New Culture Forum - July 09, 2021


Alexander Adams - Why The Left Hates Good Art

My Favourite Books...with Michael Collins Nick Timothy - Elites Regard Englishness As Dangerous & Embarrassing

Episode Stats


Length

34 minutes

Words per minute

173.79

Word count

5,980

Sentence count

164

Harmful content

Hate speech

3

sentences flagged


Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
00:00:00 Hello and welcome to So What You're Saying Is. Now around about this time all of our
00:00:29 institutions, including our arts institutions, are opening up. But what kind of art, what kind
00:00:36 of thing will they be displaying and exhibiting? It seems that a day doesn't go past now where
00:00:44 one or other of our institutions has gone entirely political as opposed to, if you like, artistic.
00:00:51 One such is the Institute for Contemporary Arts which opened this week and it's got a new
00:00:56 exhibition which is called war inner babylon which apparently would seem on the face of it
00:01:03 to be more about systemic racism in britain than anything artistic now what exactly is going on
00:01:12 what can we do about it if anything now with me to discuss this today i'm very very pleased we have
00:01:19 the artist, art critic and author Alexander Adams. Alexander is an
00:01:27 internationally exhibited artist. Here's a catalogue for one of his works. I think
00:01:33 you'll agree it's quite beautiful and he also writes for the Critic magazine and
00:01:38 indeed is the author of a number of books including most recently Culture
00:01:43 War which of course you know is a go straight to the heart of what we talk
00:01:47 about on this channel, and indeed Iconoclasm, which addressed as well this phenomenon which
00:01:54 we've seen over the past year of the assault on history and statues. Thank you very much for
00:02:01 coming, Alexander. Thank you. I mentioned there the Institute of Contemporary Arts. Now this is
00:02:07 a gallery in London. It's been going since the 1940s, isn't it? You have protested against what
00:02:14 they've been doing for quite some time, haven't you? Can you explain what this exhibition is
00:02:19 that's opened this week, this one I mentioned, War Inner Babylon, what is that? Well, judging
00:02:26 from the press release, because it hasn't yet opened, but judging from the press release,
00:02:29 this is going to be a collection of documentary materials, interviews, photographs, press
00:02:37 reports and presentation a live presentation which is centering on the issue of policing in
00:02:46 Tottenham and especially race relations in Tottenham and this is essentially all documentary
00:02:53 material there is no art involved at all and when I mentioned this to the culture secretary and the
00:03:00 ICA the ICA replied saying this was contextualization so basically admitting that it's not
00:03:05 heart at all that this is actually I would go so far as to say this is political campaigning by
00:03:11 proxy because they're inviting in activists political activists community activists to use
00:03:18 the ICA as a platform in order to push their ideas and I have to say now that I don't know
00:03:25 what their ideas are and I don't know the situation of policing in Tottenham and I take no no position
00:03:30 on that it may be a very worthwhile subject but I don't think it's a subject that's suitable for
00:03:35 publicly funded art gallery. But the things that I read this press release too and they seem to be
00:03:40 quite clear about systemic racism in Britain, the problem of the black response to policing,
00:03:48 it seemed to be actually quite clear actually what their agenda was and they also mentioned as well
00:03:54 the 2011 riots don't they in London and particularly Mark Duggan. Yeah so apparently this
00:04:00 this presentation, I can't really call it an exhibition, this presentation is centering on
00:04:06 the police shooting of Mark Duggan. Again, this is a serious issue. I don't feel qualified to
00:04:13 comment on it, but I do think that it's inappropriate for the ICA to be doing this,
00:04:18 I think especially because of two things. The first thing is it's using arts funding in order
00:04:23 to do political programming. This is actually, I think it's pretty much outlawed by the Charities
00:04:31 Commission. The Charities Commission says that charities cannot politically campaign
00:04:37 on anything other than their core subjects. So for example, if your organisation is Save
00:04:43 the Elephants, you can lobby for changes in laws to do with the ivory trade, because this
