New Culture Forum - November 16, 2019


S2.08 Charles Moore - Margaret Thatcher: Radical or Traditionalist?

S2.03 Martin Durkin: Media Bias & Brexit Snobbery S2.10 Theodore Dalrymple: Britain's Vanishing Culture & Character

Episode Stats


Length

36 minutes

Words per minute

170.38

Word count

6,288

Sentence count

179


Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
00:00:00 Hello and welcome to So What You're Saying Is, I'm Peter Whittle. Now I'm delighted to say that my
00:00:21 guest this week is Charles Moore. Charles is the authorised biographer of Margaret Thatcher,
00:00:28 The third and final volume of the biography, Herself Alone, has just been published.
00:00:33 It covers the years from 1987 up to her death in 2013.
00:00:39 Charles, of course, was editor of The Spectator, The Sunday Telegraph, and The Daily Telegraph.
00:00:44 He currently writes a column for The Telegraph and for The Spectator.
00:00:48 Thank you very much for joining us.
00:00:49 Thank you, Peter.
00:00:51 First thing I wanted to ask about this extraordinary achievement of this book is,
00:00:56 did you think it was going to be three volumes when you started um i did because they commissioned
00:01:04 me for three volumes penguin and then when i'd done a bit of work i thought this is ridiculous
00:01:09 better be two volumes and then when i did more work i realized it had to be three volumes so i
00:01:14 i went back and forth um and the reason for the length is the nature of the project which is that
00:01:20 um she asked me to do it and i was the first person to see all these papers both her papers
00:01:26 and the government papers of the Prime Ministerial Office.
00:01:31 And I saw them in full and was authorised to see them
00:01:35 before a lot of them were released.
00:01:37 And then authorised by her to approach everybody possible,
00:01:41 so interviewed 600 people for the book.
00:01:44 And therefore, that's why it's intended to be comprehensive
00:01:49 and why it has to be long,
00:01:50 because this is new material to a large extent.
00:01:53 and also it's necessary, I think, to try and cover all the main subjects.
00:01:59 You say that she wanted you to do it.
00:02:01 How did it work out? Did you know her, Tom?
00:02:04 Yes, I did know her, yeah.
00:02:05 And that's how it came about?
00:02:06 Well, I didn't really know how it came about
00:02:08 and I never asked her why she wanted me to do it.
00:02:11 But anyway, she did.
00:02:14 And in 1997 this was.
00:02:15 So basically the whole thing has taken 20 years?
00:02:19 Yes.
00:02:20 She asked me in 1997.
00:02:21 I got the contract from the publisher in the following year and I think I started interviews
00:02:27 in 99 so 20 years of actual work but I didn't do the hard work until 2004 onwards because until
00:02:34 then I was editing the Telegraph till the end of 2003 nearly and I didn't really have the time
00:02:41 but then I from 2004 I settled down to the full thing. You know it's a good point there because
00:02:48 when I've said that I'm meeting you today
00:02:50 what a lot of people have asked is actually
00:02:52 a very harshly practical thing
00:02:54 how do you do this
00:02:56 on a day to day level
00:02:58 how do you work when you are writing something
00:03:00 like this
00:03:01 as a psychopath
00:03:03 as apparently forgets his crimes
00:03:06 I can't really remember how I do it
00:03:07 I can't
00:03:08 I've had no time really to look back on how I do it
00:03:12 because of being a journalist
00:03:14 and employed by the Telegraph
00:03:15 there are some days a week when I can't do it really
00:03:17 because of writing columns and all the rest of the time I am doing it was and a lot of it is
00:03:26 accumulation and sifting and so on and then boiling it down to write luckily being a journalist I
00:03:31 don't suffer from writer's block I can write fast but the amount of research is pretty stupefying
00:03:37 so and also you don't want to rush your fences so you you do muck around doing asking a further
00:03:44 question i find the only way you know what you want to know is by sitting down to write because
00:03:50 it's only then you discover that what it is you don't know yes you try to answer a question in
00:03:54 your own mind and you find you can't so you have to go off and do a bit more research and so on so
00:03:58 um it's i'm surprised by these people who quote do all the research and then write the book
00:04:04 don't quite see how that works because you have to sort of taste taste it before you can
00:04:11 you know as you cook it I mean you this this volume covers I said the broadly
00:04:19 speaking the Cold War obviously her well the climax of the Cold War and also
00:04:26 Europe and and her time after the office does it sort of when you were going
00:04:35 through the stupefying amount of research as you put it did it sort of
00:04:39 open up new things more than not I mean did or did you find things confirming you well in some
