New Culture Forum - September 17, 2022


The Queen Is Dead Long Live The King The New Culture Forum Reflects On The Old Reign The New

Fired By Childline For My Child Safety Concerns. Abusive Practices Are Damaging Our Children. PayPal v. Free Speech Union + Muslim-Hindu Sectarianism in Britain + Britain's Obesity Crisis

Episode Stats


Length

42 minutes

Words per minute

174.27

Word count

7,339

Sentence count

141


Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
00:00:00 Hello and welcome to Newspeak, New Culture Forum's weekly look at news. Of course the
00:00:12 news this week is of a different order entirely and we're going to be devoting our program to
00:00:19 what has been a momentous time in this country's history. I'm very pleased to be joined as usual
00:00:28 by Senior Fellow and Royal Commentator Rafe Hadle-Mancou, Emma Webb, who you know obviously
00:00:36 is usually the host of this program, and Dr. Philip Kisley, Senior Fellow of the New Culture Forum.
00:00:44 We're going to look at various different aspects of the past week, but I want to start really
00:00:50 with asking my fellow guests here their initial reactions to what we've seen so far.
00:00:56 It's basically just over a week since Her Majesty Queen Elizabeth II died. Words we never thought
00:01:04 we would say. Queen Victoria once said famously, great events make me calm. Rafe, start with
00:01:15 you. How has it made you feel? Well, it turns out that the Britain that we were told was
00:01:23 long dead and gone is alive and well and I've been so heartened to see the outpouring of support
00:01:31 and affection for both her late Majesty as well as for the King and I got the first glimpse of it
00:01:38 really on Tuesday. It was a cold miserable damp day and the hearse with Her Majesty arrived
00:01:45 and I have to say it warmed the cockles of my heart to see the reception that Her Majesty's
00:01:51 Coffin got. Now I'm an old traditionalist for me when you would see a coffin go by you you'd
00:01:57 duff your cap and you'd bow your head but times move on and we had this round spontaneous round
00:02:02 of applause and cheers which seemed to be very odd and a thousand spots of light from all of
00:02:07 these mobile phone cameras but then I thought well the sincerity behind the motivation behind
00:02:13 the action was just as genuine as a traditional way of mourning and sharing respect and times
00:02:18 move on and it just to me encapsulated the the vast change that we've seen
00:02:23 socially since Her Majesty has been Queen and yet despite how cynical we
00:02:27 might be about the people of today here there was genuine outpouring of support
00:02:32 and sympathy and concern and I found that extremely heartening as I did with
00:02:37 His Majesty when he on his first time going to Buckingham Palace as King he
00:02:41 had his car stop at the gates of Buckingham Palace something we've never
00:02:45 seen before, we've never seen the cadre stop and the sovereign to emerge from it and engage with
00:02:50 his subjects and it was it was reciprocated and there was and you know for 10-20 years we have
00:02:57 been worrying about the transition. Many people thought in the royal household this would be a
00:03:02 time of crisis when we weren't certain whether the people would actually accept the new sovereign,
00:03:08 how would that go? And I must say I'm sure everyone in the royal household is feeling
00:03:12 very reassured. It's early days still but it certainly seems as if the transition and the
00:03:18 succession has gone as well as could ever be hoped. I think I would agree to you that the
00:03:23 journey of the Carfin from RAF Northolt to Buckingham Palace for me has an almost Shakespearean
00:03:31 quality about it in the rain. I'm thinking particularly of that motorway, what we call
00:03:36 the Westway coming into London and all these people from 15 miles. Emma, what particular
00:03:45 point has stood out for you in terms of reaction? Well I mean just in response to that, I don't know
00:03:51 if you saw the photos of the people on horseback and tractors lined all along the motorway and that
00:03:57 was very Shakespearean, it looked like something from a sort of Shakespearean battle scene or
00:04:04 or something, so just before I came here I got trapped in the crowds with the procession
00:04:11 coming through, and one thing that really struck me, in line with what Rafe was saying,
00:04:19 was that on the side of the barrier that I was on, so this huge, opaque, probably eight
00:04:25 foot, opaque barriers, hundreds of people who couldn't see the procession, still waiting
00:04:31 there patiently and then this shush came across the crowd, everyone went silent listening
00:04:37 to hear the sound of the procession because they couldn't see anything and then suddenly
00:04:41 this cheer and it was this just an incredible gesture of respect from the crowd towards
00:04:47 the Queen and the reverence of that because even though they weren't able to actually
00:04:51 see what was going on it was almost as if all these hundreds of people wanted to show
00:04:58 that respect and to just be present and just the day before we heard the news of Her Majesty
00:05:04 passing away, I was in Bowwood Estate in Wiltshire and we were looking around the grounds and
