New Culture Forum - September 06, 2019


S02 01 - Peter Hitchens: The British Revolution WAS Televised

28. Konstantin Kisin - The Last Laugh S2 02: James Cary - Comedy, Religion & The New Morality.

Episode Stats


Length

43 minutes

Words per minute

176.71

Word count

7,654

Sentence count

241


Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
00:00:00 hello and welcome to so what you're saying is i'm peter whittle i hope you had a great summer
00:00:24 Now, since we started the show in January, there's been one name that viewers have suggested as a guest for our show.
00:00:32 One name more than any others.
00:00:34 So I'm very, very pleased that today I have with me the author, journalist and broadcaster, Peter Hitchens.
00:00:41 Thank you very much, Peter.
00:00:42 Pleasure so far.
00:00:44 You have quite a dedicated following.
00:00:47 It's lovely to know that.
00:00:49 But I noticed that when you do Twitter, which you do quite prodigiously,
00:00:55 you've managed this amazing thing of actually getting about 72,000 followers
00:00:58 and you follow nobody.
00:01:01 How do you manage that?
00:01:02 Well, I don't know.
00:01:04 The whole idea of following somebody is repugnant to me,
00:01:08 so when I was offered the chance to do it, I didn't take it.
00:01:11 And then people started going on and on at me about how I didn't follow anybody,
00:01:15 so it then became a matter of principle.
00:01:17 As for why people follow me, you have to ask them why they did that.
00:01:21 I can't tell you.
00:01:23 When you go to colleges to talk or universities or whatever,
00:01:29 I know that there's been some controversy around that.
00:01:32 You've been more and more people no-platformed or disinvited.
00:01:36 It's more difficult because of the regulations which student bodies impose on societies.
00:01:42 and they often demand pledges of good behaviour
00:01:46 on behalf of speakers
00:01:47 which no civilised person could conceivably give
00:01:50 so I just don't give them.
00:01:52 It makes it difficult sometimes.
00:01:53 At Liverpool I actually had to speak in the open air
00:01:56 because we couldn't find anywhere on the university premises
00:02:00 where I was allowed to speak.
00:02:01 It went off very well actually
00:02:02 and open air speaking is a good exercise.
00:02:05 It was great fun for everybody
00:02:06 but these regulations are pestilential
00:02:09 and then there was the University of Portsmouth
00:02:11 which just dropped an invitation to me in short notice and then for some bizarre reason imagine
00:02:16 that having said I wasn't acceptable in that particular week that I might come back some
00:02:19 other week I didn't know I was not going to go back what were you actually meant to be talking
00:02:25 about on that occasion what they were completely and utterly preoccupied with was was homosexuality
00:02:33 a subject on which I have fallen almost totally silent because there's no it's one of those
00:02:38 about which there's obviously no point in saying anything anymore.
00:02:43 You just can't argue rationally about it, so let's not bother.
00:02:48 When you do speak at those events,
00:02:50 going back to the idea of people following you
00:02:52 and holding you in great esteem,
00:02:55 do you ever find that people come up to you
00:02:58 and their views have been changed by what you've said?
00:03:02 Not that you are after that.
00:03:04 I don't think people come up to me.
00:03:05 I have had experiences with people who in combat
00:03:08 have changed their minds as a result of it
00:03:12 and people who've said that various books of mine
00:03:14 have altered their way of thinking on some subjects
00:03:17 but that's why I wrote them
00:03:19 it's a rare thing for people to do this
00:03:21 and of course the old Jonathan Swift rule always applies
00:03:26 you can't reason a man out of a position
00:03:27 he wasn't reasoned into in the first place
00:03:29 and most people don't hold opinions
00:03:32 because they were reasoned into them
00:03:33 they hold them for protective colouration
00:03:35 or because it was what they were brought up with or what they saw on television so you can't reason
00:03:39 with them generally in any case people will often change their minds a long time after the event
00:03:45 which caused the change of mind that certainly happened with me what are the instances with you
00:03:50 oh I took I was a revolutionary socialist and I ceased to be but there was a very long period
00:03:56 when I continued to be outward and visible signs of revolutionary socialist but within I was having
00:04:03 severe doubts which i was fighting against because i knew as anybody who seriously changes his mind
00:04:09 knows that as soon as i did it i'd lose an awful lot of friends and become very unpopular life
00:04:14 would become much more difficult and unpleasant and it was easier not to even open the door that
00:04:19 led to the staircase that led to the exit that led to the change of mind so you just you you hold a
00:04:25 long way back from the steps of doing it and i understand this better than most people because
00:04:29 I've done it. Do you think there's something different though now compared to say like what
00:04:36 you've just described there with yourself if you take younger people now who may be at college the
00:04:40 young the people you may be talked to whatever events go and speak at it seems now that their
00:04:47 views are held even more rigidly. It's not rigidity I was reasoned into my revolutionary position I
00:04:53 had been brought up as a traditional imperialist conservative I grew up in a navy family I was
00:04:57 one of the last people on earth
00:04:59 to be educated in traditional fashion
00:05:01 about English history
00:05:02 and the geography of the world
00:05:04 and politics and all the other things that went with it
00:05:07 and I was persuaded out of it
00:05:09 by some very eloquent
00:05:11 arguments both listened to and read
00:05:13 and I changed my mind and became
00:05:15 a revolutionary Marxist
00:05:16 and then I found that those arguments
00:05:19 didn't hold up in practice. What's happened with
00:05:21 the young of today is that they have
00:05:23 been, I don't like to
00:05:25 use uncomplimentary terms like
00:05:26 brainwashed but they have been brought up to believe a set of opinions they've
00:05:32 been taught very systematically what to think and very seldom have they been
00:05:37 taught how to think and so the whole idea of being confronted with somebody
00:05:41 who doesn't agree with isn't just well it's not a challenge or a moment when
00:05:47 you become curious it's an outrage how can anyone dare to believe these things
00:05:52 which I've been taught from the very start are wrong so they begin from that
00:05:57 point of view I'm quite impressed by the number of people who've escaped it or
00:06:00 who have actually managed to find their way out of it but I'm not surprised by
00:06:05 it and I'm I'm in a sort of strange paradoxical way sympathetic to the
00:06:11 plight of the people who attack me there is one particular person who writes to
00:06:15 me from a very very ferociously feminist point of view every few months
00:06:18 absolute streams of vituperation and loathing and I'm always extremely
00:06:23 polite to her because I think that quite possibly the moment may come when
00:06:27 actually she may be open to argument and so why not I sympathize I can see I
00:06:33 know I always I always sympathize with people really really taking on a point
00:06:38 of view and arguing it to its logical conclusion with all the force at their
00:06:41 command what's wrong with that ever but do you think though that when they are
00:06:46 are sort of so angry, you know, I think there's many Phillips ones that said this to me,
00:06:51 why would they get so angry? It's because they might feel that you are right?