00:04:49 relates directly to your charity's function. However, an arts organisation can't simply invite
00:04:55 in political activists or social activists in order just to use the venue and the money
00:05:02 for political campaigning. This is complete misappropriation of funds, I would say.
00:05:10 And also, so it's breaking charity regulations. I believe also that it's using money that it
00:05:17 is taken in donations from companies private donors and the british taxpayer and using this
00:05:23 money that's earmarked for arts for political campaigning and i think that that's um it's
00:05:29 quite a serious ethical what actually if you take something like the institute of contemporary arts
00:05:33 what how much public money do they get i mean from what i can understand they've also had
00:05:39 various is it loans or something during this time of lockdown what what is what are we talking about
00:05:45 here what are the numbers uh well we're talking about hundreds of thousands i think back in 2013
00:05:49 they got over a hundred thousand pounds from the arts council um recently they've had some of the
00:05:54 covid sort of um support money so that's uh tens of thousands at least maybe over a hundred thousand
00:06:00 um so this is quite large large amounts of money and so that's the public money side so there are
00:06:08 two issues here as you just said there's what they're meant to do in their charter for want
00:06:13 of a red expression. And then there's what the charity commissioners should be looking at. Isn't
00:06:18 that right? I mean, you've approached both, haven't you? You've written actually not just on this
00:06:23 issue, but on other past issues. Can you tell us what that was about? Yes. So in October 2018,
00:06:31 the ICA invited Chelsea Manning, who's an American political activist, to come and speak at an event
00:06:36 hosted by the ICA, not in their buildings, but in a different building. But it was arranged,
00:06:40 it was hosted and it was promoted by the ICA. Chelsea Manning is a political activist.
00:06:45 The discussion was not about art. You can go through the transcript and you can go through
00:06:49 the tweets that were done at the time by the ICA. And there's no discussion of art at all.
00:06:55 Again, the ICA just says, well, this is contextualizing the social situation, which
00:06:59 I think is, if you use the contextualizing argument, you can get away with presenting
00:07:03 pretty much anything. Absolutely. So I wrote to the ICA and I wrote to the Charities Commission
00:07:08 and said, look, this is political campaigning from an arts charity,
00:07:12 but is there anything you can do about it?
00:07:13 And I basically got brushed off by the Charities Commission.
00:07:17 The Ministry of Culture didn't really give any sort of response.
00:07:21 This is Oliver Dowden?
00:07:22 Well, it was his predecessor, but it is now Oliver Dowden.
00:07:25 Ed Vasey, would that be?
00:07:27 I'm not sure. I can't remember.
00:07:29 But anyway, the department is very timid when it comes to confronting
00:07:35 arts organisations on political issues because I think that they're just they're afraid that
00:07:40 they're going to be called racist and xenophobic and so forth but this is public money isn't it
00:07:45 yes yeah and and guess what these organisations plus lots of media organisations are going to call
00:07:51 the conservative culture ministry run by the conservative government racist and sexist and
00:07:58 whatever they do so you're going to be called these things anyway just sort of step up and
00:08:03 protect the public money um so there was this case of chelsea manning the activist now we've got this
00:08:09 exhibition um it seems utterly clear on the face of it to me i mean i i haven't seen it yet
00:08:17 and i probably won't go and see it but it seems to me that essentially alexander this is the drift
00:08:26 of things this is the way things are going now you're an art obviously as I said very successful
00:08:32 artist and I would have thought first of all on a personal level it's quite a you plow a lonely
00:08:38 furrow if you in your world uh from what I would imagine isn't that right well yeah you you realize
00:08:46 that um I did realize sort of about 10 or 15 years ago that I was not going to be invited to the ICA
00:08:51 I was not going to have my pictures bought by the Tate Gallery I was not going to be exhibited at
00:08:55 the Whitechapel Art Gallery.
00:08:56 In previous eras, maybe I would have been.
00:09:01 I think maybe I have the ability.
