New Culture Forum - June 21, 2020


What Impact Will The Covid-19 Crisis Have On The Green⧸Environmental Movements?

Andrew Roberts - Winston Churchill, BLM, The Far Left And Britain's Culture War The Long March Through The Institutions: How The Left Won The Culture War & What To Do About It.

Episode Stats


Length

29 minutes

Words per minute

150.68

Word count

4,403

Sentence count

130


Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
00:00:00 Hello and welcome to Counterculture. I'm Peter Whittle. Now if you read your average
00:00:12 metropolitan columnist at the moment you will find that the skies are bluer, they're certainly
00:00:18 clearer, the air is fresher and the fish are back in the canals of Venice. All we know the
00:00:24 grass is greener too. But there is a serious issue here which we're going to discuss today
00:00:29 And that is, how far will this crisis affect the green movement?
00:00:34 Will it give it a new incentive?
00:00:37 Would it mean that the future is indeed greener for everybody?
00:00:41 Should it be greener?
00:00:42 Or indeed, would it be entirely different, particularly given China's position on these particular issues?
00:00:50 So today, to talk about that, I have three guests.
00:00:53 First of all, Dr. Benny Pizer of the Global Warming Policy Forum.
00:00:59 James Delingpole, who's host of the Delingpod podcast, and also, of course, columnist and commentator.
00:01:06 And Richard Bingley, who is chief executive of the Global Cyber Academy.
00:01:11 So thank you very much, gentlemen, for joining us.
00:01:14 I want to start with you, actually, James, if I may.
00:01:19 Are we going to see more or less of Greta Thunberg, do you think, in the future?
00:01:27 It's an interesting question.
00:01:28 let me answer it in in a different way i think there are two possible um outcomes of this
00:01:36 coronavirus crisis one is and this is the upside this is what i'm hoping and praying for
00:01:44 is that it will be increasingly apparent that governments do not have any spare cash
00:01:54 to spend on green boondoggles the only reason i mean this is something that that warren buffett
00:02:02 a point warren buffett made years ago it's known to anyone with a with a functioning brain the only
00:02:09 reason that the renewables industry for example can survive is through state subsidy through
00:02:16 government intervention unless unless people are compelled to use renewable energy which of course
00:02:21 is the darling of the green movement then people will not pay for green energy okay
00:02:27 so clearly now that the government's coffers have been supposedly exhausted by spending for this
00:02:34 this this crisis you think about all the money that rishi sunak has allocated to enable people
00:02:39 to to sit in their gardens improving their suntans um there's not going to be really much left for
00:02:45 this net zero product uh project you know we need recovery and the way to economic recovery is not
00:02:53 to dump more um more taxes and regulations and expensive energy on the economy so that's the
00:03:03 happy answer the unhappy answer is you you in a way answered it yourself with your introduction
00:03:09 which is that lots of people are looking at looking outside their windows and thinking
00:03:13 hey, the birds seem to be chirping more cheerily.
00:03:19 This is how our post-COVID-19 world will look.
00:03:24 It's a greener world, and we need to do more.
00:03:28 We need to double down.
00:03:29 And you see this happening already, actually, to a degree.
00:03:31 You see, for example, that Grant Shapps,
00:03:34 while there are no MPs in the Commons to oppose him,
00:03:38 he's coming up with all these measures,
00:03:40 like all these extra cyclic cycle cycle lanes and stuff you see it's been happening in italy as well
00:03:46 that that that uh milan i think has taken it on itself to to to to get rid of all of of of all
00:03:54 these uh roads and turn them into bicycle routes this is this is dangerous and this is this this
00:04:02 i think is slightly the more uh likely outcome i fear would you agree with that benny do you
00:04:08 you think that that is the likely outcome? By and large, yes. There's of course the
00:04:17 issue of people avoiding public transport altogether and going back to
00:04:27 work in cars. So what you've seen for instance in China is a 50% increase in
00:04:35 in car traffic in the big city simply because people are afraid of using public transport.
00:04:41 They're not going on their bikes, I can tell you that.
00:04:44 That age of cycling in China when they were dead poor is over and they're not going back to bicycles.
00:04:53 They want cars, modern cars, the bigger the better.
00:04:57 That's what's going to happen in most countries outside of Europe.
00:05:01 the europeans will go down the green route because that is the dominant ideology today
00:05:13 some things will crash like renewable energy some things will work a lot of things will become
00:05:23 greener simply because a people want to live in a cleaner world and b because very often
00:05:29 cleaner means also more efficient and and very often can be done in an economic
00:05:39 way that doesn't harm people or the economy but I don't see any significant
00:05:46 change in the short term on the green agenda and the green ideology that most
