New Culture Forum - June 30, 2021


Gareth Bacon MP - Member of the Conservative Party's anti-woke "Common Sense Group"

What Do We Think Of GB News? Reviewing Britain's Newest News Channel My Favourite Books...with Michael Collins

Episode Stats


Length

44 minutes

Words per minute

197.9

Word count

8,848

Sentence count

162

Harmful content

Hate speech

6

sentences flagged


Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
00:00:00 hello and welcome to so what you're saying is I'm Peter Whittle now thank you very very much
00:00:28 for subscribing to the channel as you've been doing in your thousands actually but please to
00:00:35 those of you who haven't do subscribe won't you because what it means is that you will get
00:00:39 notifications of each program as they come up it's very very simple you just go to the subscribe
00:00:44 button click on that and next door there is a blue bell and if you click on that that means you get
00:00:50 notifications of each of our programs as they come up what three a week now so please do that
00:00:56 Now I'm very pleased that my guest today is one of the new MPs who came in in 2019.
00:01:04 Gareth Bacon is MP for Orpington.
00:01:08 Before that he was on the London Assembly for nine years, the last five of which he was head of the Conservatives there.
00:01:17 He's also part of a new group which was started by Sir John Hayes called the Common Sense Group.
00:01:24 they've just got a new book out which you can see the cover of here it's called common sense
00:01:29 conservative thinking in a post-liberal age um thanks very much for coming on gary um you've
00:01:37 contributed one of the essays there's a number of essays in this book and yours is about wokeism
00:01:43 and how we can defeat it i mean i just thought it's best you know because if we define this
00:01:50 Because a lot of people, according to a recent poll, didn't quite even understand what the word meant.
00:01:56 How would you define wokery?
00:01:59 Well, wokery, I think it has its origins in the hard left.
00:02:03 It's broadly anti-capitalist, anti-Western, anti-conservative, and I would submit anti-British. 0.74
00:02:10 It seeks to completely change our understanding of our national identity.
00:02:16 It's intolerant, borderline totalitarian, I think.
00:02:20 It seeks to impose censorship on different points of view.
00:02:23 It would see itself as a progressive, inclusive worldview that seeks out prejudice.
00:02:31 But unfortunately, that doesn't really tally with how its protagonists behave.
00:02:36 I think it's quite sinister.
00:02:38 And I think it is culturally, I think it is a very big threat to our way of life.
00:02:44 Would you say, I mean, for example, take, we're recording this, the day we're recording this,
00:02:48 There have been three examples of what you might call work.
00:02:50 On the one hand, we've had a picture of the Queen taken down in an Oxford college.
00:02:54 We've had increasing protests at the number of players taking the knee as well.
00:03:02 And also there has been, for example, the journalist Julie Birchall has just been banned, I think, from Twitter.
00:03:09 And she's lost her job at the Telegraph for something that she wrote a joke.
00:03:14 Would you say that those are all examples of workery?
00:03:18 Yes, I would.
00:03:19 I mean, to take the first one, the portrait of the Queen at Magdalene College, that's
00:03:23 been taken down because she represents recent colonialism.
00:03:27 And that is deemed to be one of the great sins of Wokery, or they perceive that as a
00:03:33 great sin.
00:03:34 Well, the Queen is our head of state and has been for almost 70 years.
00:03:38 She is widely loved, I think, and admired across the country.
00:03:42 She is the symbol of Great Britain.
00:03:44 Now, she was queen when we had the remnants of the British Empire because, of course,
00:03:48 she assumed the throne after the war and the empire was in the process of disintegrating
00:03:53 at that time.
00:03:54 But what the woke left have done is they've taken words like colonial and they've superimposed
00:04:00 the word racist on it.
00:04:01 So it's now become interchangeable.
00:04:03 And I completely reject the idea that the British Empire was founded on racism.
00:04:08 If it was, then why do we have a Commonwealth?
00:04:10 Where's Germany's Commonwealth, for example?
00:04:12 You know, if the British Empire was based on military conflict, based on enslaving people, stealing their wealth, then you would understand people kicking back against it. 0.69
00:04:24 Now, that was the very definition of what Nazi Germany did during World War Two, which is unsurprising, where they have no Commonwealth.
00:04:29 But we have a Commonwealth made up of scores of nations who choose to be part of it.
00:04:34 It's entirely voluntary, isn't it?
00:04:36 Yeah. So why would we have, why would they want to be part of an organisation that reminded them of their enslavement?
00:04:41 if that indeed is what the British Empire was about.
00:04:43 It wasn't, of course.
00:04:44 The British Empire was about trade.
00:04:46 So the idea that colonialism is equivalent to racism
00:04:50 is something that I think is completely objectionable.
00:04:53 And it's an example of how woke tries to appropriate language
00:04:57 for its own purposes.
00:04:58 So queen, colonial, empire, racism.
00:05:01 And I think that's appalling.
00:05:03 And the irony of that, of course,
00:05:04 is that Oxford University is one of the country's great institutions.
00:05:09 It's centuries old.
00:05:11 and these students who are benefiting from an education at Oxford that will stand them in good
00:05:16 stead in their future years are rejecting one of the biggest cornerstones of our country and
00:05:22 its institutions i.e rejecting the monarch and I think that that's absolutely appalling. The
00:05:27 question about taking the knee and whether footballers should take the knee or not well
00:05:31 of course this all sprang up after the Black Lives Matter protests a year ago when football
00:05:39 returned after the break imposed by the lockdown, the first lockdown. Players were playing in
00:05:45 front of empty stadiums and they seemed to think that taking the knee was something that
00:05:49 should happen. And since crowds have started coming back in, it's been very notable that
00:05:55 obviously people have been starting to boo. Now, I think the reason why people are booing
00:05:58 it is because they see taking the knee as a symbol of solidarity with Black Lives Matter,
