New Culture Forum - May 16, 2020


David Starkey - Covid - 19 -- Britain's Disastrous Response Will Have Devastating Consequences

State Of The Union - President Trump, Covid - 19, America's Culture Wars & The Presidential Election Ed West - Why Conservatives Have Lost Almost Every Political Argument Since 1945

Episode Stats


Length

40 minutes

Words per minute

144.64

Word count

5,795

Sentence count

177


Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
00:00:00 Hello and welcome to What You're Saying Is. I'm Peter Whittle. Now I'm delighted that my guest
00:00:21 this week is Britain's best-known historian. David Starkey came on to our show last year
00:00:27 actually and his interview with us proved to be one of the most popular we've ever done
00:00:33 and in december he also gave our new culture forum lecture the smith lecture which was on
00:00:40 one nationism and israeli i'm delighted he's with us again uh hello there david hi
00:00:47 hello peter um how how is it affecting you this lockdown are you has your life changed drastically
00:00:55 or not at all? It has transformed. My entire existing income has disappeared. I, in other words,
00:01:09 public lecturing, performance, all that kind of thing, I've shifted from a half metropolitan
00:01:15 creature into complete, you can see how I'm dressed, into a complete country mouse. I wear
00:01:23 the uh the the the the the kind of much binding in the marsh blouson uh i haven't put a tie on in
00:01:32 weeks um and i am fairly well uh socially isolating the reason is i had a conversation
00:01:41 um with my doctor and i am i hate associating myself with vulnerability in any form but i am
00:01:49 75. I have mild atrial fibrillation and there is a very sharp correlation between the impact of
00:01:58 COVID-19 and heart disease. So he said be sensible, we'll revisit it. But I must admit, I mean,
00:02:06 you look at the circumstances in which I am, we can maybe twiddle it around a bit more, it's a
00:02:11 very agreeable prison that I'm in. I have my books, I have my library, I'm a bit like Prospero,
00:02:19 driven out of milan and i have my books i have my library this presumably is my aerial and my
00:02:26 spirits um uh he only had a guard he only had an island uh i've got a very beautiful garden so
00:02:34 and once support continues but it's utterly bizarre my life turned on a pin's head yes exactly
00:02:43 how do you feel uh sorry i hate that i know you'll hate that how do you feel sorry should i say what
00:02:50 do you think about the general way at the moment this we've just had uh last week we had boris
00:02:58 doing his speech didn't we on sunday what sort of state do you think we're in at the moment with
00:03:04 this how do you think it's being handled oh i i think it's impossible to exaggerate how dire
00:03:15 um the we've committed economic suicide and i think it's really very important to be quite clear
00:03:24 um we've we talk about it as the covid19 crisis it's not it's a specific political crisis which
00:03:33 bizarrely everybody seems to have got themselves into starting with the Chinese. In other words,
00:03:39 it's an extraordinary version of the emperor's new clothes, because what we need to understand,
00:03:44 Peter, is there is enormously long history of epidemics, pandemics, incidences of local disease,
00:03:53 incidences of disease transferring themselves from one community to another. One of the famous
00:03:59 examples is when venereal disease was transferred from latin america to europe um with the spanish
00:04:06 conquerors it was the revenge of the conquered people and syphilis at the beginning of the
00:04:12 16th century was the most horrible disease you know the king of france his nose falls off you
00:04:18 know the the whole of this horror but what is peculiar about um covet 19 is it's not actually
00:04:26 a very serious disease if you look at the numbers affected in Britain that we have been putting this
00:04:35 you know immense passion about Boris practically wearing sackcloth and ashes you know each he's
00:04:42 right of course each death is terrible for those involved but it's 40 000 deaths that out of a
00:04:50 population of 60 million is an infinite percentage. If you go back to a real
00:05:00 pandemic, if we go back to the Black Death of the middle of the 14th century,
00:05:05 you're looking there at a first impact when it hit England of about 20 to 25
00:05:12 percent of the population with repeated returns. So that by the end of the 14th
00:05:19 century, the population of England is half what it was at the beginning. What is unique, in other
00:05:26 words, about this pandemic is, apart from the fact it's rather small, is that the damage that it does
00:05:33 is self-inflicted. Earlier plagues did inflict enormous economic damage. I mean, curiously,
00:05:40 the Black Death did not inflict economic damage. What the Black Death did was to deal with a
00:05:46 country that was getting badly overpopulated, in which wage levels were sinking very sharply,
00:05:53 and it suddenly transformed the English agricultural labourer from a dispensable item
00:06:02 into a valuable property which transforms feudalism. In fact, feudalism was never very
00:06:11 strong in England. It destroys it and it facilitates an extraordinary economic takeoff, a huge transfer
00:06:19 of wealth from the few to the many. So it's a very Labour Party disease. It transfers wealth
00:06:28 from the few to the many and it leads to the development of a market economy. Some other
00:06:34 plagues had much more terrible consequences. They were on a similar scale. The great plague
00:06:40 which afflicts the late roman empire empire the so-called justinian plague um which sweeps across