00:06:56 Well, people, the main reason, and again, I have personal experience with this,
00:06:59 the main reason I feel we get angry in arguments is because they hear somebody expressing their
00:07:03 own suppressed doubts, and that is the most guaranteed way of infuriating someone,
00:07:08 which is saying something which they sort of suspected might be so, but they would never
00:07:12 ever admit to saying and as a result they don't really have any defense against it so you can
00:07:18 tell when they they will turn nasty at that point and you can tell you've struck a blow it's so it's
00:07:24 when it happens it's quite satisfying also isn't it just on this point as well when when you say
00:07:30 that people young people now have not come across disagreement at the same time also there is is
00:07:37 there not this sense in which these are the views that a good person has i.e that if you don't have
00:07:43 them you're wicked in some way yes well it's a sort of extension beyond um beyond calvinism
00:07:49 and lutheranism of justification by faith alone isn't it we are made good by our opinions rather
00:07:57 than by our actions and so it's not a new idea that people might think that but it used to be
00:08:02 you had to have the right religious opinions now you have to have the right political opinions many
00:08:06 which are in essence religious and opinions which people have particularly
00:08:11 about global warming are almost indistinguishable it seems to me from
00:08:15 religious opinions. It appears sometimes that there is this kind, well you've
00:08:19 more said Lutheran, but this sort of sense in which I am a virtuous
00:08:24 person. This is obvious, I mean so many opinions are held for the purpose of
00:08:29 virtue and I don't imagine any of us are guiltless of this, of publicly espousing
00:08:34 opinion in the hope that people will think that we're better than we are as a result of it.
00:08:38 It's all part of the general state of sin in which we find ourselves, in which we want people to
00:08:43 believe that we are better than we are. So I'm not, again, I don't find this particularly surprising.
00:08:48 I just think it's important to be able to tell it apart from a serious argument. So if someone
00:08:53 starts saying, I want to intervene in Syria because I'm really outraged by the terrible
00:09:00 the humanitarian misdeeds of the Syrian government.
00:09:03 Well, the humanitarian misdeeds of the Syrian government
00:09:05 are indeed appalling,
00:09:07 but to make that a justification
00:09:11 for dropping more bombs on Syria
00:09:14 than have already been dropped on it
00:09:15 seems to me to be pretty far-fetched.
00:09:17 And so what we're really doing
00:09:19 when we say things like this
00:09:20 is we're saying, look at me,
00:09:21 how good I am, I want to intervene.
00:09:24 And instead of calling down thunderbolts
00:09:26 and the anger of the Lord on the Assad state,
00:09:29 what you want to call down is cruise missiles
00:09:32 and the bombs of the U.S. Navy.
00:09:35 But it's the same sort of thing, isn't it?
00:09:38 It's fundamentally very, very similar
00:09:40 to that sort of religious behavior.
00:09:44 And it doesn't actually confer any virtue.
00:09:47 And we all know as we get older
00:09:48 there's only one form of virtue,
00:09:50 and that's fundamentally self-sacrifice
00:09:53 and self-reform,
00:09:55 which you have to do in private in any way.
