New Culture Forum - November 16, 2019


S2.06 Emma Webb: Defining Islamophobia

S2.03 Martin Durkin: Media Bias & Brexit Snobbery S2.10 Theodore Dalrymple: Britain's Vanishing Culture & Character

Episode Stats


Length

30 minutes

Words per minute

150.65

Word count

4,637

Sentence count

138


Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
00:00:00 hello and welcome to so what you're saying is I'm Peter Whittle now my guest today is the editor
00:00:22 of this new publication. It's called Islamophobia, an anthology of concerns. It's published by the
00:00:31 Civitas think tank. Emma Webb is the director of Civitas's forum for integration, democracy and
00:00:40 extremism. She has tended in her work to concentrate on Islamist extremism and how it works particularly
00:00:47 in the public sphere and she's written for many publications such as the Times, Telegraph and
00:00:53 Spectator. Very good, thanks for coming on Emma. Thank you for having me. Can we start, this is a
00:01:00 response, this report, this collection of essays, it's a response to what exactly? So in November
00:01:07 2018 the APPG on British Muslims released a report that was the result of all of their evidence
00:01:16 collection to try to define Islamophobia as a working definition that they were proposing
00:01:22 get adopted by particular bodies and by the government nationally as a means of trying
00:01:28 to deal with Islamophobia or what most people would say should be anti-Muslim hatred. The
00:01:35 anthology was really responding to, I would say, particular parts of the report that were
00:01:40 chilling but actually the report overall was so concerning to so many people
00:01:46 that earlier this year we had an open letter response that was addressed to the Home Secretary
00:01:53 asking him to consider the concerns because we realised after the APPG had published this
00:02:02 report and the Home Affairs Select Committee had been set up to assess the evidence for whether
00:02:07 or not it should be adopted, all of these bodies, political parties and so on, started adopting the
00:02:13 definition before the evidence had been weighed up. And so it was just being adopted without
00:02:19 scrutiny. And there were a number of people from all across the spectrum, political, religious,
00:02:25 non-religious, all of whom were extremely concerned about the implications of the definition for
00:02:31 various things, particularly sort of summed up under the umbrella of civil liberties, free speech
00:02:37 and so on and so we sort of got together and put together this open letter to the Home Secretary
00:02:44 and off the back of that we also put together this anthology so it brought together you know
00:02:49 activists and experts in various areas to put forward their various concerns not all of the
00:02:57 concerns agree with each other but as a way of bringing everything together because we were
00:03:03 concerned that there wasn't proper scrutiny of the definition and that if it was adopted without that
00:03:09 we would be in serious trouble well before we look at that definition i get to have a look here
00:03:15 some of the people it is very wide we've got peter tatchell um we have the
00:03:20 dr rami hassan david green hardeep singh i mean you know this sort of basically is uh
00:03:30 as you say, right across the board. Can we start, actually, Emma, because people will be
00:03:36 maybe not familiar with it. What is the definition that the all-party group came up with? How does
00:03:43 it sound? I can read out the definition because I think their own words are more chilling than mine
00:03:48 ever could be. Islamophobia is rooted in racism and is a type of racism that targets expressions
00:03:55 of muslimness or perceived muslimness muslimness yeah um and as you can tell from the definition
00:04:02 it's impossible to um enforce it doesn't really mean anything it's just post-modernist jargon
00:04:09 what does muslimness mean who who gets to be the arbiter of that you know what's what group are
00:04:14 they talking about what is perceived muslimness you know there's not one single um muslim community
00:04:20 in the uk so what are they referring to there um and the concern that we all had about that is that
00:04:27 really what it is is a backdoor blasphemy law because it is founded on the concept of cultural
00:04:32 racism um and by definition it therefore um oversteps the mark of anti-muslim hatred as you
00:04:40 would have with you know anti-seek hatred or you know hatred against any other um religion right
00:04:46 Christianity, for example. And it starts to get into the very subjective grey area of, you know, microaggressions, structural Islamophobia, and into the realm of ideas, belief and practice, because its idea of expressions of Muslimness starts to go really attacking that would be attacking things like Islamic practices or particular Islamic beliefs.
00:05:16 With the definition, you mentioned at the beginning there
