New Culture Forum - May 09, 2020


State Of The Union - President Trump, Covid - 19, America's Culture Wars & The Presidential Election

Jon Long: A Celebration of Traditional Western Art & Heritage David Starkey - Covid - 19 -- Britain's Disastrous Response Will Have Devastating Consequences

Episode Stats


Length

43 minutes

Words per minute

176.15

Word count

7,706

Sentence count

209


Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
00:00:00 hello and welcome to counterculture I'm Peter Whittle now here we are in the latest of our
00:00:14 discussions on the coronavirus pandemic and tonight we're going to be particularly discussing
00:00:20 America the American response to the pandemic how it's being handled by President Trump and
00:00:27 indeed what that response tells us about American culture now and indeed
00:00:32 going forward into the future what changes if any we can expect to see with
00:00:38 me to discuss this I've got a great panel first of all John O'Sullivan who's
00:00:43 joining us from Budapest John O'Sullivan is president of the Danube Institute he
00:00:49 is editor at large of the National Review and indeed was a special advisor to
00:00:55 Margaret Thatcher. Andrew Clavin, who is joining us from Los Angeles, is host of
00:01:01 The Andrew Clavin Show on The Daily Wire. He is an award-winning author and some
00:01:07 of his books have been made into very successful Hollywood movies. And also
00:01:14 Rave Hadle-Manku from the New Culture Forum, who is an historian and
00:01:19 commentator. Thank you very much for joining us gentlemen tonight. I would
00:01:25 like to start with quite a broad question if i could please andrew um we've been discussing here
00:01:31 a bit about you know what's the response to the pandemic has shown about british culture has it
00:01:38 been if you like a typically british response or not would you say that the response in america has
00:01:45 been a typically american one whatever that might be well it depends uh what you're looking at it's
00:01:51 been typically American in the sense that we're tremendously divided. We have people on the right
00:01:56 who feel that their civil liberties have been completely overwhelmed by the emergency powers
00:02:02 of the state, and people on the left who feel that we should never leave our homes ever again,
00:02:06 and we're all going to die if we pop our heads up. So those two sides are at daggers drawn.
00:02:12 We have an amazingly different response from our president, which hasn't been properly
00:02:17 appreciated in my opinion, which is that this is the first true emergency of my lifetime that I
00:02:24 can remember in which the federal government has not tried to expand its powers. I don't know
00:02:30 whether Donald Trump can spell federalism, but he is actually operating on our very cherished
00:02:37 federalist tradition, which is that our states should be allowed to govern themselves. And he
00:02:43 has done that. He has refused the pressure. The press has done nothing but call him an
00:02:47 authoritarian and a fascist and a Nazi. And yet it's the press that has been urging him to take
00:02:52 more power. And Trump, who has been saying, no, I cherish the constitution. I'm going to let the
00:02:56 federal governments fend for themselves and has let the governors largely make up their own minds,
00:03:03 which has led to, in the left-wing Democrat states, a lot of overreach, a lot of people
00:03:08 crushing civil liberties and keeping everything closed and on the right it's led to a lot of
00:03:13 people like in texas uh opening their governments uh early and trying to get people back to work
00:03:18 so i would say typically american in the sense very we're very divided is that a sort of picture
00:03:23 you would recognize as well john well i recognize it as being the happening in america sure i mean
00:03:31 my own view would be a mixture of the two i i myself tend to think that we should probably
00:03:36 obey the rules, wear masks, stay at home mostly for the moment, although I'll slightly qualify
00:03:43 that. But at the same time, I find it unnerving that more people in Europe don't feel a bit
00:03:50 angry and upset about the restrictions on their civil liberties. Although I don't approve
00:03:56 of people turning up with guns at the Michigan central government, I nonetheless think it's
00:04:02 good thing there are some people who feel strongly in our society about civil liberties and about
00:04:09 normal life and and so i was slightly heartened by that here it's very different really i would say
00:04:16 we've had strong self-discipline among the hungarians and by the way a friend of mine
00:04:22 in italy says the same about italians which might be more surprising but and the strong
00:04:27 self-discipline has meant that really the rules have been quite easy not to break but to bend
00:04:34 slightly so here in budapest a lot of um people exercise walking as we call it but it just means
00:04:41 walking but they're also sitting down on park benches and moving about in family groups or in
00:04:46 groups of two and the police don't seem to bother that they only intervene as far as i can see um
00:04:52 Unlike England, where the police no longer seem so wonderful, they only intervene here
00:04:58 in Budapest when there are groups of six or seven youths making a bit of a fuss, and then
00:05:04 they tell them to separate out into smaller groups and to keep two metres apart.