00:09:57 with uh if you'd take again this these sort of received opinions or the opinions that the young
00:10:06 have or younger people have if you like that they tend to have on block um this revolves very much
00:10:13 around identity politics doesn't it really it's i don't really i hear the phrase but i'm not entirely
00:10:20 sure what it means well isn't it where basically somebody is increasingly defined by one
00:10:26 characteristic? Oh there is some of that and some people obviously find some solace in that
00:10:33 yeah again who can blame them it's a lonely frightening world if you can find some place
00:10:39 where you've got comradeship and solidarity and something which makes you feel less alone and
00:10:44 more important who can blame people for that I don't. But at the same time don't you think it
00:10:49 sort of it rather sort of cut society maybe class once cut society horizontally and now
00:10:56 identity points cut it vertically almost don't well yes I suppose it does yes but again if you
00:11:01 want if you want to create loyalties then you need to have groups of people who feel distinct
00:11:07 from other people who will be loyal and that's in the nature of politics you find groups which
00:11:13 you hope you can recruit to your cause and identify with it's just another
00:11:21 another way in which it's been been done in a society which obviously the old
00:11:25 class distinctions which used to be so important politics have dissolved into
00:11:29 something completely different so I think it's not it doesn't disturb me
00:11:33 particularly I think there's the academic John Gray wrote a piece this
00:11:39 week when he's talking about humanities in universities and how they were now
00:11:43 basically because of the march of identity politics because of the kind of
00:11:47 restriction that essentially the humanities were beyond you know beyond
00:11:51 help well everything's beyond help that's not a great it's not a great
00:11:55 discovery as far as I said we live this is really ridiculous thing about the
00:12:00 modern West we live in post-revolutionary societies and in most cases we don't
00:12:04 even realize the revolution has taken place it's been the Kierkegaardian
00:12:07 revolution which all the buildings remain standing but everything which
00:12:11 which led to their being built and contributed to their design,
00:12:15 and the whole society which supported them has been wiped away.
00:12:18 And people walk around in it, still relatively prosperous,
00:12:21 thinking a revolution must mean a red flag flying over the post office
00:12:25 and the barracks and the railway station and commissars in the streets.
00:12:28 It doesn't.
00:12:30 Modern left-wing revolution means this.
00:12:32 It means the policing of thought, the deadening of the academy,
00:12:37 the lack of serious debate or understanding the suppression of disagreement and everybody accepts
00:12:43 it and you're surrounded by it and there is no there is no cure for it it's all gone education
00:12:47 is dead most of the media is dead it's almost unwatchable most most of what is put out now
00:12:52 and particularly on bbc television it's almost impossible for an intelligent person to sit and
00:12:56 watch it but luckily for that and the number of intelligent educated people watching it is very
00:13:00 small so they get away with it would would you say therefore that younger people who
00:13:06 given this might be the case young people should go off themselves circumvent university go off
00:13:12 and find the class my advice to the young in this country is to leave the country but that's
00:13:16 that's and people laugh when i say it but i've never been more serious in my life and they say
00:13:21 where shall i go i don't care where you go it's not i'm travel agent it's not up to me the point
00:13:25 about this country is in the foothills
00:13:29 of such a catastrophe that it's not a good idea
00:13:32 to wait around and find out what it's like.
00:13:34 If I were 30, I'd go myself, but I can't,
00:13:37 I don't believe you can go and live
00:13:39 in someone else's country unless you can support yourself.
00:13:41 It's too late for me to learn how to do that,
00:13:43 so I'm stuck with whatever is to come.
00:13:45 I just hope I die naturally before somebody breaks
00:13:48 into my house and beats me to death
00:13:50 for whatever I happen to have in my wallet,
00:13:54 which is just a race between the one and the other for me.
00:13:58 You have called yourself Britain's obiturist.
00:14:00 Yes.
00:14:01 I mean, is that an ongoing obituary?
00:14:03 Well, I keep writing these books which amount,
00:14:06 I've gone to my publishers and said,
00:14:08 look, can we put it all together in one whopping great
00:14:10 Dominic Sandbrook-style breezeblock-sized volume
00:14:13 and call it the Obituary of Britain,
00:14:15 which I think is a great idea,
00:14:16 but they haven't taken me up on it.
00:14:18 But it could have a cover completely black,
00:14:22 except for the words of the obituary of Britain in white
00:14:25 in lovely 18th century lapidary script.
00:14:29 But no, they haven't taken me up on that.
00:14:30 No, everything I write is another chapter of the obituary.
00:14:36 Death was pronounced long ago.
00:14:39 But when you first started writing about it?
00:14:41 Oh, I didn't think that.
00:14:42 When I first started writing about it,
00:14:43 I deluded myself into thinking it might make some difference.
00:14:47 Right up to 2010, I thought I could make some difference in this country.
00:14:51 And what happened then?
00:14:52 Well, I believed in the, I suppose, six or seven years before 2010,
00:14:56 that the most important thing that conservatives in this country could conceivably do
00:15:01 would be to destroy the Conservative and Unionist Party,
00:15:03 which was the principal obstacle to conservative politics.
00:15:07 And I tried to persuade people that David Cameron offered no hope of any kind
00:15:10 and that, indeed, if the Conservative Party could get back into government,
00:15:14 it would be the loss of a great opportunity.
00:15:17 It had, at that stage, lost so many elections in a row
00:15:20 that won more and it would have fallen apart
00:15:23 and would have ceased to attract any financial contributions
00:15:25 and as a result there would have had to be a rethink
00:15:28 among conservative minded people about what sort of party they wanted
00:15:32 and we could have actually had a political party
00:15:34 which was genuinely patriotic and genuinely conservative morally and socially
00:15:38 and I couldn't get anybody
00:15:40 I approached other columnists, I approached people in politics
00:15:43 I had endless arguments with my readers about it
00:15:47 I wrote in my newspaper and I said whatever you do
00:15:49 in 2010, do not vote Conservative.
00:15:53 They can't win, which they couldn't have done in 2010, in fact.
00:15:57 There's nothing to be lost, and you'd be far better off
00:15:59 enduring another five years of Gordon Brown
00:16:01 than saving the Conservative Party from its deserved doom,
00:16:04 and nobody paid the slightest bit of attention.
00:16:06 I feel since then that my warnings have been entirely vindicated.
