New Culture Forum - June 19, 2021


What Do We Think Of GB News? Reviewing Britain's Newest News Channel

Victor Davis Hanson - Biden & Radical Elites Are Destroying America Gareth Bacon MP - Member of the Conservative Party's anti-woke "Common Sense Group"

Episode Stats


Length

55 minutes

Words per minute

188.59

Word count

10,395

Sentence count

302


Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
00:00:00 Hello and welcome to Counterculture. I'm Peter Whitfall. Now I say this every time
00:00:18 but that's because I mean it every time. Please do remember to subscribe, won't you?
00:00:22 It's very simple, you just go to the subscribe button, press that. Next door
00:00:27 there is a blue bell you press that too that means you get notifications of all our programs
00:00:33 as they come up so don't forget to do that um well last sunday uh was probably one of the most
00:00:41 hotly anticipated media events for well years and years that was the launch of gb news so today on
00:00:49 counterculture we're going to be discussing well as morcom and white used to say what do you think
00:00:53 of it so far but also we're going to be talking about the wider implications of GB News for the
00:00:59 media landscape and also more specifically the whole idea of impartiality. Has that actually
00:01:07 kindly finally died a death? Now to talk about these issues I'm very pleased to say we have
00:01:14 Gawain Tola who's a columnist for The Critic and also was press secretary for the Brexit party.
00:01:19 We have Claire Fox, that's Baroness Fox of Buckley to you and me, Rafe Hadle-Manku, of course, from the New Culture Forum, historian and commentator, and the television documentary maker, Douglas Churnside.
00:01:35 Thank you very much for coming. Can I start with you? What's your first impression of GB News?
00:01:44 i think uh it needs time to bed in yeah i thought that andrew neil's opening
00:01:52 one hour show on sunday evening was brilliant and it it spoke to exactly what i want the channel to
00:02:00 be because i think it's been caricatured in advance as being you know some vehicle for
00:02:07 right-wing prejudice and a uk fox news and that it will throw impartiality out of the window
00:02:13 But I think that he explained that certainly the ideals of the channel are that there won't be any attempts at, for example, putting out information that's not true or, you know, that they're going to have very high standards themselves.
00:02:29 Now, I think that it's going to take a bit of time to see whether that can work and not
00:02:33 all the shows will follow that format, as I think was obvious by the fact that the Dan
00:02:39 Wharton show that followed it didn't follow that format and you could see, therefore,
00:02:43 the reaction on social media was immediately say, ha ha, gotcha.
00:02:48 But when you actually watched it the next day, you saw that the different programmes
00:02:51 had very different tones to them.
00:02:54 Now, I want it to work.
00:02:57 I really want it to work.
00:02:58 And the reason I want it to work, which I think is a more significant thing for me, is that I really believe that the media landscape needs shaking up and that impartiality is, which we're going to go on to discuss, the impartiality has become stuck in aspic.
00:03:14 i believe in impartiality but not in the way that it's been interpreted in recent years
00:03:20 so i'm hopeful that this is a channel that will represent far more intuitively what ordinary
00:03:27 people are interested in pursuing but i feel is neither represented on their mainstream tv channels
00:03:33 and indeed that even raising some of the questions will get them in trouble and they're walking on
00:03:39 eggshells and they're not allowed to say it so that's a good thing for me uh do you feel that
00:03:43 it's Douglas and it is a fresh thing do you know as Claire said there the actual opening monologue
00:03:49 I thought was very impressive but you know we're going to look at things anew do you think it's
00:03:53 it looks like it's going to do that yes I do I absolutely love it I think it's terrific it's
00:03:58 very positive it's entertaining I thought they were absolutely right to have Andrew Neill set
00:04:06 out their stall but what they did much better than that was they then fulfilled exactly what
00:04:10 he said they were going to do. Dan Wooten is a fantastic TV star. I don't know how anyone can go
00:04:19 for three hours on live television with that amount of energy and he's got a unique capability
00:04:25 I think of really challenging people quite aggressively while being very likable and
00:04:30 charming. This is not Newsnight, it's not Piers Morgan, he doesn't interrupt people all the time
00:04:35 But that first three hours was like a train going at 100 miles an hour.
00:04:40 He had great guests.
00:04:42 I thought the Chinese scientist whistleblower was an exciting guest.
00:04:46 I thought Lord Sumption was a challenging guest.
00:04:49 He would not be allowed to say those things uninterrupted on other channels.
00:04:54 When I watched through the day yesterday and today,
00:04:56 I have a slightly different opinion about it.
00:04:58 I agree totally with Claire.
00:05:00 The programmes very strongly reflect the cast that they've assembled.
00:05:04 Andrew Neil or whoever it is has made a family of people and like some American
00:05:10 channels I think what they're going to do is these are going to be our friends
00:05:13 these are going to be people I'll pick this three hours you'll pick that two
00:05:17 hours but I'll like this guy and the person that he's doing the show with or
00:05:21 this woman and her colleague and the sort of people that they have on and the
00:05:26 sort of things that they discuss I do have a lot of comments about it as a
00:05:30 television producer i don't ever do live television it's it's very scary and gb news is explaining
00:05:37 very clearly why it is very clearly they've had every single technical fault you could possibly
00:05:42 have but they've got terrific people they haven't had people sitting waiting for an autocue to roll
00:05:49 up they keep talking they all keep going they're never lost for words um they have constantly
00:05:55 new guests coming on from very ordinary people
00:05:58 in places that, I mean, they went to Hoyt yesterday morning.
00:06:02 Nobody in their right mind ever goes there
00:06:05 to do TV interviews.
00:06:06 They've been all over the north of England.
00:06:08 They've been to Wales.
00:06:10 I haven't seen anything in Scotland yet,
00:06:12 but I have noticed they haven't, on the bits I've seen,
00:06:15 they haven't gone to London.
00:06:17 They've deliberately stayed away.
00:06:19 Today, they did a piece with a woman
00:06:21 who is the arts director or something like that
00:06:24 at the Birmingham Hippodrome.
00:06:25 Now, if you were on the BBC,
00:06:27 they would either talk to Andrew Lloyd Webber
00:06:29 or they'd talk to somebody in subsidised theatre.
00:06:31 They actually talked to somebody on a modest budget
00:06:34 who has to put bums on seats
00:06:36 about the four-week delay in lockdown.
00:06:41 And what she explained was,
00:06:42 I need to put 75% bums on seats to even break even,
00:06:47 and it's another four weeks of this year, I can't do that.
00:06:49 Now, this was just very refreshing to me.
00:06:52 It wasn't a whining person asking for government money.
00:06:55 It was somebody running a theatre
00:06:57 just explaining to you how that sort of business works.
00:07:01 And most of us have no idea.
00:07:02 And you suddenly think,
00:07:03 well, I'm now thinking very differently
00:07:05 about the announcement that the Prime Minister made yesterday.