00:09:03 I mean, I do very well exhibiting in museums around Europe
00:09:07 and there are collectors and corporations and so forth.
00:09:12 But I think, you know, I can see which way the wind's blowing.
00:09:15 And I understand that, obviously, taste moves in different directions
00:09:19 and I may not be flavour of the month.
00:09:21 But I feel like what we're seeing in the big public institutions is what I've called cultural entryism, where you have people who have very similar political aims and interests entering an organization in order to influence, control or destroy that organization.
00:09:40 and we've seen this in popular culture in franchises you know pop culture franchises
00:09:46 like sort of star wars and star trek and so forth um the american comic industry which i've reported
00:09:51 on and also you know in even in things like hobbies like the knitting the knitting hobby
00:09:56 that you get you get activists moving into these areas and taking them over and i believe that
00:10:00 that's what's happened in arts funding in britain well but you've written about this in the book
00:10:05 haven't you uh culture war is about entryism yes uh you know how this is the kind of 64 000
00:10:12 question how deliberate is that do you think i mean we did a book last year on the long march
00:10:18 institutions and uh basically uh mark civil wrote it and pretty much came to conclusion that yes
00:10:26 this had happened but that it was kind of a rather random thing and indeed it was actually also aided
00:10:32 and abetted by conservatives doing nothing about it do you think that that is it or do you think
00:10:37 entryism do you think it's sort of concerted well it looks concerted because it happens
00:10:44 from very many different directions with lots of different individuals and lots of different
00:10:48 organizations but i think it's more just confluence i think that if um you're a middle
00:10:53 class person you go to university you've been through british public schooling or i should say
00:10:58 state schooling, you go to university, you're taking the same sort of courses, you're learning
00:11:03 the same sort of thing, your professors are overwhelmingly left-wing, you're listening
00:11:08 to the BBC and ITV, Channel 4, you're reading The Guardian and so forth. How can you not
00:11:14 end up having a sort of a left-leaning world view? So what I think it is, I don't think
00:11:20 it's anything, it's not so much conspiracy as convergence, it's parallelism. People thinking
00:11:26 and talking in the same way and working towards the same end and having the same assumptions
00:11:30 and that's how you get these cultural you get these sort of political monocultures in public
00:11:36 life in public institutions especially the ones that are funded solely by the public so it's not
00:11:42 actually organized it's not directed people are not taking orders but they're just happening to
00:11:46 be working together towards the same ends. Well you know that the National Gallery which of course
00:11:51 is a not if you like a contemporary it's not a contemporary uh uh collection it's it's a it's a
00:11:58 for want of a better expression a heritage one um but it said last year something like the time has
00:12:03 come where we can no longer not be political i think the director of the national gallery said
00:12:09 and you sort of thought what are you talking about you know you're the national gallery
00:12:14 you're meant to curate a collection for the nation uh what did that is part of what you're
00:12:21 talking about isn't it? Yes you're also getting this in an English heritage we've seen that
00:12:25 already that there's been lots of conflicts between volunteers and lower members of the
00:12:32 organisation conflicting with the management which has gone very woke. I think the problem
00:12:37 is that what it is it's that you've got some these sort of left-leaning woke people who are
00:12:43 going to the top of organisations now just because of generational sort of replacement
00:12:48 and I think the ones in the heritage organisations feel a bit left out
00:12:53 because they're not like the Tate or the ICA.
00:12:55 They can't get in all these sort of black immigrant artists and so forth.
00:13:02 They can't set up displays of feminist art 0.62
00:13:05 when all the art they've got ends in sort of 1900.
00:13:08 So they're feeling a bit left out.
00:13:10 So what they have to do is they have to virtue signal and say,
00:13:13 oh, it's time to draw a line under our past
