New Culture Forum - November 16, 2019


S2.05 Douglas Murray: Identity Politics & The Madness of Crowds - Race, Gender & Identity

S2.03 Martin Durkin: Media Bias & Brexit Snobbery S2.10 Theodore Dalrymple: Britain's Vanishing Culture & Character

Episode Stats


Length

41 minutes

Words per minute

158.56

Word count

6,536

Sentence count

159


Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
00:00:00 hello and welcome to so what you're saying is i'm peter whittle now i'm delighted this week
00:00:22 that our guest is the internationally best-selling author douglas murray douglas as you might know a
00:00:29 book out called the strange death of europe it was an international bestseller it was on the
00:00:35 best-selling lists here in the uk for about 20 weeks it was translated into many languages huge
00:00:41 success uh he's since then obviously become very well known on the international debating and
00:00:47 lecturing circuit as well with such illuminaries as jordan peterson his latest book this has just
00:00:54 come out is the madness of crowds gender race and identity um good to see you douglas very good to
00:01:04 be with you peter um first of all gender race and identity you talk about this as being basically
00:01:11 a form of new ideology or a new religion yeah can you explain a bit about that
00:01:20 Well, I'd noticed in recent years, as I'm sure you and many others have,
00:01:24 that almost every day's news was about, or very significantly about, issues of identity.
00:01:32 It was people's careers being over because, for instance,
00:01:37 they had nicked one of what I recognised to be the tripwires.
00:01:40 It was people demanding a new recognition of a particular identity.
00:01:46 And there are others I could have put in,
00:01:49 but the four that I realised they were most centred around
00:01:52 was everything to do with being gay,
00:01:55 everything to do with women,
00:01:57 particularly relations between the sexes,
00:01:59 everything to do with race,
00:02:01 and absolutely everything to do with trans,
00:02:03 which is the most recent of these rights claims.
00:02:07 Now, I should stress that I think in all of these cases,
00:02:10 we live in the most free most liberal in the proper sense societies in the world and to live
00:02:18 in this society now is to live not just in the most fortunate society in the world at the moment
00:02:23 but the most fortunate society in the world ever so why was it that all of these things which have
00:02:29 never been better anywhere ever should have increasingly been portrayed as if we lived in
00:02:37 the most repressive, oppressive, patriarchal, white supremacist societies in the world.
00:02:44 Societies which, as a result, needed, if not to be brought down completely, then to be
00:02:49 completely changed.
00:02:52 And I started to notice that there were common patterns going on.
00:02:56 And I stress that this is not to overstate things.
00:03:02 what's behind this is the most serious attempt i think since the end of the cold war
00:03:08 to come up with a comprehensive explanation and justification for what we are doing here yeah
00:03:15 after all you know i addressed a bit of this in the strange death of europe but it's highly
00:03:22 unlikely that we are going to be the first people in human history to require no explanation for
00:03:27 our presence on earth and not need anything to do now my view is that historically we recognize
00:03:36 that when the economics goes wrong other things follow we know this from the french revolution
00:03:41 we know this from every every period in history and we've been very reluctant to recognize that
00:03:46 when the financial system went wrong in 2008 something else happened in its wake other things
00:03:54 start to go wrong in the culture my view is as I explain in the book that in the wake of a
00:04:00 financial crisis it isn't clear for instance why young people who can't accumulate capital should
00:04:05 have an instinctive love of capitalism or to put it another way it's not clear to me that people
00:04:13 who don't see any likelihood of ever getting on the property ladder won't find themselves attracted
00:04:18 to a system which claims to be able to solve every inequity on earth yeah it's got something
00:04:25 going for it hasn't it and and my view as i explain is that post 2008 what we see is that
00:04:35 there are ideas around of course there are ideas around all the time and this idea the
00:04:40 intersectionalism the identity politics the weaponization of identity have been around in
00:04:45 this form since at least the 60s 70s been worked on in the 80s American universities it's a
00:04:53 demonstrable demonstrable nonsense I explain I try to pick it apart in this book but perhaps
00:05:00 when the economics goes wrong our whole system becomes highly vulnerable to bad ideas and I
00:05:08 think that's one of the things that's been happening and into the system in the last 10
00:05:13 years has flooded these claims about lgbtqi issues about women issues about
00:05:20 racial issues and just in case anyone thinks I'm obsessing about a you know a
00:05:27 liberal arts college issue on the west coast of America I would just say in a
00:05:32 country like Britain or America the only people who don't think this is coming
00:05:36 for them are people who are self-employed yes yeah yeah anyone who
00:05:40 works in government anyone who works in local authority anyone who works in
00:05:45 private organizations in public companies will know that increasingly
00:05:53 issues in our society are not to do with people's competencies they're to do with
00:05:58 their identity issues it's whether or not we have the right identity mix now
00:06:04 there's an awful lot going on there but one of the things I try to show is this
00:06:09 is an unwinnable game yes unwinnable it seems to many people Douglas I think
00:06:17 you've you've already alluded to it there but it seems to many people that
00:06:20 this has suddenly come you know it's it seems to have suddenly arrived you
00:06:27 mentioned the 2008 financial crisis but it was a long time of brewing but it
00:06:33 It has been incredibly quick, hasn't it?