00:06:03 the organisation. And there's a problem with that because Black Lives Matter is a hard
00:06:08 left political organization. It puts at the center of its raison d'etre, something that nobody argues
00:06:14 with, because of course black lives do matter. Every life matters. Nobody says that they don't.
00:06:19 And so you can't contend that. But simultaneously, they're also advocating destroying capitalism,
00:06:25 defunding the police, overturning the family unit. There's a strong strain of anti-Semitism
00:06:28 and some of the stuff they put on social media. And taking the knee is seen as a gesture of
00:06:33 solidarity with the organization not necessarily with the anti-racist sentiment now in football
00:06:39 the the idea of driving racism out has been something that's been there for a very long time
00:06:43 kick it out is what it had been called kick out racism was what i think it was called before
00:06:48 and nobody argues with that everyone agrees that that is is you know the way you should go but
00:06:52 players kneeling down in a gesture of subservience before a game i think is starting to get a bit
00:06:57 preachy and i i do understand why some people are booing it it's not because they're racist it's
00:07:01 not because they are pro-racism it's because they are against this gesture which they associate
00:07:06 with a particularly unpleasant organization. But isn't it also that the implicit in a lot of the
00:07:12 Black Lives Matter stuff well not just implicit quite explicitly in identity politics it's this
00:07:17 idea that you are racist you know whether you know it or not or whether you know by sheer virtue of
00:07:23 maybe being white or whatever it is and so people are sort of reacting almost again to that aren't
00:07:27 I mean, they're also reacting against being lectured to. 0.83
00:07:31 Yes, I think that that's perfectly true.
00:07:33 See, I genuinely believe that most people in this country
00:07:36 are quite happy to rub along with everyone else.
00:07:38 We just want to get through our lives.
00:07:40 We want to think about feeding our children,
00:07:42 our children's prospects, how work is going,
00:07:45 just earning our lives, improving our family's existence.
00:07:48 But the woke mentality is to impose their values on you
00:07:52 and force you to confront them.
00:07:54 And if you don't necessarily agree with everything they're saying,
00:07:56 you instantly get branded as something.
00:07:57 so it's not enough not to actually do racist things or say racist things you have to actually
00:08:02 attack racism and go out of your way to find it and and oppose it otherwise you are yourself a
00:08:09 racist and that i don't accept that at all and i think people are getting a bit tired of being
00:08:16 branded racist simply because they're not taking the knee to a militant organization
00:08:19 that does not equate to racism and i do think i i'm inclined to agree with what you've just said
00:08:24 that people are tired of being lectured and accused of things
00:08:28 when they haven't done anything.
00:08:30 You know, if you're born with white skin, that doesn't make you a racist.
00:08:32 It doesn't make you a white supremacist.
00:08:34 It doesn't mean that you've got any kind of privilege over anybody.
00:08:39 I mean, the idea of white privilege is one of these sinister things
00:08:42 that has come about.
00:08:42 I mean, you know, I think about Irish immigrants
00:08:45 that came to this country from Ireland.
00:08:47 What privilege did they enjoy?
00:08:49 I think about the desperate poverty there was in Victoria and London.
00:08:52 Were these people privileged?
00:08:53 i rather think not some of my colleagues in in the house of commons who went to schools like
00:08:58 eton uh who are black am i more privileged than them i don't think so um you know and i don't
00:09:04 mind the fact that they've had the opportunity to to go to these places um but you know this
00:09:09 sort of attack on people it's actually if you flip it if we were to say that someone who is born 0.89
00:09:14 black must have a whole load of beliefs and understanding we would be accused rightly of
00:09:18 racism yes and equally these these same charges on the other side of the coin are aimed at white
00:09:23 people and that's not racist yeah so this this sort of it's an unnecessary friction that i think
00:09:29 that is is not helpful actually because it's it's dividing people it's pushing them apart rather
00:09:33 than putting them together um in your essay you know you you talk about uh what's happening with
00:09:40 work which seems to be gathering pace i would say and people often think oh well you know i think
00:09:44 it's peaked you hear this a lot i think it's peaked i think it's quite a pushback um in fact
00:09:48 there's something happens you think oh actually no there's no tipping point it's just getting worse
00:09:52 But what are your suggestions for defeating it or challenging it?
00:10:00 Well, there's a lot, and I've put various into the essay.
00:10:04 I mean, I think, for a start, organisations that are the beneficiary of UK taxpayer money
00:10:10 have an obligation not to attack our country, our history, our institutions.
00:10:16 Right.
00:10:16 So we've got a whole range of charitable organisations.
00:10:19 English Heritage will be one example.
00:10:22 that get money from the government and then do massive audits on slavery and this is the other
00:10:27 thing that woke likes to talk about is slavery a lot with an attempt to try and make out that
00:10:32 Britain is and always has been a deeply racist country so that sort of thing needs to be pushed
00:10:37 back against I think the other thing that we should do I mean the woke mentality is very
00:10:43 insecure it doesn't like open debate which is why it seeks to censor people that's why reading this
00:10:49 get altered that's why people get no platform that's why they try to cancel people on social
00:10:52 media because they don't like having to have an open debate because when you flush them into the
00:10:57 open a lot of what they're saying has absolutely no intellectual grounding at all they can't hold
00:11:02 their argument particularly without start shouting insults and they tend to lose the argument and so
00:11:06 they're scared of that so that's why they try to cancel people so i would encourage much more
00:11:10 open debate the third thing is freedom of speech particularly in universities now we are finding
