New Culture Forum - June 06, 2020


Is BBC Bias Getting Worse? Is the BBC still a force for good or too biased now to serve the nation?

Newspeak - Scandal Of Illegal Immigration During Covid19 Lockdown BLM Protests: From Historic Statues To Television; Is Britain In A Full-Blown Culture War?

Episode Stats


Length

32 minutes

Words per minute

176.5

Word count

5,802

Sentence count

131


Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
00:00:00 Hello and welcome to Counterculture. I'm Peter Whittle.
00:00:11 Now, should we trust the BBC? Can we trust the BBC?
00:00:17 There's no question that that is a particular issue that we've looked at many times on this programme.
00:00:23 It's one that's bubbled again to the surface this year.
00:00:26 In particular, in the recent weeks, we've had two high-profile examples,
00:00:30 the first being a programme by the BBC Panorama on the NHS,
00:00:35 and more recently, a monologue by Emily Maitlis, presenter of Newsnight,
00:00:40 for which she was actually censored by the BBC.
00:00:44 Is the BBC really, as it would have us believe, a force for good,
00:00:48 or is it actually more damaging than anything?
00:00:51 Now, I'm delighted to discuss this today.
00:00:53 We have two guests, Charles Moore, who was editor of The Daily Telegraph, The Sunday Telegraph, and The Spectator.
00:01:01 He now writes a column for The Daily Telegraph, and he is, of course, Margaret Thatcher's authorised biographer.
00:01:07 And from the New Culture Forum, Rafe Hadelman Koo, historian and commentator.
00:01:12 Welcome to you both.
00:01:14 Charles, thank you for joining us.
00:01:16 What was your opinion of what Emily Maidlis did?
00:01:22 I mean, did you see it as something which was a particularly blatant form of aggressive, you know, partisanship or what?
00:01:33 Well, perhaps not exactly partisan. I didn't think it was a party minded type thing, entirely blatant piece of editorialised and opinionising.
00:01:44 so obviously it had no impartiality whatever it entirely and deliberately
00:01:51 bbc rules and obviously um she must have known that perfectly well
00:01:56 you you uh this wasn't the first time was it with her on news night i think she did something quite
00:02:02 similar about the covid virus recently you know when it was about the inequalities of the covid
00:02:08 bars yes um but i wouldn't particularly single out uh emily mateless um i mean this was a very
00:02:16 egregious example but i think it happens a great deal um among many presenters what's unusual about
00:02:23 what emily mateless did was that it's unarguable that it that it broke the rules and yet she did
00:02:30 it so why does we do we have a corporation which has these rules and yet an important presenter
00:02:37 feels able to do this that seems an extraordinary situation to be in it's
00:02:43 more extraordinary than the position she took I think I mean the position she
00:02:47 took is a legitimate position but not a legitimate position for an impartial
00:02:52 presenter and really she's only been wrapped on the knuckles about it so one
00:03:01 I think has to assume that the BBC it doesn't fulfill its duties and is not
00:03:06 prepared to doesn't take impartiality seriously. That's the most serious aspect of it. And I think
00:03:13 it's a problem that runs through its political and news coverage, and actually also through its
00:03:19 cultural coverage to a large extent. If anything, you could say that the cultural coverage is
00:03:24 actually sort of almost more insidious, isn't it, in the sense that there are certain assumptions
00:03:28 made in drama and comedy, very much which are along sort of, you know, liberal cultural lines.
00:03:36 yes and of course they're unchallenged whereas sometimes on the political coverage they are
00:03:42 challenged you know there's sometimes more than one person in the room uh not always by any
00:03:46 missions but um but with the culture ones absolutely um rave did you uh this panorama
00:03:52 program just for some of our viewers could you explain actually what what what the controversy
00:03:57 was about well the panorama program um was as you know is an investigative journalism program of
00:04:03 very long standing in the united kingdom and it was performing one of its typical um exposés on
00:04:09 you know scandals within institutions and on this scandal was about protective equipment ppe
00:04:14 and the alleged inability of the government to supply it in insufficient quantities
00:04:19 throughout the health care system and um despite being an investigative journalism show it apparently
00:04:25 was unable to find out the fact that each of the people each person that had interviewed
00:04:29 was or had been a Labour activist,
00:04:32 something which half an hour on the Internet
00:04:34 would have been able to find on Google.