00:06:37 Yes, well, as I say, the origins of it lie some way back,
00:06:42 but it does seem to have flooded through the system.
00:06:44 I demonstrate the way in which in the last 10 years this goes into the system
00:06:49 and then in the last five years becomes highly weaponised, highly weaponised.
00:06:54 Obviously, particularly in the wake of the Brexit and Trump votes
00:06:57 where there's an added political utility to weaponising these things.
00:07:02 But, yes, I mean, until the last 10 years, things like LGBTQI were not on the agenda.
00:07:11 That we knew about gay rights.
00:07:13 And in the same way, gay rights, women's rights and equal racial rights for everyone, whatever their skin colour,
00:07:21 had pretty much arrived, I would submit, now of course lots of people contest this,
00:07:25 but I would submit by the late 20th century and the early part of this century,
00:07:30 had arrived at something like their desired destination.
00:07:35 And the desired destination was equal.
00:07:40 And as I see it in recent years,
00:07:42 this has been like watching a train drawing into a station,
00:07:45 the desired destination.
00:07:48 And then suddenly, just as it's drawing in,
00:07:51 gets a head of steam, goes shooting off down the tracks,
00:07:53 off the tracks, and starts scattering bodies in its wake.
00:07:56 Why, when gay rights have never been better,
00:07:58 are they portrayed as if they've never been worse why when women have never been freer and able to
00:08:03 make choices about their lives is everything about the lack of opportunity for women and the
00:08:08 discrimination that people see against women why do we hear talk of the patriarchy
00:08:13 at the least plausible time in human history to do such talk why do we see the weaponization of
00:08:21 gay people against straight people of women against men of black people against white people
00:08:28 and trans against absolutely everyone why what's actually going on and I think there's a number of
00:08:35 things going on but one of them one of them is simple brute politics brutal politics
00:08:42 perhaps it's a an image that people don't want in their heads but
00:08:48 trans is the one that gives this thing away and I think in recent years
00:08:53 the radical left has used transsexuals as a battering ram all right a battering ram for what
00:09:02 for several things one is and you can see it with complete predictability across the system
00:09:09 trans is used by people who want to do something else i'm not referring to trans individuals who
00:09:15 broadly speaking want to just live their lives like everyone else
00:09:18 but i'm talking about the people who can predict with absolute certainty will agree to whatever
00:09:24 the latest claim is broadly speaking they are people who want to wage a conflict on
00:09:33 the patriarchal white cis heteronormative capitalist democratic societies that we live in
00:09:44 actually that's a an important point because uh you mentioned the book you know that in in the past
00:09:50 when there was a kind of a diagram of oppression you know it capitalism was at the top and then
00:09:56 you had you know the works or whatever now capitalism is still at the top but you have a
00:10:02 different hierarchy of groups that are apparently being oppressed which is yes i says i i as you
00:10:07 know i i do each of these landmine issues one by one gay women yeah race trans but they have
00:10:13 interludes in between them to explain what I think the things going on underneath are and that's why
00:10:19 I have an interlude on the Marxism issue because you can see the Marxist substrates in a lot of
00:10:24 this I mean the as you say that the pyramid of oppression capital is still at the top money
00:10:35 finance but this time instead of the the rest of the pyramid being supported merely by the workers
00:10:41 and the working class on his noble shoulders, the middle class and then the aristocrats and the bishops and so on.