00:11:15 freedom of speech being completely closed down university used to be where you go to broaden
00:11:19 your mind to explore new ideas to test theories to develop ideas and that's how new ideas and
00:11:25 new theories are actually creatives by bouncing arguments off one another well you can't do that
00:11:30 if you're only allowed to occupy a very narrow terrain of ideological thought so if you cancel
00:11:37 freedom of speech you're actually it's a very totalitarian sinister thing because you're
00:11:41 preventing new thinking from coming along and i put in my chapter that you know these these things
00:11:47 are they have sinister overtones of some of the activities we saw in the totality and dick
00:11:51 spaceships in the first half of the 20th century you know insecure ideological beliefs try to stamp
00:11:58 out others you know and and that is what we're starting to see so the government have got a
00:12:03 freedom of speech bill which is aimed at universities uh in the queen in queen speech
00:12:08 it's a matter of great regret that that's necessary but it is actually yes in in in
00:12:13 great britain you know this bastion of democracy we have to now start legislating for freedom of
00:12:17 speech the thing about freedom of speech it matters most when it's controversial
00:12:22 because that's you know i i'm perfectly comfortable listening to people whose views i don't agree with
00:12:27 because they're entitled to express them um you know i will then either choose to listen to them
00:12:31 or i will argue with them but that's fine they can't be silenced or cancelled and that should
00:12:34 should apply in the other direction as well. You mentioned as well in the piece the Equalities Act
00:12:42 can you tell us what the relevance is there you said this would have to be
00:12:46 amended in some way. Well the case law that's followed so the Equalities Act is a piece of
00:12:51 statute and it's there's various different things about the protective characteristics in there
00:12:55 but the way it's been interpreted by case law since 2010 has meant that people if they feel
00:13:01 that they are it's about feelings rather than actuality if they feel that someone has attacked
00:13:06 them on the basis of one of their protective characteristics then that is what has happened
00:13:10 and the woke warriors are now pouncing on that and they are using the legalities of the case law
00:13:16 to underpin what they are doing and that is one of the ways that the woke ideology has managed to
00:13:21 impose itself on society at such speed because you've got big organizations now who are terrified
00:13:28 of being sued or accused of anism, whether it be racism, feminism, sexism, etc., underpinned by the
00:13:37 Equality Act. So legal definitions of terminology, I think, are now required. So amendments to the
00:13:42 Equality Act to change that, to change the case law that's followed, I think are one of the ways
00:13:48 that we could do this. Because the legal interpretation of it has led to a whole load
00:13:52 of case law which underpins the woke position. And I don't think that was the intention of
00:13:57 parliament when the equality act was passed but it has led to a legal underpinning for a lot of
00:14:01 the abuses that we're seeing now there's this idea that uh basically well hate crime in a way
00:14:08 and uh requires no evidence it's just purely on perception isn't it and also this phenomenon of
00:14:14 non-crime hate incidents yes um i understand that the home secretary recently said that this should
00:14:22 these should not be put down on any kind of register anymore is that actually happening
00:14:27 well it's not been passed into law um but it is the declared intention of the home office is to
00:14:34 move in that direction now one of my colleagues wrote a chapter on this because he himself has
00:14:38 been subject to it um and this is a particularly sinister development the idea that someone should
00:14:45 be logging down things that are not crimes but could be construed by somebody as hate but not
00:14:52 over the edge and to be in crime why are they doing that I mean what what is what does that
00:14:56 what purpose does that serve what does it achieve it is a very sinister approach to law and order
00:15:03 and it's not so our police don't have enough to do you know that they are increasingly overburdened
00:15:08 and having to keep records of things like this I think is a major problem either there is crime or
00:15:13 isn't a crime if there isn't a crime the police have no action to take that's how it should be
00:15:17 but with this it's straying into territory it really shouldn't with the police generally i
00:15:21 mean the police are covered in the in the in the book the collection of essays um there is this
00:15:28 sense in which people are very concerned at the increasing politicization of the police
00:15:34 i mean i think you know having been on the police and crime committee on the london assembly i i
00:15:39 I think there's no question about that, but how would that be challenged?
00:15:45 How would that be corrected, do you think?
00:15:48 Well, I don't fully accept the idea that the police are being overly politicised.
00:15:54 However, you can't divorce policing from politics.
00:15:57 And I think certainly since the Macpherson report way back at the turn of the century,
00:16:04 the Metropolitan Police particularly have been very keen to try to show themselves not to be
00:16:10 a racist organisation which is laudable but I think that has had consequences in the way that
00:16:16 they have behaved in certain circumstances. The advent of social media which is another tool
00:16:21 that the woke activists use to very great effect has also had an impact on the police
00:16:26 and it's perfectly possible to argue that the police have reacted to or tried to prevent
00:16:32 adverse social media and media criticism
00:16:36 with some of the things that they have done.
00:16:39 So as an example, Operation Midland,
00:16:42 the investigation of supposedly historic sexual offences
00:16:45 by leading establishment figures,
00:16:47 was based on a complete fantasy
00:16:48 by somebody who was a proven liar who is now in prison.
00:16:52 And the police took it all at face value
00:16:53 because they were terrified of being accused
00:16:55 of not taking it seriously
00:16:56 because of the fallout from Jimmy Savile
00:16:59 and things like that.
00:17:00 Other things that the police have done
00:17:02 so people who are charged with sex offences their name finds its way into the public domain and I