00:04:38 This was revealed by another investigative journalism website
00:04:41 called Guido Fawkes,
00:04:42 and it seems unconscionable that they didn't know this.
00:04:47 And yet, again, BBC guidelines state
00:04:49 that any affiliation that a person has
00:04:52 has to be revealed, there has to be transparency.
00:04:55 So either the BBC's flagship investigative show
00:04:58 didn't know that these people had this or they were deliberately hiding the fact either one of
00:05:03 which is a damning statement about the program and you know the editorial policies yes um charles
00:05:09 you've written about the bbc for years and years um do you think that it's something uh qualitatively
00:05:16 different about it now i mean compared to maybe when you first wrote about bbc buys do you think
00:05:23 it is more overt than maybe when you first talked yes I think I think it's I think it's on a
00:05:30 continuum I don't think it's suddenly gone from a very good situation to a very bad one I think
00:05:34 it's gone from a bad situation to a very bad one um but uh I think the culture has shifted so that
00:05:41 um part of what the left is trying to do is to make it um fundamentally immoral to have a different
00:05:49 view on certain questions um and that reflect is reflected in what in the bias we see so that
00:05:56 uh the bbc has decided for example that on all climate change questions uh it's not right it's
00:06:02 actually wrong sort of unethical and unsuitable for the bbc to put contrary views so um you are
00:06:11 being excluded simply because you don't accept the the dominant orthodoxy and that is a tremendous
00:06:17 permission to editorializing because the distinction between opinion and fact is heavily elided.
00:06:25 And that's also true of quite a lot of coverage of Brexit, I think, and certainly anything that
00:06:31 can be tagged with the name of racism, no matter how remote the claim. And that allowed, that came
00:06:38 into Brexit because if you could assert that any objection to immigration was racist, then that
00:06:45 that gave you the right to exclude it from the conversation and I think this
00:06:49 happens continuously and it's pervasive of course not just the BBC you see it
00:06:56 more and more at universities for example and it also means that if you
00:07:01 think that way it comes to raise very important point about not doing due
00:07:07 diligence you all you need to work out is who's on the right quote right side
00:07:11 and then you put them on and you don't ask the difficult questions so it's
00:07:15 absolutely commonplace now for government ministers particularly if it's
00:07:20 a Tory government to be you know harangued and lots of things brought up
00:07:24 about their record and all that sort of thing whereas that sort of work will not
00:07:28 have been done on the average spokesman from an NGO or or indeed a spokesman for
00:07:34 the Chinese Communist Party who might be not coming out sailing under the name
00:07:39 of the chinese communist party um and so um the whole idea is often people like um president trump
00:07:48 are often accused and often rightly and um the internet too of making up things and just pushing
00:07:55 them out but i think similar claims can be made about the bbc in the sense that it's a
00:08:01 a sort of moral world view like a pseudo religion which is just preached and preached and preached
00:08:08 and therefore the normal ideas of objectivity on which the BBC is supposedly founded cease to apply.
00:08:19 That's exactly right and of course commentators will always be described as a right-wing commentator
00:08:24 but very rarely will one see someone described as a left-wing commentator
00:08:27 as if they are beyond the pale if you are on the right
00:08:30 and certainly as Charles Wolf very very correctly pointed out last year
00:08:37 the imbalance on question time where spiked online another website did a report showing that
00:08:43 there was a two-to-one bias between 2017 and 2019 there were 300 people who were remainers on the
00:08:49 panel at that during those periods and there was only about 150 people who actually leave us
00:08:54 but this goes to the larger point or the BBC wants to see itself as the state broadcaster
00:09:00 and yet at the same time and it's funded nationally and yet it's failing to serve the
00:09:05 or meet the needs and requirements of over 50 percent of the population as we've seen in terms
00:09:10 of the election of the Tories and indeed with Brexit and part of the problem there I think
00:09:15 it really comes down to the fact that the BBC always had a policy of impartiality in its news
00:09:21 department that was enforced with an iron rod and the BBC has seemed fit in recent years to encourage
00:09:29 its news presenters to be seen as personalities and to engage with their audience through social
00:09:35 media. So that's where their existing liberal bias comes into being. For example, the BBC
00:09:43 consumes more Guardian newspapers than any other newspaper, despite the fact that the Guardian
00:09:47 is the nation's least popular newspaper, which shows the imbalance there. And it's very evident
00:09:52 on Twitter. If you look through all the news presenters, and Guido Fawkes did another survey
00:09:56 on this, 96% of Emily Maitlis' tweets, which were non-neutral, were anti-Boris. There was
00:10:02 only one tweet they could find that was actually in any way pro-Boris. And it's lost its position.
