New Culture Forum - July 15, 2021


Nick Timothy - Elites Regard Englishness As Dangerous & Embarrassing

Alexander Adams - Why The Left Hates Good Art Legendary Pollster Frank Luntz: The British Public Are Deeply Disillusioned

Episode Stats


Length

42 minutes

Words per minute

144.9

Word count

6,217

Sentence count

118


Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
00:00:00 Hello and welcome to So What You're Saying, I'm Peter Whittle. Now my guest today is somebody
00:00:27 who writes about politics but also has been at the very centre of politics.
00:00:33 Nick Timothy is a columnist for the Daily Telegraph.
00:00:37 He's also the author of the book Remaking One Nation, the Future of Concertism,
00:00:44 which came out this year.
00:00:45 It's going to be actually coming out in paperback in September.
00:00:50 But before that, he was right at the heart of politics
00:00:53 as special advisor to Theresa May when she was at the Home Office. And then after that,
00:01:00 Joint Chief of Staff at Downing Street when Theresa May was Prime Minister. So he's been
00:01:07 both sides of the divide, if you like. Thank you very much for joining us, Nick.
00:01:12 Thanks for having me.
00:01:14 It's a pleasure. I want to ask, before it behoves me to do this, how will you be,
00:01:21 well are you going to be watching tonight the football i will i've been watching uh all the
00:01:28 england games and actually uh quite a few of the other ones yeah uh this is an anglo-swiss
00:01:34 household so we've been cheering on switzerland uh as well as england but my wife is actually
00:01:39 uh half italian so it's a bit a bit difficult uh um uh but we'll be we've we've got a we've got
00:01:46 a nice big screen in the living room and we'll be oh i see watching in there with the kids so it's
00:01:51 going to be a home thing it's going to be a domestic thing it's not going to be some pub
00:01:54 or something yeah it's good i think i'm going to be in a pub on the seafront at plymouth uh
00:02:00 apparently that's the plan so we'll see but um interesting you wrote a piece i want to talk
00:02:07 to you about this this week in the telegraph which i thought you know obviously it was extremely
00:02:11 timely. But it was about England. It was about England and Englishness and English identity
00:02:18 and also about the need or not for an English parliament. Can I start by asking you, as
00:02:27 you say in the article, there is this view that English identity is, as you put it, thin,
00:02:34 that it doesn't amount to much. Who has that view?
00:02:40 Well, I think this is one of the emerging myths of the debate about the role of England at the
00:02:46 moment. So English identity and culture, I think, has been just ignored for quite a long time.
00:02:56 I think the English identity has been subsumed into a British identity for a matter of centuries.
00:03:03 And the English were, I think, by and large, were actually quite happy to do that.
00:03:08 And I think a combination of factors, which I think might be partly down to things like asymmetric devolution and the creation of national institutions to Scotland and Wales.
00:03:22 But also, I think, the increasing importance of identity and culture.
00:03:27 um but also i think all the sense that the british project the things that brought
00:03:35 uh the nations of the uk together firstly the imperial project second uh fighting fascism in
00:03:43 europe um uh have have weakened um and and the the the extent to which the english feel english
00:03:53 and not British is, or English as well as British, is changing.
00:03:58 And in response to that, I think a lot of people
00:04:02 in the kind of liberal centre and the left have ignored it.
00:04:07 It's inconvenient.
00:04:08 They find patriotism at the best of times pretty distasteful.
00:04:13 Remember Emily Thornberry and the flag.
00:04:16 But those, I think, who are starting to engage with it
00:04:21 are sort of propagating this myth
00:04:25 that English identity and English culture
00:04:28 isn't really a thing, that it's very thin,
00:04:31 it barely exists,
00:04:33 and in fact it's a kind of negative reaction
00:04:36 to others' identities,
00:04:39 which I think is completely wrong.
00:04:42 It is sort of quite extraordinary
00:04:44 when you consider how rich, actually,
00:04:47 English identity is.
00:04:49 It seems to me that when people do say, well, you say it's this myth of being thin.
00:04:56 It's almost like the people who claim that want it to be so.
00:04:59 Would you agree with that?
00:05:01 Yes, I think so.
00:05:02 I mean, I think it's probably connected to some of the assumptions of the sort of uber, ultra, hyper, whatever you want to call them, liberals,
00:05:11 who tend to ignore or are even hostile
00:05:18 to the specificities of place.
