New Culture Forum - September 25, 2022


Lord Frost: Defending the Nation State: Truss, Brexit, Cultural Identity, Free Markets & Free Speech

PayPal v. Free Speech Union + Muslim-Hindu Sectarianism in Britain + Britain's Obesity Crisis Modern Wisdom: From Love Island Model to Acclaimed Podcaster - A Journey of Curiosity

Episode Stats


Length

48 minutes

Words per minute

154.72

Word count

7,470

Sentence count

185


Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
00:00:00 Hello and welcome to So What You're Saying Is, I'm Peter Whittle. Now I'm delighted on
00:00:24 part of the New Culture Forum today to welcome to the show David Frost, Lord Frost of Allentown.
00:00:33 You will know him as Britain's chief Brexit negotiator. Before that he had a top flight
00:00:40 diplomatic and political career including being ambassador to Denmark. He's also senior fellow
00:00:47 at Policy Exchange for which he has recently written a report on what the government might
00:00:53 do in the coming years um which is called holy issues um thank you very much for joining us
00:01:01 thank you delighted to be here thank you um before we go further into anything particularly
00:01:08 political uh i wanted to ask you what your general reflections uh are at the moment on
00:01:16 on the past week we're we're actually recording this on on the wednesday and so the state funeral
00:01:22 of the Queen was on Monday. What has it told you about Britain the past 12 days?
00:01:28 Yeah it's been an amazing 10 days obviously. It's shown I think that lots of people still feel
00:01:37 you know a very deep emotional loyalty and commitment to the monarchy, to the country,
00:01:45 to the things that made this country what it is today which I happen to think is a good thing.
00:01:52 And I think it's been a pushback against the conventional view that the country is declining,
00:02:02 that its history doesn't mean anything, that all these things don't count and we've seen
00:02:08 concrete evidence that a lot of people in the country don't think that way and it's
00:02:13 very good.
00:02:14 Were you surprised?
00:02:15 I wasn't really.
00:02:19 I think a lot of people do think like this and when you get out of SW1 you find that
00:02:24 very quickly. So no, I'm not at all surprised. I think it's very good that organisations
00:02:31 and people who you might have thought would be a bit sceptic actually got with the programme
00:02:37 quite quickly on this and understood the depth of feeling and actually began to reflect and
00:02:43 think about it a bit and I think that's a good sign.
00:02:46 I think, I mean, obviously, we on the NCF are very much concerned with cultural issues.
00:02:52 And from my point of view, it would seem that this was a strengthening exercise, actually.
00:02:57 I liked seeing our history almost played out.
00:03:01 I believe you were at one of the ceremonies, which was the Accession Council.
00:03:04 Yeah, that's right.
00:03:05 Can you tell us a little bit about that?
00:03:07 So the one I was at was the parliamentary reception of the King and Queen, the formal
00:03:15 presentation of addresses. And I wrote a little bit about the Telegraph column last week. And
00:03:23 it's a remarkable occasion. You know, the weight of history is extremely strong and the sense of
00:03:30 continuity you know this is a very old country uh not many countries have got a historical continuity
00:03:38 like we have as a nation state you know arguably france is maybe the only one and um we we need to
00:03:47 sort of respect this and show it and demonstrate it so i think it's been very powerful from that
00:03:52 point of view when you're in that article in the telegraph um i should add of course that you are
00:03:56 columnist for the Telegraph now as well. In that article you talked about the extraordinarily
00:04:04 successful duality of the monarchy and parliament in our constitution over a period of 300 years?
00:04:14 Yeah, I think our history is unusual from that point of view. Parliament, yes, was a check
00:04:22 at various times but more often it's been a partner of the monarchy it's survived from the
00:04:28 middle ages because it was an effective partner of the monarchy in governing the the country and
00:04:34 over the last 300 years it's gradually taken more and more of the powers that rested with
00:04:39 the kings for itself and that that process of evolution is is quite unusual to to britain yes
00:04:47 Well, politics is definitely sort of like elbowing its way in again now.
00:04:52 We're going to have the party conferences quite soon.
00:04:55 And obviously we now have a new Prime Minister and new government.
00:05:00 I wanted to turn to the extended essay, really, rather than report that you did for Policy Exchange.
00:05:08 And which in some ways, I think you do in fact point out at the beginning,
00:05:13 is not unlike a similar sort of set of recommendations
00:05:17 that were developed for Margaret Thatcher
00:05:19 when she was in opposition in the 1970s.
00:05:22 Do you think we are in a comparable position now?
00:05:28 I think we are in some ways.