00:10:47 This is another form of the pyramid of oppression, but it involves these minority groups.
00:10:52 Now, by the way, lest anyone think that I'm some conspiracy theorist on this,
00:10:57 I cite at considerable length some of the Marxist scholars who make this completely plain.
00:11:02 And I was staggered when I was looking into this at the completely frank way in which some of them write about this.
00:11:11 uh uh writers like lachlan move in the 80s are already writing that the working class have
00:11:18 basically let us down yeah remember the working class didn't show up for the revolution on time
00:11:23 the working class were a big letdown if you were you know a communist in in britain or america in
00:11:30 the 20th century so in the 80s when they're still trying to work out why the best they've got to
00:11:36 show for their horrible experiment is Yugoslavia or Romania, Albania. They're trying to work out
00:11:43 why this has happened and why the working class is such a letdown and they decide that we've got
00:11:49 to get a new form of revolutionary class and they are completely frank that they want to find it in
00:11:56 minority groups. They want to find it in women and one always has to stress that women are not a
00:12:01 minority group but nevertheless they're always packaged in with this. They want to find in
00:12:05 sexual minorities and they want to find it in racial minorities now there are certain problems
00:12:10 in this and lachlan moof among others stress that there is a problem because the working class is
00:12:15 likely to be racist because this is one of the problems that the communists always have they
00:12:19 always had a problem with the working class this is just one of them the working class will be
00:12:23 racist and they might not like some of our client groups well this is just another contradiction
00:12:27 we need to get over yeah and in this whole business of contradictions we see part of the
00:12:33 marxist substructure but we also see one of the things that the rest of us have to address
00:12:39 because you and i might think that when you have two opposing things trying to go forward at the
00:12:49 same time one of them's got to give that the contradiction the contradiction means one of
00:12:55 them is wrong yeah but one of the things that the marxists always managed to do was to embrace the
00:13:01 contradictions so i show with the intersectionalists i show in somewhat gruesome detail i think in the
00:13:08 madness of crowds that intersectionalism claims that if you unlock one minority group you unlock
00:13:15 the lot yeah so we live in a society that's patriarchal white supremacist cis heteronormative
00:13:22 etc etc goes without saying but these things are all interlocked and if you could undo one you
00:13:27 would undo the whole thing now i point out this is demonstrably wrong demonstrably wrong for
00:13:36 instance trans runs against women fundamentally it happens to also run against men but let's put
00:13:42 that one off for another time it runs fundamentally against women because you cannot claim that being
00:13:48 a woman is a performative act which you just become if you would like to become yet being
00:13:53 trans is a hardware issue you have no say over can run one of those programs you can't run both
00:13:58 i submit and this has not i think previously been focused on enough trans runs totally against gay
00:14:04 totally against gay it fundamentally undermines the central claims of the gay and lesbian
00:14:12 liberation movements have gone in gone on over the last half century so the intersectionists say
00:14:17 but this will all if you undo this never mind the racial one if you undo these everything will come
00:14:23 right? And I say, no. Since there is such clear and blatant contradictions, why don't you see that
00:14:29 one of them has to give? Well, again, the intersectionists, because they're influenced
00:14:32 by the Marxists, don't find this a problem, like the rest of us would. And they don't think that
00:14:37 as a result, maybe you have to re-estimate the whole thing. The problem is, you see, if one,
00:14:46 you know, if they allow for one contradiction, then the whole thing falls down, doesn't it?
00:14:51 This is the problem. I mean, for example, with the trans issue, which, I mean, you mentioned that this one seems to be, as you said earlier, a bit of a catalyst in a way.
00:15:05 We had Rod Liddle on the programme and he said this is the one that's going to tip people away, if you like, from this agenda in its claims.
00:15:14 For example, you talk to trans people in the book, don't you?
00:15:19 And, for example, if there is a young boy who maybe has got quite feminine traits,
00:15:25 he might grow up gay.
00:15:27 Now, in an odd way, he would be, oh, well, maybe actually you probably are trans.
00:15:32 You should probably be a woman.
00:15:33 So, in other words, it's actually quite conservative, isn't it?
00:15:35 It's saying you've got feminine characteristics, so therefore you must be a woman.
00:15:38 Absolutely.
00:15:39 The tomboy girl.