00:07:09 Gwaine, did you stay with Dan Wooden for three hours?
00:07:14 I didn't.
00:07:15 Right.
00:07:17 I watched a bit of it, I have to admit,
00:07:20 mostly um on uh watch back mainly because about a year or so ago i gave up on tv news altogether
00:07:28 right and turned off my license so i have to go on to onto the internet to watch it
00:07:33 this may change my mind but i i i got so fed up despite my life for the last 20 years being
00:07:39 news news news news news over the last four or five years i've given up on the news i'll read
00:07:44 read the papers sometimes.
00:07:46 I'll read weekly magazines,
00:07:48 New Scientist, The Economist, New Statesman,
00:07:50 Spectator, because
00:07:52 they cover all the things that
00:07:54 are not instant
00:07:56 and the instant
00:07:58 is of less interest to me. Now I'm not
00:08:00 doing day-to-day political press
00:08:02 releases and things of that sort.
00:08:05 So I didn't watch it all.
00:08:07 I have watched to a certain extent.
00:08:08 What do you think of that format?
00:08:11 It's very much, isn't it, it's like
00:08:12 well it is
00:08:14 these are long shows
00:08:15 when I
00:08:17 coming back to what was said earlier
00:08:20 about the group of friends
00:08:21 it was very apparent
00:08:22 in watching all the Twitter feeds
00:08:24 of the various people
00:08:25 as they were being brought into GB News
00:08:27 as they started talking to each other
00:08:29 people from very different backgrounds
00:08:31 the Del Piero show
00:08:33 against somebody who is very
00:08:35 unlike her historically
00:08:38 it reminded me
00:08:40 and I would say this
00:08:41 to a hammer and nails and all that but it reminded me of pushing together the crowd of people who
00:08:46 were then to become the Brexit party MEPs you had I remember turning a corner once in the first week
00:08:52 after the election turning a corner in Strasbourg and walking towards me in lockstep with these two
00:08:57 women Anne Whittacombe and that one and I looked at it and went oh my goodness and everybody
00:09:06 everybody they're going to fall out they're going to fall out thick as thieves and have remained so
00:09:11 ever since because though they have wildly different points of view they shared a belief
00:09:17 in that diversity of thought they shared a belief in democracy they shared a belief
00:09:22 in that pluralism that meant despite very strong differences of opinion on a whole range of issues
00:09:29 they have they became friends and that what you were talking about this melding together very
00:09:34 different people with very different outlooks in a common endeavor to improve the lot of the people
00:09:41 of this country to improve the understanding of the people in this country is something that can
00:09:47 can really become something special now it hasn't happened yet but it is clear absolutely clear that
00:09:54 that is what seems to be happening out of base metal in some cases we may see some form of of
00:10:02 media tungsten come out and I wish it well. Do you think, Ray, that this is, it
00:10:10 calls itself GB News and this is not being facetious really but it seems it
00:10:16 is mostly opinion to me and that's not a bad thing but would you say that it's
00:10:22 what you were expecting? It is by and large. I would say it's more accurate to
00:10:27 call it a 24-hour editorial channel rather than a news channel because of the very nature and i
00:10:34 actually i understand full well why andrew neal decided not to do a rolling news program because
00:10:38 we all know that the ratings for rolling news be it bbc or cnn are very low unless you're dealing
00:10:43 with the gulf war or some major event people don't tune in or they need for covid but at the same
00:10:48 time i think you know there is a huge void in this country for people who want to watch the news
00:10:53 but don't actually want to watch mainstream news
00:10:56 because they know that they're centre-left to varying degrees.
00:11:00 And so whilst it's fine to have all these opinion shows,
00:11:02 which are based obviously on MSNBC and Fox News and Sky News Australia...
00:11:06 Do you think they're all actually based on that?
00:11:07 Well, that's clearly the model to have a personality-based format.
00:11:10 I think it was a mistake not to have a news for half an hour
00:11:15 at, say, 6pm at 1 o'clock and at 9pm or 10pm,
00:11:19 just to have a half-hour news so people who don't watch BBC,
00:11:22 who don't watch ITV or Channel 4
00:11:25 could actually tune in and get news
00:11:27 where they actually aren't throwing their slippers at the TV in anger.
00:11:31 And I think that was a bit of a mistake.
00:11:33 And I don't know, maybe it's a cost issue
00:11:35 because putting together a news programme
00:11:36 is a very expensive thing to do.
00:11:38 But they do have reporters out there.
00:11:40 I think there would be a way to,
00:11:41 even if not just news bulletins,
00:11:44 look at the format of Good Morning Britain, right?
00:11:45 Why not have a similar format to Good Morning Britain
00:11:48 for their big breakfast show
00:11:49 by having just news headlines announced there?
00:11:51 That was a bit of a mistake.
00:11:53 But it is called GB News.
00:11:54 And I did love Andrew Neill's swipe to the BBC during his opening monologue
00:11:58 when he said, here at GB News, we won't forget what the B stands for in our name.
00:12:03 And so it is something that I think is actually very, very positive.
00:12:06 And I'm so delighted by this channel.
00:12:08 It's absolutely necessary.
00:12:09 And, you know, it's going to reach like Heineken.
00:12:11 It's going to reach the parts other channels won't reach.
00:12:14 People like us and our viewers surely will find something here.
00:12:17 I've got it on all the time now, at least for the next few days,
00:12:20 just to get a taste of it and I'm actually enjoying it even though like Claire I think it was a huge
00:12:25 mistake to have Dan Witten on right after Andrew Neil had said there will be no hectoring there'll
00:12:30 be no shouting and all we got for the next three hours was hectoring and shouting and ironically
00:12:35 you know here we have a similar format but it's calmed collected reasoned discussion which I
00:12:42 think increases people's information and knowledge of a subject now conflict always creates good
00:12:48 ratings but you get to a point where that can become a bit tiresome and it no one actually
00:12:52 learns anything and the great shame to me was on that first show they had one person from the
00:12:57 left benjamin butterworth from the independent he's a real kind of a very lefty famous from his
00:13:03 interactions with piers morgan and he ended up in my opinion being the most reasonable person there
00:13:07 and actually felt sympathy for him because he was ganged up on by everybody else there's space for
00:13:12 that but it was a shame to have that following that wonderful monologue from andrew neal well
00:13:17 it's about time we had shows where the one person from the left is ganged up as they would be if
00:13:22 they were in a pub. If you turn on BBC or any channel, Channel 4 News, the person who has the
00:13:30 right of centre view is always the one that has to moderate what they say. They're the one that
00:13:35 is interrupted all the time. On the first evening, they had Nigel Farage on. It's the first time I've
00:13:40 heard him manage to get a sentence out. And the only thing that came in and interrupted him were
00:13:45 the adverts because the adverts are on an automatic timing system and they got their
00:13:49 timing slightly wrong. I would just say in defense of Dan Wooten that this is the first evening of
00:13:57 this channel and his show for three hours outrated the BBC News and Sky News added together for three
00:14:05 consecutive hours and I think a lot of people like me turned on thinking I will give this five
00:14:10 So I know Dan Witten is on radio, but I don't know him and I don't know what he normally does.