00:05:12 I was talking to one of the tour guides about the landscape was created by Capability Brown
00:05:19 and we were talking about the maps that he'd produced and that they just had these little
00:05:23 dots on where the seeds had been planted and so I asked her well if it takes a hundred years for
00:05:29 these trees to mature then Capability Brown and none of the people who ever hired him to do any
00:05:34 of his work would have ever seen his works fully mature Capability Brown wouldn't have seen his own
00:05:41 creations coming into maturity and for some reason that sort of stuck with me and seemed
00:05:47 really poignant because when I heard the news that Her Majesty's passing was
00:05:52 imminent I can't believe that sort of how surreal it was that I was sitting in
00:05:57 Sir Roger Scruton's office listening to an opera performance that was organised
00:06:04 by the Common Sense Society with Lady Scruton and we'd just been out apple
00:06:08 picking in the orchard and we were sitting there and the first thing that
00:06:15 that popped into my mind after seeing this text message I think was actually
00:06:19 your text message Peter the first thing that popped into my mind was this
00:06:23 Anglo-Saxon phrase with I think it's pronounced weird than arid which means
00:06:27 fate is inexorable and it's this sense of the marching of time and like you
00:06:30 were saying Rafe that when Prince Philip died I almost felt that I was mourning
00:06:36 the Queen as well as Prince Philip and I cried so much but I cried less on this
00:06:42 occasion, not just because I think I did a lot of my mourning in advance but because
00:06:46 it really was a case of the Queen is dead long live the King and you had this feeling
00:06:51 of the march of history continuing to go on and I haven't really quite worked my way
00:07:00 through how I feel about all these things yet.
00:07:03 You mentioned the tractors and the people on horses all lined up along the road in rural
00:07:10 Filarious. Philip, this isn't just a London based thing is it?
00:07:15 Oh god no, my response was, I was shocked at how visceral my response was actually,
00:07:25 it was a raw emotional response and I'm not ashamed to say that I filled up when I heard
00:07:32 but I was quite surprised that I did. I was thinking about the Queen and I'll come back
00:07:38 Back to the point about other places, but I was thinking about the Queen as this tiny
00:07:45 yet enormous figure, and I was thinking about the family and how their experience maps onto
00:07:55 our own experience, there's something about it, and I said this over the weekend, there's
00:07:59 something about it that is about the we, there's something that brings us together,
00:08:06 It's human and it's natural and it's symbolic.
00:08:11 One of the things that really struck me was the fact that, as Rafe said, so many people
00:08:17 have just responded essentially in the same way that I've done.
00:08:21 And I've seen that, I've talked to neighbours where I live in Leeds, I've talked to people
00:08:25 who I know in Manchester, everybody feels the same.
00:08:28 Everybody feels as though this is seismic, this is enormous.
00:08:31 But one of the things that I really take away from it, and I think this is really important,
00:08:36 we talk about a set of values on this show every week, don't we?
00:08:44 Within which the Queen is at the centre and the monarchy is at the centre.
00:08:49 They represent our values, don't they?
00:08:51 It's so lovely to see other people actively and publicly buying into those values.
00:08:57 We think about this often in an intellectual way, but actually, responding emotionally
00:09:04 to it is so important because, and I suppose this is where I'm getting to, it's the
00:09:10 pomp, the ceremony and the Queen, it's like an antidote to the poison of identity politics.
00:09:17 It's the we rather than the me and I felt that right across the North, everybody I know
00:09:24 right across the north feels feels the same thing and it's and it's so wonderful that
00:09:28 they do.
00:09:29 Yeah I mean I think you know you're quite right this idea of the we that you talk about
00:09:33 I think this is extraordinarily powerful even when it is the we in mourning there's
00:09:41 an oddly life-affirming feeling that you can get even in sadness.
00:09:46 It's also the the the proof of the value of ritual as well like I was saying that
00:09:52 because we haven't seen many of these rituals before you know we haven't seen the accession
00:09:57 and yet it's something that it seems so natural to people to understand and appreciate it even
00:10:01 though it's something that transcends explanation it transcends obvious reason
00:10:06 and that we talked about this during the jubilee this sort of transcendent familial
00:10:12 aspect to the relationship between the monarchy and the people
00:10:15 Well that's why, you're absolutely right, constitutional monarchy is a form of government
00:10:22 as a system, is a far more personal and emotional and physical form of relationship than you
00:10:31 could ever get into a republic.
00:10:34 Republics have a constitution, a written piece of paper behind glass in the Library of Congress
00:10:39 for example, but we don't have that, we have a living, breathing embodiment of our constitution.