00:05:13 So it's really quite an easygoing application of the rules here, but the rules were imposed
00:05:19 early and they seem to have been fairly effective i mean rave would you say that you know america
00:05:26 now because of the you know andrew talked about the division there but we have seen protests and
00:05:33 what have you uh anything like that is you know just simply not happened here would you say that
00:05:40 america is now you know the most liberty-loving country whereas maybe once we thought that we
00:05:45 were here absolutely well on the same lines i think it's remarkable that america and britain
00:05:49 now find themselves in the situation where they've committed economic suicide in the short term
00:05:55 uh despite being you know the two nations that forged the modern world the two most important
00:05:59 nations with more scientific nobel prizes than anywhere in the world and that this was so badly
00:06:04 manhandled but what it has exposed to me is what we all knew for some time that america is the
00:06:09 guardian of english liberty of those principles laid out in magna carta and in the glorious
00:06:14 revolution all those principles which we espoused every true-born englishman uh held to his heart
00:06:21 are now to be found in america a land of course created by the english and the founding fathers
00:06:26 were english after all as flanders and swan said you know englishman getting rid of a german king
00:06:32 and so it is that land of liberty still but yet what is also shown i think is how dysfunctional
00:06:38 the relationships are in america between the federal government and the states and how broken
00:06:43 the system is trump of course is getting a lot of flack uh because of his personality but this is
00:06:50 not a question of personality and you can't blame the man at the top for something like this trump
00:06:55 actually in 2018 put together a a pandemic plan um you know america has an organization solely
00:07:03 devoted to looking at pandemics and they had alerted to this everyone knew in britain and
00:07:07 america that there was going to be an asian pandemic of some sort plans were in place in
00:07:13 2019 congress passed a bio defense act so it's it's not at the top of the problem lies it's in
00:07:19 the bureaucracy of an america it's in it's in the failure to implement these things it's in the lack
00:07:24 of coordination between the states and and the federal government and not knowing whose job it
00:07:28 is to do what there's no orchestrated plan going on there so i think what it has exposed is yes
00:07:33 land of liberty but in a right mess and certainly i think there's an opportunity there for either
00:07:39 trump or biden to make sorting that out one of the election platforms without does does that sort of
00:07:45 resonate with you andrew i mean well again that's very typically american we believe in ordered
00:07:52 liberty but we've always been a little bit short on the order uh and big on the liberty i i think
00:07:57 that uh you know i i think there's been a lot of bureaucratic screw-ups especially at the very
00:08:01 beginning. But I'm actually kind of impressed. I'm impressed with Trump and his team and the way
00:08:06 they've actually acted, stripping out all the noise, stripping out, as Rafe said, all the
00:08:11 personality. You know, Trump's interests are very much aligned with common sense. He wants as few
00:08:17 people to die as possible, but he wants the economy to come back as quickly as possible.
00:08:22 And that seems to me to be the middle road that we should be treading. In Michigan, where there
00:08:27 was this demonstration, and you have to remember, the demonstrations are getting a lot of press,
00:08:31 but they're still very limited and very small.
00:08:33 But in Michigan, where there was this demonstration,
00:08:37 the Michigan governor has been extremely oppressive
00:08:41 and extremely arrogant in her uses of her emergency powers.
00:08:45 So what you're seeing is a reaction, not an action.
00:08:48 And that's important.
00:08:49 I think what we have seen, I mean, places like New York
00:08:52 have been incredibly badly managed.
00:08:55 The mayor of New York has just not only been incompetent,
00:08:58 but he has just exacerbated any kind of sense of community relations.
00:09:03 The people in New York want to stay home and keep safe
00:09:05 because the flu has hit them so badly.
00:09:08 But I think that, you know, we do have because we are a huge country.
00:09:13 And this is the thing I lived in England for many, many years.
00:09:16 And the hardest thing to convince Europeans of in general
00:09:19 is just how huge this country is.
00:09:22 I mean, England is the size of one of our states.
00:09:25 It's the size of Oregon.
00:09:26 I should say Britain is the size of Oregon.
00:09:29 So when you say there's a lot of bureaucratic snafus, there are, but there's just so much
00:09:35 more bureaucracy to be dealing with.
00:09:38 And it's in so many different places.
00:09:39 So I've been very impressed with the fact that Trump has kept federalism first and foremost,
00:09:44 that he has basically said, yes, we should stay safe, but yes, we also should keep the
00:09:49 economy going.
00:09:50 That seems to be the right way to go.
00:09:52 And I think that each state has to be judged on its own.
00:09:58 John, are you impressed with Trump?
00:10:01 I mean, you know, obviously, the situation in Britain, for example.
00:10:05 And it's almost impossible to get what you would call a half-decent or impartial view, actually, of what's happening.
00:10:12 I mean, we've got a media here that's almost entirely anti-Trump.
00:10:16 I mean, what would you say?
00:10:19 Would you agree with Andrew?
00:10:19 Are you impressed with his performance?
