New Culture Forum - June 19, 2020


Andrew Roberts - Winston Churchill, BLM, The Far Left And Britain's Culture War

BLM Protests: From Historic Statues To Television; Is Britain In A Full-Blown Culture War? What Impact Will The Covid-19 Crisis Have On The Green⧸Environmental Movements?

Episode Stats


Length

29 minutes

Words per minute

160.33

Word count

4,783

Sentence count

50


Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
00:00:00 Hello and welcome to So What You're Saying Is. I'm Peter Whittle. Now I'm delighted that this week
00:00:27 my guess is one of our most eminent historians. Andrew Roberts is the author of numerous books,
00:00:33 critically acclaimed books, including The Storm of War, which was about the Second World War,
00:00:40 and an award-winning biography too of Napoleon. His most recent book is this, Churchill. It came
00:00:48 out two years ago. This is now in paperback. It's been called the greatest single volume biography
00:00:55 of churchill ever written uh churchill obviously is in the news quite a lot at the moment um thank
00:01:02 you very much for joining us andrew thank you thank you very much indeed peter um andrew on
00:01:08 my way here today uh we're filming in westminster on my way here today i passed the statue uh in
00:01:15 parliament square of churchill it's still boarded up um i wondered what what are your feelings when
00:01:22 you see that oh well of course churchill would have hated it uh being boarded up he loved to be
00:01:30 in the uh in the center of the fray he loved to uh be amongst the give and take of uh politics and to
00:01:36 uh to be boarded up would be something that he would have hated um he would have also hated of
00:01:43 course the people who uh both vandalized his statue um from the extreme left and also then
00:01:51 gave Sieg Heil salutes to his statue on Sunday from the extreme right. He was always profoundly
00:01:58 opposed to those kind of people, imprisoned Sir Oswald Moseley, of course the British Union of
00:02:05 Fascist leader, and despised what they had to say. So I think when I see his boarded up statue,
00:02:13 of course I feel sad for the wider cultural malaise that both that and the boarding up of our cenotaph
00:02:21 our memorial to the war dead of the First and Second World Wars, makes me feel about this.
00:02:29 But it also makes me regret that we didn't have a proper police presence on the day that the statue was vandalised
00:02:40 in broad daylight, outside our legislature, in the centre of our capital city.
00:02:47 And also, it sort of is still boarded up, isn't it?
00:02:50 i mean you know that particular moment has passed it makes one wonder how long is this going to be
00:02:55 boarded up um i know that you wrote recently in the mail on sunday about this particular crisis
00:03:03 going on at the moment um and you talked actually about it being sort of part of a kind of culture
00:03:09 war which has sort of been brewing anyway that's how you see it oh certainly yes these attacks on
00:03:17 churchill have been uh continuing for some time um and you'll remember last year john mcdonald
00:03:24 calling churchill a villain which was a uh an outrageous remark i think to be made by the
00:03:33 deputy leader of the labor party and it goes back actually to various attacks spray paintings around
00:03:41 and so on that have been made against churchill as well as a wider and much more respectable
00:03:47 intellectual revisionist attack on churchill which uh of course is the right way to this
00:03:53 kind of thing you should deal with it in rational and reasoned debate rather than with spray cans
00:03:59 yes do you think uh i mean there is a danger now is there not that this will now in the media at
00:04:05 least forever be the controversial statue of churchill um i mean there is that problem and
00:04:12 you could say to an extent that is a step in the culture war isn't it when that happens
00:04:16 oh yes no no no the the uh it's a well-known um plan an organizational plan um in fact the
00:04:22 maoists came up with this in the 1960s the key thing is not to win the battle at the beginning
00:04:28 it is to get noticed and then to get support and this of course is all part of that. The BLM
00:04:37 movement has won a great victory as far as they're concerned in the great long-term struggle that they
00:04:44 want to alter British national identity. They come from the extreme left, the leaders of this
00:04:50 organisation, they are really impossible to attack because they've brilliantly, as ever with
00:04:57 communist organizations latched on to the um to the passion of the hour which is uh which is
00:05:04 anti-racism and they are riding it for all it's worth but don't for a moment think that that's
00:05:09 where it ends it certainly doesn't it doesn't end with statues about slavery or statues about
00:05:14 churchill statues about anything to do with the empire it's ultimately a much more profound
00:05:20 part of the culture war that we've been fighting in this country for a long time.
00:05:26 Do you think that as an historian that the way in which history has been taught or for that matter
00:05:32 not taught over a period of time has made this kind of thing easier? I mean that people just
00:05:38 simply have no context anymore? Undoubtedly yes. Ever since the 1960s the educational
00:05:46 establishment has not believed in heroes um it's believed in villains and it's brought up a number