00:10:44 The Sovereign is not only our direct tie back to William the Conqueror and Alfred the Great,
00:10:50 but is actually the living embodiment of the collective evolution of our Constitution
00:10:55 and is the source of all power, is the Fonz of Norm, the fount of honour.
00:10:59 Everything stems from the Sovereign and the idea of this woman's epitomising it all makes
00:11:06 us personally invested and as I've often said before on here, we don't have a national day
00:11:12 to celebrate every year. We don't have a war revolution, we don't have like Bastille
00:11:17 Day, an Independence Day, like July the 4th of America. So for us it is the royal family
00:11:24 that is the focal point of all of our emotion, all of our patriotism is focused on royal
00:11:29 weddings, on births, on coronations and jubilees, the triumphs, but also the tragedies of state
00:11:35 funerals. It provides those rare moments for our nation to come together. We don't really
00:11:39 have much jingoistic patriotic options in this country and it's the focal point and so when that
00:11:44 is lost the Queen's life spans one-tenth of the existence of the monarchy. It's incredible.
00:11:49 She was around for a hundred years and when the monarchy is a thousand years you think gosh and
00:11:54 for better or worse our collective memory is the span of a century so that link of the Queen's life
00:11:59 which goes beyond 70 years it goes it goes to 96 years basically a hundred years we think of her
00:12:04 also on the balcony of Buckingham Palace with Winston Churchill the last global figure connecting
00:12:10 us to the second world war that is something so profound and just the psychology of the fact that
00:12:16 in our subconscious we have seen this woman's image since we were children on stamps on coins
00:12:22 on banknotes but you go to you go to Canada or America you see it there too it's ubiquitous
00:12:28 and we don't even realise the profound psychological impact this person has had in our lives.
00:12:32 Talking about that psychological impact, I think this week and what's happened speaks
00:12:39 very very definitely and very clearly to the human condition and that's two things, isn't
00:12:44 it?
00:12:45 Longevity, we all wish for longevity but we all wish for renewal as well and I think you
00:12:50 know the Queen dying and the King, both of those things together, it's another thing
00:12:56 that we invest in.
00:12:57 There's a certain eternity to it.
00:12:58 thing that we invest in, it connects directly with our humanity and us as people.
00:13:04 Well isn't this in a way, I mean this is that that famous Edmund Burke quote isn't it?
00:13:10 Absolutely. The society is the people who came before.
00:13:14 It's a partnership between the unborn, the living and the dead.
00:13:16 Yes and the people, a monarchy almost is a living embodiment of that.
00:13:20 And that's why it sort of stuck with me that I was saying about that the Capability Brown
00:13:26 landscape of the the fact that you you would you know plant these trees and make these
00:13:33 extraordinary landscapes but you're not you're in doing so it's an act of faith it's an investment
00:13:38 in the future it's something that is for future generations it's an entirely different way of
00:13:43 thinking that is embodied in the Queen herself of it's an entirely um different way of you know
00:13:51 know we've heard over the last couple of days people particularly on online
00:13:55 saying things about the monarchy you know what does this person done to
00:13:59 deserve this but that's actually that's that's from a very different way of
00:14:04 thinking the way of thinking that is embodied in the institution of monarchies
00:14:07 is the very Burke in view that that these things come to you in life and you
00:14:13 step up to them and you fulfill your duties and the Queen in her birthday
00:14:18 speech on her 21st birthday when she said that whether her life be long or
00:14:22 short that she promised to serve this nation and that was something that
00:14:25 immediately people were talking about as soon as they heard that she passed away
00:14:28 because she had done what she had said and she kept her word and I think that
00:14:34 you were saying this is the antidote to many of the troubles of our time that
00:14:39 actually culture isn't some often people talk about things and they talk about
00:14:45 values but ultimately the way that you preserve a culture and the way that you
00:14:48 keep it alive is by doing it and what we've seen is that people have
00:14:52 instinctively something has spoken to the human condition that there is
00:14:56 something that to a degree it's like asking someone why do they love their
00:15:00 mother why do they love the Queen you know there's something that has brought
00:15:04 people out in hundreds of thousands perhaps millions in Edinburgh all
00:15:09 across the country and now in London as well over the next couple of days and
00:15:14 and they are acting out something that is ancient and they are part of this sort of almost eternal
00:15:21 thread that's that's why the and in a way the ceremony the pomp is so important but in a way
00:15:27 they are participating what you're saying the queen is somehow small and huge that that they
00:15:33 themselves being part of this historical moment are like capability brown planting those seeds
00:15:38 it's a kind of faith in the future that i find very heartening and there's something else as
00:15:42 as well Roger Scruton always used to say it's really difficult to describe conservatism
00:15:48 because essentially you're describing a feeling what we've had over the last week or so is
00:15:53 that feeling playing out on a national scale and it feels as though people are beginning