00:05:31 I think there's the sense that I remember a bit from the 70s,
00:05:35 although I was obviously fairly young,
00:05:38 of the end of an era,
00:05:40 that a way of doing things had reached its conclusion
00:05:45 and now we need to go off in a different direction.
00:05:50 And the 70s and Mrs Thatcher marked the end of the post-war consensus
00:05:56 way of doing things from Atlee and Macmillan and so on.
00:06:00 And I think what we're seeing now is the end of the conventional wisdom
00:06:04 of Blairism, Brownism, Cameronism, Cameronism of the right way to manage the economy.
00:06:14 It was bound up with a single market, with EU membership.
00:06:17 It evolved a very particular view of how to run an economy.
00:06:22 And we haven't particularly prospered in this over the last 10, 15 years.
00:06:27 And I think Liz Truss got the point that we need to go off in a different direction.
00:06:33 I think one of the points that John Hoskins who wrote that report he referred to made
00:06:38 very strongly and he makes it several times in the report is there is no point in doing
00:06:45 things purely because they're politically possible if they don't solve the actual problems
00:06:51 that you're dealing with.
00:06:53 And I think that's something we really need to take forward over the next year or two.
00:06:59 We must do things that are capable of solving our problems, even if they look politically
00:07:04 difficult.
00:07:05 Otherwise we're wasting our time.
00:07:06 Don't you think, therefore, that we've become kind of addicted to short-termism, would you
00:07:11 say?
00:07:12 I think, you know, politics often is short-term.
00:07:18 I think we probably have got more addicted, I would say, to politics as kind of media
00:07:26 manipulation.
00:07:27 How do things look in the media the next day, the next week, whatever?
00:07:33 And I think there's been a reluctance to make arguments from principle.
00:07:40 And again, one of the things I say in this report is that we haven't talked about the principles of free market economics,
00:07:49 how a capitalist society works, what the role of profit, free choice,
00:07:55 all these things are making the economy tick
00:07:58 we've simply not really talked about that very much
00:08:00 we've been a bit embarrassed about it
00:08:02 and I think it's a very good sign incidentally
00:08:04 that Liz Trust is not embarrassed by talking about some of these things
00:08:09 You supported her didn't you?
00:08:10 I did yes in the campaign
00:08:12 and we've got to get back to talking about these fundamentals
00:08:17 so people can understand
00:08:19 and actually I think people are crying out for this
00:08:23 you know people want authenticity they want debate about actual issues and things that are
00:08:29 capable of changing things and in in different ways i think the brexit referendum and everything
00:08:35 that followed with that caught that but also jeremy corbyn caught that you know he tapped into
00:08:40 people's wish for things to be done differently in a malign way but he kept tapped into it and
00:08:46 we we on the right must do the same yes i suppose you could say in some sort of kind of hideous way
00:08:52 he was a conviction politician um yes i mean many of the worst politicians have been conviction
00:08:59 politicians as well it has to be said so one one needs to keep these things within limits but
00:09:03 you've got to stand for something other than just keeping the show on the road
00:09:08 and that that's how it's felt i think in the last few years you start actually the essay with a
00:09:14 quote from orwell um who's really must be the most quoted of our writers over the past five years
00:09:20 but we have sunk to a depth at which restatement of the obvious
00:09:27 is the first duty of intelligent men
00:09:29 what if you like do we need to restate them economically to begin with
00:09:36 economically we need to restate that
00:09:39 the most prosperous countries are the countries that are
00:09:46 have depend depend on free markets free market capitalism
00:09:49 have freedom in the way they look at the world.
00:09:54 And low taxes, letting people run their own lives,
00:09:58 all these conservative nostrums produce prosperity.
00:10:01 And I think there is a version of,
00:10:04 one of the things that slightly worries me at the moment
00:10:05 is there's a version of politics on the right,
00:10:08 the sort of red Tory or blue Labour,
00:10:11 depending on where you're coming from,
00:10:13 that seems to say we can get away from that.
00:10:16 It's not as important as it once was.
00:10:20 And I strongly disagree with that.
00:10:23 If we don't anchor ourselves in an economics that produces prosperity and growth,
00:10:31 we're going to have a problem.
00:10:32 We're just storing it up.
00:10:34 So those are some of the obvious truths.
00:10:37 Look around the world.
00:10:38 It's obvious.
00:10:39 The most successful countries are the ones that are free market, have freedom in their DNA, and allow people to experiment, prosper, and run their own lives.
00:10:51 Along those lines, economically, but also for that matter culturally, one of the biggest complaints we have, not least from our viewers, but I mean this is heard all over,
00:11:01 is that here you had a nominally conservative government with a huge majority, which appeared to do very little that was conservative.
00:11:09 Do you think it's fair?
00:11:11 I think it's fair up to a point.
