New Culture Forum - September 24, 2022


PayPal v. Free Speech Union + Muslim-Hindu Sectarianism in Britain + Britain's Obesity Crisis

The Queen Is Dead Long Live The King The New Culture Forum Reflects On The Old Reign The New Lord Frost: Defending the Nation State: Truss, Brexit, Cultural Identity, Free Markets & Free Speech

Episode Stats


Length

45 minutes

Words per minute

169.59

Word count

7,771

Sentence count

—


Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
00:00:00 Hello and welcome to this week's News Speak, the New Culture Forum's weekly current affairs
00:00:10 programme with me Emma Webb and this week I am joined by Peter Whittle, the director and founder
00:00:14 of the New Culture Forum. So there's been a lot in the news this week but before we begin Peter
00:00:19 would you like to tell viewers a bit about the event that's coming up? Yeah thanks Emma, we've
00:00:23 We've got an event coming up on the 3rd of October in Birmingham, it's during the Conservative
00:00:30 Party conference, but it's on the fringe of the Conservative Party conference, and we
00:00:36 have speaker in Nick Timothy who's been on the channel, he's a columnist with the Daily
00:00:43 Telegraph, obviously quite famously he was Theresa May's Chief of Staff, and it should
00:00:49 be a good event it's the first of our what we might call local events that we're going to be
00:00:54 doing and so if uh people watching are in the area and they watch ncf and they subscribe to
00:01:01 the channel they want to come along then please do uh just register your interest via um it's
00:01:08 contact at newcultureforum.org.uk um if you because it has to be by rsvp um because we've
00:01:18 got limited space but it's the Monday the 3rd of October and basically if you will put that in the
00:01:26 link under this video but if you get in touch there I'd like to come then we'll make sure we
00:01:31 can make space for you so but thought it'd be worth saying because it's only what is it a week
00:01:36 or so away so shall we begin then by talking about what's been going on in Leicester with this
00:01:45 what looks like basically sectarian warfare on British streets between Hindus and Muslims.
00:01:54 Well it is isn't it, sectarian warfare. It seems to have come about originally from a cricket match
00:02:03 and sort of escalated and there is now a concern being voiced in newspapers that this is actually
00:02:11 going to spread to other cities and in fact indeed in Birmingham it already has
00:02:17 and I think really that what is interesting about this Riyama I don't know what your view is is that
00:02:26 the general emphasis will eventually I feel become about social media and the effects of
00:02:38 social media. In other words, anything to distract from what I see as being the main issue, which is
00:02:46 imported problems. Why, in God's name, why should we be having to deal with sectarian issues from
00:02:57 another part of the world? This is appalling. And the fact is that nobody in mainstream politics,
00:03:05 apart from people like Claudia Webb in the Labour side who's actually chosen to start talking about
00:03:12 the far right or something in this occasion totally ignoring what's going on but this happened
00:03:20 throughout started to happen throughout the time of the Queen's funeral and just before
00:03:26 and it shows a parallel society yeah it's amazing how like you're saying with Claudia Webb how
00:03:32 a factual a lot of the commentary has been and so Douglas Murray and Calvin Robinson both made the
00:03:37 point that basically that if you import the world you import the world's problems and like I agree
00:03:44 with you completely I think the clear direction that this is going to go in is this is going to
00:03:49 be fuel for the fire for the online harms bill this online safety bill which will basically get
00:03:54 online you know the big tech companies and we'll talk more about that later in relation to what's
00:03:59 been going on with PayPal but that these big tech companies will be encouraged to censor
00:04:05 things online particularly misinformation and that's interesting because that's something that
00:04:10 anybody who's interested can look at Hardeep Singh's articles in The Spectator and in Spiked
00:04:16 Hardeep Singh and he's he's pointed out how misinformation fake news has been part of this
00:04:23 for example um the muslim community believing that a muslim girl had been kidnapped by a hindu man
00:04:31 but it's going back to um this issue of sort of sectarianism um charlotte littlewood from
00:04:39 the henry jackson society she gave a really interesting analysis of this situation on gb
00:04:45 news which is totally unlike anything anybody else has been saying and is actually sticking
00:04:50 to the facts as she can see them on the ground because a lot of people have been saying this is
00:04:55 to do with you know in the broadest sense what's going on abroad is being played out on the streets
00:05:01 of of leicester birmingham we've seen this before when anything goes wrong in cashmere there's
00:05:06 always tensions in the community here um and she's pointed out that through her own research
00:05:14 which is ongoing right now she's looking at what people are talking about on social media and in
00:05:18 in the various chats that are going on within the community,
00:05:21 that it seems to be a sort of a territory dispute,
00:05:25 which I think is very interesting,
00:05:27 a territorial dispute in a majority Muslim area
00:05:31 where the Hindus were apparently marching
00:05:37 sort of in protest against the attacks
00:05:39 that they had experienced
00:05:41 through putting up their own religious symbols.