00:17:09 remember having an exchange with a former deputy commissioner of the Metropolitan Police about this
00:17:12 and I put it to him that this was not the way to be going because either the state can make
00:17:18 its case with the evidence it has or it can't because his argument was that well if you put
00:17:22 these names out in the public domain it might encourage other people to come forward who might
00:17:25 not otherwise have done but that's not how you do it you don't throw a Hail Mary and throw this
00:17:30 person to the wind and you know let justice take its course because the stress and strain on that
00:17:36 person is incredible if the state can't make its case and there isn't a case and this sort of thing
00:17:40 shouldn't happen but on the flip side of that so we have if you look back to say the Sarah Everard
00:17:46 vigil on Clapham Common appalling crime was committed unfortunately by a serving metropolitan
00:17:53 police officer who is now admitted to that crime and a vigil wants to take place well
00:17:58 in normal circumstances there will be no issue with that at all but we had coronavirus restrictions
00:18:03 now the coronavirus doesn't care whether you're at a vigil it doesn't care whether you're in church
00:18:07 or a football stadium or on the tube if people are in close confines there is a good chance that
00:18:12 the virus will pass which is why those restrictions were put in place and into law the police were put
00:18:17 in a very invidious position there because what are they supposed to do um you know you can have
00:18:22 this vigil we understand they understood uh the deep sensitivity around why people would gather
00:18:26 at that vigil and the vigil went on all day and for the most part it was fine but right at the end
00:18:32 people wanted to start making speeches and everyone huddled up and that was when
00:18:35 the police tried to break it up and it ended up in the scenes we saw on social media
00:18:40 the police then got castigated for this for their insensitivity and their heavy-handed
00:18:45 but what were they supposed to do the law is the law the law was as it was passed by parliament
00:18:50 the police had said in advance please don't come to this because if people breach social distancing
00:18:56 we'll have to do something to break it up that was then upheld in the high court and everybody knew
00:18:59 that everyone knew that in advance but the problem we have with the police is that they often i think
00:19:05 they're too sensitive to the way they are covered in the media and part of the problem there is that
00:19:10 they don't feel i don't think that they have got political top cover for the job that they need to
00:19:15 do and the mayor of london would prove that point i think because he went public with his criticisms
00:19:21 of the commissioner um in terms of what she said to him afterwards quite how she can uh have a
00:19:27 working relationship with him after the way he threw her under the bus um that's a problem for
00:19:31 them but i would certainly have a problem working with him after what he said in public because all
00:19:36 he was interested in was his election prospects so he went after the police so the police have
00:19:40 got a very difficult job to do can you remind us of what he actually said well he said that her
00:19:45 explanation didn't satisfy him or words to that effect he was very much condemnatory in what he
00:19:52 said to her or said about her because he said i'll be asking for um an accounting of this from
00:19:57 the commissioner and then he came out and said i'm not satisfied with what she's told me and that's
00:20:01 not working together no i think the thing is is that uh from the perspective of a lot of people
00:20:07 who who watch for example uh they would not necessarily disagree with you on the sarah ever
00:20:12 but they would say but in that case but why then do the police seem to happily dance with
00:20:18 Extinction Rebellion or take the knee with Black Lives Matter and there's this feeling so that is
00:20:24 what when I say politicization that is what I'm really getting at and I think you've touched on
00:20:28 a couple of good points there because and these are questions I've had in conversation with very
00:20:33 senior police officers if you're wearing the Queen's uniform you're supposed to police without
00:20:38 fear or favor that's really important fear or favor you can't be seen to be favoring political
00:20:44 sides because once you do that then you've you've lost your authority so people dancing with 0.62
00:20:50 extinction rebellion people skateboarding extinction rebellion taking the near a black
00:20:54 lives matter march etc etc etc is a very bad advertisement for the police there was a young
00:20:59 police officer a couple of weeks ago who was at the palestinian march who shouted out about free
00:21:05 palestine well she's wearing the uniform and i think nothing's happened to her i think she's
00:21:09 i think there's uh disciplinary inquiries are ongoing um i mean you know she's a young
00:21:17 probationer but she should be investigated for that i personally think she should be in a lot
00:21:21 of trouble for that but that should apply across the board regardless of rank so when you have
00:21:28 senior police officers in uniform taking the knee that's a political statement a political gesture
00:21:32 when you have junior police officers taking the knee at protests that's a political statement
00:21:39 and police should stay away from this because they are supposed to be neutral they are supposed
00:21:44 to enforce the law not visibly take sides and i think those are very bad developments
00:21:50 and i know the police want to be seen as a more friendly organization than they might have been
00:21:57 seen in the past but they really mustn't blur the lines here their job is to enforce the law
00:22:02 and if they're there in their uniform they are representing the state they're representing the
00:22:07 queen they should not be taking part in anything that could be construed as politically partisan
00:22:12 because then that inhibits their their ability to actually enforce the law impartially you mentioned
00:22:17 there about uh Sadiq Khan and uh and the commissioner Cressida Dick um I should explain
00:22:23 by the way um Gareth was from the London Assembly and I was a Johnny come lately in I joined him
00:22:28 So we were sort of sitting relatively near each other, won't be the most question time.
