New Culture Forum - September 29, 2019


S2.03 Martin Durkin: Media Bias & Brexit Snobbery

S2 02: James Cary - Comedy, Religion & The New Morality. S2,04 Sir James Macmillan: Scotland's Great Composer on his Influences: Faith, Heritage & Tradition

Episode Stats


Length

33 minutes

Words per minute

173.56

Word count

5,867

Sentence count

101


Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
00:00:00 Hello and welcome to So What You're Saying Is, I'm Peter Whittle. Now my guest today is one of the
00:00:23 most distinctive voices in the current broadcasting scene. Martin Durkin is a producer, director and
00:00:30 writer. You might remember a few years ago at the time of the referendum a film called Brexit
00:00:35 the movie. It was extremely influential for many people. He made that but over the years as well
00:00:42 he's turned his attention to such subjects as GM crops and Britain's horrific debt and indeed
00:00:49 climate change and the environmentalist industry he's with me now martin thank you very very much
00:00:55 for coming in thank you it's a pleasure pleasure lovely to see you again and you um you've actually
00:01:01 got a new project coming out haven't you you're actually doing a program about gun culture in
00:01:07 america at the moment yeah we're making in fact i'm working on two big feature documentaries at
00:01:12 the moment one about guns and freedom in america yeah the story of you know how they're linked
00:01:18 and one on race, again, in America, so both American-focused.
00:01:23 So why the American focus?
00:01:25 I mean, how does that work, Martin?
00:01:26 Have you been commissioned by people there to do these, or what?
00:01:30 No, we're doing some crowdfunding,
00:01:33 but generally I'm just getting the money together
00:01:37 from anywhere I can to make the films.
00:01:40 It's slightly, you know, over there,
00:01:42 I suppose I could try to approach broadcasters and say,
00:01:45 how about letting me do a couple of really big noisy scandalous films but
00:01:49 that takes a lot of time and it's very hard to persuade them so these days
00:01:53 because of the internet and so on you know it's it's the old power of the
00:01:57 gate creeper keepers creepers I should call them gate creepers
00:02:00 have crumbled and you can do your own thing so that's what I'm doing
00:02:04 with you say it's sort of crumbling this is a fascinating thing and there's
00:02:11 crowdfunding and all the rest of it I mean you presumably started in
00:02:15 television at a time when it was much more if you like sort of regulated in
00:02:22 the sense that you went to a commissioning editor and all the rest
00:02:26 and then basically had to get the funding from that and then you went off
00:02:29 and made the film isn't that how it happens that's exactly right which was
00:02:32 obviously very hard if you happen to be sort of like the libertarian leaning in
00:02:37 your in your views because you've got to slot in with the views of the the
00:02:41 institution that you're pitching to so the BBC I always had great difficulty
00:02:45 getting anything away with I did do a film for the BBC once but the crack
00:02:52 came with the with Channel 4 I mean Channel 4 we I did a few quite a few
00:02:58 films with Channel 4 of course was set up by Margaret Thatcher and part of the
00:03:01 remit of Channel 4 was to be counter-cultural and to go against the
00:03:06 prevailing wisdom and so they had to take films from people who didn't sort
00:03:11 of quite fit in. Channel 4 has historically been and is today very much
00:03:15 very left-leaning, very woke as it you know is as we call it these days but
00:03:22 there was in the past some sort of sympathetic commissioning editors in
00:03:28 there who would countenance having kind of radical films which didn't fit in
00:03:32 with that and so I got a few opportunities. Has that changed? I mean you say that in those days
00:03:41 you got people who were would take a chance or whatever do you do you think do you think
00:03:46 that the perception that the the media world in which you operate has become more closed if you
00:03:55 like has become less tolerant of you do you think that's a real perception an honest one do you
00:04:00 think it's one that is right? Totally honest I mean totally it's absolutely
00:04:05 right you know the BBC is an organisation which represents the views
00:04:13 of the people who work at the BBC you know the pro-state big tax big
00:04:19 regulating views of the new class who work there and likewise with Channel 4
00:04:26 it's not I mean it's it's not even you know I wouldn't even say it's an open
00:04:31 secret it's not a secret you know everyone at Channel 4 knows what Channel
00:04:35 4 does everyone the BBC knows that you know where no way in the world are they
00:04:40 going to do a film on the BBC saying the theory of climate change is nonsense no
00:04:47 way are they going to do a you know a countenance doing a pro-Brexit film or
00:04:53 anything like that it's it's it's very clear that that's what the mainstream
00:04:57 media is. Well with your your movie Brexit the movie I went to the premiere of
00:05:03 that that was a big premiere in Leicester Square I remember if I remember it might
00:05:06 even have been the week or the week before the actual referendum that was
00:05:10 something that you you basically raised the funding for yourself and did you
00:05:15 not and I mean and that went out in cinemas didn't it? No we did the big
00:05:21 Bash in Leicester Square which was great great fun and then we put it on the
00:05:26 internet and it got I don't it went out on a few different platforms I think it
00:05:31 got approaching 8 million hits something like that I'm sure they didn't all watch
00:05:35 the whole of the film but you know hopefully enough of them watched enough
00:05:39 of it that it had it had an effect. Well let's just actually just take a
00:05:43 brief look at it now before we go on this is a clip from Brexit the movie from
00:05:48 2016.