00:10:22 Well, of course, as you said, if you say that you approve of Trump, I would, by the way,
00:10:34 have to do.
00:10:36 But nonetheless, I agree with Andrew that, first of all, yes, Trump has acted as the
00:10:42 head of a federal government in a country, a federal system, in which the states obviously
00:10:48 are going to do most of the heavy lifting.
00:10:50 Secondly, I'd add, he's been very careful to bring in the private sector again and again on this, to encourage them to deal with some of the shortages, make sure that new equipment is going to be available.
00:11:05 he's suggested not always wisely perhaps but as it turns out in most of
00:11:10 these cases correctly that there are other ways of dealing with the virus
00:11:15 that there are some cause which are not simply palliative and we should expedite
00:11:21 speed up the process whereby we the regulatory process whereby we make them
00:11:27 available I think that has has been has proved to be correct even if in some
00:11:32 cases it might seem a bit risky um and to some degree by the way i think that's also true of
00:11:38 britain where what you've had is a government actually wanted to get people like dyson to
00:11:42 help and and encourage them to do so but the problem is that america is no longer a society
00:11:49 which is united on the kind of government it should have it's a divided society there is a
00:11:55 really quite a serious moral civil war that's going on between people who look to the american
00:12:01 constitution in the way andrew has just been citing but others who essentially really want
00:12:07 a massive administrative state which we have already actually extended and made more powerful
00:12:13 and unfortunately while the uh crisis has actually uh innovated uh not innovated i'm sorry
00:12:21 done the opposite it's encouraged the private sector to be more active it's also encouraged
00:12:28 the expansion and the respect for and the kind of, well toadying is too bad a word, but the subservience
00:12:37 to the administrative state that many people really want to see become the norm in America,
00:12:45 and I think there is a danger at the end of this, particularly if the democrats win the presidency,
00:12:50 And the administrative state will have notched itself up a few more inches, more control over this over society.
00:13:00 And I would regret that.
00:13:02 When you say the administrative state and the support amongst some people for a hugely expanded one.
00:13:11 I mean, when when would you say that that actually started? Is that a relatively recent phenomenon?
00:13:17 well no i think i would bow to andrew here most people think it began with roosevelt
00:13:26 um but on the other hand in and it was wound back a few times by the eisenhower administration and
00:13:33 so on but it does have a way of um it's going to going up 10 points and being wound down five and
00:13:39 then going on another 10 points when the next crisis occurs so i think we now have to find some
00:13:46 way of ensuring that it just doesn't become the way in which most people feel Americans
00:13:52 should live. And I would say, by the way, the same is true for the Brits, because although
00:13:57 America may now be the chief standard bearer of the Magna Carta and the liberties associated
00:14:04 with it, nonetheless, that tradition surely has not completely died in England. Under
00:14:09 thatcher it got a tremendous boost and i think we want to see it protected and revived i think that
00:14:17 it often depends who you're listening to or reading but there are some people who think
00:14:22 that in britain we've sort of actually forgotten these things so we we know we no longer are taught
00:14:27 about them so we've kind of forgotten about them i would agree with john the private sector has been
00:14:32 the the stellar example of an industry working together across the board i mean you've got
00:14:37 You've got cases of Barber and Burberry offering to make PPE, gowns and so forth.
00:14:42 Dyson getting involved in those ventilators.
00:14:43 You know, Mercedes-Benz helping to get people off ventilators
00:14:46 onto other breathing apparatus.
00:14:48 That's been inspirational to see.
00:14:49 The private sector, again, a champion of people's life and liberty.
00:14:54 And undoubtedly, you know, Trump's getting a raw deal on all of this.
00:14:57 People forget, you know, that he was the one who wanted to stop flights from China
00:15:01 and got a huge amount of flack for that.
00:15:03 And that's conveniently forgotten by everyone who's now condemning him.
00:15:06 And I think Britain and America have had a rather bad press recently over death tolls,
00:15:12 which simply is a crude analysis to try to compare them to Europe,
00:15:15 given the fact that the populations are far larger.
00:15:17 People don't actually look at these things in terms of death per million,
00:15:20 in which case America is far below Britain, France, Italy and Spain.
00:15:24 And Britain is still below European countries on a per capita basis.
00:15:29 And of course, Britain and America have much more ethnic diversity than European countries.