00:22:36 That place was pretty much the mothership of woke, wasn't it, really?
00:22:40 Well, there were some notable exceptions, I would say, Peter.
00:22:43 But yes, I mean, the other political parties, so the Liberal Democrats, the Greens and Labour,
00:22:49 were much closer to what we would say is the woke ideology.
00:22:52 And Sadiq Khan embodies much of the woke ideology.
00:22:56 But there was some resistance.
00:22:58 obviously the conservative group um doesn't really go with that and uh and yourself and your
00:23:02 colleague from ukip um were sort of notably resistant indeed i remember your very um
00:23:09 interesting exchange with sadiq khan about statues uh which which i gather is now doing
00:23:14 doing the rounds on social media the tunes of land of hope and glory so it's got about a million
00:23:20 views yes it's remarkable isn't it um so yes i mean you know i i think because woke is very much
00:23:26 a left-wing thing and city hall is certainly on the left of the spectrum um you know and i think
00:23:33 a lot of people that work at city hall don't necessarily regard themselves as left-wing they
00:23:37 just think that well we're the mainstream middle like much of london does like the bbc does for
00:23:42 example but there's no doubt about it that they're they're on the left of the spectrum
00:23:46 and there's a lot of woke ideas in there you obviously is more effectively lead well leader
00:23:52 with the opposition to Khan on the assembly what do you what do you make of him of Sadiq Khan yeah
00:23:59 um in in private he can actually be you know occasionally he can be quite uh quite reasonable
00:24:07 and sometimes I think well maybe I've misjudged you maybe you're not such a bad guy
00:24:10 and then he'll say or do something in public I think you know what does the matter with you
00:24:14 he's a very political creature um he's very interested in his own position he likes I think
00:24:20 the platform that being mayor of london gives him he likes the attention i don't think he's
00:24:26 the impression i always got in the five years that he was mayor that i was still there i never
00:24:31 got the impression he actually wanted to do the job much he wasn't about outcomes i know what you
00:24:35 mean he was about positioning he was about attacking the government on everything he was
00:24:39 it was almost like a running commentary of what he perceived to be government failings
00:24:42 brexit dominated a lot of his time and and he could argue plausibly that brexit would have an
00:24:47 impact on London therefore he needs to have a view on it but it's spilled over all the time
00:24:52 into party political attacks and that's what he was using his position for you know so if you look
00:24:57 at his house building program that he likes to boast about the truth of the matter is he's built
00:25:00 17 he's completed 17,000 houses in five years that's negligible you know that's making no
00:25:07 difference at all you know he hasn't got a grip got to grips with knife crime that spiked massively
00:25:13 and carried on going up throughout his five years as mayor you know key tangible deliverables he
00:25:18 isn't delivering he likes the profile he's not so interested in the day job and he can be quite
00:25:25 I think unnecessarily nasty and unpleasant I think the way that he treated some assembly members was
00:25:30 over the line in terms of it just didn't need to be like that so he can be on occasion I think he
00:25:38 can be quite a small man in every way and i think i think he should be a bigger man in the job that
00:25:43 he's got why do you think therefore that he got re-elected gareth well that's a very good question
00:25:48 i mean i mean because honestly most people you know the one thing you came across was
00:25:52 he can't possibly be you know we've got shocking crime all of these things um and also london
00:25:59 very beleaguered you know people leaving london things like that
00:26:03 Well, London is tribally Labour in great, great swathes of it.
00:26:10 And if you look at, leave aside the mayoral election and the assembly election and just
00:26:13 look at, count up the number of councillors for each political party, the number of members
00:26:17 of parliament, the number of councils that are run by each political party.
00:26:22 And you can see that he was starting with a very big advantage right from the off.
00:26:26 And I think he worked out, he ran a very similar campaign to the one that he did in 2016.
00:26:30 the key difference was that this time he had a record to defend but he didn't do a great deal
00:26:35 in public did he i mean i i remember seeing two hustings on television one on bbc and one on itv
00:26:41 um he might have done one or two more but i didn't see them that was pretty much it there
00:26:45 wasn't a great deal else so he approached it with the i think the objective that as long as i don't
00:26:49 frighten the horses so say or do anything particularly outlandish i'm going to win
00:26:54 because i've got the inbuilt advantage and sure enough that's what happened i mean in 2016 the
00:26:58 the only policy difference that he was really offering was what he called his fares freeze,
00:27:03 which turned out to be a partial fares freeze. That was the only point of difference, really.
00:27:07 Everyone else agreed that we need more affordable housing. Everyone else agrees that we need to
00:27:10 crack down on crime, et cetera, et cetera. But he was going to freeze transport fares.
00:27:14 And that was the only real differential. And of course, that's caused Transport for London
00:27:18 some financial problems. So I think he won, not because he is Sadiq Khan. I think he won because
00:27:23 he was the Labour candidate in a city that still has a very large Labour vote his numbers went
00:27:29 down quite a lot but I think he started with a big advantage and maintained it do you think I
00:27:33 mean do you have any truck with the idea you know Orpington is a London constituency isn't it
00:27:37 your constituency do you have any truck with the idea which is sort of doing the rounds a bit that
00:27:42 you know the whole idea of mayors and assemblies is you know a bit dubious really you know it's
00:27:50 just a layer of government we we don't need i mean do you think it's an important role
00:27:54 it's an important role and it has an important uh as a figurehead it's very important i think
00:28:00 all three mayors have brought their own personality to it ken livingstone was the only job he ever