00:05:49 The EU, s'il vous plaît.
00:05:56 Straight off, there's a snag.
00:06:01 On my quest to understand the EU, my first challenge is to find it.
00:06:05 There are over 90 EU buildings here in Brussels, and a load more in Strasbourg and Luxembourg.
00:06:13 As impressive as the modernist buildings is the number of directorates, councils, commissions
00:06:17 and ministries which occupy it. But here the EU slips its first cog. For a democracy to
00:06:24 function there needs to be transparency. Martin, would you ever consider doing a film,
00:06:32 here we are three and a half years later, would you ever consider doing a film, is it
00:06:36 the sort of thing you would do looking at all the things that have happened since and
00:06:40 the state we now find ourselves in? I'd be really tempting because in fact I think
00:06:45 make a very different film to Brexit the movie because things are so much clearer and I think
00:06:50 the battle for Brexit the nature of the struggle it has become you know much more clear you know
00:06:57 before it was oh should we be part of the EU should we not be part of the EU now I think it's
00:07:02 it's much more clearly a class struggle the the class lines are drawn and on one on the one hand
00:07:10 you have people who are very much part of the establishment, people who are members of, you know,
00:07:19 who are in the public sector or who are members of organisations that are paid for out of taxation,
00:07:23 whose jobs depend on regulating the lives of others and they are enormously keen on Europe.
00:07:31 They're part of the, you know, the arts establishment, the university establishment.
00:07:35 well you can tell you know when you go to a party say who's likely to be Brexit and who's not likely
00:07:40 to be Brexit if you if you bump into a second-hand car dealer from Essex they are likely to be
00:07:45 Brexit you know if you bump into a sociology lecturer from Hackney they are likely to be
00:07:50 remain you know we know what that division is and we know that essentially this is a clash between
00:07:57 two sets of people with two ideas one set of people who think that the guardians the experts
00:08:03 should be in charge of us and they should have the real power and they love the EU because that
00:08:08 is their project and the rest of us who would rather not be taxed so much and who thinks that
00:08:14 you know perhaps we should control our own lives and obviously that's historically very strong in
00:08:19 Britain which is why we're the belligerent ones in the EU you know that the nature of that struggle
00:08:24 I think is much clearer now than it was three years ago. But it seems to me now that there is
00:08:29 this kind of you know a bit like in America they've got Trump derangement syndrome whatever
00:08:32 you think about trump that you know i was there recently and there is just totally irrational
00:08:37 inability to even talk about it i feel it's not unlike that with brexit here that you know i mean
00:08:44 we're doing recording this in london and london is a remain a city uh you work in what is must
00:08:51 is a remainer industry isn't it without question do you find that that there is this kind of just
00:08:57 you know people are beside themselves with anger about it I mean I I found
00:09:02 that you know you talk about class there have been all sorts of things have
00:09:05 re-emerged and not least of all good old fashioned snobbery for example oh yeah
00:09:11 no I mean the snobbish Remainers you know it's what an absolute you know
00:09:15 phenomenon that is I know it's an entirely right I mean they you know the
00:09:23 media is you know an utterly remain industry and the vitriol the absolute sort of you know
00:09:34 their eyes glow red and their tails lash they're absolutely furious and it sort of makes me
00:09:39 delighted in a way because I realised what a huge blow the Brexit vote was to this class
00:09:47 you know they thought they had things stitched up that you know we're drifting towards the
00:09:51 the EU is full of jobs and grants and the general ethos is that of those sorts of people
00:09:58 being in charge through their various organisations and institutions. The intelligentsia, the largely
00:10:06 state-funded intelligentsia, it's their project and it was an expression of their power and
00:10:12 we have just kicked a great hole beneath the waterline and they are, you know, it's almost
00:10:18 an existential assault on them you know it is awful the oiks the deplorables you know are up
00:10:24 and at it you know and and um so the angrier they get in a way the more delighted we should be yeah
00:10:30 i mean it is they've basically had things their own way isn't that what it is i mean and essentially
00:10:36 suddenly they've been challenged yeah the natives are suddenly uh you know uh are taking over and
00:10:43 I mean, Martin, you know, you mentioned being a class thing, you know, to make an obvious segue, maybe, but politically you've been, you know, you started off as pretty much a class-based political activist, didn't you? You were a Marxist for quite a while.