00:05:20 that without scrutiny, some people would take...
00:05:23 Well, I happen to know that's true.
00:05:25 I think of the Mayor of London, for example.
00:05:27 I think he accepted the definition. Isn't that right?
00:05:31 But, I believe.
00:05:32 But, you know, in terms of the government,
00:05:36 they actually rejected it, didn't they?
00:05:38 Yeah.
00:05:39 For the time being, or blank it?
00:05:42 So, the case with the Conservative Party is interesting
00:05:45 because obviously they've been under a lot of pressure from people like Baroness Farsi
00:05:49 who is part of the APPG and very influential, sort of pushing the definition
00:05:53 and pushing the cause of trying to stamp out Islamophobia as they see it.
00:05:58 The Conservative Party are obviously in a particularly pressured position
00:06:05 and they did refuse to adopt the definition when every single other party,
00:06:10 including the Scottish Conservatives, so the SNP, Plaid Cymru...
00:06:14 And the Liberal Democrats and City Hall, as you mentioned, all adopted the definition as well as a number of councils, Harrow, Oxford, Regbridge, Islington, Lambeth as well, an ever increasing list.
00:06:28 The Conservatives did reject the definition under Theresa May, but then Theresa May set in motion the process to establish a definition of Islamophobia.
00:06:39 And the person that she appointed as the independent advisor to that process is an imam called Kari Asim, who has himself accused Boris Johnson in the past of Islamophobia for his criticisms of all the things that he said about Islamic dress.
00:06:53 and so the conservative party are moving in the direction of defining islamophobia
00:07:00 and the concern there is that any definition of islamophobia because of you know what the word
00:07:06 means as opposed to anti-muslim hatred is in dangerous territory and being able to propose
00:07:13 a definition you know that's any less dangerous than the one that's already been proposed by the
00:07:18 APPG it's a very slim chance that they'll do that and so the conservative party is a slightly
00:07:24 different case but the definition has sort of been adopted with a rat by by sort of circumventing
00:07:32 the usual processes and so really when it comes to pressuring them to adopt it nationally
00:07:37 they can say well you know everybody's already adopted it so so should you
00:07:42 there are there are a number of particular distinct grounds you sort of you've already
00:07:49 mentioned which are you know the main objections which are illustrated by this uh by this booklets
00:07:55 but if we can just go go through them first of all you've got the very vagueness right you
00:08:00 this is this term muslims i mean can you can you just explain again you know what are they
00:08:08 getting at I mean what or should I say how how do the problems present
00:08:13 themselves if if you know if you're to go by that definition which um it's so
00:08:19 unworkable it's obviously unworkable to anyone that Muslimness is a nonsense
00:08:24 concept and so is the idea of it being a form of racism being a Muslim is not
00:08:30 being part of a particular race there is a huge diversity of Muslim communities
00:08:34 from all sorts of backgrounds including white convert muslims being able to enforce the
00:08:40 definition is impossible if you try to imagine the police for example having to work with the
00:08:48 concept of muslimness what does that mean and it's opened so much to abuse from particular interest
00:08:55 groups lobby groups the people who were behind the definition sort of pushing it and they will
00:09:00 be the people who potentially police what muslimness means and you have people for example
00:09:05 like kanta ahmed who um she got accused of being an islamophobe because of her comments about the
00:09:11 for example you can imagine lgbt muslims um being called islamophobes for their criticism of islamic
00:09:18 beliefs uh or or treatment of um lgbt people as we saw um recently you know in other countries
00:09:25 and the treatment of LGBT people there,
00:09:30 you can imagine feminist Muslims, for example,
00:09:34 who would be attacked for being Islamophobes.
00:09:37 And so you can disagree with LGBT campaigners,
00:09:43 you can disagree with feminist campaigners,
00:09:45 but even those who disagree with them
00:09:47 couldn't really call them Islamophobes for attacking
00:09:51 or disagreeing with particular aspects of Islamic belief and practice.
00:09:55 And so the idea of Muslimness as part of this definition,
00:10:00 it's so elastic and so subjective
00:10:03 that it could be used in a way to sort of trample on people's civil liberties
00:10:12 and try to deprive them of their free speech.
00:10:14 And we've seen that with the way that it's been used already.
00:10:19 Well, that's the second area, really, which is about freedom of expression,
00:10:24 isn't it freedom of freedom of speech um you know this would obviously seriously hamper people