00:16:01 to understand or more people are beginning to understand what we try and intellectualize
00:16:05 every week and and what everybody on our side of the fence does and it's it's seeing it
00:16:11 and feeling it and experiencing it I think I think that that is a um cannot be underestimated
00:16:18 at that point actually the people are seeing things working out in front of their eyes
00:16:23 that they wouldn't have known Rafe obviously people will know you've been on GB news it
00:16:29 seems like 24 hours a day you're wearing wearing well I've got matchsticks under my eyes
00:16:36 but I'm sure they've got beautiful brocade on them and you obviously have been commentating
00:16:43 and explaining these particular constitutional ceremonies and everything um do you feel that I
00:16:48 mean I I feel that people I feel this is strengthening our culture yes because people
00:16:54 are actually seeing the constitution played out for the first time this is far better
00:16:58 than sitting in a university academic course learning about constitutional law or in a civics
00:17:03 class in secondary school and it goes back to what you're saying you know if children can now see
00:17:08 how the transition works how smoothly and flawlessly it works there are no hanging chads
00:17:14 if people remember the the Al Gore George Bush election the supreme court having decided whether
00:17:20 whether a vote counted or not the transition just works there's stability there's continuity
00:17:26 and in terms of what you were saying earlier i absolutely agree you know the queen regarded
00:17:30 the coronation as a sacrament akin to becoming a priest and for her it was a covenant between god
00:17:36 and herself and between herself and the people and she fulfilled that covenant now the people
00:17:42 the subjects the citizens of this country may not understand it in those terms but they sort of get
00:17:47 it that she has fulfilled her covenant she has fulfilled her promise now it is up to us to say
00:17:52 thank you for that. Now it is up to us to pay respect and to pay tribute and homage to an
00:17:57 honourable woman who has done what she said she would do, but also by doing that they are proactively
00:18:04 inserting themselves into history, they are becoming part of the fabric of this nation
00:18:09 by being able to say well I was there. You don't get that in a republic, there's no way to engage
00:18:14 with the constitution in a republic, this way people will say you know this woman meant so
00:18:21 much to me, I was there, I saw the succession take place, I am now part of history.
00:18:26 Do you know the thing is, sorry Emma, the thing is actually that there are actual physical
00:18:30 manifestations of that. I went and put flowers down in winter at the top of the Long Wall,
00:18:39 which is where most of them are. People were actually, the things they were writing, you
00:18:42 had kids writing things and everything, but people also writing from families, like from
00:18:46 the Smith family or something um that very thing duty done rest in peace it was that duty done in
00:18:54 other words yeah you kept your side of the bargain you know which is quite extraordinary isn't it
00:18:59 and it's it's uh unusual as well for um character traits to be something that is praised because
00:19:07 really what people are thanking her for is her loyalty and her service and i think that we never
00:19:12 really and you know you were saying about comparing it with republics that
00:19:17 have an elected head of state I think there's something about the monarchy
00:19:22 that works because fundamentally at its heart it's true and there's a truth to
00:19:27 it whereas you can't have an emotional bond or an emotional feeling towards
00:19:32 something that doesn't have that truth at the heart of it which I think is the
00:19:35 way that people fail to emotionally respond to republics and I think part of
00:19:41 that truth as well is her stoicism there's something very real and awe-inspiring and
00:19:50 strong about her stoicism and again it contrasts completely with the emotional incontinence
00:19:57 and and essentially emotional lies that tend to you know represent our the day today.
00:20:05 So Elizabeth the Steadfast, Elizabeth the Great, it's almost like a slightly therapeutic
00:20:10 feel to it, I mean if you get caught up in a national thing like this, you know you forget
00:20:15 about all that internal stuff actually. I think it's also, I think it's also the fact that we are,
00:20:20 people are realising that we have lost somebody who stood for values and beliefs which aren't
00:20:26 around very much any longer, this was a supreme champion of civic duty, the supreme champion of
00:20:32 self-sacrifice and of service and indeed of stoicism, somebody who steered the monarchy
00:20:37 away from a celebrity path, somebody who stood for qualities which were once commonplace,
00:20:43 but now seem to be despised. And there's a sort of feeling of loss because in this increasingly
00:20:49 discombobulated and fractious world, knowing that Her Majesty was there provided that reassurance,
00:20:55 not just Constancy and the Rock, but a belief that those values still existed.
00:20:59 And there's something else there that's a generational thing, isn't there? Because
00:21:02 she is of a generation, the generation that won the war, that have pretty much gone now
00:21:09 and that generation absolutely represents all of those things you've just been talking
00:21:13 about and it's almost like we're saying goodbye to that amazing generation that's connected
00:21:18 to Rachel Churchill. I see it as more of the people coming out and saying no we want that.
