New Culture Forum - October 13, 2020


Sex Education Reforms: What Are the Reforms? Should The State Teach Sex Education & Gender Identity?

The Identity Obsessed Heroes & Villains View Of History Is Dangerously Simplistic & Divisive Sacred Music: The Unsung Battleground In The Long March | Culture Wars

Episode Stats


Length

38 minutes

Words per minute

158.2

Word count

6,139

Sentence count

177


Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
00:00:00 Hello and welcome to Counterculture. I'm Peter Whittall. Now this summer of course
00:00:18 the headlines have been completely dominated by Covid and indeed then the culture war and
00:00:25 particularly Black Lives Matter. But there's another issue which has been bubbling away
00:00:30 and causing many people a lot of concern. As of this month, September, there is going to be new
00:00:37 compulsory sex and relationship education in our state schools and this is dividing opinion and
00:00:46 indeed it's causing a fair amount of controversy. But a lot of people won't even really know what
00:00:53 it contains what actually it means what they should be worried about and that's what we're
00:00:58 going to be discussing today on counterculture and with me i have some great guests to talk
00:01:05 about it first of all there is belinda brown who is a journalist and campaigner caroline fisk
00:01:14 who is a former conservative counselor and journalist susan mason who is founder of the
00:01:20 school gate campaign the reverend linda rose who is also ceo of voice for justice uk and
00:01:30 ben lochnane who is a theologian and communications consultant so thank you very much for coming
00:01:38 everybody um belinda could you start by just explaining you know what actually
00:01:46 this actually means what what is being introduced that is new um well the government has made
00:01:55 relationships and sex education compulsory um throughout school from primary school onwards
00:02:02 um but there are and and there are there are sort of three different ways of looking at this on one
00:02:09 hand there's the law which has been set up and if you read it the law on relationships and sex
00:02:15 education sounds fairly okay you there's nothing particularly objectionable to it can I ask you by
00:02:23 the way what it says then at the moment there's to be honest I think this will emerge during the
00:02:31 course of the discussion because there are so many different elements to it there's really
00:02:35 there's really quite a lot and also following from this there's the education department guidance
00:02:42 So that's what they've done with the law, which is kind of, you know, it's okay.
00:02:50 But the real problem is that there's actually no specific curriculum.
00:02:57 So there have been a whole host of educational providers, a really wide range, have got in on the Act and have produced a whole lot of material for schools.
00:03:09 This is obviously a very lucrative business because schools have to buy into this and it's in this wide range of materials that the really serious problems arise.
00:03:22 Now there are a few I think key points which I should make and that is that schools are obliged to consult parents about what they're going to teach their children.
00:03:33 and actually it's now been delayed
00:03:36 until the beginning of the summer term
00:03:38 in order to allow enough time for consultation
00:03:41 and it is part of the law, the UN law
00:03:45 that schools are obliged to take the values of parents
00:03:51 they must respect the values and religious values of parents
00:03:55 so the schools are obliged to do this
00:03:57 and schools are also not allowed to teach ideology
00:04:02 things from a particular ideological angle and I should also say that in primary school
00:04:09 the sex education is not compulsory and in secondary school relationships and you put
00:04:23 it differently you can withdraw your you can withdraw your child from sex education in primary
00:04:28 school. You can withdraw your child. And in secondary school, you can withdraw your child
00:04:32 from sex education. I think it's up until the year of their 15th birthday or something
00:04:40 like that. But to be perfectly honest, these things are fairly meaningless because the
00:04:45 material gets into the curriculum in other ways. And I have actually attended a sex education
00:04:50 forum seminar, webinar, where they said, you know, this material, if they don't get it
00:04:57 through sex education, they'll get it in the sciences or they'll get it in the health part
00:05:02 of the PSHE curriculum. So it's very difficult actually to withdraw your child from any of
00:05:08 this material. But they must consult you and that is a key thing to take home. Schools
00:05:13 must consult parents. You mentioned there that it's in the law that schools have to
00:05:22 respect parents' values. How exactly is that actually enforced? I mean, how do we know that
