New Culture Forum - June 14, 2020


BLM Protests: From Historic Statues To Television; Is Britain In A Full-Blown Culture War?

Is BBC Bias Getting Worse? Is the BBC still a force for good or too biased now to serve the nation? Andrew Roberts - Winston Churchill, BLM, The Far Left And Britain's Culture War

Episode Stats


Length

48 minutes

Words per minute

179.94

Word count

8,706

Sentence count

162


Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
00:00:00 hello and welcome to counterculture I'm Peter Whittle now over the past few weeks we seem to
00:00:15 have gone a very very far distance in a very short space of time from the death of George
00:00:22 Floyd in Minneapolis right through to statues being toppled and TV shows
00:00:28 cancelled. No wonder many people seem extremely bewildered and indeed angry
00:00:34 and indeed there seems to have been absolutely no pushback from any quarter.
00:00:38 So what exactly is going on? With me to discuss this I'm very pleased to say we
00:00:44 have Claire Fox who is a director of the Academy of Ideas and of course a former
00:00:49 Brexit Party MEP, Emma Webb from the Civitas Think Tank, and the New Culture Forums, Rafe
00:00:57 Hadelman Koo, historian and commentator. I want to start with you, if I may, Emma. On
00:01:06 my way here today, as we've seen in all the pictures, the statue of Winston Churchill
00:01:12 was completely boarded over. What are your sort of feelings when you see that?
00:01:19 I think it's a symbol of extraordinary failure.
00:01:23 The fact that the police have shown themselves to be incapable of defending our monuments.
00:01:29 I was actually there when they defaced the statue on Sunday and stood next to the police whilst they sort of haplessly looked on,
00:01:37 while people were chanting awful, vulgar things and spray painting churches of racist on the statue.
00:01:44 and as well I think in the end they'd also um the Antifa symbol had also been spray painted
00:01:50 on the side of it I think what it shows is that not only the police I think the police officers
00:01:56 themselves so many of them were injured that they've actually been failed by the leadership
00:02:00 by Crest Dick and also by the statement that Neil Basu put out as well um over the last couple of
00:02:08 days and and just generally the leadership from the government has been so weak that now we have
00:02:14 No talk of the influence of the far left hijacking these protests, but the people who are actually coming out to protect our monuments are being described by the mayor of London as being far right, when all he has done is legitimise the iconoclasm and the criminal damage that's been taking place.
00:02:32 Not just on monuments that are connected to slavery, but people like Robert Peel, who founded the police force and actually are responsible for us having community policing and disarmed police.
00:02:46 So I think it's outrageous and a lot of people are going to be very, very angry to see that.
00:02:51 Cleo, do you see a sense of failure there too, like Emma?
00:02:55 well i mean it does appear to have um given what the people who want the statues you moved
00:03:04 given them what they want because you now can't see them i mean you know covering up pulling them
00:03:08 down and so on i think that emma's right although i i i i actually think that the police themselves
00:03:16 i mean leadership you might say but nonetheless there has been a a fair degree of collusion and
00:03:24 agreement by senior police chiefs about uh standing by and letting this happen as we saw from the
00:03:31 interview with uh the uh the head of somerset and avon police essex police have come out and so on
00:03:37 which is that there is a sense in which they believe that there's something righteous about
00:03:43 what's happening on these demonstrations i don't think it's even that they're fearful
00:03:47 i mean if they are fearful that's problematic but you know sometimes it's presented as though it's
00:03:52 the yobbery of the protesters whereas actually I do think that if you abdicate responsibility
00:04:00 and let people I mean almost in a way it's like a kind of incitement you know if you kind of stand
00:04:06 back and say well you know what can we do then it actually encourages people potentially to do
00:04:13 things that they wouldn't have done I mean it's got a kind of endorsement aside to it and I think
00:04:18 that we've generally seen as Peter you indicated in your introduction that this is not about you
00:04:24 know this is kicking an open door so many institutions from the top have been prepared
00:04:31 to metaphorically take the knee and this has become far removed from what was a completely
00:04:38 legitimate and genuine outrage at the brutal police killing of a black man in America and then
00:04:47 people wanting to show solidarity maybe saying that there are issues of racism in the UK they
00:04:54 want to do take on but but but at this point we've we've almost become far so far removed from that
00:05:02 that it does a great disservice to anti-racism that this is the censorious outcome with an
00:05:08 institutional leadership that's you know on its knees sadly. Yes Rafe Emma alluded there to Neil
00:05:17 Basu and what he said I mean are you familiar with what what when he came out and basically said
00:05:23 you know that we're institutionally racist this this was he used in the Met Police account actually
00:05:29 to make this announcement and you know it was I think quite extraordinary coming from a chief
00:05:36 of police would you you're obviously very involved in statues actually in a way aren't you
00:05:44 and commemoration um you know do you sort of see this as a cultural sort that's exactly what it is
00:05:51 and far from having a state that's institutionally racist what we have is a situation where you have
00:05:55 an institutional acquiescence in that cultural onslaught and that can't be stressed too highly
00:06:01 enough now i've been a member of the international churchill society since the age of 14 and served
00:06:06 on its board of directors so for me churchill someone who's of polish and seek indian ancestry
00:06:10 Churchill has always been a great inspiration to me and I've had no qualms at all coming to terms
00:06:15 with what were views held by any contemporary Victorian of that era. But what we're basically
00:06:21 seeing from the police are statements that Britain is a racist country when we know full well from
00:06:26 every global survey that's been done in terms of racial tolerance, in terms of who the average
00:06:31 person would have living next to them, Britain and those former British colonies, Canada, Australia
00:06:36 and New Zealand are among the least racist countries in the world far more tolerant than
00:06:41 you'll see on the continent of Europe for example along with Latin America another racially diverse
00:06:45 region of the world those are the two most racially tolerant parts of the planet and yet
00:06:50 here we are trying to be trying to be sold this line that we are living in a racist country
00:06:55 which simply holds no water whatsoever but what we are seeing really is an attempt to supplant
00:07:01 British identity and British culture we've gone from the general erosion of British identity
00:07:05 through the long marcher institutions to this direct onslaught and you know i've seen this
00:07:10 before you know my own family the the oldest civic statue in in Lviv in the former Poland
00:07:15 now Ukraine was of my ancestor who commanded the cavalry at the siege of Vienna and stopped the
00:07:20 Turks advancing at the gates of Vienna into Europe that was demolished by the Soviets in 1945 why
00:07:25 because they wanted to supplant the existing culture with a new ideology and we're seeing
00:07:30 something that's not dissimilar now.
