New Culture Forum - November 16, 2019


S2.07 Melanie Phillips: The Elite's Anti-Brexit Coup Proves I was Right

S2.03 Martin Durkin: Media Bias & Brexit Snobbery S2.10 Theodore Dalrymple: Britain's Vanishing Culture & Character

Episode Stats


Length

38 minutes

Words per minute

160.19

Word count

6,188

Sentence count

251


Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
00:00:00 Hello and welcome to So What You're Saying Is, I'm Peter Whittall. Now my guest today I'm
00:00:21 delighted to say is one of Britain's best-known columnists. Melanie Phillips was in fact the very
00:00:26 first person to come speak to the New Culture Forum when we were founded in 2006. She now
00:00:32 writes a column for the Times, but before that she's written extensively for the Guardian,
00:00:37 for the Observer, for the Sunday Times. She's also written numerous books, perhaps most
00:00:42 famously, All Must Have Prizes, which was about the left-wing capture of our education
00:00:47 system, Londonistan, which was about radicalisation in London, and The World Turned Upside Down,
00:00:55 which was basically about, well, the world turned upside down.
00:00:58 She's with me now.
00:01:00 Thanks very much for coming, Melanie.
00:01:02 I wanted to start because we are filming this
00:01:05 just about a week before we are meant to be leaving the EU.
00:01:10 You wrote a piece very recently about the deal and your attitude.
00:01:16 Can you tell us what you think of it?
00:01:18 Well, the deal is, in my view, a variation on Mrs May's infamous deal, which was deemed
00:01:28 so terrible the House of Commons voted it down no fewer than three times. Now, Boris
00:01:33 Johnson has improved on that deal in that he has removed the backstop, the infamous
00:01:39 backstop, and he's got one or two other things altered. But basically it remains Mrs May's
00:01:45 deal. And the great mistake, I think, that he has made, and that so many opponents of
00:01:50 Mrs May's deal made, was to focus entirely, almost entirely, on the backstop, which was
00:01:55 terrible. But nevertheless, there were other bad things about the deal, particularly, but
00:02:00 not exclusively, the way it ties up our ability to act independently in the military sphere,
00:02:06 in spheres of foreign policy, and the way in which, through the political declaration,
00:02:10 it ties any future trade deal that the UK would do with the EU
00:02:15 broadly to the principles of the single market
00:02:21 and European rules and regulations.
00:02:24 So although we would be out of the EU,
00:02:27 we would be tied to its rules and regulations
00:02:30 in a way that would prevent this country
00:02:33 from capitalising on its independence
00:02:36 to do trade deals in its own interest,
00:02:38 which is a lot of the point of leaving the European Union.
00:02:43 So in my view, although Boris poses as, you know,
00:02:47 the most Brexity prime minister anyone can think of,
00:02:52 he's actually just produced Mrs.
00:02:54 May's deal Mark IV, an improved version,
00:02:58 but still it would leave Britain in a very parlous situation.
00:03:02 And to my horror, I have observed the European research group
00:03:07 of parliamentary brexiteers including those who were called spartans because they would
00:03:13 die in the ditch to secure a proper clean break brexit they've all caved and the reason they've
00:03:21 caved isn't entirely clear to me but i would guess it's basically um uh warfare fatigue they fear
00:03:31 that if they don't take this kind of last chance deal then they won't get brexit at all
00:03:37 They fear that they will never get a more Brexity Prime Minister than Boris Johnson.
00:03:42 And I think they've been seduced by the charisma and the story.
00:03:46 He is very cleverly and not untruthfully woven around himself,
00:03:51 that he is defending parliamentary, he is defending democracy
00:03:55 and the sovereignty of the people and the right of the people
00:03:58 to have their democratic wishes fulfilled by their democratically elected representatives.
00:04:04 He is defending that against a kind of rolling coup by Remainer MPs, by Remainer Parliament, which is a coup against democracy, a coup against the sovereignty of the people in which the constitution of the country has been basically gaily ripped up.
00:04:21 And that's all true. But because he's in that position and of saying this is what I'm doing, the mystique has grown that he's actually defending Brexit.
00:04:30 But he's not, because now we have the almost impossibly entangled situation in which a prime minister who is genuinely fighting a rearguard action by people who are determined to subvert the sovereignty of the people is doing so by promoting a deal which itself would not be Brexit.