00:28:06 wanted in politics it was a destination job for him and he got the institution up and running uh
00:28:11 he introduced policies such as the congestion charge and whatnot um that people you know can
00:28:16 either like or dislike but you can't argue that ken nivingston put the institution on the map
00:28:20 boris came along and he gave it a bit of bounce i think there was a lot of optimism about how
00:28:24 boris did the job and he sort of projected london internationally um and you know he was fortunate
00:28:29 that the olympic games was coming to london and at the beginning of his second term they took place
00:28:34 and that that was i i don't think i've ever experienced anything that had such a national
00:28:38 feel-good factor as the olympics and i think boris benefited by that sadiq khan has changed it a bit
00:28:45 I find his reign at City Hall to be a much more negative experience
00:28:49 in the sense that it's just constantly critical.
00:28:51 Nothing's ever good.
00:28:52 It's always looking on the dark side of life rather than the bright side of life.
00:28:56 To the guts of your question, do we need mayors?
00:29:01 There is an argument for them because they can attract inward investment.
00:29:04 They can drive change on a more localised level than, say, Whitehall might.
00:29:10 The weak side of it is that it loosens the fabric of our nation.
00:29:13 there is no argument in my mind that devolution of power to scotland and wales has loosened the
00:29:18 fabric of the united kingdom the rollout of additional metro mayors hasn't helped so in a
00:29:25 national pandemic an emergency health situation we had reports of negotiations taking place between
00:29:32 the prime minister and the metro mayors of manchester and london about where they should
00:29:36 go in terms of lockdown and what financial support they'll be given negotiations what
00:29:41 they're not a sovereign state they should be taking orders not negotiating and you know so
00:29:48 this this all adds to confusion to doubt it undermines uh the sanctity of the nation um and
00:29:54 i i personally i would prefer to turn the clock back um and to get back to britain being a unified
00:30:01 state and not have these things because i think the political consequences outweigh the benefits
00:30:05 there are benefits but there are also political consequences and personally i'm unconvinced that
00:30:10 benefits outweigh the consequences just to go back to the book a bit um you know a lot of i
00:30:18 agree with huge amounts in it also i should say it does cover every sort of subject i mean as i
00:30:23 say immigration and education and and uh obviously woke the woke agenda um there are about 60 people
00:30:31 in the group, aren't there? 60 MPs and peers. How influential are you? Have you had any successes?
00:30:42 Yeah I think we have. So Oliver Dowden in particular in the culture space has really
00:30:48 stepped up in some regards regarding things like the institutions that are being funded by the
00:30:53 government about sort of really sort of setting down where they should go. We have been getting
00:30:58 in touch with a lot of these institutions as well um and they are quite willing to come and meet us
00:31:03 and we are very direct with them um and you know i think in the longer term that is is putting a
00:31:09 marker down too senior government ministers pay attention uh to what's coming out of the common
00:31:13 sense group you know we've had a number come to address us and listen to us um and i think you
00:31:17 know it is having an impact i i think um and and also further afield than that so i i did a what
00:31:23 we call an adjournment debate which is a members of parliament can apply to have debates as the
00:31:28 house is rising for the for the day and a minister will come in to reply to the debate they're not
00:31:32 hugely well attended as you can imagine because they tend to be at the end of the parliamentary
00:31:35 day and and by that point people have voted and they've had enough but mine was about it was about
00:31:40 woke um and it was about uh sadiq khan's commission to uh investigate and topple statues around london
00:31:46 um and i as the the mover of the adjournment debate get to make a lengthy speech and then
00:31:53 the minister will apply and other members within the half an hour that's lots of two it can also
00:31:56 contribute and we put that on youtube and uh quite a large number of people have written to me
00:32:02 thanking me for standing up and saying those things because they thought that no one in
00:32:06 westminster represented their views because social media has created this impression that the woke
00:32:12 view is the commonly held view and it really isn't you know twitter gets things wrong most of the
00:32:18 time if twitter is to be believed in aggregate we would never have had brexit boris would never
00:32:23 have become Prime Minister, the Conservative Party would not have won the last general
00:32:26 election. Because all of these things, the aggregate view on Twitter was these things
00:32:30 just won't happen. And the power of social media shouldn't be underestimated because
00:32:35 it creates an impression in people that aren't used to being on the receiving end of it that
00:32:39 this is massive outpouring of anger and whatever about whatever it happens to be. And they
00:32:44 make concessions to it. And this is how woke steals a march. So we've been pushing against
00:32:49 that so me standing up and doing that adjournment debate um the book that has has come out setting
00:32:54 out uh some alternative positions things that other mps are saying in parliament is starting
00:33:00 to push back on this i think woke has managed to steal the march for too long and what you're now
00:33:05 seeing is the beginning of a pushback against it it's by no means i don't think we've reached peak
00:33:10 woke here i don't think we've turned the tide yet i think it would take a lot more to do that
00:33:15 and a lot of the woke ideas i mean when i was growing up um some of them are rehashes of things
00:33:19 i saw back in the 1980s and in those days they were just dismissed as the loony left
00:33:23 but they didn't have the tool of the social media to broadcast their views so much wider audience
00:33:27 now they do and it creates the impression wrongly that this is the majority view it isn't yes it's
00:33:33 not although i i would just maybe add a bit to that in that it seems to me that you've got