00:13:16 and to say that, you know, these past attitudes are wrong
00:13:19 and we have to step away from them.
00:13:21 And then what they do is they invite lots of guest artists
00:13:24 who are contemporary artists, and they invite in lots of women
00:13:27 and non-heteronormative artists and so forth
00:13:34 in order so that they can display that, oh, yes, to their friends
00:13:38 in the cocktail set, in the Guardian reading set,
00:13:43 they're part of the club too.
00:13:46 Yeah, so it's become about what you are, who you are, rather than actually the quality of your work, really.
00:13:52 Yes, sadly. I mean, it is kind of shocking that when you read the press releases from arts organisations,
00:13:59 especially public organisations, where they start off with this Nigerian-born woman artist,
00:14:05 well, it's kind of interesting, but then they're foregrounding the lived experience of this or that.
00:14:12 They're not talking about the arts. They're more interested in talking about the skin colour.
00:14:16 than the colour of the pictures.
00:14:17 Yes, exactly.
00:14:20 Do you see any end in sight to all of this?
00:14:27 Well, I'm not...
00:14:28 Honestly, I mean, you can be pessimistic if you like.
00:14:31 We're fine about that on this show.
00:14:33 Well, I'm afraid I'm going to have to be slightly pessimistic.
00:14:35 But I see the future as simply setting up organisations
00:14:39 that are not funded by the state,
00:14:42 that are independent of the state,
00:14:44 that individuals can have more control over,
00:14:48 so philanthropic organisations.
00:14:51 So you could have arts organisations, museums.
00:14:54 You could have organisations which fund particular events.
00:14:58 You could have prizes for more traditional crafts.
00:15:01 You could have art that's judged in blind terms.
00:15:05 So you have all the pictures, but you don't know the artist's name,
00:15:08 so you don't know their ethnicity or their political agenda,
00:15:11 and you just judge the work on the quality of the work,
00:15:13 which would be fantastic I think we need more people stepping up to back those sort of things
00:15:18 and I think that the public will move with them I think the public is really really tired of
00:15:23 political interfering and the finger wagging where they have artists especially artists coming in
00:15:27 from London to these regional venues and finger wagging and saying oh you're all racist you're
00:15:32 all backward oh you know that statue that you really like and that you voted to keep well did 0.58
00:15:37 you know about his connections with this slave trade or this colonial enterprise I think that
00:15:41 the general public is quite frustrated with this they're very tired they want art judged as art
00:15:48 and I think that they are actually very open-minded when it comes to gay artists black artists feminist
00:15:53 artists and so forth they're very welcoming if the art is good enough they're excited they will back
00:15:58 it they'll go and see it they'll buy the catalogs they'll maybe even buy a small print for their war
00:16:03 or something I think that there is a huge appetite for that and so I think that there is some cause
00:16:09 to be optimistic. I think the thing is that's a very interesting suggestion that you know this
00:16:13 idea whereby increasingly in in the workplace uh CVs are meant to not show anything about
00:16:22 the person almost to the point of being ridiculous but actually that is what if you actually had
00:16:27 pieces of art judged entirely just on the art without you knowing in a way who could possibly
00:16:34 disagree with that i mean isn't that the perfect anti-discriminatory way of doing it absolutely
00:16:40 but that's exactly why the woke types hate it hate it that's why they hate aesthetics they
00:16:44 consider aesthetics to be like a parlor game played by the intelligentsia and the and the
00:16:49 connoisseurs to keep out uh outsiders marginalized groups as they put it it's not the case at all
00:16:55 if you judge art on the best art you get someone like um uh jean-michel basquiat entering the
00:17:01 canon i think he's i mean people got different views on him i think he's a terrific artist he's
00:17:05 got loads of vitality and energy and he's bringing in ideas from pop culture and high culture and
00:17:10 street art and graffiti and so forth it's really exciting stuff and an artist like um frida carlo
00:17:16 so sort of part native heritage very strong sort of feminist outlook communist she's been embraced
00:17:22 by people because of the quality of her art and i think that we forget that the canon is always