00:04:52 so this is a really horrendous situation which as we can all see at this moment in time talking to
00:05:00 you we don't know what's going to happen from one hour to the next let alone how we're going to get
00:05:04 out of this well yes it is meant to be next week on the 31st isn't it I mean what I say when I ask
00:05:10 you what do you think will happen it it seems to me that everyone thought that if we sail past the
00:05:18 31st that's Boris destroyed but that doesn't appear to be happening does it? No and I didn't
00:05:24 think that either on the contrary I always thought that his that the story he needs to tell at the
00:05:31 general election whenever it comes is that I Boris Johnson have tried my very best to do the best for
00:05:40 this country to honour parliament to honour democracy to honour the sovereignty of the people
00:05:46 and the right of the people to have their voice heard
00:05:48 and to honour the referendum result of 2016.
00:05:51 And I've done my best, but look what's happened.
00:05:53 The Remainer Parliament has succeeded in thwarting me.
00:05:57 I am now going to the country on the basis that I am the defender of democracy
00:06:02 and your sovereign right to have your voice heard.
00:06:06 Now, in my view, if he were to do so by saying,
00:06:10 and therefore I will come out without a deal, he would clean up.
00:06:15 He would destroy the Brexit Party because as things stand, if he's going to go into an election whenever it is, saying on the one hand, I'm defending democracy, on the other hand, this is my deal and that's what I'm standing for, the Brexit Party, i.e. Nigel Farage, is going to come forward and say, this is not Brexit, he is betraying you.
00:06:36 And as a result, the Tory vote is going to be split between the Tories and the Brexit Party.
00:06:44 And also, you see, if Boris were to go for a clean break, a no deal,
00:06:52 I believe he would then do what people have always thought was completely impossible.
00:06:58 He would get diehard Labour constituencies to vote Tory.
00:07:03 because I think it's hard to exaggerate the fury of the working class Brexit vote.
00:07:11 They understand exactly they have been betrayed
00:07:14 and they would even vote for Boris if he were to make this very clear stand.
00:07:20 But if he doesn't, then that vote's going to be split.
00:07:23 And of course, we can see the Labour vote will be split
00:07:25 between Labour and the newly resurgent Liberal Democrats
00:07:29 who become, for the sake of this argument, the Remainer party.
00:07:33 And so we would face a situation of complete chaos, a complete uncertainty, in which it's quite likely we would again end up with a hung parliament.
00:07:42 Maybe with Labour being a minority party governing with the help of the Lib Dems, the SNP, whoever.
00:07:50 Or it could be the Tories as another minority party. We don't know.
00:07:55 But if Boris Johnson were to, as I say, make a very clear declaration, which would mean he'd kind of have to kind of resile from the deal he's done, then I think he would clean up.
00:08:10 When you look at the past, what is it now, three and a half years, what has this whole Brexit fiasco, what has it revealed to you about Britain?
00:08:23 Has it revealed anything new?
00:08:25 Well, it revealed to me on the day that the referendum result was announced,
00:08:31 it was, to me, an absolutely stunning day.
00:08:34 Yes. Were you expecting it, though, Manny?
00:08:36 Did you think it was going to happen?
00:08:38 I thought it was quite possible, but I wasn't sure at all.
00:08:45 And given what we'd all lived through,
00:08:48 which was this torrential amount of propaganda
00:08:52 that if Britain voted to come out of the European Union,
00:08:55 you know, the apocalypse would descend,
00:08:57 the economic apocalypse would descend immediately on the country.
00:09:00 And given how, you know, the whole project fear thing,
00:09:04 and that does work.
00:09:05 And so I thought, well, you know,
00:09:07 people are going to be very influenced by that.
00:09:10 So I was pretty staggered to find that, you know,
00:09:14 what I'd hoped would happen had actually happened.
00:09:18 And I had two thoughts.
00:09:19 The first was Britain now has a chance of rescuing itself for the first time ever in my professional and indeed my entire lifetime.
00:09:29 The agenda of the West destroying left had been stopped.