00:05:24 They don't really sort of appreciate
00:05:26 the institutional, cultural, legal contexts
00:05:32 in which things are done.
00:05:34 I mean, I think there are actually quite long-lasting
00:05:37 philosophical reasons behind that
00:05:40 if you trace some of the early liberal thought.
00:05:45 But you see it in the way that people behave now
00:05:48 where countries are almost treated as platforms
00:05:51 upon which anybody in the world can do anything they like.
00:05:57 And the traditions and the institutions and so on
00:06:02 of that particular place count for very little
00:06:06 in the eyes of these people.
00:06:07 I also think there's probably a, it's quite convenient for them to argue that our identity and culture is thin
00:06:14 because it's an excuse for them not having taken our identity and culture very seriously for quite a long time
00:06:21 It does seem, obviously there's this, you know, very often quoted line from Orwell, you know, about the English intelligence
00:06:33 the English intellectual is, I think he said, is unique in the world in being ashamed of
00:06:39 their identity. And they'd rather steal from, as he put it, a poor box and stand for
00:06:46 God save the king, as it then was. I think that that view would seem to have spread as the so-called
00:06:56 intelligentsia has spread in the post-war years. Would you agree with that?
00:07:00 i mean i think there are plenty of people on the left who are patriotic um and there are some
00:07:08 people who are patriotic and may think of patriotism in a slightly different way to
00:07:13 those of us on the center right um and i think it's important that we don't um inadvertently
00:07:20 um attack some of those people i think there are there are many ways in which you can love
00:07:27 your country and you don't have to subscribe to an ideological uh or philosophical uh perspective
00:07:35 to do that but i think it is true that uh there is a um there there is a almost a self-hatred
00:07:43 um some now i think again i mean i think some of that is partly down to
00:07:49 um ideology because there's a there's this sort of trend towards so-called anti-colonialism
00:07:57 um uh and and there's a lot of self-flagellation about britain's own uh history of empire uh you
00:08:05 might argue their anti-colonialism is somewhat late uh and not necessarily relevant to today's
00:08:11 england and to today's britain um uh but i think um but as i say i mean i think some of it comes
00:08:18 down to the fact that um there's this appreciation of all sorts of cultures from around the world
00:08:25 which is right we should enjoy all those cultures um um but uniquely there is one culture which is
00:08:32 not to be liked and not to be enjoyed and that is our own uh and i think orwell was was right then
00:08:38 and as you say uh the the the people guilty of the thing that he described uh are perhaps larger
00:08:45 in number now than they were then yes i think there's a kind of what you might call a kind of
00:08:51 lumpen intelligentsia now you know who would broadly go along that but i i would i would
00:08:57 totally agree i think a man like say tony ben would have been real patriot but i mean in a very
00:09:03 strong radical tradition i mean like a cromwellian tradition almost you know um and i i think that
00:09:10 you know that that doesn't stop someone being patriotic i suppose what i'm trying to get to
00:09:15 the nub of which i think is very important is this you mentioned this self-hatred i mean we're
00:09:20 about the football earlier around this time i mean you know there have been a few conversations that
00:09:25 i've had with people and you can tell that they're actually slightly disappointed that england are
00:09:31 doing well they you know you've had these comments like i feel sorry for the danes or the danes were
00:09:36 robbed and you sort of think what is your motivation for that you know yeah i mean i think
00:09:43 that's certainly true um i mean i don't know how many people are actually like that and sometimes
00:09:49 I think in this age of social media, some fairly extreme minorities have their voices amplified more than perhaps they should and maybe give a misleading impression of broader opinion.
00:10:06 But there's definitely a certain kind of person who pretty angry saw about Brexit, who sort of would like a European country to show us a thing or two, I imagine.
00:10:18 yes um uh but i think to be honest there's a bit of a danger i think in uh in drawing or trying to
00:10:25 draw um very political conclusions from the performance of a football team i mean in the end
00:10:31 um uh you know if we win this evening or uh or lose um that will be down to quite obviously
00:10:41 uh questions of football and tactics and strength of character and things like that
00:10:47 There are people who are trying to draw, maybe from a pro-Brexit perspective, some conclusions about what an English victory might be.
00:10:56 And there are people on the other side who are trying to make arguments about how this is a great vindication of high levels of immigration or whatever, which is pretty silly at the end of the day.
00:11:09 Football matters a lot to football fans like me, but the political conclusions you can draw from them, I think, are fairly limited.