00:17:27 absorbing the best art from any period and that the canon cannot exclude it can only include and
00:17:33 omit and that it's not run by sort of you know bearded patriarchs who are saying you shall never
00:17:39 enter black artists shall never enter women artists shall never enter no these artists are
00:17:43 already coming into the canon yes yes um do you think alexander that there is a dislike
00:17:52 of beauty as well amongst these people i mean we had uh an artist called jonathan miles leon a
00:18:00 while ago and this is very much one of his preoccupations and i think it rings true to me
00:18:05 there is a sort of you know this idea that somehow things that we would consider to be
00:18:11 transcendental and beautiful um are to be discredited there's a distrust of them even
00:18:18 a lack of understanding of them absolutely there is there is a real anger against nor
00:18:24 not just beauty but normality because the idea of beauty suggests consensus and of course
00:18:29 post-modernism tells us there is no such thing as consensus there's just simply power being imposed
00:18:33 being through being imposed through the canon and through language and through discriminatory
00:18:38 institutions and so forth so beauty is just an illusion being forced top down to control and
00:18:44 exclude marginalized groups so there was a real aggression against beauty and this even goes back
00:18:49 to soviet times where you know sort of soviet socialist realism art was directed to have
00:18:55 specific political aims and that uh it was very difficult to exhibit work that was just beautiful
00:19:01 because if you were just exhibiting something that's um entrancing an entrancing landscape or
00:19:07 a beautiful figure or a great still life or something this was a room for private contemplation
00:19:12 and for personal judgment yeah and of course once you're doing that you're stepping away from
00:19:16 the party telling you what is useful what is necessary so this is actually an act of um
00:19:22 rebellion to have private taste and private consumption so this goes all the way back to
00:19:28 soviet times don't you think that i mean the the one area i would have thought where this is
00:19:32 particularly strong is in public art you know art that's on display which has always been its own
00:19:37 particular category isn't it you know memorials often uh weren't necessarily there for great
00:19:44 uh you know artistic merit i mean they might have been very good but they they serve a different
00:19:50 purpose don't they but generally our public art now is shockingly banal or you know just
00:20:00 untalented isn't it well yes but this is partly the problem of the de-skilling of art schools
00:20:05 so a lot of art schools they don't actually teach um skills i went to art school myself
00:20:09 where did you go i went to goldsmiths in the early 90s actually it was just the generation
00:20:14 just a couple of years after uh damien hurst yeah so you had lots of want to be damien hurst
00:20:19 you know in our art studio sort of posing and taking photographs he's a particular favorite
00:20:23 with our viewers and he's uh yes so there was there was a lot of networking and a lot of such
00:20:29 there was a little bit of backstabbing as well unfortunately but um yes i've forgotten no no
00:20:34 No, I was just thinking, you know, basically, the de-skilling, in other words, the jettisoning of traditional methods.
00:20:44 Yes, there is this idea, there is this false idea that traditional skills and traditional materials are naturally allied to conservative worldviews and conservative outlooks.
00:20:56 I don't think that's the case.
00:20:57 I think that if you, the problem is, of course, if you learn a traditional skill, you actually learn, oh, actually, the craftsmen of ancient times actually knew what they were doing.
00:21:06 They were very, very skilled. And so actually there is a value in tradition.
00:21:09 And that's why the left hates it, because they want to say, oh, you know, tradition is just is just arbitrary.
00:21:14 It's being imposed. It's just it's completely false. It's not natural.
00:21:18 Well, no, actually, if you understand how to carve stone, you see, oh, actually, the Greeks did understand this and they were solving problems, you know, 2000 years ago.
00:21:26 So you do end up instilled with a degree of respect for tradition, which the left hates.
00:21:32 But you've also got this thing of having to, I don't think that you need to use traditional skills to tell traditional stories.