00:05:53 parties in Europe have adopted. Richard one thing that's become clear when I was
00:06:00 looking before we did this discussion and I was looking at what green activists
00:06:04 are saying and some of them saying things like I think it's the from
00:06:08 Extinction Rebellion for example one of the co-founders was saying that this has
00:06:12 shown how you know overnight virtually we can change so we should take great
00:06:18 hope from that i mean what do you make of that sort of comment um well i you know i work in and
00:06:24 around technology and more private business than i do government but i i feel that um you know the
00:06:29 mere fact it took us an hour to set this interview up you know behind the scenes you know we we were
00:06:34 sort of testing microphones and and the sound wasn't right um we're just not as a society
00:06:39 geared up to live remotely and virtually as yet you know it might be different in about 50 years
00:06:45 time. So I just think we will pretty much, if the government let us, settle back down to normal.
00:06:52 I tend to agree with James and Bernie. Look, it's not just about government. The entire thrust of
00:06:59 the global economy in many, many places has shifted towards green. Whether it's a fake
00:07:03 science or not is a different issue. That's where most CSR budgets are being spent by the
00:07:10 international banks, the big insurance houses. It's where particularly younger people's politics
00:07:15 sit at. So I do feel that when we sort of move towards shifting out of COVID and then looking
00:07:22 maybe at the American election, you know, if that's not put back, I don't think it will be,
00:07:26 but that Joe Biden will raise this as a huge topic. You know, it's a huge dog whistle topic
00:07:31 over in America. I think Macron the same when he comes up for re-election, you know, so it will
00:07:36 remain a centrepiece political topic. I have to say, in terms of the Green Party and Greta Thunberg,
00:07:44 I think post-COVID, they're pretty much insignificant in terms of if they ever stood
00:07:49 for election or tried to do anything significant in politics. I think the power rests with the
00:07:55 big tech firms, the power rests in Downing Street, Washington. How do they want to deal with this?
00:07:59 How do they want to deal with China's approach to climate? The thing is, though, is that one of the
00:08:04 things with the Green Movement, they do rely, don't they, on big protests and being very,
00:08:09 very visible. And that's kind of been sort of taken away from them. It's been taken away
00:08:13 from everybody. But wouldn't you say? I mean, won't this sort of, I mean, you mentioned
00:08:18 there it's a dog whistle topic. Is it though? I mean, has environmentalism really broken
00:08:25 through? I mean, it's one of the things people sort of feel, isn't it, that they sort of
00:08:29 feel they should be support. But actually, is it really a concern, James?
00:08:34 i think i think it it's a case of the battle between stated preferences versus revealed
00:08:42 preferences so if if people asked to do more green action they'll say yes of course we want
00:08:51 the planet to be greener and yeah we need more money to be spent on on on green things but when
00:08:57 it comes down to it as as benny said they want to travel in their own cars and and and this is
00:09:04 what we're we're seeing every time they don't want a a wind turbine despoiling their favorite view
00:09:10 and chopping up the birds and bats on the on the horizon they don't like this stuff if given the
00:09:15 given a real choice where nobody's watching them people will not take the green option i i thought
00:09:22 i i don't normally take issue with with benny but i thought benny was was conceding way too much
00:09:27 territory to the green movement there by saying that you know uh greenery is going to you know
00:09:33 there are ways of helping the economy um rather the ways of introducing green things without
00:09:39 damaging the economy i think that requires that that's a fairly narrow definition of green i mean
00:09:45 in that sense i'm a green because i like you we all want clean air we all want clean rivers and
00:09:51 stuff like that but really let's be honest green green as it as it exists in the world today is
00:09:58 not about those those little things it's not about having clean air and clean rivers it's about
00:10:02 something much more all-encompassing than that it is about the total transformation
00:10:06 of the global economy uh and that i think is something very scary and i think there's going
00:10:13 to be this battle between uh chinese style uh oppressive government uh intervention to
00:10:22 to enforce this kind of stuff versus individual choice no i i think uh james is right you know
00:10:29 the it's not so much about uh the actual policies it's about the size of government these days now
00:10:36 i mean i spend a lot of time driving over through germany through through central europe and the
00:10:41 countryside is the landscape is just plastered with turbines you know and i don't for a minute
00:10:46 believe that those communities have been consulted i i just feel that this is a big sweeping central
00:10:51 government initiative and in an odd way you know we just we're living in a revolving door of crises
