New Culture Forum - November 16, 2019


S2,04 Sir James Macmillan: Scotland's Great Composer on his Influences: Faith, Heritage & Tradition

S2.03 Martin Durkin: Media Bias & Brexit Snobbery S2.10 Theodore Dalrymple: Britain's Vanishing Culture & Character

Episode Stats


Length

33 minutes

Words per minute

152.63

Word count

5,046

Sentence count

157


Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
00:00:00 Hello and welcome to So What You're Saying Is, I'm Peter Whittle. Now I'm delighted that this week
00:00:21 my guest is somebody who has been called Britain's greatest living classical composer.
00:00:27 Sir James Macmillan, in an extraordinary career, has produced symphonies, choral work, opera, concerto.
00:00:35 This year, his fifth symphony was premiered at the Edinburgh Festival.
00:00:39 He's also well known to the readers of such publications as Standpoint and Spectator,
00:00:45 where he's written very eloquently about art and politics.
00:00:49 Welcome. Thank you very much, James, for coming.
00:00:52 It's a special year this year, isn't it? It's your sixth year.
00:00:56 That's right.
00:00:57 And this has been marked in the musical world, hasn't it?
00:00:59 It has. It feels a bit like being the Queen, actually.
00:01:03 Every day seems to be a birthday.
00:01:05 And the Edinburgh Festival, as you've indicated, put a big focus on me this year
00:01:11 and there's been various things like that at home and abroad.
00:01:14 So I've been very busy and travelling and writing a lot too.
00:01:18 And you've also produced a book, haven't you?
00:01:21 Yes, to mark my 60th birthday, I've written a very short collection of reflections.
00:01:27 I use things that have happened in my life as a starting point
00:01:31 and then begin to reflect on issues that arise from them,
00:01:37 mainly about music, but not only religion, some politics,
00:01:41 I'm a little careful about that sometimes,
00:01:44 and wider artistic aesthetics and so on.
00:01:48 Yes. We first met actually about 10 years ago, and we did a conversation for a book that we produced here at the NCF.
00:02:00 And I remember in that, one of the reasons I wanted to speak to you is in that, without going immediately into politics,
00:02:07 I remember you saying something you used to get frustrated that people automatically made assumptions about what you were politically
00:02:14 because you were in the art world, because you were a composer.
00:02:19 Yes, I think that's true, and I can understand why those assumptions were made
00:02:25 and continue to be made, not just about me, but about many people in the arts.
00:02:31 But the issue is that gradually throughout my life,
00:02:34 and I began as a kind of precocious teenager interested in politics,
00:02:39 and it was very left-wing politics.
00:02:40 It was the Young Communist League, wasn't it?
00:02:42 Yes, I joined the Young Communist League when I was about 14.
00:02:45 And basically since then, very, very slowly and incrementally,
00:02:49 I've been losing all my youthful certainties.
00:02:52 And I try to make an account for that in some of the things that I say and write about.
00:02:58 But as a Catholic, I also feel a great deal of sympathy with agnostics
00:03:06 because I now know what being an agnostic feels like,
00:03:09 except the religion I have lost is the anti-religion, anti-religious religion of Marxism
00:03:15 and that's been an interesting journey and I remember crucial moments where I began to
00:03:22 have severe doubts and it doesn't mean I've become the opposite of whatever that was
00:03:28 but I enjoy being that kind of free-floating figure now
00:03:34 engaging in conversations and thought and reading
00:03:37 and indeed friendships with people I would never have had anything to do with
00:03:41 30 odd years ago. I mean obviously you therefore
00:03:45 politics to be that involved at 14
00:03:50 you know this was something that you were quite passionate about. Was it a political
00:03:53 family? Yes and no
00:03:57 my uncle Brian was a labour councillor and
00:04:01 And those kind of communities are steeped in labour tradition
00:04:07 in working-class areas like Ayrshire, where I grew up.
00:04:13 But that was a moderate, socially conservative labourism.
00:04:19 My grandfather, who was a coal miner, was committed to the Labour Party,
00:04:23 but he was very, very wary of Marxists in the National Union of Mineworkers,
00:04:28 and he fought against them, not physically but politically throughout his life.
00:04:35 And that strain of labourism is something that I've always had a great admiration for.