00:11:16 I think I would say there's been more of a sense of drift
00:11:21 and inability to kind of reconcile different objectives.
00:11:27 I think the situation we've got into is one where productivity hasn't grown for 10, 15 years.
00:11:35 there was an effect on the economy as a result of leaving the single market and customs union
00:11:41 obviously there will be therefore the most important thing is reform growth getting taxes
00:11:49 down and that should have been the priority and i think what we saw was a kind of drift into
00:11:54 um leveling up social measures kind of um trivial almost virtual signaling measures like you know
00:12:04 food bans and this this and that and there wasn't a story there wasn't an agenda that people could
00:12:10 get behind and i think there now needs to be there needs to be a plan there needs to be a
00:12:16 clear vision of what we are trying to do as a party interesting because actually when
00:12:23 boris nonson was elected um there did appear to be at least at the beginning a kind of very
00:12:28 strong sense of what people could get behind. You obviously famously resigned from the government
00:12:38 because one of the reasons being was that the benefits of Brexit were not being realised
00:12:42 adequately. How much was this drift down to personalities?
00:12:47 i think i mean to be to be honest i think um i mean a lot of the things to be fair i think a
00:13:00 lot of the things that are problematic were in the um 2019 manifesto which was composed in a
00:13:08 very different moment economically and politically to the one we're in now um you know we didn't put
00:13:15 lot of emphasis on deregulation net zero is one of the five pledges so or not is not increasing taxes
00:13:25 so i don't think it's so much about people i think it's just it's that the the manifesto and
00:13:33 the thinking reflected a world that was disappearing it was the world of eu membership and all the
00:13:39 debates that went with that and we're now in the new world and it took time to to realize that and
00:13:48 i i don't think the previous government collectively ever did um i hope this one will so so for example
00:13:56 the idea which you do uh touch on in in this uh report of the nation state becoming stronger again
00:14:03 do you think it's we have strengthened at all do you think that idea has strengthened at all
00:14:10 in the past three years yeah i think it has um and we are in various ways um i think we're taking
00:14:20 more decisions for ourselves again which is good um we're seeing politics come back into things
00:14:26 that have not been particularly political trade policy for example you know entirely non-political
00:14:31 subject 50 years, all of a sudden has come back to life with the debates about food standards
00:14:38 and who we want to be open to and all this sort of thing. So I think we're seeing some
00:14:42 normal politics coming back. I don't think, I mean, I think the debates around devolution
00:14:51 and independence and the very specific problem with Northern Ireland are still as live as
00:14:56 ever. I think one of the problems we've got is that the nation-states become
00:15:02 unfashionable. We don't really have the language to talk about it anymore in the
00:15:09 same way. I think many people just see it as something from the past and to be
00:15:15 modern you've got to be a bit doubtful about borders and believe in
00:15:20 high levels of migration and be a bit sort of sceptical about national loyalty and and so on
00:15:28 and we don't have the language for it i think it's very interesting watching what's going on in the
00:15:32 us and this sort of national conservatism movement which which in my view has some
00:15:36 strengths but also some some problems but it's interesting they have taken the word
00:15:42 nationalism and national. And I fear that's an irredeemably tainted word in Europe. We
00:15:51 need a language that is about the nation state, nation statism, patriotism, loyalty, because
00:16:00 the nation state is the best, the most successful way we've found so far of allowing people
00:16:06 to do politics and have different views within a common arena. No one's come up with anything
00:16:11 better yet and we need to hang on to it yes the the national conservatism movement you talk about
00:16:18 in america is that would that be the same as the what they call the new can the new right uh you
00:16:24 know i think they've recently had a conference down in florida yeah that's right um um natcon
00:16:30 three i think there are some you know there are different strands in that that movement i think
00:16:36 obviously and it's an attempt as I see it a bit to make sort of post-Trumpism kind of respectable
00:16:44 and I think they they have taps into a lot of things that are important you know the need for
00:16:50 sort of self-respect and self-esteem in a in a nation-state the need to have productive capacity
00:16:57 the need to kind of care about your history and culture and not see it kind of attenuate away to
00:17:04 be serious about borders. I think all that's really important. I think at the fringes it
00:17:12 does seem to creep into nationalism that makes me feel a bit more uncomfortable at the edges,
00:17:21 and of course there is a particular relationship with religion and Christianity that is different
00:17:28 in the US to the way things are here and that gives a different tone. But I think it's interesting
00:17:34 that they're responding to some of the same needs and developments, I think, in an American
00:17:41 way.
00:17:42 Yes.
00:17:43 In the Holy Issues, you also do mention various cultural aspects to what we have to do.