00:07:34 This is the point, really, isn't it, Claire and Emma?
00:07:37 I mean, that, as Rave just said there,
00:07:40 if you see it or if you think it is a cultural onslaught,
00:07:43 which I think, for me, it seemed undoubtedly that it is,
00:07:46 it is the speed which I think has bewildered people.
00:07:51 I don't know, can you comment on that, Emma?
00:07:53 I mean, it seems that suddenly here we are
00:07:55 at a time where, for example, HBO are pulling this programme,
00:08:00 You know, the BBC are pulling that one.
00:08:03 OK, it's statues now, but I mean, you know, how, you know, this is this is extraordinary.
00:08:08 How do you think it has been the case?
00:08:11 Why has it been the case that it has been so quick?
00:08:17 That what Rafe is describing there, what we're definitely seeing is a sort of authoritarian cultural revolutionary impulse that wants to.
00:08:26 So it isn't intended to particularly target necessarily racists or slave owners.
00:08:34 The statue of Robert the Bruce was was graffitied and he died in the 1300s.
00:08:40 So I think that what we're actually seeing and this goes back to the point about the police and Neil Basu and the sort of institutional licensing of what's happening is that in local authorities, not all of them.
00:08:55 um and within certain institutions and um certain positions of people who are in positions of
00:09:00 authority there is an assumed neutrality about something that is very very ideological
00:09:08 um and the the assumption is that this kind of imagined consensus even though there are quite
00:09:14 clearly lots of people who are against this and are opposed to and feel very angry very helpless
00:09:18 to see their heritage being attacked in this way i think the the speed of it is definitely something
00:09:23 that is clearly very worrying um and people will have a lot of questions about how it was possible
00:09:30 for the mayor of london to turn around this orwellian named um commission in such a short
00:09:37 period of time um i think that it's partly because the the path had already been laid in a sense
00:09:43 because people the the institutions had already absorbed and accepted this idea of systemic racism
00:09:50 which is a very different idea to discrete acts of racism it's not part of the civil rights
00:09:56 tradition it's very different from the sort of things that people march for with martin luther
00:10:00 king in systemic racism the ideologues and and academics behind the literature that has
00:10:08 influenced this movement people like robin d'angelo believe that every aspect of our society
00:10:13 our history our culture um and every white person in the west is complicit in systemic racism so
00:10:22 there is literally nothing that is off the table when it comes to the things that they might try
00:10:27 to attack next the the remit will just get larger and larger and larger and it started with statues
00:10:32 connected with slavery we've already seen it moving into other areas of cultural life like
00:10:37 television programmes, even Anton Deck have been done in by this. So I think that the issue is
00:10:44 that it's assumed that this very ideological movement is actually, and it is very much
00:10:53 enthused with ideas that we should be able to disagree with, but it's become very, very high
00:10:58 cost to stand out against them because people don't want to be seen as pro-slavery, even if
00:11:02 they're defending the statues sort of on principle um yeah claire if you talk about ideology i think
00:11:11 this is one of the at the moment you know there is the slogan isn't there black lives matter
00:11:15 but there is also the organization black lives matter and i i wonder how many people know what
00:11:23 the aims of that organization are i mean i think that isn't it the case you think that people are
00:11:28 sort of clambering to support the slogan, but actually pretty ignorant, maybe, of what
00:11:34 the organisation says.