00:15:34 and we know that the highest risk groups are people from ethnic minorities and yet nowhere
00:15:38 do you see that in any of the analytics. Similarly, not to their credit, they're also the fattest
00:15:42 nations in that comparison chart. And so, you know, if someone would actually try to analyse
00:15:47 that out, I think a lot of the attacks made on Trump and Johnson, who did start too late,
00:15:52 has to be said, but they are exaggerated and unfounded on that level. But certainly, you know,
00:15:57 if I were Biden, I would, as John said, I would look to FDR if I wanted to offer up an alternative
00:16:02 to trump and appeal to those keen on a bigger state and offer a new new deal you know we might
00:16:08 we may not like it these days but that basically was the hope that was given after the great
00:16:13 depression in creating a safety net of socially and economically and i think that is going to
00:16:18 actually be one of the dividing lines that we'll see at this election and a lot hangs in the
00:16:22 balance based upon that can i ask you already this is a very i think interesting thing we have
00:16:27 with Brexit here we had something called Brexit derangement syndrome right so and you know what
00:16:33 I'm going to ask there is what can it this seems to be an entirely irrational hatred of of Trump
00:16:42 the Trump derangement syndrome Andrew I mean what do you think that shows I mean regardless of the
00:16:49 pandemic if you like I mean ongoing it is not just about hating someone's politics is it
00:16:56 Oh, no, it's not. And remember that there was Bush derangement syndrome before this. Trump has
00:17:02 amped it up because of his personality and his brusqueness. But John is absolutely right. You
00:17:09 know, the division in this country is no longer in the, up until the 1970s and into the 1980s,
00:17:16 the division in this country used to be between people saying, yes, we love our constitution and
00:17:21 our tradition, but we would like a little bit more of a welfare state, a safety net to maintain
00:17:25 people in times of trouble. That was a rational debate. We are no longer in that debate. We are
00:17:31 now in the debate whether the Constitution should be operational at all. This week,
00:17:37 Harvard law professor and a law professor from, I think, the University of Arizona
00:17:42 published an article in Atlantic saying that the Chinese have been right, that censorship
00:17:47 and surveillance is absolutely necessary. And so we're really dealing with people who have lost
00:17:53 the plot of America altogether. And as I see it, what they had was they had this beautiful vision
00:18:00 of globalism in which the elites were going to run the world in their expertise, they were going
00:18:07 to make a lot of money in their expertise, and they were going to pay the rest of us a universal
00:18:12 income to sort of make us go away, that our lives didn't have to have dignity or purpose or meaning.
00:18:17 We just needed some cash in our pockets and we'd be quiet while robots did all the work.
00:18:21 And they just sat around and fought great thoughts and basically invented the technology
00:18:25 of the future. Trump has very much, with his nationalism and his simple instinct for the
00:18:32 country, his instinct of love of country and his instinct of love of the traditions of the country,
00:18:36 he has just thrown a wrench in that operation. And you hear people talking about our dislike of
00:18:45 elites and experts as if there was something wrong with that, and as if elites and experts
00:18:49 had done such a great job. I mean, America has been in a war for 20 years in Afghanistan,
00:18:55 and that was the elites and experts got us into that. We had for three years, our life expectancy
00:19:02 he was dropping because people were killing themselves at such a high rate that it was
00:19:07 overtaking whatever medical advances there were. And that was simply despair because all of our
00:19:12 jobs had been farmed out to China and other places. And people were just dying in the middle
00:19:17 of the country from meth addiction and other forms of despair. Something was terribly, terribly wrong
00:19:22 that caused the people to rise up and send Trump to the White House, which they only just barely
00:19:27 did. And not once, not once have any of the elites, any of the experts, including some of the elites
00:19:34 on the right, not once has anyone said, what are they trying to tell us here? What have we done
00:19:38 wrong? Is there some other voice that should be included? Donald Trump is a symptom. He is not the
00:19:44 cause of this division. He is the people who feel that they have not been heard, that their lives
00:19:51 have been taken away, that their voices have been taken away, that they are fired from their jobs
00:19:56 for saying that men can be different from women. They're fired from their jobs for remarks they
00:20:01 may have made personally on Facebook. They have lost their rights to be themselves and to live
00:20:07 their individual lives. And Trump was basically a cri de coeur, you know, just a cry to be listened
00:20:13 to, to give somebody a voice that would speak for those people. And Trump has done that. And that's
00:20:19 what they hate him for. They hate him because he is a bowling ball that has rolled down into their
00:20:24 perfect global vision and just knocked it askew let me say um well it seems to me that we are all
00:20:33 sitting around this table members of the elites or an elite um but we are traitors to our class
00:20:42 and we recognize since we're in that class that um experts differ um that you if you got a good
00:20:50 doctor saying you were going to die on thursday you'd ask for a second opinion and i think that
00:20:56 that's true across the system and if you have a situation a problem like brexit uh membership of
00:21:01 the eu that's composed of so many different expertises so to speak that you can't possibly
00:21:08 be an expert on it now what's the problem we have i would put it this way in responding to andrew
00:21:15 the elites managed to solve a problem which had long puzzled many of them and that is
00:21:22 how do you get rid of democracy without getting rid of democracy and the answer is you transfer
00:21:29 more and more political decisions which you declare to be terribly important from democratic
00:21:34 institutions accountable to the voters to non-democratic institutions accountable to
00:21:39 themselves or to a general amorphous atmosphere of progressivism and that's the problem they did
00:21:46 they carried that out and the rest of us kind of couldn't quite work out what was going on how come
00:21:54 more and more times we complained about something the politicians the ministers and the civil
00:21:59 service would say i'm afraid there is nothing we can do that in britain they'd say well that was
00:22:04 a european decision we had to accept it in america they'd say well that was the decision of the
00:22:09 supreme court that's all we can do we must go along with it we can't possibly in a sense change
00:22:15 the law now um we didn't understand how this had happened but we knew something was wrong
00:22:21 trump came along and he articulated these uh feelings but he didn't articulate them very well
00:22:27 because that's not the kind of thing he does he what he does he expressed powerfully emotions
00:22:33 which people um feel but don't quite make the case it's up to therefore intellectuals and they've
00:22:40 come forward in quite large numbers to begin to articulate um in britain and america in brexit
00:22:47 and other places in central europe to articulate the grievances of people who knew they were being
00:22:53 cheated but couldn't work out how the three-card trick had been played on them absolutely and
00:23:01 And certainly, just as Trump, you know, I'm reminded of G.K. Chesterton, for we are the people of England who have not spoken yet.
