New Culture Forum - October 11, 2020


The Identity Obsessed Heroes & Villains View Of History Is Dangerously Simplistic & Divisive

Covid-19 - The Authoritarian Social Hygiene Regime Is Illiberal & A Global Threat To Civil Liberties Sex Education Reforms: What Are the Reforms? Should The State Teach Sex Education & Gender Identity?

Episode Stats


Length

37 minutes

Words per minute

152.66

Word count

5,769

Sentence count

131


Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
00:00:00 hello and welcome to so what you're saying is I'm Peter Whithall now cultural history is very much
00:00:29 on the front line during the culture wars we've been seeing over the past few months so i'm
00:00:36 delighted that this week my guest is the author dr philip kisley who lectures in cultural history
00:00:45 at the university of leeds philip thank you very much great to be here thank you i want to start
00:00:52 with one very particular thing you wrote an article for spiked online recently yeah and it
00:00:58 was about the statue situation which obviously we're very preoccupied with here but you said in
00:01:04 it towards the end that we were at a sort of tipping point yeah can you expand on that a bit
00:01:11 well um i think what i was talking about in the article was the idea of history and actually what
00:01:19 history is and simplistic heroes and villains versions of history which i think throughout
00:01:26 the summer we got which were you know narratives which were which were racialized which were
00:01:32 identitarian which were about dividing people rather than kind of uniting people
00:01:39 and it feels as though we've come to a point i think in discourse uh and and in intellectual
00:01:47 thought generally as well as the broader culture where we either stand up against that and
00:01:56 say actually this is just too simplistic, this isn't our history, this isn't what our
00:02:01 history is all about. Yes, we had the evil of slavery but we also abolished slavery.
00:02:08 Yes there's Colston but there's also Wilberforce. So the history of Britain is a complex and
00:02:15 multi-layered narrative if we emphasize that that's the case and if we take on
00:02:25 this this this simplistic narrative this identitarian narrative then I think we
00:02:31 can push back and I think we can say you know there are more and more people
00:02:35 doing it there are more and more people saying well hang on you know yes we've
00:02:39 we've had this this this identitarian kind of discourse for a long time but
00:02:44 it is simplistic but it's not only simplistic I think people are beginning
00:02:49 to see for the first time well that it's doing more harm than good you know if
00:02:53 you racialize everything in the name of anti-racism you get racism because
00:03:00 people are obsessed with race if you tell white people that they're inherently
00:03:07 evil because of the color of their skin or their history which is linked to the
00:03:12 color of their skin then that can't be good in the long run so i think these
00:03:20 identitarian tropes these identitarian now don't get me wrong they're incredibly you know deeply
00:03:27 embedded in in in our young people and in our middle age kind of people as well um they're
00:03:33 there but people are beginning to question them i think in a way in a way that they haven't done
00:03:39 before um and i think they're thinking about racism and and how to deal with racism in different ways
00:03:47 i don't think people have got the answers yet okay because you know if if i was coming on here
00:03:52 and saying well you know i've got the answer to racism um you you know it'd be it'd be it'd be
00:03:57 fantastic but you know i think people are thinking well actually this isn't working and so if there's
00:04:04 a tipping point, I'm not sure I like that word, but if there's a potential time for
00:04:10 change, maybe it's now, okay, and maybe it's people thinking about narratives that bring
00:04:17 us together. I think, you know, Roger Scruton used to talk about that a lot, that kind of
00:04:22 that collective pronoun, the we. What does that mean?
00:04:25 Actually, what does that mean?
00:04:26 The we.
00:04:27 The we, you know, we instead of I. And what does that mean in a, you know, in a
00:04:34 nation-state this you say that's it embedded it certainly is it seems to be
00:04:42 intensifying though I mean in your academic career you have you seen it
00:04:47 become more more intense it's always been there it's in in you know I I
00:04:55 started my degree in the the mid 90s the early to mid 90s and then I did an MA
00:05:02 and then I did a PhD, I've always been involved with culture
00:05:07 and the performing arts and acting, theatre, television, film.
00:05:12 That's kind of my area.
00:05:16 It's always been there because that was the period when it developed, really.
00:05:23 I think the key book that other people have come onto this show
00:05:27 and talked about is Judith Butler's Gender Trouble,
00:05:30 but there are others as well.