00:04:40 He was very disappointed in me when I became a communist
00:04:43 because it was like joining the enemy.
00:04:45 And I still have huge regrets about that.
00:04:48 I did hurt my grandfather by doing that and I was stubborn, I was silly.
00:04:53 But he was right, it was probably the worst thing I've ever done.
00:04:57 Yes, really?
00:04:57 I mean that's
00:05:00 it's still a living regret
00:05:02 it is, I still wake up
00:05:04 in a lather of
00:05:05 self-recrimination
00:05:08 from time to time, wondering whether
00:05:10 even just as a teenager
00:05:11 it's not very important I suppose
00:05:14 in retrospect, but just in
00:05:16 the thought
00:05:18 and the
00:05:18 just wondering whether I may have
00:05:22 given sucker to
00:05:23 one of the most evil ideologies
00:05:26 that has ever been in this world.
00:05:29 Before this, though, and in some ways far more importantly,
00:05:34 you were already composing, weren't you?
00:05:36 Exactly.
00:05:37 I read, is this right, at 10 years old you were composing?
00:05:40 Yes, yes, I was given a little recorder, a plastic recorder.
00:05:44 Like we all were at school.
00:05:45 Absolutely.
00:05:46 It's not the seismic experience for most British school children
00:05:49 that it was for me, but certainly it felt like a light going on
00:05:53 and I knew immediately that I wanted to play other instruments
00:05:56 but also, more crucially, I felt the desire to make my own music right from the beginning.
00:06:01 Even before I knew what the notation was, I was scribbling down note names and making shapes and so on.
00:06:07 So that instinct was ignited on the first day.
00:06:11 Really? How does that come to you?
00:06:15 It feels mysterious to me.
00:06:19 How can you know at ten it's something that has to come out, whether you like it or not?
00:06:24 Yes, that's the way it was then and the way it's been ever since.
00:06:29 I don't know how it happens.
00:06:31 It's just one of these mysterious things.
00:06:33 But it's when one's own character comes into alignment with a skill
00:06:39 that is absolutely drawing something from you,
00:06:42 a necessity to respond to that.
00:06:46 And it's there in all the arts and I'm sure in many other things.
00:06:49 but that little moment
00:06:52 when Miss Grey
00:06:54 she's still alive
00:06:55 gave me my first recorder
00:06:56 was the light going on for me
00:06:57 that has had huge implications
00:07:01 for what I've done
00:07:02 in the decades since
00:07:03 I mean in some ways
00:07:05 I think you're rather blessed actually
00:07:07 I mean because most people
00:07:08 I say most people
00:07:10 a lot of people go to life
00:07:11 and they don't quite know
00:07:12 they have a feeling for something
00:07:14 maybe this
00:07:15 to actually know
00:07:16 yes although I didn't know
00:07:19 what it would mean at that stage
00:07:20 and what the implications of a life in composing would be.
00:07:26 But my mum was very interested in music
00:07:30 and indeed my grandfather that I've mentioned,
00:07:32 as I say, he was a coal miner,
00:07:34 but he lived for music.
00:07:36 He loved music.
00:07:37 He played a euphonium, as many of these miners did
00:07:39 all over areas like that in the UK.
00:07:43 And so when I came along, he was delighted.
00:07:45 and they began talking to me about composers
00:07:49 and I found out about other composers, dead composers, the great composers
00:07:54 because my mum had played piano when she was young
00:07:56 and I kept on finding her old piano music, sonatas by Beethoven
00:08:00 and little pieces of Chopin and so on
00:08:03 and so there was music in the house
00:08:04 my grandfather started giving me stuff that he had played and sang
00:08:09 he sang in the local Catholic church choir and so on
00:08:12 so gradually I began to realise there's all this music
00:08:16 and crucially I realised there were still composers alive
00:08:20 and some of them, great composers, just a few hundred miles down the road
00:08:24 from where I lived, Benjamin Britten
00:08:26 and so I get very interested in the idea that it was not necessarily
00:08:30 only a museum culture, a dead art as it were
00:08:33 but there were people doing the same things, this was the 1970s
00:08:38 that they were doing 200, 300 years before that
00:08:41 And that was very, very exciting and indeed an encouragement for me.
00:08:45 But you see, you were quite specific about wanting to compose.
