New Culture Forum - September 15, 2019


S2 02: James Cary - Comedy, Religion & The New Morality.

S02 01 - Peter Hitchens: The British Revolution WAS Televised S2.03 Martin Durkin: Media Bias & Brexit Snobbery

Episode Stats


Length

37 minutes

Words per minute

183.93

Word count

6,902

Sentence count

92


Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
00:00:00 Hello and welcome to So What You're Saying Is, I'm Peter Whittle. Now my guest this week stands at
00:00:23 the intersection between two very hot issues, that's comedy and religion. James Carey is a
00:00:29 writer for radio and television. He created the award-winning Think the Unthinkable on Radio 4
00:00:35 and he also contributed to Bluestone 42 and to Miranda. He is also the author of a number of
00:00:42 books, the latest of which is The Sacred Art of Joking. And he's also a member of the General
00:00:50 Synod of the Church of England. Welcome very much, James. It's good to see you. You haven't
00:00:57 exactly made life easy for yourself with this particular path if you're not yes I don't think
00:01:03 yes I'm also a Calvinist so I think the path has chosen me um but yes no I like I like comedy I've
00:01:10 always loved comedy um I didn't I didn't really see the point of anything else growing up I just
00:01:15 wanted to watch comedy and watching all the great sitcoms of our time like Porridge and
00:01:18 yes Prime Minister which is probably my favourite of the lot um but also um have a Christian faith
00:01:24 which i acquired really from my school and um and since then i've always i've always been a i've
00:01:32 always been the weird one because in the world of um in the world of comedy i've always been the
00:01:37 weirdo who's actually a christian which is not all that common but then in in my church world
00:01:42 i'm the weirdo who works for the bbc which is in their view full of full of um non-christians and
00:01:49 and socialists but actually let's take that point i mean you know is that a caricature
00:01:55 or are you unusual at the bbc or for that matter actually in broadcast well here we go i attended
00:02:02 a comedy conference i was one of the speakers at the craft of comedy a couple of years ago up in
00:02:07 north wales and the today program were there and there were about 100 people in the room including
00:02:12 professional comedians and writers commissioners controllers as well as um other delegates at the
00:02:17 conference and the today program asked and you can listen to this if you go back into the archives
00:02:21 um the radio 4 program would like to talk to somebody here who voted to leave is there anyone
00:02:28 here who voted to leave and we were all having lunch 100 150 people one voice came up yep
00:02:36 that's me so i was the only person in that room for example to vote leave
00:02:41 yes um and so what that tells you is that there is a sort of reinforcing uh echo chamber uh around
00:02:50 comedy which is not just the bbc i think obviously the channel forum um other broadcasters have got
00:02:55 this because everyone moves around in all these different jobs so there is undoubtedly you know
00:02:59 i think um good heart's book uh about the the anywheres and the somewheres or yes the road to
00:03:05 yeah road to somewhere i mean i think that's i think that's a very accurate portrayal of
00:03:09 people who are disproportionately influential within the media and lots of comedians are
00:03:15 graduates they all went off to university they're slightly you know disconnected and i'm like that
00:03:20 too but um for whatever reason i moved back to to the west country where i'm from and um so i you
00:03:27 know i would probably think of myself more as a somewhere than an anywhere um but yeah so but
00:03:33 But because of the nature of the BBC and what it is,
00:03:37 it is full of people who were absolutely astonished
00:03:41 when, A, when a Conservative government is re-elected,
00:03:44 when a Republican is made president in the American election,
00:03:49 and then when Britain votes to leave.
00:03:52 The only thing that astonishes me is at the time of recording,
00:03:55 it still looks like we're pretending
00:03:57 that we are actually going to leave the European Union.
