New Culture Forum - July 02, 2021


My Favourite Books...with Michael Collins

Gareth Bacon MP - Member of the Conservative Party's anti-woke "Common Sense Group" Alexander Adams - Why The Left Hates Good Art

Episode Stats


Length

38 minutes

Words per minute

179.41

Word count

6,952

Sentence count

200


Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
00:00:00 Hello, I'm Mark Sidwell, and welcome to Between the Lines, a new show about books and the people
00:00:21 they inspire. Joining me today to discuss five books that matter to him is the author and
00:00:27 journalist Michael Collins. Michael has also worked as a TV producer and a script writer and
00:00:32 he recently made a heresies documentary for the New Culture Forum, White Privilege, the demonization
00:00:38 of the white working class. He's also written an acclaimed biography of the white working class,
00:00:44 The Likes of Us. Michael, thank you so much for joining me today. You've brought in a fantastic
00:00:50 pile of books and I can't wait to discuss them with you and why these matter to you. But let's
00:00:55 start by talking about how the world of books entered your life uh were your parents readers
00:01:00 did you have books around when you were young no no at all i mean i was um it was pop music film
00:01:06 and telly for me um if there were books in the home they were boxing books football books my
00:01:12 dad had a couple of books about the craze and jack the ripper and that's the best it got um
00:01:16 i am really didn't start reading until probably until i was 20 because as i said it was it was
00:01:22 really pop music for me um and uh i can't even remember really attempting books at school there
00:01:31 were two books in the school library that struck me one of one of which is up the junction and um
00:01:36 the other one was a book called go ask alice by anonymous which was um uh the diary of a drug
00:01:44 addict yeah and that it was that kind of thing that drew you attention because that was about
00:01:48 drugs up the junction there was um and there was a there was an abortion story in it so suddenly the
00:01:54 you know the kids were interested in that and that's how i got this up the junction really
00:01:59 and this is the this is the pam paperback this is the original and um why it was important to me
00:02:05 and why i remember is because it was a london london-based novel no done the the writer was
00:02:12 grand she was um she was the the daughter of a baronet and she left the chelsea set she moved
00:02:19 across the river sort of slumming in battersea and then she wrote these vignettes of um life
00:02:26 among the working classes of battersea uh between 1959 and the early 60s um and it's brilliant
00:02:34 stuff because she's doing it as an observer she's not she's not um grafting it onto any kind of
00:02:41 political agenda and so she's just reporting in a really simple economical way the lives of these
00:02:49 people in their kind of voices as well which which which really struck something it struck me in a
00:02:54 big way that because i i just you'd see that on television but you suddenly find it in the book
00:02:59 you recognize these voices you recognize the language and you recognize the characters i mean
00:03:04 the one the one thing i'd say about the junction is she it's it is big on the the abortions and the
00:03:10 They all, you know...
00:03:12 Backstreet abortions and sort of being flushed down the toilet
00:03:14 is the famous story.
00:03:15 Exactly, and the husbands were always, you know,
00:03:18 the women were kind of put upon,
00:03:21 the husbands were always bruises
00:03:22 and there was another side to the working class
00:03:25 and there was a kind of more of a decorum
00:03:27 and it wasn't that dramatic,
00:03:28 which is kind of absent from this in a way.
00:03:30 But I think it's a really important book
00:03:32 and it's just, as I said, it's an important book
00:03:36 because she does it in quite a dispassionate way.
00:03:39 She does it as an observer, just reporting on these lives at that particular time.
00:03:45 And also, you know, the factory, the market, the pub, because they're a younger generation
00:03:50 and it's the beginning of the 60s, they're beginning to really discover pop music and fashion.
00:03:56 There's not really money, but they're connecting to a more, a culture that is a wider experience
00:04:02 than maybe their parents had.
00:04:04 So yeah, Up the Junction, really still a good book.
00:04:07 And also Ken Loach did the BBC play up the junction
00:04:13 and I interviewed him way back in the 90s
00:04:17 for a documentary about Carol White
00:04:21 who played one of the characters
00:04:22 and he said when they made it
00:04:24 they were literally just pulling pages out of the book.
00:04:26 There was no script.
00:04:27 There was so much dialogue in it.
00:04:28 Yeah, and there was no plot.
00:04:32 It was just these little outtakes from these lives.
00:04:36 And her next book, Up Poor Cow, which Loach did on film, again with Carol Wyatt,
00:04:42 it was actually filmed in this estate, these tenements, condemned tenements,
00:04:48 called the Palatinate, which was literally two streets from Warragore.