00:04:47 ways Mrs Thatcher is a very open book as a character because she was in many respects very
00:04:54 consistent however you do find important things which are different from what you might imagine
00:05:00 and it quite a few things surprised me obviously because I covered it as a journalist I knew quite
00:05:04 a lot about it anyway but fundamentally superficially whereas when you start looking at all this so for
00:05:10 example though of course I knew about her speeches about climate change when she was essentially
00:05:17 she essentially was the first world leader to endorse the theory of climate change
00:05:20 I hadn't realized how much time she gave to it how important she considered it and how
00:05:26 innovative she was in terms of supporting the international process that was just getting
00:05:31 going then and which we still have of the UN supervision through the IPCC and so on and
00:05:37 like quite a lot of people of a conservative disposition I was slightly hoping that she
00:05:44 had been misrepresented and didn't quite believe this stuff but she did and she slightly recanted
00:05:52 in retirement but I think she really did believe it and it was very interesting to see how zealous
00:05:59 she was and how persuasive she was in public and how much she got involved in the science
00:06:05 because she was of course a scientist and another thing that surprised me was what happened
00:06:10 about South Africa and I find this tremendously interesting because we all know that she opposed
00:06:14 sanctions and very much did not want the South African economy to collapse, she thought there'd
00:06:21 then be violent revolution and communism might take over and poverty would ensue and that's all
00:06:29 known and it's also known to at least to some extent how important she was for FW to clerk in
00:06:34 moving towards the end of apartheid what wasn't so known and was almost new to me was the extent
00:06:41 of the British government's association privately with the ANC before the release of Mandela
00:06:46 which she, while always criticising the ANC for its socialism
00:06:51 and for its flirting with violence,
00:06:54 you know, with the armed struggle,
00:06:56 she did authorise such contacts and they were important
00:06:59 and they built up a lot of trust.
00:07:01 And Mandela, when in prison, was very impressed by Mrs Thatcher
00:07:05 because of what she'd done with Gorbachev.
00:07:07 And he thought, hmm, well, this really is remarkable
00:07:11 and we're going to need a process like this.
00:07:13 we're going to need a white Gorbachev
00:07:16 to come to terms
00:07:18 and also I think he sort of thought of himself
00:07:22 slightly as a Gorbachev
00:07:23 because he wanted the reconciliation
00:07:25 much more than most of the ANC did
00:07:27 so he was very, in a way, well disposed to Mrs Satchel
00:07:31 although he jolly well didn't agree with her
00:07:32 about sanctions or about economic questions
00:07:35 and she well disposed to him
00:07:37 sort of same thing the other way round
00:07:39 She admired him, didn't she?
00:07:41 Yes, and this bit was utterly new to me,
00:07:45 which is that after he'd been released
00:07:47 and he was able to travel the world,
00:07:50 he quickly got very tired.
00:07:52 He was quite old and he was doing these very grueling tours.
00:07:55 And because of the secret connection with the British government,
00:07:59 the ANC asked, passed on a request to Mandela
00:08:02 that could he have a little tiny holiday in Britain
00:08:04 looked after by the British government.
00:08:07 And so it was arranged that he should go to a sort of safe house
00:08:10 the country house in Kent and there and looked after by the British government and as their guest
00:08:16 and there he met Oliver Tambo the other leader of the ANC who he hadn't seen since he went to prison
00:08:21 in 1963 and their wives so it's very sort of emotional yes gathering and British officials
00:08:28 were also there and Mandela as a private visit obviously indeed a secret visit only there briefly
00:08:36 but at dinner he drank quite a lot of hot port
00:08:40 he didn't like cold alcohol but he liked hot alcohol
00:08:42 and he drank a glass and a half of hot port
00:08:45 and got excited and rang up Mrs Thatcher at quarter to midnight
00:08:49 and there, even though it was a Saturday night I think
00:08:53 the indefatigable Charles Poles Inn
00:08:56 took the call, talked to Mandela
00:08:58 and Mandela said, I must talk to Mrs Thatcher, can I see her?
00:09:03 and Charles said, well I'm sure she'd love that
00:09:06 but what time have you got?
00:09:07 He said, well, actually, I'm near Tunbridge Wells
00:09:09 and I've got to get a plane at 10 tomorrow morning from Heathrow.
00:09:12 So there really wasn't time.
00:09:14 But she rang him at 7.30 the following morning
00:09:18 because Charles wrote for a note straight away that night
00:09:21 explaining all this.