00:11:00 Marxist for many years.
00:11:02 How many years? I mean, when were you talking, like, from teenage to what, Adam?
00:11:05 Yeah, sort of from, you know, 14, 15, I was, I think, a very young, underage secretary of the Labour Party,
00:11:12 young socialists in South Shields, and a member of the Militant Tendency, and all of that sort of thing,
00:11:17 got involved in trot organisations, I mean, just, I was involved in all of that until my 30s,
00:11:24 and then it was really making a series about environmentalism that made me turn,
00:11:31 because I realised then that actually these supposed radicals
00:11:35 weren't in favour of ordinary people at all.
00:11:37 In fact, they were quite appalled by ordinary people becoming better off.
00:11:42 I realised that selling left-wing mags outside Brixton tube
00:11:46 and all that sort of thing, I did the works,
00:11:49 that ordinary working-class people weren't interested in buying this nonsense
00:11:54 about how communism was just the best thing ever.
00:11:58 They had far too much sense.
00:11:59 it was middle class students who were interested in this and slowly it dawned on me the nature of
00:12:05 the green movement the kind of constituency for this politics that it wasn't in fact
00:12:10 the politics of ordinary people being more powerful and better off you know the
00:12:16 socialism had meant to be about the liberation and enrichment of ordinary people but actually
00:12:23 greater state power
00:12:25 involves the opposite
00:12:26 and in fact the Greens
00:12:28 of course who proclaim themselves
00:12:31 to be radical loathe people getting richer
00:12:32 they say we are all consuming too much
00:12:34 Gaia can't cope with us consuming too much
00:12:37 and the form of consumption they hate most
00:12:39 is mass consumption, industrial mass consumption
00:12:41 well of course mass consumption goes with
00:12:43 mass production
00:12:45 this is the very thing that has made ordinary
00:12:47 people better off
00:12:48 spectacularly better off over the last
00:12:51 hundred years and so this notion that we're going to go back to handicraft production
00:12:55 actually is these are the whims of well-off people who are actually repelled by the prosperity
00:13:04 of ordinary people that capitalism has brought so in a sense I've kept the class analysis
00:13:10 but it's kind of flipped I feel like I'm more on the side of ordinary people today than I was when
00:13:17 was a filthy Marxist on that point I mean I think it seems to me as well that with the
00:13:23 some of the environmentalist movement uh it's not just a class thing it's a sort of almost
00:13:28 humanity hating thing I think they actually sort of don't particularly seem to like people before
00:13:34 we talk more about it we're going to take a look at a clip this is from Martin's film
00:13:38 the great global warming swindle
00:13:40 man-made global warming is no longer just a theory about climate it is one of the defining
00:13:48 moral and political causes of our age campaigners say the time for debate is over any criticism no
00:13:54 matter how scientifically rigorous is illegitimate even worse dangerous but in this film it will be
00:14:02 shown that there is nothing unusual about the current temperature that the earth's climate is
00:14:07 always changing, though the scientific evidence does not support the notion that climate is
00:14:12 driven by carbon dioxide. You must have ruffled a head of a lot of feathers with that particular
00:14:20 film. Yeah, they got really cross at that. We had lots of Ofcom complaints and it took
00:14:28 a long time to handle that. It was very, very bad news. But, you know, nevertheless,
00:14:37 These are arguments that are never really put.