00:11:16 yes um i just would go back to one thing you said earlier about the british the idea of the british
00:11:21 sort of imperial project sort of having sort of coming slowly to its end um i don't know whether
00:11:27 this was the reason but i remember my parents um we always refer to ourselves as british so far as
00:11:33 i remember but there was a sort of imperceptible time around about i'd say 20 years ago where they
00:11:39 suddenly started calling themselves English and you know they were not you know the sort of
00:11:47 political people who would have done that very consciously but I think it was almost like there
00:11:53 was a feeling that something was being lost and it had to be held on to you know and I think that
00:11:59 if you look at the football in 1966 you know it was all Union Jacks wasn't it and and from the
00:12:07 90s onwards as indeed it will be tonight it will all be the george flag won't it i mean
00:12:12 there is a growing consciousness would you say yeah i think so and actually i mean the
00:12:18 maybe for maybe football played a part in this uh but i mean i think it was really striking if
00:12:24 you look back at the pictures from 1966 as you say everyone's waving a union jack and come euro 96
00:12:29 30 years later and this was before uh things like a scottish parliament so it's you know it's kind
00:12:37 of evidence that this isn't a reaction against kind of political scottishness or whatever um
00:12:43 uh the people were waving the cross of saint george i think and the interesting thing for me
00:12:49 i think is um is the rise of the salience of english identity um is not i think an anti-union
00:13:00 or an anti-British thing, they're complementary.
00:13:05 And where I think this takes you,
00:13:10 where you start to ask questions,
00:13:11 well, how do you give effect to that identity?
00:13:15 How do you create the kind of democratic
00:13:18 and institutional manifestation
00:13:24 of that identity and culture?
00:13:28 It's got to be done in a way that is,
00:13:30 complementary for the Union and for the UK. I think that's perfectly possible to achieve.
00:13:36 You said in your piece that you didn't think the way forward was English votes for English laws,
00:13:45 but that it should be in English Parliament. Yeah. I mean, I think the problem with what
00:13:54 we have at the moment is devolution is asymmetric. And we've never answered the question that was
00:14:04 first posed by Tam Dial, the Westlathian question about why it should be right that an MP representing
00:14:11 a Scottish constituency should fate on issues that affect England that have been devolved
00:14:16 in Scotland. But I think in many ways, the situation is actually a little worse than that.
00:14:21 Because if you think that's a perfectly valid question and a question that hasn't been answered on an individual matter.
00:14:31 But I'm very concerned about a future election in which we might have a UK government elected, which has no majority in England.
00:14:44 And as we've been reminded during the COVID crisis, the UK government is actually in so many ways, education, on policing, on the health service, not the government for the whole of the UK.
00:14:59 Sometimes it's the government for England and Wales, and sometimes it's the government just for England.
00:15:03 and if you have a government of the UK that is also the government of England elected without
00:15:10 a majority of seats in England you have a huge crisis of legitimacy for that government are
00:15:17 they able to legislate for issues relating to England if you have English votes on English laws
00:15:26 then you end up with parliamentary gridlock and an election that arises from that kind of context
00:15:34 pits england against the other nations of the uk and i think that's really dangerous potentially
00:15:40 ruinous for the union so english rates and english laws doesn't address that problem
00:15:46 and i think as soon as as soon as you accept that there needs to be parliaments in scotland and
00:15:54 Wales, you have to accept that there needs to be a parliament in England as well, because
00:15:59 there needs to be balance in the constitution. Otherwise, you will have crises like these
00:16:03 coming up from time to time.
00:16:05 What form would you say that this parliament should take? How should it be elected?
00:16:12 Well, to be honest, my view is that people who advocate for an English parliament at
00:16:21 this stage of the debate shouldn't be too prescriptive about about exactly how it should
00:16:26 work um i personally have uh no time at all for the idea of regional parliaments in england
00:16:35 some say that england is too big uh to fit into a federal model um i think my answer to that is if
00:16:44 that's true it's too big for the union full stop and that the solution to a large england inside
00:16:48 the UK cannot be to allow for circumstances in which England is governed by governments
00:16:58 that don't have democratic legitimacy there.
00:17:02 So I think there does need to be a parliament for England.
00:17:06 That gives rise to all sorts of questions.
00:17:09 Well, if England is so large inside the union, does that mean it needs to be accompanied
00:17:15 with guarantees of a certain amount of decentralized government.