00:09:36 the West destroying left which believes that the very idea of a Western nation the very idea of
00:09:43 British nationality based on its historic traditions culture religion language literature
00:09:51 all of that to uphold that is racist and we've been told that you know year in year out expressed
00:09:59 through the education system expressed through the culture people had it thrust down their throats
00:10:03 and look that that's what they voted for so for the first time I thought if you know Britain now
00:10:10 has a chance of regaining its identity and thus pulling itself out of the state of cultural
00:10:18 demoralization which in my view it's been in since the end of the second world war which made it prey
00:10:24 to all these negative west destroying Britain destroying ideologies so if it became itself
00:10:32 again and thrived then there's a chance that it can recover from its cultural
00:10:39 demoralization that was my first thought my second thought was they'll never
00:10:45 allow it they'll never allow it this cannot stand because the entire weight
00:10:51 of that liberal intelligentsia governing class whatever you like to
00:10:55 call it is so strong so overwhelming and everything they will throw everything
00:11:02 at this now to stop it because they know they know they have to stop this
00:11:07 brexit is both the symbol and the the vehicle yes for a renaissance of
00:11:13 everything that they have tried for decades to destroy so I knew this fight
00:11:18 would be titanic I didn't foresee precisely the calamitous entanglement
00:11:24 that we're now in but I knew it would be a fight to the fight to the political
00:11:29 and cultural death which is what we're in we're which is why we're in the state we're in it has
00:11:34 been relentless hasn't it over the past three years i i think there's also when you look at the
00:11:39 specifically the house of commons where it's becoming clear surely to the you know the even
00:11:45 the most ardent remainer what is going on actually it's finally the pennies i think is
00:11:50 it's dropped this past couple of weeks even um this is very dismayed because there's always this
00:11:56 view oh well you know Denmark France they've all voted twice they all had to
00:12:02 go twice we're not like that that's right that's right well we're not like
00:12:07 that that was the idea and I think from what I can see and hear and what people
00:12:14 tell me what I observe myself the fury of the people beyond the charmed circles
00:12:20 of Westminster and the cultural bubble in London the fury of people at what
00:12:25 they perceive correctly to be a coup against themselves, an attempt to thwart the democratic
00:12:36 right of the people to express their view and have it acted upon, the right that Parliament
00:12:40 itself gave them, because they came up with a wrong result, their fury is excessive. And
00:12:47 thank goodness this is Britain. Fury in Britain, it doesn't express itself through street violence
00:12:53 as so much we see in Europe goes on.
00:12:58 People in Britain are quiet.
00:13:01 They internalise it.
00:13:03 It doesn't make the fury any less,
00:13:05 but they express that fury through constitutional means,
00:13:08 through the ballot box,
00:13:09 which is why, as we now sit here,
00:13:12 the general election,
00:13:16 which is the constitutional remedy for a broken parliament,
00:13:19 which is what this is,
00:13:19 you have a prime minister who cannot move.
00:13:22 He's held hostage by his backbenchers in an unconstitutional way.
00:13:26 He can't proceed with anything, really.
00:13:29 Government has kind of stopped in any meaningful sense.
00:13:33 So the remedy for that under our constitution is that you go back to the people,
00:13:37 you say, I can't govern.
00:13:38 You go back to the people, they decide.
00:13:41 Parliament's not even allowing the people to decide.
00:13:44 This is absolutely outrageous.
00:13:46 And so I think when the election finally happens,
00:13:50 I think that the anger of the people will be expressed through the ballot box.
00:13:54 Now, quite how that anger will be expressed,
00:13:58 what result that will produce,
00:14:01 given the fragmentation that we've just been talking about,
00:14:05 the political fragmentation, it's anyone's guess.
00:14:07 I think the thing that strikes me about it,
00:14:10 which I think you sort of alluded to there,
00:14:12 is that people like 17.4 million or whatever,
00:14:15 they they now they're under no illusions how they are regarded and i don't just mean by parliament
00:14:23 i mean by the whole establishment you know racist xenophobic stupid all of these things they might
00:14:28 have had a feeling before that that was how they were thought thought about but it's been quite
00:14:33 explicit hasn't it and they now have this knowledge they have no illusions at all anymore i think that
00:14:39 There will be some form of consequence to that, surely, won't there?
00:14:45 Yes, I mean, I think people always felt that.
00:14:49 They always felt that they had been, you know, that they'd been introduced in that way.
00:14:54 And indeed, ever since the referendum result, that's what we've all been told.
00:14:57 Everybody who voted for Brexit is, by definition, an imbecile and a racist bigot.