00:09:22 And they had a very warm conversation,
00:09:23 which, though they disagreed,
00:09:25 you could never have such conversations with this
00:09:27 without disagreement at some point.
00:09:28 But she was so solicitous about his health and things
00:09:33 and he was very touched by all of that.
00:09:34 and they agreed to meet a few weeks later
00:09:40 and he came to Downing Street
00:09:41 and almost uniquely she shut up for 50 minutes while he talked.
00:09:45 She let him talk uninterrupted for 50 minutes
00:09:47 which she almost never did anybody
00:09:48 and they went on for so long
00:09:52 that the press all standing outside in 10 Downing Street
00:09:56 all started chanting free Nelson Mandela.
00:09:59 I find it all very interesting that she had
00:10:05 very typical Mrs Thatcher actually
00:10:06 that she had taken a very strong line in public
00:10:09 which was certainly not hypocritical
00:10:10 is what she believed
00:10:11 but she also had a sort of back way
00:10:15 so she was aware
00:10:17 she was working for what came after
00:10:21 as well as fighting
00:10:21 as just fighting the issue of sanctions
00:10:23 You mentioned there that her reputation
00:10:27 is it true to say that
00:10:30 during this period, which was kind of the imperial
00:10:32 period in a way
00:10:34 these extraordinary clothes
00:10:36 is that a caricature
00:10:38 this idea of her being
00:10:40 absolutely unapproachable
00:10:42 not
00:10:43 taking anybody else's opinion
00:10:46 on board, all of these things
00:10:48 is that a caricature?
00:10:50 It is a caricature because
00:10:52 though Mrs. Satchel was very frightening
00:10:54 she did like to have discussions with people
00:10:56 and if she thought somebody knew about something
00:10:59 she wanted to have to meet that person
00:11:00 I mean she did that very much with the climate change things
00:11:03 for example all these people like James Lovelock and so on
00:11:05 the sort of founding fathers of all of this
00:11:09 she was always very interested in ideas and policies
00:11:12 and the people who put them forward
00:11:14 so in that way she was open
00:11:16 she was much less open by this time to her colleagues
00:11:18 because most of the senior ones had gone
00:11:21 and she felt she was sort of
00:11:24 had grown out of that almost
00:11:25 and was too negligent of them.
00:11:28 The other factor was that,
00:11:30 which I think is people in Britain slightly forget,
00:11:32 is she'd become such an important global figure.
00:11:35 And this was perhaps too much to her detriment in domestic politics.
00:11:38 But she'd been the senior leader of the Western world
00:11:41 in terms of time serves right back till something like December 82.
00:11:45 So here we are in 89, 90.
00:11:47 She was a very, very prestigious figure
00:11:52 and had huge, I mean, real adulation in places like Poland, Armenia, Russia,
00:11:59 hundreds of thousands of people sort of throwing flowers in her path, literally.
00:12:02 I mean, contrasting in a way that must have been very strange psychologically
00:12:06 with, you know, poll tax right back here or whatever.
00:12:08 Yes, yes.
00:12:09 Bad opinion polls and by-elections.
00:12:12 And this perhaps did get her rather out of touch.
00:12:17 I think a lot of what she did in this late period was important on the global scene,
00:12:21 particularly obviously the end of the Cold War, because she'd worked so hard for that.
00:12:24 How important was ultimately her role in the ending of the Cold War?
00:12:28 Well, it sort of went wrong at the very end, and I'll come to that,
00:12:32 but the trajectory of it was very important over the 10 years, 11 years,
00:12:38 because she'd been the first person to warn against detente with the Soviet Union
00:12:42 because we were doing it from a position of weakness, she reckoned.
