New Culture Forum - May 26, 2021


Kathleen Stock OBE - The Dangers of Transgender Ideology

Alex Kaschuta - Why The West Isn't Having Children Quentin Letts - How We Need To Stop Being Told What To Do

Episode Stats


Length

32 minutes

Words per minute

161.03

Word count

5,251

Sentence count

—


Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
00:00:00 Hello and welcome to So What You're Saying Is. I'm Peter Whittler. Now the trans issue is one of the
00:00:29 dominant issues and debates of our time but it generates a hell of a lot of noise and very very
00:00:35 little light. So I'm delighted today that my guest is Professor Kathleen Stock who's just written
00:00:42 this book Material Girls Why Reality Matters for Feminism. It's been hugely well reviewed
00:00:50 and she's with me now. Thank you very much Kathleen for coming on. At the beginning of the
00:00:55 book, you refer to yourself, or having been described as a bit of a heretic, what is the
00:01:04 nature of your particular heresy? I think I've got multiple heresies going on. I mean, one is that,
00:01:14 I mean, the main one is, I suppose, just to cut to the absolute chase, is that I don't think it's
00:01:18 literally true that trans women are women and trans men are men, and that non-binary people
00:01:25 are neither men nor women I mean of course that's not going to seem like a heresy to a large
00:01:30 number of people listening it's going to seem like truism but there is a group of people for
00:01:36 whom it is a heresy so that's that's one of them the other area in which I think I'm thought of
00:01:43 I don't know if heretical is the right word but I am a sort of outsider to the whole gender area
00:01:49 and and in a way I think that's given me many advantages um in being able to try and work out
00:01:55 for myself what's supposed to be going on in the book which i found extremely clarifying actually
00:02:02 um but you know if you don't mind some of this might seem like you know various of nuts and
00:02:07 bolts to you but i think that uh it will be very very helpful to people it certainly was to me
00:02:13 listening um you make this basic distinction or rather should i say the main issue seems to be
00:02:19 around this basic distinction between sex and gender doesn't it could you could you explain
00:02:26 that difference okay well it's it as I say in the towards the beginning of the book
00:02:33 sex is understood by me and by many obviously in its traditional sense as a biological state
00:02:43 um gender unfortunately is a word that has now been come to um mean various different things
00:02:52 completely different things in some cases so when you get an argument about gender you quite often
00:02:57 get people talking past each other i mean for some people gender is just a polite word for sex
00:03:02 yes because they don't want to say the word s-e-x um and then in the in the original distinction as
00:03:11 it was made in the mouths of 70s feminists
00:03:16 or 60s and 70s feminists last century.
00:03:19 Gender was the social meanings around sex,
00:03:21 which seems to be a perfectly reasonable distinction to make.
00:03:24 There's the biological state
00:03:25 and then there's how that biology kind of has causal effects
00:03:31 in the social world.
00:03:32 So that would be masculinity and femininity
00:03:35 and it can vary from culture to culture to some extent
00:03:38 or to a radical extent depending on whether you think some things are hardwired or not
00:03:43 but you know pink being associated with femininity and blue being associated with masculinity
00:03:49 that's culturally contingent but it would fall under gender the social associations stereotypes
00:03:55 meanings of sex now um things have moved on since then so now there's two sort of significant
00:04:04 developments for this argument i think uh one is um a quite strange move made in some academic
00:04:12 circles where they want to say that woman and womanhood and manhood are genders but in a
00:04:19 understood in a social sense so now womanhood and manhood themselves are no longer biological
00:04:26 states they no longer just sort of synonymously refer to adult human females and adult human
00:04:33 males um they refer to a sort of social role probably associated with femininity or masculinity
00:04:39 that's a weird move but it does get made and then um at the moment the big hot topic and the and
00:04:49 really the um the the meaning of gender that's most common i think in policy making is gender
00:04:56 identity and that's really the target of the book so this is the idea that really i mean i try and
00:05:02 go through several different accounts of gender identity to work out what that really is supposed
00:05:06 to be but it's something psychological so it's an inner state it's not about your presentation
00:05:12 what you've done to your body it's not about your biology it's not it's not about how other people
00:05:17 see you even it's something inner the way you experience yourself in relation to manhood or
00:05:22 womanhood maleness and femaleness and what we're seeing in the UK as you possibly know is