00:15:05 and that message has been hammered home relentlessly but there's also a number of
00:15:12 Remainers who I would say are not ideological Remainers but they're people who had a very
00:15:16 I mean I don't agree with this but their position but nevertheless I think was a perfectly reasonable
00:15:21 position that they felt that Britain would be worse off and that it was it was too much of a
00:15:26 risk and that the consequences would be too too too too bad and that's why they voted Remain and
00:15:31 I respect that absolutely and among those people there is a great deal of
00:15:38 horror and anger and precisely what we're talking about and among those
00:15:41 people I found my astonishment some of them have been saying to me as far as
00:15:47 I'm concerned I want no deal I just want out because this thing has got to stop
00:15:52 yeah we voted out I didn't vote out I voted remain but we voted out and it
00:15:57 has to be respected because otherwise we're not a democracy they feel that
00:15:59 very strongly. So I think this anger goes actually across that divide which has now opened up between
00:16:06 Remain and Brexit. Do you think, I mean, being a, wrong to say, a creature of the media, I mean,
00:16:12 being a journalist, somebody who's been on countless shows, Question Time, and across the
00:16:18 board, do you think that the media certainly seems to me haven't learnt any lessons? It seems that
00:16:24 they've kind of doubled down. I mean, would you say that's true? Yes, I mean, obviously one,
00:16:29 shouldn't generalize because there are pockets of the media which are for Brexit and which
00:16:35 have remained so. But the media, without wishing to generalize, I shall now generalize, the
00:16:44 media tend to hunt in a pack and they tend to follow one's story. And whatever the story
00:16:50 is, that's the story that you can't break without being regarded as kind of extreme.
00:16:55 And the whole Brexit thing is that sort of story that, you know, first of all, Brexit is a step too far.
00:17:02 But if you're going to have Brexit, well, the only sensible Brexit is a soft Brexit.
00:17:07 And for three years, I've been trying to say to these people, there is no soft Brexit.
00:17:12 You cannot be half in, half out.
00:17:14 If you're half in, you're not out.
00:17:16 You can't be out, but a little bit in.
00:17:19 That's what a soft Brexit is.
00:17:20 It makes no sense at all.
00:17:23 It's merely a means of saying, well, we don't like Brexit and we'll really remain,
00:17:26 but we don't want to be opposed to the people's will.
00:17:29 Therefore, we'll have a soft Brexit.
00:17:30 It's dishonest.
00:17:32 It's a fundamental dishonesty.
00:17:33 I had this argument with people in the Labour Party.
00:17:36 I remember having this argument on TV with Keir Starmer.
00:17:38 I said to him, this is a lie.
00:17:40 He'd say it's a nonsense.
00:17:42 It makes no sense.
00:17:44 And he said, this is ridiculous.
00:17:45 Of course you have a soft Brexit.
00:17:47 In other words, anyone who doesn't think of Brexit as being soft is by definition extreme.
00:17:52 So anyone who, in my view then, anyone who believes in Brexit is extreme.
00:17:57 And that is why no deal is so horrifying to people, because no deal is not perfect.
00:18:03 It's much better than leave with a deal, withdrawal deal.
00:18:06 But nevertheless, the real deal that matters is the trade deal that Britain needs to make
00:18:12 in the fullness of time with the EU, in order to make any deal, your negotiating position can only
00:18:20 work if you're negotiating a position of strength. You cannot be in a position of strength. The United
00:18:26 Kingdom cannot be in a position of strength in its negotiations in the future with the European
00:18:31 Union if it's a supplicant. It has to be able to say to the European Union, we're out of here.
00:18:37 you want a deal we'll be delighted to have one but on our terms because that's what they've said to
00:18:44 us yeah you mentioned there a while ago money which i think is a so resonates with me this
00:18:53 point that when people voted it was sort of like a right look actually we're putting our foot down
00:18:58 right at this point um and i wondered you know when you talk about the kind of reversal and
00:19:07 the demoralisation
00:19:09 that's happened in Britain
00:19:11 and I would say actually in the West
00:19:13 when you look at that
00:19:16 it's something you cover in your book
00:19:17 The World Turned Upside Down
00:19:19 about this lack of resolve
00:19:21 to defend
00:19:23 or even to understand the basis
00:19:25 of our civilisation
00:19:27 Judeo-Christian basis of our civilisation
00:19:29 when you look at the
00:19:31 so-called populist movements
00:19:33 that you see in Europe or Trump
00:19:35 and America or whatever, do you think
00:19:37 that that is a response to that do you think that they are do you think that
00:19:40 that is a form of response to to that very degradation as it were very much
00:19:45 so I mean you've got a situation where the entire political establishment in
00:19:50 the West has basically sung from the same hymn sheet for decades which with
00:19:56 some variations has been basically we have to be in a globalist world because
00:20:07 Not just because it's economically to our advantage, but because there is something terribly wrong with the very idea of the nation-state.