00:11:37 Well, that might be true, but I think that there's a danger here of over-flattering the
00:11:43 importance of the organisation with its particularly, you know, as it happens, completely incoherent
00:11:51 combination of revolutionary sounding slogans with kind of management woke speak, if you
00:11:58 kind of read it it's kind of got all the kind of diversity buzzwords and then you know occasionally
00:12:02 you'll say abolish the police you know let's have a revolution it's a kind of very odd mix
00:12:06 anyone who's ever been serious about revolutionary politics which i have been
00:12:10 will know that this wouldn't pass muster at the you know first year seminar never mind anywhere
00:12:15 else but you see what happens is and i know that um you know there's a kind of trend to say these
00:12:22 people and in fact it's just been said you know these people are kind of ideologically marching
00:12:26 through the institutions whereas I see this as an institutional collapse you know there is no reason
00:12:33 why this particular institution this particular organization needs to have these things have
00:12:39 happened often preemptively you know one demonstration in Bristol which I think was
00:12:44 pretty spontaneous and got out of hand the police standing by and watching it and so on then as
00:12:51 has been indicated you know the next minute faulty towers goes you know and it the whole thing loses
00:12:56 any sense of coherence i think that's important because you have to know who you're going to as
00:13:03 it were aim your your fire and eye rat and know who you need to talk to what what the kind of
00:13:11 discussion is because i my my greatest concern here is is that we end up in a situation where
00:13:17 we kind of appear to have, you know, a kind of imagined enemy of Black Lives Matter's
00:13:22 organised ideologues on the streets versus, you know, Tommy Robinson's army of thugs on
00:13:29 the other side being called down to them to defend statues. Whereas actually, the speed
00:13:35 with which this has happened is that it hasn't happened quickly, so much as it's been happening
00:13:42 slowly for the last 10 12 years you know you had me on peter to discuss my book which is all about
00:13:48 exactly these themes four years ago and also i i said then you know the students aren't the problem
00:13:56 it's the academics it's the institutions that that almost use the student activists as you know to
00:14:04 ventriloquize their their ideas you know something is rotten at the heart there that's that's very
00:14:10 worrying so I just think it's dangerous to over imagine because it ends up with a kind of
00:14:16 conspiracy theory and people will have read these you know that Black Lives Matters have
00:14:20 got in their nooks and crannies I mean most of the angry young teenagers from Tottenham that
00:14:27 were down at the demo on the first week you know a stunning round has bemused as anyone else right
00:14:32 I mean they what I mean they're not kind of schooled in this stuff they're not they're not
00:14:37 familiar with the uh critical race theories that that kind of lie behind some of this stuff so
00:14:43 let's be cautious about where we kind of as it were uh lay the blame i think i agree with that
00:14:49 and i was good sorry can rave come in first sorry yeah and i was and as i said in my earlier comment
00:14:55 we've gone from a from a gradual erosion over the years to now this full-scale onslaught and that's
00:15:00 because you know the ground's been set for this conflict and we've known for a long time about
00:15:05 the balance that has been shifted in universities where it went from a two to one balance of two
00:15:09 liberals for every conservative academic to one now where it's nine to ten left far left compared
00:15:14 to everyone conservative in the humanities in in in in Britain and in Canada for example
00:15:19 and the problem there I think really quite clearly is that no one is actually coming to terms with
00:15:24 the fact that the next 10 years are really what counts because we have a crisis of age in this
00:15:30 in this country where the divide is so much upon age grounds that if we don't take it in any steps
00:15:35 at the current time to to really address this issue we're going to see no end to this sort of
00:15:41 iconoclasm in the future and there was this great hope that with dominic cummings and boris johnson
00:15:45 there'd be some effort to reverse the bias that exists within institutions in this country
00:15:50 yet coronavirus came out of nowhere and seems to have have sunk all chances of that happening
00:15:55 I think it seems to me that obviously the coronavirus has been pretty much sort of like
00:16:01 wiped off the headlines for a while. There's no question about that. But I think that what
00:16:09 you were alluding to there, what you were alluding to there about the softness, which
00:16:12 of course, you know, we've talked about on this programme many times. There's been, if
00:16:17 you like, a long march, I would say. If you look at the way that the media is treating
00:16:22 this now um two aspects here on the one hand it seems i wonder whether you agree with me that
00:16:28 people are clambering on to sort of make a gesture because the price of not doing so is just too high
00:16:34 now right and similarly there are worrying things within the media so for example in america you
00:16:40 might have seen uh editors of newspapers not least the new york times have actually been uh
00:16:46 forced to resign because they you know they let commission certain pieces as you should do with
00:16:53 an opinion as an opinion editor um but they've actually had to you know they've been censored
00:16:58 or lost their jobs it seems that the media is is pretty much you know sort of as one on this
00:17:05 would you not say you not say emma i i agree completely firstly with everything that claire
00:17:11 just said um and i think like you say that the i think the issue is that the the the use of language
00:17:18 and and the ideology that has a background in some of these particular academic circles
00:17:24 has seeped into common use in particular in in institutions within the civil service within the
00:17:32 police and like you're saying in especially within the media there is this sort of censorious streak
00:17:40 um where it's and we saw the same thing um with a guy who worked for a radio channel manx radio
00:17:49 channel yeah who also um got fired for and we've seen also nigel farage stepping down from um his
00:17:56 his show at lbc after he compared um the what quite clearly is a fair comparison in terms of
00:18:03 iconoclasm to the sorts of things you see in extremist movements like in with the taliban
00:18:08 Islamic State, the French Revolution, the Reformation. These are just things that are
00:18:13 quite typical of revolutions and cultural revolutions, especially, and activists themselves
00:18:17 have used the term cultural revolution. So it doesn't seem that there should be a problem in
00:18:21 referring to it as that. I think that it's, as Claire said, it's something that has been going
00:18:26 on for a very, very long time. And actually, it may have just sort of erupted now, but the groundwork
00:18:32 had already been laid for it. And so I think that the thing that really worries me is that
00:18:38 It's not possible to actually have a proper, reasonable, honest conversation publicly on mainstream platforms about this, because the cost is if people see people being fired for raising concerns, people who have used the hashtag All Lives Matter being and ending up losing their careers over this, then people are going to feel that they can't speak out.