00:05:53 large number of them but it hasn't believed in anybody that we should be looking up to
00:05:57 particularly um and it does believe in knocking down many of the ones that we've had in the past
00:06:03 and so this is uh and it's of course part of the greater uh concept of um of trying to move away
00:06:12 from the great uh person great man and woman view of history and and because we've been following
00:06:19 this for half a century and because winston churchill is not taught objectively and properly
00:06:24 to anything like the degree that he ought to be considering he is our greatest national hero in
00:06:29 our schools this is what is ultimately the um inevitable result now it is important to remember
00:06:37 that of course he did believe in a hierarchy of races um born in 1874 he was at school at the
00:06:45 same time as charles darwin was still alive and the and people in those days believe something
00:06:51 that we know to be ludicrous and absurd and obscene indeed um about the whites being on top of a
00:06:58 of a hierarchy of races but that was considered scientific fact at the time and i don't believe
00:07:04 that he should be attacked because he believed what the majority of people believed at the time
00:07:10 don't you think actually that he's attacked actually more by the people who attack him he's
00:07:16 attacked much more simply because he symbolizes uh sort of british history in a way i mean he's
00:07:22 the ultimate symbol of identity isn't he that and also of course he was a conservative prime minister
00:07:30 I would very much doubt whether a Labour Prime Minister's statue would be treated as viciously as this.
00:07:38 I think that he was a very profound, in fact, in many ways, our first really strong anti-communist leader as well.
00:07:48 And so they would hate him for that. And he was a true believer in everything to do with freedom of speech.
00:07:55 And that's also that I think there's quite unpopular on the on the left at the moment.
00:08:02 So all in all, yes, he is the he's the sort of magnet.
00:08:06 But this is why he should have been protected, why he should have had phalanxes of policemen on that day rather than people watch what was going on, which is what actually happened.
00:08:16 and um and policemen going down one knee and policemen turning their backs in bristol on
00:08:23 basically mob violence and this is the most extraordinary thing that part of what i mention
00:08:29 is cultural malaise and that the um that the authorities don't uh treat this in the same
00:08:36 ways that the authorities would have treated it back in the i don't know the 1950s 60s up to the
00:08:43 1980s. Yes, I think that I know you're a great admirer of Margaret Thatcher. I'm sure that
00:08:50 she probably wouldn't have let that situation come to pass quite so quickly. Can you imagine?
00:08:59 By the way, let me just point out, this isn't just an attack on Boris. If you look at what
00:09:11 Emmanuel Macron allowed with the gilet germe a entered the Arc de Triomphe and chopped off the
00:09:20 heads of the statue of Napoleon Bonaparte can you imagine Charles the Gaul putting up with that kind
00:09:24 of thing there is as I say a much wider geographically wider but also historically
00:09:33 wider cultural malaise in this country that allows first of all that anyone would want to do it in
00:09:39 first place. Secondly, it allows it to go, and so far, go unpunished.
00:09:46 I do want to talk to you about Churchill the Man in a minute, but before we leave
00:09:49 that, go on to that. You talked there a bit
00:09:54 about the lack of resistance to what's been
00:09:57 going on generally with our heritage. I mean, at the moment,
00:09:59 as I understand it, you know, the knives are out now for
00:10:03 Arthur Bomber Harris, you know, in the statue of him in the Strand.
00:10:09 so far as i know there's nothing to do with slavery there that's just something to do with
00:10:12 our history um and i just i just wondered do you think that and monty we read we read in the times
00:10:19 that monty um general lord montgomery is also going to be uh uh attacked um so uh so these
00:10:27 second world world war figures obviously are under um under attack as i say as an attempt
00:10:33 to raise awareness uh for the um blm movement um moves on to other um cultural icons yes um
00:10:44 obviously we have a prime minister who's written a biography of uh churchill and uh also one that
00:10:49 tends to well has always i think prided himself on his general sense of the sweep of history
00:10:55 shall we say um do you think that he's were you sort of happy with his response or do you think
00:11:02 it was do you think it was adequate i was actually yes yes i thought it was um it was what needed to
00:11:09 be said i wouldn't have minded if it had been said uh the day before um rather than on the on
00:11:15 the uh on the sunday but um nonetheless it's just one of those things he's a very busy man
00:11:21 the key thing is though that he must back up what he says i i would like to see people including
00:11:26 that teacher in um bristol who was part of the uh attack on the statue in bristol to be prosecuted
00:11:34 because otherwise we really are just allowing um mob rule to decide what our built environment is
00:11:41 going to look like and that would just be a sweet um a complete abdication i think of uh
00:11:47 of our responsibility not just to ourselves and to the next generation but to the past generations as