00:21:42 I think that you can do a bar relief in bronze that has a feminist subject or, you know, like a sort of black diaspora subject that you can put all sorts of messages into something.
00:21:56 And you can use traditional means and traditional methods.
00:22:00 I don't see a conflict, but the left tends not to feel that way.
00:22:04 And a lot of art tutors in colleges are now quite intimidated by the idea of craft and tradition,
00:22:12 because, of course, they weren't taught it themselves.
00:22:14 So it's very difficult for them to pass it on to their students.
00:22:17 So we had to do a lot of learning on our own, sort of testing things for ourselves in the studio.
00:22:23 And then a tutor would come in and say, oh, yes, actually, you've done that quite well.
00:22:26 if you're interested in that you want to look at this artist because he did it very well so go and
00:22:29 have a look at his works so they would give you advice rather than actual technical instruction
00:22:34 when you look around the landscape now we actually quite coincidentally before we you know
00:22:41 it happened before we knew we were going to be talking today this statue of diner went up for
00:22:47 example now you know people say some people say yes some people they like it others not but to me
00:22:53 it was a good example of the general deterioration for me anyway of standards of sort of craftsmanship
00:23:01 actually more than anything and shocking sentimentality i mean do you have a view on
00:23:06 on it or did you well i haven't i haven't seen it i think the problem with a lot of sculpture now is
00:23:11 that um it's it's too literal uh it can be too sentimental you you look at some of the some of
00:23:18 the great war memorials from the Great War,
00:23:22 the Jagger War Memorial especially,
00:23:24 where they combine pathos and dignity.
00:23:30 And this is very difficult to achieve,
00:23:32 especially if you haven't been trained in it.
00:23:35 So I think it's very easy to miss the mark
00:23:37 with a modern figurative sculpture
00:23:40 if you've not been trained in it.
00:23:41 I think the perfect example of that actually
00:23:43 would be the Cenotaph in Whitehall.
00:23:46 The Cenotaph by Lutyens is this extraordinary, and it just says the glorious dead.
00:23:52 It doesn't say the glorious dead men or anything.
00:23:55 But then along came in the 90s the sort of smaller black basalt sort of cenotaph for the women of World War II,
00:24:04 with all of their sort of coats hanging on the memorial, which you sort of thought, actually, this one was all-encompassing.
00:24:13 But we somehow can't seem to do that anymore.
00:24:16 Yes, and it's quite divisive when you start sort of separating people out.
00:24:21 And I mean, I think that a lot of people were quite upset
00:24:24 at the attack on the Cenotaph last year by the BLM protesters.
00:24:32 And also people on the left as well,
00:24:34 because you know that the people who died in the war
00:24:35 were not necessarily volunteering because they believed in the colonies in the empire.
00:24:42 Some of them went against their will.
00:24:43 Some of them fought because they were shamed to do it.
00:24:45 some of them fought for their families for their communities for their nation for their monarch
00:24:49 and some of them died unwillingly and many of them were socialists many of them were left-wing
00:24:55 they were working class but they joined the cause willingly or unwillingly and to have their memory
00:25:01 shamed is is quite despicable I think a lot of a lot of ordinary people found that quite revolting
00:25:06 when we just before we leave this public art thing of course this week we had announcement
00:25:13 of two of the things that are going to go
00:25:17 on the fourth plinth in Trafalgar Square.
00:25:20 And this is something which exercises
00:25:23 a lot of people's minds.
00:25:25 This plinth has been empty for a year.
00:25:26 You know, it should have had,
00:25:28 I think it should have had,
00:25:28 it was William IV, I think, on it originally.
00:25:32 For real purists, I think that's what it was.
00:25:35 But since then, they've had this revolving thing.
00:25:37 And the two examples they've got now,
00:25:41 which are going to go up,
00:25:42 but obviously intensely political.
00:25:44 One is sort of born obviously as a response
00:25:46 to the Black Lives Matter protest.
00:25:48 The other one is broadly speaking about the trans issue.
00:25:54 Do you know at all how has this come about?