00:05:31 they are? Do you know? Well, we don't know that they are. And schools have, for example,
00:05:37 with sex education, which has been in schools for many years now, primary schools do not have to
00:05:43 provide it, but they may do. And as Belinda says, parents can withdraw from primary. They have a
00:05:51 right to request withdrawal in secondary now as of this September they don't have an automatic
00:05:56 right of withdrawal but what we've seen there is there was a legal obligation to consult parents
00:06:03 there for example and Ofsted has observed how schools do not they're not very good at consulting
00:06:10 with parents about sex education so that that's on the record that they're basically they are not
00:06:15 fulfilling their legal obligations on that level and I can't see how it's going to be much better
00:06:21 with relationships education yes did you is that something caroline that you recognize i mean i
00:06:28 think yeah i think for me the main point is belinda's point that where parents have a right
00:06:33 to withdraw most parents won't most parents trust schools and and so they should they should be able
00:06:40 to trust our schools what this reform has done is it's opened up a gateway really and i would say
00:06:47 10, 20 years ago, that might have been fine. For some reason, the era in which we live,
00:06:52 there's a whole lot of organisations keen to push various things through this gateway.
00:07:00 I would say sexualisation, a sort of sexualisation that most adults don't agree with.
00:07:07 And then gender identity ideology, I think, is the thing that most of us are concerned about.
00:07:13 and there are many organisations producing materials
00:07:18 that push gender identity ideology through into schools
00:07:23 and onto school children, primary, from four years old upwards.
00:07:29 I think that's what most of us are concerned about.
00:07:32 Is this something that concerns you, Ben?
00:07:34 Well, for me, the main concern isn't necessarily the content
00:07:37 of the sex education curriculum.
00:07:39 That is, of course, a major issue.
00:07:41 my concern is the overreach of the state and certainly through schools into what should be
00:07:47 the domain of the family so this is something that should naturally be happening within families
00:07:51 and the state taking it upon themselves to educate your children about what they ideologically
00:07:57 believe about for example transgenderism you know that is not their job their job is to educate it's
00:08:03 you know the three r's would be probably a lot more value but we're now not teaching what should
00:08:08 be taught and teaching a lot of what doesn't need to be taught and it for me that is very confusing
00:08:13 what is the what is the function and what is the purpose of a school in this case is it to teach
00:08:18 children or is it to teach them how to learn and and you know lead them towards knowledge so that
00:08:23 they have a love for learning or is it about indoctrinating them and making sure that they're
00:08:27 right on and agree with every government edict and i think it's the latter unfortunately which
00:08:32 is what you're saying isn't it caroline really that basically what you're saying is that the
00:08:36 times have changed essentially something that might have been okay it's now basically it's
00:08:41 almost like a portal through things can come it's a portal and there's a large number of groups who
00:08:49 have long been gearing up for it producing the resources telling primary school children that
00:08:57 there's no such thing as biological sex that sex is a spectrum it's not there are two sexes
00:09:04 telling primary school children that they all have an inner gender identity which is unaligned to
00:09:11 biological sex. I've got one here, don't judge or make assumptions about people's gender because
00:09:20 of what they look like. Telling a primary school child, a little girl, that she can't go up to
00:09:25 another little girl and assume she's a girl. It's utterly unscientific and it's dangerous.
00:09:32 But you see, something like that, where does that come from?
00:09:36 Who's providing that? You can hold it up if you like.
00:09:39 So this is not a little LGBT plus group.
00:09:46 This is actually from Bernados, the children's charity.
00:09:50 Not only that, this is on a portal which says this is authorised by the Government Authorities Office.
00:09:57 So it's just everywhere.
00:10:00 The website where this is basically says this has been endorsed by the government.
00:10:07 Just one more thing, because I know you all want to go on.
00:10:09 Gender identities, sometimes our gender identity matches our assigned gender, the gender we
00:10:15 were told we were when we were born.
00:10:19 So in other words we're not male and female, male and female is not in our DNA, it's something
00:10:25 we were told we were when we were born.