00:21:24 That's what I mean but she's the last of that and and it's she's the last of those people or
00:21:29 one of the last of those people there can't be many people left born in the 1920s but the values
00:21:34 that she represents what I'm saying is you know we're that's why we're responding to her in the
00:21:38 way that we are I think I think those values that exist but there is nobody purveying them on any
00:21:45 platform on the national or international stage no but they and that's that's what I meant it's
00:21:50 she's very you know we don't want to say goodbye to that we desperately want that to continue
00:21:55 and she's the last of that generation that absolutely embody those things.
00:21:59 Yes, I mean by the very nature of coming out and thanking someone for having those,
00:22:03 tends to suggest that those values are still there, but not as you say reflect on the public
00:22:08 platform. Do you think that the coverage has been good? I mean I have to say I think mostly
00:22:15 it's been impeccable. The only thing, I know in some ways you know you're biased in this,
00:22:21 I think on the whole who has been more critical of the BBC than us, I think on the whole that
00:22:27 they have done, they're obviously not going to you know take any chances with red ties
00:22:33 like we have with Peter Sissons or these terrible jokey things that they had at the Diamond
00:22:38 Jubilee.
00:22:39 Threatening to remove a licence fee clearly has its benefits doesn't it, which focuses
00:22:44 the mind wonderfully.
00:22:45 I've been watching GB news rolling the entire time so my entire experience has been watching
00:22:52 rave yeah I'm sorry yeah what about I mean one thing the media has highlighted and you can't
00:22:59 blame them for doing it although it does distort the picture have been these various peripheral
00:23:05 protests I mean you know one in Edinburgh two in Edinburgh and then a couple of people here and
00:23:10 that and obviously there are people who are now there's a kind of debate on social media isn't
00:23:15 there if you believe in free speech then basically you can't have it one way and not the other you've
00:23:22 got to defend them which I sort of would kind of agree but don't you I don't know whether you agree
00:23:26 with this but to me it's not actually a match of principle yes I would say that they could
00:23:30 it's just a matter of what I'd call just common decency you're gonna have like months now to make
00:23:36 your case, why do you have to do it at the funeral?
00:23:39 Well, I think that's precisely it, I mean we have to be very careful not to be hypocritical.
00:23:44 If we want to preserve freedom of speech on our side, we have to perfectly accept it when
00:23:48 it comes from the other side, but there's plenty of time to protest at the coronation,
00:23:53 I have no objection to that, at any of the future events involving the monarchy in the
00:23:58 months ahead, but until Monday, until the funeral is done and done and buried, if I
00:24:03 can say that are undusted let's have some decorum to hurl abuse at a son of a mother whose coffin
00:24:11 he's walking behind is detestable yeah to um to hold up signs with vulgarities on them in front
00:24:17 of people who are mourning and this is a family now that being said i don't think the police were
00:24:22 right to arrest these people no no i don't think that they were right now we know the problems with
00:24:26 the police the monarchy never asked for the police to act in this way this again is the is the police
00:24:32 overreaching as they have with Harry Miller and the thought crimes of Twitter so they're doing on
00:24:38 this side. Let these people embarrass themselves and don't make martyrs of them and the problem
00:24:44 now is Republic, this Republican organisation has now got a, is chomping at the bit saying
00:24:49 look what should this is an attack on free speech, the monarchy is anti-democratic. If the police
00:24:54 had just let them alone people would have been so disgusted by them. The sheer hypocrisy of it is
00:24:59 just it's just breathtaking is that you know the the radical left have been closing down
00:25:03 free speech on everything in every institution for years and you know the anti-monarchy
00:25:10 oh great free speech absolutists now I mean for me let them let these people do it it
00:25:17 just shows them how it shows everybody how devoid of human decency they are and and you
00:25:24 You know, it illustrates the kind of world we would have, their kind of world.
00:25:30 Do we want their world?
00:25:31 Of course we don't.
00:25:32 Let them scream and shout as much as they want.