00:20:17 In my view, this demoralisation across the West goes back to the Holocaust and the Second World War.
00:20:23 In fact, I would say it goes back further.
00:20:25 It goes back to the trenches of the First World War.
00:20:27 And you could say that it's actually wrapped up with the Enlightenment, the 18th century Enlightenment,
00:20:33 which had the seeds of this destruction because it elevated the individual.
00:20:38 But that's a bigger and more complex argument.
00:20:40 I think you can certainly say that the Second World War and the Holocaust
00:20:45 had a shattering effect on Western morale because there it was,
00:20:52 one of the very worst crimes in human history,
00:20:55 in the very crucible of high Western culture, Germany.
00:21:02 You know, a country which thought of itself as so cultured, so educated.
00:21:08 It loved Goethe. It loved Beethoven. It loved Schiller.
00:21:12 And it produced one of the most barbaric regimes ever known to humanity.
00:21:17 And I think that did something terrible to the Western idea of itself as the embodiment of reason,
00:21:25 the embodiment of progress, and in particular the idea that the nation did this,
00:21:31 that nationalism did this now in my view this was actually a mistake because in my view hitler was
00:21:36 not a nationalist indeed hitler despised nationalism as being petty and and and narrow
00:21:44 what hitler was in his mind was an imperialist he believed that he was a reincarnation of the
00:21:50 holy roman emperor he was going to restore the holy roman empire to that end he had to occupy
00:21:56 everyone else's country. And if Britain hadn't been nationalist, if Britain in 1940 hadn't had
00:22:05 the strongest belief in itself as a nation defending itself against oppression and tyranny,
00:22:14 but a nation which understood what it was, founded on particular principles of democracy and liberty
00:22:20 and all that, it would never afford Hitler.
00:22:23 We wouldn't be sitting here today.
00:22:25 So this is a profound mistake, but that mistake has led people
00:22:29 to basically negate the idea of the nation in Europe.
00:22:32 So the peoples of Europe have nowhere to go.
00:22:34 They have no way of expressing their belief in themselves as a nation,
00:22:39 no way of articulating through a democratic process
00:22:43 their belongingness to something, to a shared national project.
00:22:48 And so since the entire political class has abandoned them on this, it's left a vacuum in which has risen up so-called populist movements.
00:22:59 Now, some of these movements, in my view, are no more than movements which aim to restore a good sense of national identity and purpose.
00:23:09 And some of them are obnoxious and founded in racism and all kinds of other stuff.
00:23:16 Nazism, you know, they have Nazi backgrounds, but people have nowhere else to go.
00:23:21 So that's why you're seeing this phenomenon in Europe.
00:23:26 You started off in a completely different political guise.
00:23:31 You were very much on the left, weren't you?
00:23:33 And I just want to talk about anti-Semitism and racism there.
00:23:37 This is one of the big, obviously, issues of our time,
00:23:40 the apparent inability of the Labour Party to deal with this particular issue.
00:23:45 Unwillingness, inability, call it what you want.
00:23:48 I just wonder, when you were on the left, were you in the Labour Party?
00:23:53 I never joined any political party at all.
00:23:58 The only isms to which I subscribe ever, have subscribed ever, are journalism and Judaism.
00:24:03 I never belonged to anything.
00:24:07 But I very kindly mentioned my earlier books,
00:24:10 but I wrote a book which was published in paperback last year
00:24:15 by an American publisher called Guardian Angel.
00:24:18 This is your memoir, isn't it?
00:24:19 Yes, which is a personal and political memoir.
00:24:22 But it's basically, it describes the reasons why I moved my political position.
00:24:29 And through that personal story,
00:24:31 I believe it tells a story of what happened to Britain and the West culturally.