00:03:59 What I thought would happen is that we'd vote to leave,
00:04:02 and everyone would go well that was all very interesting like with the lisbon treaty and then
00:04:07 five ten years time we'd be talking about the eu and we go we voted to leave that didn't we i thought
00:04:13 we weren't to be leaving and then nothing happened um i was sort of assumed that we would just be
00:04:17 ignored completely on that one but it's absolutely dreadful it's interesting you you you made the
00:04:22 point there about the bbc or i myself was in broadcasting for a long time uh it's not so
00:04:27 dissimilar in other you know areas it's not just the BBC they take the lead if
00:04:31 you like they set the agenda but it's not just is it about parties and like not
00:04:36 being fair to the Tory party and being you know too fair to Labour or whatever
00:04:41 it's actually a whole set of cultural attitudes I mean I picked on something
00:04:45 actually that you've written about on your on your blog which was about the
00:04:51 BBC's attitude to religion mmm and I think you know it's not interested in
00:04:56 religion well you say it's not interested in religion but also you say in it that it's actually
00:05:01 more interested in promoting what if i get it right you call it judeo-christian post judeo
00:05:07 judeo-christian sort of quasi-socialist secularism yeah is that right yeah it's sort of a sentimental
00:05:13 sort of form of you know it's an inoffensive form of what used to be a version of christianity
00:05:20 It's sort of a second-hand thing where it's the kind of thing where, you know, it sort of reminds me of how, for example, the likes of Polly Toynbee, who hate Christianity, hate the Lion, the Witch and the Wardrobe.
00:05:34 For example, when I remember seeing her writing about it, and when she talks about Aslan being Jesus, she sort of hates that idea and just said, nobody asked Jesus to die for us.
00:05:46 you know I'm not you know we we don't need religion uh all we need is common sense and
00:05:51 decency and you think well where do you think 2019 British common sense and decency comes from
00:05:56 it comes from Judeo-Christianity um so I think what we're trying to do is we're trying to have the
00:06:03 the Christianity but without the Christ um and I think you can run on that for a while and I think
00:06:09 we have been running on that since the 30s 40s 50s and eventually the fumes run out you can't
00:06:14 And now we're sort of running on the memory of the fumes, if you see what I mean.
00:06:18 That's a very nice way of putting it, actually.
00:06:20 There's been a book out recently by Tom Holland, you probably know,
00:06:23 where he's saying, look, you know, Christianity is at the basis of our civilisation,
00:06:29 our society, and it's wrong to deny that.
00:06:34 But also there's this sort of sense in which, you know, somehow secularism,
00:06:38 and I'm secular, I'm not.
00:06:39 but you know does this mean that you know i'm fooling myself if i think that what i consider
00:06:47 to be decent behavior whatever does not come from religion is is that what your sort of
00:06:52 yeah it has it has to have come from some form of christianity because if you go to other countries
00:06:57 in the world if you go to um pakistan um if you go to china if you go to indonesia if you go
00:07:04 New Delhi or
00:07:08 whatever it's called now, Calcutta and all these different
00:07:10 places, if you go to India
00:07:11 then
00:07:12 they have a completely different understanding
00:07:16 of what common sense and decency is
00:07:17 and that's because they've had a completely different
00:07:20 world view for the last thousand years
00:07:21 based on a completely different theology
00:07:24 and
00:07:26 that's completely
00:07:27 understandable, so the idea that we
00:07:30 pulled secularism out of thin air in this country
00:07:32 I can't see
00:07:34 how that could possibly have happened um and the the irony is of course that it's it's the
00:07:39 reformation uh in the 1500s that made all of this sort of pluralism possible yeah um so in a way
00:07:45 christianity's greatest gift uh to secularism is to say well you get to not be a christian you get
00:07:52 to you get to refuse you get to have different um to get to have a different faith or no faith
00:07:57 um and that is not self-evident to many people in and other cultures so to deny and we can have a
00:08:03 debate about which one of them is it's true or based on something or but it seems like a
00:08:08 we have to admit it I think Tom Holland's right I mean it's like this is where it comes from
00:08:13 where do you think it comes from the BBC has this thing it promotes you know which is I imagine it
00:08:19 probably thinks that it is doesn't need religion obviously yeah interestingly I think you pointed
00:08:25 out the title now is not it's not head of religion and ethics it's actually editor of ethics and
00:08:32 Religion, yes, well there you go.
00:08:33 Turned it around.
00:08:34 Yeah, where do you think ethics come from?
00:08:36 They come from religion.
00:08:37 But the point is really, James, is, you know, in a way, which came first, chicken or the egg?
00:08:42 I would have thought that the BBC will probably think, well, we're just reflecting the way society is now.
00:08:48 Or do you think they have helped it along?
00:08:50 Do you think that, you know, as it were, their anti-religion helped the situation to what we have now?
00:08:58 Yes, I don't know whether they're anti-religion.