00:05:28 really quite radical reorganisation of social spaces and data collection and people's
00:05:37 understanding of the self in terms of this thing, gender identity. So that's really the target of
00:05:42 the book. Yes, this gender identity, what is the legal status of it at the moment, Kathleen,
00:05:50 in the sense that I do obviously know that gender reassignment was a protected characteristic,
00:05:57 was it not, under the Equality Act 2010. Gender identity, which is the newest development,
00:06:06 does that have any legal status? No. Well, only derivatively. So it's not
00:06:12 specified in the Equality Act. It's gender reassignment, i.e. a process. It doesn't have
00:06:20 to be a surgical process either. I mean, actually in the Equality Act, gender reassignment is rather
00:06:24 loosely defined anyway and in the gender recognition act the subject is gender reassignment there is
00:06:35 moves to make hate crime legislation directed towards
00:06:43 kind of offense against gender identity so it's in the air but the our sort of main national
00:06:51 lobbying groups ostensibly on behalf of gay and trans people for instance Stonewall are very keen
00:06:57 to see gender reassignment replaced with this idea of gender identity I see why are they actually
00:07:05 if you take Stonewall and if you take Mermaid you actually what you go through in the book
00:07:11 is you first of all you know that the government or parts of our bureaucracy or whatever seem to
00:07:17 be very much enthralled to these groups. But they use a lot of hyperbole, do they not?
00:07:24 Yes, they do. They do. Well, why, I mean, in answer to your question, why are they so
00:07:28 focused on gender identity? I think there's a sort of pseudo logical reason. And then
00:07:31 there's a kind of more, more, a reason more connected to their motives. But you know,
00:07:38 the pseudo logical reason is, if you say, okay, trans people, being trans is not just
00:07:45 a matter of having surgery because lots and lots of trans people these days don't and some of them
00:07:50 have no i mean some are on waiting lists but some of them don't want to make massive changes to their
00:07:56 bodies um so you say okay so it can't be surgery and perhaps it's not even dress because you get
00:08:03 sort of non-conforming trans people who don't want to fit into the one or other category you know and
00:08:10 sometimes you could have a day off and you don't feel like dressing a certain way and so so there's
00:08:14 now hunting around for something well what is it that makes you trans oh it must be this inner state
00:08:19 that's persistent whether you dress a certain way or move your body you know um yeah change your
00:08:24 body a certain way so there's a kind of weird stripping back to what they assume is the kind
00:08:29 of essential property of transness now i don't think that works philosophically you know in
00:08:35 terms of motives why are they so focused on gender identity well i mean arguably they've done
00:08:40 everything they could do stonewall in terms of gay rights on a legal level so they need a new
00:08:46 revenue stream so i mean that's the more cynical always comes down to money yeah i mean it's given
00:08:54 them a huge boost in terms of profile in terms of projects all over the place because of course if
00:09:00 you're going to try and reconstruct um any area where sex was formerly relevant as a distinction
00:09:07 you know so which would include public spaces data collection um health education if you're
00:09:13 going to try you know that's a massive project to replace any talk of sex with gender identity
00:09:18 it's going to keep you going for years so would it be uh would it be a caricature to say that your
00:09:24 that your view is similar for example to jermaine greer's Kathleen i mean in in the in the essential
00:09:31 feature that i learned at the beginning i would say yes i mean jane is being i don't know jermaine
00:09:36 sorry I don't know I'm calling her Jemaine but you know I'll talk first if I do know her
00:09:40 um she's been uh vilified for making exactly the same point in a more colourful manner um so has
00:09:50 Julie Bindle uh various other people have too and I think that's outrageous I mean I think
00:09:56 there is they are essentially um stating what they believe they have reasons for it I think
00:10:03 they're right and why shouldn't they express it in a colourful way it may not be that respectful
00:10:08 but it's they certainly don't deserve the kind of hounding that they've had and I think this
00:10:15 connects in with another aspect of the book which is when I go into the nature of the fiction
00:10:20 involved I think it's a fiction that trans women are literally women and I think therefore there
00:10:25 can be a whole lot of outrage around exposing that as a fiction because that's something to
00:10:29 do with the nature of fiction we don't want to know that is not true so that is actually your
00:10:35 background uh discipline isn't it uh it's not actually it hasn't been this area has it no no
00:10:41 i mean i've spent most of my philosophical life um writing about imagination fiction and pretense