00:05:45 And that is what has led to the conflict
00:05:47 this specific circumstance that has been triggered by this um this cricket match and so it's it's
00:05:54 just it's very interesting that you know to stick to the facts on this that this really this isn't
00:06:01 about what people are saying online although it may be a factor in it this is about what happens
00:06:06 when you have a multicultural society that where serious conflicts and i'm interested to know what
00:06:14 you think about this when these serious conflicts are triggered it reminds me of Northern Ireland
00:06:20 and I see this playing out very much as Northern Ireland has where you have these communities that
00:06:27 in this sort of territorial dispute and Hindus being made to leave the area or feeling pushed
00:06:33 out of the area and then returning and feeling they can't put their symbols up because they may
00:06:36 be attacked and things like that but we shouldn't even have areas you know people should not be
00:06:42 subjected to areas the talk of a territorial district this dispute is extraordinary exactly
00:06:48 and in fact online there have been I've seen a few of the the more radical people behind this or at
00:06:56 least you know talking about it was one Muslim guy and he was talking about you know bring your boys
00:07:02 yeah it's the same as what happened in Batley where they invited people to come from outside
00:07:08 of the area more radical islamists possibly inviting them in to get them to go out on the
00:07:15 streets and some of these scenes there were people walking around in balaclavas wielding weapons and
00:07:20 you see this little thin line of police officers a lot of them female trying to keep these two
00:07:25 communities apart when they're brandishing knives and all they've got is batons but you see that's
00:07:29 all they can do in a way i mean the fact is is that the political class the governments of
00:07:36 whichever stripe are not willing to take this on the fact is you say it's multiculturalism yes it
00:07:44 is it's multiculturalism is one and then the other side is sheer numbers if you import if you allow
00:07:52 into the country the kind of numbers that we have over the past 10 years this is kind of inevitable
00:07:59 well it's a fundamental failure of integration as well if you have areas that are majority
00:08:05 Muslim and then an area next to it that is majority Hindu that can't mix with each other
00:08:11 and I think it's a point that has been sort of made to me privately that you get this
00:08:16 we talk often you see in the news about gang warfare and things but there are cultural
00:08:20 elements in a lot of these conflicts that are playing out on the streets of London all
00:08:24 across the UK because people are bringing with them to the UK political and personal
00:08:32 and family conflicts from back home also the other thing as well is that people who come in
00:08:38 such numbers there is no need to integrate first of all because you've got ready-made communities
00:08:44 there speaking the same language there's absolutely you know even a few years ago there was a kind of
00:08:51 initiative to get people to at least speak english that uh appears to have gone uh even
00:08:59 labour took that on at one point I'm talking like 10 years ago now that seems to have gone but
00:09:05 essentially you've got huge numbers do not need to integrate plus you have got a cultural
00:09:11 establishment that doesn't really think you should integrate I mean you know that for years you know
00:09:20 they've been saying well we are terrible we are awful you know that all the things we've done in
00:09:26 the world of wrong we quite you know don't be like us we're terrible that's been it has no
00:09:32 no sense of in addition to flagellating what exists it also has this lack of a sense of
00:09:39 self so even the British values that are being promoted have been that have been defined are
00:09:46 about as watery and as weak as they could be and it's because they are trying to accommodate
00:09:50 so much within those values that they there's no sense of you know any any
00:09:58 positive understanding of our national identity that people might it's funny
00:10:05 that as well so it's gonna say that people might want to integrate into but
00:10:09 also that this was going on whilst you were seeing these extraordinary scenes
00:10:13 in London in relation to the Queen lying in state and and the sort of pageantry
00:10:18 around the funeral and for many people this was binding you know this feeling of how absolutely
00:10:23 extraordinary this you know the constitutional monarchy is and you know that that is a real
00:10:30 vision of what in a more fundamental sense we are as an identity as a nation in terms of its symbols
00:10:37 and so on but at the same time there's something quite symbolic about the fact that in Leicester
00:10:41 that this warfare was basically playing out I mean the thing is it's one of those things that
00:10:45 people don't really like to say and indeed I don't actually but the fact is
00:10:51 when you look at those groups of most young men fighting and the civil
00:10:56 disruption in these places the Queen doesn't mean anything to them I mean it
00:11:02 she just doesn't and you then have to say well actually how far has this whole
00:11:09 experiment been a success I think it's been on the whole disastrous I don't
00:11:15 mind admitting um and but the fact is is that we can sit here and viewers often say this they say
00:11:23 well you know you sit there and talk and in fact we agree with every word but you know what are we
