New Culture Forum - November 16, 2019


S2.09 UK Immigration - The Facts: Rt. Hon. Lord Green

S2.03 Martin Durkin: Media Bias & Brexit Snobbery S2.10 Theodore Dalrymple: Britain's Vanishing Culture & Character

Episode Stats


Length

34 minutes

Words per minute

150.22

Word count

5,182

Sentence count

303


Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
00:00:00 Hello and welcome to So What You're Saying Is. I'm Peter Whittle. Now I'm delighted that my
00:00:21 guest this week is Lord Green of Deddington. Lord Green is the founder of Migration Watch,
00:00:27 which is the only independent body arguing for sensible controls on migration.
00:00:33 Migration Watch was founded in 2001.
00:00:36 Before that, Law Green was a diplomat, indeed ambassador to Saudi Arabia.
00:00:42 Welcome to you, Law Green.
00:00:43 Thank you.
00:00:44 I wanted to start by asking you, because it's very current.
00:00:48 We've just had a report that comes from the ONSI,
00:00:54 that's the Office of National Statistics, so it's a government.
00:00:57 body, that our population is going to increase by something like, they say, 3 million in
00:01:04 10 years. And I just wondered, it seems to have passed by with relatively little comment,
00:01:12 something which I consider, I think most people would, to be quite a big thing. Why do you
00:01:17 think that is? Well, first of all, this is a quite extraordinary statistic. It's nearly
00:01:22 a million every three years. And a million is a population of Birmingham. Think of what's
00:01:27 involved in Birmingham. Every three years, that's what we have to build in terms of roads
00:01:32 and railways and houses and business and jobs. This is massive. But almost more important
00:01:38 is almost for the first time, the official statisticians have admitted that 80% of the
00:01:45 population increase is down to immigration. So what we face is a huge increase in our
00:01:52 population, which is optional. And I don't know anybody who thinks that an extra million every
00:01:57 three years is of itself a good idea. Skilled migrants, yes of course. I mean none of us are
00:02:02 opposed to immigration in principle, quite the opposite. But it's the scale of it that is our
00:02:07 problem. And you've got to remember we are one of the most crowded countries, major countries in the
00:02:12 world. We're number five in the world. We are nearly twice as crowded as Germany, three and a
00:02:18 half times as crowded as France. Now why do we want any more people? I mean frankly it's
00:02:23 ridiculous and most of the public agree with this. It seems to me as well that this might
00:02:30 be an underestimate, is that right do you think? I mean they are, as I understand it,
00:02:36 they are calculating this on the basis of 190,000 people a year, but isn't it more like 250,000
00:02:44 at the moment? The average of the past 10 years has been 250,000. The official statisticians
00:02:52 have been very cautious about what they've said all the way through, and they underestimate
00:02:58 yes. We've been saying that for years, yes, and we're right. I see. With this though,
00:03:04 to get back to my point originally, when I say it's passed without comment, it was in
00:03:09 the papers but when you consider this is a huge number as you say historically without precedent
00:03:15 really. Oh absolutely. Why do you think that there is less discussion about this? Well at present
00:03:24 it's because of Brexit. Brexit drowns every other issue in terms of salience it's 60 percent no
00:03:30 other issue is more than about 17 percent. But isn't this really related to Brexit as well in a way
00:03:35 Isn't it? Immigration was one of the main reasons people voted for Brexit.
00:03:40 Oh, it absolutely was, yes. There's no question about that.
00:03:43 And the government have tried to ignore it.
00:03:46 The Labour Party have tried to ignore it.
00:03:48 But in terms of the day-to-day press,
00:03:51 when you've got the big questions that Brexit are throwing up,
00:03:56 we're sitting around waiting to be told what the EU will accept,
00:03:59 that's bound to hit the headlines more than this much longer term,
00:04:03 but in my view much more serious issue because after all the consequences of brexit will be
00:04:10 considerable but in 10 or 20 years we'll have gone through it we'll be in a different situation one
00:04:15 way or the other but when it comes to immigration we won't i mean these numbers are climbing and
00:04:21 they will continue to climb unless serious action is taken to reduce them there's also been recently
00:04:28 this announcement by the government that they would pursue, I say they would
00:04:33 because in fact you know what they can actually do at the moment is a matter
00:04:37 of conjecture, they would pursue an Australian style point system. Now what
00:04:43 what is your position on that? Well I have to smile because the reason they
00:04:50 talk about an Australian style system is because the focus groups like it and
00:04:55 And the Australians have the image of a tough country on immigration.