00:19:05 And that's a very, very dangerous situation because it means that what's happening right now could escalate very quickly and without sort of scaremongering.
00:19:14 There is only a very small step from attacking physical objects with that much fire to actually becoming physically violent and having clashes between different communities and raising the tension between those communities.
00:19:31 So I think that the censorious tendency in this is the thing that is really most worrying.
00:19:37 Yeah. Claire, can I just ask you, just on a more specific point, how do you account for Boris Johnson's near total absence on this?
00:19:50 I mean, today, this morning, just before we came on air, he did actually put a statement out by Twitter.
00:19:55 but frankly people are perplexed utterly that a prime minister who's always actually prided
00:20:03 himself on his sweep of history and indeed was a biographer churchill as it happens you know
00:20:08 has been almost entirely absent you know why is it that our politicians do not feel that they can
00:20:15 speak out on what are obviously cultural issues because the french do so it's um one thing you
00:20:24 you mentioned the coronavirus issue having gone but one of the things that i was going to say was
00:20:30 that i actually think the lockdown partly explains the intensity and speed with which this has
00:20:36 happened because i do think there was a kind of you know almost like a kind of cauldron of kind
00:20:44 of pent-up energy infrastructure which a lot of us feel over a lot of things and and and this kind
00:20:49 of became a lightning rod you know a very real genuine terrible thing happens then there's
00:20:54 demonstrations all over the place and and you know it's almost like sort of like you know
00:21:00 all the kind of you know fears and frustrations and worries about you know mass unemployment and
00:21:07 prospects being in decline and so on kind of exploded onto the public scene so I think it's
00:21:12 had an impact on that but I also think let's be honest it's completely disorientated the government
00:21:18 and they don't actually know how to relate to the public at the moment because they've sent us home
00:21:23 and atomized us there's no public square in a way they don't really know who who they're talking to
00:21:30 or how to talk to people because everything's become a bit distorted you know we're not even
00:21:35 talking to each other we've only just been allowed to visit each other's homes you know so we're all
00:21:40 kind of very living our lives peculiarly via press conferences at five o'clock and social media
00:21:47 by the way of course I understand that millions of people are going to work I mean I do know that
00:21:52 but we have been effectively demobilized as a public and I do think that's not helped the
00:22:00 political class to know how to relate to people they're just not they're not even seeing people
00:22:06 they're kind of getting letters but there's no sort of like they can't just wander through the
00:22:09 town have a chat with people because that's not what you're allowed to do and there's no one in
00:22:13 the town so that's one thing that the the thing that's yeah so i mean i mean how there's also the
00:22:20 potential question of cowardice by the way which is in the middle of it all i mean if
00:22:23 if you're going to say it's going to be hard i mean i i like you have been incredibly
00:22:29 concerned about this slightly new although not that new but but a recent turn in media circles
00:22:37 which is to try and get seen people sacked your colleagues sacked a lot of the sackings have
00:22:44 actually come from within that's what happened in the new york times but i've watched it happen
00:22:48 on social media here of people calling upon other times journalists try and uh you know
00:22:55 get the editors of the the editor of the times to sack uh you know melanie phillis i'm bet i'm
00:23:01 frightened to say it in case it makes it worse we know what i mean um actually it appears that
00:23:06 there was an element of that in the LBC decision in relation to Nigel Farage certainly there's been
00:23:11 this you know we as staff at LBC have had to put up with this for far too long we didn't ever want
00:23:17 him in it's like a kind of I mean first of all it doesn't indicate much in the way of solidarity I
00:23:21 don't care whether you like someone or not especially on a talk radio program where people
00:23:26 are often employed because they've got controversial views I mean and to have a diversity of views
00:23:30 But there's something of that McCarthy atmosphere that is frightening. And you can see that people are nervous. I mean, I'll be honest, I am nervous about being on this. You know, this will be clipped. This can go out. It's not straightforward. Who is going to be cancelled next? Or what for? It's not, you know, it's no longer sufficient to say, but I'm an anti-racist.
00:23:59 I mean, that's not going to wash, right?
00:24:01 I'm a white woman and I can be cast in the shadow of a far right and so on.
00:24:08 But just just sorry, just one one small thing.
00:24:11 One of the things I'm worried about is the demonization of all sides.
00:24:14 And one of the most galling things that I've found from the government is they've on the one hand absented themselves.
00:24:21 And not just involve themselves in a proper discussion about cultural icons.
00:24:26 And, you know, I mean, I don't I don't think that necessarily I want every statue to be there forever and I would never imagine a statue ever going.
00:24:33 But, you know, that's a debate. It's a discussion. You could have that discussion. And that's the kind of thing that you can do.
00:24:39 They haven't done that. But when they're trying to look like they're asserting authority, they then have become quite authoritarian.
00:24:48 So they say, you know, there's going to be summary justice. Everyone's going to be in prison after 24 hours. Right.