00:05:32 I think that came out in 1990 or 1991.
00:05:35 So that was at the time when this kind of thought,
00:05:39 these kind of ideas were emerging.
00:05:41 I mean, they've been around in kind of various forms
00:05:44 since the 60s, I think, really.
00:05:46 But they didn't have the kind of currency they've got today.
00:05:52 And they didn't have the force that allows them
00:05:57 to take everything else out
00:06:00 and obliterate everything that stands in their way.
00:06:06 So when I started teaching, which was round about the 1999,
00:06:14 yes, these ideas were there, and some of them were quite useful.
00:06:18 But as time has gone on, you get the sense,
00:06:23 and it's not just in academia, it's in the broader culture as well,
00:06:26 that these ideas have not only kind of expanded
00:06:31 and become dominant, they're now actually sacrosanct.
00:06:35 So if you, I suppose like we're doing now
00:06:41 and like you always do on this show,
00:06:43 if you take on the identitarian kind of narrative,
00:06:46 then you're placing yourself outside of the mainstream now,
00:06:50 Which is ironic, because these ideas started as radical ideas, as ideas that were different.
00:07:01 They still characterise themselves as radical ideas, but they are actually very much the mainstream,
00:07:07 as we see, and again, as other people have said on this show, you know, it's part of business, it's part of finance.
00:07:13 Yes, it's part of education, it's certainly part of culture,
00:07:16 but it's generally part of everything we do now.
00:07:20 we think in identitarian terms. So yes, it's become much stronger. It's become a force that
00:07:28 is wielded often in a very cynical way. How do you mean cynical? Well, I mean, if you don't
00:07:41 tow the party line in some of these ideas, then you get cancelled and we see that all the time.
00:07:49 now I'm not talking about we all want equality and we all you know we all dislike racism and we
00:07:56 all think black lives matter I've never I've never met anyone who doesn't it's not that we all agree
00:08:02 on that we're all on the same page the problem is the method the problem is you're not allowed
00:08:10 to speak because you're a a white cisgendered male and da da da da da and I'm not allowed to
00:08:16 speak because I'm the same you know and and I have all of this privilege that puts me on the
00:08:23 debit side of the ledger whereas other people have victimhood points that that you know and
00:08:29 it's and it's this kind of moving up and down um which is used really cynically that that idea of
00:08:37 privilege and victimhood is used cynically I mean we've seen just in the last few weeks we've seen
00:08:42 um the academic in america who was who was claiming you know black ethnicity um to white
00:08:49 a white person who's a white person who was claiming black ethnicity and and and and and
00:08:55 and performing this um and you know and you have to ask yourself why you do what when uh
00:09:04 in your particular discipline i mean or actually in the academic world generally what
00:09:11 has been the effect if you do not entirely go along with it if you make it
00:09:16 known that you don't go along with it I mean we're hearing more and more stories
00:09:21 of academics coming under attack either from the students or indeed you know
00:09:27 from their fellow academics I mean is this something you've experienced I mean
00:09:31 or you know or or do you feel you know in your particular approach to these
00:09:38 things in your beliefs that somehow you know you're besieged you're that you are alone
00:09:43 it's a really good question um i could give a really simplistic answer um i'm not going to
00:09:54 um i don't feel as though i'm alone um i don't feel as though i'm besieged
00:10:01 But I do feel as though my approach to history, my approach to culture, my approach to the performing arts is an approach that is a kind of minority approach.
00:10:20 So the way I deal with history, I kind of do not engage with identitarian jargon at all.
00:10:30 and so the currency of academia is the peer-reviewed journal article essentially that's what we do
00:10:40 the peer-reviewed journal article peer-reviewed journal article so you know we we write journal
00:10:44 articles that's our research we present our research in journal articles and books and
00:10:48 yeah I mean my peer reviews come back glowing obviously but you know when they do come back
00:10:56 They tend to say this is refreshingly free of jargon.
00:11:03 Right.
00:11:03 So that tells me a couple of things, right?
00:11:06 That tells me that, okay, I'm doing something different,
00:11:10 but it also tells me I'm not the only one,
00:11:13 and I'm not the only one who appreciates this.