00:09:00 it feels more like
00:09:02 the BBC probably would make less
00:09:05 religious broadcasting if it
00:09:07 could but it has its statutorily
00:09:09 required to make a certain amount
00:09:11 and it does and the stuff that it makes
00:09:12 some people are helped by so I don't want to
00:09:15 throw it all
00:09:17 under the bus but the BBC
00:09:19 yearns to win
00:09:21 awards for natural history
00:09:22 and for news reporting
00:09:25 it's not trying to win awards for religious
00:09:27 broadcasting, happily accept them
00:09:29 But I think it's more that it's a bit like comedy as well.
00:09:34 It's like, does comedy lead the way in terms of changing attitudes or does it reflect them?
00:09:40 And I think it just contributes to a feedback loop, doesn't it?
00:09:43 So a comedian will be, the job of a comedian is to sort of notice things
00:09:48 and put things together slightly earlier than society has.
00:09:52 And they can say, oh, isn't it funny how this or that,
00:09:55 I mean, I sort of noticed a thing the other day where there was a whole load of people gathered together
00:10:01 and they all had their heads down and they were looking at their phones.
00:10:04 And I thought there's a sort of a possible joke in how there would be a caricature of people in the 15th century
00:10:11 all shuffling into church with their heads down, looking like complete idiots,
00:10:15 believing in something that isn't actually there.
00:10:17 And, oh, weren't they stupid?
00:10:18 And here we all are voluntarily just doing this with our heads down,
00:10:22 shuffling around, looking at something that isn't actually there.
00:10:25 And so what the comedian does is he sort of puts things together that are a comic,
00:10:31 and he does that before everybody's noticed them.
00:10:34 So he or she, their job is to kind of get there slightly early.
00:10:37 But if they get there way earlier, then nobody really quite gets the joke.
00:10:42 You're sort of trying to just sort of, you know what I mean?
00:10:45 You're just sort of leading people along like that.
00:10:49 Whereas if you suddenly come out of nowhere,
00:10:51 where if you did a 2019 progressive comedy act 30 years ago,
00:10:57 people would have just been completely mystified
00:11:00 by what you were talking about.
00:11:03 Even 15 years ago,
00:11:05 I mean, you remember when civil partnerships came in,
00:11:08 everybody who was in favour of same-sex civil partnerships said,
00:11:12 well, there's no question that this is going to lead to same-sex marriage
00:11:14 because nobody wants that.
00:11:15 Nobody's asking for that.
00:11:17 And then suddenly it's like, oh, my goodness.
00:11:19 And now you're in the wrong side of history.
00:11:21 and everyone conveniently forgets uh the narrative that was that was um that was told before um
00:11:28 so it is interesting how the bbc in the same way as newspapers and all culture really and all art
00:11:36 um comes which is it's just trying to get slightly ahead get slightly ahead
00:11:41 and there are people who were you know who we would look back and say well they were prophets
00:11:45 of their time but they died completely penniless because everyone thought well this is nonsense
00:11:48 and therefore when you have an exhibition of the Impressionists everyone
00:11:54 just thinks what on earth is that I mean that kind of I guess that looks like a
00:11:57 bridge why didn't you actually paint a bridge some people of course still say
00:12:01 that yes of course yeah you know you know and then you know we're always told
00:12:05 that oh when whenever sound so this first this this concerto was first
00:12:09 performed this simply was first performed in Paris there was a riot and
00:12:12 you sort of think well was there but you know that there probably was and
00:12:16 People thought, well, music shouldn't sound like this.
00:12:20 When you, I mean, just go back to BBC for a minute.
00:12:23 You've written a lot for the BBC.
00:12:25 How does it actually work, James?
00:12:28 I mean, you're commissioned.
00:12:31 You go and write the thing or whatever.
00:12:33 Do they know what to expect from you?
00:12:36 At what stage do they start to become involved?
00:12:40 Do they ever say, well, we can't say this, we can't say that?
00:12:43 You know, did you have experience of that sort of thing?
00:12:46 Not particularly, but I think once they've commissioned the show
00:12:50 and the show's up and running, as it were,
00:12:52 there are editorial guidelines and policies which are eminently sensible.
00:12:57 And overall, I was very, you know, so I made a show, full credit to them,
00:13:02 I made a show about bomb disposal in Afghanistan and it was a comedy
00:13:05 called Bluestone 4-2 and they really defended that.
00:13:12 And obviously they were slightly nervous about how people would receive that.