00:10:58 you know it was the green stuff before covid came along covid will probably dissipate next year
00:11:02 then it will kick back into being green or something else and and but all along with
00:11:07 these things they are simply not controlled by the grassroots anymore you know that the covid
00:11:11 response has not been grassroots driven it's been entirely top down and one dimensional and and so
00:11:17 so that that's why i think this uh i'm not disputing the green science i'm not disputing
00:11:23 that climate change is more rapidly happening.
00:11:27 I'm not a sceptic in that way,
00:11:29 but I am a sceptic about governmental powers
00:11:31 and the ability of governments to do something about it.
00:11:34 And I do think it's incumbent on all of us,
00:11:36 whether we run companies or whether we're citizens,
00:11:39 to be more ecological.
00:11:40 This is simply not a top-down thing,
00:11:43 but it's becoming an out-of-control, top-down vehicle,
00:11:47 coming out of the European Union,
00:11:49 coming out of the oil and gas companies,
00:11:50 that the rest of us can do nothing about.
00:11:53 Well, I think it all depends on two issues at the end of the day. One is how severe the economic crisis will be once the pandemic is over and whether there will be a rapid recovery or whether we will continue to stagnate and fall behind because that's what has been happening in the last few decades.
00:12:23 the rest of the world is of course catching up they have much higher economic growth rates than
00:12:30 most of the western world and that's a trend that could easily continue or even accelerate
00:12:38 so the question is how severe is the economic crisis and the deeper the crisis and the the
00:12:43 longer it endures, the less the Greens, which is after all a luxury movement, will
00:12:54 really have the return to their kind of dominance. The other big issue is,
00:13:00 because we know that most of the developing world prioritize economic
00:13:06 growth over these environmental and particularly the climate issue and if
00:13:13 they simply continue business as usual while Europe unilaterally decarbonizes
00:13:19 then the economic discrepancy will even be worse so these are the kind of two
00:13:26 issues where I think the jury is still out how this is going to pan out but
00:13:31 There's a growing realization that unilateral policies that burden your own economies more than anyone else will in the end damage your competitiveness, damage your economy, damage the living standards of people.
00:13:52 And that will decide whether or not the Greens have a big revival or whether they will struggle against people who will prioritise recovery and economic growth.
00:14:11 Bernie, do you feel that the world does act in a rational way now, though?
00:14:16 I mean, for me, it doesn't really, you know, the fact is, the fact is we have a, whether we agree or not, we have a multinational global green industry, you know, that's probably, that's not green in many ways.
00:14:34 The whole climate change and green agenda has become a sort of a transmogrified global industry.
00:14:41 Not outside of the Western world.
00:14:43 No one cares outside of Europe.
00:14:45 Yeah, but the Western world equates to most GDP on the planet and most decision making that has gravitas on the planet.
00:14:52 But so if, for example, it's simply not true that climate change has been occurring, then this is a fake industry.
00:14:59 Do you really think that people will move away from that?
00:15:01 I think we live now in the world of hyperbully and supercrisis.
00:15:05 I'm not sure we can adjust quick enough. That's my concern.
00:15:08 No, first of all, this is not about the science of climate change.
00:15:12 And, you know, that isn't really the issue.
00:15:15 The issue is whether the international community is actually doing something about CO2 emissions.
00:15:23 And the reality is that while in most Western countries emissions have basically stabilized over the last 10-20 years,
00:15:33 most emissions now come from the developing world and they don't really care about this issue.
00:15:40 So, there is not this kind of international agreement that we all have to do something about CO2 emissions.
00:15:46 The reality is CO2 emissions are rising mainly because most of the world outside the Western world is prioritizing economic growth.
00:15:58 They don't care about coal or gas or oil.
00:16:02 They want just to develop as fast as they can, raise as many people out of poverty as they can.
00:16:09 And that is at the core of the problem. If we had a level playing field, we wouldn't have this international disagreement about Paris and targets and so on.
00:16:21 So I think we have to realize that a lot of the green focus is really a Western luxury that most of the world's public and most of the world's governments, for them, it's not even secondary.
00:16:36 This is on their list of priorities very low. Their main priority is development, growth, jobs, industries, civil unrest and so on.
00:16:50 And unless this changes, eventually people will say it doesn't make sense to do it unilaterally.
00:16:59 Because if you really want to stabilize CO2 emissions, it has to be done globally.
00:17:06 And unless there is that global commitment, and in real terms, that is not going to help by just Europe or other Western countries going it alone.