00:15:40 Yes, exactly.
00:15:41 Isn't just a tomboy girl likely to grow up to be a happy heterosexual woman and mother or potentially a happy lesbian.
00:15:47 No, the tomboy girl actually is a boy in hiding, in waiting, who we must then give drugs to.
00:15:55 And we must then medically experiment on.
00:15:57 We must, for instance, let's not beat around the bush, flay the arm, for instance, in order to create something that approximates a penis.
00:16:04 Now, this is all presented as if this is the easiest thing in the world.
00:16:07 Yeah, yeah. And I think it's worth, just for a moment if I may, focusing on the extraordinary letdown this is by the adults of the children.
00:16:20 Because one of the things that happens in childhood is that you try to work out what is the realm of magic and what is the realm of reality.
00:16:28 in your single digits and even into your double digits.
00:16:36 You're trying to work out whether the stories are in some way true.
00:16:40 Now, in every single case, you learn that the realm of magic is not true.
00:16:48 But imagine if the adult world told you in some realms it is
00:16:51 and that you may not be able to wave a wand and fly
00:16:57 but if you wave a wand you could become the opposite sex it's quite straightforward really
00:17:03 you can choose you can choose quite easy people just choose you could be a boy this girl this way
00:17:09 one of the uh main advocates of this in the u.s who i quote in the book
00:17:14 uh describes this at one point in a hideous uh account i give says at one point in reaction
00:17:22 to the question of well what if people then have transitioned and then they don't want it she says
00:17:26 well you can get your breasts put back on again really yeah yeah what are we lego yes i know it's
00:17:35 extraordinary what are we made of but this is the adults lying to children yes yes and i think that
00:17:43 rod is right that this may be a catalyst issue despite being a minority of minority issue
00:17:49 because there's several things with it but just one of them is the parents know this isn't true
00:17:59 and you know Robert Conquest always said people are conservative about the things they know about
00:18:06 that's right parents know about children they know about their children and so that's the first thing
00:18:13 but the second thing that's just worth highlighting quickly on that is the reason why the trans thing
00:18:17 keeps on tripping people up and i give i don't i don't it sound like i'm being i i try in this
00:18:23 chapter to think as carefully as possible through the various claims being made about trans from
00:18:29 intersex all the way through the autogynophilic impulse the sexual impulse the desire to perhaps
00:18:35 get off on this all the way through to i am in the wrong body and i try to weigh up the plausible
00:18:41 things because people aren't doing this enough in our society they don't dare you know but why is it
00:18:46 The one that keeps tripping people up.
00:18:48 Because among other things, and I realise this from academics and from scientists I've been speaking to in recent years.
00:18:54 Because this is the first time, like the realm of magic, that the scientific world has been invited to lie en masse.
00:19:04 Pretend the chromosomes are performative.
00:19:09 That they don't really exist.
00:19:11 Pretend the sciences are wrong and the social sciences are right.
00:19:16 I think the thing, Douglas, as well, you know, you're talking about how these things have been weaponised and it seems entirely, entirely correct.
00:19:28 But therefore, the idea that somehow this is sincere, that people just want to further the, you know, the lives of minorities, the social justice warrior kind of argument.
00:19:42 would you say therefore that it is not actually sincere it's all about basically if you like
00:19:49 having a go at the white patriarchy my view is there's different different groups going on there
00:19:56 is one as i say that is absolutely clear a political force a battering ram these are the
00:20:02 people who enter any public discussion with one aim which is the hope that they can dishonestly
00:20:07 misrepresent something somebody else has said as either homophobic racist sexist or something else
00:20:15 there are all these tripwires now yeah all over the place they've laid them and by the way my
00:20:19 my self-appointed task in this book is to say i want to clear the minefield of it yeah i want to
00:20:24 run into it and set off some of the mines in order that other people can too because it is not
00:20:30 possible in a free society that we cannot talk about all the things that matter you have sort
00:20:36 actually you you've already run into the mindful since the book's been out when we've had a couple
00:20:40 of great examples that came along just after your book we had the justin trudeau you know
00:20:46 fascinating actually because he is not you know he is a social justice warrior actually in a way
00:20:51 yeah the ultimate social justice and also we had the thing with sam smith and in fact you
00:20:55 you went on the was it the uh radio program yeah and um but and i think someone came unstuck there
00:21:02 Yes, well, I said live on air, which what 99.9% of the population know and would like to say,
00:21:10 which is that non-binary doesn't exist.