00:14:16 But I just found that he's smiley and it was positive.
00:14:20 I was saying to you earlier on the way here, I was listening to Jeremy Vine.
00:14:23 So I've only listened to GB News for the last two and a half days because I was dutifully doing it for this.
00:14:30 But also it's entertaining and I've been enjoying it.
00:14:32 But in the car, I put on, I couldn't bear to put on Radio 4 at one o'clock, but I put on Jeremy Vine.
00:14:39 and they're announcing Britain and Australia have signed a historic trade deal well this is what
00:14:45 everybody voted for for Brexit this is a fantastic thing for Australia and for the United Kingdom
00:14:49 and we had 10 minutes of absolute misery and why it's terrible for farmers why it's terrible for
00:14:55 the environment and the climate emergency because apparently we're all only ever going to now eat
00:15:01 substandard Australian steak raised by cruel farmers who are horrible to animals and then
00:15:08 shipped on dirty old sort of puffers all the way to England and flogged through discount
00:15:13 supermarkets. And OK, I'm exaggerating it, but every time I turn on the BBC, which is
00:15:19 very rare these days, and it's the same with anything really in the mainstream, it's always
00:15:25 the negative. It's always the downside. And GB News is not uncritical. They've been very
00:15:32 critical of Boris in the last day. They've been critical of some Labour policy, but they've
00:15:38 also told you a lot of good news stories are just nice things to hear that are life-affirming and
00:15:44 there's definitely a place for that positive television gets better ratings than negative
00:15:48 television and i think they'll do well with that would you agree with that no um not really or some
00:15:55 some parts of course yes i think the critique of mainstream media is well made that's that's why
00:16:00 gb news exists we all can see that and we're all here because we are fed up with that and certainly
00:16:06 people are fed off of being condescended to
00:16:09 fed up of hearing the negative
00:16:11 I think what GB News
00:16:13 has got to avoid though
00:16:15 and this is why I had some sympathy
00:16:17 with the points that you were making about
00:16:19 the person being ganged up on
00:16:22 you see, well you can say
00:16:23 that's always what's happened elsewhere
00:16:25 well I've never liked it anywhere
00:16:26 I don't want to see a kind of
00:16:29 alternative version of ganging up on
00:16:31 what's the point of that
00:16:32 I want to be able to hear what people are saying
00:16:34 and I think that what's creative
00:16:36 and i actually quite enjoyed it uh dan wharton show last night where three of the guests were
00:16:40 actually um pro the lockdown or pro the extension of the lockdown restrictions versus dance we had
00:16:48 to kind of mediate it a bit and actually you got what you got in that then was a more interesting
00:16:53 conversation because dan had to kind of really think it through more and it then those three
00:16:58 had differences of opinion amongst themselves so i mean that was kind of like just the way that the
00:17:03 cookie crumbled on in terms of their opinions on that it doesn't mean they're left or right but i
00:17:08 just i i what i um think that we've got to find out what will happen is if it's a personality
00:17:16 led show then at the moment it's not yet clear which personalities will see but you know because
00:17:23 there's a kind of enthusiasm and we we're kind of not quite sure and everybody's getting on so you're
00:17:28 you're not quite sure everyone's making a big effort so you're not really sure like where the
00:17:33 tensions lie so the reason i'm saying that is because it can't be too samey and actually i'm
00:17:38 going to be regularly on dan's show so i'm you know i i i i hesitate to to to say this but i think
00:17:45 that i don't i won't be watching three hours of it every night let's put it that way because
00:17:49 there's a danger of that being too samey and some people by the way love him so it's going to be
00:17:55 as a presenter and like you have said god he's a new star and all that but i i actually think
00:18:00 sometimes that can be broken up and just on the news points i think is quite important i um i
00:18:06 think it's too expensive to have rolling music i mean it's just too expensive to say that you'll
00:18:10 create the news you know that kind of has expectations but where i think that there's
00:18:16 a slight danger and is that the issues become repetitive because it's almost like yesterday's
00:18:23 headlines or what that what's trending or in fact they're quite explicit in good new bit is that
00:18:29 they say well we're not just going to stick with what's on the front page of the guardian the times
00:18:32 you know we're also going to look at what's online they're as likely to be able to say well what did
00:18:37 anyone think of the new culture forum discussion as they are about something else they're very
00:18:41 broad-minded but the danger i mean if i'm not kidding you if i hear another conversation about
00:18:46 taking the knee i'm going to scream it's been on practically every program since it started
00:18:53 Now, as I think that that is an over-fetishised symbol
00:18:56 that is becoming meaningless and degrading anti-racism,
00:19:00 what I don't want to do is to also have to repeatedly hear people saying,
00:19:04 you know, there's a problem with protecting the knee.
00:19:06 So, and I think that's a danger of not having the immediacy of the news.
00:19:10 You know, in some ways, what the news, the real genuine news does
00:19:13 is it gives you the story to talk about
00:19:16 rather than just repeating what's popular.
00:19:19 OK, but they're not going to be a 24-hour news channel
00:19:22 like CNN or the BBC or Sky.
00:19:24 And you're absolutely right, it is.
00:19:26 It's utterly unaffordable.
00:19:28 I think we have to acknowledge that a group of individuals,
00:19:31 some independent people, have actually launched
00:19:33 a 24-hour or nearly 24-hour channel on TV.
00:19:36 The other people who've launched it have been the BBC,
00:19:39 ITV tried and didn't last with it,
00:19:42 and Sky, they're people with literally bottomless pockets.
00:19:45 But there's no point in sitting here doing hagiography, is there?
00:19:47 Otherwise, why have I come?