00:10:28 unscientific guest lighting little children who should be able to feel comfortable in their bodies
00:10:34 and in their sex you've you've actually haven't you Belinda done a lot of looking at the sort of
00:10:41 various different information educational uh you know basically tools that are produced by these
00:10:47 outside bodies how does it actually work you know if you've got like the local authority or the
00:10:53 the school so what do they tender out you know as it were to get people to come in and put their
00:10:58 sort of like wares down so you know we oh yes we'd like you to supply this material or that
00:11:04 material how does it work i have to be honest i don't exactly know how it works i know for example
00:11:10 that one of the organizations that's massive in producing this stuff is stonewall and stonewall
00:11:17 is actually funded by the government and they are at the front line of producing this material
00:11:22 and I think it's a parent power we've actually listed they've actually listed all the all the
00:11:29 schools that they know of that that have stonewall resources but I I think it can't I think the
00:11:35 schools are making individual decisions I mean local educational authorities might try to
00:11:40 influence schools but it is up to schools to choose their materials and I suspect that it's
00:11:47 whichever bodies are sort of getting there first and if you think about an organization like
00:11:52 stonewall that that has a you know that has a reputable name but if you actually look at their
00:11:57 material what what they're what they're teaching children goes against every um safeguarding
00:12:03 principle um you know it's it's very serious and also against science and against science you send
00:12:10 your children to school to learn and they're taught this strange pseudoscience about what is
00:12:15 effectively Gnosticism you know I have the spirit of some strange whatever inhabits my my body but
00:12:22 the body does not match it that is effectively paganism and they're going to these schools
00:12:26 they're effectively woke madrassas now rather than actual real schools and they're learning
00:12:31 nonsense they're better off not going to school at all yeah I very much agree with your point that
00:12:37 the state shouldn't be interfering with with this level of private life you know what the family
00:12:44 should be free from state interference.
00:12:46 We all have different beliefs
00:12:48 and different principles and politics within our families
00:12:52 and we should be allowed to preserve this.
00:12:54 But the state is coming in and trying to shape that.
00:12:58 And that is exactly what I have an issue with.
00:13:00 It's almost Soviet, isn't it,
00:13:02 the way that the state is saying your children are not your children.
00:13:04 They are the children of the state
00:13:05 and they'll be taught the state's values
00:13:07 before the family's values.
00:13:09 And that is a huge precedent to set.
00:13:11 the moment where the children are no longer answerable firstly to their parents and then to
00:13:16 their school but answerable first to the school and the state um linda can i ask you one when
00:13:22 when sex education like when i was growing up you know when when it was discussed what should be
00:13:28 allowed what shouldn't um it the point was always made and quite quite often from people uh religious
00:13:34 people that there should be a moral framework to it um is that what is entirely lacking now or
00:13:42 there doesn't appear to be any kind of moral framework at all i think you put your um finger
00:13:49 on a very uh good point here when educate sex education was first introduced the idea was to
00:13:55 protect children to give them the information that would protect them against getting stis
00:14:02 and to lower the teenage pregnancy rate and it was very much within a moral frame so it was taught
00:14:07 within the context of the family but the problem now is that that emphasis has totally shifted so
00:14:15 we're told that the aim of the new regulations is to prepare children for life in modern britain
00:14:22 so that they learn to be inclusive and tolerant of all the different lifestyles and the whole
00:14:28 idea of there being a moral frame has completely gone because this is somehow judgmental so the
00:14:35 emphasis now is on teaching children the how-to of sex and relationships but without any kind of
00:14:43 frame of reference that they might consider anything about personal restraint or how this
00:14:48 is going to affect them or others and on the coattails of that children are being taught
00:14:56 highly sexualized concepts that they are far too young to cope with.
00:15:03 So in relationships education from age three, would you believe,
00:15:08 the encouragement is to teach children about same sex families.
00:15:14 So they've got picture books, they've got all sorts of things.
00:15:16 This doesn't come under sex education.
00:15:18 It comes under relationships education and health education.