00:17:51 And really, from the outside looking, it is so rare that that happens in conservative
00:17:56 circles it seems to me that in fact you know in my experience at least what I see as a
00:18:03 full out you know attack on western civilisation too many people in the Conservative Party seem
00:18:09 to see it as being sort of PC gone mad you know they don't quite get it. Do you think
00:18:15 that that's a fair judgment? I think a lot of people see it as marginal you know it's
00:18:24 It's not that they don't share the opinion that history is important, culture is important,
00:18:32 and that we should kind of stand up and protect and care about these things.
00:18:36 I think they just see the phenomena as a bit marginal or a bit sort of peripheral to kind
00:18:45 of normal politics.
00:18:47 And I think that is beginning to change because some of the phenomena are beginning to merge
00:18:53 with each other.
00:18:54 the assault on our history, the assault on biology is getting conflated with the free
00:19:01 speech issue that itself became an issue during the pandemic, I think. So I think we are seeing
00:19:08 some of these problems drift into mainstream politics. I do hope that this new government
00:19:17 is going to tackle them a bit more seriously. I do myself think that the way to solve a
00:19:23 lot of them is be serious about free speech you know i'm not interested in closing down debate
00:19:29 in either direction i think our arguments are good arguments and win the day uh when they're
00:19:34 given a fair hearing and you need the government's role should be to protect the space for that
00:19:40 debate and allow people to to have it properly how would they do that best you think they did
00:19:45 how would they how would they do that because i think there's almost nobody who would disagree
00:19:50 well actually having said that when we look at younger people uh it is alarming how actually
00:19:56 they don't seem to care that much even about the concept um or many of them anyway but uh given
00:20:01 that most of us do uh how would a government best do that well i think um the constraint there already
00:20:11 are too many constraints on free speech in my view there's obviously a sort of chilling effect
00:20:16 from some of them at the margin that is that is discouraging debate i think they should be um
00:20:24 the the um the online safety bill i think should be withdrawn or massively rethought as a first
00:20:30 step i would like to see you know much clearer duties on um institutions not just universities
00:20:40 but you know government institutions generally public sector institutions generally to protect
00:20:47 free speech stand up free speech to make dismissing people on grounds of expressing
00:20:53 a normal opinion um not possible um i'd like to see clearer duties on social media
00:21:01 companies insofar as we can um to to do the same thing i think the whole
00:21:06 trend at the moment is in the wrong direction unfortunately that's going to mean the government
00:21:11 standing up for people it intensely dislikes who aren't particularly pleasant necessarily
00:21:19 and with whom they disagree but if you don't do that you're not really in favour of free speech
00:21:25 and those difficult cases are where things get get tested look look at the you know go back to
00:21:32 250 years to the first the debates around the first reporting of parliamentary proceedings that was
00:21:38 very unpopular at the time um yet it happened and you've got to stand up for unpopular things as well
00:21:45 as the things you like don't you think as well it sometimes comes down to just often people need to
00:21:52 hear just in speeches they they need to hear that people are on their side on these issues
00:21:58 i think that's what we seem not to have had very much of um and i think when i think of during the
00:22:03 time where we had the blm marches and the statues were under threat and they were coming down it
00:22:09 seems to have cooled down a bit uh since then but um yeah there seemed to be a feeling that
00:22:16 you know ministers had to be goaded into saying something yeah again i think it's one of these
00:22:22 areas where you know um at least some of those responsible were trying to reconcile you know
00:22:29 basically irreconcilable objectives so one day they said something that tilted in one way to
00:22:34 the arguments and one day they said something went in a different way and i i think you just
00:22:39 you just can't um you know people have got the right to say in my view what they wish unless
00:22:45 they're inciting violence public institutions should not be taking sides in these debates like
00:22:51 the police seem to at times we need free speech free debate let the best arguments win and that's
00:22:58 the best way through this i incidentally i i think another thing that scares people off a bit um is
00:23:05 what seems for me to be quite a coarsening in the tone of our public debate in recent years
00:23:11 and i don't know whether social media is part of this whether it's happened anyway but the
00:23:16 you know the very aggressive language the you know the the sort of foul mouth speech the the threat
00:23:23 the kind of sneering tone that is so much around that seems to me to be quite new and that's just
00:23:34 i i think you know a bit of courtesy a bit of um kind of decency in the way we engage these
00:23:43 arguments on i think it's more phenomenal the left than the right but you do see it on the right
00:23:48 i i think a bit you know let's all be a bit nice to each other maybe that will help i i would i
00:23:54 would agree with that i mean yes rule number one would be don't go on twitter i suppose but uh it
00:23:59 seems to me that uh you know um i have got a bit of a dog in this fight i suppose but it it does
00:24:06 seem to me that it has come that kind of hatred and variance has certainly come from the left and
00:24:11 And when you go back to Brexit, and you still see it on Twitter, don't you?