00:33:39 twitter and social media yes of course but it is the speed with which our institutions
00:33:46 have capitulated or indeed it's actually coming from within whether it's a national trust right
00:33:53 through to the royal college of music yeah and instruments and things this is what people say
00:33:58 where does this come from you know where is this and i just wonder you also talk about the bbc in
00:34:03 the book not not you but one of your uh fellow writers uh the bbc should be broken up because
00:34:08 BBC is the citadel of a lot of this. Yes. Are you impatient with the government? I mean,
00:34:13 in the sense that the government talks about decriminalising the licence fee. But so far
00:34:18 as I know, they've kind of, that's not happening now. Is that right? Well, it hasn't happened yet.
00:34:22 I mean, there's, the charter is due for renewal, and there'll be another conversation about that
00:34:26 coming up in the very near future. I'm not an advocate of decriminalisation, because if you
00:34:33 simply decriminalize it the BBC can then take you to civil courts to chase you for it so you end up
00:34:39 with a bigger bill it's like not paying a parking fine if you don't pay a parking fine you won't get
00:34:42 a criminal record but you'll be chased through the civil courts and you may end up with a huge
00:34:45 big fine with court costs and everything else and decriminalizing it particularly for the over 75s
00:34:51 might mean that they end up in an even worse position financially than than if they just
00:34:56 had to pay the had to pay the charge had to pay the license fee my personal preference will be
00:35:01 to examine whether the BBC needs to exist in its current form at all anymore and if it does then
00:35:07 you know I think there is an argument for it to be a subscription service and the reason for that
00:35:11 is the BBC is not impartial it pretends that it is but it isn't as you said yourself it's
00:35:16 been at the forefront of pushing some of these woke ideas it certainly doesn't act like the
00:35:20 British Broadcasting Corporation it seems to see its job as criticising the British state at every
00:35:25 opportunity and we've had umpteen examples from brexit and beyond of panels being loaded in one
00:35:32 direction of for example people talking about the national health service criticizing government
00:35:36 managing of the national health service you'll get a number of people who might be doctors or
00:35:39 nurses or so on who then it turns out they are doctors and nurses but they're also members of
00:35:43 the labor party yes and that's never acknowledged so you get a view uh that this is the view of the
00:35:48 national health service and it turns out no it's not actually it's a political view
00:35:52 And stuff like that, I don't think is quite good. But the main point, of course, is that when the
00:35:56 BBC was set up, there was one broadcaster, one channel, and this was the way to make it work.
00:36:01 And that was perfectly fine. Now there's a whole myriad of alternatives available to people.
00:36:06 One of my colleagues put it very well in the house when he stood up and said,
00:36:10 when I go to buy my morning paper, I will choose the Telegraph or the Daily Mail or whatever I want.
00:36:16 if I wanted to read The Guardian I would choose to buy The Guardian but I choose not to so why
00:36:23 when I'm wanting to watch whatever I want to watch on television am I obliged to pay a compulsory
00:36:29 tax to get Guardian type views fed to me through the broadcast media when I don't want them
00:36:34 that's unarguable there's a multitude especially with with online streaming now there are so many
00:36:41 different sources for people to get their information do we need the BBC in the form
00:36:45 that it was put in in the 1940s and you know if it goes down a subscription model and it wants to
00:36:51 continue to broadcast the sort of views that it does now well that will be up to them. How popular
00:36:58 is your view in the Conservative Parliamentary Party would you say about the BBC? I think there
00:37:04 are a range of views I think amongst backbenchers I think my view is probably in the majority
00:37:10 it isn't it certainly isn't unanimous there are some some defenders of the BBC
00:37:18 and to be honest I mean I used to be a great advocate of the BBC I used to really
00:37:22 like the BBC's output I thought it was very high quality I thought it was much more impartial than
00:37:28 it is now you know there's a lot of good stuff that it did but it's become just so the balance
00:37:36 has tilted so much that uh that i now don't think it's capable of reforming itself back to what it
00:37:42 where it should be and if it can't do that then i think it should lose the license fee and should
00:37:45 go to a subscription model finally uh uh you you came into parliament at a kind of rather weird
00:37:52 time because you came in at 2019 and then bang you know the following year we went into this
00:37:57 lockdown thing well how has it been how has it how has it affected you as an mp this whole thing i
00:38:03 I mean, has it sort of had the effect of making you more remote?
00:38:08 I mean, because you can't, you know, I just as purely anecdotally,
00:38:13 some MPs that I heard have felt so frustrated and so far from the actual centre of things
00:38:19 because of the physical restrictions.
00:38:22 Well, yes.
00:38:24 I mean, the first thing is I hope that my election to Parliament is entirely unconnected
00:38:28 with the pandemic breaking out.
00:38:30 But yeah, it's been a strange introduction.
00:38:33 Because, I mean, we were elected on the 12th of December.
00:38:37 So our first day in Parliament was the following Monday and we did a week.
00:38:40 And then we went into Christmas recess.
00:38:43 I think I got my office probably the end of January, around about then.
00:38:47 So that's when my staff were able to move in and we started functioning.
00:38:50 And then, of course, we went into lockdown within six or seven weeks.
00:38:53 So we haven't really experienced Parliament as it normally would be.
00:38:57 So the social areas in Parliament, the chamber itself, you can't get into the chamber unless you're on the call list.
00:39:02 you have to apply for a ballot to get onto the call list and so that's a lottery and invariably
00:39:06 the odds are against you and because of the need for social distancing you can't just go in you
00:39:11 can't intervene in debates as you used to be able to you can't what we call bobbing so you'll have