00:19:48 right if we can't be as it were friends of the channel and and make some constructive criticism
00:19:54 then it's never going to get anywhere and that's what happens whenever you try and discuss the
00:19:58 bbc whenever i i love the bbc i believe in impartiality i'm a bit of a bbc type if i try
00:20:04 and uh criticize the bbc i'm generally and in fact in the house of lords they had a discussion
00:20:11 on public service broadcast broadcasting because i critiqued the bbc they immediately said that i
00:20:17 hated the bbc everybody else said the bbc was wonderful wouldn't take any criticism now what
00:20:22 gb news does not need well those of us to not be able to say what will be better is if you do that
00:20:28 so i actually thought that point where you say we're not a 24-hour news channel but why don't
00:20:34 we have a news program which is a bit more located not all you have to do is i know it's
00:20:38 but to have watched somebody else's news program there and give a few headlines right so you can
00:20:43 kind of for the viewer you can locate oh the big news are these things now let's have a discussion
00:20:48 about it i'm just saying if you don't do that sometimes it's a bit too free floating where i
00:20:54 think they've been really successful i'm really grieved with what you said about the uh the
00:20:57 regional reporters that feels quite newsy yeah it's good and actually when they had a great piece
00:21:02 on northern ireland where they actually had uh somebody up there northern ireland correspondent
00:21:07 but talking about the problems of the northern ireland protocol on the ground in a way that was
00:21:12 informed and intelligent and
00:21:14 part of the news agenda
00:21:15 sometimes they've gone a bit much on the local news
00:21:19 to the point where it's like yeah but that's such a
00:21:20 banal piece of local news, we don't need to have a conversation about it
00:21:23 other things have been utterly riveting
00:21:24 so I think that they need to locate
00:21:27 themselves with some factual news
00:21:28 stories, that's all I'm saying
00:21:29 and not just what's meaning or
00:21:32 trending
00:21:33 in many cases when it comes to the
00:21:36 pre-standing
00:21:39 ITV channel for BBC
00:21:41 Sky, they
00:21:42 have been looking into certain subjects and their scoop stories when they lead the news when they
00:21:49 break a story this is after x many months hard work behind the scenes gb news has been doing
00:21:57 its hard work trying to get his text stuff sorted getting getting melding this thing together i
00:22:02 think that side of things will come some of these journalists that they've taken on board
00:22:08 are highly experienced very good journalists and they will by just by breathing be unable
00:22:15 to be the sort of person who just sits there and does comment they will want to find stuff out
00:22:20 right day three you're not going to be there and I think that that's I think what's going to be
00:22:26 very interesting this sort of this sort of project what will be interesting is who survives in six
00:22:34 month's time some of these some of the old and bold will have got tired of this new format and
00:22:40 all the rest of it and will feel that maybe not for me others of the new people that they've been
00:22:44 blooding in this in these in these shows again just won't be able to hack it we don't know yet
00:22:51 they don't know yet see what happens in six months time it will have bedded down we'll start seeing
00:22:57 their news reporters particularly the regional ones coming up with serious and and and really
00:23:01 important stories from around the country and some of the main presenters it just won't work
00:23:09 and that's fine yeah that's not a problem but you're exactly right and picking up on claire's
00:23:15 point too it's important for to acknowledge that all five of us are absolutely behind gb news
00:23:20 100 and so our criticisms of it are intended to be constructive and taken in that light and we
00:23:25 want it to succeed and that's why we're sticking our oar in even though it's in early days uh but
00:23:31 But the point you've made is very, very critical
00:23:32 because Andrew Neil has clearly said
00:23:34 that this is supposed to be personality-led.
00:23:37 So everything is built around the programmes
00:23:39 and the people hosting the programmes.
00:23:41 And the models are MSNBC on the left,
00:23:44 Fox News and Sky News Australia.
00:23:46 My slight concern,
00:23:47 that's why I want to see what happens over the next six months,
00:23:49 is that of all the models,
00:23:51 none of them have presenters who are as young
00:23:55 as the presenters are on this channel.
00:23:57 and my fear is that they lack currently it's not just no fault of theirs being that young
00:24:03 but to me they lack the experience some of them lack the experience and the skill and the knowledge
00:24:09 to actually seem as if they're commanding their roles and I'm not quite sure how they're going
00:24:15 to learn that other than by cutting their teeth as journalists in the world of journalism so if
00:24:19 you look at the successes of Fox News and others you had Megyn Kelly on Dan Whitton's show right
00:24:24 you've got Tucker Carlson these are experienced people I would have expected somebody like Julia
00:24:29 Hartley Brewer to be pairing one of the experienced male broadcasters for one of the sorts of shows
00:24:34 that's the that's the energy the dynamic the sort of relationship you get where there's actually
00:24:39 you can see there's a bit of a disconnect between the two presenters and quite a few of the shows
00:24:43 without naming names although it's fair to say people like Tucker Carlson and Megan Kelly were
00:24:48 actually very young when they because they started 25 years ago on those sorts of shows in America
00:24:52 I spend a lot of time in America and I've seen them over the last 25 years and I used to wonder how old Tucker Carlson was because he seemed to be very opinionated for somebody who I thought at the time was a lot younger than me.
00:25:06 What I think I wanted to pick up on a point you made about how they can create news is the easiest way for them to create news is Andrew Neil or another person interviewing somebody eminent such as the Prime Minister at a key time.
00:25:21 The problem they'll have, of course, is that Andrew Neil is, you know, nobody wants to get brilloaded.
00:25:26 Nobody wants to be skewered.
00:25:29 And so it was very interesting seeing him with Steve Baker.
00:25:32 It was a rigorous interview.
00:25:34 Steve Baker wasn't just allowed to say what he wanted.
00:25:38 He wasn't interrupted.
00:25:39 It was analytical.
00:25:41 He was put on the spot.
00:25:43 And I find him very interesting.
00:25:45 But it isn't a headline news story that's going to be in the paper tomorrow.
00:25:48 but it would be if they'd got Boris or Keir Starmer to come on
00:25:53 and normally when these sorts of channels launch
00:25:55 they do get somebody like that, a really, really big interviewee to come on
00:25:59 and so far they haven't announced anybody.
00:26:01 But if I come back on that point,
00:26:03 the key issue here in these early days is ratings, ratings, ratings
00:26:08 and you need to have big name guests
00:26:10 but you also need to have presenters who are equally of a big stature.
00:26:14 Now they've got Andrew Neil who's an alias, right?
00:26:16 They've got excellent presenters like Simon McCoy, Colin Brazier, and Alistair Stewart, who are superb.
00:26:22 But it's still lacking another big name, heavy hitter, someone like Piers Morgan.
00:26:27 Now, we were told that it would cost about $2 million to get him away from ITV.
00:26:33 Now, when you've got a budget of $60 million, I would say $2 million on Piers Morgan,
00:26:36 who was a confirmed ratings getter, who was the host of the Larry King show on CNN when Larry King retired.
00:26:43 that would be a huge asset to have
00:26:45 if you can imagine a two hour slot where you've got
00:26:47 Andrew Neil followed by Piers Morgan
00:26:49 that would be appointment viewing
00:26:51 that would give you the ratings
00:26:52 and I would think ensure your
00:26:55 survival and now I'm just thinking that they're
00:26:57 missing that Nick Ferrari or Julia
00:26:59 Hartley Brewer or Piers Morgan
00:27:01 characters that could really energise
00:27:03 and get the viewers in at these early days
00:27:04 how do you feel
00:27:07 about seeing Piers Morgan on it
00:27:09 you know
00:27:10 I can understand what the attraction was
00:27:13 i i i'm not entirely convinced that he was the right person because that would have put a lot
00:27:17 of people off as well so it would have been kind of you know appointment viewing but um not
00:27:22 necessarily of the right kind and you know i think they do have i understand that ratings are
00:27:27 important i actually think that making the point that they were watched on the first night i mean
00:27:31 they were watched by everyone who wanted to destroy them i mean everyone watched it i don't
00:27:36 think that works right it's the launch night and everybody what what they've achieved which is
00:27:41 amazing is that everybody felt they had to watch that launch night love or hate because that in a
00:27:46 way it became that became the appointment of you but then it was just that the conclusions drawn
00:27:52 from the only four hours that they saw were slightly skewed but what i was going to say
00:27:57 they were up against it i mean i wanted to raise the fact that you know you were saying about
00:28:02 getting these big names i mean it is well first of all i don't want to see the demise of of talk
00:28:09 talk radio you know talk radio has done very well at establishing its own brand i don't want it to
00:28:14 be talk radio on the tv and do you think it is at the moment then no no it's certain programs could
00:28:22 be and i and i don't want it to be because i think talk radio is its own brand and i want diversity
00:28:29 of opinion and of style in the broadcast media of this country not all because everything's
00:28:34 standing like the BBC or Channel 4.