00:05:00 That's why people like it.
00:05:01 But actually it's completely inappropriate for the UK.
00:05:05 Their circumstances are completely different.
00:05:07 They're trying to grow their population.
00:05:10 We're, I don't know, hundreds of times more crowded than they are.
00:05:14 So it's not really relevant.
00:05:17 What the government will now have to do is to produce some proposals
00:05:20 that arguably look faintly like the Australian system.
00:05:25 But for a start, the Australians put a cap on migration for work.
00:05:31 It depends on that.
00:05:32 Now, the one thing that this government would say they don't like is caps.
00:05:36 So, you know, they're in some difficulty.
00:05:39 But it will be possible to produce something that can be called Australian,
00:05:45 but it has to reduce the numbers, and that is the missing link.
00:05:50 what the government have done is last two days before the Christmas break
00:05:55 they slipped out a white paper on their future immigration policy
00:06:00 saying we're going to treat the whole world the same
00:06:02 because now we're free or will be free of the European Union.
00:06:06 However, there are some absolutely key elements in that
00:06:10 which have not been properly examined.
00:06:13 Such as?
00:06:14 Just to stick to the two main ones.
00:06:15 The first is there is a proposal to reduce the level of qualification required for a skilled worker from degree level to A level.
00:06:25 Huge difference.
00:06:27 Secondly, they want to reduce the 30,000 salary requirement for a skilled worker to something, could be 25,000, could even be 21,000 pounds a year.
00:06:40 Now, if you do those two things, we calculate that we will expose 9 million British workers,
00:06:49 9 million, to either new or increased foreign competition.
00:06:54 And what's more, there's no requirement to advertise it first in the UK.
00:06:59 I mean, this is going to be terribly damaging to British workers.
00:07:03 And what are Labour saying about it? Nothing.
00:07:06 You know, it's just not good enough, frankly.
00:07:08 So basically the Conservatives are actually liberalising the position, are they not?
00:07:18 There's a serious risk, not just that they'll liberalise it, which is what this certainly implies,
00:07:23 but that it will run out of control.
00:07:26 I mean, it's much easier to loosen controls than to tighten them.
00:07:28 And once you've changed the law, it gets very difficult to tighten it again,
00:07:32 and then you've got people caught halfway and so on.
00:07:34 And it's fatal to let loose the pressures on immigration in this country,
00:07:42 which have been very substantial now for 20 years.
00:07:46 When you look at those 20 years,
00:07:50 I want to talk about the role of the Labour government a bit later,
00:07:55 but when you look at those 20 years,
00:07:58 do you think that it's extraordinary that here you have,
00:08:03 what is it always about 60 to 65 percent of the population saying we are concerned about these
00:08:10 numbers and yet successive governments entirely ignoring them it's astonishing i mean first of
00:08:19 all you say 60 percent odd you're absolutely right we published a paper a few months ago
00:08:25 which examined six opinion polls not our opinion polls we didn't pay for them we didn't choose the
00:08:31 questions. These are six polls by four different organisations and the calculation from all
00:08:38 of them is that 30 million people want to see, UK adults I'm talking about, want to
00:08:45 see immigration reduced in Britain. 18 million want to see it reduced by a lot. And do you
00:08:52 know how many want to see it increased? No, how many? Five and a half million. So those
00:08:58 Those who want it reduced are more than five times greater than those who want to see it
00:09:02 increased.
00:09:03 And that's exactly the point you're making, isn't it?
00:09:05 And those are the numbers behind it, but that's the point you're making.
00:09:08 How is it that a Conservative government has failed to achieve it?
00:09:16 I think to be fair, two points.
00:09:19 One is it was Labour that let it loose, and we'll come to that later I hope.
00:09:23 But the second is that the Cameron government did seek to reduce it.
00:09:29 And certainly Theresa May did, she was focused on that.
00:09:32 The problem is within government that all the other departments want to see it increased,
00:09:40 starting with the Treasury, who were very powerful, because it makes the economy bigger,
00:09:45 it looks better.