00:21:15 It's not a thing, actually.
00:21:18 It's, or let me put it another way.
00:21:21 If it is a thing, prove it to me.
00:21:23 Show me, tell me.
00:21:25 Don't just order me to change the language.
00:21:28 I mean Sam Smith himself who made this announcement just in time for the publication of this book
00:21:33 said that you know he came out as he came out as gay four years ago he came out as gender queer two
00:21:38 years ago he obviously hadn't had enough attention for a bit and so he came out as non-binary this
00:21:43 year I just I don't want to be particularly mean to him I don't much like his music I don't much
00:21:46 like his voice but so what what I mind is that he would make a demand of the general public
00:21:54 including call me they them pronouns and say in his statement i don't understand yet what this is
00:22:01 but i look forward to the day when i can talk about i look forward to that to that day too sam
00:22:06 can't wait i've got it in the diary the day when you can come out and tell us all what non-binary
00:22:11 is in the meantime would you mind if we didn't mutilate the language and would you mind if we
00:22:16 didn't pretend that chromosomes don't exist and would you would you mind if if women didn't have
00:22:22 to be told that because you feel a bit feminine today sam that you're a woman that day yes yes
00:22:27 would you mind awfully yeah yeah and the point is everybody knows this outside a few social
00:22:33 scientists and a couple of half-paid bloggers at the guardian nobody actually follows this
00:22:40 but equally nobody says it i could sense it in the today program studio when i said it the
00:22:44 presenters were worried but i know they they want people to say everyone wants people to say this
00:22:50 because everyone knows that we're being invited into a lie.
00:22:52 And here's, if I may say so, the main thing about that.
00:22:55 I don't just mind the lie because I don't like lies.
00:22:58 I mind the lie because I think it's profoundly demoralizing to society.
00:23:02 I think it's profoundly demoralizing for everybody.
00:23:05 That no matter how prominent you are or how private you are as an individual,
00:23:12 that you are meant to acquiesce in a little lie.
00:23:16 This one's just being asked by Sam Smith.
00:23:19 But the point is that we know that it's demoralising.
00:23:22 And it's demoralising because the little lie means you'll be asked to agree to a bigger one down the line.
00:23:27 Speaking of lies and evasions, you're very funny in the book at one point, actually.
00:23:33 Just one.
00:23:34 Oh, many times.
00:23:35 I'd like to think.
00:23:37 But there's one particular point where you talk about where a lot of this originated in sort of colleges in America.
00:23:44 Are you talking 60s, 70s, maybe?
00:23:46 Yeah.
00:23:47 So basically enough to come through in a couple of generations to where we are now.
00:23:52 But you talk about the extraordinary language that is used by the followers of Michel Foucault and people.
00:24:02 And just basically how it is entirely obscured because there is nothing really being said.
00:24:09 Yes, there's a type of language which is being cultivated in places like Berkeley University.
00:24:15 where you can tell the prose is so execrable
00:24:19 that it's clearly designed either not to say anything
00:24:23 or to disguise the fact that what it is trying to say is a lie.
00:24:28 I give a quote from...
00:24:29 I've got it right here, but it's a very long one.
00:24:31 Judith Butler, yes.
00:24:32 I did the audio book for The Madness of Crowds.
00:24:37 Actually, Douglas, would you read it for us?
00:24:38 I've got it here. I'm sorry.
00:24:40 It's just perfect. This is by Judith Butler, you say?
00:24:42 Judith Butler.
00:24:43 She's the gender theorist at Berkeley who, unbelievably highly cited, I'm not citing an obscure figure here.
00:24:50 She's extremely widely cited.
00:24:54 It's her book Gender Trouble, among others, that advocates this idea that gender is about performativity.
00:25:02 Anyhow, I say, yes, here's just one sentence from Judith Butler in full flow.
00:25:07 I'll try to do it in one breath, I probably can't.
00:25:09 The move from a structuralist account in which capital is understood to structure social relations in relatively homologous ways to a view of hegemony in which power relations are subject to repetition, convergence and re-articulation brought the question of temporality into the thinking of structure and marked a shift from a form of Althusserian theory which takes structural tonalities as theoretical objects to one in which the insights into the contingent possibility of structure inaugurate a renewed conception of hegemony as bound up with the contingent sites and strategies of the re-articulation.