00:08:49 It wasn't just that you wanted to be a musician.
00:08:51 Yes, that's right. There was a bit of both.
00:08:54 I've always enjoyed performing, and nowadays when I perform, it's as a conductor.
00:08:59 But, you know, I played the trumpet and the cornet.
00:09:02 My grandfather got me into the local brass band very early on.
00:09:06 That was my training.
00:09:07 did you sort of go you went to music school did you after that well I decided to study at
00:09:16 university there are different ways of learning the craft and the skills of composition in the
00:09:24 in my day in the 1970s because the the university courses were a little bit more academic and there
00:09:31 was a kind of background of historiography and musicology that's where I wanted to go I wanted
00:09:36 to learn about the the depth of the culture the the conservatoire route was
00:09:43 slightly different although they've kind of converged in more recent years but I
00:09:47 went to Edinburgh University my teacher there was Kenneth Layton who is well
00:09:52 known he's dead now but he was well known amongst church musicians and he was his
00:09:57 music was quite like Benjamin Britton's in some way then John Caskin at Durham
00:10:01 university later yes I remember when I was at school we were played Britain's
00:10:07 young person's guide to the orchestra which is a wonderful way accessible way
00:10:11 for kids to get into classical music one particular area that you have written
00:10:19 for obviously is the church and you know sacred music liturgical music that is
00:10:27 something which I would have thought is quite unusual now isn't? Well you would think that but
00:10:34 the thing is in modernity and in modern music let's talk about the 20th century before the 21st
00:10:42 if you look at who the major figures were and are many of them were profoundly religious men and
00:10:49 women not just spiritual in the vaguest sense but you know Stravinsky for example was a believer
00:10:54 he fell in love with the Latin church when he came to the West
00:10:58 although his orthodoxy was still with him all through his life
00:11:01 he set the Psalms of course, he set the Mass
00:11:04 and he was as revolutionary in his music making as he was conservative in his theology
00:11:12 and that's the interesting thing because we imagine modernity in the arts
00:11:18 as being part of the retreat from religion
00:11:20 and you can point to some of the other arts perhaps
00:11:23 and say that is right
00:11:24 but in music it's more difficult to say that
00:11:26 and it's because I think there's something innate
00:11:28 in the nature of music that is profoundly spiritual
00:11:31 and many different composers know that
00:11:35 they might not go the orthodox
00:11:38 or the expected religious route
00:11:41 like Stravinsky
00:11:43 others explored the ideas
00:11:46 and indeed the religions of the Far East
00:11:48 John Cage comes to mind
00:11:50 But John Cage had studied with Schoenberg, and Schoenberg is another case in point,
00:11:56 a composer who reconverted to a practicing Judaism after he left Germany in the 1930s,
00:12:02 and his music's imbued with that Jewish spirit and culture and heritage, but he was a mystic.
00:12:09 He was fascinated by silence and silence's umbilical relationship with music
00:12:14 and how the music begins in the silence of our own souls, the silence of our own minds.
00:12:20 That's what drew John Cage, and of course it has impacted
00:12:23 in so much of the modernist search for the sacred.
00:12:29 You could even say that the search for the sacred,
00:12:32 right from Wagner right through to today,
00:12:34 John Taverner and Arvo Pert, whose company I was in very recently,
00:12:39 that that search for the sacred is a given,
00:12:42 and it's been part of the mainstream of modern music,
00:12:46 modern classical music, and that does not surprise me.
00:12:49 and it doesn't therefore feel that what I'm doing is very odd or out in a limb.
00:12:55 But this is unique for music, would you say?
00:12:59 It's very hard to detect it in other arts.
00:13:02 Except I've had some very interesting discussions with poets, for example,
00:13:06 who can trace the same lineage and search in modern poetry
00:13:12 through many great poets of our time.