00:23:07 And certainly Trump gave voice to the American people, the downtrodden, just as John and Andrew are saying.
00:23:13 And of course, we've seen that here too with Brexit.
00:23:15 And certainly, the attempt to erase the connection that the power levers between the public and the legislatures and the elected officials got to a point where it seemed as if the Glorious Revolution,
00:23:27 which was all about parliaments taking power from the crown in expanding democracy we had our own
00:23:33 revolution in terms of trying a battle between parliamentary sovereignty and sovereignty of the
00:23:38 people and it came very close over the last year in terms of who would win that and thankfully
00:23:42 because of the of boris johnson's intervention at the end we did win that but the the question
00:23:48 remains did we win the war or just a battle and how long is this going to last and of course
00:23:53 2020 will be one will give us one indication in america but it remains to be seen whether the
00:23:58 elites you know have been defeated um in a certain sense or whether they're just wounded and seeing
00:24:04 how they can come back um but you know but then in another sense it's the same case in europe and of
00:24:08 course what coronavirus has shown europe is how how self-interested the member states of the
00:24:15 european union are when push comes to shove is it uh trump obviously is on to a bit of a winner as
00:24:22 well isn't he when he said quite recently in fact i think it was yesterday uh about the idea of
00:24:27 tariffs on china you know that somehow there was there's talk that somehow china is going to have
00:24:32 to pay somehow uh there was there was talk i think of non-repayment of debt repayments but he said no
00:24:38 to that but that there should maybe be tariffs um this is surely going to be a winner in the coming
00:24:44 election is it not oh i i think it definitely is and uh and biden's friendships with china and his
00:24:52 you know this is something that trump has been talking about a long time and if you want to find
00:24:56 the source of trump derangement it may well be it may well start right here with his attacks his
00:25:02 continual attacks on china in the same way that reagan upended the foreign policy consensus by
00:25:09 saying no we don't have to maintain relations with the soviet union we should beat them we
00:25:14 we should defeat them in the Cold War. He was alone in saying that except for Margaret Thatcher
00:25:19 and the Pope. And nobody thought that that was possible and it upended the wisdom of all the
00:25:24 poobahs in the State Department. Well, the same thing is true right now. China has interacted
00:25:31 and interwoven itself with our universities, our media, and our press so completely that the idea
00:25:38 that you can basically say, no, wait a minute, morally, this is not a good country, that China
00:25:44 is not a good country. We should not deal with them as moral equals. They are not our moral
00:25:48 equals. They oppress their people terribly. Some of the stories that have been confirmed coming
00:25:55 out of China sound like bad thriller novels. The harvesting of organs from people who dissent and
00:26:01 from disenfranchised groups in their prisons. We've seen on TV the oppression of the people in
00:26:09 Hong Kong. And yet, and yet nobody in the left-wing press, by which I mean almost all the
00:26:16 press in America, is willing to come out and just say, you know, I may not like Donald Trump,
00:26:21 but he has a point here. Yesterday, the New York Times was attacking Trump for trying to find out
00:26:28 how much of this virus originated with the laboratories in Wuhan. We've just seen again
00:26:34 and again, they tell us if we call this the Chinese flu, as they say, the Spanish flu,
00:26:39 that we're racist. So this is going to be a powerful, powerful narrative because the people
00:26:44 hear this. They know what China is. They're not going to be fooled, I don't think, by the press.
00:26:50 And Joe Biden, listen, Joe Biden, they are trying their best. Joe Biden at this point is a hologram.