00:25:39 articulation of power now well done now i would submit that that is a lie because if we agree that
00:25:50 we're not the stupidest people in the world we're relatively well educated and relatively well read
00:25:56 and so on then then we should be able to find such a sentence comprehensible and it isn't now this
00:26:03 gets to one of the roots of all of this, which is why, you see, when I started looking at
00:26:08 the intellectual roots of the intersexual movement, I was genuinely amazed. I assumed
00:26:14 that there was a body of scholarship, serious scholarship, relatively unreadable scholarship,
00:26:19 I assumed that in advance, this is from the American Academy, so it goes without saying,
00:26:24 but I assumed that it would be some form of serious scholarship, and I was amazed to discover
00:26:29 it's either things like this
00:26:32 or, as in the case of Peggy McIntosh
00:26:35 the author of one of the foundational texts
00:26:37 of intersectionalism
00:26:39 merely a few pages of assertions
00:26:42 now, but here again is the thing
00:26:46 that's the problem for the American Academy
00:26:50 which has, goodness knows, a lot of problems
00:26:53 and in substantial
00:26:55 examples should just be shut down i mean it has nothing to add it hasn't added nothing for a very
00:27:02 long time but that's not the interesting thing the interesting thing is why would these claims
00:27:09 have had such an amazingly easy run across the culture and i go back to this thing of the post
00:27:17 2008 thing to some extent the adults in the last 10 years in particular appear to have become so
00:27:23 demoralized that they've given up on certain things or have sued for peace by saying sure
00:27:29 we'll give you the intrinsic bias training for instance in major banks energy companies and much
00:27:40 more the implicit bias tests are rife despite having already been basically disowned by two
00:27:48 out of the three people who formed the first of the tests who said this wasn't meant to be used
00:27:53 like this yeah why would all of these major corporations be you know you'd have thought that
00:28:00 if you wanted to use the work of judith butler and the implicit bias test people and all these
00:28:06 sort of things you'd have thought you'd have liked to have seen it tried out successfully
00:28:09 somewhere once yeah yes before you decided to do it in every western government and every major
00:28:16 corporation all the fortune 500 you'd have thought you'd have tried to tried it out once
00:28:21 and all of this is being tried in company after company when it is demonstrably not going to work
00:28:30 do you think there's a sort of way back from this well there has to be doesn't there
00:28:36 I'm determined to help us get out of this
00:28:46 because several reasons
00:28:47 the first is that the part of it that's simply a political push
00:28:51 has to be resisted
00:28:53 I think it's deeply immoral to be using people
00:28:58 people of different skin colours as battering rams against each other
00:29:02 for a political project is sick
00:29:03 i think it's sick to be using uh racial or sexual minorities in this manner for political ends
00:29:10 so that has to be stopped identified and stopped but there's also this aspect of it which
00:29:19 because we we've talked a bit about the the deliberate aspect that bit but there is also
00:29:25 this aspect of young people who are looking to understand the world as we always have and who
00:29:35 are being offered this as an answer now they are I would submit to put it most strongly being invited
00:29:42 to waste their lives it's not the case that everything in life is centered around power
00:29:50 It's actually quite a moving part in the book at the end
00:29:53 where you talk about the fact that leading an entirely political life,
00:29:59 as you might put it, is an unrewarding thing.
00:30:02 And I think you go off, basically find it.
00:30:06 You know, when you talk about what do people talk about,
00:30:10 what do they value in life, it's not positions of power as such,
00:30:13 but it's love and it's things like this.
00:30:16 Charity, love, forgiveness, family, friends.
00:30:18 Yes.
00:30:19 Meaning.