00:13:17 but it's very acute in music
00:13:20 and it's perhaps something to do with
00:13:22 that music is this mysterious
00:13:24 thing, it communicates its power
00:13:26 its strength, its meaning in things
00:13:29 in sounds beyond words
00:13:30 and beyond images and that is the mysterious
00:13:32 and strange thing about it
00:13:34 what is this thing that's affecting
00:13:36 my emotions and depth
00:13:38 of soul so much but it's not
00:13:40 necessarily in words and it's not necessarily
00:13:42 what I can see
00:13:43 you can't see music, you can't touch
00:13:46 music, you can't taste it, but it's
00:13:48 there as a
00:13:50 reality, but it's a very different kind
00:13:52 of reality from
00:13:54 the thingness of our lives
00:13:56 There's something
00:13:58 about transcendence, isn't it? I mean it's
00:14:00 transcendent, I think, music
00:14:02 I think so, and I've come across
00:14:04 many music lovers, they don't
00:14:06 necessarily share my
00:14:08 world view, certainly not my religion
00:14:10 but they recognise
00:14:12 that transcendent quality and
00:14:14 in their atheism
00:14:16 sometimes and in their agnosticism will speak about music as a spiritual art form and they
00:14:21 obviously mean something by that. You have written quite a lot about your relationship with if you
00:14:29 like the broader artistic establishment. How would you characterize that now? Well the first thing
00:14:39 to say is that in music, I think I've hinted at it already, there is a profound understanding
00:14:47 and knowledge of where music has come from. There's an acknowledgement of the Judeo-Christian
00:14:52 roots, of that heritage and so on, and that many of the great composers from the past
00:14:57 right up to now wrote music for the church, were employed by the church. So in music there
00:15:02 is a great open heartedness
00:15:04 open mindedness about
00:15:06 the spiritual nature of
00:15:08 the art form
00:15:09 and outside of that
00:15:12 it can sometimes be different and
00:15:14 I think this
00:15:15 bewilderment that there's
00:15:18 people still writing masses
00:15:20 and stab at matters in the 21st
00:15:22 century is out there
00:15:23 mercifully I don't come across
00:15:26 it very often but sometimes I do and it's
00:15:28 usually in
00:15:29 an article in the Guardian or something
00:15:33 sorry to single them out but you know what I mean
00:15:36 but there is a kind of
00:15:38 left-wing secular group think
00:15:42 about the arts in general
00:15:43 that might have made it more difficult for me
00:15:47 if music hadn't been so powerfully spiritual anyway
00:15:51 but also at least those assumptions
00:15:53 that we started off with doesn't it
00:15:55 the assumption that somehow you're going to be
00:15:57 broadly left politically and yes did that sort of how did that play when it came to things such as
00:16:07 the the scottish vote for example i mean yes you you actually were quite clear there weren't you
00:16:14 you you were on the no side that's right um i decided i mean this and what on one level it's
00:16:21 not that was not or wasn't originally a left right thing although perhaps perhaps it has developed
00:16:26 that way because the nationalist movement in Scotland has become very
00:16:30 left-wing and that was one of my worries about the nationalist movement
00:16:37 generally it was becoming a broadly socialistic experiment and but but
00:16:48 fueled by a profound anglophobia and that was really
00:16:55 anglophobia oh yes very much so and they'll argue that it wasn't but but it was and there was a
00:17:02 narrowing down of options and a nastiness emerged through it in retrospect I wonder whether it was
00:17:09 a good thing to come out and say what I thought but I did I wrote about it I said that for various
00:17:17 reasons not just cultural reasons but for economic reasons as well and political reasons social
00:17:21 reasons, Scotland cutting itself off from the bigger Anglophone world would have been
00:17:28 a disaster. And I wrote that and immediately attracted opprobrium, especially from the
00:17:36 arts. There's this weird organisation called Artists for an Independent Scotland and you
00:17:41 were expected to sign up for that. And they were all very shouty and young, a lot of them.
00:17:47 and I think they put a lot of people off independence
00:17:51 actually because of their quasi-hooliganism
00:17:54 and the way that they responded in debate
00:17:56 and you see that emerging in so many other debates today.
00:18:00 So when I saw this other referendum coming down the tracks a few years later
00:18:05 I decided I'm not going to be doing that again
00:18:07 and I've decided to stay out of that
00:18:10 because as we have seen it's become very, very toxic.
00:18:14 It's dividing families.
00:18:16 It's ending friendships, just as the Scottish independence thing did
00:18:23 And that's a great shame and it's made me reflect a lot on what an artist can do in the world of politics
00:18:32 And I see a lot of my colleagues entering into various debates but causing division in so doing
00:18:41 And I'm not going to do that anymore
00:18:42 There's something about the healing power of music that can make us come together
00:18:46 And I will always remember that, hopefully in the years to come, when we put these divisions and toxicities behind us.