00:10:33 wouldn't it i mean you know whether it's journalists or even creative people or whatever
00:10:37 yeah i mean we've seen the way that it has been used in the the debate uh in december last year
00:10:42 when baroness farsi was talking about the definition itself and she used andrew gilligan
00:10:48 as an example now andrew gilligan is a journalist who does investigative work into islamism
00:10:52 And so the concern is actually this doesn't protect Muslims any more than the current law protects them.
00:10:58 What it does is it protects Islamists from scrutiny and people who have been criticised like Dominic Kennedy, for example, for his work investigating Islamism.
00:11:07 People like Peter Clarke for looking at the Trojan Horse Affair.
00:11:09 People like Sarah Champion for looking at issues to do with Rotherham.
00:11:13 And the list just goes on and on.
00:11:15 Louise Casey, Sarah Khan, the counter-extremism commissioner, Muslims like, for example, Majid Nawaz, who work on counter-extremism.
00:11:23 And all of these people have been attacked for being Islamophobes in the past.
00:11:27 We see the way that the people who were involved in creating the definition used the term and the way that it is used.
00:11:34 And in fact, the history of the term itself, it's so closely associated with anti-blasphemy and particularly hostility against Islam.
00:11:45 that it just poses an enormous, enormous danger to free speech,
00:11:50 almost, pardon the pun, by definition.
00:11:52 Yes.
00:11:54 And it's genuinely chilling.
00:11:56 Actually, I could read out some quotes from the APPG's report themselves.
00:12:03 This is the all-parliamentary party group.
00:12:06 Yeah, so one of the things that they did is they have insisted
00:12:11 that this wouldn't trample on free speech the police interestingly enough bought into that
00:12:20 because we weren't talking about the councils and political parties the police also originally came
00:12:25 out against it because of concerns that it would undermine security and counter-extremism
00:12:29 legislation and policy and then they did a complete u-turn and they wrote to the government
00:12:34 and said that they should adopt the definition because they'd been reassured by the community
00:12:38 that actually it wouldn't have that effect,
00:12:41 that it wouldn't have any legal grounding,
00:12:44 that it wouldn't be a legal definition,
00:12:46 which is nonsense because even though afterwards
00:12:49 the APPG members did say it's not supposed to be legally binding,
00:12:53 as I will read to you,
00:12:54 it's quite clear that they originally intended it that way.
00:12:57 They talk about it in that context of creating a new legal framework
00:13:00 that sort of goes beyond the remits of anti-Muslim hatred.
00:13:08 And so they've reassured the police, for example, and they've done this U-turn.
00:13:13 And the police said in their letter to the government
00:13:17 that they were sorry for really basically offending the Muslim community
00:13:23 because writing the initial letter had damaged their relationship.
00:13:28 That got some press, didn't it, that letter?
00:13:30 Yeah.
00:13:30 It was covered.
00:13:31 So they had consulted various people.
00:13:33 I think they consulted MPs, members of their advisory network,
00:13:36 and they did a complete U-turn and that's quite concerning because that could pressure the
00:13:41 government in the direction of a definition similar to the APPG definition and on multiple
00:13:47 occasions including in the report itself they keep reassuring the reader or the audience that this is
00:13:54 not going to impede free speech at all but then the content of the report makes it quite clear
00:14:02 that, to me, it seems like gaslighting
00:14:05 because they say one thing
00:14:06 and then everything else indicates another.
00:14:09 They talk about, for example,
00:14:12 a test with five points
00:14:16 to decide between illegitimate and legitimate free speech.
00:14:18 And they give examples of things that wouldn't,
00:14:21 under the definition,
00:14:22 and it goes to show how it sort of steps
00:14:25 beyond the bounds of what would be narrowly defined
00:14:27 as anti-Muslim hatred.
00:14:29 And narrowly defined is something that you need
00:14:31 for something to be workable in law and policy um and they talk about for example accusing muslims
00:14:37 of entryism and that would go to like the lutva raman case for example this is in tower hamlets
00:14:43 this was the corruption case in tower hamlets council yeah um and so you know cases like that
00:14:49 um trojan horse would be another example probably um there were concerns that it would you know
00:14:53 trample on historians uh abilities to research certain things because it talks about uh not
00:14:59 saying that Muslims rule by the sword and subjugate minorities and the the most
00:15:05 two most chilling things that they've said in response to the free speech