00:28:38 But what I was going to say was that, therefore,
00:28:41 Julia Hartley Brewer, I mean, in some ways,
00:28:43 I think it's eminently interesting that they were loyal,
00:28:46 and I think that's good.
00:28:48 But I think that over time, they will probably get bigger names.
00:28:51 But one of the difficulties is how much pressure they're under.
00:28:56 So the reason I'm saying that is because this Hope Not Hate,
00:28:59 or what is it, Don't Fund Hate?
00:29:01 Stop funding hate.
00:29:02 No, no, Stop Funding Hate.
00:29:03 But I thought they might have gone away.
00:29:04 they're actually having a range of successes today they're actually um no they've had no
00:29:12 they've had a number of announced i don't want to no i don't want to advertise them by saying who
00:29:16 they are um quite a number of big brands have pulled out there's quite a lot of pressure on
00:29:21 people who go on the show that they're far right um that there's a d there's a delegitimization
00:29:28 demonization that we're all everyone around this room will be familiar with because we've all been
00:29:33 on the receiving end of it one way or another now when that goes to a channel you know and a lot of
00:29:39 energy goes into it from those people that can mean that it becomes a risky place to go because
00:29:45 people think go on if i want to have a presenting job on there they've got a great crowd we'll see
00:29:51 who lasts i agree with all that but if you're a big name you're thinking so i think those people
00:29:55 like sam mccoy and colin and alistair who've taken that risk um that they're very brave of them and i
00:30:02 really admire them for that but for other people they'll be waiting to see and all i'm saying is
00:30:07 that there's a as usual with these things there is a culture war about gb news which is led by
00:30:16 people who say that gb news is responsible for the culture war but they are actually trying to
00:30:21 destroy gb news and that's in that sense why i would want to defend it why i desperately want
00:30:27 they are trying to smother it in it's cold they're trying to smother it absolutely what actually is
00:30:30 what i found quite interesting i don't know when when they announced the figures for the first
00:30:34 night admittedly it was a first night so it's not but when they announced it was very very good
00:30:39 very healthy it also made you realize how tiny the audiences for news channels exactly yes you
00:30:46 know i mean so hang on so that's a live viewing audience but these channels don't just work that
00:30:51 that way. We're all familiar with Sky News Australia because it's on YouTube and it's
00:30:56 clicked. How do I watch TV? Yes, and people share it on Twitter or Facebook. And so I'm
00:31:03 not uncritical, but Dan Wooten started like a train and he had one of those pieces to
00:31:08 camera for about four minutes where it was his opinion. And I thought, I mean, give the
00:31:13 guy a break. The channel's launching. It's the very first thing he's saying. But the
00:31:18 ones that you see from Sky News Australia or Fox News the people are measured they're stately and
00:31:24 they set out their stall very carefully because they know that the editor is going to clip it
00:31:30 and they're going to post it to people all around the world now what I would like GB News to be
00:31:34 is a voice not just to people and it's obviously from Britain but to go around the world I have
00:31:40 lots of friends in Australia or America that would love to watch it and the only thing that
00:31:44 they can see really is Sky News or the BBC and they think that's what everybody
00:31:49 in Britain thinks and I would say it's not really what everybody thinks but
00:31:53 isn't there a sort of there's a real opportunity here for us as well given
00:31:56 that these figures for news channels are very small do people realize that Sky
00:32:02 News given its profile something like 60,000 on Sunday night or something when
00:32:08 they had the general election it was like 47,000 something really small you've
00:32:13 therefore you know these are hugely funded people and they kind of make the news agenda don't they
00:32:20 so and yet they are deeply niche yes they are actually in any other context they would be
00:32:25 called niche they'd be called very very small and i think therefore gp news has got a great
00:32:32 opportunity there but what i what i would like to ask is that what struck me was that uh throughout
00:32:37 the launch and the day after people were talking about we want to talk about people feel they can't
00:32:42 say what they want anymore people feel they can't say and you know woke and everyone's going to be
00:32:49 cancelled and there was this question mark forming in my mind thinking well so okay so what are you
00:32:55 what are you going to do uh what will they allow to be said you know isn't this how far is their
00:33:01 boundary where is that point in a way i mean when people say well no one people feel they can't say
00:33:08 what they this is undoubtedly true so how far will they allow that to go well i think a very
00:33:14 good test and i thought about this i worked with david starkey many years ago you interviewed him
00:33:20 very recently and i thought suppose they were doing harry and megan which is a sort of gb news
00:33:24 sort of thing they might do would they have him on just as a royal commentator i mean they might
00:33:29 have him on to talk about what it's like to be cancelled which would be a specific kind of
00:33:33 interview but would they just have him on as another person expert in a particular area that
00:33:38 he's an expert on and if they don't have him on then they're allowing other people to make the
00:33:45 decision about who comes on or doesn't come on their channel and they're complying with cancel
00:33:50 culture and they may well feel under that pressure because they are relying on advertisers and
00:33:54 investors but but one of the difficulties though is that you know you don't want to go out of your
00:34:00 way to be provocative which is maybe this is just my shtick but on on you know i suppose what i you
00:34:08 know in a variety of ways i i won't bore you with but you know sometimes you can let me use the
00:34:14 example of the students who voted to take the queen off the of the of the walls um you know
00:34:21 that's the kind of story that kind of went on and on and on and on and on by the time it was finished
00:34:25 i was saying what kind of students would vote to put the picture of the queen on the wall never
00:34:29 mind take it off right it was the most trivial of examples and the problem that gb news i would say
00:34:37 with the academy of ideas that i run that that that new culture forum have got to avoid is
00:34:43 where you know everything's woke and everything's cancelled culture and we spend the whole time
00:34:47 whinching about these things and and there's some such serious threats to freedom of speech at the
00:34:53 at the moment, there's such serious examples
00:34:57 of blasphemy by the back door, intolerance,
00:35:00 and I've already said a genuine attempt
00:35:02 at destroying the revenue for a new broadcasting channel,
00:35:08 that sometimes the trivial can get in the way.