00:10:47 in a sort of literary context or artistic context but um it seems to me and it has always seemed to
00:10:56 me really clear that when people say I have changed sex or you know I used to be a man
00:11:03 and now I'm a woman or I was never a man you know even when before I transitioned I was really a
00:11:09 woman now some of them believe those statements literally but not all of them do and I think
00:11:15 they're engaged in a perfectly reasonable and understandable human practice which is immersing
00:11:20 yourself in a fiction for various purposes you might have none of them need be sinister I mean
00:11:26 I think we get involved in fictions all the time as humans. So I try to explain what I think the
00:11:30 value of that might be, but also what some of the pitfalls might be as well. We're hearing at the
00:11:36 moment quite a few instances, well they're pretty much always in the news, about changing rooms and
00:11:44 things like this on an everyday basis. But there are particular ways in which this really affects
00:11:52 women aren't there i mean could you explain to us obviously we know you know we have had examples of
00:11:59 a man who identified as a woman being put in a woman's jail and then assaulting the women this
00:12:04 sort of thing um and also what i what is extraordinary to me is that we've got we're
00:12:10 getting cases now for example there was a student in dundee recently who just happened to say in
00:12:15 fact i would say what you say which is that it's a biological fact um and uh apparently has been
00:12:21 virtually cancelled at least in the confines of the university uh women are becoming the victims
00:12:27 victims of this very thing are they not yes and so i think those are different issues but related
00:12:33 so if i take the space issue first um you know women are overwhelmingly the uh victims of sexual
00:12:42 assault it's just a basic statistic and it's derived from partly from the fact that men are
00:12:48 on average bigger and stronger than women and have a many of them have a heterosexual interest
00:12:54 in women and therefore it's obviously beneficial to women to have spaces where
00:13:00 you know as a as a rule of thumb anyone who looks male entering can be um called out and said no
00:13:08 sorry you're in the wrong place because that's a way we can't police you know changing rooms and
00:13:12 bathrooms on a national level we have to have social norms that allow women to say you don't
00:13:19 belong here relatively firmly now what we have um in thanks to stonewall advising national
00:13:25 organizations that gender identity is the sort of um kind of almost a moral reason why uh
00:13:33 males with female gender identity should be allowed into women's spaces um the policies
00:13:39 in many many organizations now say you can self-identify your way into whichever space
00:13:45 feels to you the right one they you know they explicitly say this as part of their policies now
00:13:50 that's a recipe for disaster I think in terms of the original purposes for which these spaces were
00:13:57 set up the only reason we're not seeing more malfeasance is because not that many people
00:14:04 know about those policies and they're still going by the old rule of thumb but we are seeing
00:14:09 some examples and we're also seeing and so i'm sorry i just want to be clear that's not a claim
00:14:14 about the malfeasance of trans people particularly it's a claim about the malfeasance of males
00:14:20 whether or not they're trans that statistically some proportion of them will be uh will have
00:14:27 you know sinister intentions so um what we're also seeing is fear anxiety uh loss of privacy
00:14:35 you know kind of um a real anti-democratic move to radically change these spaces and men are not
00:14:44 going to notice this as much because it's not trans men you know identifying their way into
00:14:50 male bathrooms or changing rooms half as much and the threat isn't there for for men you know
00:14:56 they're not worried about what would happen if that did become commonplace so um that's the space
00:15:02 issue and then the free speech issue is related of course women are more worried about this they
00:15:08 want to speak out about it more it's their category above all that seems to be shifting
00:15:13 rather than a kind of stepwise um movement and and it's easier to tell women to shut up
00:15:21 you know so i'm both women and men do this i'm not saying it's men that are telling them to shut
00:15:26 up i'm fairly sure that that abate example you mentioned will be there'll be women involved in
00:15:31 in monstering this poor woman but but it is easier if you've got a choice between um trying to shut
00:15:37 down a man's speech and a woman's speech i would say strategically you might as well go for the
00:15:41 woman's because society will help you in that i think as well people feel passionately you know
00:15:48 when they are presented with the way in which the language is being changed particularly by the
00:15:53 bureaucracy if you like uh in the way that now we talk we hear people with cervixes people who
00:16:00 menstruation it's it's almost like women are being you know the whole idea of a woman is is somehow