00:11:27 going to do the way things are at the moment it is actually up to a government to do something
00:11:34 so they could start maybe by even commenting on this tell me if i'm wrong emma but i don't think
00:11:41 i've heard a single government minister say anything about this particular trouble that
00:11:47 we're having at the moment i haven't but it might just be that i've missed it which is possible i
00:11:51 don't think there has been and this is extraordinary and it's almost like we are now accepting that
00:11:58 this is going to be the case and i think as uh douglas actually douglas murray has said in his
00:12:03 piece you know this is not the first time we had it in oldham we have we had it for example when
00:12:10 the MP was murdered if you remember not that long ago and at that particular point again the argument
00:12:18 came about social media and things you know what should we do and at the same time it will you know
00:12:24 you have to realise that this is going to happen more and more and if you say that people say well
00:12:30 oh you're just stoking things up why no no no it's just you've got to face reality. What did you think
00:12:37 of the of the sort of the left-wing commentariat saying things like this is our or not just in this
00:12:48 instance but generally in instances like this saying well this is our fault because of what
00:12:53 we did in India and Pakistan and Kashmir and that we are responsible for carving up these countries
00:13:00 and this is a post-colonial problem that we are to blame for and it's so they're missing it's a
00:13:05 problem so this is interesting well they're actually admitting the one hand on the one hand
00:13:09 this is meant to be wonderful and and hugely uh strengthening this diversity on the other hand
00:13:16 they're seeing that obviously it is something bad that's happening this isn't it may actually it may
00:13:21 be douglas who made this point i can't remember but um the net that actually that's a good point
00:13:26 that narrative implies that in a way this is our punishment for colonialism so these communities
00:13:34 and their conflicts and their presence here they regard as a kind of punishment for just such
00:13:40 rubbish I nearly said a bad word this is such rubbish I mean we have a huge Somalian population
00:13:46 there were Somalian gangs for example in London there have been in the past so far as I know
00:13:53 that was never part of the British Empire it is it is obviously people who read the Guardian and
00:14:02 the left um are obviously going to take that view and it's always going to be our fault somewhere
00:14:07 or other but what i find interesting is that they obviously think that this this is bad what's
00:14:12 happening um it's just that they choose to sort of say that somehow or other um you know it is our
00:14:18 fault yeah it's nothing of the sort i feel where i feel particularly strongly is that these disputes
00:14:28 and cultural differences are being visited on the people of this country and they had no say
00:14:35 whatsoever in what is essentially brought it about they're having to deal with it
00:14:44 they're having to deal with it it's the cultural side of globalization if you like
00:14:49 I am not convinced that you were saying a government has to step in and do something
00:14:54 about this i'm i know this sounds bleak and this sounds sort of peter hitchens level of of black
00:15:00 pills as they say um but i am not convinced that you can do anything about this now and that this
00:15:08 is i and i'm interested to know what you think whether this is going to be like a kind of
00:15:14 northern ireland situation where the territory is disputed in some way god knows how you how you fix
00:15:21 that um but that it's something that could play out for a hundred two hundred years these communities
00:15:28 in conflict like this because i mean it's been over a hundred years of conflict in in northern
00:15:34 ireland and that is still something that flares up now and then so it seems to me that that is
00:15:41 the only route that this can take and in those other than to make efforts to integrate people
00:15:46 from these particular areas i it's the it's the like you were saying you know the density the
00:15:52 idea that you would have territorial disputes because you have majority areas that are a
00:15:58 particular culture that are in conflict with the majority neighbors in in the neighboring area and
00:16:05 that those have religious or cultural conflicts from back home that that has been have basically
00:16:11 been imported that there isn't really very much that you can do about that other than
00:16:16 well you can stop importing it I mean I was there's only so far I think you can go with the
00:16:21 Northern Irish comparison because it was in an in a kind of awful way it's organically kind of part
00:16:28 of our history but I think the fact is that this will only grow whilst you have 300 000 people
00:16:39 legally coming to Britain let alone illegally. The other dimension to it as well is that it
00:16:45 basically makes us vulnerable and beholden to politics that are playing out around the world
00:16:53 so whatever happens in any of these countries and you can see how that could easily be weaponized
00:17:00 by a foreign government if they were not an ally if they are able to basically trigger and fuel
00:17:08 conflicts within the UK. Well I mean it's amazing isn't it and a bit humiliating that I think it was
00:17:14 the Indian government called for us to actually calm it down I mean what what the hell's going on
00:17:19 I would say they are an ally but what I think is actually far more personal is that for example