00:15:22 But the problem is you start telling a child of three about, you know, same-sex families and they're saying, well, what's the difference?
00:15:32 And so immediately you have to start talking about mummies and daddies and how two mummies or two daddies are a bit different because they don't have a biological mummy or a daddy there.
00:15:43 It's somehow different. So you're beginning to make children question things that actually, temperamentally, they just accept.
00:15:51 They're not going to question that.
00:15:52 And the same with, you know,
00:15:54 now teaching children that gender is a matter of choice, not biology.
00:15:58 A child of two has a very clear idea of the physical sexual differences.
00:16:03 Being a little boy looks like a boy, a little girl looks like a little girl.
00:16:07 But it is well established that until around the age of seven,
00:16:11 many children do not have an established idea of gender.
00:16:16 So now we're teaching children that from, again, age three, four, five,
00:16:20 you can choose what gender you want to be they have no way of processing what that actually
00:16:28 means so of course that is going to be deeply confusing and destabilizing and this is one of
00:16:35 the root causes of why we are seeing so many referrals now for gender dysphoria of course
00:16:42 they have gender dysphoria because they actually they just have no idea what it is they don't know
00:16:47 to cope with what it is they're being taught so the main problem is that these concepts are being
00:16:54 brought in that actually they shouldn't be bothering about at this age and they these
00:17:00 concepts are being brought in by activists who are seeking to promote an agenda and people have
00:17:05 already mentioned stonewall and mermaids and people these are overtly political organizations
00:17:12 whose aim is to normalize and promote LGBT values they are not concerned at heart with
00:17:23 trial protection or their best interests and welfare and safeguarding of children
00:17:28 their main concern is actually promoting and normalizing the LGBT values and this is having
00:17:37 a devastating effect actually on our children so it is some we're the wrong way around and
00:17:44 just coming back to the parental right of withdrawal okay in primary they have an absolute
00:17:49 right of withdrawing children from sex education and there's no obligation to keep sex education
00:17:54 at all at primary level but at secondary level this right effectively it's been removed because
00:18:02 it's now become a right of request subject to agreement by the head teacher and this is just
00:18:09 such an abuse of parental rights and abuse of children because parents have an absolute right
00:18:15 under law to have children educated in line with their beliefs and there is an absolute right in
00:18:22 law to have religion upheld and protected and these under the new guidelines the new teachings
00:18:30 this is completely being introduced we actually have a there was quite a good instance of this
00:18:37 i don't actually know if it's still going on but you know the case in birmingham uh with the new
00:18:44 teaching at the schools in birmingham and there were religious groups mostly muslim outside who
00:18:49 objecting to it where do you stand on on that caroline you know who would you line up with
00:18:57 in that situation you know i mean now that's a difficult question and uh you know ultimately
00:19:05 i would have to line up with the parents parents have a right to teach their children these
00:19:13 intimate and important subjects at the time that those parents want to teach it but i would also
00:19:21 just add that it could well be that these Muslim families wouldn't have objected to straightforward
00:19:28 facts. As I understand it, they wouldn't have objected to children being taught that homosexuality
00:19:35 exists. It's the whole gender identity ideology that's being overlaid on that, and the explicit
00:19:43 sexual information that's also being piled on top is that what it was in the
00:19:50 case of that if the Birmingham I'm not the parents that I'm in contact with
00:19:54 absolutely they're happy I would say for reality to be taught and for science to
00:20:01 be taught but this new agenda is unscientific and it's transgressive and
00:20:08 there are many gay people who are joining groups like the LGB Alliance is
00:20:13 say that the people most vulnerable to being worried that they're, you know, a child worried
00:20:19 that they've been born in the wrong body through this teaching is little girls or boys who are
00:20:25 little girls attracted to other little girls. So I'm not a lesbian, I'm in the wrong body.
00:20:32 And off they go on a conveyor belt to, you know, I'm trans and I should have my breasts removed
00:20:38 and I should go on cross-sex hormones.
00:20:41 So a lot of gay people are against this agenda as well.