00:13:16 um and there were lots of very sort of troubling themes that took place within the show and and
00:13:21 and they backed it so uh they're a good bunch to have on your side in a scrap um once once
00:13:29 they're happy with it and and so they do go out and and go into bat for things um but yeah it's
00:13:35 always a conversation and occasionally you dig your heels in and say no i'm sorry that's the way
00:13:40 it should be um but you know it's it's it's always a bit of a feedback process um and that's the same
00:13:48 with any broadcaster really and i'm same with newspapers and all these kinds of things and
00:13:54 you're you're kind of aware that that the people for in my in my point of view i'm aware that the
00:13:59 people who who are full-time staff at the bbc have generally a fairly different outlook from me
00:14:05 and that's
00:14:08 and all things considered therefore
00:14:10 I think it's always interesting to me
00:14:12 that the people on the left
00:14:14 look at the BBC and just say
00:14:16 it just defends the Tories all the time
00:14:18 or whatever and you think
00:14:20 if you are on the right you just think I don't really quite see
00:14:22 how you can say that but actually given
00:14:24 what the political views of the people who tend to
00:14:26 work for the BBC actually are, the news
00:14:28 is actually surprisingly fair
00:14:29 and actually a lot of their big
00:14:32 hitters in terms of political commentators
00:14:34 are from the rights, like Nick Robinson or Andrew Neil
00:14:37 and people like that.
00:14:38 But they're in an impossible situation,
00:14:40 so I don't want to say the BBC are the big villains here.
00:14:44 I think that there's no question...
00:14:45 Because they pay a lot of my mortgage, by the way.
00:14:47 Right, OK, fair enough.
00:14:48 But even so, I'm happy to be fairly robust.
00:14:51 I think it's the general cultural drift of the BBC,
00:14:54 which obviously gets a lot of people very concerned.
00:14:58 I mean, there's no question about that.
00:15:00 I think it's interesting
00:15:04 you being a Christian
00:15:06 you hear this argument
00:15:08 an awful lot now
00:15:09 or have over the past few years
00:15:11 that somehow or other
00:15:12 there's nothing you can't say
00:15:13 about Christianity
00:15:14 you can mock it
00:15:16 you can joke about it
00:15:17 compared to other religions
00:15:19 say Islam or whatever
00:15:20 where you can't say anything
00:15:21 first of all
00:15:23 is that a picture that you recognise
00:15:25 I mean
00:15:25 because I was thinking about it
00:15:27 looking before we spoke today
00:15:29 and I was thinking
00:15:30 well you know if you take life of brian or if you take dave allen you know would would you have
00:15:38 those today i mean i i i'm trying to think you know when was the last time maybe jerry springer
00:15:44 do you think that's a fair criticism or do you know that basically christianity is the only
00:15:49 mockable one i do hear that view a lot and i do know that the sort of people that i go to church
00:15:54 with and and me they do feel that they're that they don't really see why their religion should
00:16:00 be the the the punch bag um and this is a view i mean i talk about it in in my book that um i mean
00:16:08 ann widdekombe did a documentary about partly about this subject uh with a comedian marcus
00:16:13 brigstock um and she wrote in the telegraph you know why is it okay for you know the comedians
00:16:21 are all very happy to make jokes about Christianity but they don't want to make jokes about Islam
00:16:25 and rather implying moral rather implying cowardice on the part of comedians and actually if you know
00:16:31 comedians they tend to lean into these things they're actually they like prodding things and
00:16:35 they're not they're not particularly scared of a fight or what the consequences might be
00:16:39 I don't genuinely think that's the reason the the reasons are a little bit more boring and
00:16:44 less conspiratorial in that in order for you to make jokes about something people have to have
00:16:49 have a basic understanding of it and therefore you can make jokes about christianity because there is
00:16:55 just about enough uh residual understanding of what christianity is for you to be able to make
00:17:02 a joke also do you mean for example the ceremonial of it if you think of dave allen yeah about vicars
00:17:07 and pulpits and everything absolutely yeah so he was doing lots of jokes about um catholic priests
00:17:12 and um and that kind of thing if you look at the stats an awful lot of people still end up at some
00:17:18 point in a church at some point in the course of a year either they go to a wedding or they go to
00:17:23 a funeral or they go to a baptism or they go at christmas and therefore you they have a narrative
00:17:30 and all of those are relatively serious occasions because they're big life events and therefore if
00:17:36 you're a comedian you're looking to mess around and you want a serious place in which you can
00:17:41 start to have misbehavior or you can start to be comic and so that's a natural place for a comedian
00:17:47 to go oh wouldn't it be funny if and therefore there was a joke on goodness gracious me which
00:17:52 is a joke which i think ofcom or somebody said you the bbc may never broadcast this joke ever again