00:35:10 That's what I was trying to say about taking the knee.
00:35:13 Don't go on about it for the rest of your lives
00:35:15 because you are being more annoying
00:35:16 than the guys taking the knee at this point.
00:35:18 And I think that therefore, it's not that,
00:35:22 I mean, you know, they can or they should or shouldn't have David Starkey on.
00:35:27 I don't suppose it's not that.
00:35:29 But what I don't want them to do is to say,
00:35:30 we're going to have them on because they were cancelled either.
00:35:33 That's the point I'm making.
00:35:34 I don't want them to be agent provocateurs.
00:35:37 And one of the things that I think about where people,
00:35:40 I wrote in The Spectator about the channel that whereas, you know,
00:35:44 there's a lobby system for Westminster,
00:35:48 that I wanted GB News to be like the lobby system for the public.
00:35:51 you know that i want i wanted to feel that they represented a broader range the thing is the
00:35:56 public themselves millions of people who don't feel represented don't all just for example want
00:36:03 the lockdown restrictions to end whether we like it or not they just don't want it right that's a
00:36:07 lot of people don't want it so you've got to be careful you don't end up in your own echo chamber
00:36:11 that's the thing is that you that you're that you're measured that you kind of sense that people
00:36:16 sense that you're on their side as the public but that you're also challenging them got different
00:36:21 points of view and i'm not just kind of acting as a sort of student you know a kind of like student
00:36:26 free speech society going let's have katie hopkins in because that'll upset everybody everybody and
00:36:31 it's like that's not what we need right and i that's what i dread i don't want them to do that
00:36:36 do you do you think i mean this is what going on from that basically what you're talking about is
00:36:40 being repetitive you know and being more business is there is there a practical problem in in
00:36:46 filling time do you think i mean if you're going to be an opinion led channel not a news
00:36:54 um how can you fill what is a huge ocean of time well i've got a quick one-liner to answer you
00:37:02 just because you'll like it which is i think they need to say we're going to have a science program
00:37:08 I think they need to say a science and invention programme, a one-hour one.
00:37:12 I think they need to say there's going to be an arts programme.
00:37:17 No, but I really mean this because I do think that they're not opinion-led, they're sort of theme-led.
00:37:23 And not taking the me, but sports.
00:37:25 Yeah, but I think you could do that really well to fill the time.
00:37:29 They'll do science items and arts items.
00:37:33 Look, the thing I think has been very impressive is because I've worked on shows
00:37:38 where you ring around and you say you know many years ago one was you know behind the scenes on
00:37:44 cable tv channels that no one had heard of and you ring up and say would you like to come on our
00:37:48 channel and you haven't even said in what the program is and no one will come on and you haven't
00:37:54 got any money and they won't come on and the thing that really impressed me was whoever is doing the
00:37:59 booking for GB News has managed to get a new person to come on every five or seven minutes
00:38:04 There were a few big stars that got a bit longer.
00:38:07 We all saw Alan Sugar and saw what curtains looked like
00:38:10 in Chigwell, which was a real knockback moment.
00:38:13 That was very surreal though, I have to say, wasn't it?
00:38:15 It was like, he felt like he was there under duress somehow.
00:38:19 Yeah, that was one interview that I didn't remember.
00:38:22 He looked, he was either very tired
00:38:24 or he'd had a very good dinner or something.
00:38:28 And as a producer, I would have said,
00:38:30 could I just see where the camera is going to be in your room?
00:38:33 because I don't think a single person heard what he said.
00:38:35 I think everybody said,
00:38:36 my God, is that what the inside of his house looks like?
00:38:39 It was such a setback.
00:38:41 He needs to be interviewed by Lloyd Grossman.
00:38:43 I mean, what do you think,
00:38:46 this more general point is,
00:38:48 and this is, I think, in some ways,
00:38:49 been entirely highlighted by GP News,
00:38:52 this idea that impartiality in the Ofcom sense
00:38:56 or in the traditional BBC sense
00:38:57 was always a shimmerer anyway.
00:39:00 It was always an illusion.
00:39:02 and that this has blown it out of the water.
00:39:04 So, you know, they are being opinionated on GB News,
00:39:08 but Sky would say they're not.
00:39:10 But I know as sure as X are X
00:39:13 that, in fact, Sky is hopelessly biased, right?
00:39:17 It's hopelessly not, you know, impartial.
00:39:20 Would you...
00:39:21 I was thinking of one of the things you said about getting guests.
00:39:25 I can't count the number of times that I've had shows on
00:39:29 And this is the mainstream rather than some dubious nobody's ever heard of a cable channel who basically say, well, so and so come on.
00:39:37 And will they say this? No, because that's not what they believe.
00:39:39 Oh, we're not interested in them. And I hope to goodness that GB News doesn't have that approach, which is we're phoning me up because we think you're going to be controversial.
00:39:48 We think you're going to do this. And if they say, well, actually, that's not what I think.
00:39:51 Oh, well, can you find somebody who will say that? No, because that's not.
00:39:56 And that side of things, I hope to goodness that GB News does not practice that.
00:40:01 We need this being said. We may as well say it ourselves.
00:40:04 Why get a guest? Because that's what we want them to say.
00:40:07 That's a problem.
00:40:08 One of the crucial things, I remember Robin Aitken talked about this,
00:40:12 the guy who was a BBC on the Today programme reporter.
00:40:17 It's all about the schedule, the news agenda that is decided in the first place
00:40:23 by the BBC, by Sky, the editorial conference,
00:40:28 what they decide is a BBC story or not.
00:40:31 Well, I suspect you're going to have to have that for GB News.
00:40:33 We've all been saying that we need some level of news leavening of the comments.
00:40:38 No, but what I'm saying is that that's where the big change could be.
00:40:40 No, well, yes, of course.
00:40:42 But you're talking about impartiality.
00:40:43 I want to do a defence of it because, you know,
00:40:46 there are still some great public service broadcasters, in my opinion,
00:40:49 who are impartial.
00:40:50 and by that what what means is that they treat guests fairly regardless of their views for a
00:40:56 start off what's happened what's happened to impartiality and why it's in such a dis absolute
00:41:01 disrepute at the present time in terms of the way it's been practiced by by by channel four by by
00:41:08 bbc uh in particular but you know then sky in the kind of background is that they say we're
00:41:14 impartial we're fair we've invited you on clare and then they spend the next half hour sneering
00:41:19 at you it's very clear to the audience that you've got three good guys and one that we're all meant
00:41:25 to despise i mean somebody once described it john waters the irish commentator described it as they
00:41:31 always make you feel as though you've got dandruff you know that you're kind of like you're you're
00:41:34 invited but you're kind of like they really and that for the audience then it comes over as we
00:41:41 know what your opinion is that we knew and brexit brought it to vicious viscerally not viscerally
00:41:47 well both viscerally to the fore because you they couldn't contain their contempt i i do know
00:41:54 certain individual quite high profile bbc journalists who that i have drank with for
00:42:00 20 years i couldn't tell you how they vote and i admire and respect that um others as we well know
00:42:08 will be making all sorts of comments on their private twitter feed um but alice stewart and
00:42:14 And Colin Brazier, as it happens, are two really good examples of that.