00:25:34 In fact, another kind of world I wouldn't particularly like is an official one, and
00:25:38 that is the American media's coverage, which, not in total, but when you consider
00:25:46 they were our main ally, etc., always very, very fond of the Queen, you've got people
00:25:53 talking about colonialism and why should you know this on on mainstream
00:25:58 again no sense of decorum but also sheer ignorance but also
00:26:05 allied with the American university system the really shocking thing is some
00:26:10 of the absolute filth that's come from major American institutions and you know
00:26:15 in the same thing as the as the press the American university
00:26:22 system has become a circus sideshow of race baiting it's just completely bizarre
00:26:27 it's just finished. It's also interesting how how removed from the facts the critics
00:26:33 have been so I've had a lot of people contacting me via social media trying I
00:26:39 guess they think to call out our side of the debate the free speech free speech
00:26:45 warriors for not speaking out in criticism of this when in fact pretty
00:26:50 quickly straight away the free speech union released a statement the free speech union
00:26:56 reached out to the person who'd been arrested and offered assistance but actually the same people
00:27:03 who have been attacking the monarchy for colonialism and so on and you know accusing the queen of being
00:27:11 in some way directly involved in all sorts of atrocities and deaths and so on that the the
00:27:18 hypocrisy that they are accusing the right of the people who are pro-free speech and therefore somehow
00:27:25 defines being right-wing they're accusing them of hypocrisy with you know when the facts completely
00:27:31 contradict it because everybody is being outspoken against it but actually like you say the hypocrisy
00:27:36 has been that those people who are critical about colonialism and so on um that they are the ones
00:27:44 who so readily would have people arrested and censored for saying things that are offensive
00:27:52 but when somebody is yelling at a funeral going by suddenly they are they're in favour of free
00:27:58 speech and think that they can call out the the usual free speech um warriors for it so um it's
00:28:07 there's hypocrisy on the one hand and there's dishonesty on the other so what they do is they
00:28:11 they take a historical event and completely misrepresent it or just out lie about it and
00:28:20 what people do is look at it and think my god that's terrible and accept it because
00:28:24 they don't have the time or inclination to research into it and think oh my god that's
00:28:28 completely and utterly wrong so I've done that a couple of times online and a few other
00:28:33 people have done that as well we've pushed back on it and that's what we've really got
00:28:37 to do because that's how social justice warriors work, they throw a lie out there, it looks
00:28:42 and sounds reprehensible and because people don't have the time or inclination they don't
00:28:47 push back on it so people who are in the business need to do that.
00:28:52 Yes in the business they need to, I think that there's one big pushback going on which
00:28:57 people don't even think it's a pushback at the moment and that's been the reaction
00:29:01 to this past week, I think. As you started by saying Rafe, it is quite extraordinary
00:29:09 to me to see a country that had fallen from view, should we say. Speaking of which, I'd
00:29:17 never been a great fan of Prince Charles, I found that actually I was a great example
00:29:23 of this thing of where allegiance simply goes from one to the other and now I've been hugely
00:29:28 impressed and um you know suddenly he seemed to have overnight grown into something to the point
00:29:34 where you sort of think well actually this must be just me projecting but actually he just seemed
00:29:38 very kingly and it's that voice actually the Queen obviously we're very used to her speaking
00:29:45 Charles has got almost a theatrical voice about him which I think actually is going to
00:29:50 really serve him very very well do you think I mean it's a honeymoon but it's a good start isn't it
00:29:57 it's a very good start I mean I looked at him and I'd never really thought of him as
00:30:03 being a queen and a king and like you a queen and who knows but like you I was flabbergasted
00:30:13 you know yes he is the king it's like someone pulled two chemicals together and he's the king
00:30:18 you know but you said that quite a quite a while ago I can't remember what it was on you
00:30:23 you said that people will just accept him and will think of him as the king
00:30:27 I think his performance seems to be more, there's a poll out today showing that his approval
00:30:33 rating has gone from suddenly from 39% which has always been around up to 61, 63.