00:20:44 Yes.
00:20:45 I mean, I think, could you give us an idea, Belinda,
00:20:48 of, you know, you can be as detailed as you like,
00:20:52 but what are the kind of things that are,
00:20:55 you know, obviously Caroline's already mentioned a few things there,
00:20:58 in these materials that can be supplied
00:21:00 in the service of sex education?
00:21:04 Okay, well, I've studied this material quite a lot
00:21:07 And an underlying idea is the idea, it's called challenging heteronormativity.
00:21:14 And in order to challenge heteronormativity, you've got to move away, and they're quite explicit about this, I can quote, it's from books.
00:21:22 They need to move away from the association with reproduction.
00:21:26 They're trying to move away from the association between sex and reproduction.
00:21:30 And what they want to emphasise is sexual pleasure and sex positivity.
00:21:35 Since we have been human, we have kept this to the bedroom.
00:21:40 There's a reason for this around privacy and dignity.
00:21:45 The agenda here has gone so far. It's beyond...
00:21:49 The agenda here really is now transgression.
00:21:53 And you have to ask why.
00:21:55 Why do you think it is, Susan?
00:21:57 Yeah, I think this has been sort of in the pipeline for a long time.
00:22:01 I think, well, let's take the 60s, for example, and the sexual revolution and so forth.
00:22:06 But there has been, I think, with certain groups, a deliberate intention to undermine traditional family, marriage and so forth.
00:22:15 And so this is ideal for them.
00:22:20 So it is, I think, a family-breaking agenda, ultimately, and a marriage-breaking agenda.
00:22:28 So, yeah, I think you're right that these things are, let's say, they're called transgressions.
00:22:38 And I just feel for the children, as I think Linda was saying, children are gradually understanding the separate nature of reality and what's imagined over several years.
00:22:50 So to talk with them about gender, for example, is crazy because, you know, as one of my interviewers said, at that age her daughter thought she was a unicorn.
00:23:01 You know, I mean, it's absolutely crazy to then talk about, oh, you know, you're a girl or a boy.
00:23:06 And 30% of those who are being referred to the Tavistock Clinic are on the autism spectrum.
00:23:13 So how well do they understand what they're electing to do?
00:23:17 But it seems to me that there are two topics here in a way
00:23:22 that you can't knock it away with them being interlinked, really.
00:23:26 You're talking about the Tavistock Clinic.
00:23:28 I think the trans issue, all of that,
00:23:30 is actually something which has almost come on top of all this.
00:23:33 I mean, we're talking about what children should and shouldn't be taught sexually.
00:23:39 The trans issue, and I agree with what you're saying,
00:23:43 For example, if you've got a rather effeminate boy or a very tomboyish girl,
00:23:48 in the past, the old liberal tradition would be,
00:23:51 well, why shouldn't she be a tomboy and everything, and she grows out of it.
00:23:55 Whereas now, it is absolutely, she must be actually a boy in a girl's body.
00:24:01 So it's actually become almost more conservative in that way.
00:24:05 I mean, this is the extraordinary thing.
00:24:06 Well, as I say, gay people call it the erasure of gay people,
00:24:09 that you'll sort of find some private girls' schools now
00:24:12 where there's no lesbians left they're all trans men so you know people are
00:24:18 talking about homosexual erasure in this just say in the no outsiders program
00:24:24 which we mentioned earlier that was in Birmingham and it continues to be in
00:24:28 Birmingham schools for primary school children you have got a lesson that
00:24:34 basically says that if you are if you are a primary school child seven or eight
00:24:38 and you have sort of affection for your same-sex friend that you were gay and that is just you
00:24:44 know that's completely misleading. It's killing friendship as well isn't it? Yes. Because you feel
00:24:48 something for a friend and at that age you can't really understand complex emotions but your
00:24:53 teacher's telling you oh no that means you're you know you have these sexual sort of desires as it
00:24:59 were. A child doesn't have any sexual desires why what is the insistence to sexualise children? It
00:25:04 to me strikes me as being a bit pedophilic this entire sort of agenda it's why the obsession with
00:25:09 sexualizing children this is the key question i think you know what what's behind this what's it
00:25:16 for what would you linda what would you like to see i mean what what would your ideal be
00:25:25 uh do you mean in sex and relationships education yes i mean if you could choose how
00:25:30 Well, I think everybody wants to protect children. I mean, that has to be sort of top priority.