00:04:52 So there's this strange connection with me and these books,
00:04:56 and they've stayed with me for a long time.
00:04:59 And still quite an important little document, I think, up the junction.
00:05:02 Do you think it was coloured by the fact that it was someone so grand
00:05:05 that had to write an extraordinary thing to have done
00:05:09 to come from that sort of Chelsea Earl background to do it,
00:05:13 but she could only perhaps see things in one way?
00:05:16 Well, I think there's, I wrote about this in the likes of us,
00:05:19 there's this history of these people, they're kind of almost like missionaries.
00:05:22 They go in, they're grand, they go in and they look for the darker side,
00:05:26 or if it's about politics, they'll try and find, you know,
00:05:30 the worst kind of example of working class existence and attach it to some kind of political
00:05:35 agenda but i think in some ways i i i don't i don't know that many i don't know many working
00:05:43 class writers that produce books like this i mean there probably are and i think but there's always
00:05:48 been this tradition of the grander um you know upper class or upper middle class people going
00:05:54 in and suddenly documenting this and what i think is good as i said is she does it in such a way
00:05:59 the vernacular you know the way she she picks up on the phrases the London
00:06:05 phrases Henry Green did something way back I mean he did he did this book
00:06:11 called living when he tried to write the whole book in a vernacular of the
00:06:16 characters this was in I can't remember where it was it wasn't it was I don't
00:06:21 think it was the north but it wasn't it wasn't wasn't London but it does it's
00:06:25 really hard to read so I think what is really good she does it so
00:06:28 economically that she's just there's no narrator it's it's it's almost like she's written so simply
00:06:34 um and reported it so simply um and they're really great they're just these self-contained
00:06:40 as little vignettes of just factory life um you know these girls going to the pub the the things
00:06:46 they experience so yeah it sort of brings it into the sort of the cultural world where people are
00:06:51 paying attention to this this and something that you could recognize but actually people start to
00:06:55 think this was real and it's like part of life that's just being ignored in some ways for a long
00:06:59 time well it's well and also it's it's it's kind of um it predates a lot of the the bbc stuff like
00:07:06 the wednesday plan all those things which which this whole kitchen sink um you know approach
00:07:13 became much more evident you know on screen there she was friends i think with john bradby the um
00:07:20 the painter that did those things like still life you know and had fish and chips and a
00:07:25 wardrobe or something and I think she does the equivalent here these are little these
00:07:28 are just fantastic little sketches of working-class London life and I think it's interesting now
00:07:33 because you know class is still an issue it's kind of almost been redefined there's a there's
00:07:41 a number of people I noticed on Twitter that are suddenly just saying that class isn't where you
00:07:44 start or where you who your parents were or you know what they did for a living it's almost like
00:07:50 trying to redefine it but they are the ones that have gone to the private school and you know what
00:07:53 I mean it's like it's it's this sort of mad thing that's going on I was going to say that's the other
00:07:57 thing I think these books they are I wouldn't say they're my favourite books entirely but they are
00:08:05 important because I think they they touch on themes and issues and trends that are still so
00:08:10 current now even though these these are ancient books I mean this is 1963 so up the junction well
00:08:17 Well, let's move on to a very different part
00:08:19 of the sort of English class system
00:08:21 with Virginia Woolf's Mrs. Dalloway.
00:08:23 This is a very well-loved copy you brought in here.
00:08:27 Classic modernist novel.
00:08:28 This is incredible.
00:08:30 It's 40 years old, this copy,
00:08:31 and you can see in it, I've got,
00:08:33 it's the old Granada paperback,
00:08:35 and I've got the bits where I've marked it
00:08:37 because I've tried to work out over the years
00:08:39 what she was actually doing.
00:08:41 I really like slim books.
00:08:43 I like slim books.
00:08:44 I like modernist writers
00:08:47 Beckett, Elliot and Virginia Woolf
00:08:49 are the go-to writers for me
00:08:51 I don't really like the big
00:08:52 plot-driven books at all
00:08:54 Was this in your 20s?
00:08:56 Yeah
00:08:56 One of the first novels
00:08:59 I really liked female writers at the time
00:09:01 Doris Lessing I was a huge fan of
00:09:03 I think Woolf's really interesting
00:09:05 because her
00:09:07 and before her, Katherine Mansfield
00:09:09 and Dorothy Richardson
00:09:11 they were trying to write a different kind of novel
00:09:13 that became this stream of consciousness type of a book
00:09:18 where it isn't without plot.
00:09:20 And it's just about this is the life in the day of one woman
00:09:25 going around a very grand woman married to a conservative minister
00:09:29 living in Westminster.