00:12:46 So she started to build up the nuclear arsenal with support from President Reagan
00:12:51 when he replaced president carter and he gave the leadership and she gave the leadership within
00:12:57 europe on that and then she thought ah we've done it we've beaten them basically into military terms
00:13:04 they're not going to dare to advance further so now we've got to change the tone and find an
00:13:08 interlocutor if we can so she's the first person to find gorbachev december 84 he wasn't even the
00:13:13 leader at that point uh the famous meeting in chequers she then persuaded reagan that he said
00:13:18 he should meet Gorbachev and so on so then she becomes very friendly with Gorbachev and her
00:13:26 long-term tactic of engaging with the people of Eastern Europe as well as interstate relations
00:13:31 appealing to dissidents and to oppress peoples and speaking directly to them also very very
00:13:37 important so she became a heroic figure in Poland, Hungary, Czechoslovakia and actually in Russia
00:13:42 very very successful meeting in
00:13:45 Moscow in March 87
00:13:48 so all this came together
00:13:50 and helped persuade
00:13:52 Gorbachev that
00:13:53 you could move towards a really very different
00:13:56 situation both within his country
00:13:58 and without
00:13:58 and help the Americans
00:14:01 to open up as well and so on
00:14:03 that all went really really well
00:14:06 and then right at the
00:14:08 end the problem arose that the side
00:14:10 effect of the end of the Cold War was the
00:14:12 reunification of Germany which scared her partly because she didn't like
00:14:16 Germany and partly because she was worried that Gorbachev would be
00:14:19 overthrown and the Red Army would fight back and sorry yeah was you know the
00:14:25 dislike of Germany was that a kind of cultural attitude that she had or I
00:14:30 think it was yes I think it was to do with the war and you know the thing she
00:14:35 said was a typical tactlessness to Helmut Kohl towards the end was twice
00:14:40 we've rescued Europe from you in this century and now you're back." And that's how she felt.
00:14:51 But she also felt other things in relation to this which were more rational. There was
00:14:56 this rational fear about the Soviets. There was also, she hated the fact that the reunification
00:15:02 of Germany was taken by the European community to be the occasion for greater centralisation
00:15:07 and integration by Jacques Delors and Kohl in particular.
00:15:11 And I found an interesting private conversation she had with Mitterrand just before her fall
00:15:14 when she said, your idea that the single currency will bind Germany down
00:15:19 and will be the price Germany pays for reunification is completely wrong.
00:15:24 If you can create the single currency, Germany will become the chief economic power in Europe.
00:15:29 It will be run on German lines and they will rule Europe.
00:15:33 and on that regardless
00:15:36 take out her anti-Germanism
00:15:38 but as a matter of prediction she's correct
00:15:40 but
00:15:42 the Americans got fed up with her because
00:15:44 Bush wanted to sort of pivot towards
00:15:46 Germany, he also wanted to be more distanced
00:15:48 from her because he didn't like
00:15:50 the way Reagan had
00:15:51 as he considered it, danced to her tune
00:15:54 and
00:15:55 so she started to be, the combination of
00:15:58 Bush and
00:16:00 Cole and Delore I suppose
00:16:01 started to exclude her from the big stuff at the very end.
00:16:05 She found that very frustrating.
00:16:08 Is it a caricature, again, to say that she was brought down by Europe?
00:16:12 Obviously, her downfall is a central part, obviously, of this book.
00:16:18 I think I would say that in an important sense,
00:16:21 she was brought down by Europe.
00:16:23 I think there were three fundamental facts, or possibly four.
00:16:25 One was that the economy was going wrong because of the Lawson boom.
00:16:29 Another was the poll tax.
00:16:31 another was the feeling she's been around too long
00:16:33 we're fed up with her
00:16:34 those were all important
00:16:35 and they all affected public opinion
00:16:39 and the backbenchers
00:16:40 but the way she was actually killed politically
00:16:43 was really by the behaviour of the cabinet
00:16:46 and they were much more moved by Europe
00:16:49 than by those other issues
00:16:50 and they were particularly horrified
00:16:52 Geoffrey Howe and Michael Heseltine
00:16:56 particularly horrified by the idea
00:16:57 that she would weaponise
00:16:59 as people now say the European issue electorally
00:17:02 they always want to keep it away
00:17:04 as a subject that the electorate was considered
00:17:05 too stupid to deal with
00:17:07 and she wanted to open it up
00:17:09 to the public
00:17:11 arbitrament and to
00:17:13 raise
00:17:16 a sort of democratic deficit point about
00:17:17 the whole thing and this really
00:17:20 really really alarmed
00:17:21 Howe and Hazeltine
00:17:22 and of course
00:17:25 it was the Foreign Office and people like that
00:17:28 were very worried about isolation and all the things.
00:17:30 So, and she raised the subject of the referendum,
00:17:33 which in those days would have been on the single currency
00:17:35 while she was still in office, just at the very end.
00:17:38 In fact, partly in one case, an interview with me
00:17:40 when she was fighting the leadership election
00:17:44 and another interview with Michael Jones of the Sunday Times.
00:17:49 And this, of course, double alarmed the cabinet.
00:17:52 Not only did she want to make it an issue as an election,
00:17:55 but she wanted to have a special referendum.
00:17:58 And they weren't having it.