00:25:37 So they need to be taught about, I think, the basics of relationships and how to combat,
00:25:45 you know, and to defend themselves against bullying and abuse of all kinds. But there
00:25:51 shouldn't be any sexualized teaching. I don't think sexual concepts ought to be introduced
00:25:58 at all and I mean just coming back to what the other speakers people were saying
00:26:05 we're seeing a huge rise in schools at the moment of child-on-child sexual abuse and again
00:26:13 apparently the police are saying this is sort of it's quite shocking the numbers of referrals
00:26:18 that they're getting there should not be any kind of teaching that makes children sexually aware
00:26:25 prematurely any sort of teaching should be just about valuing themselves and respecting themselves
00:26:33 and being able to say no and to save sex you know that that would be a very useful way of teaching
00:26:42 to teach children that they're all very very special and they are going to damage themselves
00:26:49 if they enter into promiscuous relationships from the age of 11 as they are being encouraged to at
00:26:56 the moment. So children need to be taught the risks that will come from promiscuity,
00:27:04 they need to be taught the health risks, they need to be taught about these STIs that they're going to
00:27:08 open themselves up to, they need to be taught too that they can open themselves up to far worse and
00:27:14 one of the things we're saying seeing with the formation of um oral anal sex is related cancers
00:27:20 and these really are skyrocketing the rates at the moment children must be taught the risks so
00:27:25 that they can assess it for themselves but at the right age appropriate time so that would be what
00:27:32 secondary school would that would that be would that be secondary school what is the appropriate
00:27:40 time say 11 12 i personally don't think it should really be taught so much because you know for
00:27:46 years before this and certainly now when every child has google they're going to ask these
00:27:52 questions at some point naturally and when it happens naturally they have the resources available
00:27:56 to find the answers to the questions they have or they'll go to someone they trust you know a family
00:28:01 member an older sibling or you know whoever and they'll ask the questions i think trying to force
00:28:07 on children at a certain age with so much ideology,
00:28:10 some poisonous ideology attached to it,
00:28:13 a lot of effectively Marxist ideology being threaded
00:28:16 into what is paraded as sex and relationships education,
00:28:20 but what is really about breaking down their idea of the family.
00:28:25 And certainly, when this was introduced,
00:28:27 it was about stopping teenage pregnancies,
00:28:29 but now the curriculum is all about sex isn't just for reproduction,
00:28:32 it's about pleasure.
00:28:33 So you're detaching the relationship for people
00:28:35 between sex and reproduction so that sense of ah I don't want to get someone pregnant so I won't do
00:28:42 this I'll you know that sort of thing when you focus entirely on the pleasure side of things
00:28:46 and you don't actually talk about reproduction you say oh it's not about reproduction children
00:28:50 are going to get a sense of oh well it's fine there's no consequences and then you're going
00:28:53 to get a skyrocket but I mean in a way isn't this sort of locking the gate you know way after the
00:28:58 horse is bolted in the sense that you could say that reproduction and sex were sort of separated
00:29:03 when the pill was invented couldn't you i mean you could go back as far as that 1965 was it
00:29:09 i mean one of one of the arguments that sort of our opponents would make as well you know
00:29:15 children are seeing all this pornography anyway well i was about to go on to pornography
00:29:18 actually but the fact is you know ben talked about google and and and what they can find out
00:29:23 the fact is you can go onto your phone now and see the most extreme porn um without any filter
00:29:30 I believe there was a survey about the age at which people are first exposed to pornography,
00:29:35 and it's somewhere between 9 to 12 years old, which I think is disgraceful.
00:29:40 But they probably already know this stuff.
00:29:42 I think there is an assumption that we should be guided by the children.