00:09:31 It's just the day in her life she goes to the florist.
00:09:35 She's visited by an ex-lover.
00:09:37 And it's just, you know, it's what Walford really,
00:09:40 she's got her style by this point.
00:09:42 i think jacob's room and some of the short fiction there were hints of it but this is where she really
00:09:47 finds her feet and um so so it's just the thoughts that go through her life through the day the
00:09:54 memories that come back um and this very you know the incident of things happen written in such a
00:10:01 poetic beautiful brilliant way that um you know it's an extraordinary it's an extraordinary way
00:10:08 of, well it changed novel writing, but I think it's an extraordinary way of telling a really
00:10:14 simple story to keep you gripped without any plot or anything dramatic, you know, she literally
00:10:22 buys flowers, no bombs go off, no one's kidnapped, you know.
00:10:25 But it's haunted too by that sort of sense of melancholy, you know, this is England high
00:10:31 society after the First World War, she's looking back to that childhood she has, just sort
00:10:35 an idyll but there's this other uh young man septimus who's been in in the trenches and is
00:10:40 traumatized deeply by that you get the sense that it's a beautiful world but there's sort of dark
00:10:45 things under the surface or yeah a world that's been lost somewhere well that's the septimus
00:10:49 thing's interesting because of course there's a suicide aid but the i i think the um i think i
00:10:55 think the thing about that is the characters i don't really like they're grand you know
00:11:01 know they're posh they're rich um and she's got a very leisurely lifestyle i almost wish there was
00:11:07 someone that would written in the way that wolf wrote about these characters these characters
00:11:13 i wish there was someone that could write about you know the working people in this way um where
00:11:20 you know it's quite poetic and it's uh it just gives them a lot more than you know as we said
00:11:26 the abortions and the dodgy husbands. But I think it's style, I think it's Virginia
00:11:34 Woolf style that really interests me and I think...
00:11:37 Did you take anything from it? You've sort of been a storyteller in your own career,
00:11:41 is it sort of something you've learned from?
00:11:42 Only the way, the economy of it because she will actually give you two sentences and that
00:11:49 sums up a life or that sums up a passing character and you return to it and you always, even
00:11:54 a slim book like this you return to it and you you just find things that you you didn't know
00:11:59 that were there just because one line gives a clue to someone's history or someone's story
00:12:04 i think the other reason this this is relevant now is because as i said these female writers
00:12:09 were doing a different i mean ulysses is the life in a day but there's so much fat on it you know
00:12:15 this is just so slimmed down and i think she um her you know catherine mansfield dorothy richards
00:12:21 and they were doing it, they had a different sort of take.
00:12:23 It was considered a sort of feminine fiction.
00:12:26 And we're having this now because so many female writers, you know, are prominent now.
00:12:31 And we've had this thing in recent years where the novel was apparently changed
00:12:36 and female writers are leading this by writing autofiction, you know,
00:12:40 and novels that are not particularly led by plot and they're much more personal.
00:12:46 But I find they're just the equivalent of the Hampstead novel
00:12:49 because a lot of these women are writers that they're writing about they usually live in a house
00:12:53 that's being refurbished and that's the story you know what i mean yeah yeah i think if you're going
00:12:56 to go for that if you're going to go for the you know the plotless you know female fiction if you're
00:13:02 going to call it that i'd go to wharf i really would i wouldn't bother with all the modern stuff
00:13:07 yeah and of course today there's a lot of talk about oh well novels have to sort of be about
00:13:12 your own experience or people are being kept in their boxes about what they can write about or
00:13:15 even more to some extent they're supposed to be able to understand if they read about it so it's
00:13:19 interesting she was doing that well but for you i meant as a reader you know sort of working class
00:13:24 background and a man but this the power of this book speaking to you across all the years yeah
00:13:29 and the class gap and well that's because it's style i think more than i mean another thing is
00:13:34 it does both the the up the junction and mrs dalloway very different times they tell a very
00:13:39 good story of london yeah at different times as well so that's the backdrop and that's the other
00:13:43 of thing that's interesting to me. They walk through similar streets.
00:13:48 Well, let's turn to someone who's American and from a very different area and era, because
00:13:54 this is, we're now going to the 1970s, I guess, with Tom Wolfe and his essays, his extraordinary
00:13:59 new journalism essays, in Mauve Gloves and Mad Men, which is, I think, probably came
00:14:06 out about the time I was born.
00:14:07 I was about to say, 1976.
00:14:09 There you go.
00:14:10 Yeah, I think it was 1976. This particular essay, The Me Decade.