00:11:15 So I'm in a minority, certainly,
00:11:18 but I think there are lots and lots of other academics out there
00:11:22 who feel the same, who feel that, you know,
00:11:24 maybe there are other ways of looking at culture, maybe there are other ways of looking at relationships
00:11:30 between the sexes, looking at race and ethnicity, looking at sexuality, and doing all of those
00:11:39 things, because they're all interesting things. We're not going to stop looking at them, but
00:11:43 if we look at them in different ways, then who knows, it might be more productive. And
00:11:48 And if we historicize those inquiries in empirical, proper ways, then it really will be productive.
00:11:59 But how do you do that, and what are the chances of doing that in the current climate?
00:12:05 I mean, the thing is, if this is all so embedded and it goes across all disciplines, it's not
00:12:12 just these humanities anymore it's science you know i mean how does one sort of how does one
00:12:18 say fight back but how does one re-establish a different approach when things are so embedded
00:12:25 well i'm involved with a campaign called don't divide us don't divide us ddu which is a kind
00:12:37 broad-ranging campaign which came about after the George Floyd death and there
00:12:46 are a number of academics myself included who who are involved with that
00:12:51 who say actually there's got to be a different way to deal with racism there's
00:12:56 got to be a different way to deal with with relations between the sexes have
00:13:00 got to be a different way to deal with sexuality and the clues in the title I
00:13:05 suppose it's called don't divide us and there are a number of us and and and we
00:13:11 meet every week online but but we meet every week and we talk about you know
00:13:16 how we're going to do this and and and we're taking action we're kind of
00:13:20 lobbying and we're thinking about innovative ways of dealing with the past
00:13:27 certainly which is what most of us are interested in but also the present as
00:13:32 well and thinking about how that how that culture works how who's sort of involved in it i mean are
00:13:38 they what different political views yeah yeah it's not a it isn't a it isn't a left or right thing
00:13:43 um and i think with with with lots of this as well it isn't it isn't something that um you know
00:13:51 people who are do i want to say anti-identitarian uh people who who who want to problematize to use
00:14:00 one of their words identity politics um many people probably think oh well they're they're
00:14:07 right-leaning and and maybe lots of them are but there are lots of people from the left as well
00:14:11 who find the idea that um you know uh you're only allowed to talk about your lived experience
00:14:21 what is lived experience what's it what's unlived experience isn't that the very nature of
00:14:27 experience you know lived experience it's this idea of standpoint isn't it so yes i think it
00:14:34 relates in a way without getting kind of too complex it relates to the idea of categories
00:14:42 of knowledge being broken down in a kind of post-modern way and so if you you kind of take
00:14:48 knowledge as being relative okay rather than absolute and truth as being relative rather than
00:14:55 absolute then the idea of lived experience is as important as anything else the idea of the
00:15:03 subjective becomes really quite important so that the problem with that of course is that it can go
00:15:10 absolutely anywhere you know my subjective experience at the moment might be that you know
00:15:16 you're questioning me too hard you're not but you know you're questioning me too hard and then you
00:15:20 You know, I might think, well, is it something about me that's wrong here?
00:15:25 And maybe I'm going to complain about you.
00:15:28 And maybe I'm going to kind of take that further.
00:15:30 And maybe I'm going to try and stop you earning.
00:15:33 You see where it goes.
00:15:34 I'm not saying that happens all the time.
00:15:35 And I'm not saying there's nothing too subjective lived experience.
00:15:40 There is, but it's how it's framed in a broader notion of knowledge,
00:15:43 I think is really interesting and potentially really problematic.
00:15:47 Well, not potentially problematic. It is problematic.
00:15:49 But it's also very narcissistic, isn't it?
00:15:52 Yeah.
00:15:53 Everything is seen through the kind of prism of oneself.
00:15:59 But, I mean, sorry, Peter, just to pick up on that point,
00:16:02 because I think it's interesting.
00:16:04 The idea of the self and, you know,
00:16:09 the individual being at the centre of things is part of it.
00:16:14 But ironically, the self is always subjugated to the group identity.
00:16:21 And the group identity is always the most simplistic thing.
00:16:25 So, you know, you're kind of, you're grouped by race, you're grouped by gender, you're grouped by sexuality.
00:16:33 And, you know, my sexuality is probably really important to me, who I am as a person.
00:16:38 It's not the only thing, you know.