00:17:27 what about our policy relation to Israel I'm a huge supporter of Israel and you can see that in
00:17:33 the future if something very you know particularly bad blew up in in terms of Israel a government here
00:17:41 would be thinking how is this going to play with almost in population I think probably that's
00:17:46 already a consideration of course it is but I mean at the same time it's supposing it came to the
00:17:51 push came to shove and we had to show some kind of support there would be this kind of
00:17:56 you know calculation going on so I mentioned paypal in the context of big tech because this
00:18:04 is probably going to go down like I say the the route of fielding the online safety bill because
00:18:10 politicians will argue that it's bad words online that have caused this to happen rather than
00:18:15 actually addressing the real complicated on the ground problems and actually as Charlotte
00:18:21 little wood has done looked at the facts they're really not that complicated this is the point i
00:18:27 mean i'm not being pedantic more complicated than just simply saying everything is to do with what's
00:18:32 going on online oh yeah that's just pure distraction that does pure kind of displacement activity
00:18:39 but so moving moving on to the subject of big tech this week paypal have closed down firstly
00:18:46 closed down Toby Young's personal account swiftly followed by the account of the Daily Skeptic which
00:18:52 Toby runs and also the Free Speech Union also run by Toby and that was followed by Us For Them which
00:19:00 is a parent group that campaigned against schools being closed during the pandemic. Is that in
00:19:06 America? Here in the UK and a whole host of other organizations like the Law or Fiction lawyers who
00:19:14 were campaigning against vaccine mandates gays against groomers which is a gay online campaign
00:19:21 against paedophilia so a whole host of groups have had paypal have basically removed their accounts
00:19:30 and this obviously will play into the everything around the online safety bill but what's really
00:19:36 worrying about this is it basically financial cancellation is the new is the new weapon
00:19:43 against dissenters this ability for big tech especially if we're going to go into you know
00:19:48 we're hurtling towards this cashless society that we will now be so beholden to these tech
00:19:55 giants that they'll have such an enormous amount of power to wield against anybody who dissents
00:20:01 from the orthodoxies that they as the tech giants in silicon valley permit yes i mean do you use
00:20:08 paypal for anything do you use it yourself i have a paypal account but i haven't got a clue
00:20:12 how to use it well we do i mean people are viewers you know people who support the ncf
00:20:18 i'd be very happy for paypal to get rid of my account for me that would be grand
00:20:22 Right they make donations through PayPal and in fact some people online advise that if you have
00:20:30 a balance in PayPal just to immediately kind of transfer it into another account because
00:20:36 essentially you lose it when this happens. Or they can they hold on to it so in other
00:20:45 occasions where this has happened basically they are able to seize that money as damages
00:20:51 through you having used their platform in violation of their policies.
00:20:57 So they basically steal that money from you.
00:21:00 But it's only happening one way, isn't it?
00:21:03 It's happening one way.
00:21:04 It's happening to these kind of groups who they probably perceive to be conservative in some way
00:21:10 or the wrong side of the argument.
00:21:12 In the US, I think it, and I'm happy to be corrected if I'm wrong on this,
00:21:16 but I think that PayPal have closed down accounts of left-wing groups in America
00:21:21 who have criticised Biden's policy on Ukraine so it's people on both sides of the political
00:21:27 spectrum but who are dissenting from some kind of orthodoxy we when we had the Smith lecture here
00:21:34 Nigel Farage gave the first one this is in 2018 and it was all about shadow banning and it was
00:21:42 all about the effects of censorship in social media as it was then as you say this is quite
00:21:50 new this is financial this is a way of basically cutting off people's life
00:21:57 supply their lifeline well it stopped with with the daily skeptic I think it
00:22:02 was a quarter of their revenue it halted and a third of people who pay to the FSU
00:22:08 through PayPal and so a third of the members could make those payments because
00:22:13 they were using PayPal as a result so even though the daily skeptic and the
00:22:18 free speech union will survive and they'll be fine even though they've taken a hit it's besides the
00:22:23 point because it suggests that basically what we're doing and in return for having the convenience of
00:22:29 a cashless society i just before coming here i thought how ironic it was we're about to talk
00:22:33 about this and i actually paid for a coffee um where there was a big sign up that said we have
00:22:40 gone cashless um and so for the sake of convenience we've all made this sort of deal with the devil
00:22:45 um but we're just handing over all of this power to these big tech companies and once everything
00:22:52 goes online and there's been talk this week also about in in america and in india and the eu as
00:22:59 well asking amazon to basically create digital currency so in all of these countries there's
00:23:03 this move towards um digitalizing everything financial everything going online everything
00:23:09 going cashless um having trial runs in the use of biometric data so your smile or your fingerprint