00:14:40 They're certainly not put now, are they?
00:14:43 I mean, do you sort of make enemies, if you like, in your industry
00:14:47 by doing these films?
00:14:50 Do people actually sort of like, oh, there's Martin Durkin, you know, whatever?
00:14:54 They do. I mean, not the people who know me.
00:14:56 I think when people get to know me, they usually think,
00:14:58 oh, my goodness, I thought you were a total devil, but really you're just...
00:15:01 You're gorgeous, really.
00:15:03 but there is a lot of
00:15:07 they really do hate it
00:15:10 when you
00:15:11 well you know it
00:15:13 I'm sure you get an awful lot of it as well
00:15:15 I mean the intelligentsia
00:15:16 metropolitan intelligentsia
00:15:17 they might look all nice and polite
00:15:20 but they can be really nasty
00:15:22 I don't mind it so much
00:15:25 my missus really
00:15:26 it hits her hard
00:15:28 I feel I can take it
00:15:31 you go out for a fight
00:15:32 you're a fighter yourself
00:15:33 So, you know, but you know what it's like when it comes back at you.
00:15:38 Oh, yes, yes.
00:15:40 You, though, actually put yourself very much at the forefront of your work.
00:15:44 I mean, you know, I would say the best things,
00:15:47 because I have to add, obviously, that you've done loads of different things
00:15:50 and great programmes with Brian Sewell, who I used to know, and things like that.
00:15:54 You know, so there's a huge amount of work you do.
00:15:56 But in these big set pieces, Martin, you are very much there, aren't you?
00:16:00 I mean, you know, people have called you Michael Moore or kind of Michael Moore of the what,
00:16:06 I don't know, of the right or the libertarian right or whatever,
00:16:09 but you're very much the author of some of these films, aren't you?
00:16:14 Well, that grew in, that happened accidentally because I was doing films for Channel 4 way back when,
00:16:21 however many years ago now, very old, 20 years ago, whatever,
00:16:24 and it was the lawyers said actually that I have to be in the films because it makes the point that
00:16:33 it's a polemical film because if you're not in then it becomes voice of God and then we get
00:16:38 more complaints so if I'm in then it's obviously a point of view film and so I was sort of sucked
00:16:45 in rather like that yes not that I'm not sort of utterly gorgeous and deserve to be on telly anyway
00:16:50 How long have you been in television generally Martin? Has it always been your career or
00:16:58 did you do other things before?
00:16:59 I was in print before, print journalist before TV and then sort of accidentally sort of fell
00:17:07 into TV and never particularly liked it and then sort of got stuck and I kept making,
00:17:13 I think possibly because I never particularly wanted to be in TV, I kept making films that
00:17:17 I didn't mind if it was the last film I made so not caring whether you have a continued
00:17:23 career in TV is totally necessary I think if you're a libertarian because it is it's
00:17:30 very you know it's an industry where you know it's not very friendly to libertarian arguments
00:17:35 so you kind of know you've got to have a sort of death wish in order to do these films.
00:17:41 Is that what you would actually call yourself now a libertarian is that if someone said
00:17:44 what are you politically is that's what you are is it now yeah I mean I think I
00:17:48 mean having said that I'm sure there are you know libertarians like Richard
00:17:52 Wellings who is who would probably say oh I think I'm not sure that fits
00:17:56 libertarian and that bit libertarian but broadly speaking you know I think that's
00:18:00 I mean broadly speaking I would say you're a libertarian I don't know
00:18:03 whether you would deny that I think I probably it's one of those things now
00:18:07 I don't even quite know actually what it means because it seems to me so many
00:18:12 different things to different people i wouldn't say i'm economically libertarian no i quite like
00:18:16 institutions for example or rather i did like them until brexit but uh you know i mean i think
00:18:22 one thing you mentioned the the industry there and what people uh what people think of people
00:18:29 on the right or libertarian um of all the people who get in touch with me having seen this show
00:18:35 for example um a lot of young people obviously talented particularly want to do what you do
00:18:41 They want to be in TV or filmmaking.
00:18:44 They want to do things, whether it's fiction or whether it is drama,
00:18:50 but from a different perspective.
00:18:54 What should they do?
00:18:56 It's very hard to tell them.
00:18:58 Should they steer clear of the mainstream media now?