00:14:13 I really like the new journalism of the 60s
00:14:16 and when you say about books that have influenced you
00:14:17 or writers that have influenced you, influenced me
00:14:20 I loved the scope of journalism
00:14:24 around about the mid 70s in America
00:14:27 particularly New York Magazine
00:14:28 you can't quite believe when you see New York Magazine now
00:14:31 that they used to have people like Tom Wolfe, Jimmy Breslin
00:14:34 Jimmy Breslin was on the broadsheets
00:14:38 but they
00:14:39 Oh it was a golden age for magazines of all kinds
00:14:41 Absolutely.
00:14:42 Extraordinary work coming out.
00:14:43 And the way they'd been given the opportunity to write these essays where they bring in
00:14:48 all the techniques of fiction, you know, to tell a completely different story.
00:14:52 Yeah, because Tom Wolfe's style is very… and of course then he went on to write some
00:14:55 fabulous novels.
00:14:56 Oh yeah.
00:14:57 But they're very literary even in the essays.
00:15:00 I actually prefer the journalism of Wolfe because I think… I do with Warwell as well.
00:15:05 I think he's just the scope and the nerve because the other thing that's interesting
00:15:09 it's like with Elliot or you know I really like it when you have these people that are quite
00:15:13 conservative thinkers or have quite a conservative outlook but their approach to their subject is
00:15:18 quite avant-garde and so Wolfe has this kind of very southern you know dandified kind of look
00:15:25 going on and he's you know you never he never really completely gives gives away what his
00:15:30 politics are but you sort of hazard a guess but his style is so completely wild and mad and out
00:15:37 there you know so tell us a bit about this particular essay I think so many I think this is
00:15:42 sorry this is the me decade in the great awakening yeah I think his essays again chime with so many
00:15:50 things now but this was a very interesting one because he basically talks about after the after
00:15:56 the war he says money came into America in such a way that there was no longer such a thing you
00:16:01 couldn't really talk in terms of the proletariat because the lower middle classes had pulled in
00:16:06 the working class and they were kind of quite despised by i suppose the educated uh wealthy
00:16:13 liberals who because they wore the wrong clothes they had the wrong taste and they wanted to move
00:16:19 to the suburbs they didn't want to live in worker housing or bauhaus type housing and so he talks
00:16:23 very much about how this creates this idea of a me generation that let's talk about me and he and he
00:16:30 He talks of, he defines a lower middle class now that have chosen individualism rather
00:16:37 than communitarianism, and so they've moved to the suburbs, the parents have moved to
00:16:41 retirement homes, whereas all the casualties from the 60s, so the politicos, all those
00:16:51 that followed the pseudo-spiritual cults, they're now in the 70s slightly lost, so they've
00:16:57 moved to um primal therapy or s meetings where they're actually trying to um talk about themselves
00:17:05 by the way of their problems or their issues and it begins i mean at these meetings he talks about
00:17:12 they're trying to deal with things to do with whatever happened to them as a kid or their
00:17:16 sexuality whatever but he said it gets to such an extreme thing that there's that it begins with
00:17:21 this woman who just talked about her haemorrhoids.
00:17:24 And I think this is the third great awakening.
00:17:28 I think we're now in the fourth great awakening
00:17:29 because if you look at this and where we are now,
00:17:33 on the business of, instead of let's talk about me,
00:17:37 we've got someone like Oprah Winfrey talking about your truth,
00:17:40 you know, where everything is about how you perceive something,
00:17:44 how you, whatever you project onto something
00:17:46 or how you interpret it, that is the authentic,
00:17:49 that is the one take.
00:17:50 Yeah, well, I was fascinated, too, because I was rereading this, obviously, for this conversation, and how contemporary it felt to me.
00:17:56 This is literally something that was published when I was born, but I read it now, and I think this feels very familiar,
00:18:03 this world of people being fascinated with themselves and Meghan Markle on Oprah Winfrey and so forth.
00:18:10 But, of course, the fact that it's not just for the princesses and everybody, but it's also sort of down in lower middle class life or ordinary life.
00:18:17 interesting because of course he says this was a pastime or a hobby for the aristocrats and by this
00:18:24 time it's worked its way down and of course this has happened now i mean you look at you look at
00:18:28 markle and you and you know she's a classic example um and but but not just that i mean if
00:18:34 you talk about the issue of pronouns people defining themselves by one particular thing i
00:18:39 mean that that's what i love about wolf wolf says this line she says we are never simply one thing
00:18:45 But, I mean, we live in a time now where everyone wants to attach themselves to being one specific thing,
00:18:51 whether it's about people's pronouns or whether it's the way the remit of mental health has widened.