00:17:20 So the English First Minister isn't too powerful
00:17:23 vis-a-vis the UK Prime Minister.
00:17:26 What does this mean in terms of your constitutional laws?
00:17:31 Does it need a formally codified constitution?
00:17:34 I don't think it necessarily does.
00:17:36 Obviously, there are questions about things like electoral systems
00:17:40 and issues like those.
00:17:45 It also, I think, gives rise to the question about the future of the House of Lords.
00:17:51 I would personally say it's an opportunity to put that constitutional monstrosity out of its misery.
00:17:59 And maybe the Lords could become the Parliament for the UK.
00:18:07 And then obviously there would be questions about how you would organise the composition of that Parliament.
00:18:13 would it be directly elected would it be uh would it would it be filled with members from each of
00:18:20 the national parliaments uh there are all sorts of questions like this there's no point in somebody
00:18:24 like me at this stage of the debate saying i think it needs to be exactly like this uh it's uh it's
00:18:30 obviously a long way away from uh from i think it seems pretty it would seem to me to be pretty
00:18:35 obvious that it would be done on some form of proportional representation though i mean because
00:18:40 that's generally the way these things are going isn't it i mean you know it's very hard to actually
00:18:46 have a first past the post uh to just well it's not hard to justify it but it just seems to be the
00:18:53 drift of things that's the way things are done it seems to me that i i quite strongly disagree
00:18:59 i would say what you said very unconservative uh you're surrendering to uh the the logic of
00:19:07 progressive thought uh and the problem with progressive thought is who gets to define what
00:19:11 progress is yes um it's quite often people who don't reflect what the public wants at all
00:19:17 no um fair point taken i i think though isn't wouldn't you say that if you have a federal system
00:19:23 i don't want to label the point you you said you know this is just the idea but if you have that
00:19:29 kind of system then the one thing really keeping it together will be the crown won't it yeah and i
00:19:35 think um i mean i think we're coming at this from the question of english identity but um
00:19:45 i also think that a federal system is um is a there's a strong argument for it from from the
00:19:53 perspective of scotland and wales as well and in particular scotland because unlike with devolution
00:19:59 now i would say to the scottish people look firstly this is serious because we're doing it
00:20:06 for england as well uh so you know it's real uh second um you have responsibility instead of now
00:20:15 where the government says um you know when it emerges when it emerges from its moments of
00:20:22 complacency and enters into its panic mode uh and says oh god we might lose scotland we'd better
00:20:29 throw a bit more devolution at them instead of doing that it basically says apart from these
00:20:37 things where we are unambiguously better together and where we need to do things for the for the
00:20:44 collective good whether that's macroeconomic policy defense foreign policy international trade
00:20:51 the maintenance of the uk single market and so on other than these things and we can decide what
00:20:58 those things are other than these things you're responsible for everything you can do everything
00:21:03 tax raising powers whatever you whatever you like um and and then the arguments for scottish
00:21:11 independence i think are um a lot weaker because what is it that you want that's different to this
00:21:18 um uh you would ask a nationalist and and then the things that are left uh are the things that are
00:21:26 I think according to all the research
00:21:29 among the most popular things
00:21:31 about the union in Scotland
00:21:32 the currency, the royal family
00:21:34 the military
00:21:36 and so on
00:21:38 so I think from the perspective
00:21:40 of the union
00:21:42 it would be
00:21:44 I think quite a powerful
00:21:46 solution
00:21:48 but yes I mean I think you're right
00:21:51 that
00:21:51 the number of things that are done
00:21:55 clearly together and as set out in statute would be far more limited now yeah but the
00:22:04 and the crown would be a really important part of what keeps us all together alongside all of this
00:22:11 you would still need to have I think a concerted effort to create institutions and defend and
00:22:22 renew sort of traditions and habits for things that we do together as the four nations of the
00:22:29 union before we sort of leave this topic when you were in your piece actually you talked about
00:22:40 and I think this is a terribly important point you know I've just been on the London assembly
00:22:44 for example I've just finished on London assembly and I mean essentially London has become you are
00:22:50 now a Londoner right if you sign up to kind of various values which apparently the city has I've
00:22:57 never known a city having values but apparently this is it it's no longer a shared story for want
00:23:05 of a better expression it's no it's no longer shared memories but you know even I would say
00:23:10 generation ago it probably still was but that is possibly the case is it not you know even
00:23:20 with with a nation you know with England that it's sort of we hear these very nebulous things
00:23:27 of tolerance and such like well you know most people would call themselves tolerant I think
00:23:33 even if they're not um what do you for you what for you is englishness it's a really i know that
00:23:43 there are books written about this i know so it's a very it's not a fair question but i mean
00:23:47 what would you say it is for you i think it is a fair question i think it's a really important
00:23:52 question i'm glad you asked it because um i think politicians get themselves into a real mess
00:23:58 when they talk about these things so you quite often hear uh i remember do you remember gordon
00:24:05 brown wanted to create a national motto um because he was he was desperately trying to define
00:24:12 it could have been uh it could have been that bigoted woman that would be quite a good model
00:24:16 and that's quite a good example of of what's wrong with values i'll come on to that
00:24:22 um um but they quite often say oh you know britishness is the bbc or the nhs um and
00:24:32 actually institutions do help to contribute towards identity but obviously it's that's not
00:24:38 the beginning and end of it uh and sometimes they say it's values and the problem with saying
00:24:45 its values is
00:24:47 human values
00:24:50 and interests are in constant
00:24:52 conflict with one another.