00:15:08 concerns I'll read they said giving up the term Islamophobia and with it the
00:15:14 possibility of creating legal instruments to tackle it simply because
00:15:19 of a perceived risk that it may limit free speech would be highly misguided
00:15:23 Are you misguided?
00:15:24 And then they say also that the recourse to the notion of free speech and a supposed right to criticise Islam results in nothing more than another form, another subtle form of anti-Muslim racism, whereby criticism humiliates, marginalises and stigmatises Muslims.
00:15:44 So if you say that you're concerned on free speech grounds,
00:15:51 then you are yourself guilty of a subtle form of anti-Muslim prejudice.
00:15:56 You're an Islamophobe.
00:15:58 So I think it's quite clear they don't take free speech issues seriously.
00:16:02 And the way that they use the definition to weaponise it against people that they disagree with
00:16:09 shows exactly how it will be used.
00:16:11 it's it's uh this is a bit of a you know well-known argument but it's nevertheless the case surely
00:16:19 that there's a real problem anyway with the term in that it is you know basically islamophobia
00:16:27 the implication being that somehow you're talking about the religion and that you have an irrational
00:16:31 fear or whatever and that therefore to be islamophobic would mean that you you know you
00:16:37 would not criticize what is essentially a set of ideas it's an ideology isn't it it is it is it's
00:16:44 it's like you know you should be able to criticize christianity buddhism hinduism you should marxism
00:16:50 whatever it is it's yeah it's quite it's quite clear that even the concept that it rests on
00:16:57 of cultural racism it it pushes the boundaries out beyond the narrow limits of anti-muslim
00:17:04 hatred it's not comparable to the anti-semitism definition for example. Can you explain actually
00:17:10 because a lot of people would say well what's the difference right what would you see as being the
00:17:14 difference? Well I think the key thing is that the anti-semitism definition is more narrowly
00:17:18 understood it doesn't traipse so much into the cultural sphere it's not really the idea of
00:17:26 cultural racism Jewish people have a more hereditary aspect to their faith and so it's not
00:17:34 it doesn't it doesn't quite sort of match up but I think that the key thing is the way that
00:17:39 that they have framed this as being something that you need in addition to
00:17:46 laws to protect against anti-Muslim hatred right because we already have you know numerous pieces
00:17:53 of legislation plenty of acts that deal with discrimination against people on the grounds of
00:17:57 their religion and hate crime in that sense but they want something more they want something
00:18:03 that deals with Islamophobia as they see it on a level above anti-Muslim hatred and that's I think
00:18:12 sort of the crux of the issue I see you also mentioned though you did briefly mention there
00:18:19 was this intervention about security concerns but and they've taken that back now you're saying the
00:18:26 police have more or less taken a complete u-turn um so originally what were their concerns so
00:18:31 originally they were concerned about a number of things um a policy exchange report laid out a
00:18:36 number of areas where it could possibly undermine counter-terrorism or counter-extremism legislation
00:18:41 and policy things like as we saw with the case of Begum um the potential of uh you know accusations
00:18:48 of Islamophobia against when stripping the citizenship
00:18:53 of returning foreign fighters, issues to do with stop and search,
00:18:58 issues to do with the prescription of particular organisations
00:19:01 like Al-Muhajirun, for example, you can imagine.
00:19:04 You'd end up with the judiciary, the Ministry of Justice,
00:19:07 the prison service, prevent time and time again
00:19:11 from the same people who were heavily involved
00:19:14 in submitting evidence to and actually involved in the process
00:19:17 are putting the report together, are from groups that have called the government's counter-extremism
00:19:23 policies, time and time again they've called them Islamophobic. But it's also on the integration
00:19:29 side of things as well. So, you know, people like Amanda Spielman from Ofsted have been accused
00:19:36 of being an Islamophobe because of the case with, for example, the hijabs in St Stephen's
00:19:43 school and that was a case... Can you tell us about that, what that was again?
00:19:47 So that was a case where the school had
00:19:50 banned hijabs for little girls under a certain age
00:19:55 because of concerns that it is sexualising because of what the
00:19:59 hijab means. It's not usually necessary as it's all teenagers.
00:20:02 For girls below puberty. And so they banned the hijab and then they
00:20:06 also did a U-turn and withdrew the ban because of