00:18:56 So even if you're not part of a protected group, you can probably get day release in being bipolar or personality disorder, it was called.
00:19:06 And I think that that is so much where we are now.
00:19:09 We are in a kind of version of the me decade now.
00:19:11 And interestingly enough, I mean, you could say that arguably money is poured into society, into the UK over the last 30 years and the way it probably did in America in those post-war years.
00:19:23 And we've got the snobbery in the same way about something like Brexit, about the sort of listen to Andrew Adonis or someone going on about the miserable poor voted for Brexit.
00:19:34 Well, see, I find that really interesting
00:19:36 because whenever I've written about the working class,
00:19:41 and I hate going on about it because I do feel like a boy band
00:19:44 whoring around their one hit sometimes with my book.
00:19:46 But what does interest me is I don't think,
00:19:49 I think the missed opportunity with British literature
00:19:52 in the post-war years is the absence of the suburban novel.
00:19:57 You know, I'm never actually writing about all that material
00:20:01 of the work that he refers to,
00:20:03 Wolfe refers to,
00:20:04 the working class that moved out of the capital,
00:20:07 that moved out to the city.
00:20:08 You know, it's my subject.
00:20:10 It interests me so much.
00:20:11 And no one covers it,
00:20:14 except they denigrate it
00:20:15 because they don't know about it.
00:20:17 And I remember Martin Amis,
00:20:18 I think it was Martin Amis once said,
00:20:19 no one has written about the suburbs
00:20:21 because they'd have to live there.
00:20:23 And it's that snobbery.
00:20:24 It's because you...
00:20:25 Someone will go to Battersea
00:20:26 because it's trendy and down and difficult.
00:20:28 And it's a bit like we need...
00:20:30 You almost needed someone, even as they're now done, you needed someone to go to the
00:20:34 Donut Ring of London and beyond and report on those lives and those experiences of the
00:20:40 people that had moved out.
00:20:41 Well, I mean, it brings to mind the sitcom Keeping Up Appearances, which of course is
00:20:45 about someone who's trying to escape a sort of embarrassing sort of background, but is
00:20:49 also being sort of sneered at for the way that she tries to sort of put on these middle
00:20:53 class airs that she can't really live up to, bucket bouquet and all of that.
00:20:57 I think she's kind of old school.
00:20:58 If you look at something like, what's that,
00:21:02 Gavin and Stacey?
00:21:04 Yeah, right.
00:21:04 It's that idea.
00:21:05 I mean, I don't think that particularly does it well,
00:21:07 but I mean, I just think that is, you know,
00:21:10 Sheena McKay did it to some extent in Essex, I think,
00:21:13 but with an Essex novel.
00:21:15 But I think it's a missed opportunity.
00:21:17 You know, there's no, there's this,
00:21:19 because this is a majority of the people in this country
00:21:21 and that's, it's not being told.
00:21:23 We were talking about worlds
00:21:24 that don't get their stories told.
00:21:26 Yeah, exactly. And I think that's true. I think that is a real missed opportunity because no one's actually seriously looked at that within literature.
00:21:34 And as I was saying about this autofiction, you know, we've had the Hampstead novel, we've now got this autofiction which covers similar territory, you know.
00:21:43 But, you know, there's a great opportunity there.
00:21:47 People step out beyond their boundaries.
00:21:50 Well, let's zoom back in time and place to Charles Masterman's The Condition of England.
00:21:55 This is, what, 1909, a Liberal MP writing about working class conditions in industrial London and the problems of that.
00:22:04 Why does this speak to you or why does this still speak to now?
00:22:07 This is an oldish book now, probably the oldest book you've got here.
00:22:10 And this is a terrible cover. I think this is a print-on-demand one. I've lost my original.
00:22:15 But again, this is non-fiction.