00:10:07 I'm a royal commentator, so I like to draw an analogy with the royal family. The royal family
00:10:11 and the BBC are supposed to be institutions for national unity, impartial. And the royal family,
00:10:17 as we know, compared the Queen Mother to the Duchess of Sussex. One figure was right-wing,
00:10:22 but always had an impartial position. No one ever knew her opinion. And the nation
00:10:27 collectively united around this figure. Compare that with the Duchess of Sussex,
00:10:31 immediately divisive and we're seeing that without news presenters i never knew what alistair burnett's
00:10:36 position was or a or a terry wogan or anyone like that and yet we all know the opinions of our
00:10:42 current news presenters and that's automatically divisive i think do you think uh uh charles that
00:10:48 the world view that you described earlier uh how has that informed the bbc's coverage of the
00:10:57 COVID-19 crisis? Or has it? Well, I think it has in two respects. One is that it's been like the
00:11:08 dentist looking for the hole, which is something a dentist must do. But I'm not sure that the BBC
00:11:14 has to be a dentist all the time. And I think particularly at a time of national crisis,
00:11:19 the BBC probably ought to have, it certainly shouldn't be hiding bad news, but it should
00:11:23 be trying to be encouraging and unifying rather like in a war it should be therefore less inclined
00:11:31 than usual to um go for accusation and more inclined to cover things calmly and i think the
00:11:38 opposite um has has been the case um i also think that this double standard about how it interviews
00:11:46 people is very very marked so if you if it talks to a doctor or a nurse or possibly even a trade
00:11:54 union leader in the nursing or doctor health service line or if it talks to a head teacher
00:12:02 about who says that children shouldn't return to school or something like that such people
00:12:08 and also scientists will be treated with a deference which is not accorded to elected
00:12:13 politicians and particularly not to conservative elected politicians and uh the ministers are sort
00:12:19 of monstered by the interviewers and the others are treated more politely which on the whole is
00:12:25 a good thing but sometimes they're let off very easily and their their remarks are not challenged
00:12:30 um it's also true in on the world coverage of kovid i think that um you would think from
00:12:37 following the bbc's coverage that um the worst people in the world are uh bolsonaro and trump
00:12:44 um i i don't think either bolsonaro or trump have covered themselves with glory
00:12:50 uh in the covid crisis but i also do not think that they are the sort of deep cause or even the
00:12:55 great the super spreaders of the whole thing um and really the scrutiny which is is so marked
00:13:03 because it isn't there is of china yes and you know one of the things that the british
00:13:08 broadcasting corporation has the money to do is have really proper coverage of china i've seen
00:13:13 almost nothing i've seen some quite good stuff from hong kong i've seen almost nothing from beijing
00:13:20 which tries to examine what's going on in the chinese communist party what's it what's the
00:13:24 power struggle what's xi jinping trying to do what is the belt and road initiative why is it
00:13:29 it that they seem to have got 130 UN member states in their pocket and so on. What's happening with
00:13:35 the World Health Organization and the Chinese and so on. And it's not just the bias, it's the
00:13:42 sheer lack of information and analysis, which is really marked. And I noticed that it's expected
00:13:49 of correspondence that they don't give you very much information analysis. And what they're
00:13:54 encouraged to do is to do a sort of summing up all the time and where and certain phrases come
00:13:59 on all the time like um you know and people are still waiting for answers or something like that
00:14:04 to show that they're on the side of a victim um it's just not nearly nearly informative enough
00:14:12 i think there was actually a change in policy was there not i think when john burt was at the bbc
00:14:18 which what which gave rise therefore to this sort of commentary side of things in other words you
00:14:25 had the editor of the particular area so as you say summing up it's almost impossible is it not
00:14:32 uh you know not to be you know partial in that situation so yes but to be fair to bert i think
00:14:41 um he was actually trying quite sincerely to make it more like an expert telling you things
00:14:46 right um he wasn't trying to skew it in a political manner but you're right that what's
00:14:51 happened is that you get a more sort of smart ass commentary i mean if you look at um uh lara
00:14:58 koensberg or norman smith um or even nick robinson though he's that's not his job anymore
00:15:03 they like to give a sort of sign off on everything which is their verdict on the situation