00:24:54 I might have a different
00:24:56 value system to another Brit.
00:24:58 I might have a pretty similar
00:24:59 value system to somebody
00:25:02 from France.
00:25:05 What I think is the right balance
00:25:08 between conflicting values
00:25:09 on say
00:25:11 security or justice might change according to whether we're at war or in the midst of a very
00:25:23 serious terror threat. The clash of values is inevitable and will continue forever, but will
00:25:33 also continue changing forever. So you can't say a country has a certain set of values
00:25:41 because I might share the values of somebody from another country.
00:25:47 I might disagree with the values of somebody in this country.
00:25:49 You may say that there are some values that are not welcome here.
00:25:55 And I think that's legitimate.
00:25:59 But you can't define a country in terms of values.
00:26:02 To me, a national identity is a bit like a family.
00:26:07 and and actually this comes to why it's important because it's the shared identity we have
00:26:17 is what allows us to recognize familiarity and a stranger and that familiarity gives you
00:26:26 a sense of trust and an expectation of reciprocity and the solidarity that
00:26:34 we need for nations to work whether that's in extremis the willingness to go to war alongside
00:26:42 one another to protect one another's families and our land and our home or in peacetime whether
00:26:50 it's about being willing to abide by some laws or rules that you might not like because you know
00:26:56 others are abiding by laws and rules that you think are right or whether you might pay more
00:27:02 in taxes to fund infrastructure in a part of the country you rarely visit or or to pay for
00:27:09 public services that others might use and and where do we get that familiarity from it's in the
00:27:19 shared stories and shared memories and shared moments and shared places and shared institutions
00:27:28 so you may meet somebody who's british or english and you'll recognize the familiarity
00:27:37 in one another very quickly even if you've never met because you might talk about you know the
00:27:43 football tonight or what happened in coronation street on wednesday or find out that your
00:27:48 grandparents came from the same part of the country and you both love you know the yorkshire
00:27:52 dales or something it's grounded in place and institutions and language and memories and
00:28:01 sometimes those memories might be myths right we can all argue about whether britain truly stood
00:28:05 alone in 1940 or backed by the empire and so on and so on but the myths are important because they
00:28:12 are ours and we recognize the stories they they they help us to be familiar with one another and
00:28:19 they inspire us to get through difficult periods and to be better than we might otherwise be.
00:28:26 And to me, that is what it is all about. It's not about tolerance, however virtuous tolerance
00:28:35 might be. It's a different question.