00:09:46 But actually, there is no evidence that immigration adds significantly anyway to what's called
00:09:53 GDP per head, production per head.
00:09:56 That's what your wealth depends on, the amount each person on average produces goes up.
00:10:01 There's no evidence for that.
00:10:04 Nor is there any evidence that it increases productivity.
00:10:07 We've had productivity in the UK flat for 10 years or more, and immigration has gone
00:10:14 up like that.
00:10:15 So if there was a positive effect, there's no sign of it.
00:10:19 So despite the economic case being extremely shaky, you do have people like the Treasury
00:10:26 arguing for it.
00:10:27 You have even people like the Ministry of Defence who want to recruit people from overseas.
00:10:31 Yes.
00:10:32 Of course you have the National Health Service who have simply failed to train their own
00:10:36 staff.
00:10:37 So you've got all these people who want it, plus, and this is important in the Conservative
00:10:42 government plus business which is making money out of it to put it bluntly and simply they're
00:10:49 making a lot of money out of it and they don't want to see change so they are making money but
00:10:54 the country as a whole does not so I remember and you would know better than anybody there was an
00:11:00 all-party committee about immigration it must be over 10 years ago now and it came out saying that
00:11:07 In fact, the economic advantage was negligible.
00:11:11 That was about 2008, I think.
00:11:14 This was actually the House of Lords Immigration Committee, Economic Committee.
00:11:18 Yes, they did.
00:11:20 They said, evidently to their surprise,
00:11:23 they said we have now found no evidence that net migration adds to GDP per head.
00:11:31 Ignored.
00:11:32 Not convenient.
00:11:34 Not what the bosses wanted to see.
00:11:35 when you've always been at migration watch rigorously statistical evidence-based
00:11:43 and obviously that lends itself i would have thought very well to the economic arguments
00:11:49 but there are also huge social consequences aren't there of migration and i'm thinking that
00:11:56 you know there is the view that even if one accepted that there was an economic
00:12:02 advantages somewhere, that maybe those social advantages or disadvantages might actually
00:12:09 weigh the other way. I mean, wouldn't you say that that's the case?
00:12:15 I'd certainly say that there is a case for immigration, yes, as I said at the beginning.
00:12:20 We have no difficulty with immigration. It does add to the variety in our country,
00:12:26 It brings new ideas, it brings people who are bilingual, it produces ballet dancers, artists, architects.
00:12:35 But this is not the typical experience of most people, is it?
00:12:39 Well, exactly not, no, exactly not.
00:12:41 That is not what most people out in the countryside perceive, it's not what they have.
00:12:48 And the majority of immigrants are not in that kind of category.
00:12:53 What the ordinary people, like where I live, what they perceive is that the GP's surgeries get more and more crowded,
00:13:01 that the council houses are full of immigrants.
00:13:05 Now, it may be that they are council houses that have been privatised and are now being let out to immigrants,
00:13:11 but if you're just an ordinary person in the street, you don't know that.
00:13:15 All you know is that an area that was full of Brits is now full of foreigners.
00:13:19 So, from the point of view of ordinary people, there is not much benefit from this.
00:13:27 And they know it, hence the numbers that we discussed earlier.
00:13:31 When you started Migration Watch 2001, was it easier or more difficult to discuss immigration than compared to now?
00:13:44 I think in a sense it was easier, partly because we were first in the field.
00:13:49 Nobody else was going to talk about it, partly because our whole approach was to set out the facts.
00:13:57 And we've been doing that now for nearly 20 years, and people know that that is what we're doing.
00:14:02 So that makes us, to a certain extent, bulletproof, not entirely bulletproof.
00:14:10 There are people who want to attack you in any case.
00:14:12 But we were new, the subject was new, the numbers were just taking off and we predicted
00:14:21 that they would take off by the way.
00:14:23 We said in 10 years time there will be 2 million immigrants.
00:14:26 We were rubbished at the time, this was in 2002, 10 years time it was 2 million.
00:14:32 And again with the Romanians and Bulgarians, we said they're going to be 50,000 a year,
00:14:36 rubbished at the time, what's the number, 50,000.
00:14:40 So we've been consistently right in these projections and have made consistent arguments,
00:14:48 economic and statistical arguments, which people have found very difficult to counter.