00:17:59 And I think they thought, this has got to stop.
00:18:04 During the downfall as well, all the machinations going on,
00:18:08 it sort of reads almost like a thriller.
00:18:11 But again, new light has been shed.
00:18:14 We've seen this.
00:18:16 Characters emerging in a different light.
00:18:18 I'm thinking of John Major.
00:18:19 I mean, can you explain a little bit?
00:18:21 Yes.
00:18:21 I think the first important document I discovered about this
00:18:25 was written a year before.
00:18:27 when she was challenged by Anthony Mayer who was obscure in 89 in a leadership contest it was a
00:18:33 forerunner and though she won the contest easily people warned her that this wasn't this could
00:18:39 happen again it would be worse and they really meant Heseltine and what I found was a document
00:18:44 by the deputy chief whip Tristan Garrell-Jones written only to his chief Tim Renton which said
00:18:49 the end of the Thatcher era is coming and if we don't watch out we'll get Heseltine and we don't
00:18:56 want Hazeltine because it will split the party. And so we need to arrange what we do about
00:19:02 it. And he said, all this that I've just described, all this will happen unless, and
00:19:08 that's how his memo ended, just dot, dot, dot, unless what? And I think what then happened
00:19:13 in the next year was that people like Gerald Jones tried to concert an orderly change of
00:19:19 power, which would mean that Mrs. Satcher would fall, though they wouldn't actively
00:19:24 campaign against her and certainly wouldn't campaign against her in public. And that a
00:19:28 succession would be organised which would be favourable to the Tory establishment rather
00:19:32 than to Heseltine, who they regarded rather like Mrs Thatcher, though with different views
00:19:35 as an outsider. So these were all people in the cabinet or near the cabinet, and they
00:19:40 were essentially trying to work out things to their advantage. I mean, by the way, for
00:19:46 not necessarily discreditable reasons, because she'd gone on a long time. But nevertheless,
00:19:51 there was obviously a strong element of self-interest
00:19:53 about how to position themselves
00:19:55 and what they
00:19:57 essentially came to view was we've got to beat
00:19:59 she's going to go and
00:20:00 that would be good if she did and
00:20:03 we've got to beat Heseltine
00:20:05 so they kept on thinking how do we do this
00:20:07 and what they decided was the best way to
00:20:09 beat Heseltine was to have two cabinet
00:20:11 members opposing him because
00:20:13 that would drain more votes from Heseltine
00:20:15 and those cabinet members would be friendly to
00:20:17 one another so they would say may the
00:20:19 best man win when it came to the final ballot
00:20:21 so they decided really that was major and heard the foreign secretary and tristan gerald james
00:20:28 was brokering it because he was a great supporter of her but he's also close to major
00:20:31 and various meetings took place and eventually from all this complicated process emerged the
00:20:39 idea from john wakeham that she should see each cabinet member after she'd failed to prevent the
00:20:45 second ballot yes she should see each cabinet member and they should say what they thought
00:20:50 And the reason this was arranged in this way was that they would each tell her, or most of them would, that she should go.
00:20:55 Because they'd say things like, I'll vote for you, but you can't win, that sort of thing.
00:20:59 And the sort of slightly cant phrase they used was, we don't want Margaret to be humiliated,
00:21:03 which is almost a code word saying we do want her to go.
00:21:06 And what I discovered about John Major was, of course, he was not on the scene because he'd had his wisdom teeth out
00:21:13 and he was at home in Huntingdonshire when all this was going on.
00:21:16 And Mrs Thatcher said when the second ballot was proved necessary,
00:21:20 she rang up Major and heard, and she said,
00:21:22 will you support my nomination for the second ballot?
00:21:27 And they said yes, but they weren't happy about it.
00:21:29 And Major in particular, the reason they weren't happy about it
00:21:33 was they wanted her to go.
00:21:34 And the additional reason was they wanted to succeed her.
00:21:37 And if she stood in a second ballot as cabinet ministers,
00:21:40 they couldn't fight against her.
00:21:43 So they'd have to resign from the cabinet
00:21:45 if they were to contest it with her.
00:21:48 So Major had this great conundrum.
00:21:50 If he thinks to himself,
00:21:52 I don't sign her nomination papers,
00:21:55 then people are going to be very angry
00:21:57 that I betrayed her.
00:22:00 However, if I do sign her nomination papers
00:22:02 and she uses them,
00:22:04 I've had it.