00:17:58 which is where the indian couple the um who were desperate to be british um they turn up to a
00:18:06 communion ceremony and they get handed a wafer and one of them gets out some mango chutney and
00:18:12 puts it on top and eats the wafer and Anne Widdicombe as now a Catholic
00:18:17 actually says well this is the body of Christ and you can't you can't make a
00:18:21 joke about that which you get what's a perfectly decent joke I get that you
00:18:26 might be offended by it but it's not the worst joke in the world and it works as
00:18:29 a joke it's quite funny but you could but the joke only works because people
00:18:34 know that you sort of get handed a wafer at this communion service and they may
00:18:38 not understand what exactly refers to or how the Last Supper works or anything
00:18:43 like that. But the problem is if you want to make jokes about Islam then you need
00:18:48 to go okay so what does a Muslim service look like? What
00:18:54 happens? What happens when a Muslim is baptized or whatever their
00:18:59 equivalent of it is? What happens at a Muslim wedding or funeral? Well given
00:19:03 that Muslims are only a single digit percentage of the population most
00:19:07 people don't really know okay what about the story the famous stories in the
00:19:10 Quran how can we okay or any of them as well known as the nativity story for
00:19:14 example so you could do a funny nativity story but they're not and so the raw
00:19:18 material that you need for the comedy is actually not there and I think that is
00:19:24 much as I'm happy with conspiracy theories don't get me wrong I think on
00:19:28 this particular occasion that you just don't have enough so there's enough so
00:19:34 the 80s spitting image could make jokes about catholics and protestants because there was
00:19:38 essentially a war going on in northern ireland and so there were jokes about ian paisley um and there
00:19:43 were jokes about the you know they had his holiness the pope who was like a rock star wasn't he if you
00:19:47 remember the spitting image version of the pope um we can still just about do jokes like that
00:19:54 although anyone under 40 would find it mystifying i i think but if you want to do jokes about what's
00:20:00 the difference between a sunni and a shia well good luck finding a punchline for that that anyone
00:20:04 is going to know the answer to because most people don't know the difference the only things i mean
00:20:08 what therefore anything about that uh james is that you know there's a huge hit show at the
00:20:14 moment on in london it's been going for ages the book of mormons yes now this is a huge hit it's
00:20:19 mocking of the mormon church and whatever it's foul mouths all the rest of it um i would say that
00:20:25 basically majority people don't know very much about the mormon church yet it's still
00:20:30 mockable and it's still the butt of jokes i mean i i'm not quite sure i mean surely when when you
00:20:38 talk about it being basically talking about the need for common knowledge couldn't you also just
00:20:45 say that it's downright fear that basically if 12 people get murdered at charlie hebdo yes then
00:20:51 basically you're not going to make a joke i completely accept that um i think there is a
00:20:56 there's an element of Mormonism where there is probably enough in the ether for
00:21:00 there to be something to go on because and the show starts with somebody
00:21:03 knocking on your door the show starts with hello and and they kind of give you
00:21:08 enough information that you need to know about Mormonism in order to get the
00:21:11 jokes and if you propose to do the same with Islam then you would run into
00:21:19 problems for the exactly the reasons that you are suggesting so to say that
00:21:22 is no fear is obviously not credible um just not to say that people are cowards yes at all because
00:21:30 it's a possibly a realistic yeah response to the situation yeah absolutely so so i have some and
00:21:36 that's why i wrote the book is because we we we live in a world now where a joke that a joke can
00:21:42 be taken out either out of context or even within context nobody nobody misread the jokes in charlie
00:21:48 hebdo you know they they they were done exactly as they're intended to be and some people didn't
00:21:53 like them and in broad daylight went and shot you know 10 people 12 people who were actually involved
00:21:57 in the production of that magazine so never before have jokes been more serious they can end your
00:22:05 career uh they can end your you know there was at the time of recording as it were there was a very
00:22:11 recent spat over joe brand saying i was going to ask you about that actually i mean that's an
00:22:15 interesting point you know as a comedy writer should she have apologized she did apologize
00:22:19 for this this is when she talked about throwing battery acid over politicians i think uh i think
00:22:25 there's no guesses for who she was thinking of um no i think she ended up apologizing didn't she
00:22:32 yeah do you think she should have done i mean i don't think i think there are times when um
00:22:37 an apology you you know when people demand for an apology that that's never going to be enough
00:22:43 because the Twitch mob are really in full mode
00:22:47 and there's nothing you can say to duplicate the mob.