00:16:11 Everybody hates the Conservative Party now even more than I did then,
00:16:15 and with very good reason,
00:16:16 and it has proved to be a disastrous thing and we've got nowhere as a result of it and all that
00:16:24 time has been lost when we might conceivably reverse the cultural social and moral revolution
00:16:29 and as far as I'm concerned I'm relieved of responsibility I have no political engagement
00:16:33 now I just sit back here and laugh I think the whole thing is very funny
00:16:36 when though you look at the picture whether it's Britain's long death or the Conservative Party
00:16:45 I just wonder, on a personal level, can you still separate it from yourself, or does it actually make you sad?
00:16:52 Well, it used to make me terribly sad because I used to think I could do something about it.
00:16:55 Once you recognise that it's just a comedy of morons hurling themselves off high buildings and diving under buses,
00:17:03 then you just watch and you laugh. It is actually quite funny.
00:17:09 And it's easier to understand once you realise that none of the people involved understand what they're doing
00:17:13 or have any clue as to what the long-term results
00:17:16 of what they're up to.
00:17:19 The European Union, for instance, let's not get into that,
00:17:22 but my friend Christopher Booker,
00:17:24 who very sadly died recently,
00:17:27 was at the end of his life in something near to despair
00:17:31 about the inability of people on the supposed political right
00:17:35 to understand the issues in which they were embroiled.
00:17:39 I feel much the same way.
00:17:41 As I say, it is comical.
00:17:44 And there was, I don't know whether you've read
00:17:46 Claude Coburn's masterwork of autobiography.
00:17:50 I, Claude, there's a wonderful moment
00:17:51 during some catastrophic international conference
00:17:54 in the 1930s when it's clear that everything is finished
00:17:57 and that nothing lies ahead but doom.
00:18:00 One of the journalists turns to another and says,
00:18:02 well, in between the crisis and the catastrophe,
00:18:04 we may as well have a glass of champagne.
00:18:06 That is my motto.
00:18:07 in the 1980s maybe when you maybe still thought that for example you know the
00:18:14 Conservative Party had hope say isn't the point that if you look back at say
00:18:18 the Saturday years there was virtually no what you might call broadly
00:18:22 cultural activity at all it was all economic wasn't it yeah well it was
00:18:28 economics and foreign policy yeah what did it for me I was suspicious about
00:18:32 the economics I didn't I didn't think that it was I wasn't I'm really a social
00:18:37 Democrat and I'm quite sympathetic to a lot of social democracy and I didn't
00:18:42 like a lot of what was going on and particularly was worried by what appeared
00:18:46 to be the destruction of industry but I did feel that the Cold War position was
00:18:52 right and I did feel that as I was an industrial correspondent for a lot of
00:18:56 the period I did feel that she understood better than most people that
00:18:58 there was a genuine infiltration of British politics
00:19:03 by the Communist Party, which is much more important
00:19:06 than those people realized then or understand now.
00:19:08 And on those things, I was completely with her.
00:19:11 And when it came to yes or no,
00:19:13 then it was yes rather than no for those reasons.
00:19:16 But no, it was culturally completely void.
00:19:19 There was nothing, and morally completely void.
00:19:20 There was nothing, and educationally as well.
00:19:23 What an opportunity to reverse circular 1065
00:19:26 not a thing done, not a single new grammar school created, not a single old one restored,
00:19:35 not even the direct grant system brought back to that, nothing, a blank.
00:19:38 You see, this is one, I know you've written a lot about education, but I'm from a grammar school.
00:19:45 There's been this kind of very half-hearted movement, hasn't it, in recent years,
00:19:50 a form of grammar school should come back or whatever,
00:19:53 But it seems that, frankly, it does seem that very half-hearted.
00:19:57 It's no-hearted. It never comes to anything.
00:20:01 And I know it never will whenever I hear them say it, because they don't really mean it.
00:20:06 You can't actually just have a piecemeal recreation of economic selection.
00:20:12 It has to be done as a direct national policy, encouraged ferociously by a committed government,
00:20:19 rather than a few token supposed grammar schools in a few areas.
00:20:24 That mainly distorts it, as you see in counties such as Kent and Buckinghamshire,
00:20:29 which are close to London in commuter areas.
00:20:31 You simply get a very small number of besieged grammar schools,
00:20:35 which are not typical of how grammar schools operate in the national system,
00:20:40 and actually become in themselves in arguments against selection.
00:20:43 Because short-sighted, ignorant, or frankly malicious people
00:20:48 portray this situation as if it is
00:20:50 what it would be if we had a national selective system
00:20:52 which we don't. So I'm not interested
00:20:54 in any of that.
00:20:56 It was totally funny when Theresa May
00:20:58 came out supposedly as the friend of the grammar
00:21:00 schools because I outed her some
00:21:02 years ago in her
00:21:04 reference books. She either
00:21:06 didn't mention her education,
00:21:08 her school education at all or she claimed
00:21:10 to have gone to comprehensive when in fact
00:21:12 what she went to was a grammar school that
00:21:14 was turned into a comprehensive while she
00:21:16 was there right and then to make herself out to be the apostle of the grammar schools when she's
00:21:22 hid the fact that she'd been to one yeah seemed to me to be a bit merge I think I remember when
00:21:27 my school went from being grammar to comprehensive it was under Shirley Williams would have been
00:21:31 about 1977 you survived quite late in that yeah but there was a real sense amongst people because
00:21:37 it was like I'd say half middle class half working class on the whole school there's a real sense of
00:21:43 fear and outrage why is this happening why are you taking a school why are you going to destroy
00:21:47 it basically well quite and a lot of people have this experience and the there is actually a count
00:21:52 of what happened to Theresa May's school which was a Holton Park girls grammar outside Oxford
00:21:57 when it was merged with the nearby secondary modern and the the changes for the worse which
00:22:01 immediately and visibly happened there are a lot of in local histories a lot of accounts of these
00:22:06 of schools which which had in many cases for centuries been at the heart of communities and
00:22:11 You know, excellent schools because of the kind of schools where no fees were charged
00:22:16 and where anybody who could pass the test could go.