00:16:40 My childhood is probably really important.
00:16:42 my class is probably really important class he said there with a very flat a but um this is actually
00:16:50 class sorry class with a long a the the uh that's the difference you think that's the difference
00:16:56 between us clark clases in entirely missing from all of this isn't it you know when you talk about
00:17:03 identitarian politics when you talk about uh black lives matter protests whatever it is class does
00:17:11 not seem to play a part in this does it no or it does in a way that is just an adjunct you know so
00:17:17 it's kind of thrown in in an intersectional way it's it's one of those things oh it's another
00:17:22 ingredient this is this is another ingredient of victimhood but i think i i think classes is is
00:17:28 really important and just to come back very quickly i know we've already talked about it but just come
00:17:32 back to the point about left and right i think that's one of the reasons why lots of people on
00:17:37 the left think that the identitarian turn has been a problematic one because of that
00:17:44 very thing, because it kind of takes class out of the system and out of the system of
00:17:50 thought. And of course class is really important, region is really important. If you're talking
00:17:55 about lived experience then where you're from and your family and your upbringing are just
00:18:01 as important as your sexuality and your ethnicity I would suggest.
00:18:06 would agree with that totally you know your context your physical context you
00:18:10 know where you where you grew up where you're from but that would tend to that
00:18:15 would someone has defined that David Goodhart as being a somewhere you know
00:18:20 you're somewhere or an anywhere in other words if you're somewhere locality means
00:18:26 an awful lot to you by implication is by extension the country means a lot to you
00:18:31 are you a somewhere or an anywhere no I'm somewhere right somewhere but I mean I don't I don't live
00:18:38 where I was born and bought up but that's you know I can't because I work somewhere else and
00:18:44 and and maybe perhaps I wouldn't want to stay in the same place all my life but I'm very much
00:18:49 rooted in in where I'm from um and I'm kind of northern as well you know you can you can hear
00:18:56 it in every word I say but the idea that my past is important to me and my context is
00:19:05 important to me absolutely kind of plays out in everything I do and the somewheres and
00:19:13 anywheres thing works on various levels. You've already said that about kind of nation but
00:19:18 it feeds into the kind of Brexit remaining debate and all of those other things which
00:19:23 again you've talked about on this show an awful lot um and and and i think it's important and
00:19:28 and i i think as well this is probably a bit of a generalization but i'm going to say it anyway
00:19:35 because there's probably something to it you know um the somewheres are going to be much more
00:19:41 conservative when it comes to identity politics and all the ideas around that and and and and
00:19:48 And the others, the anywheres, is that what you call them, they would probably be much
00:19:54 more receptive to that, primarily because they're thinking in different kinds of categories.
00:20:04 So the self and the identity is framed in a whole set of different categories which
00:20:10 aren't rooted.
00:20:12 And I think that's the key thing.
00:20:13 They are very much not rooted.
00:20:16 race is probably the one that stands out there but but the others are very fluid you know they're
00:20:21 all about transgression i mean you you are a a lecturer in in cultural history right so as you
00:20:30 mentioned you know the performing arts film you've written about this i mean for example we you know
00:20:35 you wrote about uh the way that empire was treated in 1970s drama tinker tainer soldier spy for
00:20:44 example, which I find fascinating. I wonder, Philip, what do you see, if you look at the
00:20:53 drama today on television and similar, what will it tell us, looking back, if you were
00:21:00 writing in the future looking back, what will it tell us about the state we're in at the
00:21:05 moment, or what will it tell us about our preoccupations at the moment?
00:21:08 God, that's a good question. I'll answer it in relation to one show, and that was A Christmas
00:21:17 Carol at Christmas. I don't know whether you saw it or not.
00:21:20 Yes, I did indeed.
00:21:21 Yeah. I wouldn't ordinarily watch it, but you're with family and you're bullied into
00:21:28 doing these things. I'd rather go upstairs and kind of watch Man at the Top from the
00:21:33 seventies or something but so I I watched the show I know what I kind of watched
00:21:39 about a good more than an hour of it I watched about an hour of it and and at
00:21:44 that time within the hour the the Victorian kind of infirmary had kind of
00:21:54 24 hours to save it before it was going to go the tenement was was burning a
00:22:01 Glenful house and someone actually said for the many for the many and not the
00:22:07 few so the many and not the someone actually said for the many and not the
00:22:11 few so I would which was the Labour slogan tagline for the election so I
00:22:19 would suggest that tells you everything you need to know it's we we have this
00:22:24 kind of, not all drama, but lots of drama, the kind of drama that I've just illustrated
00:22:35 is almost like a kind of a bad writing workshop for second-rate wokeness. And there's a sense
00:22:45 that all of these things are just shoehorned into everything.