00:25:58 I mean, how has it chosen, the fourth plinth?
00:26:02 Do you know? It's a committee, isn't it?
00:26:04 Yes, it's a committee.
00:26:05 I think that you've also got different organisations involved,
00:26:09 the arts council uh the london mayoralty uh the department of culture also gets involved so
00:26:15 they've all got they've all got their fingers involved in this and i think that they all tend
00:26:19 to say they they tend to think in very similar ways they have very similar outlooks um you're
00:26:25 not i i don't think you're going to see anything uh ever traditional there no i was um i i i'm
00:26:33 interested in following the colston issue because the colston statue the the edward colston statue
00:26:37 was toppled in bristol in 2020 in june 2020 and that's where you live that's where i live yeah so
00:26:43 i was actually quite familiar with that statue before it was toppled and uh interestingly enough
00:26:48 the when it was toppled um who could who was on twitter but stefan kalmar the director of the
00:26:55 ica who we started off with uh crowing about the fact that the location of the colston statue was
00:27:01 now in the river raven i think it's um a little bit rich for um a german curator who's a guest
00:27:08 in our country who's a being funded by the taxpayer to be celebrating the destruction of
00:27:13 british cultural heritage yeah what do you think then have you been to this new exhibit where the
00:27:22 colston statue is lying there graffiti have you seen this yeah no i've decided not to see it
00:27:27 because I consider it to be a trophy.
00:27:30 It's being presented as a trophy, as a defiled trophy,
00:27:33 that it's been captured, it's been despoiled,
00:27:37 and it's lying on its side.
00:27:38 I doubt that the Museum of London, for example,
00:27:43 would take a statue, the bust of Nelson Mandela,
00:27:47 if that was graffitied and thrown into the Thames.
00:27:49 I doubt that they would be taking it into the Museum of London
00:27:52 and showing it on its side covered in its graffiti.
00:27:54 I think it's a very definite political statement
00:27:56 of a captured flag yeah yeah uh you've obviously written a great length about this in these books
00:28:02 you have personally you know put some opposition up to as we talked about the icf
00:28:10 and unfortunately the responses have you know been should we say desultory
00:28:15 but what do you think people should do you mentioned the philanthropic institutions
00:28:23 but what do people what do you think people should do who love our artistic heritage and
00:28:28 do love beauty and are getting more and more despairing i mean you know we hear this thing
00:28:35 now of the monastery of the mind i had a guest uncle rob rob dear recently talked about this
00:28:43 whereby you just simply take the best of your artistic heritage and you take the best of
00:28:47 contemporary art and you just simply cherish it and you just simply no longer bother with this
00:28:54 other stuff easy said than done isn't it really yes it is i'm surprised you didn't plug your
00:28:59 organization save our statues dr all right okay because that's that's a fantastic way people can
00:29:04 can get involved so i know that the i know that the people on the right or just even just uh normal
00:29:10 people who were just sort of slightly socially conservative or they want to see the heritage
00:29:13 preserved regardless of their politics um they're they're pretty bad about getting involved the left
00:29:20 are very committed they're very organized they're very good with petitions they're very good with
00:29:24 pressure groups they're very good with lobby groups and they tend to get things done and people
00:29:28 on the right i just say people anyone who's not on the left is i'm on the right here so i'll just
00:29:32 say call that the right so people on the right just tend to say oh well that's a bit cringe i
00:29:37 don't really want to get involved it's a bit embarrassing i don't really want to go on a
00:29:39 march i don't really want to sign a petition but you need to you need to sign petitions you need
00:29:44 to get involved in these things you need to go to council meetings you need to write letters to your
00:29:48 mp and to your local council and i know it's boring and i know it's normie stuff but it does
00:29:52 make a difference and if you can if you can do enough of that you can get um you can maybe get
00:30:00 through the bubble the woke bubble that surrounds these councillors uh or these mps uh who spend all