00:22:50 I think in her case, she can say, yeah, okay, fair enough.
00:22:53 If anything, the programme makers could probably have thought,
00:22:57 actually, maybe that one doesn't feel right for now.
00:23:00 But she's made jokes in the past about physical violence against men,
00:23:04 which in the context of her, her persona, her act,
00:23:09 the fact that generally people have paid money to go to a gig,
00:23:12 they know what they're getting within the context of the show she's joking and therefore because
00:23:18 but because it is extreme and she's a comedian we all get that it's a joke she's not advocating
00:23:22 violence so i think we can should should she apologize well maybe should people just grow
00:23:29 up a bit and realize she's obviously joking yeah i guess so too but i have some sympathy with those
00:23:36 who say she should apologise
00:23:38 because they're often the ones who are when they joke
00:23:42 they're told that they should apologise
00:23:44 so when a joke comes from a different political perspective
00:23:46 then that's the end of your career
00:23:49 but Jo Brand is probably
00:23:52 I think she's going to be alright
00:23:54 One thing actually that you mentioned
00:23:56 which is crucial
00:23:57 and that is that now
00:24:00 you say comedy has become very
00:24:01 well dangerous possibly
00:24:03 and that is because
00:24:04 you mentioned smartphones everyone has a smartphone right so the comedy goes out of the
00:24:11 context in which it was and it ends up being seen somewhere around the world or whatever
00:24:16 totally without context and bang the balloon can go up absolutely yeah and it's it's and that will
00:24:22 have consequences um and so you can record unbeknownst you know you can go to i think
00:24:28 louis ck had this when when he was sort of trying to inch his way back into being a member of the
00:24:34 human race he did a an after-hours gig and I think somebody recorded it and he
00:24:41 made it he made a joke about one of the guys he made a joke about some of the
00:24:45 kids who've been a victim of a mass shooting or something and so suddenly
00:24:50 everyone just thought only Louis CK is every bit as terrible a human being as
00:24:54 we thought he was all along despite the fact that he was a very famous very
00:24:58 well-paid very successful comedian for a very long time saying some very
00:25:02 challenging and troubling things very skillful comedian but that but it is
00:25:08 disingenuous to be in a situation where everybody knows you know we know who he
00:25:14 is we know what he said we're in it we're in a comedy show it's a late night
00:25:17 thing and he's going to say some things to then record it take it out of that
00:25:22 context and just say well is that acceptable so well and I might say in the
00:25:27 book and I say it a lot one of the least funny things on earth is a the
00:25:34 presenter of Newsnight reading back a joke that has been made to a comedian
00:25:39 who made it you know as if it's terrible being held up through tongs in your
00:25:44 so-called comedy set you joked you know blah blah blah blah blah and usually a
00:25:49 member of the lobby group who was professionally offended by this joke so
00:25:53 again at the time of recording recently there was another spat about the
00:25:57 funniest joke at this year's Edinburgh Fringe was was was a pun about the word
00:26:02 Tourette's and florets yeah you know somebody says the joke was along the
00:26:06 lines of I'm wandering around saying cauliflower and broccoli I think I've got
00:26:11 florets yes and pretty pretty tame yeah not to say name and so I talked about
00:26:18 this on you know as usual I normally get a phone call about this sort of thing
00:26:22 oh could you come on the radio program and talk about jokes and it and and so in the blurb it
00:26:28 said when somebody introduced it and they just said and tourette sufferers were um were offended
00:26:35 by this joke to which you immediately want to say do you know what i bet you loads of them weren't
00:26:40 but the head of the organization who is you know who are trying to help people with tourettes
00:26:46 has taken offense and is professionally offended and that's completely fine they're defending their
00:26:52 you know their corner and they're going to get their 15 minutes of of media coverage and that's
00:26:58 all fair play but you know you have these round table discussions where somebody who was offended
00:27:04 is also sitting there and suddenly this comedian who has done a joke in this context his joke has
00:27:09 been voted the funniest joke of the edinburgh fringe which of course it isn't it's you know
00:27:14 it's it's quite a good joke the second funny funniest joke at the edinburgh fringe was about
00:27:19 taking antidepressants and nobody seemed to mind about that one because it didn't win um and and so
00:27:27 so we have these discussions where the joke is then removed of its context it's read out in an
00:27:33 overlit news studio and please explain yourself you just think the skill of as you know comedy