00:22:50 And so if there's political dramas,
00:22:55 then they're from a very definite perspective.
00:22:58 If there are historical dramas,
00:23:00 they're not really about the past.
00:23:03 Now, the historian E.H. Carr said,
00:23:08 great history is as much about the present
00:23:11 as it is about the past.
00:23:13 But much of the stuff that you see on TV
00:23:15 and much of the stuff that you see on film, actually,
00:23:17 just are not about the past at all.
00:23:19 It's the present dressed up in fancy dress
00:23:22 that might be 19th or 18th century or the 1920s,
00:23:26 but it is fundamentally now.
00:23:29 I think people do feel that.
00:23:31 I mean, you feel when you're watching BBC drama now,
00:23:34 actually most drama, that in fact you're getting a certain message.
00:23:37 I mean, with Christmas Carol,
00:23:39 I thought that was a sort of landmark in that way
00:23:42 for the reasons you've just said but there were also other things about it i mean scrooge himself
00:23:48 was no longer just a curmudgeon he was sort of like an arch capitalist uh they dragged in the uh
00:23:57 the collapse of a mine um bob cratchett's family were mixed race uh you know and and it was just
00:24:05 about everything and you look at it and think surely um if you write that if you want but just
00:24:12 don't be a parasite on someone else's work from the past i mean i mean there is that and that's
00:24:17 i mean that's a really really good point but but but the other point is and this feeds into lots
00:24:23 and lots of research and i'll give you an example in a minute but the other point is it's kind of
00:24:29 quite boring because you know exactly what's going to happen and you know exactly where the
00:24:37 you know the angle's going to be the agenda's going to be and i'll just give you an example i'm
00:24:42 on a an editorial board for a a series of books and and um it's a fairly new series so we're
00:24:51 getting quite a few proposals for books in and and i just read one the other day and it was an
00:24:58 identitarian take on, on, on horror, the horror genre on television. I didn't need to read
00:25:06 the, the, all of the proposal to know exactly what the findings were going to be in, in,
00:25:14 in the final chapter. So there's a sense of, okay, you're going to do all of this research,
00:25:21 but really, you know, precisely what your findings are going to be. So there's, there's,
00:25:26 there's not a huge amount of point in doing the research.
00:25:29 Research should be a, you know,
00:25:31 God, it's a hideous cliche, I shouldn't say it really,
00:25:33 but a voyage of discovery.
00:25:35 You're looking for new knowledge.
00:25:39 And it feels as though lots of work, not all,
00:25:43 you know, I'm not kind of just saying everybody else's research
00:25:47 is dreadful and much brilliant, but, you know, not at all.
00:25:50 But it seems that, you know, lots of research
00:25:54 within the parameters of, you know, the identitarian,
00:25:59 it is by its very nature going to come out with the same things
00:26:02 over and over again.
00:26:04 And so for me, actually, going back to why should we change things
00:26:09 and how should we change things,
00:26:10 OK, that's why we should change things, OK, we know a lot of this.
00:26:13 And I'm not saying that some of it isn't true.
00:26:16 You know, there is racism and there is sexism
00:26:19 and we do need to change some things.
00:26:21 but that's not the only story.
00:26:24 If you're looking at history for example
00:26:26 and you're only looking for racism
00:26:28 and you're only looking for sexism
00:26:30 and you're only looking for transphobia
00:26:31 my God you're going to find it
00:26:33 but you're going to find it anywhere.
00:26:34 You can also find other things.
00:26:37 You can also find other things
00:26:38 and I think that's one of the reasons
00:26:42 why we should be looking at other methodologies.