00:17:21 That is at the core of the problem.
00:17:24 And you say, well, the West is dominating the world, and what the West does is kind of dominating the international agenda.
00:17:32 This is going to change after this crisis, because I guess that the rest of the world, particularly in Asia, will catch up very fast and they will become more powerful, not just economically, but also politically and geopolitically and militarily.
00:17:52 And Europe is shackling itself by policies that are making industries less competitive, making energy more costly, making life more difficult for families.
00:18:07 I mean, if green energy were, you know, as cheap as people claim, we wouldn't have a problem.
00:18:13 Isn't this the point, James, really, just to come in on that, you have this situation
00:18:23 that we've just described, but it seems to me that, particularly given the nature of
00:18:28 this particular crisis, i.e. coming from China, that actually it could be even bigger, that
00:18:35 essentially the de-prioritising of the green agenda could be even more acute, because we're
00:18:42 going to have to somehow compete with this big new power aren't we i mean that's the point is
00:18:48 it's far far more than maybe it would have been maybe 20 years ago yeah definitely the the rise
00:18:56 of not just china but the east generally is going to be is going to become an increasing issue i
00:19:02 mean you look at you look for example at how the eastern economies north korea japan um singapore
00:19:10 have generally handled this crisis in a way that enables their economies to get back going
00:19:18 earlier so they've already got their head start i think we're living through a phony war at the
00:19:22 moment i think that it is i i think there was a whole heap of pain coming our way and i think that
00:19:30 um the green greenery is a form of virtue signaling and it's it's it's a kind of it's
00:19:39 the habit of a a decadent culture which is which is feeling guilty about having too much affluence
00:19:47 and therefore feels a kind of compulsion to to hobble itself with these green measures as a kind
00:19:54 of as a as a form of of ritual piety in the same way you might put on a hair shirt or you or you
00:20:00 You know, you might go on a pilgrimage to wherever, to Mecca even.
00:20:09 It's a way of compensating for your affluence and your comfortable lifestyle.
00:20:15 This is going to change as the economy starts to collapse.
00:20:19 Second thing is we're already seeing cracks appearing in the dam.
00:20:24 i i'm indebted to to benny's daily newsletter uh for this lufthansa lufthansa i think is being
00:20:34 bailed out by the german government german government is taking a 20 stake in lufthansa
00:20:41 now what's interesting about this is not that they're taking the stake but that they have not
00:20:45 the german government has not imposed any kind of green strictures on lufthansa it hasn't said
00:20:53 you've got to cut your carbon emissions by blah blah blah which is what some of the other other
00:20:57 national governments are saying to their airlines they're trying to impose these these green rules
00:21:03 well if lupanser is not subject to these rules what incentive is there going to be for the other
00:21:10 airlines to obey these rules there's going to be a real mismatch isn't there an economic mismatch
00:21:15 and i think i'm hoping ultimately that money talks bullshit walks that's going to be i really hope
00:21:23 and pray this is what's going to happen that despite all this urge for green certain virtue
00:21:28 signaling money will talk louder thing is james you know you talked about it being a kind of uh
00:21:33 virtue signaling thing many called it a luxury but it's a pretty embedded one now this is this
00:21:40 This is the point, it seems to me, that, OK, you've got the Green Party, but in this country,
00:21:46 their agenda has largely been embedded in the main parties.
00:21:51 This is the point.
00:21:53 And I think the other point as well, really, is that on one level it's virtue signaling,
00:21:57 but you wrote a book, James, called Watermelons, which was basically about being read on the inside.
00:22:04 This is how I've always seen this movement, which is essentially that they are socialistic,
00:22:09 that they want they're using this surely as a sort of a way in a trojan horse really
00:22:16 yeah no that that's that's a given it's it it's very analogous to to covet 19 or whatever you want
00:22:25 you want to call it that the public has been effectively brainwashed by the government's
00:22:30 nudge department into thinking that coronavirus is much much deadly than it is in fact it's
00:22:35 I think increasingly it's going to become evident that it's no worse than bad seasonal flu, that we massively overreacted.
00:22:42 And yet, if you went out into the people's living rooms now and asked them this, they'd say, oh, no, we need to be very cautious.
00:22:50 It's the same with the Green Movement, which, by the way, is with climate change, which, like COVID-19, is a scare generated by propaganda and computer models.
00:23:03 and ultimately there is going to be a wake-up moment it's going to be a wake-up moment with
00:23:07 covid19 there's going to be a wake-up moment with with this greenery because there was no evidence