00:22:21 These schools just being smashed to pieces in a few short years
00:22:24 and turned into caricatures of education.
00:22:27 And nobody could do anything about it.
00:22:29 Everyone was powerless because the central decision had been taken
00:22:32 and it was going to be implemented come one night.
00:22:35 But the extraordinary thing was that that educational system as it was then
00:22:40 really was having an effect, wasn't it, on social mobility?
00:22:43 Oh, it always was.
00:22:43 You can see there is one set of statistics which is available
00:22:47 in the Franks report into Oxford University in the middle of the 1960s,
00:22:52 which shows that the number of entrants to Oxford
00:22:56 from grammar schools and their very close cousins, direct grads,
00:23:00 had been going up steadily since 1944.
00:23:03 And on extrapolation, it would probably have hit the 70s by now
00:23:07 without any aids no special provision no no concessions made they would just have got there
00:23:15 and pushed aside the products of the of the public schools as they were doing and anybody who was
00:23:21 there at the time will tell you that there was this revolution going on and I went to play at
00:23:26 Glass University in the early 70s and I was surrounded by young bright working-class young
00:23:31 men and women with the same grammar school problems I checked the figures a couple of years
00:23:36 ago and it was so it was as i imagined it had been and then within a very few years after after the
00:23:42 comprehensiveization began the the number of private school entrants began to rise and the
00:23:47 number of comprehensive school entrants who of course came from comprehensive in well-off areas
00:23:52 began to rise and those those young men and women who i saw were the last to have that chance you
00:23:58 see this now reflected in areas that were always traditionally very meritocratic such as journalism
00:24:04 for example oh yeah you do but it's though in fact journalism still has some roots up for the
00:24:10 non because it's a trade not a profession there are still some roots and most of the really
00:24:17 distinguished reporters and particularly in the areas of news in journalism have not come through
00:24:23 graduate training schemes but have come up out of the grammar schools straight into the newsroom
00:24:27 people and it's it's still just but of course the grammar schools which used to feed them in
00:24:34 have largely gone so this is rarer and rarer. The thing is we're talking about the structural
00:24:40 you know the way that the system was actually structured at that time the crisis in education
00:24:47 that we're maybe now having the effects of was not just about that was it it's sort of schools
00:24:52 in a way changed they didn't they didn't see their role as passing on anything anymore well that that
00:24:58 there was several as with almost all changes there's no there's no single cause and the thing
00:25:04 which overwhelms the grammar schools and in fact a lot of the secondary moderns which were which
00:25:08 are now much calumniated and were much better in many cases than they thought to have been
00:25:11 was the great what what we called in this country the baby bulge it's now a term that's been
00:25:17 overwhelmed by the American term baby boom but it began to feed into the schools about the
00:25:24 secondary schools in the middle 50s and what was really needed was a large program of opening new
00:25:31 grammar schools and indeed new secondary moderns as well to cope with the capacity but nobody did
00:25:36 that and so the the system was overwhelmed by numbers and the conservative party at the time
00:25:43 was not particularly ideologically committed to grammar schools because so many of its
00:25:47 senior figures sent their children to private schools and they didn't really understand
00:25:50 or care. And the Labour Party was going through an egalitarian spasm which was making it more
00:25:56 and more hostile to them. So they were basically left unexpanded. In the early 50s, for instance,
00:26:06 the Gurney-Dixon report recalls, I think, that two-thirds of children in grammar schools
00:26:12 in England and Wales were from working-class homes.
00:26:15 You would not find anything remotely resembling that
00:26:18 in the so-called good comprehensives of today.
00:26:20 But it was so, but it was the bulge and the numbers
00:26:23 which overwhelmed it and the unwillingness
00:26:25 of a not particularly intelligent or sensible government
00:26:28 to do anything about it.
00:26:29 And all kinds of sins followed from that.
00:26:33 But we could spend an entire afternoon discussing it.
00:26:36 No, but I mean, it's the root of everything, really.
00:26:39 It's the root of a lot, but the other root of everything
00:26:41 of course the decline of the the decline of the married family in a stable family life
00:26:46 particularly among the poor which which got going shortly afterwards and which i did deal with it
00:26:53 at some length in my 1999 book the abolition of britain but it is it it remains the other great
00:26:59 revolution because of course both these the education and the family revolution both affect
00:27:04 the young, completely transformed upbringing, education and socialisation.
00:27:11 You have a completely different kind of person that grows up in the country in which they
00:27:16 live from what came before.
00:27:18 And knowing nothing about the country as well.
00:27:21 Increasingly now, yes.
00:27:24 Or knowing things about it which are misleading in my case.
00:27:27 And I think that you often find that people have been taught a version of the past which
00:27:32 is so partial that they can't really understand properly
00:27:38 what it is that went before NSC.