00:26:45 We should be looking at other subjects
00:26:46 and we should be thinking broader
00:26:48 and lots of people are
00:26:49 but I think there should be
00:26:50 there should be more people doing it on this point you know BAFTA the British
00:26:57 Academy and indeed the Academy in America Academy of Motion Pictures they
00:27:03 have both adopted new criteria to get nominated right in in if you're making a
00:27:12 program or a drama or something you have got to show certain things usually to do
00:27:18 with all along identity lines, either in front of the camera or behind it.
00:27:23 I mean, does this not have a profound effect even on the very idea of creativity?
00:27:28 If this is the main thing, or rather if you're not going to get nominated unless you do that,
00:27:36 then it entirely thwarts the real idea of free creativity, doesn't it?
00:27:41 I think it's a really good example of why a lot of this stuff comes from a good place.
00:27:49 Okay, it's about, you know, wanting equality of opportunity.
00:27:55 But somewhere along the line, it becomes an absolute rigid kind of, you know, a rigid definition of equality of outcome.
00:28:09 Equality of outcome.
00:28:10 Yeah, and I think those two things are very different things, and the idea of equality of outcome, I think you're absolutely right, is going to impact massively on the kinds of drama that we're looking at on all media, on radio, on television, on film, and there is going to be all of these things that we've just talked about.
00:28:34 So there is going to be a very definite set of issues that are going to have to be addressed in every single thing you see.
00:28:43 And they're going to relate to the identities of the people who are involved.
00:28:49 And that idea of flattening, that idea of reducing drama, history, culture to race, sex, sexuality, identity.
00:29:03 it's all we ever talk about
00:29:05 and I'm interested in it, don't get me wrong
00:29:07 I am interested in it
00:29:08 and I'm not entirely against some quotas
00:29:11 but I just want
00:29:13 the field to
00:29:15 open up, I want
00:29:17 academia
00:29:19 I want the arts
00:29:22 I want culture to be
00:29:23 a marketplace of ideas
00:29:25 and I think that's what it should be
00:29:27 and I'm not necessarily sure it is at the moment
00:29:29 Well I don't think it has been for quite a long time
00:29:32 actually particularly in britain um the point is you know you say that these things dominate now
00:29:39 and i think people pick it up they they pick it up in the simplest things and this this goes with
00:29:44 the bbc actually you know people think bbc bias is about the news it's actually not it's it's about
00:29:50 the assumptions behind their drama and comedy and everything if you look at what the stage
00:29:56 through it at the moment we've had covid we've got theaters that are dark we've got movie theaters
00:30:04 that are not doing very well um we've had that and then we've had the black lives matter thing
00:30:10 and then we've had this cultural onslaught i mean you know when we emerge from this whatever you
00:30:17 know whenever we do it's looking more and more distant at the moment what is our culture going
00:30:23 to look like i mean you know will it be just drenched as i think it will be in identity
00:30:29 politics even more i mean you know if you're a cultural historian and you and you and you
00:30:35 also lecture in performance you know as you do what is the impact going to be
00:30:41 of this extraordinary time do you think broadly
00:30:44 that's a difficult question um and i can't see into the future um but i could look at the past
00:30:54 and what i thought when this started and i think you know i think lots and lots of other people
00:31:00 thought this and i think douglas murray's even come on this show and said this that
00:31:03 with covid with something potentially so huge and game-changing all of this stuff would go out
00:31:11 the window and it didn't you know i think i think people have hunkered down and and and the
00:31:17 identitarian impulses has become even stronger um i i would suggest um i think we're going to spend
00:31:27 an awful long time coming to terms with covid in various ways um mind you having said that
00:31:36 i would have said at the beginning of this year i would have said there's going to be an awful
00:31:41 lot more about brexit but covid came out of nowhere so there are always lots of kind of you
00:31:47 know ifs and buts around this kind of thing but we're going to spend an awful long time coming
00:31:52 to terms with covid but if the last few two or three months or anything to go by we're going to
00:32:01 come to terms with COVID as COVID in relation to sex, COVID in relation to race, and COVID
00:32:09 in relation to kind of gender. There are lots and lots of other stuff in between, which
00:32:18 arguably is probably more important in terms of the culture at large, what is going to
00:32:24 happen there. And my guess is very few people will take that on. Because that's actually
00:32:32 really, really complex, right? How are we going to kind of interact with each other
00:32:42 in a year's time
00:32:45 when
00:32:46 let's say
00:32:47 for most of
00:32:49 this year
00:32:51 we've been interacting
00:32:54 primarily on screen
00:32:55 that's really going to impact on our
00:32:58 relationships with people
00:32:59 on our relationships with places
00:33:01 I mean we're in central London here and I just walked through central
00:33:04 it's still quiet
00:33:05 it's still quiet
00:33:06 it's like a ghost town actually
00:33:08 so all of those things
00:33:11 which relate to culture, which relate to the economy,
00:33:14 but which relate to us as people
00:33:17 and us as three-dimensional living beings
00:33:22 are really important things to come to terms with.