00:24:35 And along the way, certainly, anti-Semitism played quite an important part in that.
00:24:41 I just wonder whether when you were on the left, even though you weren't in a party,
00:24:45 whether you experienced left-wing anti-Semitism.
00:24:49 Did you see it then? You're talking about the 1970s, really.
00:24:54 Yes. I only saw it tangentially when I was growing up.
00:24:59 You know, there were occasional remarks made at my family, but it was very much a kind
00:25:06 of fringe thing.
00:25:10 I don't think Jews like my family ignored it, and it wasn't that they weren't frightened
00:25:17 by it.
00:25:18 My mother, you know, every Friday night Jews, Orthodox, traditional Jews, light candles
00:25:23 on a Friday night at the commencement of the Sabbath, and my mother would draw the curtains
00:25:27 in case anyone saw. So it's that. And British Jews always seem very nervous about that,
00:25:33 and with some good cause. But I didn't come across anything until I was at The Guardian
00:25:41 in 1982. And at that point, I should say I never thought of myself as on the left. I
00:25:50 thought I was a liberal. I still think I'm a liberal, a traditional liberal. But I thought
00:25:55 at that time that the left and liberals were the same yeah they all call themselves the liberal
00:26:00 left and I thought that was true I thought they were liberal and they were on the left and that
00:26:05 to be left was liberal and what happened in 1982 as I describe in Guardian Angel was that I was an
00:26:12 editorial writer I was a leader writer at the Guardian and there was a it was a it was a particular
00:26:17 period, Israel was engaged in a very controversial war in the Lebanon. At that
00:26:24 stage I'd never been to Israel, I never went to Israel until the year 2000,
00:26:28 never wanted to go, thought of myself as a British Jew and Israel was rather
00:26:33 other Jews who were in need but Britain was where everything was absolutely fine
00:26:37 for Jews and I was troubled by the reaction in Britain to this invasion of
00:26:43 Lebanon. I didn't agree with it, I thought it was unwise and I thought they'd gone
00:26:47 in too far and it was a strategic mistake but I it wasn't my it wasn't my
00:26:51 issue and out of the woodwork came this idea of the Israeli as the Nazi
00:26:58 literally the Nazi and to me that was anti-semitism and out of the woodwork
00:27:04 also came the idea that all you Jews stick together and I thought where did
00:27:08 that come from and I was very troubled the Guardian was majoring on this war in
00:27:13 Lebanon but at the same time there was an atrocity in Syria. President Assad's
00:27:20 father caused to be killed between 15 and 40,000 opponents at Hama, I think it
00:27:31 was, I've forgotten quite where it was, over the course of a couple of weeks and
00:27:36 that was a few paragraphs on a for on a foreign page buried in the paper
00:27:39 whereas anything that Israel did in the Lebanon was you know major front page
00:27:44 story and outrage editorial outrage columns and so I said to my colleagues
00:27:48 in all innocence I was a different person then why do we seem to have a
00:27:51 double standard and they looked at me as if I'd crossed a line and I realized I'd
00:27:56 crossed a line I didn't know what the line was but I knew suddenly I'd crossed
00:28:00 it and they said well of course it's a double standard you don't expect us to
00:28:05 judge the developing world by the same standards that we have the developing
00:28:09 world is not brought up as we are to have respect for human life so we can't
00:28:15 judge them by those standards that's racism I said what you're telling me
00:28:22 that if one is unfortunate enough to be born into the developing world then one
00:28:27 does not have the same rights to life and liberty as we do to me that's
00:28:33 racism to which they said why are you so upset we do you and I become you I'd
00:28:39 stop being we I become you yes we do you the great honor of assuming that you and
00:28:45 the state of Israel I become the state of Israel which I'd never even been to
00:28:51 you and the state of Israel have the same concepts that we do belief in life
00:28:56 and liberty so we judge you by our standards and you tell us that you have
00:29:01 higher standards than us so we should judge you by higher standards and I
00:29:05 realized at that point that it's like a shattering moment I realized they weren't
00:29:10 anti-racist they were racist and I realized there was a doublespeak in
00:29:15 which they told themselves their position was uniquely virtuous that
00:29:20 anyone who opposed it was uniquely unvirtuous by definition yeah that was
00:29:25 the line I'd crossed and that it was it was like the Soviet Union was a mirror
00:29:30 language, a mirror morality
00:29:32 and I'd crossed two lines, one I'd opposed
00:29:35 the left and two
00:29:36 I had defended the Jewish people
00:29:38 and as a British Jew you're not allowed
00:29:40 to do that. What do you think when you've seen
00:29:43 our MPs, Labour Party
00:29:44 resigning, has happened
00:29:46 what do you feel about that? It's a bit late
00:29:48 I mean
00:29:50 to me all this, I say
00:29:52 this first emerged
00:29:54 in my mind in 1982
00:29:56 and then it kind of went away in my mind
00:29:58 And it didn't emerge again until the year 2000, when the so-called Second Intifada started.