00:15:07 and that seems to be considered more important than telling you what actually happened
00:15:11 and of course we're now into our third month of dealing with coronavirus and there's been
00:15:16 wall-to-wall news coverage so there's ample opportunity to actually have wider reports
00:15:21 and investigations and debates and discussions on key issues regarding covid which aren't simply
00:15:26 being had there are so many leading scientists and doctors who you have to go onto youtube
00:15:31 and find discussions and debates there with people leading figures from the who or even the swedish
00:15:37 epidemiologists who've been proposing this and radically different approach. And yet the BBC
00:15:44 seem to be scared or shy of approaching these things, even when you have people like the Oxford
00:15:50 based research units who were the ones whose modelling the government was following until
00:15:55 Neil Ferguson actually came up with his own imperial college. They've mysteriously disappeared
00:16:00 from the BBC as well. And I think there's a huge failing to actually, you know, not only provide
00:16:06 some sort of scrutiny in opposition to what the government's doing but to actually widen the
00:16:10 discussion and debate the leading german virologists who've come out and shown how how low the fatality
00:16:16 rate is compared to what has been broadcast they're they're being excluded from the bbc and
00:16:21 yet they'll be found in newspapers uh being being reported i think that that's a that's a terrible
00:16:27 slight uh on the part of the bbc but um beyond that i think really the bbc also is lacking in
00:16:33 And the hypocrisy is blatant.
00:16:35 When you look at the way that it quite rightly held the government to account
00:16:38 over 100,000 tests that the Health Secretary, Matt Hancock, said per day were its goal,
00:16:44 it quite rightly scrutinised the government on that.
00:16:47 And yet just yesterday we saw on Newsnight their policy editor stating
00:16:52 that there were more deaths in England yesterday than there were in all of the EU combined,
00:16:59 when the FT's fact-checker said, well, actually, this ignores the fact
00:17:02 that the reporting techniques on the continent are very different.
00:17:05 And if you were to use Spain's new model for reporting deaths,
00:17:08 there were only 20 deaths in England,
00:17:10 and yet none of that seems to come through.
00:17:11 And it's this worst-case scenario type of approach to things
00:17:14 which really erodes trust in the public.
00:17:18 There's a broader question here, isn't there?
00:17:20 We are concerned with the BBC mainly because if you don't pay for it,
00:17:25 if you don't pay your licence fee, then you get fined
00:17:28 or you could end up in jail, actually.
00:17:30 I understand that the
00:17:32 I think the non-payment
00:17:35 of the license fee is the
00:17:37 second or even maybe the first
00:17:39 main reason for women being in
00:17:41 the criminal justice system which is extraordinary
00:17:43 but there's
00:17:45 a wider thing here, there was a poll
00:17:47 quite recently which showed that the broadcast
00:17:49 media, not the print media, the broadcast
00:17:51 media has seen a
00:17:53 sort of collapsing confidence
00:17:55 from the public, something like 29-30%
00:17:58 of people
00:17:58 you know this is a this is a broadcast wide thing is it not charles i mean the bbc as i say we we
00:18:05 have to pay for it i suppose we don't have to watch sky but frankly when i watch sky i feel
00:18:09 that i'm in an alternate universe sometimes yes uh you're right and i think this has driven um
00:18:16 some of the broadcasters a bit crazy and they think that and it's also because they don't
00:18:21 understand social media so they're very um preoccupied with how they're going down on
00:18:27 social media um to obviously you need to think about that but they they they somehow take that
00:18:33 um the volume of that as being representative of the whole country which it isn't it's not
00:18:39 it's not representative of the people who follow social media and it's even less representative of
00:18:42 all the people who don't follow social media and this means that um they don't actually quite know
00:18:48 what they're supposed to be doing they're sort of whoring after the things that are hardest to get
00:18:53 like for example young viewers um which and they're being and all the people who pay for them
00:18:58 who are old viewers um are sitting there getting annoyed and um what the most common thing i get
00:19:04 from my telegraph and spectator readers is plenty there are plenty of complaints about bias but even
00:19:11 more than that the most common thing of all is a complaint that i just don't want to hear this
00:19:15 anymore i don't want to see it anymore i just find it too um aggressive and miserable and
00:19:22 uninformative and so I'm actually just not going to watch it I can find out more detailed facts
00:19:26 online I can read magazines or newspapers I might pick up a few short bulletins but essentially