00:22:17 but masterman really interesting he was liberal minister um politically probably somewhere between
00:22:24 sydney webb and samuel smile so he was kind of um he was for the the role of the state was an
00:22:30 important thing but he was very much in term he was very much for defending sort of self-determination
00:22:35 and self-help to some degree so he um he he moved to london and he moved to campbell and he went to
00:22:42 work as a settlement Cambridge settlement and lived and among the you
00:22:49 know the locals in that end of the end of the 19th century in Camberwell and
00:22:54 all this he began to document this in essays and books and then the most
00:23:01 familiar one the most famous one was the condition of England which he wrote at
00:23:05 the time he was in a liberal minister in that in that government that brought in
00:23:09 on the reforms. How did this come into your life? Well bizarrely I worked for a think tank in the
00:23:17 2000s and set up a supplementary school at Cambridge House where Masterman worked and I knew he'd
00:23:23 worked there and that was the reason I chose it and I got hooked just before that because I knew
00:23:28 the territory because I knew Campbell, I knew that area very well. Why this is a really interesting
00:23:34 book and a really important book is because he he began the first the first line of it is um what
00:23:40 will the future make of the present and he looks at this um two things he looks at a city he's
00:23:47 obsessed with the city especially the capital um the modern city that's been formed in the wake of
00:23:52 industrialization and the city tribe the city tribe that is peculiar to that new modern city
00:23:59 and how they live and what they do and that the idea that there's an Israeli thing of two nations
00:24:05 you know but what he does with this book is he says what is England and where does it reside
00:24:12 why he asked that question at that time is because he says at one time you knew where England was it
00:24:17 was pastoral it was the countryside it was agriculture it's now been so urbanized where
00:24:23 do we now find England it's the question that all would ask years later and so he addresses
00:24:29 this by taking apart english society and he separates it into the conquerors the multitude
00:24:34 um and various and the suburbans in the suburbanites and various so he he addresses it in terms of
00:24:42 various tribes now within there he says he says the suburbans are the old school the high
00:24:48 simplicator you know uh he possibly doesn't have so much time to them i got the feeling
00:24:53 well he he's got the snobbery about them yeah he's got the snobbery about the villas that the work
00:24:58 as wells did he's got that snobbery about the um the people that moved to the walking suburbs or
00:25:03 the prairie suburbs as they became um and he's um so so he's got that sort of almost uh liberal
00:25:11 intellectual snobbery about them and he says at one point uh the uh the upper classes on the rich
00:25:19 look down on the suburbans and the suburbans fear the working class because they fear socialism
00:25:26 um so so he's kind of quite snobby about the um what's happening with with the uh people that
00:25:33 you know burgeoning suburbia that's that these people have been embracing at that time but
00:25:38 he also talks about the idea of a working class that are beginning to they've they've not got
00:25:45 it's not it's before universal suffrage obviously but they begin they're a voice that's swelling
00:25:50 that will begin to want to be heard you know and he he mentions this in relation to obviously
00:25:55 he knew the web so he talks in terms of trade unionism the nascent Labour Party but again he
00:26:03 does it in a way as I said about the Neil Dunn book you know that idea of being doing it as an
00:26:12 as an observer so he's actually he's documenting and he's reporting it but he's not entirely putting
00:26:18 his opinion or his take on it he's trying to and I think that's that's what makes it interesting
00:26:24 And, you know, it very much chimes with now
00:26:27 because, I mean, we're going through,
00:26:29 we've gone through a change, technological change.
00:26:32 We're going through a change in terms of asking
00:26:34 in wake of Brexit,
00:26:36 in the wake of all the shenanigans of the SNP,
00:26:38 the very idea of England is being talked about again.
00:26:41 And what is England?
00:26:42 And where does it reside?
00:26:44 So these questions are still so relevant.
00:26:47 And I think it's a really,
00:26:48 I think it's a really undervalued book.
00:26:51 I think it should be on the curriculum.
00:26:52 them. I think it's also worth saying too this might sound like the perhaps the
00:26:56 driest of the books on the table but it's often quite poetic. It is. It's a lovely
00:27:00 imagery and sort of the idea of industrial society as this dark windmill
00:27:04 turning under starless skies. That's a great line. He's a great, he's a
00:27:09 really interesting writer but an interesting politician as well. I mean he
00:27:15 was an MP in the East End initially but the other thing he does is he's a
00:27:21 bit of a poet i mean he brings in some fantastic references um and very much something of the time
00:27:28 he was very much uh in with uh as i said the webs um wells all those characters around him at the
00:27:36 time that we're familiar with now i'm amazed that this book is never mentioned you know well it's
00:27:43 one of those books that falls between stores isn't it people want to think about the past and
00:27:47 socialism or the past and I don't know free market liberalism or free trade in the late
00:27:52 19th century but a liberal person like that who's somewhere between the two working on
00:27:56 starting national insurance concerned about the poor but not actually wanting to take
00:28:00 away their autonomy at the same time.
00:28:02 Exactly and that's exactly where he was.
00:28:03 It's a very complicated place.
00:28:04 Well again I think this is the same thing I like about the Neil Dunn thing.
00:28:09 I mean he actually moved into the area.
00:28:12 He was a graduate and he'd come down from Cambridge.