00:24:54 which is a bit nerve-wracking you know although we're going to help you that's the protesters
00:24:59 they that you know the police stand by and let people uh you know jump all over the statue and
00:25:05 bash it and drag it through streets and throw it in the river and this kind of absolute frenzy
00:25:11 kind of watch on and then so we're proud of the day's work we did in bristol but then the next
00:25:17 minute you've got um priti patel saying we're going to round up the perpetrators and they're
00:25:22 going to be shown no mercy and my concern here is that you end up demonizing young protesters
00:25:29 often young black protesters as they're all part of some thug gang over there and what i you know
00:25:38 and and the conversely as we know sadik khan anyone who comes to london to want to protect
00:25:43 the statue is inevitably only coming because they're a fascist supporter of tommy robinson
00:25:49 misusing the term fascism but you know everyone's kind of and actually lots of people seem to want
00:25:56 to come to London um on Saturday because they want to show that they don't want that there's a
00:26:02 there's a vacuum at the heart of it all and I'm worried about both sides being demonized and
00:26:07 somebody like Tommy Robinson god I wish I'd said his name so often but he's actually again been
00:26:13 overflattered as the catalyst of people coming to london tomorrow he is not the catalyst he's an
00:26:20 opportunistic you know person who doesn't give it down as far as i can see who's jumped on this
00:26:27 but can take credit because nobody else will take a lead and that does frighten me because it does
00:26:33 then pit people against each other in a very extreme and polarized fashion that's unhelpful
00:26:40 And the silence of Boris Johnson and of the government
00:26:43 and of the cowardice which is really emanating itself through our media too
00:26:48 really basically plays into the hands of the Black Lives Matter coordinators
00:26:53 and Antifa who are basically engaging in all tactics
00:26:56 of using the mob to test how far they can push this
00:26:59 and when you're seeing no defence made by Boris Johnson
00:27:03 who really should be the person of the hour
00:27:05 he wants to put himself as a Churchillian patriotic figure
00:27:08 And yet nowhere are we seeing any great celebration of the fact that it was Britain that ended the slave trade, for example, that it was the Royal Navy that enforced the end to slavery, including having the right to occupy and seize American ships, for example.
00:27:21 And, you know, indeed defending the right that, you know, to use Howard Macmillan, you've never had it so good if you're black.
00:27:28 There's nowhere in the world you really want to be apart from being somewhere like Britain.
00:27:31 And nowhere are you seeing this great defense and promotion of basically of what Britain has managed to achieve in this country.
00:27:37 I want to sort of just go on a bit, actually. With this situation, which seems to be sort
00:27:44 of spreading out, where in fact do you think it could go? Where are we actually going to
00:27:50 go from here? I mean, to take one example, how I've been viewing it, Baden-Powell is
00:27:58 sort of under attack. We're not quite sure whether his statue is going to go or not.
00:28:03 it seems to be a bit confusing but isn't it to use the logic of this movement wouldn't it be oh
00:28:09 well actually you could see oh well actually the scouting movement itself was born in a time of
00:28:14 imperialism etc etc so actually pretty much why do we have scouts now you know we're in a sort of
00:28:20 you know maybe we're in a kind of revisionist period this is where I see it sort of going
00:28:25 and it goes on to books where do you actually where do you see it going Emma? Well so I think
00:28:31 that um this goes back to what we were saying about the also about tv programs and and people
00:28:38 being sort of witch hunted by their own colleagues that what we're doing with historical figures is
00:28:44 what has been described as a fence archaeology trying to find problematic things in particular
00:28:49 historical figures and history is messy no person is either good or completely definitively evil
00:28:55 um people have done bad things they've done good things as well you can criticize nelson but you
00:29:00 know, he still was a naval genius. You can criticise Gordon Powell for his opinions about
00:29:06 certain things, but the Scout movement is certainly a good thing, which should be celebrated.
00:29:10 And we shouldn't deny the fact that he was involved in its founding. And I think the
00:29:13 problem is that once you start doing this, there actually isn't an end goal. What do
00:29:18 you do? Are you going to pull down the pyramids and demolish the whole of Greenwich? Are we
00:29:22 going to demolish entire cities that were built off of the money that came from slavery?
00:29:29 One good example of this, I think, is Thomas Guy.
00:29:33 They're taking his statue down.
00:29:35 In fact, they boarded it up today outside of Guy's hospital.
00:29:39 Yeah, so are they going to rename the hospital?
00:29:42 Are they going to tear down the hospital?
00:29:43 That's a revisionism and an erasure of history.
00:29:47 And just to speak about Thomas Guy specifically, he invested in the South Sea Company that
00:29:53 was involved in the trafficking of slaves.
00:29:57 but he was an investor in all sorts of different companies he was a bookseller
00:30:01 and he made an awful lot of money but then if you look at any wealthy figure
00:30:04 in that period of time slavery was part of the economy so it's
00:30:08 gonna be very difficult to detach anybody that built anything
00:30:10 from the 16th century to the to the 18th century
00:30:13 who wasn't involved in something that today we would call problematic
00:30:17 we can't just erase the 16th to 18th century of british history
00:30:21 because there are some things that certain people did that we don't like
00:30:24 And now we see them attacking people like Robert Bruce, we see them attacking statues of Queen Victoria. And all of these people have very complicated histories. And I think what's very concerning is that you have people like the deputy mayor, who is the co-chair of this commission that Sadiq Khan has set up, celebrating Milligan's statue being taken down from outside of the Docklands Museum.