00:33:25 And my fear is that we're just going to go down
00:33:28 the same old rabbit holes again.
00:33:31 And so if you ask me what's going to happen,
00:33:34 I think that's going to happen.
00:33:36 But then also the saying is, go woke, go broke.
00:33:41 this is the problem is that if people do this sort of more and more that
00:33:45 basically the arts will gradually make themselves kind of irrelevant you know
00:33:50 the performing arts is that there is a problem there isn't there well there's a
00:33:56 there's a campaign at the moment to defund the BBC yes and that is gaining
00:34:05 traction I mean five years ago you you never would have given that the time of
00:34:10 day you would have thought okay yeah a few cranks now it's actually a serious proposition oh yes it
00:34:15 will happen i think because the the the you know the the national broadcaster doesn't really speak
00:34:23 to the vast majority of people who are i would suggest fairly socially conservative you know
00:34:29 the people who went especially the people who went the red wall voters who then went over to
00:34:35 the Conservatives in December 2019. I would suggest they're fairly socially conservative.
00:34:40 I would suggest many of them, without generalising too much, but I would suggest many of them
00:34:45 are Brexit voters. Many of them love their country, I would suggest, as well. And I don't
00:34:53 think the BBC speaks for them at all. So the idea of go woke, go broke, the idea that,
00:34:58 you know, a relatively small percentage of people who have a lot of power, there's another
00:35:04 word that they like uh and and who kind of dominate the institutions are removing themselves
00:35:12 actually from the voters so you might be right in the in in the sense that you know um the the
00:35:17 elections might and and and campaigns and lobby groups might have a say and things might change
00:35:22 but i can't look into the future i don't know but it's not good no no i i think it's we're going to
00:35:30 see sort of quite big changes not necessarily for the for the best but we remain optimistic we do
00:35:37 indeed we do indeed um thank you so much for coming on and um all the very best since the
00:35:45 campaign you mentioned don't divide us is that open to public yeah i mean you can just go onto
00:35:52 the website and there's there's lots of information there uh information about culture information
00:35:57 about education and there are some um statements there which which which are probably kind of quite
00:36:03 interesting so we we come from a position that says we want to combat racism uh we want to combat
00:36:09 sexism we want to combat all of these isms and phobias but how do we do that how do we do that
00:36:14 in a way that isn't identitarian how how do we do that in a way that doesn't kind of call on what
00:36:20 Helen Pluckrose and James Lindsay
00:36:23 call in their new book
00:36:24 cynical theories
00:36:26 how do we deal with the actual issue at hand
00:36:29 rather than imposing
00:36:30 postmodern theory on it
00:36:32 so I think
00:36:34 in lots and lots of ways
00:36:36 yes, just to go back to what you said
00:36:39 I think in lots of ways
00:36:40 we should be fairly optimistic
00:36:41 because that is happening
00:36:43 and I think if people look at the website
00:36:46 and have a look at what's going on there
00:36:48 and they can get involved in various ways as well.
00:36:51 Right.
00:36:51 And I think there was also Claire Fox
00:36:54 was one of the signatures to a letter that Don't Divide us did, didn't it?
00:36:58 So Claire Fox, Constantine Kissin, who I think is your friend,
00:37:03 and lots of other kind of public figures
00:37:06 and senior education figures as well.
00:37:10 So there are quite a few interesting names there.
00:37:14 And I think it's a really exciting campaign.
00:37:18 well thank you very much thanks very much that's it for this week do remember as
00:37:27 well that we have the campaign to save our statues which Philip wrote about
00:37:31 as well in Spiked and please do subscribe don't you I mean we've actually had a
00:37:37 huge response to I'm very pleased to say save our statues dot org dot UK and we
00:37:44 we'll see you next week, so thank you very much, bye.