00:30:20 yes so if you i'm among other things as you as you allude to at the end of the book
00:30:25 in the ways out of this one of my suggestions is that we do exactly the opposite of what the
00:30:29 age is inviting us to do and we depoliticize our lives do not use every aspect of your life for
00:30:35 political ends but but there's something more in this which is that um for young people starting
00:30:45 out and i know because i speak to people i travel all around the world all the time and i speak to
00:30:51 an increasing number of young people who turn out for things and who have so much to offer in their
00:30:56 lives you know they aren't just smart they're smart and have access to more information than
00:31:02 any of their forebears could have dreamt of so why would they be wasting their time with this crap
00:31:09 why would the best years of their thought
00:31:13 be devoted to working out for instance
00:31:16 and we haven't yet talked about it yet
00:31:17 but the privilege game
00:31:19 why would they be spending their lives
00:31:21 playing this unwinnable game
00:31:23 of working out based on their sexual orientation
00:31:26 skin pigmentation
00:31:27 sex slash gender
00:31:29 and various other characteristics
00:31:30 where and when they are allowed to think
00:31:32 speak and listen
00:31:34 why would they be doing that
00:31:36 but my invitation among other things is
00:31:39 if we say let's not play this game because it's unwinnable why don't we try to work out what we
00:31:47 should be doing and to say to the next generation coming through it's not just don't play these
00:31:56 unwinnable games but think of all the things you could be doing instead rather than this
00:32:03 global lifelong invitation to navel gaze and then compare your navel with other people's navels
00:32:12 and think that that's going to give you meaning or solve any of the many things we could do with
00:32:18 solving. Isn't it encouraging though to you that I mentioned at the beginning of the program also
00:32:24 you mentioned it there you've been doing taking part in some of these quite huge events I mean
00:32:30 there was one at the O2 wasn't there recently with uh was it Jordan Peterson and Sam Harris and Sam
00:32:35 Harris um this seems to me to be something that's quite new um where basically you are discussing
00:32:42 issues such as this on stage in front of huge audiences this is surely very encouraging yeah
00:32:49 I'm encouraged by the whole thing I'm encouraged by the next generation um I think I think they
00:32:57 could do amazing things. I'll give you an example
00:32:59 of why. Everywhere I go
00:33:01 I've been pretty much in a different country every week
00:33:03 in recent years.
00:33:05 And I
00:33:07 everywhere I go
00:33:09 the young
00:33:11 people I speak to are at exactly the same
00:33:13 place in the debate. Really?
00:33:17 I was
00:33:18 in Reykjavik a few weeks ago for
00:33:19 Icelandic translation of my last book and
00:33:22 took the opportunity
00:33:23 to look around a bit.
00:33:25 And in the street in Reykjavik
00:33:27 a young guy comes up to me and says
00:33:29 oh I know you from
00:33:30 and names various podcasts and so on
00:33:33 and
00:33:35 we get talking
00:33:36 that young guy
00:33:38 was at exactly the same place
00:33:41 in Reykjavik that young smart
00:33:43 people are in Washington
00:33:45 in LA, in London
00:33:47 in Bratislava
00:33:49 in all around the world
00:33:50 and
00:33:52 so this, there's several things about this
00:33:55 that are interesting and very
00:33:57 um very moving one is the access to information which in the first stages appeared to be hellish
00:34:08 is providing us with an answer right it's connecting people in a way which we were told
00:34:15 it would but we hadn't quite foreseen some of the consequences of that and that means that a smart
00:34:20 young man or woman anywhere in the world can if they have access to online be at the forefront
00:34:27 of the discussions of their age right but then the second thing comes from that which is in that case
00:34:34 think of what you could do with your life think of the amount of things you could solve and address
00:34:44 anywhere anywhere and so i want to take this wretched intersectional identity politics thing
00:34:56 apart because i want young people in particular to spend as little time as possible enmeshed
00:35:04 in these games there's going to be another opportunity for them to come and and uh
00:35:13 and see you talking about this, isn't there, if they want to soon.
00:35:17 You're going to be talking to Lionel Shriver.
00:35:19 That's right.
00:35:20 When is that, Douglas?
00:35:21 That's the 28th of October.
00:35:23 It's in London.
00:35:25 I much urge anyone who's in the vicinity of the continent to come.
00:35:33 Yes, Lionel Shriver and I are doing an evening together
00:35:37 talking about these issues, among others.
00:35:38 that event's put on by The Spectator
00:35:43 it follows an event I did with Roger Scruton
00:35:45 just before the summer
00:35:47 I wanted to actually
00:35:48 before we end just talk a bit about Roger Scruton
00:35:51 you were a huge champion of him
00:35:55 he came on our programme
00:35:57 just after the whole thing had happened
00:35:59 in relation to what you're talking about here
00:36:03 do you think the fact that
00:36:05 he was reinstated
00:36:07 was any form of, let's say, victory
00:36:11 or was that a sign that something might change
00:36:15 because he had, you know, he was hugely misrepresented
00:36:20 but he fell foul of all these various preoccupations, didn't he?