00:42:17 But there's also, I mean, there's, you know, I'm very fond of Amal Rajan.
00:42:22 I was just going to say, Amal Rajan, Chris Mason,
00:42:25 absolutely fantastic journalist in many ways,
00:42:28 because he, well, not just in many ways.
00:42:29 Who even wished good luck to...
00:42:31 Well, he wished some good luck, right?
00:42:32 Yes, he did.
00:42:33 These are good individual people, but I think there's just no getting away.
00:42:36 The level of distrust now for mainstream media is huge and understandable.
00:42:42 and the big difference is i think is that it's it's permeated into mainstream viewership now i
00:42:49 mean once upon a time it was tories saying why didn't you have more tory mps on to talk about
00:42:54 bros it's not that now it's people feel they look at the drama they look at the comedy and they
00:43:00 think oh god you know i'm sorry enough i just don't want to watch it anymore and i just think
00:43:05 there is a real uh chance here do you think that uh rave do you think that say
00:43:13 that just pretend just for argument's sake that we were still in the brexit argument do you think
00:43:19 that say like gb news should have a brexit should have a brexit position a declared brexit position
00:43:28 do you think a channel should have that no that shouldn't have a brexit position but well again
00:43:32 No, I mean a pro-Brexit.
00:43:34 I know what you're saying, but the point is the presenters themselves will portray that.
00:43:38 I mean, what I like about GB News so far is that you have had radically opposing views from presenters on various issues.
00:43:45 This morning, there were two radically opposing views on Taking the Knee.
00:43:48 We've seen Dan Woodson taking a very different position on anti-lockdown to other presenters.
00:43:53 And I like that sort of editorial independence that each show has.
00:43:56 I think that's very important.
00:43:58 It's the same thing at The Spectator.
00:43:59 People are always attacking Andrew Neil for his magazine.
00:44:03 He says, I've got nothing to do with it,
00:44:04 except to the editorial policies of the actual magazine itself.
00:44:08 And I regard this more as a magazine show than actually a news channel.
00:44:11 As I said, it's an editorial channel.
00:44:12 But in terms of the bias, I mean, I was shocked when I saw the polls
00:44:15 of how much of the British population have distrust in mainstream media.
00:44:20 It always used to be the Tories on the right
00:44:22 and then the Corbynistas on the left, you know.
00:44:24 But what we do have are these sort of woke Tony Blair channels now
00:44:27 from Channel 4 to Sky, the BBC, and then ITV.
00:44:31 And Sky, people have to realise, was taken over in 2018, I think it was,
00:44:36 by Comcast, who owned NBC.
00:44:38 So it's no longer a Rupert Murdoch-owned channel
00:44:42 as Sky News Australia remains.
00:44:43 And so people could be confused watching Sky News Australia
00:44:46 and then seeing this hugely woke Sky UK production.
00:44:50 So that has definitely gone over to a more biased side.
00:44:53 ITV, ITN, is the closest to the centre ground.
00:44:55 And I think it's a great shame that you've seen ITN news decline so rapidly over the past few decades.
00:45:01 Because that, to my mind, was the gold standard of impartiality.
00:45:04 And people don't quite remember, I think, how important ITN news was.
00:45:08 It was the first half-hour news programme.
00:45:11 ITN was the definition globally, I would say, of the perfect news impartiality.
00:45:17 You know, Andrew Niel's mentor was Alistair Burnett, but she's Trevor McDonald.
00:45:20 More than the BBC, it was that.
00:45:22 And it's the decline of ITN that I think has been...
00:45:24 They did sue me for libel, so I've got to slightly do it.
00:45:28 But recently, not in the old, not in the 80s.
00:45:31 But when society is very divided,
00:45:35 people like to divide between newspapers
00:45:37 and they clutch their telegraph or Daily Mail or their Guardian.
00:45:42 And actually the ones in the middle, like the Independent, don't sell.
00:45:47 And it's the same with television.
00:45:49 And the reason you're getting more polarity,
00:45:51 well, we're only getting the polarity now,
00:45:53 But the reason everything's been going in one direction is because if you're very objective, as these channels used to be, people are getting the news from so many places that actually they are looking for...
00:46:06 One thing that we haven't touched, and I think is quite important, is the impact that GB News is going to have on the other channels.
00:46:12 Yes.
00:46:12 How they're going to react.
00:46:14 I noticed that, and somebody had a go at me for pointing this out, Sky relaunched its look last week.
00:46:21 And I said, well, well, interesting.
00:46:23 oh no no we've been planning this for six months and they've been planning theirs for six months
00:46:25 i think that it will be very interesting to see if the audience does start to switch
00:46:31 if you do see this barb figure maintain over a period of six months the bbc itv channel 4 news
00:46:38 they're going to have to deal with this they're going to in order to get the audience back and
00:46:42 how is that going to impact on how they do you remember back to impartiality perhaps and i would
00:46:47 hope that that will help in the early days sky's uh sky used to have it said the joke logo was
00:46:53 never wrong for long do you remember i think what they can't what they can't escape is is is they
00:47:00 don't get it so it's a bit like the labour party trying to save itself they they often don't get
00:47:05 it well there is that so you know the the bbc thinks oh you know gv news coming up right we're
00:47:11 going to have lots of people with regional accents on our screens right that you know and it's like
00:47:18 oh god they think that if you've got a geordie accent you can't have a metropolitan outlook
00:47:22 they haven't got a clue they don't understand intuitively they don't they don't you know so
00:47:27 you know sky have got that kind of i think it's you know a daily prime time but it might be weekly
00:47:33 actually because i definitely don't watch it but a kind of climate change you know but i'm just
00:47:38 saying they they they don't really understand anything well young people so then we'll kind of
00:47:43 like have this and then they they genuinely think that every young person and of course they've got
00:47:49 a point here every young person will think that the trans issue is important so they kind of go
00:47:54 down that route they they're diversity the reason i'm saying that is because i do think it will
00:47:59 shake up the more serious journalists journalistic output but the point that you were making peter
00:48:05 is that it seeps through their drama,
00:48:08 through everything, right?
00:48:10 Their light entertainment and everything.
00:48:11 And so I think they're going to find it very hard
00:48:13 to kind of cleanse that
00:48:15 because the truth is that in those broadcasters,
00:48:20 Gwaine will know as much as I do,
00:48:22 there were secret Brexiteers in all of those places
00:48:25 because they'd come and talk to people like us, right?
00:48:27 They'd come up and they'd whisper.