00:27:41 happens in a time in a place with people and i really feel for comedians you know actual stand-up
00:27:46 comedians because their jokes have to be done out loud in front of people yes and something can seem
00:27:52 funny written down they all do try out nights they all have new material nights and the very
00:27:58 act of saying a joke they sort of don't know how it's going to go and the more experienced you get
00:28:04 the more stronger sense that you get but even strong comedians on new act nights will do
00:28:09 will do 50 jokes and five of them might survive and as a punter you might be watching it
00:28:16 listening to some of these jokes just going that's a terrible joke and you're really how could you
00:28:20 not know that that's such a bad joke but that's the process is so slippery so the very act of
00:28:25 doing the joke it has to be done in public and so for therefore to say oh you're a comedian are you
00:28:31 you know well this this could be interesting you're going to have to do all you're going to
00:28:34 have to do all of your practicing in public and if you make one single mistake we're going to end
00:28:40 your career good luck this would better be funny wow one thing actually uh about to finish really
00:28:47 one one thing i want to ask you particularly as a writer as a comedy writer is is that you write
00:28:55 characters you put words in their mouth it does not mean that you agree necessarily with what
00:29:01 they say that's the whole nature of creativity i would have thought yes if you take something such
00:29:05 as to death has to part johnny spate when he was writing that yeah alf garnett was writing it from
00:29:12 a quite a liberal position i think he was like mocking yeah but the thing is do you not feel
00:29:16 as a writer now that in fact these lines have become so blurred that actually if you even
00:29:21 write something for a character you will be pounced upon yeah by the twitchful mob yeah
00:29:28 as somehow or other you know believing the same thing or endorsing whatever you might write not
00:29:35 to you but any writer yeah this is a this is a real problem yeah i i think it is a problem
00:29:40 and i think to say my own sort of faith community i was guilty of this as everybody where they
00:29:47 assume that because i'm a christian i need to write characters who basically all say christian
00:29:50 things um and actually christians should know better because jesus tells parables about terrible
00:29:57 people doing terrible things and you can almost imagine jesus telling the parable of the good
00:30:01 Samaritan the most famous parable there is probably about you know a man goes on
00:30:05 a journey and some robbers grab him beat him take all his money and leave him for
00:30:10 dead and you can imagine people just going Jesus I think I think you're
00:30:15 glorifying violence I don't think you should be telling parables like that and
00:30:19 actually the people who tell Jesus off for the things that he says funny enough
00:30:23 are religious people and isn't it funny but it is funny that who actually has
00:30:28 jesus killed oh that's right religious people you know it's kind of you know it couldn't get any
00:30:33 funnier in a really dark sort of way um which is why my sort of theory that easter easter and good
00:30:38 friday are actually funny but people do have a terrible time understanding that so in bluestone
00:30:45 42 bomb disposal in afghanistan all of these soldiers swear a lot that's how they talk you
00:30:52 shouldn't you shouldn't talk like that i don't i don't want to talk like that and i would tell
00:30:56 my kids not to talk like that but that's how they talk about that and for and when a when a bomb
00:31:01 goes off near you you don't say oh dear that's just not how people talk it's not real so your
00:31:08 obligation as a comedian as actually as a christian i would say is to tell the truth
00:31:13 and i often then would say to you well if you're offended by the language for example you're
00:31:19 offended by some of the things that happen within the show well that's good you should be offended
00:31:26 by things actually if you're if you're offended by something it proves you're paying attention
00:31:30 it proves you're alive it proves that you've still got critical faculties so actually being
00:31:36 it's like it's like touching something and discovering that it's hot but it shouldn't
00:31:40 actually give you particular rights necessarily no yeah we shouldn't you you i mean i think
00:31:44 sometimes people that they've been either assaulted by being offended or that within a religious
00:31:49 context that they haven't been in some way made unclean or tainted by it and actually that's not
00:31:54 the case um just something has happened that you don't like yes and therefore you don't need to
00:32:01 ascribe poor motives to the person who said it or did it they don't necessarily need to apologize
00:32:06 it's just maybe unintended collateral of this is what life in this is what life in a country of
00:32:12 65 million people looks like in an always-on social media culture um it's not possible to
