and that they cannot treat others like this.
00:33:53 So where do people,
00:33:54 if they want to contribute to your crowdfund,
00:33:57 how do they do that?
00:33:58 I mean, what do they,
00:33:59 should they go to your,
00:34:01 do you have a website?
00:34:03 If they type in James S's into Google,
00:34:05 the top hit will be my crowd justice page,
00:34:08 which has all the information about the case
00:34:11 and they can make a donation if they'd like to
00:34:13 and keep up to date with the case.
00:34:15 I'm active on Twitter as well,
00:34:17 which is just my name james s's thoughtful therapists we also have our own website that's
00:34:22 thoughtfultherapists.org um and i'm always happy for people to reach out to me as well
00:34:27 if they need support or if they've got their own stories to tell it's important that i keep
00:34:31 listening to the people whose lives have been directly affected by this ideology great i have
00:34:35 to say i mean you know all power to you for you know your day in court of course um the thoughtful
00:34:41 for therapists, I think you're on to something there in the long term. I mean, this idea
00:34:50 I tend to talk about a lot of alternative institutions and alternative bodies that people
00:34:56 can go to, I think you should really go with that. That's my piece of unsolicited advice,
00:35:02 I mean for the future. I think I'll take that advice.
00:35:04 Could be very big. Thank you very, very much indeed, thanks for coming on. That's James
00:35:09 ssa you got all those addresses um that's it for this week and we shall see you next time thank
00:35:15 you very much hello if you're enjoying the new culture forum channel and you believe in our
00:35:22 mission may i invite you to join our membership scheme at the link below or on our website
00:35:29 newcultureforum.org.uk our work is more important now than ever and we have great plans ahead for
00:35:37 the future but we can't do it without your support from as little as three pounds per month you can
00:35:43 help ensure that we continue on our mission as a member you'll receive a range of benefits including
00:35:50 access to exclusive content invitations to our private events including here at our studios
00:35:58 free copies of our books and much much more including of course our famous ncf mug
00:36:04 If you aren't able to become a member then please help us by clicking this
00:36:10 button and subscribing to our channel. It's completely free, just remember to
00:36:16 also click the bell icon so that you can get notifications when we post new
00:36:21 videos. Thank you.