00:48:28 They were senior broadcasters,
00:48:31 senior people in those places,
00:48:33 voted leave but they couldn't say it there are senior people who like me and text me
00:48:39 and are very friendly but they can't be seen to be doing that and and therefore there's a climate
00:48:46 in those broadcasters that is inhospitable to diversity of opinion they just don't even
00:48:52 understand they haven't got diversity of opinion they think diversity of opinion is having a green
00:48:57 on versus an
00:48:58 Extinction Rebellion about how you
00:49:00 reduce climate, how you
00:49:02 reduce, make it zero
00:49:04 and they have a row whilst
00:49:06 agreeing, you know, that kind of thing
00:49:08 Basically diversity to them is something you can see
00:49:10 not something you think
00:49:11 Can I also, by way of ending
00:49:14 just
00:49:15 we've made this point, everyone's made this point
00:49:18 I think it's very clear, you know, we all think
00:49:20 this is a good thing
00:49:22 and are pleased about it
00:49:24 being GB News
00:49:26 just one thing you would like to see change
00:49:28 I'll start
00:49:30 please give Andrew Neil
00:49:32 a slightly bigger desk
00:49:34 you know someone of his stature
00:49:36 you know he's in this very
00:49:38 small area I would like to see
00:49:41 a bit of a wider thing
00:49:42 well following on
00:49:44 from Gwen's comment about Sky News changing
00:49:46 its look I'd like to see GB News
00:49:48 change its look next week or tomorrow
00:49:50 it's far too dark because it's supposed to be a positive
00:49:52 uplifting channel and to see it
00:49:54 It's so black and the lighting is very, very dim and sodden.
00:49:59 And even for breakfast TV, to have a black set is, I think, quite appalling.
00:50:05 You see that they've realised that.
00:50:06 They've got better lighting today as of yesterday.
00:50:09 Andrew Neil's got his jacket off,
00:50:10 so you're seeing his white shirt against the black backdrop.
00:50:13 But that would be my one comment.
00:50:15 Well, I was going to make the same comment.
00:50:18 Exactly.
00:50:19 But so I'll have to pick something else.
00:50:21 Well, I hope the new Sandman joins soon.
00:50:23 the new sound man joined soon they have to get over those technical hitches we have got great
00:50:31 goodwill towards them but in the end if you can't hear people clearly it becomes very irritating i
00:50:37 have to say that i've watched it on the app and i think the app is very uh successful it's much
00:50:42 better watching that sort of television on a tiny little screen you don't notice the background or
00:50:47 the faults with the sound quite so
00:50:49 much. But on your big
00:50:51 super HD TV, they
00:50:53 have to get over those technical things fast.
00:50:57 I think
00:50:58 going back to some of the things we said earlier,
00:50:59 I think a regular
00:51:01 understood and expected
00:51:03 headline bulletin
00:51:05 that can then
00:51:06 bleed in to the discussions that
00:51:09 are taking place is, I think,
00:51:12 essential. If it's going to be a
00:51:13 news channel, TV News, it
00:51:15 must have that. Now, it can break
00:51:17 news, you can lead news, you can comment on news, but it must
00:51:19 have the, I'm turning on,
00:51:22 I'm not watching the BBC, I'm not watching
00:51:23 ITV, I'm not watching Channel 4. What's actually
00:51:25 happened? Yes, yes, yes, exactly.
00:51:28 Sir?
00:51:29 The sound,
00:51:31 which I defended at the beginning, saying it was
00:51:33 just technical, start to then,
00:51:36 because we've actually,
00:51:37 despite everything, with DIY
00:51:39 broadcasting, you actually start
00:51:41 thinking, but even the guys in
00:51:43 the Academy of Ideas office sound is better than
00:51:45 this, what's wrong? I mean, you know, so
00:51:47 it does start to create i what i really want to see is an imaginative buying in of um are you
00:51:55 going to laugh now i really like the new culture forum documentaries for example i think they're
00:52:01 really good heresies you're going to like all these my suggestions heresies but why not actually
00:52:06 say let's have a break i mean this is they haven't said no to this we're going a couple of days but
00:52:10 i'd like to see them saying on sunday afternoon we're going to show one of the heresy series
00:52:13 by the way you're not the only ones making those kind of documentaries there'll be other people
00:52:17 and i would like to see a a you know a science and an arts program not not not to be conventional
00:52:24 because i think they do a great job of it i'd love to see uh that in a gb news format so i'm
00:52:30 looking forward to innovations not just because one thing about opinion if you're people like us
00:52:36 we've all got opinions and if you're on social media we've all got opinions is there are times
00:52:41 and you think, I need
00:52:43 a break from opinionated
00:52:45 ideas, especially
00:52:47 when they're the same as my own.
00:52:49 Do you know what I mean? On occasion
00:52:51 I'd like a bit of stimulation
00:52:53 that goes beyond... What about the potter's wheel?
00:52:55 You know, we could have a return to the potter's wheel
00:52:57 in a moment.
00:52:58 It's more the art side of things, the Melvin
00:53:01 Bragg style thing from the 60s and 70s.
00:53:03 That style of in-depth
00:53:05 looking at arts figures, but not
00:53:07 from the obvious
00:53:08 perspective that has been
00:53:11 all arts coverage for as long as I
00:53:13 can remember. They could literally do it with one
00:53:15 person coming in for an interview
00:53:17 or even interview, you know, it doesn't have to
00:53:19 be filming an art gallery or
00:53:21 going to France. It could
00:53:23 be just what you're talking about. It could be
00:53:25 literally an interview with somebody, tell
00:53:27 me your life story. It's the sort of thing that you do when
00:53:29 you're using this interview.
00:53:31 Philip, we had a quick
00:53:33 mention when we were on this programme of
00:53:35 Philip Roth, was he being cancelled?
00:53:37 Which caused controversy because people said he wasn't.
00:53:39 Bit of controversy over Philip Roth.
00:53:41 why don't we get three literature people in and talk about Philip Roth and what he means
00:53:44 that's an interesting hour isn't it educational but genuinely interesting some people might read
00:53:49 the odd novel after it and it would be genuinely a good thing to do so it's I didn't mean big
00:53:55 production no no the other thing as well just sorry before we leave is given the way things
00:54:01 are at the moment as well what would be wonderful would be some form of travel program uh lack of
00:54:07 travel program. Well, no, no, but I mean
00:54:09 sort of something... Wish you
00:54:11 were here. Yes, wish you were here.
00:54:12 You won't be here. Towards the future. But anyway,
00:54:15 as I said, that one's
00:54:17 not going to fly. No, none
00:54:19 of us are. This is, obviously,
00:54:21 we're all... Very best of luck to it, don't you
00:54:23 say? Oh, yes, absolutely. Thank you very much,
00:54:26 Gwaine. Thank you. Thank you, Claire. Thank you, Doug.
00:54:28 Thank you. That's it for
00:54:30 Counterculture, and we shall
00:54:32 see you next time, okay? Thank you. Bye-bye.
00:54:37 Thank you.