00:11:53 well. Yes. Churchill is one of these figures, I can think of a few in British history, but he's
00:12:00 one of those figures which I think people almost feel that they know, that they feel they know them,
00:12:07 and I wonder what your observations there, how does a figure, almost regardless of what they
00:12:14 actually did, but how does the figure sort of attain that kind of level of affection in the
00:12:20 popular memory i mean i think elizabeth the first is another one for example i think it requires
00:12:26 quite a good deal of selective amnesia in fact feel we know him but partly i suppose because
00:12:34 he isn't taught in schools uh today to anything like the degree that he ought to be um you can
00:12:39 almost go through your entire history teaching and leave um history teaching off at the age of 16 and
00:12:45 and hardly even heard of uh winston churchill recently there was a recent survey in which 20
00:12:51 percent of british teenagers believed that he was a fictional character and so you uh you need a
00:12:59 slight slight selective amnesia in that i'm not sure that that many people know about uh various
00:13:05 aspects all the things he got wrong apart from anything else he constantly made folders in his
00:13:09 career um the gallipoli catastrophe of course he was on the wrong side of the abdication crisis the
00:13:15 gold standard crisis um women's suffrage and so on um and so although the things that he got right
00:13:23 in the 20th century spotting the rise of the uh wilhelmine militarist uh um
00:13:30 prussia and then germany as it was and then uh adolf hitler of course and then also the
00:13:36 soviet imperialism in eastern europe after the second world war so we've got those big three
00:13:41 right means that you deserve massive great statue in parliament square but it doesn't
00:13:46 get an awful lot of much smaller things wrong um he's a extraordinary figure in the sense as well
00:13:54 that uh my my father was a very typical in his admiration of church you know he's that generation
00:14:00 who grew up in the war and you could say nothing bad about him but i think that one of the things
00:14:06 that obviously he admired about him was that he was a man who seemed to pack about three or four
00:14:12 lifetimes into one. Yeah extraordinary, just the sheer energy. I mean he was at the forefront of
00:14:20 every major issue in British politics, really from the time that he entered the House of Commons at
00:14:26 the beginning of the 20th century to the time that he left it two-thirds of the way through it.
00:14:31 yeah he he never allowed a major um struggle to take place where he wasn't in the forefront in
00:14:39 one way or another and so um and so your father's right you know it's he was somebody who packed
00:14:46 uh who packed the most extraordinary amount of uh achievements and as i said occasional disasters as
00:14:53 well um into a single lifetime i mean did you when you started writing the book and i mean
00:15:03 has your did your admiration for churchill uh grow or or diminish you know over the period
00:15:10 of writing it it grew um i would say i mean the the point i think that uh i realized that this
00:15:19 was a truly extraordinary person was when um the queen allowed me to be the first churchill biographer
00:15:25 to use her father's diaries the king george the sixth met churchill every tuesday of the second
00:15:31 world war and they uh had an audience of buckingham palace together and the um king then wrote down
00:15:38 everything churchill said so we have this extraordinary and fascinating source which i've
00:15:44 used a great deal of course in my book one of the things that one sees in those meetings
00:15:49 is quite how we could trust the king and the king would never say anything and the diaries
00:15:54 were not going to be allowed to be seen for another 75 years uh he he told him everything
00:16:01 that uh that was going on in his mind um every single tuesday of the second world war and this
00:16:08 was the thing that made me uh appreciate him even more than i did before and i'd already written
00:16:14 four books um with church in the title subtitle over the last 30 years
00:16:19 and it was the recognition that of all of the things that were on his mind
00:16:23 during the war of course but also the um depths of his frustrations
00:16:28 and his irritations and uh and and all of the of the burdens
00:16:34 on his shoulders and and the way that he um explained
00:16:38 them and and worked out with the king how he was
00:16:40 going to deal with them. He had this from quite a young age, from reading the book, it's not the
00:16:48 first book about Churchill I've read I have to say, but he had this sort of sense of that he was the
00:16:57 coming man shall we say, that he had something was already in place for him, destiny I suppose.
00:17:04 um where do you think that's right exactly yes i i subtitled the book um walking with destiny
00:17:11 for precise reason it's a reference of course to the 10th of may 1940 uh the day on which he became
00:17:17 prime minister uh when he said um i felt as if i were walking with destiny and that all my past
00:17:23 life had been but a preparation for this hour and for this trial and and he he had thought he believed
00:17:30 that he was walking with destiny really ever since um since he was a 16 year old school boy
00:17:37 at harrow when he uh he told his best friend that in their lives there would be terrible upheavals