00:23:13 to support all these measures that are being taken by governments to deal with this and it was it was
00:23:19 masked in times of prosperity people had other things to worry about um now that money is going
00:23:25 to be and the economy is increasingly going to be the focus of people's lives i think it's going to
00:23:29 be much much harder for green propagandists to do their dirty do you think i mean what will the
00:23:35 what will the wake-up moment be when will that be richard you think i mean can you be talking about
00:23:41 a coming economic crisis it almost seems too small a word actually for what i'm worried about i mean
00:23:47 what is your view of what it will be like i i can't really see that there'll be a trigger point
00:23:53 because i mean the hold of um sort of the the carbon reduction argument was around the world
00:23:59 heating up by three degrees you know over the next 50 years and this would create sort of large
00:24:03 amounts of drought areas and and particularly uh you know australia or latin american countries
00:24:10 worried about el nino were adjusting their economies anyway i was on a call to people in
00:24:15 iraq last week and they are massively moving away from an oil economy post sort of covid and thinking
00:24:20 and talking about uh the type of things that ben is um i i don't think there'll be a trigger moment
00:24:26 like there is with COVID or like, you know, some apocalyptic thing like 9-11, you know,
00:24:31 international terrorism. I think we've, whatever your view is on green, we've kind of buried it
00:24:37 and put it in the long grass. And that things like COVID, things like terrorism will usurp it
00:24:44 as an issue for the mainstream. And then probably, you know, you get to sort of 30 or 40 years time
00:24:50 where the world may be livable, it may not be.
00:24:53 I mean, for example, some countries, Pakistan, United Arab Emirates, Saudi Arabia,
00:25:00 have adjusted for many years to living in barren, sandy landscapes.
00:25:07 They've drilled for oil.
00:25:09 They're some of the world's most major exporters.
00:25:12 I'm not really feeling that we should worry too much about climate change in itself.
00:25:19 I'm worried about the political approaches and the economic approaches, but I cannot in any way, shape or form foresee a trigger point on this debate, which means it will never get the mainstream political leverage that something like COVID does.
00:25:33 No, I agree. It is very unlikely that there will be some kind of crash or trigger point where people begin to reassess or correct their views. Not least politicians will never do that.
00:25:52 However, there will be certain aspects, certain segments of the agenda and the most likely point
00:26:04 where the public and also policy makers may reconsider is the cost of the energy and electricity
00:26:15 system to the economy and so just to give you an example if you want to reduce co2 emissions
00:26:24 there are obviously different approaches and different technologies and there's a you know
00:26:30 a big debate about the cost of renewables and the inefficiency and the instability it creates
00:26:39 compared to let's say nuclear energy or nuclear together with natural gas and
00:26:45 these will be debates that will I think increasingly become relevant it's not so
00:26:52 much that you question the whole green agenda as such but the debate will
00:26:58 hopefully shift to what makes economic sense because up until now the economic
00:27:05 question has never really been fully addressed it's all about as james said the alarm we have
00:27:10 to do something it doesn't matter how much it costs we have to save the planet we only have
00:27:15 10 years so we have to throw the sink at this and as you know as time progresses we are beginning
00:27:23 to realize some of the things that have been introduced are counterproductive are damaging
00:27:31 have all sorts of unintended consequences whether it's
00:27:35 wind farms, whether it's biomass you know burning whole
00:27:38 forests and then shipping them to Britain to
00:27:41 burn in power plants, the impact on the environment
00:27:46 of these renewable projects. So there are certain
00:27:49 segments that will become increasingly contentious
00:27:54 But the main focus in coming years will perhaps shift back to a real assessment of how much does it cost, does it make sense and what are the kind of options we have if we want to clean up the environment.
00:28:16 Because everyone wants to have a clean environment, but it has to make sense and it has to make practical sense and it has to make economic sense.
00:28:27 That debate has been stifled by the activists and the alarmists.
00:28:32 And I think that's the debate that we need urgently in coming years.
00:28:36 I think people were actually very impatient, weren't they, with Extinction Rebellion?
00:28:41 I mean, when they had the protests quite recently, you know, on the bridges in London and everything.
00:28:46 people, the patience wore thin, although I have to say it still, it was actually, people were
00:28:51 remarkably tolerant, actually, despite that. I mean, that sort of is, James, quite a sort of
00:29:00 optimistic outlook that Benny said there, that basically, you know, the pendulum will swift
00:29:07 that we'll have to basically be much more real worldish about this. Do you think that's going
00:29:12 to happen?