00:24:16 People disowning their parents and things like this.
00:24:19 It's just appalling.
00:24:20 It's just no humanity in it whatsoever.
00:24:25 You mentioned that we've talked a bit about history.
00:24:29 You mentioned there the attack on history.
00:24:32 Again, I don't mean to sort of land these things on you and you to come up with policy ideas,
00:24:37 but how best to protect history?
00:24:40 I mean, you do mention that one of the reasons that we've become demoralised is that there's been decades of chipping away.
00:24:47 I mean, certainly in my lifetime, I suspect yours, that's all I really remember.
00:24:51 And that is undermining, however recently sounding, and we end up in this position of the one we're in now.
00:25:00 How can one possibly reverse or change that?
00:25:04 Well, I think there are a lot of things.
00:25:06 I mean obviously in schools the government can reasonably impose a duty to expose all
00:25:14 sides of the argument about Britain and its historical record, I mean all sides of it,
00:25:21 and I'm not convinced that is always happening at the moment.
00:25:24 I think it can reasonably impose a duty to tell the whole sweep of British history, not
00:25:31 just focus on sort of snapshots at particular moments, so that people kind of understand
00:25:37 how we got to where we are. And again, I'm not sure that's happening. People often seems
00:25:43 to me have quite a weak understanding of some of the things that would have been common
00:25:48 knowledge maybe 50 or 100 years ago. I think also we, you know, the kind of very deeply
00:25:57 rooted teleological Whig theory of history that we have in this country is, in some ways,
00:26:03 it's part of the problem. You know, the British history has been an evolution from monarchy into
00:26:09 democracy, the growth of institutions. That is definitely part of the story. But it has enabled
00:26:15 people to say, well, we're now, you know, that process is still going on. The next phase is the
00:26:21 the gradual dissolution of the nation-state into something else, into a world where borders
00:26:28 matter less. That is the natural next development. And there, I think, you have to distinguish
00:26:36 history from politics. History is how people responded to the trends, the developments
00:26:44 around them when they were alive. And they took the decisions and acted in accordance
00:26:51 with morality politics that prevails at the time you can't use that as a sort of moral exemplar
00:27:00 for guiding your your yourself now we're doing the same things and um i i worry that history has
00:27:09 become politics a bit and um it's important to try and distinguish the two uh let's say
00:27:19 doesn't mean you can't learn from history but the past was different they did things differently
00:27:25 there well people seem to have been disarmed in that they no longer know as you say certain things
00:27:32 you might have once taken guard so they actually don't really know what they're meant to be
00:27:35 defending particularly they they understand that something is sort of under attack but
00:27:40 they can't bring forth the words it's very difficult to bring forth the words to defend
00:27:45 yeah i think that is right and um again it goes back to this point about
00:27:53 nation nationalism nation status and what what is it that we are defending and why and i go back to
00:28:00 the um you know we are defending a um a country that has evolved through history and a set of
00:28:10 ways of doing politics that has proved to be pretty successful. And, you know, all that comes
00:28:17 with a kind of emotion and colour and historical content that has got us to where we are. That's
00:28:23 the sort of political science way of putting it, but I think it's true. And, you know,
00:28:30 they've always been people who wants to weaken that. I mean, Orwell himself, you know, is
00:28:34 famously highly critical of left-wing intellectuals who, you know, won't stand for God save the king
00:28:39 and all that. That I think is, you know, it's always been part of our sort of politics.
00:28:48 But I agree, we, I mean, we're ourselves I think even in this discussion sort of struggling
00:28:54 for the language that, you know, kind of makes it real to people, gives it a kind of emotional
00:29:02 component that people can respond to.