00:20:11 pressure. And the Ofsted have been called Islamophobic because of that. This is the
00:20:20 same with Dame Louise Casey, who did the report on integration. And she made a very good point
00:20:28 about the fact that ideologies sometimes stop people from integrating. She mentioned particularly
00:20:33 the Diabandi ideology. And what this definition would do is silence people from doing investigations
00:20:45 into Islamism, making claims about those people who are actually trying to be divisive, trying
00:20:50 to inculcate grievances, spreading sort of identity victimhood narratives. And in that
00:20:59 sense it would be bad for integration policy as well because it would make it difficult to talk
00:21:03 about things like trojan horse like rotherham um and instances of uh entryism or um even things
00:21:13 like women's rights as well yeah you know what would your you know what kind of definition would
00:21:19 you be happy with would you recommend i don't think that we need a definition of islamophobia
00:21:26 And I think that we should stay well clear of having any definition, because one of the arguments has been that Islamophobia is a word that is in common parlance.
00:21:37 It's used as standard to refer to the phenomenon of anti-Muslim hatred.
00:21:42 But just because something is used widely in the public doesn't mean it's suitable for government legislation or policy.
00:21:49 and one of the reasons is because islamophobia is not cannot be tightly defined in the same way as
00:21:57 anti-muslim hatred can be because we already have sufficient legislation and policy surrounding
00:22:02 discrimination against people on the basis of their religion and you know we can have a process
00:22:07 put in place to look into that further within the government but the issue with with islamophobia
00:22:14 as i mentioned is that it is so broad it does go into um the territory of belief and practice
00:22:20 and the history of the word itself and how it's been used actually should suggest that we certainly
00:22:26 shouldn't be trying to seek any official definition of it because even going back to
00:22:30 so if we talk about the origins of the word islamophobia um if we go back to some have
00:22:36 suggested that it may have originated in france edward saeed used the term to refer to hostility
00:22:41 against islam um and it's it was used for example by uh apologists of the iranian revolution in
00:22:50 1979 um and it made its way into our uh into our vocabulary really in the 1980s most people credit
00:22:59 the runny me trust with popularizing it and you can actually see in the statistics there's a massive
00:23:03 spike after um 19 the 1997 report when that's right this was a report done by the runny me trust
00:23:10 Yeah, so the Runnymede Trust did a report on the phenomenon of Islamophobia in the UK, and they actually described as part of it open and closed attitudes towards Islam and closed being sort of on the bigoted side of things.
00:23:26 And again, it was within the context of Islam as a religion.
00:23:33 And there are many activists, for example, who want to protect Islam from criticism
00:23:44 because they see criticism of Islam as a way of stigmatizing Muslims,
00:23:48 which is a very slippery slope, obviously.
00:23:50 And when it made its way into the British vocabulary, it was around the time of the Salman Rushdie affair, for example.
00:23:58 And it was knocking about in the company of people who were lobbying for blasphemy laws.
00:24:06 There were organisations in the 1980s who were trying to get blasphemy laws changed or new blasphemy laws to accommodate protecting Islam
00:24:17 because they thought that that would be good to create sort of social harmony
00:24:20 and one of the particular organisations that has been involved in lobbying with the UN
00:24:28 was trying to lobby for laws against defamation of religion
00:24:34 and even though they backtracked on that policy in 2012
00:24:39 the APPG actually held a workshop with them
00:24:44 And so Islamophobia and blasphemy have been knocking about each other's company for, well, really for as long as the term has been about.
00:24:55 And it has always been to do with a criticism of Islam as being an attack on Muslims.
00:25:02 But I think the government need to be clear that criticism of Islam is not an attack on Muslims.
00:25:08 And that if we are going to deal with anti-religious hatred or discrimination against any group, that we can't have one rule for some and a different rule for others.
00:25:21 You know, what about the Sikhs? What about the Hindus? What about the Christians? They also suffer discrimination as well.
00:25:26 But it's not good to go down the route of having a proliferation of phobias.
00:25:29 No, no, no.
00:25:30 And it wouldn't be something that would be workable anyway, because, I mean, I think to any normal person it would seem completely absurd.
00:25:38 the only problem with this new definition or for that matter any