00:19:01 What should they do?
00:19:02 I think they should get their funds out with their 4G, 5G,
00:19:07 whatever the thing is and start to make films and these days you can get a laptop with a
00:19:16 bit of editing kit, edit the thing together, shove it up and just start absolutely from
00:19:21 the ground up. I mean these days the barrier is not the cost of technology which is really
00:19:26 good. The barrier is how good will the film be? Have you got something to say? And obviously
00:19:33 you've got to kind of work out the best way of saying it. You've got to have a sense
00:19:36 of theatre and you've got to have a sense of structure and all that kind of thing but essentially
00:19:40 there are fewer barriers than there ever were before so I'd encourage everyone to you know
00:19:47 you know just dive in. So it's not really a question I mean you know I used to be in television
00:19:53 myself and you used to go into ITV or wherever it was and you said right start at the bottom as a
00:20:00 gopher and work your way up become a researcher and all that's it that's not the way really to
00:20:05 do it anymore? I mean there's still an element of that but I think they're not mutually exclusive
00:20:10 you know you can always try and get into and the independent sector is very big as well and I think
00:20:14 that's also a good route so you don't necessarily have to be a you know BBC trainee as it used to
00:20:19 be as a way in you know you can you know hustle your way into an independent much more easily
00:20:26 than you can one of the bigger institutions you know you ring someone up saying please can I come
00:20:31 and say, can I work for free for a week?
00:20:32 And then you turn up early and you leave late
00:20:35 and you make sure you make everyone cups of tea.
00:20:37 You know, you just hustle your way in.
00:20:39 The nice thing about the industry as it's changed
00:20:42 is it's become more of a kind of hustler's industry.
00:20:46 Hustler's the word I want.
00:20:51 You made Brexit the movie three years ago
00:20:55 and you talked about, you know, what's happened
00:20:57 and the the the anger of the elites if you like uh how do you how has it changed your attitude say
00:21:06 to this country or has it what we've seen happening over the past three years has it
00:21:13 changed the way you look at britain um it's made me excited i mean i've i'm i mean a lover of
00:21:22 history like yourself you know i think britain is a completely great place because there's a
00:21:29 profound love of freedom here which a lot of countries don't have which a lot of countries on
00:21:33 the continental europe don't get because there's not such a healthy tradition of it you know there's
00:21:38 a real tradition of ordinary people having a you know a passionate disdain for bureaucracy and
00:21:46 intellectuals and and so on and so forth which i think is is really good and and i think that that's
00:21:51 been reviving in recent decades we're much more entrepreneurial I think than we were in the 1950s
00:21:58 1960s and 70s you know young kids now you know that and the whole of universities is crumbling
00:22:05 young kids are just wondering well do they really need to go and do these courses maybe they're just
00:22:09 going to set up a little company or do this or do I'll go straight into a job you know so many
00:22:13 things are going in the right direction and Brexit was such a result I mean obviously it's a battle
00:22:18 that hasn't been resolved yet but I'm hoping that a kind of a really freedom-loving kind of
00:22:29 dare I say more Sacherite Britain might emerge from this I'm not sure that I wouldn't like to
00:22:35 see Scottish independence because I think that would do the Scots a world of good as well I
00:22:40 think if the Scots had to actually survive on their own money rather than sucking up
00:22:43 up welfare from someone else you know actually that would sort of um get a reality check is what
00:22:48 what Scotland needs um uh and also it would mean that Britain is England and Wales Northern Ireland
00:22:57 um is much more likely to I'd love us to become Switzerland you know without that without the
00:23:03 music you mentioned their universities and how uh young people thinking what should I bother to go
00:23:12 whatever you know huge debt at the end of it but also there's something else that's happening
00:23:18 we've discussed on this program which is that um you know almost regardless of the money side of
00:23:23 things uh you know many people think that the humanities particularly are sort of almost beyond
00:23:28 help now and uh you know that essentially young people should just go out and read books for
00:23:35 themselves read the classics for themselves and circumvent the whole thing you know yeah no i
00:23:40 think completely I think it's hideous this idea that you have to go through
00:23:43 this layer this sort of set institution at a certain time in your life in order
00:23:48 to qualify for the rest of your life when you know so often you know you're
00:23:53 not learning anything particularly useful at all is at a time in your life
00:23:56 when you know you're not you're actually more interested in you know chasing
00:24:01 people around in order to kiss them and you know drink lots of beer or do
00:24:04 whatever else do they do these days I've not learned you know it's it's I would
00:24:10 love to just stick a bomb under these institutions they seem for the most I
00:24:13 mean a lot of them the commercial side I can see if you want to learn about
00:24:17 mechanical engineering if you want to build a bridge if you want to know about
00:24:20 hotel management or that sort of thing those sorts of courses are really useful
00:24:24 and they produce people usually who are you know fairly sensible the arts courses
00:24:29 which aren't remotely useful for the most part
00:24:32 and just produce more protesters on climate marches
00:24:37 and all that kind of thing.