00:29:04 I suppose in order to try and make it real, take for example, the sheer incomprehension
00:29:09 people feel at our big institutions our museums and such like um taking on a political role
00:29:16 apparently seemingly uh decolonizing whether it's the british library whether it's a british museum
00:29:22 right down to kew gardens what should happen in those situations i mean should people should they
00:29:28 lose their public money i mean if they go beyond their remit i mean i think it is very difficult
00:29:33 here i mean the government does have a bit of a bully pulpit in this these matters to to kind of
00:29:40 stigmatize or otherwise particular behavior i mean but it comes back to you know i don't
00:29:47 particularly want the government to tell the people at kew gardens that they can or cannot
00:29:55 teach or behave in certain ways i think that carries risks as well and you know what's happening
00:30:00 in our institutions is a is a symptom of something that's already quite deep in the the kind of
00:30:07 intellectual class that isn't a cause of it. We have to provide the space for people who
00:30:15 think differently to to be allowed to to say it so you know I've no doubt there are
00:30:21 people in Kew Gardens just stay wanting I mean it seems unfair to take this example really because I
00:30:26 I love Kew Gardens, and I was at its Sussex outpost Wakehurst only yesterday, but people
00:30:37 have got to feel empowered to speak differently. We mustn't have the sense that there's only
00:30:44 one correct set of opinions, that that set of opinions is the only thing that can be
00:30:50 represented on the boards of our major institutions, end of story. We've got to keep the space
00:30:55 for debate and discussion would you be part of this government i believe that you've been asked
00:31:03 haven't you uh if you would be in and you haven't accepted so is that correct well i i mean i don't
00:31:08 want to go into the the detail but we we had a couple of discussions uh and um i felt it wasn't
00:31:17 quite the areas where i felt i was most able to kind of contribute so we we left it at that and
00:31:25 you know that's that's fine you know i i support the government as long as it's doing the right
00:31:30 things and it seems to be showing good signs of of that at the moment and um i feel like i'm
00:31:36 probably best support by sort of saying and um kind of contributing to the public debate around
00:31:43 this at the moment although since uh you know you were negotiating Brexit you your profile has become
00:31:48 much wider and you know you must be aware of people a lot of people admiring the positions
00:31:54 you've taken not least on uh on the climate for example that's the lack of a climate emergency i
00:32:00 think you must have got it in the neck for that i'm sure i definitely have i mean a lot of support
00:32:05 and uh you know a lot of of criticism and um yeah i mean you know people have been kind enough to
00:32:12 say they thought i ought to have some role and still and still should but but yeah i i that's
00:32:19 that's sort of up to them. I don't think that my presence is essential to a Liz Trust government
00:32:29 that is doing a lot of the things that I agree with. So that's kind of how I would look at it.
00:32:35 Have you always been interested in politics? Since when you were a kid were you?
00:32:41 yeah i was and um i you know all through my my life really and you know i've my opinions have
00:32:48 changed with time as as many people's have um and you know one of the reasons i went into
00:32:55 politics into civil service diplomatic service was it was a it was a way of being in that that
00:33:02 world if you like without taking all the risks that um the kind of real politician has to but
00:33:08 But the reason I left was I got frustrated with not being able to say and say what I think and, you know, do what I thought.
00:33:17 And, you know, you don't lose those constraints in other organisations, but it's particularly acute in the civil service.
00:33:25 And that was the frustration that led me to move on in the end.
00:33:30 When you first became interested in politics, were you what you might call an instinctive conservative or not?
00:33:37 or just interested in the whole procedure so i find i mean i was i was on the left when i was
00:33:44 young um a student and a school and this this sort of thing and my my opinions changed quite fast
00:33:52 once i sort of hit the real world i suppose um but i do think that one of the things i find
00:34:02 frustrating about the left is that they seem to have abandoned a lot of the things that
00:34:10 I thought ought to have been important to the left. And we've been talking about some of them,
00:34:15 you know, high standards in education, high standards in culture, belief in the nation
00:34:22 state. Go back 30, 40, 50 years, those were important parts of left-wing culture,
00:34:29 of working-class culture. You know, you wouldn't find somebody like Ernie Bevin pouring scorn
00:34:36 on any of those subjects, quite the reverse. And, you know, one of the reasons I moved on from the
00:34:42 left, I think, is because the left itself seemed to have abandoned things that seemed like important
00:34:50 to me in the way you run a country and a good society. And actually, I think quite a few people
00:34:57 on the left themselves feel some of that and they've drifted there's a phenomenon i think of
00:35:04 people left-wing people are intellectuals who think they are on the left but aren't and they
00:35:11 haven't kind of acknowledged it to themselves yet they've moved to the right because the things
00:35:16 they thought were important left-wingers and the labor party no longer do but being on the left
00:35:22 is so important to their self-identity they can't quite acknowledge it and i find that
00:35:29 that's quite revealing about what's important in politics yes do you think i mean this is part of
00:35:34 that really but do you think that there was this extraordinary thing wasn't there where
00:35:40 the red wall uh you know fell to the conservative but it was such an opportunity do you think that
00:35:48 is one of the things that has been completely wasted. It was kind of revolutionary, really.