00:28:40 You might say that that is maybe one of the reasons why many people seem to be, and I
00:28:47 would say absolutely rightly uh utterly bewildered and and and indeed furious by what appears to be
00:28:55 the attack on our history so so therefore you could say that in fact that that memory those
00:29:01 sets of memories those personal shared things are being undermined and therefore you know the
00:29:08 response is a very emotional one isn't it yes i think that's completely right i mean we can
00:29:14 try to work out why those things are being attacked but the very things that are bringing
00:29:22 us together i think some of them are some of them you could argue are growing a little weaker just
00:29:28 through kind of organic change you might say the church of england might be one of those
00:29:34 yeah um uh you know arguably the bbc might be one of those as technologies change and
00:29:41 you know we don't we don't watch tv in the same way as we did 30 years ago so when you're at work
00:29:49 and you're talking about the uh the the climax to uh whatever drama uh was on tv last night it
00:29:57 doesn't work like that now because people are watching it um by streaming and so on so some
00:30:02 of these things are a bit organic but i think some of them are uh a growing weaker through
00:30:08 political choices uh and political attacks um and uh and instead of instead of trying to renew
00:30:16 and strengthen the things we're talking about which i think is what politicians really need
00:30:21 to be doing right now uh and you know it is it is harder to forge shared identities when you're in
00:30:29 a multicultural society because you know multicultural by definition means there are
00:30:33 differences. So we've got to try to find ways of creating and building up the shared identities
00:30:40 despite those divisions and differences. Instead of building those things up, a lot of political
00:30:47 positions are actually attacking them and weakening them, whether that is through the
00:30:53 education system at schools and at universities, whether it's about symbols of our history with
00:31:00 statues um uh and and sometimes it's about uh you know the institutions themselves you know a lot of
00:31:09 you know why is the national trust behaving as it is why is it why is it um giving in to some of
00:31:18 these political pressures coming from the left uh it's i don't think it's by conviction i think it's
00:31:23 because they're afraid but we need institutions like the national trust to keep on telling
00:31:28 our national story and to and to keep us in touch with things that have happened before us
00:31:35 um on this point uh nick you know with uh whether it's our history and and the need to
00:31:43 uh keep healthy of national memories and a sense of family uh on the general cultural points which
00:31:51 are connected obviously they're all connected at the moment do you sense that the government
00:31:58 and the administration, for want of a better word,
00:32:02 do understand and take these things seriously?
00:32:06 I mean, would you say that on an intellectual
00:32:09 or an emotional level, they really do?
00:32:13 I think increasingly ministers do, actually.
00:32:19 I think some conservatives are pretty worried
00:32:25 about getting involved in these arguments
00:32:28 because they dislike the idea of a culture war.
00:32:34 And I get that.
00:32:35 I mean, a culture war is not a very nice thing.
00:32:38 But if somebody is waiting war against you,
00:32:41 at some point you have to decide to defend yourself
00:32:43 and promote your own side.
00:32:46 And I think it feels to me
00:32:49 that ministers are increasingly prepared to do that.
00:32:54 and i think and i think oliver dowden as culture secretary has been prepared to do that um
00:33:01 but i think some conservatives just wish the political dividing line was about the economy
00:33:09 that's why a lot of them came into politics they don't really want these kinds of arguments
00:33:13 some of them find it a bit uncomfortable some of them might not even agree
00:33:16 um uh but i think ministers increasingly get it the broader problem they will face i think
00:33:25 is how do you how do you encourage the wider public sector and actually increasingly what
00:33:35 do you do about the private sector with lots of businesses uh especially the multinationals going
00:33:40 woke um uh what do they do about those things because as i say i don't think this is a
00:33:47 this is a sort of widespread thing where lots of senior leaders middle managers have suddenly
00:33:55 been persuaded of the arguments of critical race theory or anything like that um i think those
00:34:02 people are uh often just acting out of fear uh so they haven't been empowered they haven't been
00:34:08 uh informed um about how to push back uh and how do you confidently hold the line
00:34:17 in a way that's respectful you know nobody should tolerate racism but that doesn't mean
00:34:23 that we should accept that absolutely everything needs to be racialized in line with some of these
00:34:27 theories um everybody should be polite to trans people um but that doesn't mean that we should
00:34:34 sacrifice the security and privacy of women. So it should be done in a respectful way. But I think
00:34:41 those people need to be informed and empowered to use their common sense and hold the line when
00:34:49 they come under quite serious personal and professional pressure sometimes. And then I
00:34:55 think there's another question as well, which I think is a bigger one, which is to what extent
00:35:01 are the big legal frameworks that these organizations operate within the equalities act
00:35:09 the equalities act the human rights act to what extent are these legal frameworks um driving some
00:35:17 of this behavior and to what extent are they um and you know in a context um where political
00:35:25 pressures are very different to the ones that were uh that existed at the time that those
00:35:32 acts were introduced uh to what extent are they part of the problem and to what extent
00:35:36 do they need to be reformed or replaced yeah yeah um do you think that
00:35:46 boris johnson has understands these issues i mean i remember you know on the channel last year we
00:35:52 we covered for example you know the sudden attack on the built environment you know heritage
00:36:00 environment and there was great frustration that it was so slow the response was so slow
00:36:07 but would you say he understands it
00:36:14 i mean i think he does um i think he
00:36:17 doesn't want to give the impression that he is staking the culture war that he's sort of rushing
00:36:26 into it um that he's using it for political advantage or glorying in it and i think i think
00:36:35 a lot of conservatives are slightly worried about um becoming the republican party of america
00:36:42 and the way in which the Republicans
00:36:47 quite gratuitously fought the U.S. culture war.