00:30:04 Israelis are being blown to smithereens in pizza parlours and in cafes and on buses.
00:30:10 And it went effectively to war against the Palestinians in the so-called West Bank to
00:30:18 stop it.
00:30:19 Thousands of Israelis were killed.
00:30:22 And from the word go, in this country, in Britain, Israel was being blamed.
00:30:29 And so I started to speak out.
00:30:31 And as soon as I started to speak out, I'd never previously spoken on this subject in
00:30:35 public or written.
00:30:36 It wasn't my thing.
00:30:37 I was a social policy writer.
00:30:40 As soon as I spoke out, I became the Jew.
00:30:44 And not only the Jew, but the extreme Zionist, warmongering Jew.
00:30:49 And once I realized that, I started to read.
00:30:52 And once I started to read about the history of the region, I realized not only how ignorant I was,
00:30:57 but how the generally accepted beliefs about the Middle East conflict were almost completely wrong.
00:31:04 And then I realized the enormity of the libel against Israel.
00:31:10 And then I began to realize, because defense of the Palestinians
00:31:13 and the belief in the oppression of the Palestinians by Israel is kind of the default belief among progressive people,
00:31:22 I realised that their entire moral compass had disintegrated.
00:31:25 And once I realised that, a lot of other stuff that I'd been fighting for years
00:31:29 about cultural decline and cultural absurdity and the collapse of education
00:31:34 and the rise of multiculturalism, the inability to say that a liberal society is better than any other,
00:31:40 the inability to distinguish between truth and lies, between justice and injustice,
00:31:44 it suddenly all made sense. It suddenly all came together.
00:31:49 And so that's why I wrote The World Turn Upside Down,
00:31:51 because it was turned upside down but you've also covered this you've written a novel recently
00:31:55 haven't you yes the legacy yes and and basically you cover a lot of the ground of anti-centrism
00:32:02 in that don't you yes um I wanted to write the novel because um uh I've always wanted to write
00:32:08 a novel yeah and also I believe there's more truth in novels than anywhere else um unfortunately what
00:32:13 I hadn't realized was that you know I I've had difficulty getting published in Britain for a
00:32:18 long time because people do not want to publish me. It's sort of extraordinary in a way, sorry,
00:32:21 I say that greenly, but it's extraordinary considering that you are one of the better
00:32:27 known. I'm box office, and publishers don't want to make money out of me because they don't want
00:32:30 the views expressed. But I've put that to one side, both these books, Guardian Angel,
00:32:34 my memoir, and The Legacy of the Novel, published in America last year. They've had no publicity,
00:32:40 you can't get them in the bookshops in Britain, but you can get them on Amazon. Anyway, The Legacy,
00:32:44 I used the novel form to explore contemporary anti-Semitism in Britain, but also more deeply,
00:32:54 and I wanted to get into the head of an anti-Semite, but also more deeply, I wanted to explore
00:33:01 what I have come to believe to be the case, which is the fact that you can't escape your identity,
00:33:07 me, however much you may want to. And so my hero, my anti-hero is a person of Jewish ancestry
00:33:16 who doesn't want to be a Jew in Britain. And it's a kind of story in which he realises
00:33:23 that he can't escape it and he wants to escape it. And he realises the good things that he's
00:33:28 missed by trying to escape it. And yet it's not a satisfactory situation and it can't
00:33:33 be made okay. But that's what I wanted to explore, the pull of history, the inevitability
00:33:39 of your identity, the historical, the fact that anti-Semitism is the longest hatred.