00:19:33 I'm not going to put up with this it's just making me miserable to know and I'm not getting
00:19:37 better informed yes that is something that we hear more and more is it not that basically
00:19:42 if you want to keep your sanity you basically stay away from it well all we see on the BBC
00:19:47 and across the broadcast media is this assumption that the person being interviewed is a liar
00:19:52 and they have to be caught out and there's got to be a gotcha moment everyone wants to be a
00:19:56 paxman paxman used to be an exception to the rule and now it seems everybody wants to be a paxman
00:20:01 now someone like andrew neal i think is perfect because he is we all know that he's right wing
00:20:05 but that's only visible if you watch him on twitter if you see him when he's broadcasting
00:20:08 for the bbc he is faultlessly impartial and he will give each side equal and equally tough time
00:20:14 and his style of interviewing is excellent during the run-up to an election for example or during
00:20:19 conference season but there is no need to have that style of interrogation year round through
00:20:25 every single news channel and in every interview. That's why this type of forum where everybody
00:20:30 actually has a chance to speak to elaborate and expand upon their views is far more useful and
00:20:35 if you read the comments under YouTube discussions where you've had controversial columnists you'll
00:20:40 see many people saying gosh I actually never liked this person but now that I've heard them elaborate
00:20:45 and expand on their views for 10 minutes,
00:20:47 I really enjoyed them, and I agree with them,
00:20:49 whereas on the news, you'll only have a 20-second soundbite.
00:20:52 Charles Hild?
00:20:53 Yes, I think that's a very good point,
00:20:55 but one thing I would add to what Ray's saying
00:20:59 is that the whole business is about tweeting.
00:21:03 I actually think Andrew Neill shouldn't tweet like that,
00:21:07 and nor should all these other people,
00:21:09 because what's changed is that the performers on the BBC
00:21:14 do regard themselves as individual performers this has been mentioned already but it's very
00:21:17 important rather than servants of the BBC so they're always trying to increase their profile
00:21:23 and that includes masses of tweeting and they don't exert on those tweets the same discipline
00:21:28 as they are supposed to exert and sometimes do exert on their performances uh on television
00:21:35 so it's a bit like working for a public service like the BBC ought to be like being a clergyman
00:21:42 used to be where they'd say
00:21:44 if you can't do it in a dog collar
00:21:46 you can't do it. In other words
00:21:48 you are
00:21:50 a full time
00:21:52 clergyman and in the same way
00:21:54 you ought to be, if you're a
00:21:56 BBC employee, that's sort of quite a sacred
00:21:58 duty and it's not regarded as that. So it's
00:22:00 a series of ego trips
00:22:02 and that I think partly explains
00:22:04 the Emily Maitlis performance on Newsnight
00:22:06 that we began with because
00:22:08 she knows she's on a programme that
00:22:10 very few people watch now
00:22:12 but she is very famous so what she was able to do was increase her fame uh riding on the bbc
00:22:19 and uncontrollably absolutely no i i i agree i agree 100 with that and i certainly wasn't in
00:22:24 any way saying that i approve of andrew neill's tweeting on those matters but actually it was
00:22:29 part of bbc's deliberate policy richard mosey the former head of news at the bbc said that the bbc
00:22:33 wanted news presenters to become personalities and to actively engage on social media but the
00:22:39 Problem is, once you try to put your personality across on social media, your bias comes through.
00:22:44 Now, I happen to side more with Andrew Neil's bias than Emily Maitlis's, so I prefer his tweets, but that's absolutely correct.
00:22:50 And as you were saying, it goes far beyond the news media into the wider culture.
00:22:53 For example, who of us knew how Tommy Cooper or Morecambe and Wise would have voted or what their political stance was or Bob Monkhouse?
00:23:00 We didn't know, and the whole nation enjoyed those comedians.
00:23:05 You could say the same thing for Hugh Grant and Steve Coogan in the 1990s.
00:23:08 They were adored by the nation because that was pre-social media.
00:23:12 Now we know what their views are.
00:23:14 Suddenly the nation's divided.
00:23:16 And suddenly half the nation, or more than half the nation,
00:23:18 can't enjoy those BBC panel shows and comedy programmes.
00:23:21 I certainly can't watch Steve Coogan now without thinking constantly
00:23:24 that he detests half of the nation and regards them as fools and imbeciles.
00:23:28 Yes, I think that's a very good point.
00:23:29 In fact, if you take Have I Got News For You, for example,
00:23:32 I don't really watch it now.
00:23:34 Partly because, as you say, Ralph, I feel that they would disapprove of me.