00:27:41 On this point as well,
00:27:44 obviously you were very politically active in the 60s, weren't you?
00:27:47 And then the 70s.
00:27:48 I began, I suppose, I could call it politically active really after about 68.
00:27:55 After about 68.
00:27:56 Before that I was just a troublemaker.
00:27:58 If you take that period as being, if you like, the start maybe, or round about the start of what you would call the Cultural Revolution.
00:28:07 Oh no, it had begun well before that. In many ways it has its roots in the First World War and before that in the Bloomsbury Group and the Fabian Society.
00:28:18 So it's the ideas that eventually came to pass in the 50s and 60s, whether they be Edmund Leach's attack on marriage or the growing desire for comprehensive education on the left or the sexual revolution.
00:28:40 These were being espoused by people such as Roy Jenkins and Anthony Crosland in the late 50s
00:28:46 and were beginning to come to pass in the 1960s.
00:28:51 The thing about the 1960s, really the high 60s, as I call them, right at the end, 68, 69, 70,
00:28:56 is that people went further in that period than they'd ever gone before
00:29:02 and indeed a lot further than they were prepared to go in the years afterwards.
00:29:05 1973, the oil shock, the Yom Kippur War and what followed it, put a stop to it all and chilled things down quite a bit.
00:29:14 So it took a very long time for us to get back, in terms of cultural revolution, to the really frenzied levels that they were at in the late 60s,
00:29:25 which were often in rather isolated places, like university campuses and parts of the capital city and little corners of culture like BBC2 and so forth.
00:29:33 But they then became enormous and general.
00:29:38 But it wasn't, it hadn't just begun out of nothing in the 1960s.
00:29:41 There were an awful lot of ideas which had been seeking.
00:29:44 But of course the advent of television,
00:29:48 which was in many cases particularly under Hugh Carlson Green at the BBC,
00:29:53 dominated by people with sort of Thabian Bloomsbury radical ideas,
00:29:59 meant that instead of just having the Bloomsbury group
00:30:01 talking to each other in novels that nobody read
00:30:05 and in gatherings in London's squares.
00:30:10 The Bloomsbury Group suddenly gained control of the national transmitters
00:30:13 and were able through...
00:30:15 What a thought.
00:30:16 Well, particularly through drama, Wednesday plays
00:30:20 and of course through the supposed satire programs,
00:30:27 that was the week that was and so on and so forth,
00:30:29 to project onto a much larger number of minds
00:30:33 ideas which had previously been restricted
00:30:35 to a very small number of intellectuals.
00:30:40 Would you say that,
00:30:42 actually you talk about the Bloomsbury Group,
00:30:43 interestingly, if you go back that far,
00:30:46 you had Gramsci or whatever in the 1920s.
00:30:49 But by the 1960s, this had become this slogan
00:30:52 of the long march through the institutions, hadn't it?
00:30:54 Well, Gramsci is an interesting thing
00:30:56 because he was one of the very earliest people
00:31:00 on the revolutionary left to understand
00:31:02 that the Soviet experiment had been a disaster.
00:31:05 He went there, he saw it was a catastrophe, he came back,
00:31:07 he told his comrades in the Italian Communist Party,
00:31:09 this is not, we can't get anywhere like this.
00:31:13 It's doomed to fail, it's a millstone around our necks.
00:31:15 If we're to make any real progress, what isn't necessary,
00:31:19 he didn't use this term, is a cultural and moral revolution,
00:31:22 so the people who we're trying to preach to
00:31:24 will be more receptive to our ideas.
00:31:25 But as things happen, the conservative, prosperous, Christian working classes of Europe will not ever buy Bolshevism as an idea, in which he was absolutely right.
00:31:36 And that's why he became so important, because his idea of hegemony and his idea of taking over the ideas of society was one which became very appealing to the new left in the universities in the 1960s.
00:31:49 And they had the ideas, and then they met Gramsci, I think, rather than the other way around, and he became a sort of flagship.
00:31:55 But this is coincidental, really,
00:31:59 that the Bloomsbury's and the Fabians
00:32:02 who had their own ideas about overthrowing
00:32:05 the mores and system of society,
00:32:09 working in a sort of almost blind way
00:32:12 towards a similar destination.
00:32:14 They all come together in the 1960s
00:32:16 as a series of forces.
00:32:18 I think it was one of the German revolutionaries
00:32:22 who actually came up.
00:32:23 That's it was indeed, yes.
00:32:24 Was it Dutschke or the term of the long march?
00:32:28 It wasn't Gramsci, but it's associated with him.
00:32:31 But there has undoubtedly been a long march.
00:32:33 Yes, but this is the interesting point.
00:32:36 I was on it.
00:32:38 Right.
00:32:39 And when I set out, when I first went into journalism,
00:32:42 I was fully intending to gain the necessary skills
00:32:46 to spread the revolutionary message through newspapers and the media.
00:32:52 that was what I was intending to do.
00:32:56 That was my intention.
00:32:58 I think I was more focused than most people.
00:33:00 Most of the, I mean it's extraordinary
00:33:02 how many members of Blair's cabinet
00:33:04 were actually members of Trotsky's
00:33:06 or communist organisations that we know about
00:33:08 and I suspect there were probably more
00:33:10 who we don't know about
00:33:12 but because I was a member
00:33:14 of a revolutionary organisation
00:33:16 I was more focused, more conscious
00:33:19 of what I was doing
00:33:19 but our ideas spread very, very widely
00:33:23 When I was at the University of York in the 1970s,
00:33:26 we became, in the period when I was there,
00:33:29 we became the dominant political organization on campus.