00:18:56 On that point, it struck me, for example, this year at the Proms, the last night at the Proms.
00:19:04 Suddenly this thing that had been quite a fun thing had seemed to have become a forum.
00:19:10 Did you see it?
00:19:11 I didn't this year, but I've seen it coming over the last few years, yes.
00:19:16 Yes, it's sort of like it was a mixture, an awful lot of EU flags.
00:19:19 It was something which was, you know, for many people a bit jokey, for many people quite sincere.
00:19:25 But it's become this kind of, you know, this sort of battleground in an odd way.
00:19:30 Yeah, it's a great shame because I used to hate The Last Night of the Promise for left-wing reasons.
00:19:35 Right.
00:19:36 And then I came to love it because it was a bit of a laugh.
00:19:39 It was like letting her hair down and having a laugh at ourselves
00:19:42 and nothing was very serious and everything was ironic
00:19:44 and the waving of flags and the singing of these wonderfully comic and silly songs.
00:19:49 But I would hate to see that disappear and it become, as you say, a battleground,
00:19:53 another forum for the divisions in our society.
00:19:58 You said that you have become less certain as you've got older.
00:20:05 Obviously you're talking about politics, but generally.
00:20:07 I mean, you know, do you feel, does that make you feel, as it were, better?
00:20:14 I mean, do you feel more open?
00:20:17 Is that, that's really what I'm asking.
00:20:19 In some senses, I do feel more relaxed.
00:20:24 More relaxed.
00:20:24 Because I feel that I can, I'm happy in the company of many different kinds of people.
00:20:30 you know I have formed friendships with people who I would not have encountered many years ago
00:20:39 from the likes of Roger Scruton for example who I admire greatly and I cite his writings on Wagner
00:20:46 and aesthetics and beauty a lot I've got a story about that citation that I'll come back to in a
00:20:53 minute and then the likes of George Weigel who was John Paul II's biographer and very much on the
00:21:00 sort of Republican side
00:21:02 in American politics until recently perhaps
00:21:04 and to engage in
00:21:06 friendly conversation with him
00:21:08 has been a real learning
00:21:10 process for me, I've found out a lot about
00:21:12 American politics and then someone like
00:21:14 Alexander Stoddart, the great
00:21:16 sculptor up in Scotland
00:21:17 very much associated with
00:21:20 social
00:21:22 conservatism perhaps
00:21:23 and I've enjoyed their company a lot
00:21:26 but I don't think I would ever want
00:21:28 to lose the friendships I've made with
00:21:30 genuinely left-wing people that are as open as I am to dialogue.
00:21:37 Now, whether it's more difficult to find that openness on the left is a matter of debate.
00:21:44 But as I say, I remember quoting Roger Scruton in a, it wasn't just a pre-concert talk,
00:21:50 it was an on-stage talk at the South Bank Centre a few years ago.
00:21:58 And then there was a review in The Guardian, of course, where else, which mentioned me quoting Scruton as perilous.
00:22:07 Perilous for who?
00:22:08 Well, exactly. Who did he mean?
00:22:11 Perilous for the people who are hearing these dreadful opinions?
00:22:15 Or was it perilous for me?
00:22:17 Was this a threat?
00:22:19 Was this a sign that I had stepped out of the fold?
00:22:26 That's the feeling I got.
00:22:28 and that was another danger moment
00:22:31 I realised this is going to get more and more difficult
00:22:36 for many of us in the years ahead
00:22:39 and I think that has been proved to be the case
00:22:42 You have said I think James
00:22:45 that because your Catholicism is central to your life
00:22:49 that that tends to put you immediately
00:22:52 as it were against the grain of opinion
00:22:54 would you say that's right?
00:22:56 Yes, and there's been a long history of that, of course, in this country.
00:22:59 To be Catholic was to be against the grain.
00:23:04 To be Catholic was to be treacherous in our deep, deep history.
00:23:11 And perhaps there's a little bit of that today.
00:23:14 I still get a lot of reaction from the left, again, it has to be said,
00:23:18 which automatically sees all Catholics as conservative,
00:23:23 socially conservative on a whole range of things.