00:16:06 or other being traduced yeah i mean that that kind of shift so is purely based on this kind of
00:16:16 fantasized projection onto trans people mainly by non-trans people that if they hear any reference
00:16:22 at all to womanhood or manhood like you know any kind of general claim like women have periods
00:16:29 they will you know trans men will feel affronted and maybe even trans women too you know because
00:16:34 they can't have them so now we need to sort of change the language to to avoid the affront and
00:16:42 that's just a crazy practice because we need language for more purposes than avoiding affront
00:16:48 we need clear communication and health for people that don't understand what cervix is but they do
00:16:53 know what a woman or a female is for instance um it's an exceptionally sort of middle class
00:17:00 university derived movement this and it's not really thinking about how these changes impact
00:17:07 on people who don't understand this gender studies stuff um but also it's just kind of profoundly
00:17:14 stupid because people with the cervix is no less biological you know as a descriptor it's arguably
00:17:21 more reductive and more um dehumanizing um and certainly doesn't take you out of the biological
00:17:29 realm so i just think the whole thing's preposterous yes one thing that was i found extraordinary in
00:17:39 your book was the number of people who identify now as being trans having shot up i mean i think
00:17:47 it's around about 2004, 2,000 to 500, 2,000 to 5,000, something like that in the UK. And
00:17:56 I think in 2018, it is, Kathleen, it was something like, well, Stonewall say 600,000,
00:18:03 the government says up to 500,000. I mean, you know, what do we make of those figures?
00:18:08 Is that just simply because the argument in the terms of reference have changed or what?
00:18:13 it's it's partly that because originally um the numbers were based on assumptions about who would
00:18:23 apply and get a gender recognition certificate um and it was assumed that there would be some
00:18:30 meaningful what they call meaningful social transition which you know i don't think changes
00:18:35 your sex but it does may change your body surgically through injecting hormones over a
00:18:39 long period of time or having your genitalia reconstructed um and it would involve cross
00:18:45 dressing and things like that now again when the move the sort of activist focus became gender
00:18:51 identity then it automatically expanded the category because you don't have to be doing
00:18:55 those things anymore it's just a matter of how you feel how you describe yourself to others
00:19:00 and it includes this new category not thought of i don't know by many 30 years ago um which is
00:19:08 non-binary people and it's a you know it's a trend amongst younger people to describe themselves as
00:19:15 non-binary they don't want she or he pronouns they want to be described as they or some other
00:19:20 kind of made-up pronoun um and that's that's expanded the category enormously of course it
00:19:26 suits Stonewall to say that there has been a huge increase in trans people because then they can
00:19:31 get some um credibility for their project there but um it's definitely this huge category now
00:19:40 contains people of very different kinds you know it contains young same-sex attracted
00:19:47 girls and boys who are now describing themselves as non-binary or as trans
00:19:52 and they may be transitioning from completely different reasons to 50 year old heterosexual
00:19:58 males who are married who continue to be married to a woman um and who now cross-dress in public
00:20:05 you know those are different demographics and i think we need different understanding of those
00:20:09 but they're being pushed together in this big category and the common fact is supposed to be
00:20:13 gender identity gender identity uh so basically with non-binary it's sort of what we used to call
00:20:23 Or bisexual or unisex or what?
00:20:27 No, no, no.
00:20:27 It's not about sexual orientation, although that's in there somewhere.
00:20:32 But it's about feeling that you neither, I mean, I use the words of the activists or Stonewall's definitions, but roughly you neither identify as a woman or a man.
00:20:44 Oh, I see.
00:20:45 So you're androgynous or you identify with androgyny as a kind of ideal psychologically.
00:20:50 you don't feel you fit firmly in one category or another you maybe you feel
00:20:55 you fit in both so it's something like that isn't it need have nothing to do
00:20:59 with sexuality sexuality is another set of identities now that you can add on as
00:21:03 it were but they can cross cross cut so basically somebody like Sam Smith
00:21:10 recently calling himself non-binary and therefore he's referred to as they they
00:21:15 yes they refer to as they right I mean Kathleen I'm sure you we're both gay
00:21:24 people there there are consequences too for gay people in this aren't there well
00:21:30 absolutely because although I said you know bisexuality and non-binary this is
00:21:36 not the same category conceptually it's um there are multiple effects that this