00:33:31 If people wanted to talk about left-wing politics,
00:33:33 it was to the international socialists they turned.
00:33:37 They came to our meetings, they read our publications,
00:33:39 they listened to what they made as a join.
00:33:41 I don't believe that they ceased to be in favor of some sort of revolution
00:33:48 when they went off into the world.
00:33:50 I think they continued to be.
00:33:52 But they'd learnt through the processes that we all learnt about life that you don't do this by selling the socialist worker on the street or going on marches or picket lines.
00:34:03 You do it by the slow, gradual process of inserting yourself into society and making yourself influential.
00:34:09 And about 25, 30 years after we all left university, there we were, all in position.
00:34:15 And in many cases, it's livid that the political government of the country was in the hands of what was formerly a conservative party.
00:34:22 which is one of the reasons for this sort of red glow revolutionary sensation when the Blair government was elected.
00:34:30 All the left-wing people I knew behaved as if there had been a red dawn.
00:34:35 They were completely overwhelmed by this.
00:34:37 I just thought it was silly.
00:34:40 I didn't realise at the time that they were actually right.
00:34:42 It was a red dawn.
00:34:44 I remember Matthew Parris, of all people, saying, this was in one of his columns around the time during the Blair thing,
00:34:51 There was something sort of slightly, he put it alien about them.
00:34:55 I think meaning there was something that just did not feel like before.
00:35:00 Well, it wasn't like before.
00:35:01 Matthew was often very perceptive because he does allow himself to think.
00:35:04 But what I had been told by, I'd say who he is now because he subsequently died,
00:35:11 he's called Philip Bassett.
00:35:13 He'd been an industrial correspondent, as I had been, and we'd been good friends.
00:35:17 but he suddenly announced a few months
00:35:21 before the 97 election
00:35:23 he was going off to work for Blair
00:35:24 and we realised after this
00:35:26 we were not going to be able to have much to do with each other
00:35:28 because it was going to be
00:35:30 if not an actual friendship buster
00:35:31 it was going to be a cool thing
00:35:32 so we went for a drink together
00:35:33 and as it were part on good terms
00:35:37 at the end of it he said
00:35:38 you have no idea
00:35:40 how extensive the Blair Project is
00:35:44 and how deep it is
00:35:45 and then a few years later
00:35:46 a character called Peter Hyman who was very close to Blair wrote an article in the Observer quite
00:35:51 recently actually which I often quote saying that Blairism was far more revolutionary and
00:35:56 radical than Jeremy Corbyn that again it was an enormous project to change the country and I think
00:36:01 it was and nobody really understood at the time just how extensive it was including probably
00:36:07 Blair himself who although it emerged a few years ago had actually been a Trotsky University which
00:36:14 if that had come out at the time would have destroyed him but now nobody cares
00:36:18 I don't think Blair fully understood it because he wasn't very bright
00:36:22 but a lot of the people around him understood this was an enormous moment
00:36:26 in history in which the actual the thinking
00:36:30 I won't say Marxist because probably in most cases
00:36:35 it would narrow them to call them that the thinking radical left
00:36:39 finally got their hands on the leaders of power
00:36:42 of political power as well as cultural power
00:36:46 as well as broadcasting power as well as educational power
00:36:49 and they were in a position to change the country
00:36:51 and they did and they changed it economically
00:36:54 as well as culturally.
00:36:56 Huge amounts of money were shifted
00:37:01 from one place to another by Gordon Brown
00:37:02 in ways which did transform society
00:37:05 which people underestimated
00:37:07 as well as all the cultural and moral stuff.
00:37:09 I think as well that...
00:37:11 It was a revolution.
00:37:12 Yes.
00:37:14 It's interesting as well that there was this moment, wasn't there,
00:37:18 which was, I think, it was not intentional,
00:37:21 but one of Blair's speechwriters, Andrew Neither,
00:37:25 pointed out, oh, there had been this real attempt
00:37:28 to have social consequences for mass migration to change.
00:37:33 Well, he said that there had been this discussion.
00:37:36 He just outed it in an article in the Evening Standard,
00:37:39 which
00:37:41 has ever afterwards been a terrible embarrassment
00:37:43 it was one of those moments
00:37:45 a bit like the Peter Hyman
00:37:47 article in the Observer
00:37:49 where for once people spoke directly
00:37:51 of what it was
00:37:52 that had been going on
00:37:54 rather than leaving us to work it out
00:37:57 and I think it's
00:37:59 an interesting revelation because
00:38:01 of just how explicit it was
00:38:03 but who can doubt it, I mean when I was a
00:38:05 revolutionary socialist for instance we were very much
00:38:07 in favour of large scale immigration
00:38:09 not because we particularly liked immigrants
00:38:12 but because we thought we didn't like Britain
00:38:14 and we thought that if we had large numbers of people in Britain
00:38:18 who were from outside
00:38:20 it would make our task of changing the country easier
00:38:24 it's rational, it makes perfect sense
00:38:27 and it would make perfect sense in a new labour context as well
00:38:30 so for Andrew Nieder to have said that as he did
00:38:32 and I've often, I've done what I can
00:38:36 to give it the widest possible circulation
00:38:38 because it seems to me to be a very, very interesting historical document.
00:38:41 It's a huge thing, but also, as you say, at the time,
00:38:44 actually, considering what was being said, remarkably underreported, actually.