00:30:40 I think though going back to what we were saying about the relationship, the emotional
00:30:45 relationship with the royal family being a familial one, the way that I view it is that
00:30:51 you don't choose who your family are and so while my views of prince charles's past behavior the
00:30:59 views that he's expressed and so on and in some cases the people he's associated with whilst i
00:31:06 still have my views about those things he is still my king he's our king um and that isn't you know
00:31:14 you don't get to choose the character of the person when he isn't when he is anointed in the coronation
00:31:18 ceremony even more so and so like you're saying about your allegiance switching
00:31:23 as it really is it totally embodied in and actually I was at a dinner the night
00:31:30 after everybody heard about this and John O'Sullivan stood up and said the
00:31:34 Queen is dead long live the king and it really is that switch and suddenly you
00:31:40 know he is that he is the king and my loyalty is to the crown and to the
00:31:45 institution of monarchy and with that comes a love of the monarch regardless
00:31:49 of the fact of his character he will be moulded by the role and I actually feel
00:31:55 quite optimistic in some ways. Are you or are you more sceptical Ray? No I've never
00:32:00 been sceptical I've always said that he should be not the king. No no no of the long term. But my point was whether or not you agree with his
00:32:07 views on various issues nobody can deny that the motivation is genuine
00:32:13 sincerity to improve the country no one can say that he has an ulterior motive
00:32:17 to undermine the nation and that's the key aspect here we're so lucky to have
00:32:22 somebody who's devoted their lives the longest apprenticeship in history having
00:32:26 to find a role for himself as Prince of Wales everything he's done it has in his
00:32:30 mind beefed for the betterment of Britain we could have had a playboy
00:32:33 Prince we could have had somebody who spent the last 50 years in Monte Carlo
00:32:37 on the roulette wheels instead we had somebody actively engaged and there's a
00:32:40 very very good letter he wrote in 93 which is published in David Dimbleby's biography of him
00:32:46 in which he's he's lists his motivation in in all of his activities he said I want to make
00:32:52 Great Britain great again I want to put the great back in and that means to me looking after
00:32:57 agriculture but also getting a professional military and he lists all of these things which
00:33:01 no traditional conservative could have any objection to it's a remarkable list to go through
00:33:06 and uh at the at the end of it he said you know he says I want to roll back the 1960s and all of
00:33:13 the terrible results of architecture art music and you think well who could do who could not say
00:33:20 but the key thing where do I put my cross was in his first was in his first speech he said
00:33:24 I understand as king I will not have time for the interests and charities I was previously
00:33:29 involved with and I think we have to take him he understands he's not a fool he said I'm not a fool
00:33:33 before i know when i'm king i have to be different so yes i'm absolutely behind the man now as long
00:33:39 as he keeps to his word and keeps the activism at bay yeah when he said he would he would put
00:33:44 the politics to one side yes it was that but it was it was coupled with the sheer emotion of of
00:33:52 that speech and and and and i was just watching it and i was just absolutely in awe again i've said
00:33:58 said that twice now, I really was, and I thought yes, you can do this, you can stand up to
00:34:04 this, he looked every inch, the king, and he acted it, he wasn't playing it, acting
00:34:10 is the wrong word, he wasn't playing it, he was being it, and I'm hopeful for the
00:34:14 future, I'm hopeful for the future.
00:34:17 Speaking of the future, you know, although we've talked endlessly, haven't we, about
00:34:21 the way schools indoctrinate young people and everything, all I can say is that down
00:34:26 in like winter at the long walk or or indeed in London, central London here. I would say
00:34:33 that half the crowd if not more have been under 40. You know there is this view of world fans
00:34:39 being oh you know we used to call blue rinse hair and all the rest of it like the Troy Barley
00:34:43 Conference. Not at all, young families, teenagers, single people whatever all coming with flowers
00:34:50 so that that to me gives the light to that time. And children leaving their teddy bears
00:34:55 and I saw it was probably on GP news that some of the notes that had been written said things like
00:35:05 please look after my teddy bear and you know children handing over their toys and
00:35:11 leaving little paddent and bears and little marmalade sandwiches in plastic bags with
00:35:16 for later written on it. Do you know what it is? It's the difference between the media version
00:35:21 of Britain and actual Britain you know and and we what we're seeing now is actual Britain.
00:35:28 Well actually in terms of the the split the media version of Scotland versus the actual
00:35:33 version of Scotland I wonder if Nicola Sturgeon will have had a look at those crowds and thought
00:35:37 maybe this isn't the time after all. Yes finally people talked about a memorial I mean or rather
00:35:47 people talked about statues of queen for quite a long time uh there used to be a convention that
00:35:51 you should wait till the monarch's gone although i don't know how they got around that with queen
00:35:56 victoria all the statues of you know from the diamond jubilee queen victoria from that time
00:36:02 anyway um simon heifer has written a piece talking about a statue he thinks there should be a statue
00:36:08 of the queen and a fountain possibly in parliament square so in other words not on the fourth plinth
00:36:13 you know the fourth plinth in Chevalier Square in London is where those hideous pieces of trash art
00:36:20 are put up in order to mock the rest of the square let's face it. How would the Queen best be
00:36:29 commemorated in marble or stone in your view and where? Question of the week. I agree with Simon,
00:36:37 I think it should be in Parliament Square and I think he said something about an equestrian type
00:36:41 like a statue, I think that would be marvellous. I don't think it should be in Trafalgar Square,
00:36:46 it shouldn't be on that fourth plinth, it should be permanent. I know that it would
00:36:51 be permanent anyway there but I think it should be a million miles away from the nonsense
00:36:56 that that fourth plinth represents.
00:36:58 I agree, although why limit ourselves to one statue? I also think that there are some absolutely
00:37:08 beautiful photographs of the Queen ceremonial on horseback and she looks so regal and so
00:37:15 powerful. I think that a sculpture made of one of those photographs would be just magisterial
00:37:23 and there should be at least one primary large statue in a very prominent place in the most,
00:37:32 whatever the most prominent place would be in Parliament Square for example. But I also
00:37:37 think that in favour of local people organising themselves, we saw so much of that interest
00:37:45 through Save Our Statues, that there should be help for local people to organise themselves
00:37:52 to get local statues as well, we should have statues of her all around the country.