00:06:47 they all begin in china by the way they all begin in that corner uh of of the eastern eurasian land
00:06:54 mass the great players um at the end towards the end of the reign of justinian not only
00:07:02 inflicts terrible population loss on the roman empire which is now by the way basically in the
00:07:08 eastern mediterranean it also deeply afflicts rome's great enemy iran persia and it effectively
00:07:18 destroys the power of both iran and of the roman empire and what it leads to it leads to the rise
00:07:25 of islam so you see there a play that is vast in scale and has got dreadful consequences this is
00:07:33 a very odd plague it's rather small in scale but it's gigantic in consequences because we have
00:07:40 chosen to inflict uh a form of economic suicide on ourselves there's no other way that one can
00:07:47 describe it um you've written a piece uh you write a column for the critic magazine don't you and
00:07:53 there's a piece coming out i think in the june issue which is out in a few weeks
00:07:59 um which i've seen and and in that uh you you it's very interesting you actually pinpoint a
00:08:07 particular weekend when policy sort of changed that boris johnson and the government had been
00:08:14 going along one path and then on this weekend there were a few events that happened that
00:08:20 made them change direction can you tell us what that was david yes until the weekend the key
00:08:30 weekend and this will go down in history this is the first draft of the history of the overreaction
00:08:37 to kobe 19 in brooklyn up to that friday the with the chief medical officer and the chief scientific
00:08:44 officer and the prime minister himself the good sense of the scientists and the uh and the
00:08:52 statisticians on the one hand and particularly uh boris johnson's libertarianism and generally you
00:08:58 know looking on the bright side uh the pot half full rather the pot half empty we were going to
00:09:04 go along with what Sweden has done. We were going to go along with what was demonized as herd
00:09:16 immunity, but which would have resulted in things like social distancing, a suggestion that people
00:09:23 observed, extra special hygiene and that sort of thing, but not this gigantic lockdown. But what
00:09:30 happened that weekend and it's it's this peter is how history is made we tend to think of history
00:09:35 as being gradual yeah usually history is a crisis things turn on a pin's head and in that weekend
00:09:43 three things happen and the first is that the deaths you know they're running at about 20 or 30
00:09:48 they double that looks dramatic the second thing that happens is the nemesis of britain france
00:09:57 president macron of france threatens to close the frontier if britain did not adopt the same kind of
00:10:04 extreme measures which france had done and the third they are but those two things are public
00:10:10 knowledge the third thing is private information from a journalist friend of mine who is exceedingly
00:10:16 well informed and on the sunday at northwick park hospital in northwest london one of the areas that
00:10:24 been of the capital throughout has been worst afflicted by the virus there were scenes that
00:10:30 were reminiscent of what was happening in italy and what was happening in spain the hospital
00:10:36 looked as though it was going to be overwhelmed the ic unit was you know shutting down there
00:10:41 weren't enough ventilators there were people piling up in admissions there were some bodies
00:10:49 beginning to collide with incoming patients and i think at that point the government's
00:10:54 simply panics and a few days later you get neil ferguson's absurd report from imperial college
00:11:03 suggesting half a million deaths and i think the combination of that localized panic and these
00:11:10 gigantic figures suddenly landing on their deaths produces a complete change of approach but there's
00:11:17 another factor peter that we've got to put in there is a necessary local political factor
00:11:22 If we go back to the kind introduction that you gave about my last interview with you, and indeed, more precisely, I suppose, the Smith Lecture, I was talking about the new compact, the new one-nation Toriesm, the way that Boris has revived Israeli.
00:11:41 Now, part of that compact, in other words, reuniting the South with the North, part of that compact is that the Tories had to present themselves as absolutely the party of the NHS.
00:11:56 This had always been the Achilles heel. It had been the thing that Labour had been used to get at them.
00:12:02 If you're going to take over as blue Labour in the North, you've got to be beyond doubt committed to the NHS.
00:12:10 So the manifesto did that. Now, look suddenly at what's happening. On the evening of the 15th, it looks as though the headlines in two days' time are going to be NHS overwhelmed under Tories. That is the key issue.
00:12:28 And if you look at what was then done, we focused all the time. You began talking about lockdown. But that wasn't really the important thing that happened in the aftermath of that weekend. It really wasn't. And again, as you can see from Sweden, lockdown doesn't make very much difference.
00:12:48 The thing that was peculiar, the thing that was odd in Britain, were the measures that were taken.
00:12:55 And here my information does not extend.
00:12:58 Future historians will have to determine who took the steps that I'm going to describe now.
00:13:03 Because the steps that were decided were to protect the face of the NHS at all costs.
00:13:12 And the decisions are as follows.
00:13:14 The first is you stop all forms of surgery and diagnostic testing completely.
00:13:23 Cancer, heart disease, the lot.