00:38:48 Well, things are. I was just mentioning this.
00:38:49 When Blair told Peter Hennessy on Radio 4,
00:38:54 yes, I was at Trotsky University,
00:38:57 nobody reported it except me. Nobody.
00:39:01 I mean, by any standards, it's an interesting thing, isn't it?
00:39:04 But not a word.
00:39:06 It's extraordinary.
00:39:06 I mean, some things, you mustn't assume
00:39:08 that just because something hasn't been reported
00:39:10 hasn't happened.
00:39:12 You mentioned there about, I mean, I'm very fascinated
00:39:14 you're talking about actually, you wanted
00:39:16 to go in to one
00:39:18 of our institutions, if you like, the media or whatever,
00:39:20 and you wanted to spread the word.
00:39:22 If you look at the kind of, if you look at
00:39:24 the cultural output now,
00:39:26 and how plays, we mentioned
00:39:28 films, whatever.
00:39:31 I've noticed that in your column
00:39:32 in the Mail on Sunday,
00:39:34 you mentioned films quite a lot.
00:39:36 I wanted to ask you really
00:39:38 first of all
00:39:39 do you avoid now
00:39:42 looking at certain things
00:39:43 because you know
00:39:43 it's just going to make you angry
00:39:45 because of the subliminal messages
00:39:46 or actually I mean
00:39:48 are you a great film man?
00:39:50 I mean I speak as one who is
00:39:52 I love going to the cinema
00:39:54 though I'm usually disappointed
00:39:55 No but you keep going actually
00:39:57 I've noticed that you do actually
00:39:58 There's a very simple reason for that
00:40:00 What's that?
00:40:01 Will you try illustrating
00:40:02 a political column?
00:40:03 Right
00:40:04 okay
00:40:08 but do you actually
00:40:10 the film always provides you with it
00:40:11 you can say something
00:40:12 there's always something interesting to be said about a film
00:40:14 and usually it produces a good attractive illustration
00:40:17 but it solves that problem
00:40:20 that's all
00:40:21 it's no more complicated than that
00:40:24 but do you find you actually
00:40:25 do you bother now for example
00:40:27 I'm talking about the results maybe
00:40:29 do you bother with the theatre
00:40:31 well I'm not a Londoner
00:40:33 So the theatre is such an expedition,
00:40:37 I can't really be bothered most of the time.
00:40:40 It's too far to go.
00:40:43 I suppose the point really I'm making is that drama or plays or films,
00:40:47 they tend, if anything now, just to parrot the orthodoxies
00:40:52 of the establishment on the whole.
00:40:53 Well, yeah, that can be fun sometimes.
00:40:55 I mean, David Hare is quite good some of the time.
00:40:58 I remember going to see Pravda years and years ago
00:41:02 when the National Theatre was new
00:41:04 and laughing at the wrong bit.
00:41:06 I was the only person, I was probably the only person
00:41:07 who actually worked in Fleet Street in the theatre
00:41:10 and somebody said something.
00:41:11 It was actually very funny.
00:41:13 But it was only funny if you knew Fleet Street.
00:41:15 And it was funny in quite a conservative way
00:41:17 and I laughed and everybody in the theatre
00:41:19 turned and stared at me.
00:41:21 But no, some of the, as it were,
00:41:25 the radical playwrights are quite good
00:41:27 and enjoyable in their own.
00:41:30 but I just don't, because I'm not a Londoner,
00:41:32 going to the theatre is something
00:41:33 which I don't do all that much of.
00:41:36 There are wonderful, sometimes, performances of Shakespeare
00:41:39 in the courtyard of the body and in Oxford where I live,
00:41:42 which is architecturally exactly of the time of the place.
00:41:46 It's completely perfect, which I will go through.
00:41:48 And increasingly, when I go to Shakespeare,
00:41:49 I take the text because it adds so much to it,
00:41:53 but that I will still enjoy.
00:41:55 And also, the other luxury of Oxford
00:41:57 is an awful lot of open-air Shakespeare
00:41:59 college gardens which is another great luxury but going to the theatre as such let's say
00:42:03 it's a londonist thing i don't really do it being britain's obiturist to go back to that point um
00:42:11 i think i have sort of asked you this but you know when you go with your life now you can you still
00:42:17 enjoy your britain as it were no i don't the it's not a question of enjoying my britain i am a very
00:42:24 fortunate person by the standards of most people and i live a very fortunate life which i won't
00:42:28 I won't go into it in any great detail,
00:42:29 but I'm, for the moment, relatively insulated
00:42:32 from an awful lot of things which are happening
00:42:34 to my countrymen and countrywomen.
00:42:38 But it doesn't, the fact that I am fortunate
00:42:40 doesn't blind me to the fact that most people are not.
00:42:43 And if it did for a moment, then the letters
00:42:46 and the telephone calls and the emails that I get
00:42:48 from people in the more blighted parts of the country
00:42:51 all the time would very quickly remind me
00:42:53 of just how fortunate I am
00:42:55 and how untypical that experience is.
00:42:58 Well, there are those people, those followers again, coming back to you.
00:43:02 Peter, thank you very, very much for coming and talking to us,
00:43:07 and it's been an absolute pleasure.
00:43:09 Thank you for having me.
00:43:10 Thank you very much indeed.
00:43:11 That's it for what you're saying is this week,
00:43:14 and please remember to subscribe, won't you?
00:43:17 And we'll see you next time. Thank you.