00:26:56 You know, I'm not even sure he's actually there. I think he is a projection of the press and the
00:27:01 left wing and the Democrat Party that is just a three-dimensional placeholder. He himself said
00:27:06 he's going to be a placeholder president. He can barely put an English sentence together.
00:27:11 He is not being called on to defend himself against rape allegations, which had they been
00:27:15 leveled against a Republican would be all the news. And his relations with China and his
00:27:22 friendliness toward China and his son Hunter's profits from China are all going to come into
00:27:29 question. And I just don't think the press is going to be able to keep it silent.
00:27:32 Absolutely. And the thing is that Trump has actually been the only leader in the Western world to actually understand what's been happening over the last few years.
00:27:41 And it's been so depressing, embarrassing and actually sickening to see the docile nature of our European leaders when it comes to handling China.
00:27:49 Very happy to take its money and let it get itself embedded firmly into the infrastructure and the very backbone of Europe.
00:27:56 And even to see the conservative government willing to go along with Huawei until recently.
00:28:01 but you know one wants you know you shake your head in disbelief because the reality is
00:28:05 we are in a new cold war you know china is the new soviet union and anyone who thinks we're not
00:28:10 in a cold war now is going to be severely missed you know up for a rude awakening over the next
00:28:15 few years and trump has been the only person to fully understand and recognize that and so he's
00:28:20 got every right to make that a key part of his election re-election platform to contrast himself
00:28:25 with biden who's quite frankly a rum lot in comparison what is it what is the fact that
00:28:30 what is the fact that uh the democrats have got biden up what what does that say about the
00:28:35 democrat democratic party i mean you know it's it's is it actually going the same way as labor
00:28:41 labor in britain would you say is that what uh john well no i'm doing rather well unfortunately
00:28:51 I mean, apart from the fact that Biden is obviously a bad candidate and in almost any other circumstances wouldn't be making it to the candidacy and may yet not do so.
00:29:05 But the fact is, it's controlling one of the houses of Congress. It did well in the last elections. It may do well. It may win the Senate this one. I think it won't, but it may.
00:29:19 And, of course, bad though he is, Biden is slightly leading Trump in the polls.
00:29:27 I don't think that will turn out to happen on the day, but that's another matter.
00:29:31 So, yes, you've got to take them seriously. Why is that?
00:29:34 It's because they essentially have created an electorate, partly by immigration,
00:29:40 partly by other methods, in which they are representatives of what they think of as a new America,
00:29:46 America, a different America, an America which will, in future, be less self-reliant, less
00:29:54 independent minded, less liberal in the true sense of the word, and more worshipful of
00:30:00 big government which gives them free stuff. And unfortunately, that's the way, there's
00:30:06 always a strong appetite for that kind of policy, so I don't dismiss them. I think they're
00:30:13 really serious, a serious threat of the kind of America that, for example, Andrew is, so to speak,
00:30:19 representing here around the table. Speaking of a kind of America, this really brings us on to
00:30:27 what we would call the culture wars, if you like. And you've already alluded to it in different ways,
00:30:33 actually. But when Andrew was talking about what, you know, Trump was saying, what people really
00:30:37 thought and and they didn't have an outlet um do you think that you know that this pandemic
00:30:44 will sort of wipe that away once and for all when i when i talk about the culture was i'm talking
00:30:50 about the identity politics the kind of the woke culture you know do you think that because it's
00:30:56 obviously gone off of the page the front page for a while you know but i i wonder whether it's so
00:31:01 entrenched that it will just simply return whether we're actually seeing it creeping back anyway do
00:31:07 Do you think that what's happening now will really make a difference, Andrew?
00:31:11 One of the things I think that John is hitting upon that really has to be focused on
00:31:16 is the difference between intellectual power and what we'll call mechanical power.
00:31:21 The left is out of ideas.
00:31:22 The reason they have this candidate who is essentially a walking house plant
00:31:26 and his chief opposition is a 102-year-old communist spouting Marxist ideas
00:31:34 who really doesn't realize the Soviet Union has fallen,
00:31:36 is because they are literally out of ideas.
00:31:39 They do not have an idea that it's not from the 19th century.
00:31:44 And all those ideas since the 19th century have failed in practice.
00:31:47 So they have nothing intellectually to offer.
00:31:50 A long time ago in the 50s or 60s, a very famous critic named Lionel Trilling
00:31:54 said there is no intellectual life on the right.
00:31:56 Well, that is now true of the left.
00:31:58 All the intellection is being done on the right.
00:32:00 All the thinking, arguing, debating is being done on the right.
00:32:03 However, they have implanted a tremendous mechanism for enforcing their points of view, which is, of course, giving away free stuff is one of them. That always is good. But as John said, the administrative state and bad Supreme Court decisions that have given a tremendous power to the administrative state is part of it.