00:33:49 It never goes away. So my book is set on not exactly a small canvas. It's set apart from
00:33:55 being in contemporary Britain. It's also set in medieval Britain and in Holocaust Poland
00:34:00 and in contemporary Israel and America.
00:34:02 So it's a modest canvas.
00:34:04 But I wanted to explore this idea that these things go through generations.
00:34:12 And I don't know, I mean, on Amazon, people have raved about it.
00:34:15 They say it's a compulsive page-turner.
00:34:19 So compulsive, nobody has reviewed it.
00:34:23 You have covered pretty much the waterfront in your writing.
00:34:28 as you say, social policy, everything, right the way through,
00:34:32 you attract a lot of anger in your critics.
00:34:39 Why do you think they get so angry with you?
00:34:42 I mean, they do seem to reserve a certain anger for you.
00:34:44 I'm in a particular circle of hell, unique circle of hell,
00:34:46 reserved for me.
00:34:49 Well, you know, the old saying is, you know,
00:34:53 an apostate is always hated.
00:34:55 And I was considered to be on the left,
00:34:57 and then I became not the left.
00:34:59 We've had quite a few on this show, actually.
00:35:01 Oh, I post it.
00:35:02 But I think it's more than that.
00:35:04 I think it's more than that.
00:35:06 Because I think that the particular fury is...
00:35:10 The particular fury among people of a certain age,
00:35:15 I exclude younger people because they don't know my background,
00:35:17 but people of a certain age who know where I came from
00:35:21 cannot understand what I've done.
00:35:24 but they do understand that it's very difficult for them to label me as they're labeling me as
00:35:33 they've labeled me as you know right wing extreme right wing fascist nazi because i clearly am not
00:35:38 because i still believe in the things that they believe in or they say they believe in
00:35:43 i still believe in truth against lies the oppressed against the oppressor justice against
00:35:49 injustice i believe in opposing prejudice and discrimination and bigotry i just believe that
00:35:54 they are the bigots. And they are the people who stand for the erosion of reason and evidence
00:36:02 and facts and truth. But I believe in the things that they say they believe in. And
00:36:07 that's their problem. Because I call them out on their own territory. And they have
00:36:13 no defence against this. None. They can't answer the criticism. And so they never engage
00:36:20 in the argument ever they have to shut me down and they do so they try to do so by first of all
00:36:29 making sure that i'm not published okay so i am published but by the skin of my teeth well that
00:36:35 was the case with londonistan as well wasn't it absolutely it was it became a bestseller didn't
00:36:39 it but it started off in america it was going to be published this is a book about britain
00:36:43 which was going to be published only in america until about four weeks before publication when a
00:36:49 tiny publisher publishing out of his front room came forward and said I'll publish it so he did
00:36:53 and he sold actually quite a lot of books so um it's this it's this I think this understanding
00:36:59 that um that I'm attacking them on their own territory so they they they don't engage in
00:37:06 the argument they have to they try and shut me down they do so by labels not just me you know
00:37:11 so many of us this is what we're finding so we're all phobes of various kinds I've been so many
00:37:17 folks. I mean, you know, they seem to make up a new phobia to lay around my neck the
00:37:22 whole time. You know, I'm extreme. I'm a racist. I'm a mad, Zionist, warmongering Jew. I'm
00:37:30 insane, deranged, you know. So once I've been called a deranged, warmongering, Zionist,
00:37:38 fascist nazi jew what else can they say about me so you know i mean hello i'm still here
00:37:47 thank goodness um many i want to say uh that's all we've really got time for at the moment but
00:37:54 the two books that you can get on amazon right i wanted to just make sure people know this
00:38:00 it's basically the legacy is the novel yes and then guardian angel is your memoir that's right
00:38:05 It's Guardian Angel, and there's a subtitle, isn't it?
00:38:08 Guardian Angel, My Journey from Leftism to Sanity.
00:38:11 To Sanity. Great.
00:38:13 Both available on Amazon.
00:38:16 Melanie, thank you so much for coming on and talking.
00:38:18 Not at all.
00:38:18 And all the very best for the books that are now out.
00:38:22 And I hope you come back soon.
00:38:24 Thank you so much. It's been a pleasure.
00:38:26 Thank you very much, and see you next week.
00:38:27 And by the way, in the meantime, of course, please do remember to subscribe, won't you?
00:38:31 Take care. Bye.
00:38:35 You