00:24:38 I just think, what a waste of time.
00:24:41 You started by talking about the fact that you love
00:24:45 the fact that we've become more entrepreneurial and whatever
00:24:47 and this is something that's definitely a good thing.
00:24:51 I mentioned in the introduction
00:24:53 Thatcher, Death of a Revolutionary
00:24:56 which is, I think, one of my favourite films that you made,
00:25:00 and you feature in that too.
00:25:01 Let's just take a quick look at a clip of Thatcher's death of a revolutionary.
00:25:07 There are so many things that she did that people say they wouldn't reverse,
00:25:12 and yet she still hated.
00:25:15 Where there is no rationale for changing a main avenue of policy,
00:25:22 why change it? There's absolutely no point in doing it.
00:25:26 I mean, Mrs Thatcher didn't denationalise...
00:25:28 So she was right?
00:25:30 No, she wasn't right.
00:25:32 What her friends and enemies seemed to agree on
00:25:34 is that the Thatcher Revolution, as it became known,
00:25:38 changed Britain forever.
00:25:40 I was someone who grew up in the 1980s and watched what she did,
00:25:44 very difficult decisions, and, as I said,
00:25:46 she was absolutely on the right side of the big arguments,
00:25:49 and, in a way, the biggest legacy and testament to her
00:25:52 was that the governments that came after her,
00:25:55 Even though there were Labour governments that had complained bitterly about what she had done, they kept what she had done.
00:26:02 Martin, in that film, the basic thesis of it is that Thatcher was actually an extraordinary radical for working class people.
00:26:11 And, you know, you've got these great pieces in it where you see quotes from the intelligentsia of the time,
00:26:18 Jonathan Miller and Lady Warnock and people like this, and the things they said about Thatcher.
00:26:23 you know um you know extraordinary but she just she didn't care didn't she that was that was the
00:26:29 wonderful thing about there's a wonderful clip in it where you're interviewing kinnock and uh
00:26:34 saying what would you change back you know if you you know he was leader of the opposition
00:26:38 what would you change back from what thatcher did and he just is silent isn't he he's just quiet he
00:26:44 can't he's he's got no answer yes i find it's very easy to beat in in arguments um
00:26:52 well Neil Kinnick but also a lot of socialists in general and members of the intelligentsia
00:27:00 on the subject of Brexit or climate change because by and large they're never challenged
00:27:05 you know they have control of for the most part the media they have they read their newspapers
00:27:13 they talk to each other they you know inhabit their world and they're rarely does anyone
00:27:20 come and just state the bleeding obvious to them and when you do do that they often as neil kinnick
00:27:27 look as if someone's just pulled the plug out yes with the films that you're doing now or about
00:27:33 you know that you're about to do you mentioned about the gun culture and also about race is that
00:27:37 right you know are these going to be authored films they will be they will be you can you tell
00:27:44 us anything about how you're going to approach them or not or is that not fair yes i mean the
00:27:49 The guns film is going to be pro-gun, it's going to be a defence of the Second Amendment
00:27:55 and it's going to say that the argument is essentially a question of where sovereignty
00:27:59 lies rather like Brexit, should the state have a monopoly of force or should ordinary
00:28:04 people have the right to be armed and it will go into history to show how the popular possession
00:28:14 of guns absolutely is tied up with individual freedom and the attempts to deny the right
00:28:22 of ordinary people to be armed is entirely connected with tyrannical government. And
00:28:28 it looks at America today, it looks at the ownership of guns, the problem of the murder
00:28:34 rate, who's shooting who and why and all the circumstances around it. But I've no doubt
00:28:40 I'll get a good kicking for... I was going to say it's been a bit of a hard sell shortly at the moment
00:28:44 I mean I would have thought. Well I I mean you might think so but I don't think so I think it's
00:28:50 a really strong argument about guns if you look at the the murders that go on in America the the
00:29:00 people killed by guns the atrocities form it although utterly awful form a tiny tiny tiny
00:29:07 percent by 0.1 of a percent of people killed by guns in America and atrocities happen all over
00:29:14 the world so in fact you know you can't simply link either that association is is is not