00:32:19 make a joke in a room of i would say more than 10 people which couldn't be either willfully
00:32:23 misconstrued or correctly construed that doesn't you know you could do a joke about somebody in a
00:32:30 car and someone can say well I actually had a very serious car accident or my sister had a very
00:32:36 serious car accident a week ago and I'm not so well you ought to know that of course not so I
00:32:41 think people are people assume that they have a right to live in a society where they are never
00:32:46 offended and and that is insane it's unrealistic but also unnecessary because when we're offended
00:32:55 by something when we see something happening when we're offended by a story where the good
00:33:01 guy is suddenly behaving in the wrong way and I'm I'm worried you can watch you know
00:33:06 it's a wonderful life wow what an incredible movie and people have got this chocolate box
00:33:13 image of that movie in their mind it gets really dark and when James Stewart starts yelling at his
00:33:19 kids oh my goodness you're really just like oh blimey this is this is really dark and but you
00:33:26 need to go to those dark places in order to find the light you know you need you know that that is
00:33:31 the context in which these things are happening so I think this idea that you know no one should
00:33:37 be you know I should never be offended I was offended by that and therefore you should
00:33:40 apologize it's like those statements are not as closely connected as you think they are i think
00:33:46 don't you think that the problems well is that for writers actually for writers for anyone doing
00:33:52 anything creative uh essentially there is the possible temptation just to simply self-censor
00:33:59 i mean you think actually why i give myself brief you know it's going to be offended by that
00:34:05 they're going to be offended they're going to be offended you know i might want to do it and that
00:34:09 is a real problem i think it's very dark in that yeah i think well actually i wonder if um i mean
00:34:16 i think writers and comedians particularly do do are fairly attracted to things that are quite
00:34:20 subversive or potentially offensive but then i think there's an element of second guessing that
00:34:24 goes on when it comes to selecting ideas or and but it's interesting isn't it that the most
00:34:28 profitable um forms of broadcasting at the moment are streaming services and they're doing some very
00:34:35 strange and troubling and challenging things like you know you know chernobyl or um you know
00:34:41 netflix series that do do seem to be very um uh very subversive so actually people people are
00:34:49 prepared to watch things with very very adult themes and be treated like grown-ups um but it
00:34:56 is i think the you know the i think it was david frost who said that the you know television
00:35:03 allows you to be entertained by people in your living room
00:35:05 that you wouldn't allow in the house.
00:35:08 And therefore, there is an element of,
00:35:11 I've switched on the TV and suddenly someone said this thing
00:35:13 and I wasn't really prepared for that.
00:35:14 So there is an emotional kind of hit
00:35:18 that then makes you feel rather angry.
00:35:21 And then the other thing, though,
00:35:24 and this is why social media creates this vortex,
00:35:25 I was doing a panel on this recently at the Greenbelt Festival
00:35:28 and Elf Lyons was a comedian who was taking part in it.
00:35:31 She made a really good point that when you sit there watching something on TV,
00:35:36 10, 15 years ago, you would have been offended by something
00:35:40 and just thought, oh, I don't, oh, that's not right.
00:35:44 And then you'd have stopped watching it, turned it off, had a bath and gone to bed.
00:35:49 And forgotten about it, yeah, yeah.
00:35:50 And then next morning, you know, probably you've forgotten about it
00:35:53 or someone might mention it and you go, oh, yeah, I saw that thing and that was that.
00:35:56 But now you're offended by it.
00:35:58 Twitter, I'm offended by this.
00:36:00 Oh, other people are offended by it.
00:36:01 Oh, there's a hashtag.
00:36:02 Oh, we might end someone's career here.
00:36:05 Oh, that's great.
00:36:06 And social media, unfortunately,
00:36:08 rewards outrage and rewards anger
00:36:11 because you sort of can't really challenge anger and offence in a way.
00:36:16 Just saying to somebody, get over it, seems quite unkind.
00:36:21 I mean, sometimes it is.
00:36:23 But actually, that is the right response occasionally.
00:36:27 I think probably the moral to that story
00:36:29 is to stay away from the black mirror.
00:36:31 isn't it stay away from the black screen yeah simple as that yeah and thank you so much coming
00:36:37 on i'm going to mention again your book the latest book the sacred art of joking it's got a lot of
00:36:44 very very interesting discussions in it thanks very very much for coming on and uh all the very
00:36:49 very best of the future thank you very very much for watching do subscribe please keep subscribing
00:36:55 and we will see you next time thank you
00:37:01 Thank you.