00:14:52 Indeed, they haven't.
00:14:54 But you say, was it easier or more difficult?
00:14:57 It's now more difficult, I would say, because people are much more nervous about the racial
00:15:03 aspect.
00:15:04 And I think that is what makes people pretty nervous about the subject, and there's no
00:15:08 need to be.
00:15:09 you know, this isn't about race, but the present opposition, the Labour Party, are trying to
00:15:15 make it about race in order to deter people from stating their view. And that undermines
00:15:21 democracy, actually. If you feel that on a subject that's important to you, you'd better
00:15:26 not talk about it. I mean, you're completely undermining the democratic process, in my
00:15:30 view.
00:15:30 But haven't they always done this? Haven't they always tried to make it, close it down
00:15:34 by talking about people being racist and whatever.
00:15:37 I mean, as long as I can remember, that's sort of been the argument.
00:15:41 I mean, I'm very alarmed that you think that, in fact, it's actually more difficult now.
00:15:47 That's also my perception.
00:15:48 It seems like it's an issue that's been kind of kicked into the long grass again.
00:15:55 Well, when I started, as I say, we were sticking to the facts very carefully and rightly.
00:16:01 I was a former ambassador.
00:16:03 I'd served for, I don't know, 15 years in the Arab world.
00:16:07 I mean, it's quite hard to call me a racist.
00:16:09 You don't join the Foreign Service if you're a racist.
00:16:12 So we were quite well placed from that point of view,
00:16:15 and there was less general nervousness.
00:16:17 I think there's now more.
00:16:19 I think to some extent it's deliberately generated by the opposition,
00:16:24 by the Labour Party and by the Liberal Democrats,
00:16:26 to deter those who want to see immigration brought under control.
00:16:32 What about, though, Andrew, the role of the media in this?
00:16:37 You talk about the Liberal Party, Labour Party, and we sort of all know that.
00:16:43 But when it comes to sort of the broader establishment, for want of a better word,
00:16:48 I mean, with the media, how has your attitude to the media's role changed in, what is it,
00:16:55 nearly 20 years now with Migration Watch.
00:16:57 How has your attitude to them changed?
00:17:00 Well, I have to say I'm disappointed with the BBC.
00:17:05 In the first place, it was new material, new subject.
00:17:09 I had a certain amount of time on the BBC,
00:17:12 although usually on Radio 5 Live.
00:17:15 The BBC regarded immigration as something the peasants are concerned,
00:17:18 you know, football and things like that.
00:17:21 Radio 4 didn't much like it,
00:17:22 although I was on the Today programme from time to time.
00:17:25 But increasingly, it's clear that they are not willing to present the issue in a balanced and objective way.
00:17:38 And that's not just my opinion. Senior BBC people, as they retire, will tell you that they hadn't understood.
00:17:46 John Hamfress was the latest one. He said, BBC never grasped the significance of this.
00:17:51 And the head of the television said the same a few years before.
00:17:55 So there's no question that the BBC are disposed in favour of immigration, it's part of their world view, they're entitled to that.
00:18:05 What they're not entitled to do is to slant their coverage, and in my view that's what they're doing.
00:18:10 Can you sort of give us any examples of how they would do that?
00:18:14 I mean, when you say slant their coverage, I mean, is it sort of, do they underplay the figures, for example?
00:18:21 How would they do that?
00:18:23 They report the figures accurately and briefly if they have to. In other material they are
00:18:33 not so balanced. I'll give you one example. A leading BBC man, I better not name him perhaps,
00:18:41 produced a I think 40-minute, 60-minute programme about immigration about a year or so ago and I
00:18:47 I was asked if I would appear and I said of course the appointment was changed
00:18:52 five times and finally they cancelled it and they cancelled it when the main
00:18:59 presenter got involved I shan't mention his name although I'm tempted to but I
00:19:05 think this will be not come as a surprise to too many people listening and
00:19:09 watching this kind of actually it's not just BBC we talk about the BBC because
00:19:15 it's the main media, it's the nucleus if you like, and also we pay for it. But I would
00:19:21 say generally media-wise there is a kind of scepticism about the immigration argument.
00:19:31 They tend to be pro-migration, don't they? The broadcast media, I mean.