00:23:26 they assume a whole range of phobias that you suffer from and attack you for it without a word
00:23:32 being spoken and it's I think it is my Catholicism that that puts me in that kind of firing range
00:23:39 can I ask you I mean this is a question probably you'll ask quite a lot I remember at school with
00:23:47 my recorder we had an orchestra and we were taken to the festival hall to see things is it more of
00:23:54 an uphill task now with our educational system now to get younger people
00:24:00 interested in classical music than maybe it was when we were young we're roughly
00:24:05 the same yes yes I think that is probably the case and it's because music
00:24:10 is not seen as one of the basics and perhaps there is blame on right hand
00:24:15 left on this that music is being edged out of the curriculum and that's it's
00:24:24 causing real disastrous disintegration in state schools especially it's getting
00:24:35 to the stage that the only people that are being in a position to learn music
00:24:40 and to make encounters with classical music and indeed a whole range of very
00:24:45 very different kind of musics are our kids that have been to private schools
00:24:49 and that's a great slight on our meritocracy if that continues and so yes
00:24:58 that there are danger signs the people the numbers that are wanting to take
00:25:04 music at school at a level standard and so on are dropping precipitously in
00:25:09 Scotland as well as in England and I think a degree of some kind of musical
00:25:15 or cultural activism is required from us that are involved in that and I know
00:25:20 that the likes of Simon Rattle and many others have given voice to these
00:25:25 anxieties. You see I remember you know again growing up there would be
00:25:30 programs on what we had three channels or whatever there would be programs about
00:25:34 music or for young people you know this is what's sort of gone from our culture
00:25:39 in some ways now, hasn't it?
00:25:40 This kind of what you might call
00:25:41 casual coverage of these things.
00:25:45 You're not going to just sort of like
00:25:47 happen upon them so easily, are you?
00:25:49 No, decisions have been made
00:25:51 that the high arts, the classical arts
00:25:55 are not to be on the main channels anymore.
00:25:58 So they're hived off into little ghettos
00:26:00 where you can go if you want.
00:26:02 But you're right, those chance encounters,
00:26:05 you know, a child turning on the television
00:26:07 and seeing Verdi's Macbeth
00:26:09 which happened to me
00:26:10 by that stage I was very involved in music
00:26:13 but I'd never come across a Verdi opera
00:26:14 I just happened to see it on the television one day
00:26:16 and I was just blown away by it
00:26:19 and there may have been others
00:26:20 maybe not many like that
00:26:22 but it did happen and it can still happen
00:26:25 I mean even the proms
00:26:27 are beginning to disappear from BBC One
00:26:29 when my Confession of Isabel Gowdy
00:26:31 was shown on the television
00:26:33 30 years ago
00:26:34 of course it was broadcast on BBC Radio 3
00:26:37 but it was on primetime or evening BBC One Scotland or something
00:26:44 and so lots of people could come across it by accident
00:26:50 and in fact the next day after it was shown on the television
00:26:54 I went to a Celtic Aberdeen game at Parkhead
00:26:59 and at half time I was tapped on the shoulder by another fan
00:27:03 who asked was that your premier that was in the television last night
00:27:08 and at that point I realised yes something has changed for me
00:27:11 if that's happening when I go to the football
00:27:14 but here are fellow working class men mainly
00:27:19 who are watching the proms last night
00:27:22 and hearing a brand new piece of classical music
00:27:24 It's a pity that this is happening
00:27:28 because it seems to me that British classical music
00:27:32 is actually pretty healthy at the moment
00:27:35 in terms of people such as yourself, composers.
00:27:40 Would you say that's right?
00:27:41 I certainly feel that.
00:27:43 We're in an odd position here in the UK
00:27:46 in that we've not gone down the top-down cultural route
00:27:53 that the Germans and the French do.
00:27:55 They impose high culture and modernist culture from the top.