00:23:17 can be used to pay and things like that but i don't know whether people realize the degree to
00:23:23 which they are just blindly handing away their liberties because if you have physical cash
00:23:29 that you know that that's something that you that is a kind of safeguard on your freedom to make
00:23:38 transactions that you can't really be fully censored with the threat of financial ruin whereas
00:23:45 if everything is going through paypal or through these big tech giants and that that that is
00:23:51 basically you're dependent on that for your ability to to transact then they have the final say really
00:23:58 over what you are and are not allowed to say or think or express but interestingly you say people
00:24:05 have willingly you know given this up they willingly gave up their privacy for example
00:24:12 if you go right back to the early days you know it was Facebook and saying right up to now it's
00:24:16 extraordinary people will do anything for convenience anything for convenience but also I
00:24:20 think younger people older people obviously including myself you know I think it's appalling
00:24:26 the idea you won't have cash but I think younger people see it as they have brought into the
00:24:35 illusion of freedom they think this is that they're all these choices lined up about how you
00:24:41 can pay a lot is about freedom as you say and convenience and i think they're very mistaken i
00:24:49 mean i think the point with the paypal situation is what indeed can a government do about it i mean
00:24:56 we're talking about the online uh safety bill which i think was originally called the online
00:25:01 harm bill by the way um but there are certain ways that they could actually do that i mean
00:25:07 for example i think the point was made by fraser nelson in the telegraph today i think it's a very
00:25:13 good point uh he said look look you know the government can't completely regulate for example
00:25:18 the housing or the renting market but it can certainly say it is illegal to discriminate
00:25:25 uh against people on the basis of uh race religion or or creed you know um and that's the law of the
00:25:33 country quite rightly um so why can't we do it in these the bill they should be passing is but is to
00:25:38 prevent these companies from discriminating against people but i do i do think that there is a problem
00:25:44 with this idea of um this was in Fraser Nelson's article this idea that we need to protect diversity
00:25:53 of opinion or protect diversity of thought now i agree with that in terms of the ends of protecting
00:25:58 those things but i feel like it but like by by by phrasing it and framing it as another diversity
00:26:07 i think that that that in a way is its own fausty impact because this is not about having more
00:26:14 diversity of thought or more diversity of opinion this should be separate from that people have a
00:26:19 right to those things it's not one thing among other categories that people should be um not
00:26:26 discriminated against for if this makes sense absolutely and so i think it worries me that
00:26:31 we're now in this situation we saw this actually with the my force data case um that she was found
00:26:37 in a court that she her right her gender critical rights were um protected under the equality act
00:26:44 that they were protected philosophical beliefs but that's also a problem for me because that
00:26:49 implies that those beliefs that are based on facts are themselves protected philosophical
00:26:55 beliefs and so in order to defend ourselves we're now in this position where we're having to use the
00:27:01 language that is already rigged against us and i think i find that very worrying no i i think
00:27:08 superbly put emma there i think i totally agree with it also it's sort of too fundamental just
00:27:15 to be something along with these other things very fundamental something we never even thought
00:27:21 perhaps you could and this is a bit of a council of despair maybe but you have to sort of almost
00:27:25 say well actually that is the situation that we're having to deal with so that we've got to take
00:27:30 that we've got to use that we've got to use their language if you like for that but i totally
00:27:35 understand but the fact is this thing that's going through the online safety bill where this could
00:27:42 actually at least be changed or either get rid of that bill or at least hugely modify it I believe
00:27:49 that Liz Truss the Prime Minister has said nothing about this she has said nothing about any of this
00:27:55 I think Kemi and was it was she perhaps Penny Morton as well they made some statements about
00:28:02 it but Liz Truss puts herself forward as being a sort of free speech warrior but if she really
00:28:09 wants to do something that matters nipping this online safety bill in the bud particularly because
00:28:15 going back to what we were saying about the whole issue of misinformation and fake news if we
00:28:20 remember during the pandemic talk radio for example had their live stream taken down for a period of
00:28:26 time people forget this and that was because the policies of these tech companies in many cases
00:28:32 their definition of misinformation which by the way there is an arbiter for what counts as fact
00:28:39 and what counts as fake news in all of these circumstances.
00:28:43 And in those cases, YouTube, for example,
00:28:46 they were relying on local and national public health positions, basically.
00:28:54 Things that turned out to be a U-turn further down the line,
00:28:59 and actually those things that were misinformation
00:29:00 were no longer misinformation because they had become accepted.