00:19:38 Well I think they're citizens of what I would call the chattering classes, particularly
00:19:42 London yeah and yeah they don't like the subject they don't want to deal with it
00:19:47 they certainly don't want to deal with the case against it but I remember
00:19:50 talking to a producer privately this is two years ago ten years ago I won't name
00:19:56 him and I had seen a certain amount of him and I asked him about the workings
00:20:05 of the today program and he said to me if as a producer you suggest in the sort
00:20:11 morning meeting that maybe migration watch should be consulted or invited to speak he said the sort
00:20:18 of silence in the room that's how it's done i think yes um go back to talk about if you look
00:20:26 at the broad picture of of migration say since 1990 uh essentially it was the advent of the
00:20:36 Blair Labour government which changed so much wasn't it Andrew I mean before then
00:20:41 as I understand it net migration was around about 50,000 and then from the
00:20:47 moment almost 1997 the Labour government seems to have been entirely pivotal in
00:20:54 changing the course of migration you say that's right absolutely right
00:20:59 absolutely right it changed beyond recognition under the Blair
00:21:04 government. It was done by underhand methods and indeed to the extent that Blair's memoirs
00:21:12 barely mention immigration despite having transformed the situation. But it so happens
00:21:17 that one of their members blew the gaff. This was the case of? Somebody called Andrew Nether.
00:21:24 Andrew Nether, yes. Now he was a speech writer for Tony Blair. He then went to the home office
00:21:29 and himself says he wrote the draft of the speech that Mrs Roach gave.
00:21:39 This is Barbara Roach.
00:21:40 Barbara Roach, she was then the Minister of Immigration,
00:21:42 that kicked off this whole thing.
00:21:44 And if I may, I'd like to quote some sentences from his article
00:21:48 ten years later in the Evening Standard.
00:21:54 So this would have been around about 2008?
00:21:57 2009 it was.
00:21:57 2009.
00:21:58 Exactly ten years ago. Ten years ago yesterday, I think.
00:22:01 OK.
00:22:02 It makes the most extraordinary reading.
00:22:06 Yes.
00:22:06 Today, in the light of how it all turned out.
00:22:10 What he was doing, there was some concern about the scale of immigration.
00:22:15 And his article was entitled,
00:22:17 Don't Listen to the Whingers, London Leads Immigrants.
00:22:20 Yes.
00:22:22 And he says, what's missing is not only a sense of the benefits of immigration,
00:22:27 but also of where it came from.
00:22:30 Now listen.
00:22:32 He says this.
00:22:33 It didn't just happen.
00:22:35 The deliberate policy of ministers from late 2000
00:22:38 until at least February last year, 2009,
00:22:42 when the government introduced a points-based system
00:22:44 was to open up the UK to mass immigration.
00:22:49 That from a man who had been at the heart of government.
00:22:52 He then went on to explain how it had been done.
00:22:57 He said later, he wrote that London's role as a magnet for immigration busted wide open
00:23:08 the stale 1990 clichés about multiculturalism.
00:23:12 It's a question of genuine diversity now, not just tacking a few Afro-Caribbean and Bengali
00:23:18 events onto the white British mainstream.
00:23:22 His words, not mine.
00:23:23 Yes.
00:23:24 Then he says, so why is it that ministers have been so very bad at communicating this?
00:23:30 I wonder.
00:23:30 Because I wrote the landmark speech given by the then immigration minister, as we discussed, Barbara Roach, September 2000,
00:23:38 calling for a loosening of controls.
00:23:40 It marked a major shift from the policy of previous governments.
00:23:44 Didn't it just?
00:23:45 he then refers to the unit that did the think piece
00:23:50 and he says that this report
00:23:54 on which the policy was based
00:23:56 was surrounded by an unusual air
00:23:58 of both anticipation and secrecy
00:24:00 drafts were handed out in the summer of 2000
00:24:03 only with extreme reluctance
00:24:05 there was a paranoia about it reaching the media
00:24:08 I mean just listen to this
00:24:10 it gets worse
00:24:12 I mean this is extraordinary
00:24:13 it's factual, he was there
00:24:15 He has made, he and his mates, have made a fantastic difference to our society by means of conspiracy.
00:24:22 There's nothing else.