00:39:16 seen at prime minister's question time in normal times that whenever the prime minister finishes
00:39:19 his answer you see lots of mps across chambers stand up those will be people that are not on
00:39:23 the order paper they're trying to catch the speaker's eye in the hope that he might ask them
00:39:27 to a question towards the end if they can sort of jump in you can't do any bobbing at the moment
00:39:32 because unless you're on the call list you can't go in a lot of the all of the committees at the
00:39:36 moment are being done largely remotely the social restrictions in places like where MPs congregate
00:39:43 so the tea room the smoking room etc they're starting to reopen now but they're with capacity
00:39:49 restrictions so a lot of my intake have not really experienced what it's like as an MP in Westminster
00:39:55 properly and one of the things I was very keen to do in my first year as a member of parliament
00:39:59 pre-pandemic in Westminster I wanted to go into the chamber a lot to observe more experienced
00:40:05 members and see how they did things what works in there what doesn't and learn from other people
00:40:09 just by watching and that hasn't been possible because of this but in my constituency I wanted
00:40:14 to get out and meet as many of my stakeholders face to face as I could so go around all of my
00:40:18 schools to to you know meet as many of my businesses and some of that has been possible
00:40:23 but nowhere near on the level that I was hoping it was going to be and I'm very much hoping that
00:40:28 as we approach the potential lifting of all restrictions that both sides of that equation
00:40:33 starts to change so almost two years in as a member of parliament my intake can start learning
00:40:37 how mps function properly yes exactly because we've all spoken in the chamber we all sit on
00:40:42 committees we all ask questions but we've done it in this very strange atmosphere you know i've never
00:40:46 faced i've never spoken uh in a chamber with you know the benches opposite me packed where i'm
00:40:52 being hissed and heckled and whatever so i've never had to deal with that um and that's going
00:40:57 to be a new experience and it's the same for all of my intake so it's been a very weird first sort
00:41:02 of year and a bit but the context for this though peter is is very important because this is small
00:41:07 beer compared to some of the suffering that we've seen around the country because of the pandemic
00:41:11 and so i don't want to lay a big woe is me card on the table because some people have suffered
00:41:15 grievously because of this is it right that you're actually going to be going into a temporary
00:41:20 chamber as well is that what's happening there is that is that still happening this is because
00:41:24 parliament itself is huge you've got a huge restoration thing going on hasn't it so it's
00:41:29 actually closed oh no of course it's not closed no parliament's open but the the current intention
00:41:35 it's called the restoration renewal project uh is that the palace of westminster itself needs such
00:41:41 an overhaul that um before my time it was decided by a previous parliament that the plan would be
00:41:47 as follows they would build a temporary chamber temporary has a commons chamber where richmond
00:41:52 house now is on whitehall yes yeah uh they'd move the house of lords into the queen elizabeth
00:41:58 second center over the road from over over parliament square um and we would stay in there
00:42:03 so it would be decanted into there whilst they renovated the the palace of westminster um
00:42:11 that would save money and would probably whether it's allegedly it would save money it would it
00:42:15 would probably speed things up a bit my reservation about that you know because there's some argument
00:42:20 about whether that could be revisited and changed my reservation about that is that um a future
00:42:26 government that didn't value the history and tradition of parliament might not ever put us
00:42:30 back into the power of westminster so the house of commons as it is now would become a museum or
00:42:35 something like that i think there's a real plausibility about that that's occurred to me
00:42:39 actually this would be the perfect time to actually make a permanent change and i i i would
00:42:45 resolutely oppose that yeah you know the parliament itself is one of the great institutions
00:42:51 and symbols of our nation uh it's a very historic place you can feel the history when you walk
00:42:55 down the corridors there um you know the house of commerce chamber itself actually isn't that old
00:43:00 it was rebuilt after a turret hit from a german bomb during world war ii but this is the same
00:43:05 chamber that people like winston churchill clement attley margaret thatcher spoke in 0.99
00:43:10 and I would be loathe to see all of that history and tradition scrapped because you know an incoming
00:43:17 government in a few years time decided to renege on a plan that was conceived in the 20 teens
00:43:23 so that it is the current plan but it could be revised and I hope that it is I hope that they
00:43:31 do it in a way that they partially decant so it might be for example the House of Lords moves over
00:43:35 the road and the House of Commons sits in the House of Lords while the House of Commons is being done
00:43:38 and then they go back and so on and so forth well i mean i do hope gareth that you uh you do manage
00:43:44 to get his stand uh as you say uh from uh from the packed opposition benches at some time soon
00:43:51 uh you know that it all starts working as it should do um where can people read uh the book
00:43:57 the common sense where is is there a link they can go to uh to get it it's on the common sense
00:44:02 group site is that yes it's available online it's available online i believe it's been
00:44:07 i believe i've got the link to it which i i think i've sent to you which you're more than happy for
00:44:12 you to put that up yeah when it goes out yeah um the common sense group doesn't yet have a website
00:44:17 right um but it has been released online i see okay well we'll put that up but but thanks very
00:44:23 much indeed for coming on my pleasure and uh you know i hope that uh the um collection is listened
00:44:29 to by the white people um and um thanks very much indeed good to see you um that's it um we shall
00:44:36 see you next week but as i said at the beginning please do remember when you to subscribe thanks
00:44:41 very much bye