00:30:06 their time sort of hanging out with sort of left-wing journalists and hanging out in sort
00:30:11 of the Channel 4 news studios and so forth. You can get through there by getting involved. And I
00:30:18 know that this other option that you've talked about, the sort of the Benedictine option, which
00:30:22 is like the idea of retreating to a monastery and allowing the rest of the country to sort of
00:30:28 decimate itself while you protect what you can. That's great in terms of traditions, skills,
00:30:34 teachings education books and so forth you can you can do that you can you can have these sort
00:30:40 of little fortresses of knowledge and of tradition and that's a good thing to have the problem is
00:30:45 that you can't do that when it comes to physical culture you can't move the cenotaph you can't you
00:30:51 can't move the art in the national gallery to these to these places where they're going to
00:30:56 be protected by traditionalists you're not going to be able to you're not going to be able to sort
00:31:00 paint your own rembrandts and carve your own canovas no so you have you have to you do have
00:31:06 to get involved with these organizations you do have to be a normie you do have to write letters
00:31:10 you do have to get it you do have to subscribe to the critic and the jack door the the newsletter
00:31:16 which is for sort of more um conservative outlook on the arts all right no i completely agree that
00:31:21 you know oh what you know you should write your mp something like that oh you say what's the point
00:31:26 of that you're not going to do anything what we found out as you said last year was actually it
00:31:30 really did make a difference not writing to the mp necessarily but these kind of putting into
00:31:36 local consultations about it really made makes a difference finally um alexander i wonder
00:31:44 do you think that people fully appreciate well what my view which is that this is a
00:31:52 outright attack actually on our very civilization i feel um our culture and civilization i don't
00:32:01 know whether you would go that far but do you think well first of all would you yes i would go
00:32:07 i would go that far and i would go further i would say that all the institutions that you believe
00:32:12 protect your your culture and your heritage have been entered by political activists and social
00:32:18 activists none of these organizations are truly committed to heritage none of them are actually
00:32:24 committed to saying look politics has to leave has to stay outside you've got a generation or two
00:32:30 generations now of people who believe that their first commitment is to their personal private
00:32:34 politics rather than their institution or to serving the people or to even serving the art
00:32:40 form by preserving it or presenting it and explaining how things are not justifying slavery
00:32:45 but saying, look, this is something that was bought by a man who owned slaves.
00:32:51 There's the information.
00:32:52 You can judge it morally or you can take it without adding that extra context.
00:32:58 But they're not doing this.
00:33:00 They are having show trials of morality in order to humiliate
00:33:05 and to denigrate people who were involved with our heritage.
00:33:09 And I think that they know that this is an implicit attack
00:33:11 on the majority of the people as well.
00:33:13 And they're doing this very deliberately.
00:33:15 And don't rely, don't think that behind the august front of the National Portrait Gallery or the National Gallery or the British Museum, that there are these sort of crusty traditionalists who are diligently sort of looking after materials.
00:33:30 No, they're retiring, they're being moved out, these organisations are being downsized, and you're getting in diversity officers who are political commissars.
00:33:40 and this is happening in all the heritage organisations so beware. Beware yes exactly 0.96
00:33:46 and wake up. Yes. Thank you very much Alexander thank you I will just mention the books again
00:33:53 there have been many that he's written but the ones I think which might interest you the most
00:33:57 are Culture War this one here and Iconoclasm available on Amazon I guess. Available on all
00:34:04 book selling websites and through bookshops. And through bookshops as well and thank you very very
00:34:09 much for joining us. My pleasure. Thank you very much, Alexander. That's it for this week. Do
00:34:16 remember, won't you, to subscribe. As I say every week, it seems to work. And we shall see you next
00:34:23 time. Thank you. Bye-bye.