00:29:04 And so you're manipulating the public debate
00:29:08 if you allow these companies to have the power to be the arbiter of what we can discuss publicly
00:29:16 and to and also even in terms of shadow banning to decide you know how what things should be
00:29:22 prioritized or which things should be demoted and it's the same as for the discussions that
00:29:28 are going on at the moment to do with the ESG ESG scores the environment I think it's environmental
00:29:33 social governance um that that again is a manipulate libertarians free marketeers people
00:29:41 like liz trust should be talking about this because that is a manipulation of the free market
00:29:46 it's it's an intentional manipulation by these huge corporates to manipulate people's behavior
00:29:53 and to manipulate and in in they believe they're manipulating people's behavior in
00:29:57 in aid of what is good and to manipulate the public debate yeah and I think I mean
00:30:04 you could say whether they intend to or not but it seems that the purpose is
00:30:09 almost transparently to try and change the things that people can express and
00:30:14 the things that they can't well on this point again in this bill online safety
00:30:19 bill there is this utterly insidious new definition of something which is
00:30:25 harmful but not illegal yeah now what is that harmful but not legal that I would
00:30:34 say could cover 50% of human discourse mm-hmm and who decides what's harmful as
00:30:39 well exactly imagine the police getting hold of that well it's not too
00:30:44 different from a non-crime hate incident well again it's the same as a non-crime
00:30:48 hate incident the same thing so let's I was about to say let's move on to
00:30:53 something lighter but trying not to be gloomy um we're trying desperately not to be gloomy yeah let's
00:30:58 move on to something lighter let's talk about obesity um boom boom a heavy subject
00:31:06 so the telegraph this week had a a comment piece in it and it was entitled only systemic change
00:31:14 can save britain from an obesity epidemic um and this was something you you've said to me
00:31:20 each so I'm just going to go and summarise for the sake of those watching or listening
00:31:25 what these sort of the basic stats were that this article was basing itself on so
00:31:31 firstly a number of studies that have come out in the last couple of weeks
00:31:35 80% of the UK population will be overweight by 2060. 80%? 80% unless I've taken that number
00:31:44 down wrong I think it's right no no it does seem rather large pardon the cost in the economy 142
00:31:51 billion and that Britain is in the grip of an early onset cancer epidemic with rates of colon
00:31:59 kidney and liver cancer going up and that in 20 to 40 year olds and that this is likely to be due to
00:32:06 the consumption of junk food and that women with type 2 diabetes die on average five years earlier
00:32:11 than those without it and men four and a half years earlier um and the argument in this article
00:32:19 which there's a lot to unpack here the argument in this article is basically that it's not about
00:32:25 individual choice and that the government like liz trust for example she's very much against the
00:32:29 nanny state i think that's fantastic i completely agree with her on that she wants to get rid of i
00:32:33 think the sugar tax and things like that um the arg the argument in this article was against that
00:32:40 for you and then instead it's not about what individuals do it's about systemic
00:32:44 change in the food in food production and in there she puts it the food system
00:32:49 so that the food that we have now in compared comparison with the food that
00:32:53 we had in the 1950s is just so much worse in terms of how much fat and sugar
00:32:57 and all sorts that it's gone in at the it's not there's not really anything the
00:33:00 individual could do that it's something the government have to force food
00:33:03 industries to to make systemic change but what I thought was so interesting in
00:33:10 here is the two things firstly this reminds me of the whole Covid narrative
00:33:15 that we're now addicted to talking about how many years earlier people die and
00:33:20 the numbers and statistics and so on which is a very I think a very inhumane
00:33:27 way of looking at health because people make certain choices and maybe those
00:33:33 choices have impacts on and on the length of their life or the quality of
00:33:37 their life but maybe for them personally when they weigh those things up they'd
00:33:41 rather have a cigarette or they'd rather have a burger and live a slightly
00:33:44 shorter life perhaps but also this idea that now that we're we really are sort
00:33:51 of um putting at loggerheads individuals and the system everything now is about individuals versus
00:34:00 systemic change you know say with the race narrative around racism that it's not or even
00:34:05 climate change it's not something the individual can do it has to be something that changes within
00:34:10 the system but this is this kind of amorphous utopian thing yes i mean i i would actually
00:34:16 take more I take the approach you talk when we were talking about the problems in Leicester when
00:34:21 you were saying I don't quite see how what we can change about this it's not anything the government
00:34:25 can do it's not this I would take that approach to to this problem there is a problem obviously
00:34:33 you can just tell I mean you know if you've lived long enough fat people kids or whatever
00:34:41 in the 1970s when I was a teenager were kind of quite rare and they would be basically mocked now
00:34:47 you know that is that I had it myself because I was a chub ball right hard to imagine and you know
00:34:54 and I certainly had that on the wrong end of that but but at the same time it was kind of rare but
00:35:02 and you say well it's not fair to more people fine I do think people have changed I mean
00:35:09 And there's something, one of the articles you might actually be quoting from there,
00:35:13 I remember that the author of the article, I think it was in the Telegraph,
00:35:18 was sort of blindly said, is this because people have changed?