00:32:22 and now you have the left arguing that that's even better than the constitution. And also you
00:32:27 have civil rights law. There's a wonderful new book, an important new book by Christopher Caldwell
00:32:32 called The Age of Entitlement, which traces how civil rights law has now set up an alternative
00:32:37 constitution and it's enforced by lawsuits. So if you say, if I, for instance, go on the air and make
00:32:46 comment like men and women are different and some left-wing website comes after me for that it's
00:32:53 possible that my sponsors will abandon me because they're afraid of being sued not because they're
00:32:58 afraid of losing money from their customers because their customers all know men and women
00:33:03 are different they're afraid that they will be sued as a civil rights violation and that that
00:33:08 their their support of me will be proof in that lawsuit and that has worked in the past
00:33:13 So the left being empty of ideas has set up a tremendous mechanism of power, which also includes their takeover of our academies, our entertainment industry and our news industry that really is separate from their ideas.
00:33:26 And so what we're going to see and what we did see with Trump is the fact that some of our ancient mechanisms, like the Electoral College, saved us from the absolute steamrolling effect of this mechanism they put in place.
00:33:39 and there's a very powerful open question of whether trump is canny enough and smart enough
00:33:46 to start to dissemble the mechanism that they have built because that's the key thing that is
00:33:51 what reagan failed to do uh and i don't know whether trump is going to do it we really have
00:33:56 to start to reverse the kind of laws maybe he did it with his supreme court appointments we'll see
00:34:00 but that's the difference you have to understand they're not winning on ideas they're winning on
00:34:04 pure power thank you very much um well i just was going to say in the last week there's been an
00:34:21 example of what andrew has just described mainly the left running out of ideas but at the same time
00:34:28 having the power uh to to make sure that it so to speak wins and that was last week michael moore
00:34:35 and jeff gibbs from the extreme left brought out a movie um it's called planet of the humans which
00:34:42 argues that the i that for the left to rely on the renewables industry to provide um uh energy
00:34:52 without damaging the atmosphere is a myth, a delusion. And furthermore, delusion which has
00:34:59 been used by ruthless capitalists to make millions out of the delusion. Now this strikes at the very
00:35:06 heart of the argument that the left, the moderate left, has been making. So it's an interesting fact
00:35:13 that this happened. First of all, the movie is quite a good movie from the standpoint of telling
00:35:17 a good story and making a sort of honest argument comes up with a ridiculous solution namely
00:35:23 essentially we have to have fewer human beings well i don't see you can achieve that in any
00:35:29 decent way myself other than relying on people to have fewer babies voluntarily and i don't think
00:35:34 that's enough for socialists generally but the point is that this film is a news item i mean
00:35:41 it's Michael Moore, a strong left winger, rejecting the orthodoxy of the left, making a film that makes
00:35:48 a good argument. And you would think everybody would be talking about it. Well, a lot of people
00:35:52 are because three million people watched it free on the internet. But you can't find any references
00:35:58 to it in a lot of news stories in Google and elsewhere, except people are demanding that the
00:36:07 film be banned so on the one hand even the slightest deviation from the left's position
00:36:13 becomes impossible to get a hearing for in a normal way and that of course is is a society
00:36:21 in which honest argument and debate cannot persist if even on the left um people get shouted down
00:36:28 for saying things that the whole left believed 10 minutes before and that's of course because
00:36:33 the godless left have reverted to type and have made their ideology into religious faith and they
00:36:38 are zealots and anyone who you know who varies one iota from scripture is going to be cast out
00:36:44 as a as a blasphemer and a heathen and so you're seeing done to michael moore what we've seen
00:36:48 happen to germaine greer and all these other figures of the old left who are now being
00:36:52 cannibalized by their own um and for me one of the great tragedies of or potential uh tragedies
00:36:59 of coronavirus is that we may have lost or we may lose the opportunity that we had up until a couple
00:37:06 of months ago both in britain and america to actually reverse that long march through the
00:37:10 institutions because you know there have been two power sources in both countries and governance in
00:37:14 this country was you know conservatives are the natural party of governance but in all the
00:37:18 institutions of education and the civil service and in the media you've got the soft power of
00:37:23 the left which is arguably more influential and they've basically never engaged with each other
00:37:28 properly and so with dominic cummings i think more than boris johnson actually behind the scenes
00:37:32 we really had a great chance to try to reverse that and i just wonder in this country you know
00:37:36 having expended so much of our personal finances whether we'll be able to live up to our promises
00:37:41 to the former labor party voting and members of the red wall and elsewhere to prove the credentials
00:37:46 um of living up to their expectations and providing them with infrastructure and everything
00:37:50 that they needed and that may actually derail what we thought were 10 years or we could actually try
00:37:55 to you know reverse that trend and we may find something similar in america because in america
00:38:00 has you know full employment had a deregulation boosted confidence in business you had such a good
00:38:05 situation there the foreign policy of trump turned obama on its head and was so encouraging and you
00:38:11 know nobody since coolidge had actually delivered on their campaign promises more you know people
00:38:16 forget that and that's something that people look look at when it comes to election times and i
00:38:20 think it would be a great shame if those two unique opportunities were um you know became
00:38:26 had to be abandoned because of all of this yes frustrated i mean do do you think the outlook is
00:38:32 bleak i mean that that sounds like a bleak outlook to me actually there um you know that there was a
00:38:39 chance um but that that's now sort of not being squandered but frustrated by what's been happening
00:38:45 No, I mean, I think conservatives are usually conservatives because they have a talent for
00:38:50 seeing disaster that proceeds from change. They have a talent for building the constellation
00:38:56 from any change to complete disaster. But no, I think we actually are in an interesting balance.