00:17:45 great struggles and but that he would be at the forefront of saving london and saving england
00:17:52 he said this when he was 16 and then 50 years later exactly that took place so a very very
00:17:58 powerful sense of a driving sense of personal destiny where do you think that derived from
00:18:04 though oh a number of places uh the first of course was uh his parents uh his father um who
00:18:14 was a very important victorian politician chancellor of the exchequer lord randolph
00:18:19 churchill who despised him and had no time for him and as he grew up he he showed his contempt for his
00:18:25 uh son um in a way that was obviously uh entirely crushing and uh and so all his life even though
00:18:34 his father died at the age of 45 when churchill was only 20 um he wanted to prove to his long
00:18:40 dead father a shade of his father that he was actually a worthwhile individual his mother
00:18:46 ignored him as well um for a very long period indeed until uh he became a signatory on her trust
00:18:53 fund uh at which point she a great deal of this great spendthrift lady uh showed a great interest
00:19:00 in him but not in the early days and he wrote in his autobiography my early life uh that she shone
00:19:05 for me like the evening star brilliant but at a distance which is a very sad thing to to say he
00:19:12 was because they were both spendthrift he was broke all his life so he had to write 37 books
00:19:17 and over 800 articles in order to um uh to have cash to spend and that was another reason that
00:19:26 he had great drive he became the best paid war correspondent in the world at one point
00:19:32 and um and also he did have this personal destiny uh that he was um being in some way saved
00:19:40 for great deeds and he had many many brushes with death in his life again and again he very nearly
00:19:49 died and on several occasions he talked about the invisible wings that beat over him and obviously
00:19:57 wings that were there in order to protect him for the great when he was going to defeat Hitler and
00:20:03 the Nazis we do you mentioned his parents so we do tend to forget don't we that he was sort of
00:20:09 half American. And I wonder how that, I mean, that presumably did inform, you know, his outlook
00:20:18 and his politics to an extent. That's right, yes. He did go through, his mother was born in Brooklyn,
00:20:26 Jenny Jerome, and he went to America 16 times in his life, which was an awful lot more than most
00:20:32 British politicians did and he used his half American background very much during
00:20:40 the Second World War to to bring the Americans round to the idea of a full
00:20:47 scale alliance and and he loved America and he went back there as I say a great
00:20:53 deal he was did go through an anti-American phase in the 1920s when
00:20:59 thought the americans were squeezing too much money through war reparations uh and war debt
00:21:05 repayments out of the um out of the world financial system and that that was one of the reasons for
00:21:11 the great crash of 1929 so he wasn't a sort of starry-eyed follower of americans under all
00:21:19 circumstances but his great speech uh in september 1943 at harvard in which he talked about um us
00:21:26 having some kind of a of a sort of joint citizenship with america shows how much how far
00:21:33 he was willing to take this concept that he himself pioneered and championed of the english-speaking
00:21:40 peoples uh you actually carried on his he's his series of books on the english-speaking peoples
00:21:47 didn't you you wrote uh uh it i think he stops around about the death of victoria if i remember
00:21:52 and then you carried on yes he stops in 1901 and so i brought it from 1901 up to um up to
00:22:01 the time of publication which i think was about uh 2005 or so yeah um it was a fairly hubristic
00:22:08 thing to have done today um but um but but fun yes um i i understand i think it was about this
00:22:16 particular his his uh english-speaking peoples that orwell said when he was reviewing it uh
00:22:24 george orwell said he paid it the highest compliment in that it was the work of a human being
00:22:30 i don't know whether you've heard that quote i have yes yes yes exactly he meant a sort of
00:22:37 a fully rounded individual yeah Churchill undoubtedly was and of course Orwell and
00:22:45 Churchill did have certain things in common they both were patriots of course and they although
00:22:53 Orwell went through a communist stage he wound up being one of the most eloquent anti-communists of
00:23:00 the 20th century and so Churchill appreciated that in his work there's a very good
00:23:07 book about uh about Churchill and all that was published um just a couple of years ago which
00:23:13 i do recommend as soon as you finish mine yes okay right oh i have um he was never what you
00:23:20 mentioned there about uh you know uh the the financial crisis of the 20s churchill himself
00:23:26 was never very good with money was he he wasn't a great sort of like he he didn't know how to save
00:23:31 or he didn't he was he was always bordering on being a bit broke wasn't he yes um as i say partly
00:23:37 that's because he didn't have very much money to begin with because of his parents being great
00:23:42 spenders and secondly because as his friend effie smith said winston is always satisfied
00:23:48 with the best of everything he spent uh he constantly outspent his uh his income he wasn't