00:35:58 I think there are quite a few fallacies around about the Red Wall. Let's not forget that Mrs
00:36:04 Thatcher won a good chunk of what's now the Red Wall in the mid-80s. It's not quite as new or
00:36:12 astonishing as as people say sometimes and she won it with an appeal to you know getting control
00:36:19 of your own life again from the socialist bureaucracies who ran it and told you you
00:36:25 didn't have any future other than sort of stay where you were and vote labor now it's different
00:36:30 now um but i think some of the appeal to run your own life get on with things prosper um is still
00:36:38 important in the red wall as well as in the the blue wall um i think we did tap into a kind of
00:36:47 patriotism belief in democracy and belief that the referendum result obviously should be respected i
00:36:54 think that's that's really important but i don't draw the conclusion that we won lots of labor
00:37:00 seats therefore we need to have lots of sub-labor policies to keep them people came over because
00:37:07 they realized they had they actually had a different set of values somewhat and the brexit
00:37:14 vote kind of legitimized people realizing that and you know we must give conservatism to people who
00:37:22 voted conservative in my view it's it's a mistake to go into in a different direction yes and we
00:37:31 we talked a bit about history but i just wonder having been so involved in in brexit um over the
00:37:39 past years what's your general view david of where it's going there not that one should care but i
00:37:46 think we sort of should care do you think it is an empire in decline and you generally regardless
00:37:53 almost a Brexit? I think it's getting exhausted as a project you know you can
00:38:03 see the believers still wanting to use every crisis to produce a further leap
00:38:10 in integration you know whether it's through the euro or the stability
00:38:15 mechanism or whatever or now it's let's get rid of qualified majority voting in
00:38:19 foreign policy, Ukraine shows
00:38:22 it needed and so on. Each time you get
00:38:23 that, but I think the
00:38:25 kind of moral force
00:38:28 of that has got a lot
00:38:30 weaker over the years
00:38:31 and I think the reason is that
00:38:34 integration has gone so deep
00:38:36 in the EU now that it's touching
00:38:38 the fundamentals
00:38:40 of what it is to run a country
00:38:42 or to be an independent country
00:38:44 and people in Europe can see that
00:38:46 as well as
00:38:47 as anybody else and you know the fact that migration has been such a big debate and borders
00:38:52 and and so on um even the role of the court in the french election you know a bit all these things
00:38:58 are are there so i think it personally i think it's reached its natural limits or close to them
00:39:05 in terms of integration um i don't think it's going to go much further i don't think they'll
00:39:11 they'll be able to sort of admit that to themselves.
00:39:14 I don't see it kind of unwinding much,
00:39:17 therefore, for the same reason.
00:39:21 You know, I claim intellectual property slightly
00:39:26 and being the first person to compare the EU
00:39:28 to the Austro-Hungarian Empire,
00:39:30 which I did in the lecture in 2008.
00:39:33 But I think it's still valid.
00:39:34 You know, it sort of works after fashion,
00:39:38 but they can't get the energy to go in any real direction.
00:39:44 And just like the Austro-Hungarian Empire,
00:39:47 they were as much a problem for their allies
00:39:49 as a strength for them.
00:39:52 And that I think we're seeing at the moment as well.
00:39:55 I think, you know, do get hold of this report,
00:39:59 of policy exchange reports, if you can,
00:40:01 because it's fascinating, very, very interesting to read.
00:40:04 There's one very specific thing you said, actually, David,
00:40:07 I'd like you just to tell us why, and that is that the Equalities Act should be abolished.
00:40:12 You're quite clear about that.
00:40:14 Well, I think the problem with the Equalities Act is that it bears more heavily on the public sector
00:40:20 than on the private sector, though it hits both.
00:40:23 There are a set of specific duties on public sector organisations, government,
00:40:28 and all the others around it
00:40:30 to ensure that these certain characteristics are protected
00:40:38 and in a very intrusive way.
00:40:43 And of course, government's particularly vulnerable
00:40:44 to judicial review and all the other stuff that goes around that.