00:21:42 is having on gay people um partly because the the group is now understood as the lgbt so um
00:21:51 again the the relevant differences between those groups are not are just being completely ignored
00:21:56 but the obvious difference is um that same-sex attracted people are precisely the clue is in the
00:22:03 name attracted to people as of the same sex as themselves now that's a reference to sex twice
00:22:09 your sex and the sex of the people that you are interested in as um trans activism tries to
00:22:17 evacuate our language of reference to sex it wants to replace that with gender identity
00:22:21 so now being gay is a matter of having a gender identity that's the same as the gender identity
00:22:27 of the people you're attracted to which leaves us with the absurd conclusion that um a male
00:22:34 who transitions who who becomes a trans woman but who stays in in my terminology heterosexual
00:22:42 that is stably attracted to females can count as a lesbian so right because they're they've got a
00:22:49 female gender identity and the people they're attracted to allegedly have female gender
00:22:52 identities so we have this new phenomenon of trans women describing themselves as lesbians
00:22:57 and and so you know again we've lost the word to refer to the original phenomenon and this has
00:23:05 practical negative consequences um in terms of protecting the rights of gay people as originally
00:23:13 understood and also i think specifically in the area of young people um because young people who
00:23:21 are trying to get to grips with their own sexuality are now being told you know there's a possibility
00:23:28 at least that they are trans they are in the wrong body maybe they're a boy in a girl's body or a girl
00:23:33 in a boy's body and it turns out that this is more likely to happen or these feelings are more likely
00:23:39 for you if you are gay right right so there's a high you know we're hearing from the Tavistock
00:23:46 gender identity service that one of the sort of predisposing factors to turning up in that clinic
00:23:51 as a child or adolescent is if you are same-sex attracted so that's one obvious knock-on effect
00:23:58 because and this has gone sorry cutting that's this has gone up hugely too hasn't it young people
00:24:03 presenting to the nhs i think it's gender development uh it's gone up for girls particularly
00:24:11 to fight by five thousand percent yes it's gone up hugely um again modern trans activist gives us
00:24:20 no opportunity to ask why that's happening the story is unrelentingly positive they are they
00:24:25 should be affirmed they are really boys or they are really not girls um and it turns out that
00:24:34 again predisposing factors may be being gay or being autistic or having trauma a history of
00:24:40 trauma so there's lots of complicated stuff going on there and they are not well served by an
00:24:44 activism which um says that any discussion of that is bigotry that we must affirm these
00:24:51 these kids um and we're seeing also the effects of this because there are now deep what are called
00:24:58 detransitioners that is people at a relatively young age who made decisions to alter their bodies
00:25:04 or at least to change their whole social persona and um the ones who took testosterone or who had
00:25:13 their ovaries removed or their breasts removed or had full hysterectomies in their early 20s
00:25:19 or late teens even are profoundly distressed now that the mists have cleared and they've
00:25:26 realised that this was just a phase for them and that nobody really told them that this would be
00:25:33 a phase because the surrounding rhetoric is so affirmative and positive and anyone who disagrees
00:25:39 with you as a hater and a bigot so this is just disastrous um particularly impacting on on lesbians
00:25:45 again who you know and butch lesbians in particular um and then another aspect of the impacts on gay
00:25:53 people gay young people is this what i just mentioned that trans women describing themselves
00:25:58 as lesbians there is a sort of really unpleasant aspect of activism which is saying
00:26:03 your preferences for the same sex as you are transphobic so you should open your mind to the
00:26:12 possibility if you're a lesbian you should open your mind to the possibility of sleeping with a
00:26:16 trans woman who is also a lesbian like you even though they've got a penis and you know they're
00:26:22 male so that's that's really against the grain of their sexual orientation and that that's
00:26:28 appalling too but again not being talked about so one thing that I always struck me about this as
00:26:36 well is that there's a very regressive nature to some of this because um you know there was a case
00:26:41 recently it was it was in the papers and it was on on television of a a little girl who said she
00:26:47 wanted to be a she was a boy 18 months old I think and the parents were being very affirmative about
00:26:53 this but the fact is is that the the old position used to be why should girls just always like pink
00:27:00 and why should boys always like blue and what if a boy wants to play with dolls anyway now