00:23:38 do you know they would disapprove of my views
00:23:40 and therefore how can you
00:23:42 laugh at somebody when they do that
00:23:43 if I can just draw two things together actually
00:23:45 if you're talking about the fact that we
00:23:48 can't watch Tommy Cooper or whatever in the
00:23:50 1970s
00:23:51 also Charles you mentioned how
00:23:54 few people watch Newsnight
00:23:55 basically does this
00:23:57 we're getting very angry about this but actually does it
00:24:00 matter anymore because
00:24:01 25 million people would have watched
00:24:04 the BBC whatever in the 1970s
00:24:06 even the 80s
00:24:07 How many people watch Newsnight? Probably, I think, even less than watch this channel that we're doing.
00:24:14 Its influence is actually going, isn't it? Isn't this a kind of last, final gasp to be relevant in a way?
00:24:23 I think I think that might be so, but it's a long time of dying.
00:24:27 And as long as the license fee system persists, the BBC will continue to get a great deal of money.
00:24:35 um it gets um uh more than three billion pounds a year from the license fee nearly four billion
00:24:42 and uh plus some other income that rides on the back of its monopolistic position and um that's
00:24:49 not right and um it's not sustainable but it nevertheless people used to say um uh about the
00:24:56 erm i remember um uh it won't work but my answer to that was yes of course it won't work but that
00:25:02 doesn't mean it won't happen. And this is the true of the BBC as well. The licence fee
00:25:10 doesn't work, but it will continue for a long, long time unless the government decides to do
00:25:16 something about it. Do you think, well, I mean, that might be the case. It's obviously hanging on
00:25:23 in there. What do you think actually should happen? Straight question. What do you think?
00:25:28 do you think that the license fee should just simply be scrapped um what do you think right
00:25:33 what do you think of the way forward well i think that uh you should look there should be a proper
00:25:41 look at the bbc's stated initial purposes um its charter with a completely open mind so one wouldn't
00:25:48 say automatically that the license fee should be done away with though um i'm basically against
00:25:54 license fee but i think you should say does it fulfill its purposes can it still fulfill its
00:25:59 purposes in modern times is its form of payment the best way of fulfilling its purposes are its
00:26:05 purposes worth achieving and so on and then you you do a sort of real audit of the whole thing
00:26:10 um and i think if you did that you would find that it is in moral and intellectual decay and
00:26:17 um in an unsustainable form of revenue and therefore you would reform it dramatically
00:26:23 But I think there's a big range of arguments one could have between complete abolition of the licence fee and radical reform, such as, for example, halving it.
00:26:35 In other words, I don't think one should immediately settle on a point about how it's paid for without looking at the whole of these questions.
00:26:43 um i was going to related to that i mean do you think that the bbc actually does as it thinks it
00:26:51 does uh really have this function of bringing the country together i'm sure it feels it has done with
00:26:58 covid um royal occasions things like that you know it tends to think it does to me i think the
00:27:05 damage it does culturally now outweighs anything you know that's remains of those functions i agree
00:27:12 and I'm loathe to admit that.
00:27:14 In the past on this programme,
00:27:15 I've said that I'm a passionate believer
00:27:17 in the value of a state broadcaster
00:27:18 to be accessible to all people in this country,
00:27:22 to be a point for basically
00:27:23 for creating a national culture.
00:27:25 We have to remember in the golden age of the BBC,
00:27:27 it was actually things like British comedy shows
00:27:30 and dramas that formed a sense of British culture
00:27:32 and that united the nation.
00:27:34 Now in this era when we have Netflix and so forth,
00:27:36 there's not necessarily a need for that,
00:27:38 but there still needs to be a uniquely British product
00:27:40 that's being put out there
00:27:41 to create a sense of national identity,
00:27:44 or at least to spread the message to people in the country
00:27:47 as to what it means to be British.
00:27:49 And that's no longer being fulfilled by the BBC,
00:27:52 which is a great shame,
00:27:53 but I still believe that there needs to be someone there
00:27:55 to represent, free of charge, things like royal occasions,
00:27:59 national ceremonial occasions.
00:28:01 We had VE Day recently.
00:28:02 I remember 1995, the celebrations that the BBC covered.
00:28:07 There's been a huge decline in the quality of that sort of programming.
00:28:10 I mean, Sky News is now far better, for example, with its raw coverage than the BBC is,
00:28:14 which has endless Vox Pops, as if we need to know what every person and their dog thinks on every issue.