00:37:55 Certainly, because that was what statues have always been about, it's been about local
00:38:00 people getting their own statues, yeah public subscription.
00:38:03 I prefer Parliament Square to be a square for statesmen. I've never been too happy with
00:38:08 it being used for other purposes and we've seen that now with an actually British statesman,
00:38:12 I don't know why Nelson Mandela is there for example.
00:38:14 Gandhi also.
00:38:15 And again Gandhi as well, I just don't understand the logic behind there. Now, the reason that
00:38:19 they've got the temporary exhibitions on the fourth plinth is because the intention had
00:38:24 always been to put the Queen there and that this was basically just a way to keep it going.
00:38:28 Problem is though, I think the elites of our society are so happy with the temporary exhibitions
00:38:33 there, they've become so iconic and connected to the art gallery that I don't think they
00:38:37 would actually support the Queen now going on to this thing.
00:38:39 Well I know someone quite well who commissions those monstrosities actually.
00:38:44 Also it makes a mockery of the statue.
00:38:46 Yeah, exactly yeah. It was meant to be for William IV originally but then he never paid
00:38:50 the bill so the statue never ended up going up there. But there must be at least one,
00:38:55 but I would think more than one statue going up in London of Her Majesty so great as to
00:38:59 I would actually one equestrian one for example in Hyde Park or something like that.
00:39:02 It would be nice to have something on the scale of the Victoria Monument outside of
00:39:06 Buckingham Palace something that is that.
00:39:08 Yeah sorry just to finish the point about the fourth plinth like I say I know the person
00:39:13 who's on the committee for those and I don't think you know they're not going to change
00:39:19 and they're not going to let go of that fourth plinth.
00:39:21 Oh they're not.
00:39:22 That's what I mean yeah.
00:39:23 Yes you're quite right it was actually it was meant to be six months each just keep
00:39:27 it going but of course I think possibly these things become entrenched because of course
00:39:31 when they started that, the Queen was already old, they probably didn't think she was going
00:39:35 to live this long. I'm with you on a big statue, bearing in mind there already are statues
00:39:40 around the country, there's one in, I think it's Gravesend, which is a lovely one, it's
00:39:45 remarkable, why Gravesend actually, but it's a great seated one in the Garter Road.
00:39:49 One of those, and you helped erect one in Runnymede.
00:39:51 That's right, in Runnymede, and that's again a useful one, and then there's also one in
00:39:58 Bexley Heath which if you live near Bexley Heath anyone anyone watching there's a clock tower in
00:40:04 the middle of Bexley Heath by the shopping centre there and there was an empty sort of what you'd
00:40:09 call cameo what an alcove in it and it's now got a statue of the Queen but anyway these are small
00:40:16 ones we need something big we're talking Albert Memorial. Well hopefully Charles will have some
00:40:20 kind of input into it with his traditionalism to make sure that it's not one of those awful
00:40:25 modern type statues that it's actually something that is elegant and traditional yes I don't want
00:40:29 I'm not interested in anyone else's interpretation we want majesty we don't want brutalism we want
00:40:35 majesty yeah I think we can put brutalism to bed now that the king is king yes that's on a very
00:40:41 very happy note that you don't know obviously we've got the uh funeral next week um but
00:40:47 But, Emma, thanks so much, Phil.
00:40:50 Thanks, Ray.
00:40:51 And that's it.
00:40:53 And we shall see you next week.
00:40:57 Bye-bye.
00:40:59 Hello, if you're enjoying the New Culture Forum channel
00:41:02 and you believe in our mission,
00:41:04 may I invite you to join our membership scheme
00:41:08 at the link below or on our website,
00:41:11 newcultureforum.org.uk.
00:41:14 Our work is more important now than ever,
00:41:16 and we have great plans ahead for the future,
00:41:19 but we can't do it without your support.
00:41:22 From as little as three pounds per month,
00:41:24 you can help ensure that we continue on our mission.
00:41:28 As a member, you'll receive a range of benefits,
00:41:30 including access to exclusive content,
00:41:34 invitations to our private events,
00:41:36 including here at our studios,
00:41:39 free copies of our books, and much, much more,
00:41:42 including of course our famous NCF mug. If you aren't able to become a member
00:41:48 then please help us by clicking this button and subscribing to our channel.
00:41:54 It's completely free. Just remember to also click the bell icon
00:41:59 so that you can get notifications when we post
00:42:02 new videos. Thank you.