00:25:44 definition you might say is that people have so internalized these things now
00:25:50 that actually it doesn't almost matter in a way yeah what the definition is
00:25:56 made up of how it's expressed because people basically now are in a state of
00:26:01 confusion about what they can do and say so consequently it's almost like free
00:26:06 speech has already been chilled.
00:26:08 I mean, so if you talked, for example,
00:26:10 about Salman Rushdie, that was
00:26:12 1990, 91?
00:26:14 And it's still very much in our consciousness.
00:26:16 And it's still very much to the extent that I can't
00:26:18 imagine that book, for example, being
00:26:20 written today. Yeah, I mean, there are so
00:26:22 many examples of,
00:26:24 you know, Charlie Hebdo is an example,
00:26:26 you know, the Danish
00:26:28 cartoon affair, where
00:26:29 the accusation of Islamophobia
00:26:31 is actually extremely dangerous
00:26:34 because it does
00:26:36 get taken in some cases as we saw with Charlie Hebdo as an excuse yes to attack
00:26:41 people and that has played a role not just in our consciousness but in in
00:26:48 across Europe that people self-censor we saw this with the the Ipsos Mori and
00:26:56 the issue to do with press freedom I want to ask you about this because this
00:26:59 is very this is actually very new isn't it what was happening to my Ipso here
00:27:03 This is the independent press standard organisation.
00:27:08 This just happens to have come out quite recently, isn't it?
00:27:10 Or should I say it's been leaked, that there are various guidelines that they are...
00:27:17 Can you explain what that is about?
00:27:19 So, Ipso put together, I believe it was at the end of 2017,
00:27:23 they put together a working group or a subcommittee to establish a...
00:27:31 or to develop guidance for journalists reporting on Islam or Muslims.
00:27:38 And again, as with the definition, they had this sort of very elastic advice
00:27:43 to be sensitive to the community, to not...
00:27:47 What does that actually mean in the end?
00:27:49 Exactly. I mean, it's so subjective.
00:27:51 And they want journalists to be careful not to be sowing tension within communities
00:27:59 and to be mindful of the consequences of their reporting,
00:28:03 for example, resulting in the harassment of particular communities.
00:28:08 And so basically their advice to journalists
00:28:10 will lead to them tiptoeing around the issue of Islam
00:28:15 and reporting on Islam.
00:28:17 And, you know, with the cases of Lutfur Rahman
00:28:19 and the issue in Tower Hamlets with the electoral fraud,
00:28:23 with Rotherham, with the Trojan Horse Affair,
00:28:27 On those and many other instances, people have been too afraid because of accusations of racism or Islamophobia to come forward.
00:28:36 It was very difficult for people like Andrew Norfolk, I imagine, also someone who's been accused of Islamophobia, to actually report on these issues.
00:28:47 and so what the press have done
00:28:49 and I believe it was Trevor Phillips
00:28:51 described it as a form of
00:28:54 media apartheid because it's
00:28:56 one rule for the Muslim
00:28:58 community and another for everyone else
00:28:59 This is Trevor Phillips saying this
00:29:01 and so
00:29:04 what they're really doing is
00:29:05 giving advice to journalists that
00:29:08 has the effect of making people
00:29:10 tentative to report on issues to do with Islam
00:29:12 and Muslims because
00:29:12 it's
00:29:15 it's it's sort of um uh moved on into the territory of activism political activism
00:29:23 and there are all sorts of issues around this that you know very detailed stuff that is you
00:29:28 know out there and people can find it themselves and make their own judgment but the the point is
00:29:33 that ipso had been um issuing this particular guidance that would have a basically a chilling
00:29:40 effect on reporting on issues to do with Islam. And it gives the impression that journalists
00:29:46 have somehow a responsibility if, you know, harassment occurs as a result.
00:29:53 It's very important what you've been doing, Emma. Thank you for coming. I mean, how do
00:29:59 people get to read this? Can they go online? Can they buy it or can they download it or
00:30:05 what?
00:30:05 So it's free online as a PDF through the Civitas website.
00:30:08 Where should they go?
00:30:10 So you can get it through the Civitas website or if you just Google Islamophobia Civitas Anthology.
00:30:17 Yeah, there you go.
00:30:18 And also I think you can buy it in a hard copy through Civitas or I think it's even on Amazon.
00:30:25 Right. And as we were saying before, it's extremely broad and there are people from right, left and secular and wherever, you know.
00:30:34 Thank you very much for coming on indeed. Thank you. It's great.
00:30:37 that's it for this time but see you next time and please in the meantime do
00:30:44 do subscribe won't you thank you very much bye