00:30:51 so she's the co-chair of this commission and she's celebrating the fact that it was removed
00:30:56 with what looks like very little due process or debate even though some people may have objected
00:31:00 to it he was outside of a museum um he could have been easily contextualized before information
00:31:06 so i think what we actually need is more history in the public space not less what we're doing by
00:31:11 removing statues is just removing our sense of historical perspective or our ability to
00:31:18 meet our history in the streets which i think is something very fundamental that no generation
00:31:23 individual commission politician has the right to remove those things from our memory in our
00:31:30 physical space and i think that's something that's very very worrying and i actually think for a lack
00:31:35 of historical perspective as what has resulted in this in the first place because people aren't
00:31:40 properly educated about complexity of history and people have this idea that people are either
00:31:45 diabolical or saintly and speaking of saints actually um saint boniface's statue was defaced
00:31:51 in greenwich with antichristian graffiti um they're actually defacing saints it seems now
00:31:57 i don't know whether or not that was related but there's some suggestion that it was to do with
00:32:01 anarchists so i think that that that searching for things that are problematic in historical figures
00:32:07 will literally lead to the destruction of potential destruction of absolutely anything
00:32:11 and everything that people find a little bit distasteful and one has to ask what value is
00:32:17 there in in destroying and pulling down such statues in terms of black lives how many black
00:32:22 lives are actually going to be saved through this process certainly if black lives matter why are
00:32:27 there no howls of protest over the number of black on black killings in south london where are the
00:32:31 great marches and protests there you know in america in the last 40 years over 90 percent of
00:32:36 black african americans who've died have died at the hands of other african americans now it's fine
00:32:40 to protest on this issue if there's some consistency and if black lives do matter why is there no
00:32:45 similar howl of outrage at that that that decimation of the black population or indeed
00:32:50 modern slavery i mean this is another issue that no one seems to address is the fact that
00:32:54 there are 12 to 15 million africans who were transported to america in the slave trade and
00:33:00 yet there are approximately 40 million slaves alive today in the world and seven in every
00:33:05 thousand africans are believed to be in slavery currently so where are the great protests outside
00:33:09 the Nigerian embassy or the embassy of Congo. Nowhere are they to be seen. You have Sadiq Khan
00:33:15 declaring last year that he was in favour of a slavery museum in Britain and that Britain had
00:33:19 to live up to it, had to stand up and recognise its role in the slave trade. And yet, you know,
00:33:23 he would have repetitive strain injury from saying that he was the son of a Pakistani bus driver.
00:33:27 And yet, even when he made an official visit to Pakistan, not once has he ever actually called
00:33:32 Pakistan out for being one of the worst countries in the world for modern-day slavery, where there
00:33:36 are over three million people living in slavery in modern-day Pakistan and surely it's the lives
00:33:41 of people today that count for a lot more when they can actually be freed and the yoke can be
00:33:46 removed from them rather than revisiting questionable people from the past most of
00:33:51 whom no one's ever heard of you know I'm a historian I don't really know much about Coulson
00:33:54 at all you know most people don't and yet they're being whipped up by the by this organization and
00:33:59 so one has to question the motives of an organization called Black Lives Matter when
00:34:03 they seem to be more interested in stone than actual lives. Claire, where do you see it going?
00:34:10 Yeah, so not positively, but there's so much still untangled. But I think that point about
00:34:19 what about today's contemporary issues is right. I think one of the issues here is that Black Lives
00:34:24 Matter is a bit of a kind of free-floating amorphous hashtag. That's why I was trying
00:34:31 to say don't overthink it's an ideology it's not quite as simple as that and actually if you
00:34:36 actually ask activists you know what is it directly that you want you know it'll be things
00:34:42 like you have to have a black square on your instagram you know it's like what's that got to
00:34:46 do with them you know what i mean you've got to you know you as a uh you know what white people
00:34:51 have got to admit their complicity uh you know it's not always concrete i mean in america there's
00:34:55 kind of demand to defund the police but nobody seems to even understand what that means in the
00:35:00 UK's terms because it's not clear what you know there it's kind of what is it you're demanding
00:35:06 right and for me I was horrified by the scandal around Windrush and I'd actually there was one
00:35:14 Black Lives Matters demonstration during the week which actually was a Windrush demo which was
00:35:18 perfectly legit to me I mean it seems to me the British state made an absolute disastrous error
00:35:24 at the expense of British citizens who didn't do the filing of their paperwork okay and then were
00:35:30 treated like you know at the worst possible way i that would make me go out on a demo right
00:35:35 that's infuriatingly terrible but that's not actually the focus it's the statues you know
00:35:42 it's these kind of so in in other words what's interesting to me is that black lives matters
00:35:47 doesn't appear to have a a sense of what it stands for or what it wants positively as it were what
00:35:53 what do you want and the museum's question is fascinating you know because i think owen jones
00:35:59 got an article in the Guardian he says this is a massive history lesson for the for the the nation
00:36:04 we can all learn something and you think well why don't you write a book well why doesn't you read
00:36:07 a book you know I mean you don't have to go around taking down statues in order to have a sense of
00:36:11 history but um if you when people say well we should contextualize them and put them into museums
00:36:18 it means they haven't been paying attention to what's happening in museums because museums are
00:36:22 now run by people who hate historical artifacts and they're spending the whole time sending them
00:36:26 back, hiding them, putting up plaques. I mean, you know, I mean, you wouldn't you wouldn't last