00:29:47 This is very much prevalent in the material.
00:29:50 It's like we've given up.
00:29:51 But actually, I think we are in a position where we can guide children.
00:29:55 I mean, for example, if we explain to children the consequences of watching pornography,
00:30:00 I mean, if you tell young boys, look, when you get too much into pornography,
00:30:05 you actually find that you, excuse me to be so graphic,
00:30:08 but you can't maintain an erection when you're in a relationship with a woman.
00:30:12 This is the reality of it, is that young men who become too hooked on pornography
00:30:18 actually find it more difficult having sexual relationships with a real person.
00:30:25 And I think that if you tell young people of the risks,
00:30:28 if you tell young girls that when you have a sexual relationship with someone,
00:30:34 when you then split up, this is really devastating.
00:30:37 And it's quite interesting because actually there are real physiological changes
00:30:41 which happen through the sexual act.
00:30:44 and they mean that actually you're quite traumatised when you break up.
00:30:49 If you tell young people this, if you tell them, you know,
00:30:52 maybe it would be better to read a book than masturbate or whatever,
00:30:56 you know, I think you can actually guide them out of these habits.
00:31:00 You know, yes, all this stuff is available,
00:31:02 and I think if we tell them of the risks,
00:31:05 actually children would be interested in this.
00:31:08 They want to know, and they say that they want to know more about relationships,
00:31:12 So let's tell them the dangers of, you know, early sexual debut, of getting too hooked on pornography, which can follow on from getting too involved with masturbation.
00:31:24 All of these things are being encouraged.
00:31:26 So I think we can guide children away from this.
00:31:29 Can I just put in the idea that, I mean, basically there is this view, again, entirely anecdotal, actually.
00:31:37 I've got no data for it, but that in fact younger people are, I hasten to say the word
00:31:43 Puritan, but younger people are far more as substemious than maybe the generation or the
00:31:49 one before that. Do you hold with that view?
00:31:51 They're less sexually active, I think, but I'm not sure about if they're more innocent.
00:31:55 I think they're actually just numbed to it and it's partly to do with the sex education
00:31:59 because when you have a teacher telling you all this stuff, it sort of takes the fun out
00:32:03 of it really, doesn't it? If it's on the curriculum, you get bored of it.
00:32:07 You know it all. You've seen it all.
00:32:09 Not completely, but I'm saying that it's no longer something which is private.
00:32:14 It's no longer rebellious.
00:32:15 Yeah, it's no longer rebellious. It's been mainstreamed.
00:32:19 And when people have access to all sorts of pornography,
00:32:22 anything they can imagine or even things beyond their imagination,
00:32:26 their appetites change, I think.
00:32:29 But I think even if, nevertheless, damage is still done.
00:32:33 I think, again, I just go back, as you say,
00:32:35 some of these things we didn't ever think we would need data on humans just held them to be true
00:32:40 people didn't generally look on each other performing sexual acts we've become human
00:32:47 as we've developed a sense of privacy and dignity so i actually think it's incredibly damaging
00:32:54 not just for people to look at the online porn i actually think it's damaging for a bunch of 13
00:33:00 year olds to sit around in a group discussing what they might do with a
00:33:05 tongue and an anus it's not liberating it's damaging do you have any I think
00:33:15 Bobby I know the answer this but do you have any truck with the idea that this
00:33:21 is good intentions? It's interesting reading the relationships and sex education
00:33:32 regulations, there are actually just the four points, I can't remember them, sorry
00:33:36 I can't reel them off from memory, but they look very innocent and then there
00:33:43 was an added point before it actually passed through into law and it's just
00:33:49 Oh, it's things like, well, you know, what are the characteristics of healthy relationships?
00:33:53 That was one point, you know, and how, you know, if you have a poor relationship, it
00:33:57 can be damaging for your health and your well-being.
00:34:00 You know, that was point two or, you know, something like that.
00:34:03 And you think, well, that's fine.
00:34:05 You could also say that's an act of parliament.
00:34:09 Surely, since, you know, human race has existed, parents have explained those things to their
00:34:15 children anyway.