00:22:06 So what he did secretly
00:22:08 was make an agreement with the whips
00:22:11 and with Mrs Thatcher's
00:22:13 parliamentary private secretary peter morrison that he would submit the nomination papers
00:22:17 signed by him but only if he was promised that she wouldn't use them so he could say
00:22:24 i've nominated her but peter morrison was under orders which he agreed to to
00:22:30 withdraw the nomination papers if she tried to use them um so um it was a brilliantly sort of
00:22:38 cunning piece of play and of course the one reason he did this was he wanted if he was standing he
00:22:44 wanted the vote of Thatcherites and if Mrs Thatcher had known that this was his game she would not
00:22:50 have endorsed him in this and so it was a very cunning piece of politics which succeeded he
00:22:55 signed her nomination papers he boasted in public of having signed her nomination papers but he
00:23:00 made sure that they were never submitted and he won the leadership. When she left and the period
00:23:07 after which obviously is the last third really of your book um there was an attempt i it seems
00:23:14 sorry i'll turn this off sorry you know there was an attempt it seems to me from if you like the
00:23:19 intelligentsia the people who hated her to kind of sort of take back her reputation or at least
00:23:26 mold her reputation retrospectively in in the public mind would you say that's true i mean
00:23:31 it's because she didn't care really what they thought very much did she she didn't care about
00:23:36 Baroness Warnock she didn't care about Jonathan Miller any of these people no but essentially
00:23:41 once she'd gone there was a feeling that somehow the 80s the Thatcheride era was going to be
00:23:46 basically seen as the most terrible evil time yes I think that would be the the public doctrine
00:23:53 it doesn't totally dominate by any means but I noticed the way this is dealt with for instance
00:23:58 if I go on the BBC and do an interview they always first thing they always say is Margaret Thatcher
00:24:02 was the most divisive prime minister of our time yeah they don't say she was the worst prime minister
00:24:06 so they couldn't say that, but that would be the line.
00:24:09 And of course, in certain respects, she was divisive.
00:24:12 But they don't say, for example, which would also be true,
00:24:15 factually true, regardless of whether you think she was right,
00:24:18 the most successful prime minister of our time,
00:24:20 by which I mean, in all the indices of political success, she succeeded.
00:24:24 She won every election she contested.
00:24:26 She won them all big.
00:24:28 She succeeded in bringing in most of the measures she wanted to bring in.
00:24:33 She had a doctrine or set of doctrines named after her.
00:24:36 she was world famous, very, very influential in every respect,
00:24:42 and, of course, the first woman.
00:24:44 So you could not say that she was not successful,
00:24:46 even if you didn't, but it seems to me
00:24:48 that the right word for her is successful,
00:24:50 and then go on from there.
00:24:53 And it's a pity if people don't know what she did.
00:24:58 That's, in a way, the purpose of the book
00:25:00 is the need to tell it historically, not polemically.
00:25:02 You know, though I'm sympathetic to Mrs. Thatcher,
00:25:05 I try to give all the points of view of the people who engaged in the argument.
00:25:09 And the thing is, very few politicians, to use the cliche, make a difference.
00:25:15 And she clearly, clearly did.
00:25:16 And that's very interesting to know what difference she made.
00:25:19 There is a feeling, I think now, that she has kind of broken finally away from that kind of character.
00:25:26 Do you think that a bit like Churchill, she has broken away from the Tory party, in a way, in terms of her reputation now?
00:25:33 She's seen as a singular figure, isn't she?
00:25:36 Some of her supporters, we've had some on the programme,
00:25:39 for example, Martin Durkin, the filmmaker, did a film about her.
00:25:44 Do you think that she was a radical or a traditionalist,
00:25:47 or was she both?
00:25:48 It's a very good question, and the answer is she was both.
00:25:51 She was a true Conservative with a big C and a small C.
00:25:55 She was very loyal to the Conservative Party and in the country.
00:25:59 The grassroots loved her.
00:26:01 she wasn't very
00:26:03 enamoured of the Conservative Party
00:26:05 at the top in the House of Commons
00:26:07 her conservatism
00:26:10 consisted in a great belief in
00:26:12 I would say
00:26:14 ultimately is a sort of idea
00:26:16 of a Christian social order
00:26:18 and
00:26:20 in the traditions of Britain
00:26:22 and the
00:26:23 established way
00:26:26 of doing things
00:26:27 monarchy and parliament and the rule of law
00:26:30 in our particular form and all that sort of thing.
00:26:33 She wasn't radical about that at all.
00:26:35 She was extremely radical about what to do
00:26:37 in the face of weakness and difficulty and failure
00:26:42 in economic questions.