00:36:32 any longer in a museum than you would on a plinth at the moment. So it's almost that's why I'm saying
00:36:36 it's a kind of cultural crisis. I'm not a great fan of British exceptionalism. You know, Britain
00:36:45 led the way on fighting injustice. I mean, Britain was an imperialist colonial power with blood all
00:36:50 over its hands. But I'm not. But, you know, that was the past. And you have to, if you're involved
00:36:55 in politics believe that things can improve right i happen to think that things have improved
00:37:00 from attitudes on race from the 19th century actually they've improved in my lifetime in
00:37:08 terms of attitudes on race since the 1970s 1980s where actually people were you know not just people
00:37:15 but the police actually were much more explicitly uh openly uh racially harassed young black people
00:37:22 in in areas where i lived and the reason i'm saying that is because i absolutely agree that
00:37:28 history is complicated so what we don't want to do is emulate the worst aspects of something like
00:37:35 the black lives matters or the the race theory simplifying of history that he is a slave owner
00:37:41 he is bad by having a we are britain we are great you know that doesn't make i mean it's it's like
00:37:47 the people who sort of say what about the engels statue in manchester then he's got he's a bad
00:37:51 person he's a communist pull that down it's like we don't want anyone pulling anything down yeah
00:37:56 don't want to have a competition between oversimplifying narratives on history or which
00:38:02 people should be uh dumped in the river where will it end funnily enough i this is just where you
00:38:08 just know it's got nothing to do with history um first of all a school has renamed uh rowling house
00:38:16 because jk rowling as in so this is now suddenly not black lives matters it's to do with the trans
00:38:22 wars and the turf wars as they're called and a school has renamed a house because they can't
00:38:28 have a house called jk rowling i mentioned that because we got i got sent a couple of emails from
00:38:35 different schools in london who are as we speak asking the sixth form to rename their houses
00:38:42 around you know drake house is going to go in wherever that is you know asking students saying
00:38:48 we feel uncomfortable with the names of the houses now by time we've had that debate what this has
00:38:54 just happened is that every institution will rename everything and it will become completely
00:38:59 meaningless and lose any sense of you nobody will remember why we're renaming them and there'll be
00:39:07 lots of rows over whether that's an appropriate name and every time you name somebody something
00:39:13 somebody will find out something bad about the person you renamed them all after and then we'll
00:39:17 have to rename it again so this can run and run and run but let that run and run and run
00:39:23 much more important is how we get debate about the superficiality of this right at the center
00:39:29 of politics and don't allow anyone to tell us it's just a trivial silly campus childish game
00:39:36 which is what people have been telling us when we've tried to warn this was happening.
00:39:39 People have just said to me, oh, it's students being students, what's your problem?
00:39:43 Well, this is my problem.
00:39:45 I think, I mean, where I would have to disagree with you on that point,
00:39:49 when you say we shouldn't sort of like start taking caricature positions.
00:39:53 I find it, I don't really think people are seriously kind of calling out, you know,
00:39:57 Britain is the absolute best and all that.
00:40:00 If anything, I think the whole, you know, narrative of the way British history has been treated
00:40:04 over the past 40, 50 years,
00:40:06 is to actually be very, you know, self-loathing, actually,
00:40:11 and, you know, basically quite derogatory.
00:40:13 I mean, I don't really see that there's been a huge jingoism.
00:40:17 And that's where...
00:40:18 I just mean people on our side, Peter.
00:40:20 I mean, people who I know are worried about this
00:40:23 can try and bend the stick too far.
00:40:25 That's all I'm saying.
00:40:26 Yeah, yeah.
00:40:27 And where this will end, I mean,
00:40:28 we'll get back again to the march through institutions,
00:40:30 because, you know, I live near the American embassy,
00:40:32 so I've seen each one of those marches pass by my balcony
00:40:35 and comparing it to the civil rights movement in America in the 60s
00:40:39 the key difference is the age of the participants
00:40:41 where the age of those participating today is really under 35
00:40:45 and of course you have to wonder
00:40:47 who is educating the next generation of museum curators
00:40:50 the next generation of people in the police force
00:40:53 and in government and in academia
00:40:55 it is people on the left who have these agendas to put forward
00:40:59 and that's why I don't think we're going to see
00:41:01 an end to this coming any time soon.
00:41:03 You know, you look at people like Neil Ferguson,
00:41:05 one of the great historians of our time,
00:41:06 unable to get a tenured position in a British university
00:41:09 because of having very balanced views on empire.
00:41:12 But there needs to be, at this time, more than any other,
00:41:14 someone to stand up.
00:41:15 And I take Clare's point that no country is free from sin at all.
00:41:19 Of course not.
00:41:19 But it was the case that Britain was the country
00:41:21 that led the world in abolishing slavery.
00:41:24 It was the Royal Navy that enforced that policy,
00:41:27 including the right to seize foreign ships
00:41:30 if they had slaves on them it was the case that it was africans who enslaved other africans white
00:41:35 people never actually made any incursions into the continent of africa they were moored off the coast
00:41:40 and took prisoners of war and there were there were as many slaves held by other africans as
00:41:45 there were being transported across you know the islam was engaged in the slave trade for centuries
00:41:49 that only ended officially in 1900 and continued continued long after that where are the people
00:41:54 raising those points and if you put it into that context and actually britain and europe
00:41:59 come out very, very well, in my view.
00:42:02 I think what we could end up, we were talking about where it could go,
00:42:04 I don't mean to be flippant here, but, you know,
00:42:06 obviously there are statues round and about of Wilberforce.
00:42:10 Perhaps he will be cancelled as being a white saviour, you know?
00:42:16 This is one of the narratives now, you know, that we don't need this
00:42:20 because this is now a woke thing, isn't it, of white saviour?