00:39:04 We're kind of on the razor's edge. I have never heard, because of all the things we're talking
00:39:09 about. The left has become completely isolated from the voice of the people altogether. I have
00:39:16 never seen, I have never seen this kind of pre-French Revolution arrogance coming from the elites in
00:39:24 America before, but I'm seeing it now. I watch the late night comedians and these guys who make
00:39:30 literally $15 million a year to go on TV and make jokes are sneering at people who want to go back
00:39:36 to work because they're starving to death and their businesses or their small businesses are
00:39:40 collapsing and they're making fun of them and they're making jokes about them. And this has
00:39:45 got to resonate. I mean, I think that the elites have become so separated because they have
00:39:52 isolated power in mechanisms rather than ideas. The elites have managed to become so separated
00:39:58 from the ordinary human being who walks the street and lives and dies and pays his taxes
00:40:03 that they now sound very much as if they should be wearing those long, curly French wigs from
00:40:10 the 18th century. And I think that that is going to have an effect, I hope, at the polls.
00:40:15 You know, it's funny. John was saying this before. I am an elite in that sense. I mean,
00:40:21 my happy place is to drink Chardonnay and discuss literature. That's what I want to be doing. But
00:40:27 it's not a leap of Christ-like vision for me to imagine that the guy who is currently delivering
00:40:33 the groceries that are keeping this old man alive also has a life and also has an inner vision and
00:40:38 also has opinions that deserve just as much recognition as mine and yet in america that
00:40:44 which used to be the standard it used to define our movie business it used to define our press
00:40:48 it used to define our intellectual life is now gone and has been replaced by some kind of european
00:40:54 continental aristocracy of mind that simply does not believe in the people anymore fact i used to
00:41:03 argue that um america is the only genuine social democracy in the world because it's a democracy
00:41:11 in which everybody feels they have a right to an opinion and that they don't have to defer
00:41:16 to everyone else's opinion now that's less true than it used to be was it's true less true today
00:41:22 than say in 1960 but it's still still true and i think to answer the question about how we get out
00:41:29 of this current situation i suppose electorally in the next few years in in the uk i think we
00:41:35 have to say this that if we leave the uh if we actually do in every full sense leave the european
00:41:43 union at the end of the year and we are emerging at the same time from the pandemic shutdown and
00:41:49 we have to revive the economy and get things going again i think the way i think boris could actually
00:41:55 do this i think he could do it by appealing to the british people on the lines of we just have
00:42:02 two great crises dumped in our laps and we have to handle them alone and we have to handle them
00:42:08 in ways that revive live that on the basis of greater liberty greater initiative greater
00:42:15 opportunity for everyone in the country and that's what we're going to do and so instead of
00:42:21 leaning back into the arms of the administrative state he actually goes out and simply says
00:42:28 do you have it in you under thatcher um we discovered that the old virtues the the vigorous
00:42:35 virtues as she called them had been latent they hadn't died in us and they revived quite quickly
00:42:42 it only took about five years before we were again the fourth largest economy in the world
00:42:48 maybe the the same virtues plus the virtues of love of country and desire to excel as a nation
00:42:56 as well as people um i think those those vigorous those kind of virtues you might call them the
00:43:02 patriotic as opposed to the economic virtues i think they're still in us and i think that they
00:43:07 they can be brought out by bold leadership.
00:43:10 We've got that ability.
00:43:13 John, you've put a spring in my step for the weekend.
00:43:16 Thank you. Thank you very much.
00:43:18 Gentlemen, thank you very much for your time tonight.
00:43:22 Andrew Claven, John O'Sullivan, Rafe Hadle-Manku.
00:43:25 It's been a great conversation.
00:43:27 I do hope that maybe we can get together again later in the year,
00:43:30 maybe around the time of that election and have a talk about it.
00:43:34 So thank you very much once again.
00:43:35 that's it for counterculture this week so I hope to see you next time and please
00:43:40 do subscribe won't you thanks very much