00:27:05 the fact is you know now we sort of gone back to a kind of almost Victorian idea that this
00:27:12 must mean that therefore they are actually a boy who does that must therefore be a girl in a boy's
00:27:20 body and we've gone back to that situation which is one that gay people fought against yes you know
00:27:27 yes it's tragic because um i don't think i saw i think you might be talking about a child that
00:27:34 was on this morning and was also in the paper i think they were four i mean obviously far too
00:27:39 early to take anything they say about this seriously i mean children are forming their
00:27:43 concepts of the world at this point they um there's no reason to think at all that they have
00:27:49 access stable access to womanhood and manhood and girlhood and boyhood such that they know that they
00:27:55 are not that but so it's really just the projections of parents and educators at that age
00:28:01 I think around a child um and possibly some anxiety about gender what I would say sex
00:28:07 non-conformity because I hate the word gender now it's just so so confusing but um yes you're right
00:28:13 ultimately when you um ask or read the narratives of trans people and i think there's nothing
00:28:20 wrong with this they say you know how did you know that you were a woman in a man's body or
00:28:27 how did you know you're a man in a woman's body it will it will be things like well like the man
00:28:31 will say i liked makeup i always played with the barbies i felt at home with the girls rather than
00:28:37 boys you know and that's i completely understand those feelings it's nothing to criticize those
00:28:42 feelings but the for the culture to say oh okay well in that case that's what makes you a woman
00:28:48 is of course completely regressive um and i i think it's just tragic that parents like the
00:28:56 parents of that child are taking this new religion on authority you know they're not
00:29:02 we can't expect everyone to think this through for themselves you know we'd like to know if
00:29:06 somebody tells them if schools and teachers tell that child you're a boy you know of course this
00:29:15 sort of thing is going to happen you have had your fair share of people uh you know getting
00:29:24 out you haven't you counting for the things that you have said and i mean what what is the what
00:29:28 what what form is that taken um well it's uh taken multiple forms i mean i i stress that i
00:29:38 mention this because i think people who are listening should take this as representative
00:29:42 of what happens to anyone in british universities any woman in particular who tries to say the
00:29:48 things i've said so it's not it's really an instructive tale and not i'm not just complaining
00:29:52 But I have had highly unusually virulent pushback to my relatively, you know, measured attempting at being as respectful as possible sort of argument.
00:30:09 So I've had open, several open letters against me or against publications that have published me.
00:30:18 I've had, you know, multiple forms of local harassment, as it were, to do with students or faculty in my own university.
00:30:30 i've had um people withdrawing from uh academic events if they know i'm there or else no platforming
00:30:39 me asking me to withdraw once it's discovered or or as people complain to the organizers about it
00:30:46 um i've had that i've there's been a volume dropped by an academic publisher at oxford
00:30:51 uh partly on the basis that i would be in it you know so this all adds up over time um
00:30:58 and it's not good for the state of free discussion about these very
00:31:05 I think important social issues that we are now facing that it takes you know
00:31:11 quite a lot of nerve to keep going yeah how is it sort of how do you do that actually personally
00:31:19 I mean I know you were you were talking there about this kind of thing look on this channel
00:31:24 you know we've talked to many different people certainly in the academic world so what you're
00:31:29 saying is is in fact very much what they've experienced in different ways um you know so
00:31:33 i absolutely understand that but how do you uh keep going i mean you know you've written
00:31:38 you've written this book here which i i think this is presumably doing well is it i hope it is
00:31:42 it's doing really well yes i mean at one point about five days after it was released it was
00:31:46 number 11 in the hardback non-fiction chart for the uk so i think that's doing quite well that
00:31:52 must be uh something actually that uh really does act as a boost um kathleen i mean
00:32:00 thank you so much for coming and talking about it um and i know that people will be very very
00:32:06 interested we'll get a lot of feedback on this i'm sure the book is actually called say material
00:32:12 girls why reality matters to feminism by kathleen stock i couldn't recommend it more highly um
00:32:20 So, thanks very much, Kathleen, and all the very best to you, and keep it up.
00:32:27 Thank you, Peter, I will.
00:32:29 Thank you very much.
00:32:30 That's it for what you're saying is this week, and we shall see you again next time.
00:32:35 Thank you very much.