00:42:25 um just to round off therefore uh you wanted to say something emma there
00:42:29 uh yeah i just wanted to say that i think um actually on that point that um in the u.s they
00:42:37 actually did and part of this i think is to do with historical illiteracy so there were they
00:42:41 tried to remember there have been some disputes about the statues of robert peel that some people
00:42:45 want removing because actually they're confusing robert peel with his father who was anti-abolition
00:42:51 um and in the u.s they actually did deface a statue of an abolitionist and i think it's a
00:42:56 really important point going back to what claire said about the naming of schools houses that you'll
00:43:02 have it named something for one week and then someone will find something wrong with that person
00:43:05 and then it will just go on and on and on and on and it's because it's like the famous saying that
00:43:10 um like saturn revolution devours its own children um and i think that's what we're going to end up
00:43:16 with it was very metaphorical that um you know the french in the french revolution they began
00:43:21 by decapitating statues and ended up by decapitating each other between the revolutionaries, with
00:43:26 Robespierre ending up being bought by it. And I think it's quite metaphorical that you saw the
00:43:34 statue that fell on a protester in the US when they were trying to pull down one of the statues
00:43:41 and actually fell and very badly injured one of the protesters. And it just leaves you thinking,
00:43:46 who is going to be the woke Pierre um who is going to be the you know the the person who ends
00:43:54 up sort of almost like um we had with um with uh certain people who have spoken out about
00:44:01 Islamophobia then ending up being attached to Islamophobia who is the most woke person that
00:44:06 you can think of right now that eventually is going to be the person who gets it exactly I mean
00:44:11 we've seen that in the trans debate of course haven't you we've had people like Jermaine Greer
00:44:14 and even Peter Tatchell and others in terms of Islam and so forth
00:44:18 now being basically cannibalised by their own.
00:44:21 And unfortunately, there is going to be no end to this.
00:44:24 But of course, historical and cultural relativism is never a good idea.
00:44:29 Rather than tear down statues, why not actually propose new statues,
00:44:32 propose new heroes, because we're always going to be re-evaluating and re-judging
00:44:36 and how better than to actually compare and contrast people from today and from the past.
00:44:41 I think that's a very good point, Ralph. Thank you.
00:44:44 Look, I have to end it there. Sorry, Claire, yes, please.
00:44:47 No, because what I was going to say was, I was, you know, I didn't agree with the whole summation that you made earlier about slavery, right, and the whole historical account of slavery and who ended it.
00:45:00 But what a rich conversation we could have about that.
00:45:03 You know, that is fine, you know, that history is always contested.
00:45:07 And in a way, those nuances, to go back to what you said, you know, this is a nuance, this is interesting.
00:45:14 This should be what we're having discussions about. Now, were I to imagine that in schools, the renaming of houses, I mean, when I went to school, we never had houses, I don't even know, but the renaming of whatever they all are, right, that that would lead to an open, rich, you know, challenging, lively series of debates about historical figures, then I wouldn't object.
00:45:38 But we all know that's not what's true. You know, because as soon as you try and raise a question about whether what happens in Bristol was correct, you're accused of being an, you know, an apologist for slavery. Like, don't be ridiculous. I mean, it's a low bar, isn't it? You know, am I a good virtuous person in 2020 because I condemn slavery and the slave trade?
00:46:00 well god you don't have to make very many moral moves to get there but you can obviously feel
00:46:05 very virtuous by saying but that what it means is we never have a decent discussion and i still go
00:46:10 back to the fact that you know that it wasn't just about george freud but who has remembered him in
00:46:16 this you know that guy that we watched on film that did spark genuine outrage even if if you know
00:46:25 it's been overly confected in a period of time and kind of gone off into different things but
00:46:32 honestly i think it's forgotten it gets forgotten and so what is most exasperating for me is that
00:46:38 these cultural this cultural regression actually uses the suffering of contemporary victims of
00:46:47 racism or police barbarism or whatever it is and adopts it and and and makes it their own
00:46:53 And then the next minute we know, and this is something that I would say as a lefty, because it's been said about the left, that every capitalist corporation has been at the forefront of adopting Black Lives Matter insignia, you know, going around policing the behaviour of their employees, making donations.
00:47:14 I mean absolutely hopeless and dangerous when your bosses are shouting at you if you don't
00:47:23 put a black square around your Instagram post which I know has happened in some corporations
00:47:29 that is going on as we speak so it just seems to me that poor old George Floyd has been
00:47:35 used by a whole range of different organisations and individuals for their own ends and it's
00:47:40 got nothing to do with fighting racism.
00:47:41 absolutely and i fear that those brands who are doing that are falling into the same trap that
00:47:46 you know media and everyone else fell for in terms of brexit as well in terms of misreading
00:47:51 what they think is the mood of the land and going with them with the voice of the vocal minority
00:47:55 rather than as you know gk chesterton for we are the people of england who have not spoken yet
00:47:59 and i fear that the bubbles in london and edinburgh and elsewhere are actually setting
00:48:04 the agenda here when the public as a whole are aghast of what they're seeing well thank you once
00:48:10 again and thank you Claire
00:48:12 Fox, thank you Emma
00:48:13 Webb, thank you Rafe
00:48:15 and that's it for Counter Culture
00:48:18 this week and
00:48:20 we will look forward to seeing you next time
00:48:22 thank you