00:28:16 he was a christian and he um so it was it was the time of charles booth surveys um the salvation
00:28:22 army yeah so he was actually living in this place called albany buildings um you know when my family
00:28:28 were living just streets away again bizarrely but i i'd love the idea of him again if he was the only
00:28:35 voice that was going to go in and record that or document that and that was to inspire him to bring
00:28:40 this book then I'd rather him than no one else, you know what I mean? So again with the Neil Dunn
00:28:46 thing I think these figures are important because they did leave us with something that
00:28:52 documents a particular time that again of people that didn't have a voice within literature.
00:28:59 Well let's turn to, for the final book, to a very different voice but it's also a voice that needed
00:29:04 to be heard. This is Ralph Ellison's classic Invisible Man. Now this is about the African
00:29:09 American experience in sort of mid 20th century America but why does that speak to you or where
00:29:16 did you come across this book? This contradicts everything I've just said because this is a really
00:29:19 big book and it took him seven years to write. This is a great cover actually. I first came
00:29:27 across this again about 40 odd years ago and I started looking at just before bizarrely just
00:29:35 before the bricks and riots happened all the rest of it and then i sort of put it down i was a bit
00:29:39 you know i sort of was a bit overwhelmed and so i i came back to it a few years ago
00:29:45 and finished it um and i think ellison's a really interesting um
00:29:51 no i don't think it's a great book i just think it's a really important book because
00:29:55 you know when you think about black american writers men in particular of that particular
00:30:01 of that period like you said in the middle of the 20th century you think of Baldwin and James
00:30:05 Baldwin has got that sort of six to hipster thing going Richard Wright much more graphic much more
00:30:11 political probably more you know it's kind of almost right in a more documentary style Ellison
00:30:17 wrote this book which is just simply about this young educated black American man who he never
00:30:25 names but he writes in the first person and everything that he goes through I think I think
00:30:30 I think the problem is he's always acted upon this character
00:30:33 because he's almost like Candide or a kind of Catholic character.
00:30:37 Yeah, sort of picaresque where he goes through all these adventures
00:30:39 and he sees these situations.
00:30:41 That happened to him.
00:30:44 But what is interesting is in the process.
00:30:47 And again, Ellison does that thing, which I love,
00:30:50 and I've said in these other books,
00:30:52 he's the dispassionate observer, even though he's the narrator.
00:30:55 He's not imposing an agenda.
00:30:57 He's just slightly, he's just reporting the things that are happening.
00:31:01 It's not a social protest novel in the way that people think.
00:31:04 It's not Uncle Tom's cabin saying we've got to end slavery.
00:31:06 And that's been the criticism.
00:31:08 That's why, you know, that's why I said Richard Wright or James Baldwin get more kind of respect in a way
00:31:13 because they think this is a criticism, Ellison.
00:31:16 He wasn't, he didn't do that.
00:31:18 He wasn't political enough with it, even though him and Wright were both communists for a while.
00:31:21 Yeah, and sometimes it's quite nuanced, right?
00:31:23 I mean, you get the sort of almost satire of the black protester movements.
00:31:28 Or at least it observes their self-interest as much as it does the racism in the society.
00:31:32 And not just them.
00:31:33 This is why I find it a really interesting book, because they become like these archetypes.
00:31:36 Because he's got the characters in there.
00:31:38 He's got the sort of black nationalist character who is like pre-Black Panther, like BLM type characters now.
00:31:47 He's got the posh, white, rich woman that is toying around with left-wing politics that objectifies the black man and wants to even indulge in a rape fantasy.
00:31:57 You've got the kind of eyes-rolling, Rochester black characters that have to play the game.
00:32:03 And he comes across all these and these particular characters that sometimes they almost take on a sort of Dickensian filter.
00:32:11 Because I think that's where, I think the book's very melodramatic.
00:32:14 There's a big coincidence, isn't it?
00:32:16 I don't think, you know, it is one of those big, big books with a plot and he spent a
00:32:22 long time writing it. But I think for me, what's important is the, the way he documents
00:32:26 characters and events that are still with us now. The relationship with the police, the
00:32:34 riots, the looting that follows the riots, everything is with us now. And we've witnessed
00:32:39 it in the last year or so, you know, especially in America with Black Lives Matter, which
00:32:44 is which seems like pure theater in relation to when he was writing a very complex time you know
00:32:51 a bleak time uh when people were you know laying their lives on the line because you know they
00:32:58 wanted change they had conviction which completely contradicts i think which is completely opposite
00:33:03 of where we are now after so many decades and so much change and so i think a lot of people could
00:33:09 go back to this novel and probably see that these characters that were with us now, whether
00:33:16 it's race baiters or the grifters that are around us now, and find them within this.
00:33:20 It reminded me a bit too of one of the Tom Wolfe's novels, Bonfire of the Vanities, which
00:33:24 has some of that in this version.