00:24:24 But the earlier drafts I saw also included a driving political purpose,
00:24:29 that mass immigration was the way that the government was going to make the UK truly multicultural.
00:24:35 I remember coming away from some discussions with the clear sense that the policy was intended,
00:24:40 even if it wasn't its main purpose
00:24:42 to rub the right's nose in diversity
00:24:45 and render their arguments out of date
00:24:47 that seemed to me to be a manoeuvre too far
00:24:50 at least he said that
00:24:52 he goes on, I've nearly finished this
00:24:54 but it is so important
00:24:55 ministers were very nervous about the whole thing
00:24:59 for despite Barbara Roach's keenness
00:25:01 to make her big speech and to be up front
00:25:03 there was a reluctance elsewhere in government
00:25:06 to discuss what increased immigration would mean
00:25:09 above all, wait for it, above all for Labour's core white working class vote.
00:25:17 Indeed so.
00:25:19 And then he admits, I've nearly finished,
00:25:21 the results were dramatic.
00:25:24 In 1995, 55,000 foreigners, a few years later, trebled.
00:25:30 So you couldn't have clearer evidence.
00:25:33 Of course, the Labour Party have said nothing about this.
00:25:36 They were told to clam up, nothing they've said.
00:25:37 But don't you think, Andrew, it's extraordinary that this, I remember this very clearly.
00:25:43 It didn't have much coverage.
00:25:45 It didn't have, that's the point.
00:25:47 It was commented on, but it did not have coverage when you consider the magnitude of what was being said.
00:25:54 Exactly.
00:25:55 Which I think really, really tends to confirm what you were saying earlier.
00:25:59 I mean, essentially, you're talking about a media, broadcast media particularly, who are pro-immigration.
00:26:07 What was interesting about that article by Andrew Neither, too, was that he's entirely for this, actually, isn't he?
00:26:16 It's not like, this is not a criticism.
00:26:18 He's entitled to his view.
00:26:20 What he's not entitled to do as a civil servant or political advisor,
00:26:25 take part in a conspiracy to deceive the British public with a view to changing the whole nature of our society.
00:26:32 It's outrageous.
00:26:32 Do you think that, as well, that, how shall I put it, electoral advantage played any part in any of this?
00:26:44 I mean, in terms of, for example, you know, the Labour Party, you think, well, actually, essentially, we have many new voters here.
00:26:56 I think at the time, the motivation was what he described it to be.
00:27:01 that is to make Britain much more multicultural.
00:27:07 I think that is changing
00:27:08 and I think that the growth of the immigrant communities
00:27:12 and the disparity between their voting
00:27:16 in the sense that something like 65% of black voters vote Labour
00:27:21 and I think in other communities
00:27:26 it is not as strong as that
00:27:29 But the immigrant voters tend to vote Labour.
00:27:33 So yes, I think now we're in a situation where Labour want to build on that.
00:27:40 And to take an example, the Windrush affair has been weaponised by Labour against the Conservatives.
00:27:49 Well, the first thing to say is this went on for 50 years under both governments.
00:27:53 and secondly that you can't blame civil servants for it.
00:28:01 They didn't know the technicalities of someone who arrived in the 1950s.
00:28:06 My chairman, Al-Mahmed, is by this standard a Windrush child.
00:28:12 He's done extraordinarily well. He was an ambassador.
00:28:14 So, you know, it's being deliberately weaponised and rather effectively.
00:28:19 do you think that there will ever be a time do you think can you envisage circumstances in which
00:28:28 for example we could return to a situation where there are say net 50,000 you know coming into
00:28:36 Britain like there was unless people who apart from people who are on the real extremes most
00:28:44 Most people were perfectly fine with that situation, they're not against migration,
00:28:48 as you said, quite rightly, and that seemed to be a perfectly commonsensical amount.
00:28:57 That can't be returned to, can it, or can it?
00:29:00 We can't get back down to 50,000, no, because once you accept people as immigrants they
00:29:05 have certain rights to bring in some of their relatives, not all of them, but some relatives
00:29:09 or spouses or whatever.
00:29:13 So that is beyond the possible I think.
00:29:17 You could get it down to 100, which was of course their target, but you'd need to take
00:29:21 a whole range of measures over time and tighten up the system.