00:36:54 They don't want to appear like that.
00:36:56 And I think they're right to worry about that.
00:36:59 I mean, as I say, I mean, I don't think
00:37:01 I don't think conservatives need to cross the road
00:37:03 to start these arguments.
00:37:06 There's enough of them already.
00:37:08 um i think conservatives need to um uh to basically hold a line of common sense
00:37:16 of polite common sense um and and so boris i think has um you know he's intervened in
00:37:26 some of these arguments when it comes to um things like what happened in the black lives
00:37:30 matter protests and the attacks on the senator statue of churchill um and he's backed it up
00:37:38 with action you know they're changing the law um uh when it comes to protecting statues from
00:37:44 attack and he may not be wading it into wading into it um uh very personally but he's definitely
00:37:53 empowered some of his ministers uh to uh to make sure that um they are holding the line so i
00:38:02 mentioned oliver dowden the culture secretary is doing some of this um you know rob jenrick the
00:38:07 community secretary is uh has acted similarly uh gavin williamson the education secretary has
00:38:14 intervened about free speech on campus um so so you don't just have to judge the pm based on
00:38:22 what he says personally but on what he has allowed or encouraged his ministers to do and
00:38:29 it may not be as robust or as pervasive as um as some people would like but they definitely are
00:38:39 um i think becoming more robust than they were i think um you know you mentioned the republicans
00:38:46 there but i was thinking actually more of macron uh that essentially whatever we might think i
00:38:51 think he's been so robust on this. And the French seem not to ever have worried about
00:38:57 talking about cultural issues in frontline politics. And there's always been this sort
00:39:02 of reluctance, I think, in Britain. But that might be changing. I mentioned at the beginning
00:39:11 you were at number 10, famously. You're obviously now successfully writing, but do you miss
00:39:19 do you miss the kind of life of being in the center of of the whole thing like you know like
00:39:25 you are uh i mean yes and no um i mean it's it's quite difficult to uh do jobs like those and give
00:39:37 enough time to your private and family life uh and so my life now is much better balanced uh
00:39:44 you got married recently did you not you yes that's right that's right uh thank you um uh
00:39:52 and you know my life is much more balanced and uh and happier now as a result um but i think
00:40:00 the thing is if you're if you're driven by uh by public service and and political debate
00:40:10 and some of the ideas we're talking about and i am um then uh then you know you're always if
00:40:17 you're writing about it um then you're making a contribution yeah and it's a and it's a privilege
00:40:23 to do that uh it's a privilege to have a national newspaper column and have many people reading uh
00:40:29 your arguments um on a weekly basis and the same with uh people who um who are prepared to buy your
00:40:36 books um uh but at the same time i think you you do always think well um this is a reasonably
00:40:46 indirect way of influencing things and maybe uh um maybe it would be better to be in the thick of
00:40:53 it again uh and try to and try to serve more directly would you uh have another go um on the
00:41:00 political route you know uh standing for parliament or you know would you do that
00:41:05 yes maybe um i mean you can't you obviously can't say yes i plan to do that with uh with
00:41:13 great certainty because um in democracies it's not just down to you it's down to it's down to
00:41:18 the public the um for the party members to select you as a candidate and for the voters to choose
00:41:25 you um uh but i certainly haven't ruled out trying to do that at some point well look um nick thank
00:41:33 you very much for you know joining us today um and also well i mean i think obviously we're going
00:41:41 to say good luck if that's not bad luck to say that is it in football but good luck for the people
00:41:47 tonight for the team tonight um but i wonder maybe um you know six months time years time you'll come
00:41:54 back to talk to us again um you know when your book is your book is out in september by in
00:42:00 paperback isn't it the paperback edition is okay well maybe next year then um but thank you very
00:42:06 much nick timothy for uh for joining us today thank you thanks for having me um well that's it
00:42:11 for us to what you're saying is this week and um we shall see you next time in the meantime please
00:42:18 obviously do remember to subscribe won't you thank you very much
00:42:24 Transcription by CastingWords