00:27:58 but we haven't gone the populist route that happens in America
00:28:03 we're in a strange position, probably mid-Atlantic, looking both ways
00:28:07 but it does mean that the approach
00:28:11 to modern music in this country is less
00:28:14 doctrinaire than it is in Germany and France
00:28:18 and different in its own ways from what happens
00:28:23 in America, but it's a good place to be because there's no
00:28:26 school of British music
00:28:28 has emerged
00:28:29 there are very different kinds of
00:28:32 British composers, I love
00:28:34 them all, I conduct the music
00:28:36 of Thomas Addis or
00:28:38 Mark Anthony
00:28:40 Turnage, George Benjamin
00:28:42 and they're very very different composers from me
00:28:44 but I have a very
00:28:46 I've always had a non-doctrinaire
00:28:48 attitude to the various
00:28:50 stylistic shifts
00:28:52 and changes in modern music
00:28:54 and that's a very British thing
00:28:56 just to be celebrated. You were I think quite clear weren't you about wanting to compose for
00:29:02 the concert hall isn't that right you didn't go down the other routes or maybe film or anything
00:29:07 like this? No that moment has gone for me I think you need a particular kind of mindset and you need
00:29:13 to be young to be to go into film a lot of my colleagues did it and they're doing very well
00:29:19 a lot of them make a lot of money out of it good on them but I don't think I've got the mindset for
00:29:24 it mainly because you've got to give over control to someone else and I haven't really been in that
00:29:31 position I wouldn't want to be in that position I want authority over what I do. James it's right
00:29:42 that you're premier of the fifth symphony I mentioned that is now that's going to be
00:29:47 you're going to be conducting yourself in London are you? It's not me that's conducting I wrote
00:29:53 this piece, the Fifth Symphony, for
00:29:55 the Sixteen, which is conducted
00:29:57 by Harry Christophers, one of
00:29:59 the best choirs in the world
00:30:01 it's actually for two choirs, it's for his
00:30:03 Sixteen, which is a chamber choir
00:30:05 and then Genesis Sixteen, which is the
00:30:07 larger chorus that has
00:30:09 come out of his training academy
00:30:11 for the Sixteen, so Harry Christophers will conduct
00:30:13 it with those two choirs and the
00:30:15 Britain Symphonia
00:30:16 at the Barbican
00:30:18 on the evening of the 14th
00:30:21 of October
00:30:22 It's got a subtitle, it's called Le Grand Inconnu, The Great Unknown, that means something
00:30:29 quite different I think in Britain, but it's something that points to and is inspired by
00:30:34 and reflects on the mystery of the Holy Spirit, The Great Unknown, Le Grand Inconnu, and it
00:30:42 allows me to really experiment with sounds and ideas and words and phrases from Hebrew and Greek and Latin.
00:30:54 I even have the choir breathing in and out at the beginning,
00:30:57 just because the word ruach is associated with the Holy Spirit, and it's about the breath.
00:31:03 And there are some wonderful musical images associated with the physical attributes of the Holy Spirit.
00:31:10 there is breath and wind, spiritus
00:31:13 there is water of course, living water
00:31:17 mayim chayim in Hebrew
00:31:19 and there is fire, the fire of Pentecost
00:31:22 inye, vel inye
00:31:25 You've actually talked in the past about the importance of silence I think
00:31:30 and this, I think you called it an assault on the interior life
00:31:35 actually, by noise
00:31:38 By noise, absolutely. And we musicians participate in that, collude with it sometimes too, I'm afraid. But it's a place I go to, and I know that many composers go. It's the breeding ground of music.
00:31:54 I think no matter whether you're in the countryside where I am now
00:31:58 or in a big noisy city like this
00:32:00 composers have to carve out that space where they can go
00:32:04 and be silent and engage with the silence of their thoughts
00:32:08 because it's in that silence that the music begins
00:32:11 there's an umbilical link between silence and music
00:32:15 that all composers know and recognise
00:32:18 it's something we need to make the music
00:32:22 to make the noise that we do
00:32:23 well thank you very very much James
00:32:26 for speaking to me today
00:32:27 I would say actually
00:32:29 one of the great things about YouTube
00:32:31 and the world of YouTube
00:32:34 is that an awful lot of your music
00:32:36 is actually on it
00:32:37 performances of it
00:32:39 and really
00:32:41 people want
00:32:43 if they don't already know your music
00:32:45 and they want to
00:32:45 they should actually look that up
00:32:47 it's quite sublime
00:32:49 thank you very very much indeed James
00:32:52 yes, do look up
00:32:54 on YouTube some of the performances
00:32:57 of Sir James Macmillan's music
00:32:59 we'll look forward to seeing you
00:33:01 next time, thank you very much indeed
00:33:03 thank you