00:28:19 So I would be in favour of maintaining the BBC in a state-funded, but in a much more slimmed-down version,
00:28:26 more perhaps like PBS in America, and actually review the Royal Charter, as I said before,
00:28:31 to ensure that it has a clear mandate and it knows what that is, and it is actually impartial.
00:28:35 Charles, do you think that the BBC has basically taken as a whole more of a demoralising force than, if you like, a sort of community force to people? Has it been culturally more damaging than not?
00:28:53 I think I think it is. I think it is now more damaging than its benefits. But I don't think I'm not convinced that it's absolutely irredeemable. I think this is all open to radical thought. And I think it is what Rafe is saying makes considerable sense.
00:29:12 i don't have a sort of one view about what ought to happen next what i do think needs to be
00:29:17 recognized two things one is that it's in a very very poor way and it's drifted very far from where
00:29:23 it should be and the other is that there's a fundamental problem about the license fee
00:29:27 and at the end of the day you know that for all for all its attempts to to represent as much
00:29:32 diversity as possible it continually fails to represent diversity of opinion and that needs
00:29:37 to be its main approach and there's a new director general that was going to be appointed very soon
00:29:42 with the retirement of Lord Hall
00:29:44 and that would be a great time
00:29:45 to see who they choose.
00:29:46 I mean, this could be its last gasp.
00:29:47 It knows full well
00:29:48 that the writing could be on the wall
00:29:49 with its government
00:29:49 and hopefully the next director general
00:29:52 will be one to perhaps
00:29:53 bring the BBC out of the bubble,
00:29:55 put it in the north of England
00:29:56 and have editors
00:29:57 who are actually drawn from the population
00:29:59 that now feel dispossessed.
00:30:00 Well, they tried that before
00:30:01 but they just kept on
00:30:02 shipping people up from London,
00:30:03 if I remember.
00:30:04 Well, beyond Salford, yes.
00:30:05 But just finally,
00:30:09 I take it then
00:30:09 that you don't really watch it very much.
00:30:11 What do you watch on the whole, if anything, Charles?
00:30:15 What do you watch when you turn on, when you want to see visual images?
00:30:19 I watch very, very little now.
00:30:22 I listen quite a lot.
00:30:24 I listen to Radio 4 and Radio 3 quite a lot.
00:30:28 And they still have some good things, but they're both considerably worse than they were.
00:30:34 I was listening to Radio 3 this afternoon, and we had a concert.
00:30:39 And the performer said at the end of it, it's been very nice to, in the Covid shutdown, that we can hear the birds and we can see the flowers growing.
00:30:51 Well, fair enough. And then he said, and how sad it is that George Floyd can't see this.
00:31:00 oh no um and um it is indeed very sad that george floyd can't see it but why is it that everything
00:31:07 has to be framed for the for at any one time in the voice of a particular sort of iconic grievance
00:31:14 when i'm afraid there are thousands and thousands of people across the world in far more far far
00:31:21 worse countries in the united states are being killed every week so um and why do we all have
00:31:27 to think in the same way and pick out the same icons and so on it's um this this interferes with
00:31:35 with thought and with freedom and with the sort of separateness which is part
00:31:40 suppose you're listening to classical music it seems to be what you want to hear is classical
00:31:44 music you don't want to hear thoughts about current political events that sort of demarcation seems
00:31:51 to have broken down what do you watch if anything you don't have a tv do you i don't have a television
00:31:56 but i listen to radio um and certainly in terms of of radio three presenters again i said you know
00:32:02 we don't know we never knew alistair burnett's political views were richard baker managed to
00:32:06 switch from being a news presenter to being a radio radio three um presenter and certainly
00:32:12 no one knew what his views were but i do say that i like bbc4 a lot so i on the internet i always
00:32:17 like to watch bbc documentaries when they're of a non-political nature and those still remain
00:32:21 excellent when the when the topic's right and there's been some recently with two chaps on
00:32:24 university challenge you've been looking at the industrial revolution and so forth and i find i
00:32:28 find those sorts of products still very very useful but you have to pick and choose rather
00:32:32 than just turn on the television and hope to find something good well uh we've we've now got this
00:32:37 channel that you can watch so charles thank you very very much for joining us uh today thank you
00:32:44 for that um that's it for counterculture this week we shall see you next week so please do subscribe
00:32:50 Thank you.
00:32:51 Bye.