00:34:16 so why is and we've had different family configurations as well you know maybe
00:34:21 you know a child has lost one or two parents has to go and live with the
00:34:23 grandparent or an aunt or something or whatever and we've always had those
00:34:28 sorts of family configurations but now all of a sudden we need a curriculum for
00:34:35 children in school it's as if parents have overnight have lost the capacity
00:34:40 to explain these things to their children there's no evidence for that
00:34:44 and there's certainly no evidence that this curriculum going into primary and
00:34:48 secondary schools is any better. Can I just say that I don't think anyone knows
00:34:55 who first said it but the road to hell is paved with good intentions and I think
00:35:00 possibly Gavin Williamson had good intentions but I'll just read something
00:35:05 out I think the good intentions have sort of assumed swamped by a tidal wave
00:35:11 this is again we're talking about the education section yes yes so this is the
00:35:17 sheet for schools for example avoid saying men or boys penises just say
00:35:25 penis can we all understand why I mean imagine teaching boys and girls about
00:35:33 sex education and not being willing to say that men and boys have penises so
00:35:40 So this is no longer to make, I mean, the idea that there was a trans child in the class
00:35:47 anyway, the chances of that, this is now like bodily disassociation.
00:35:55 It's no longer just breakdown of family.
00:35:58 This is kind of transgression of how we are human, of scientific reality.
00:36:03 So I think the good intentions have long since been lost in the tidal wave.
00:36:10 Well, Linda, you had something to say there.
00:36:12 Because I think there is also this difference between the government,
00:36:16 which isn't great but isn't as bad,
00:36:19 but it's the materials coming in through this process.
00:36:23 And having studied them,
00:36:25 there really is the whole challenging heteronormativity agenda.
00:36:29 I mean, I've studied the academic...
00:36:31 There is an ideological push,
00:36:34 whether you call it queer theory or challenging heteronormativity,
00:36:37 it's why you can read through all the academic literature and this has very specific aims they
00:36:42 want to move away from traditional ideas of marriage they want to to break away well they
00:36:47 want to move away from marriage altogether as we understand it they want to break the assumption
00:36:51 links between parents and they want to get away from the assumption that heterosexuality
00:36:56 is normative they want to break the links between parenthood and reproduction they want to break the
00:37:02 links between reproduction and sex they want to break the binary assumption of male and female
00:37:06 This is all clear and documented in the literature.
00:37:10 And then if you follow and look at some of these sex education materials, they're simply reflecting this ideology.
00:37:15 So, you know, I don't call that well-intentioned, but that is a certain group of people's view of what an ideal world looks like.
00:37:23 So from their point of view, it's well-intentioned.
00:37:25 From my point of view, they're imposing their ideology on the rest of us.
00:37:29 It's not just ideology. It's actually Orwellian.
00:37:31 It's sort of removing any sense of something which is observable.
00:37:34 so you know a penis can't be male or female it's a woman can have a penis
00:37:41 because someone with a penis can identify as a
00:37:43 it's effectively doing what Orwell talked about
00:37:47 and removing people's sense of reality so that they're more likely to
00:37:50 you know conform and be told ideas which don't ring true
00:37:54 but their sense of what's right and wrong has been so shattered
00:37:57 by this ideology at a very young age 11 to 13
00:38:00 when they're at an age where they are absorbing everything
00:38:04 and they trust their teachers to tell them the truth
00:38:06 and you remove their sense of reality
00:38:08 and when they grow up they're not going to have any
00:38:10 sense of discernment whatsoever
00:38:11 and it's very worrying that they're doing that
00:38:15 Well look, I mean this is
00:38:16 now in, isn't it
00:38:18 as we speak
00:38:20 this programme's going out in mid-September
00:38:23 Thank you very much
00:38:26 for an interesting discussion
00:38:28 Thank you very, very much
00:38:29 Reverend Linda
00:38:31 Thank you
00:38:32 and we will be back next week with another counterculture but much food for
00:38:42 thought here okay so thank you very much indeed bye