00:35:21 Of course not.
00:35:22 People have suddenly lost willpower in the last 50 years.
00:35:25 It's not even just willpower.
00:35:26 I think it's what it is, is that there's a kind of indulgence.
00:35:32 You know, I can tell a lot of people will probably disagree with this.
00:35:35 it seems to affect certain sections of population more than others I think
00:35:41 Ferdinand Mount wrote a brilliant book called mind the gap a few years ago and
00:35:45 it wasn't specifically about obesity but it was the same along the same lines
00:35:50 we're getting to have two classes of people now a bit like in the time
00:35:55 machine at HG Wells and you've got the kind of professional classes who are you
00:36:01 you know, fit and slim to the nth degree, which on the whole they are, and what you would
00:36:08 have called working-ass people who are more overweight, it's more of a social thing, and
00:36:14 this is kind of going to grow and grow, and there's a moral dimension, these people are
00:36:18 morally correct and puritanical, and these people are not, and obviously one hates that
00:36:23 kind of comparison to be made, but I do think, you know, but it also feeds this nanny state
00:36:28 elitism as well because i think they think that there's this attitude of we're superior to these
00:36:33 people and we need to control what they eat because they don't have the ability to do that
00:36:38 for themselves because i agree i think that i mean i have sort of listening to all this stuff about
00:36:45 seed oils and things and started looking at the backs of packets and the amount of total crap that
00:36:53 is in most unnecessary ingredients and obviously there's this whole movement towards trying to eat
00:37:00 cleanly and that can be very difficult because it's actually hard to find things like bread for
00:37:04 example that doesn't have loads of junk in it but at the same time I think it's it's more than just
00:37:09 about the you know food system it's also that since the 1950s you've got more women in the
00:37:16 workforce and so people not preparing their own food at home not having somebody whose job is
00:37:24 basically to take care of that aspect of a family's life you have more people who are atomized and so
00:37:30 it's harder to eat healthy when you're living on your own because it's easier to to shop and to
00:37:35 cook for for more people and to do that affordably and in a way that is healthy and you also have
00:37:41 people who have far more pressures on their working life and in their careers than they did
00:37:45 in the 1950s and that that's something that has increased and so now things like Deliveroo have
00:37:51 grown up and there's a market for people just being able to push your button and get food
00:37:55 delivered to their door and that food is obviously not as healthy as food that they would cook at
00:37:59 home so there are all of these other aspects and but I just it's this this distraction I think from
00:38:06 from willpower like you can still make an effort to eat healthily and well when Lee Anderson
00:38:12 did that speech in parliament and was absolutely slated for it the conservative mp who's from a
00:38:18 working class background stood up and said that he thought that it was good that people that there
00:38:22 was a group in his constituency that were doing this basically charitable work helping people who
00:38:27 use food banks learning to learn to cook healthy meals on a budget because it's genuinely very
00:38:34 difficult to do that it's a skill to be able to do that he got completely slated for it yes but
00:38:39 funny thing is it's interesting he was stated by the left mostly right because he was a tory and
00:38:44 you know and they were calling him a toff even though he's yes they're never going to uh never
00:38:49 going to win but um there are elements of that what he says is right i think it is a cultural
00:38:54 change which is going to be very hard to reverse first of all we do know right that for example
00:39:00 grazing by eating at various different times throughout the day is terrible in terms of
00:39:05 putting on weight i.e it makes you put weight on right so people do that people walk along you know
00:39:12 eating in the street although it's become part of life it's everything partly i think because
00:39:17 people are so busy they need to feel like they need to fit it in where they can no i don't think it's just
00:39:20 business no people just want to eat it then and there um i think people have culture with no
00:39:27 delayed gratification no they have but they have more leisure time i am than in fact ever they had
00:39:33 and in fact you know people were very slim when they actually were working very hard
00:39:38 take my mum she worked in a shop and where we were going to school too but she still
00:39:44 you know cooked and at night and things like that but could that be because it's more people are
00:39:48 doing more sedentary jobs more desk jobs more sedentary but also people don't eat together
00:39:55 right now this has been proven as well that you come together at say like six or five whatever it
00:39:59 was your dinner or tea as we used to call it right and you have basically that that's structures
00:40:05 everything is structureless now so just in the same way that people you know for example have
00:40:12 television so the kids watch something in the bedroom the parents watching something downstairs