00:23:57 it wasn't until he was in his early 70s that he actually finally um managed to break even to um
00:24:05 get out of out of the red sorry his early 70s when he signed his book contract for the memoirs
00:24:12 of the second world war up until that point he was um he was broke continually and we are very
00:24:17 lucky of course that he was because it meant that he had to write these books and articles
00:24:22 and uh we're able to get into the mind of the man so much more uh easily because of that yes um
00:24:30 Andrew when when you talked at the beginning about you know how in fact Churchill is seen
00:24:37 as a kind of fictional character to many young people he's also apparently in various surveys
00:24:44 you know there's an ad with a bulldog for an insurance company I think and some people thought
00:24:49 that this was this was actually what they meant by Churchill what would you what would your
00:24:54 observations be about how we change the way history is actually taught how our island story
00:25:00 if you like is carried on what would you like to see happen oh i think just try and teach it you
00:25:08 know treated totally objectively you've got to uh teach the bad uh sides of things like the
00:25:15 british empire for example of course you must but you should see it in an overall um an overall
00:25:21 arc a trajectory that appreciates that for most of the people in most of the
00:25:29 Empire for most of the time it was an extraordinary good it was something
00:25:34 brought incredible benefits that brought and peace for a very long time in
00:25:38 places that hadn't had it for ages that brought the doubling of the life
00:25:45 expectancy for Indians for example that enormous increase the numbers of people
00:25:50 things that church was incredibly proud of and which no racists no true race would be proud of
00:25:59 the fact that double expectancy of non-white people and increase the numbers of non-white
00:26:04 people or at least the british empire did of which he was a champion you know that's another reason
00:26:10 that i think we can uh we can ignore these um these attacks on him today um because underlying
00:26:19 them is the complete misconception that because he believed in a racial hierarchy he was therefore
00:26:26 the same as Adolf Hitler no he wasn't he was the exact opposite he was somebody whose whose sense
00:26:33 of moral purpose of the British Empire along with most people who were working for the British Empire
00:26:39 working in the British Empire and defending the British Empire did it because they had an altruistic
00:26:44 sense that it was good not just for britain but also for the natives of the empire because they
00:26:50 didn't see economics for example as a zero-sum game they saw it as something where development
00:26:57 would be able to help both sides and if we were able to teach the um the next generation that
00:27:03 i think that we would find that we wouldn't have people with spray paints um acting like
00:27:09 ignoramuses in the centre of our great cabinet. Well, yes, I think this is unfortunately a story
00:27:18 that's going to continue for a while. But before we leave it there, Andrew, I just wanted, could
00:27:24 you actually just settle one thing? During the whole Brexit argument, if we can cast our minds
00:27:30 back to now what seems like another world, yes, Churchill was used by both sides, wasn't he? He
00:27:38 was used by both sides and i wonder what was his attitude to britain and the eu and britain in
00:27:45 europe can you settle it for us um yes i believe i can i've worked very hard on this there are lots
00:27:51 of quotations of course in my book about this uh this issue um he wanted to have a um a european
00:28:02 federation european project he wanted to have europe come together he never wanted uh as he
00:28:08 put it tewton to fight gaul he'd lost two friends in both the first world war and the second world
00:28:14 war when tewton fought paul ever to want that to happen again um but he didn't believe that it
00:28:23 that the united kingdom needed to be a member of that federation he was all in favor of there being
00:28:28 a european coming together but he never wanted britain to be part of it because he saw britain
00:28:34 as the ideal place that could be part of the special relationship with the united states which
00:28:40 he termed that he invented in that speech at harvard i mentioned earlier he also saw us as
00:28:46 being a link with the commonwealth um the uh the all the countries of the commonwealth that we'd be
00:28:52 able to trade with and also with um with europe he wanted us to be a friend and an ally um of uh
00:29:01 of europe but never a member of european union as it became or the common as it was during his
00:29:08 lifetime um and uh and he made that pretty clear in a series of uh of memos and various things he
00:29:15 said to montgomery and so on uh all of which you'll find in my uh in my book well uh the book
00:29:22 again of course is churchill by andrew roberts um and it is it is quite brilliant thank you very
00:29:28 very much uh andrew for for joining us uh that's it this week for so what you're saying is uh just
00:29:34 to remind you the book which is wonderful churchill by andrew roberts it's available in all good
00:29:41 bookshops when they open and indeed of course on amazon we look forward to seeing you next time
00:29:47 thank you very much