00:29:19 straightforward the um and where gun ownership is really strong in say Missouri you often have a
00:29:26 you know a tiny murder rate you know it's sort of lower than Cornwall you know it's sort of it's
00:29:30 that's not where the problem is happening the problem is happening in the welfare areas of
00:29:36 America where everything is broken down to such an extent that you know the drug economy has taken
00:29:42 off you know illegal economic activity where no contract will do and so violence comes over and
00:29:49 in those circumstances you know you will the murder rate is awful and you know among African
00:29:56 Americans the murder rate is up so but actually if you scratch the surface that's really the welfare
00:30:00 problem if you if you the welfare problem is awful in america it's awful in a lot of countries but
00:30:07 it's it's it's particularly bad in the u.s among those and really you know you've got to strip away
00:30:13 that problem but ultimately you know the question is where does sovereignty lie and um i think this
00:30:18 is an aspect of the the gun issue that people in britain don't quite get or they don't appreciate
00:30:24 is they think it's sort of like an issue maybe i don't know like fox hunting or something here
00:30:28 but it's really a principle thing isn't it it goes right to the heart of
00:30:33 absolutely profound in America because the very basis of it was you know the
00:30:38 attempt by the British crown to take the guns off ordinary Americans because you
00:30:43 know you can't keep people down if if they're armed that is one throughout the
00:30:50 Middle Ages the serfs were not armed and the serfs were kept in place but as soon
00:30:54 as you have a population with guns you cannot keep them down this was the
00:31:00 anti-slavers were very keen on the Second Amendment because they knew that if
00:31:04 African Americans got guns you could slavery would die yeah you can and in
00:31:09 fact gun ownership played a huge part in the civil rights movement the long
00:31:16 civil rights movement in America because it was when blacks got guns that really
00:31:21 the problem started in the south and they couldn't and that connection went right through to the
00:31:30 civil rights movement in the middle of the century you know Rosa Parks you know was very confident
00:31:35 that she wasn't going to get messed with actually because everyone in town knew that her father
00:31:41 had a lot of guns no one was going to mess with the Parks because you know he wasn't going to put
00:31:45 up with it and that and in a lot of places in the south the clan would come riding into town and
00:31:53 then suddenly be confronted with a lot of African Americans with guns prepared to use them and
00:31:58 that's what stopped the clan going into towns so there's a and even today if you look at
00:32:05 attitudes towards gun ownership there's much they're much more positive people are very much
00:32:11 more pro-gun within the african-american community than in the white i hate all the black and white
00:32:21 this is going to be uh this is going to be a feature-length film yeah okay um i think we've
00:32:27 got a link actually we can give people uh i think it's you've got a kickstarter or something which
00:32:32 you can we have and a wonderful trailer with some because we've done some of the interviews already
00:32:36 with some great people like larry elder and walter williams and a whole whole bunch of people who
00:32:42 are fantastic interviewees and with your other films if people want to see them martin like
00:32:48 you know we've got i've got being so terribly old-fashioned i have them on d on uh dvd here
00:32:54 we've got the great global warming swindle this one and then a wonderful one britain's trillion
00:32:59 horror story which does
00:33:01 actually change the way you look
00:33:02 at the future
00:33:04 but these can be seen online is that right
00:33:07 as well can they?
00:33:08 I think they're online
00:33:11 I think they've been pumping pirated and shoved online
00:33:13 so go and watch the pirated
00:33:15 version of the line, I think the DVD
00:33:17 is revealed through Amazon as well
00:33:19 Right, okay
00:33:19 well Martin thank you very very much, all the very best
00:33:23 with the new films
00:33:24 thank you very much for coming on today
00:33:26 Peter thank you so much for having me and good to see you again
00:33:28 great uh thanks so much for watching so what you're saying is please remember to subscribe
00:33:34 i say every week but that's because i mean it um see you next time thank you