00:40:17 all of that it's the same with food um children are indulged hugely right so it used to be that's
00:40:24 what we're having tonight Satan kidney pulling peas and potatoes eat it or you won't you know
00:40:29 blah blah blah now it's oh no but young Tarquin can't eat this and young Delilah can't eat that
00:40:34 and they didn't like that blah blah blah so it's all much more kind of much more indulgent in that
00:40:40 way but so those are the sorts of things that start to make weight gain and and also people
00:40:46 drive everywhere we used to walk to school they drive everywhere now the kids just popped off at
00:40:51 school everything but I think that what's interesting about this is that food and the
00:40:57 consumption of food even though we're you know we're getting more and more obese it has never
00:41:02 been more central to our whole culture it is the way in which now food is our main creative
00:41:10 activity I would say if you want to call it creative you know cities are judged on how much
00:41:17 different cuisine they have, Sid is a judge, their dynamism is judged on how many cafes and
00:41:23 restaurants there are, not on who's painting what or who's making what music, it's actually how many
00:41:28 people are going to eat out. If you look at the pandemic the whole thing was what would it help
00:41:33 out, eat out to help out, shocking phrase and then on top of that you sort of you know you have
00:41:41 even we were talking about multiculturalism, even food is now used as a massive kind of like
00:41:47 reason to celebrate multiculturalism, look at all the different restaurants we have, you know,
00:41:53 if you take that out of the equation then you say well come and tell us about multiculturalism
00:41:58 but please don't mention food, then you find there's a bit of a silence in the room. So food
00:42:04 has become sort of central at the very time where basically people are becoming... But don't you think
00:42:09 though that what you're describing there that this whole argument that we have to change the food
00:42:14 system is really to use a horrible phrase disempowering because actually what you're
00:42:20 describing there is a cultural problem and a cultural problem is in the hands of the people
00:42:24 we can make routine changes to our habits and the way that we live our lives and that's the way that
00:42:30 you rescue a culture by doing the culture and if we behave differently then yes we might be up
00:42:37 against it in terms of the fact that a lot of our food has got all sorts of rubbish in it
00:42:43 um but it's just simply by making those changes that would solve a lot of the problem because
00:42:50 there are yes we do have a lot of people in this country who are obese but there are also some
00:42:55 people like a self-beater who are not and it means that it is possible to be you know healthy
00:43:02 and not obese eating the food from this system and so if everybody learned to to live by better
00:43:10 habits and for that to become a culturally enforced thing rather than Deliveroo being
00:43:15 the culturally enforced thing then I couldn't agree more look at what you know if you live in
00:43:19 flat I live on first of all the other thing eight million people live on their own now I think it
00:43:23 is something like that that's a sure way as well of eating irregularly and badly and and I fully
00:43:29 see that but like in my flats you know where I was living before in London you'd get Deliveroo
00:43:36 coming in the morning you know with with you know various breakfasts what's the matter with you makes
00:43:42 you know get up and make a breakfast and one of the worst things i ever did was getting the delivery
00:43:46 app on my phone oh really right but i mean honestly it is uh i think it is something that
00:43:53 people can actually do themselves as you say it is the cultural aspect kids are going to school now
00:44:02 not being able to use knife and fork for example people really do not know what certain vegetables
00:44:08 are much less cook them right and this is not a class thing you know the culture is not being
00:44:17 transmitted in all sorts of ways which we endlessly discuss on this program but this is one of them
00:44:21 this is pretty fundamental well this has really been a council of despair thank you so much for
00:44:26 tuning in please despite the despair do tune in next time like subscribe tell us what you think
00:44:32 of the topics and the show in general and we will see you next time on newspeak hello if you're
00:44:38 enjoying the new culture forum channel and you believe in our mission may i invite you to join
00:44:44 our membership scheme at the link below or on our website newcultureforum.org.uk
00:44:52 Our work is more important now than ever and we have great plans ahead for the future,
00:44:57 but we can't do it without your support. From as little as £3 per month you can help ensure
00:45:03 that we continue on our mission. As a member you'll receive a range of benefits including
00:45:09 access to exclusive content, invitations to our private events including here at our studios,
00:45:17 free copies of our books and much much more, including, of course, our famous NCF
00:45:23 mug. If you aren't able to become a member then please help us by clicking
00:45:29 this button and subscribing to our channel. It's completely free. Just
00:45:34 remember to also click the bell icon so that you can get notifications when we
00:45:40 post new videos. Thank you.
00:45:47 You