00:26:46 And there she really did want to overthrow
00:26:48 pretty well every orthodoxy about public finance,
00:26:52 trade unions, how you control inflation,
00:26:56 who runs businesses, privatisation.
00:27:00 and open up opportunities for people who hadn't had them
00:27:04 and remove powers from people who'd abused them.
00:27:07 And that was all tough stuff.
00:27:10 And she would take on not only obvious things like trade union left-wing barons,
00:27:15 but the legal profession, for example,
00:27:18 because of its sort of closed shop practices in the bar and that sort of thing.
00:27:24 All that was highly radical.
00:27:26 And she was pretty radical in foreign affairs
00:27:28 because, as I say, she doesn't just think of these things in terms of interstate relations.
00:27:33 She thinks of them as democratic issues, issues of values and rights and things.
00:27:39 And so, and she had an instinctive, she sort of liked the sound of breaking crockery.
00:27:47 I mean, she wanted there to, she thought there had to be some conflicts and she didn't like consensus.
00:27:52 In that sense she was divisive and she also didn't really, she very strongly
00:27:59 believed in the superiority of the Western way of life. She wasn't by any
00:28:04 means so sure that the sort of institutions across the world that were
00:28:09 supposed to protect it were very good at doing it. So she was sceptical of the
00:28:12 United Nations and very sceptical of the European community and became more so
00:28:18 and was worried that global institutions would threaten national institutions.
00:28:25 You mentioned the economic struggles.
00:28:28 It would seem that most of her battles were economic ones, at least in the beginning.
00:28:32 Particularly in the first half force.
00:28:34 Do you think she had any sense of what we would now call maybe the culture wars?
00:28:42 Or was it the fact maybe that it just wasn't an issue?
00:28:45 It was an issue.
00:28:46 So she would, I don't think she would probably have used the phrase culture wars, but it was.
00:28:53 You know, she didn't like the sort of arts that attracted state patronage for the most part.
00:29:00 She didn't like the sort of traison des clerks in academia,
00:29:05 which was, I'm sure, one reason why Oxford absurdly refused the first woman prime minister
00:29:11 and who'd come, of course, from Oxford, their honorary degree.
00:29:13 I mean, the most extraordinary, I mean, only at Oxford could this have occurred.
00:29:18 And that sort of thing.
00:29:21 And she was basically conservative in culture, not authoritarian, but conservative.
00:29:28 So she would be, take an issue like homosexuality.
00:29:32 She was quite unusual in Tory backbenchers in the 1960s in voting for legalisation
00:29:37 because she thought that it's a terrible infringement of people's privacy,
00:29:40 that they should be, why shouldn't they do whatever they want to do?
00:29:44 On the other hand, she would have a slightly old-fashioned Christian idea
00:29:50 that moral education, religious education at schools
00:29:56 should favour the heterosexually married family life,
00:30:01 not alternative lifestyles.
00:30:03 They shouldn't be persecuted, but they shouldn't be celebrated, would be her.
00:30:07 And so on.
00:30:09 so she disliked most of the sort of culture war innovations of the period
00:30:17 but it was not I would say reactionary
00:30:19 and she wouldn't, oh another one would be teaching
00:30:23 I mean she was very much in favour of learning to read and write
00:30:27 and things like that
00:30:28 and she would describe the sort of radical thing with infants
00:30:35 making plasticine worms, that sort of thing which she didn't like
00:30:38 so all of those things you knew where she came from but it wasn't the dominant thought in her
00:30:43 mind but so for example take the bbc yeah she would have felt that maybe it was unfair or biased
00:30:50 but she would certainly not want to get rid of the institution that's right um bbc is a good
00:30:55 example i write about that quite a lot in this volume she thought it was basically a good idea
00:30:59 because it but only if it really conformed to its charter yeah so that it ought to be a sort of
00:31:05 solemn responsibility of the people on the BBC rather than just a vehicle for whatever they
00:31:10 wanted to do and she took very seriously their role in high culture like programs like civilization
00:31:16 and that sort of thing and news and she didn't really see the point of Radio 1 and I'm not that
00:31:23 she was against pop music but why should why should a nationalized sort of channel do it
00:31:27 she wanted more pluralism she wanted more channels more competition and she did quite a lot of all
00:31:33 that but her basic approach to the BBC as a structure was not to abolish or even really
00:31:40 much reform the structure but put in one or two people who would bring about change so
00:31:47 the Prime Minister was entitled to appoint the Director General of the BBC or was under that
00:31:52 time at that time and so she put in Dukie Hussey to shake it up and he put in John Burt and
00:32:00 And between them, they did a lot to make the BBC less infuriating to her, and as she would
00:32:05 see it, restore standards.