00:40:48 And what's happened is that we've seen this massive growth
00:40:53 of internal bureaucracy that is aimed at protecting
00:40:57 and ensuring diversity and ensuring the protection of all these characteristics and it's one
00:41:03 that is where I've seen HR in the public sector grow hugely, why there appears to be this
00:41:07 huge sort of diversion of effort to worrying about this all the time and it's not easy
00:41:15 for the people who run the departments, whether they're ministers or the top civil servants
00:41:21 to say we're just not going to bother about it anymore because it's there in law, they
00:41:26 they can't not pay attention to some extent and every time they don't they're taking a bit of a
00:41:31 risk um so i don't see any alternative but to actually weaken the legal duties and get them
00:41:39 proportional again so that you know the primary um duty of government departments comes to be
00:41:48 again doing the job that they're constituted for and not worrying about the composition of the
00:41:53 employees well actually we we had an interview on recently one of our most popular for a long time
00:42:00 journalist called juliet samuel who was talking about hr yes and it really struck a chord with
00:42:06 people because obviously most people have come across hr in their time and it was as you say
00:42:11 this extraordinary way in which the aim of what they do has been is diverged completely from
00:42:16 actually what they're meant to do is to imposing another sort of form or an ideology one would say
00:42:21 yeah i think it's become like that in certain places you know you you do find good hr
00:42:28 officers in the civil service and and areas of kind of common sense where people kind of try
00:42:34 and keep the show on the road without getting overwhelmed by all this stuff but but all the
00:42:39 pressures are in the other direction and um it is one of the reasons why the ministers have just
00:42:46 found it so difficult to get a grip in this area on why some civil servants at least seem to think
00:42:52 they don't have to pay too much attention to ministers who disagree with them on it because
00:42:56 there it is in in the law but it's it's just as you know a specific case of the general problem
00:43:02 that there's too much superstructure yes that is stopping people doing their job and you see that
00:43:10 in all sorts of areas that's you know we've got a productivity problem that is undoubtedly one of
00:43:14 the reasons yes definitely um and we've got a we've got to uh close in a minute um with history in
00:43:22 mind um how do you think how do you think boris johnson will be remembered in history i think
00:43:29 history will think more kindly of him than many people do at the moment uh to be honest i you
00:43:35 know, to me he is, I loved working with Boris. It was a moment of intense sort of psychological
00:43:48 crisis, I suppose, when I had to do what I thought was the right thing and leave. And
00:43:55 you know, a lot of things that have happened in this country wouldn't have happened without
00:44:00 him you know undoubtedly um we would still be in the eu if if if he and i i think without blowing
00:44:10 our own trumpet too much uh me and dominic cummings had not been in these places at the right time i
00:44:16 think we would still be in the the eu and he deserves huge credit for that for all the criticism
00:44:21 on the pandemic which you know i've been quite prominent in nevertheless we didn't get lockdowns
00:44:28 like a lot of other countries got them.
00:44:30 We did come out to them first.
00:44:31 I think Boris is always a bit uncomfortable with it.
00:44:35 I just wish he trusted his own judgment a bit more on that.
00:44:39 And he saw the moral urgency on Ukraine.
00:44:43 To me, it's a real, he was a great man
00:44:46 brought down by tragic flaws, really.
00:44:50 Things that people could see he should do something about,
00:44:53 but somehow never could, and in the end caught up with him.
00:44:57 but he should have realised that you can't give your enemies too much ammunition.
00:45:03 Unfortunately, he carried on doing that.
00:45:06 So I think, looking back, this is obviously going to be a hugely important,
00:45:14 pivotal period in the history of this country.
00:45:19 And he has been at the heart of that.
00:45:22 He's put the country onto a new course.
00:45:24 Sadly, he's not there to help steer it.
00:45:26 but that's politics and i'm sure we've done the right thing also there's no question that the
00:45:33 kind of collectivism that you talk about has been embedded further by the pandemic actually hasn't
00:45:39 it it really has i think and i think we're just beginning to realize the the kind of psychological
00:45:45 cultural political effects of it which have gone quite a lot deeper than people thought i mean
00:45:51 it had a big effect on me and I think you know people have been reflective
00:45:56 about it and often said the same thing I realized governments could do things
00:46:00 that they you know in the past we thought they they couldn't and you know
00:46:08 the whole way free speech in practice got restricted on certain issues the
00:46:15 whole inability to kind of debate certain facts, honestly, I found, you know, extremely
00:46:23 troubling. And it's a huge relief that we've got out of it. But no, unfortunately, I don't
00:46:30 think these things have been quite put back in the bottle yet. And it's been another turn
00:46:38 of the handle to take us in a more collectivist direction. And, you know, it's so important
00:46:43 this government says stop
00:46:46 David thank you very very much
00:46:50 for joining us
00:46:51 and giving us your time
00:46:52 and I do hope that you are up there
00:46:56 in government at some point
00:46:56 whatever happens
00:46:57 thank you very much indeed
00:47:00 that's it for what you're saying
00:47:03 this week
00:47:04 we shall see you next time
00:47:06 thank you very much
00:47:07 hello if you're enjoying the New Culture Forum channel
00:47:11 and you believe in our mission
00:47:13 may I invite you to join our membership scheme at the link below or on our website
00:47:20 newcultureforum.org.uk. Our work is more important now than ever and we have great plans ahead for
00:47:28 the future but we can't do it without your support. From as little as £3 per month you can
00:47:34 help ensure that we continue on our mission. As a member you'll receive a range of benefits
00:47:40 including access to exclusive content, invitations to our private events
00:47:46 including here at our studios, free copies of our books and much much more
00:47:52 including of course our famous NCF mug. If you aren't able to become a member
00:47:58 then please help us by clicking this button and subscribing to our channel.
00:48:04 It's completely free. Just remember to also click the bell icon so that you can
00:48:10 get notifications when we post new videos. Thank you.