00:33:26 Absolutely, Sherman McCoy.
00:33:27 Yeah, there you go.
00:33:29 But it's fascinating.
00:33:30 These resonances in these books, which are really from decades ago, but they give us
00:33:34 these new lenses to see things that are going on right now.
00:33:37 And I think that's probably more true about Ellison than anyone else.
00:33:41 I mean, I think if you look at where we've been with all the BLM stuff over the last year or so,
00:33:48 and you think it's all here, you know, decades earlier in a different time,
00:33:54 and you are just, you know, you're playing a game, you're going through this whole farce, you know,
00:34:02 that seems kind of madness in relation to these characters
00:34:09 and these events at this particular time
00:34:10 when it was a very different society, you know.
00:34:13 Some of these battles have been won
00:34:14 and you're just prolonging them or recreating them.
00:34:18 Recreating them.
00:34:19 Well, fantastic.
00:34:20 Thank you.
00:34:20 That's been great to run through those books.
00:34:22 That's almost all we have time for today,
00:34:25 but thank you to my guest, Michael Collins,
00:34:27 for sharing these books with us.
00:34:29 You can find his book, the likes of us,
00:34:31 on Amazon and elsewhere,
00:34:32 and you can watch his documentary, White Privilege,
00:34:35 The Demonisation of the White Working Class, right here on YouTube.
00:34:39 Do please click below to subscribe if you haven't already
00:34:42 and as ever, let us know what you think in the comments
00:34:45 and perhaps share the books that matter to you as well.
00:34:49 Finally though, just to close out,
00:34:50 Michael's agreed to read us a quote from one of the books,
00:34:53 from Masterman, I think.
00:34:54 Yeah, Condition of England, which I've edited.
00:34:59 is that bad of me I'm editing Charles Masterman
00:35:02 lightly editing
00:35:03 yeah well he's basically in this particular
00:35:06 early part of the book it's called The Spirit of the People
00:35:08 and he's basically saying
00:35:09 if you look at the character
00:35:11 or what defines the character
00:35:13 of England
00:35:15 at the time of writing
00:35:17 it's
00:35:18 that of the middle classes
00:35:21 it's the outlook of the old school middle classes
00:35:23 and he said but there are
00:35:25 other voices which he talks about the multitude
00:35:27 where now we could still talk about this and talk about the 80 percent and I think a lot of this
00:35:32 chimes now in what's happened with how we talk about post-Brexit England how we talk about people
00:35:40 being censored and not having a voice it's it's all relevant so so this is how he begins
00:35:45 and below this large kingdom which for more than half a century has stood for England
00:35:50 stretches a huge and unexplored region which seems destined in the next half century to
00:35:57 progress towards articulate voice, and to demand an increase in power. It is the class of which
00:36:03 Matthew Arnold, with the agreeable insolence of his habitual attitude, declared himself to be
00:36:10 the discoverer, and to which he gave the name of the populace. To most observers from the classes
00:36:16 above, this is the deluge, and its attainment of power, if such attainment ever were realised,
00:36:23 the coming of the twilight of the gods. They see our civilisation as a little patch of redeemed
00:36:29 land in the wilderness, preserved as by a miracle from one decade to another. They behold the
00:36:34 influx as the rush of a bank holiday crowd upon some tranquil garden, tearing up the flowers by
00:36:41 the roots, reeling in drunken merriment on the grass plots, strewing the pleasant landscape
00:36:48 with torn paper and broken bottles.
00:36:51 It's a class full of sentiment
00:36:53 which the foreigner is apt to condemn as sentimentality.
00:36:58 Next to this sentimentality,
00:37:00 so astonishing to Europe because so irrational,
00:37:03 comes the invincible patience of the English workman.
00:37:06 He will endure almost anything in silence
00:37:10 until it becomes unendurable.
00:37:12 When he is vocal, it is pretty certain
00:37:15 that things have become unendurable.
00:37:18 And this is England, an England which has learnt more than all other peoples the secret of
00:37:24 acquiescence, of toleration, of settling down and making the best of things, in a world on the whole
00:37:30 desirable. But an England also of a determination unshaken by the vicissitudes of purpose and time,
00:37:38 with a certain ruthlessness about the means when it has accepted the end, and with a patience which
00:37:45 is perhaps more terrible in its silence than the violence of a conspicuous despair.
00:37:52 Read in my best headgirl voice, I've heard.
00:37:55 That's wonderful. Michael Collins, thank you so much.
00:37:57 Thank you.
00:37:58 This has been Between the Lines.
00:38:15 Thank you.