00:36:25 Because a young journalist called George Eaton lied
00:36:28 and thought that we live in an era in which you're allowed to lie
00:36:33 and you get away with it.
00:36:34 and I hate that and it's not just that I admire and know Roger been friends with
00:36:44 him for almost 20 years but that there's no way I was going to let them get him
00:36:50 and yes the moment that Eton and the New Statesman published these lies I decided
00:37:00 to undo them, to expose them. I knew immediately it was a lie. The editor of the New Statesman,
00:37:05 Jason Cowley, should have known immediately it was a lie. By the way, we live in such
00:37:09 a deracinated media culture that 10 years ago, Johann Hari is found to be lying, and
00:37:14 even what was left of the Independent then managed to realise he had to go. 10 years
00:37:20 later, George Eaton, deputy editor of the New Statesman, lies, lies about the transcripts,
00:37:24 lies about a philosopher, lies about a major public figure, lies to MPs, lies to the Cabinet,
00:37:30 and he's still at the New Statesman.
00:37:33 So there's something so deracinated about the media culture as well
00:37:38 that that's possible these days,
00:37:40 and nobody thinks, apart from a small number of us perhaps,
00:37:43 that it's reprehensible, utterly reprehensible that that should be possible.
00:37:48 And yes, I knew immediately that it was a lie.
00:37:51 I showed that. I think I exposed it.
00:37:54 And yes, and Roger Scruton ended up getting his job back.
00:37:58 But here's the thing.
00:38:00 That trick that Eton did could be done on anyone.
00:38:06 And most people do not have enough of a public profile to be able to have defenders.
00:38:13 Most people aren't in the position of having people in the fortunate position that I am in, for instance,
00:38:18 who can push back against that with the media platforms that we have.
00:38:22 Most people, in fact, fear that.
00:38:25 if there's a good thing about it it's that as Fraser Nelson said at the time it was one of the
00:38:31 first media pile-ons in which people ended up paying a price for joining in in that the MPs
00:38:38 who joined in in trying to throw out Roger Scruton from polite society all themselves paid a price
00:38:45 in the end because people didn't like it they didn't admire them in fact they thought incredibly
00:38:51 badly of them those who joined in so that that's one thing I mean another is just that
00:38:56 we also cannot live in a society this stupid we can't we Andrew Gwynne the Labour frontbench
00:39:07 spokesman who attacked Roger Scruton when he was initially appointed by the government last autumn
00:39:11 said in one of his public statements I mean this is a man so dim I'd be surprised if he'd finished
00:39:18 any short book and he says in a statement about Roger Scruton that somebody with Roger Scruton's
00:39:27 views not just shouldn't have any public appointment but has no place in the modern world
00:39:34 okay Andrew Gwynne where are we to go in future for information about Kant and Hegel are we going
00:39:42 to come to the Labour front bench are we going to be asking Diane Abbott and Andrew Gwynne and
00:39:48 a few other geniuses if they can explain 19th century German thought to us but this is what
00:39:55 we're being invited to agree to we're being invited to agree to a public square so stupid
00:40:01 and deracinated that people who actually are thoughtful and have thought about things can be
00:40:08 disappeared at the whim of an ignoramus or in the case of the new statesman a liar
00:40:14 and I think that quite frankly a bit more civic courage is needed a few more
00:40:25 adults are needed and we see this every single day that's why I say that if you
00:40:31 if I can condense what I'm trying to demonstrate in the madness of crowds it
00:40:36 is to say we are as a society becoming stupider because we're pretending to
00:40:41 know about things we don't know about and we're pretending not to know about
00:40:45 things everyone knew till yesterday. Douglas, great summing up. Thank you very
00:40:52 very much. The book is actually called, as you said, The Madness of Crowds. It's out
00:40:56 now. It's brilliant so do read it. Douglas, thank you very very much for coming in.
00:41:02 It's a wonderful conversation. Thank you. It's a great pleasure. That's it. Do subscribe, won't you?
00:41:08 And see you next time. Thank you.
00:41:11 You