00:29:26 That is what is necessary, that is what Mrs May was trying to do.
00:29:30 She didn't succeed because of opposition within the government, among other things.
00:29:36 So it will not be easy to get this back to a sensible level.
00:29:42 But the problem is this. The problem is you've got 30 million people, and this is absolutely
00:29:47 serious stuff, you've got 30 million people who want it reduced, and there are no serious
00:29:52 proposals by either party to get it down. Now, I think that's really bad for our democracy.
00:29:58 And frankly, I don't think Brexit is good for our democracy. People are sick and tired
00:30:01 of Brexit and the contortions of the various elements of government. But they'll be touched
00:30:09 by a failure of immigration policy. And the risk is this, that if the Conservative
00:30:17 government remain in power, if they implement the proposals that they've
00:30:21 outlined in their white paper in the manner that they've been indicating, it's
00:30:25 not that immigration will not come down, it will go up. The average of the last
00:30:30 10 years, I mentioned 250,000. It has touched a third of a million. Now the
00:30:36 an awful lot of uncertainties about the shape of the future,
00:30:41 but it's by no means impossible that it go up again
00:30:43 to a third of a million or more.
00:30:45 And then we will have again a situation
00:30:47 where the governing parties are completely out of touch,
00:30:52 out of sync with the weight of public opinion.
00:30:57 And that is very serious.
00:30:59 I mean, I know we talked about this earlier,
00:31:02 but it seems to me that they don't quite care
00:31:04 whether they're out of touch.
00:31:05 This has been a very consistently measured opinion, hasn't it, in the public
00:31:13 for a couple of decades, and it seems to make no difference.
00:31:18 Just a couple of more things, really, Andrew.
00:31:20 I think it seems also that the current situation of mass migration
00:31:26 is being justified retrospectively by changing the history, if you like.
00:31:31 So, you hear a lot now that Britain is a nation of immigrants, and it's almost like, you know, actually we're going to sort of, like, adjust history to suit the current situation.
00:31:47 That's what they have tried to do with some success.
00:31:49 Yes.
00:31:49 And the fact of the matter is that the foreign-born population in the year 1900 was about 2%.
00:31:55 Yes.
00:31:55 It's now 14%.
00:31:56 Yes.
00:31:57 we're probably one of the most consistent populations in the world because we're an island so that foreign migration has been foreign to our culture until effectively about 1950 or so since when it's gone up very sharply we now have one child one baby in three born to having one foreign parent
00:32:24 so there has been a huge
00:32:27 impact but not because we're a nation
00:32:29 of immigrants but because the
00:32:31 Labour government lost
00:32:33 control of immigration and the Conservatives
00:32:35 failed to bring it under control
00:32:36 We hear an awful lot of the Huguenots
00:32:39 are pressed into service
00:32:41 an awful lot aren't they
00:32:42 in the 17th, 18th century
00:32:44 I believe it was something like between
00:32:47 50 and 100,000 Huguenots over a
00:32:49 period of a century
00:32:50 we're now talking about
00:32:53 250,000 oh yeah you know thank you very much for joining us under and talking
00:33:00 about this it's an extraordinary and also I just really want to finish by
00:33:06 asking I asked this but do you do you feel that the argument is going to get
00:33:14 harder to make for sensible migration do you think it's actually going to be
00:33:20 harder looking to the future than it has been even until now no I don't think so
00:33:27 I think you've got to be prepared to make the arguments and you've got to
00:33:30 have a thick skin and get on with it yes but I think the sheer facts of the
00:33:34 matter are going to alert public opinion yeah they're already they're already
00:33:38 aware of it privately you talk to people around the countryside they do not like
00:33:43 what's happening that's the fact of the matter most MPs know it now if we get
00:33:47 into the situation I described where the numbers start climbing up again, then we'll be in
00:33:52 a new political situation altogether. And I think people will insist that action is
00:33:58 taken to preserve the society that our predecessors have built, have fought for, have died for.
00:34:08 And it's just, to me, unacceptable that that should be thrown away.
00:34:15 Well, on that note, thank you very very much Andrew for coming in. Thank you.
00:34:19 Thanks for watching So What You're Saying Is. We will see you next time.
00:34:23 Please do subscribe in the meantime. Thank you very much. Bye-bye.