00:32:07 So she didn't want to knock it down, but she did want to give it a hard kick.
00:32:14 When you mention and go into great detail about the final years of her life, very beautifully
00:32:22 written if I may say, there was a movie out a few years ago called The Iron Lady, I don't
00:32:29 know whether you helped on that no certainly not certainly not and I wouldn't have done it but
00:32:33 but um did that you know what was your view on that did did they get it entirely wrong I mean
00:32:40 this is the Meryl Streep film no it's a film of 100% useless politically that film yes um and um
00:32:47 confusing historically but um it's good for one simple reason which is that Meryl Streep captures
00:32:55 Mrs Thatcher in old age
00:32:57 it was very unfair to do that because
00:32:59 she was still alive and you know she was
00:33:01 demented and they were portraying that
00:33:03 however
00:33:04 its effect as a film I think has been
00:33:07 beneficial to Mrs Thatcher's reputation because
00:33:09 it conveys to a new generation
00:33:11 something that people miss because she was
00:33:13 so tough they didn't realise that she
00:33:15 was vulnerable and they don't realise that she paid a
00:33:17 price for all her great efforts
00:33:19 and they don't realise that she
00:33:21 had frailty and
00:33:23 sort of there was rather touching aspects of her and this is very well portrayed and therefore made
00:33:28 her seem rightly because she she was more human you uh i have to ask you this question do did she
00:33:38 know or what did she make of boris johnson well she did know him a bit um well by the time he
00:33:47 became a political figure she was pretty well out of the political world yes but she knew him
00:33:52 and admired him as a journalist so she noticed when he started to write from brussels in 1989
00:33:57 and greatly enjoyed those dispatches and sort of um used to wave him around a bit and you would
00:34:03 have been his boss at that point i was his boss um uh more or less at that not when he began in
00:34:09 brussels but yes yeah a bit later in the 90s most of the 90s and um uh she liked him and she liked
00:34:17 his work and he was a great admirer of hers they were never intimates or anything like that but um
00:34:22 Boris would be a good thing in her mind
00:34:24 and still
00:34:25 well I mean I never talk about
00:34:28 what she didn't, what is a speculation
00:34:30 but she was, to the extent
00:34:32 she had to do with Boris
00:34:34 she liked what she saw
00:34:35 you say the very final words
00:34:39 in the book
00:34:40 Charles are
00:34:42 she gave
00:34:44 everything she could
00:34:46 the last words in the epilogue
00:34:48 to use
00:34:50 that famous quote about greatness
00:34:52 Do you think that Margaret Thatcher achieved greatness or was born great?
00:35:00 Well, you'd have to say both, I think, because obviously she was born with prodigious abilities.
00:35:05 But it could have been like Grey's Elegy, which is an entirely a poem about people who haven't done things.
00:35:11 You know, this mutant, glorious Milton here may rest, this cromwell guiltless of his country's blood.
00:35:15 All these people in a poor village who might have done something but haven't.
00:35:20 and the sense of possibility not fulfilled but she did do it so she could have been the
00:35:27 muting glorious grossest daughter um but she wasn't she was the she did it so by the most
00:35:34 prodigious effort I mean quite incredible effort and commitment I think and sense of duty and
00:35:41 very strong personal ambition so a combination of if you like selfishness or egotism let's say
00:35:46 and true service
00:35:49 did it
00:35:51 so it's greatness in
00:35:53 both those forms I think
00:35:55 So you admire her more as a result
00:35:57 of this book or less?
00:35:59 Yeah more because I mean goodness
00:36:01 she could be dreadful I mean you know terrible
00:36:03 and difficult and everything but the thing was
00:36:04 what you realise, what I realise
00:36:11 writing the book is the difficulties she
00:36:13 overcame were stupefying
00:36:15 The opposition, the problems, the fact she's the only woman, class issues, bureaucracy getting in the way, everything.
00:36:26 And the fact she could achieve so much and do so much and communicate so much and care so much and keep going and win, keep winning.
00:36:35 Absolutely extraordinary.
00:36:37 Thank you very much, Charles, for that. Thank you.
00:36:39 the book of course is called herself alone and uh it is it's quite an achievement the whole thing
00:36:46 thank you very much indeed um we will see you next time um do subscribe as i always say i'll see you
00:36:53 next time