00:13:27 The National Health Service becomes the National COVID Service.
00:13:32 Secondly, you clear every bed that you can so that you can deal with the expected influx of COVID patients.
00:13:43 This is when, of course, patients, usually elderly, the so-called bed blockers, very well have had COVID-19 get sent back to care homes.
00:13:55 And so it is this it's this series of astonishing clinical decisions, which, of course, are coupled with something else.
00:14:02 You also shut down dentistry.
00:14:04 astonishing you shut down all private medicine you do a deal with the private hospitals you
00:14:12 close them down and the result of this of course is that britain was spared that humiliation we
00:14:19 did not have the scenes that were in italy we did not have the scenes that were in spain but there
00:14:25 is a terrible price to pay because we've got two other sets of deaths which are now catching up
00:14:32 There are the deaths of the people who should have been treated for cancer, who should have been treated for heart disease, who are also terrified to go to hospital because of COVID-19 and therefore are dying in droves.
00:14:44 And then there is the final sting in the tail as the deaths go down in hospitals, they go up in care homes.
00:14:51 Because why are we so casual, Peter, about care home? Because they're not part of the NHS. They're not covered by that magic label.
00:15:03 So you see, there's a terrible, as I said, there's an awful sting in the tail that one of the things that's happened throughout this crisis is that joke, Sir Nigel Lawson joke about the NHS being the nearest thing in Britain to a national religion.
00:15:21 It's actually come true. We see popular observances. We see nurses being hailed as angels. We've stopped doing anything on Sunday, the Church of England has shut itself down. Instead, everybody gathers outside and claps for carers.
00:15:40 But it's a false religion. The way the NHS has behaved, and this is really going to get everybody very cross, the NHS behaved exactly in the way that the Catholic Church did under the threat of child abuse.
00:15:57 In other words, it tried to protect the institution, not the patient. And this is what's coming back to haunt us.
00:16:05 would you would you say then that obviously you mentioned it there that you know all of those
00:16:13 things notwithstanding we should have stayed on the same track as swedenhurst that that's what
00:16:18 we should be doing now of course because what is going to happen peter is eventually every country
00:16:25 will have roughly the same level of mortality unless they continue to seal themselves off
00:16:32 It's all very well being smug in New Zealand. But unless New Zealand keeps its frontier closed, I'm sorry. Viruses don't respect frontiers. So it's not only going to be that. I think there's another issue, which is the ignoring that the only way that you can have serious structures of health care is because you have serious economies.
00:17:02 Repeatedly, we've been told, especially by the soft-headed left,
00:17:06 that, oh, we mustn't prioritise the economy over health or over deaths.
00:17:11 But it isn't.
00:17:12 You've got to maintain the balance between the two.
00:17:16 And the Swedish approach perfectly maintains the balance between economic rationality
00:17:22 and a degree of respect for human life and all the rest of it.
00:17:26 Whereas what we've done is lurch completely.
00:17:29 And we also did something which I think is really unforgivable, which is that we lurched without a plan. What I am describing now is not a plan to deal with an epidemic. It is a plan to save the face of the NHS. These things were just scrabbled off the wall.
00:17:47 Again, the future public inquiry, which one hopes will have some serious historians on it,
00:17:54 will need to ask these questions. Was it Public Health England? Was it the NHS directorate that
00:18:00 came up with this? How far were ministers actually involved? I would suggest they just said,
00:18:06 ministers said, for God's sake, do something. And then these things were come up with. And again,
00:18:13 It also raises absolutely fundamental questions.
00:18:16 How is it that the Hippocratic Oath can be completely overwhelmed
00:18:20 by considerations of saving institutional face?
00:18:25 How can an administrator actually instruct a consultant to suspend treatment?
00:18:33 These are really, really radical questions.
00:18:38 And I'm leaving aside, Peter, everything that my friend Jonathan Sumpshen
00:18:42 raised very early on about the fundamental attack on on liberty and the irrationality
00:18:49 of it in legal terms and so on but but even if you look at it in narrowly health terms
00:18:54 it stands up very badly you talk there about this the weekend you talk about the saving the face of
00:19:01 the nhs um what therefore would you say when people bring up well yes okay so we you know
00:19:07 there was this huge panic but it looks like most of the western world has panicked i mean you know
00:19:14 or at least should we say the anglosphere as we call it i mean why would that be the case i mean
00:19:20 they they don't in america there's not the same imperative necessarily but or in many other
00:19:27 countries you can think of but there has been this kind of what you might say is an extraordinary
00:19:33 overreaction well I think I mean again was it that I've described about the
00:19:41 suspension of medical treatment and so on they are peculiar to Britain yeah
00:19:46 those things are peculiar the general overreaction isn't and against there are
00:19:55 much more general factors I mean there are the strange notion that we have now
00:19:59 that it's wrong to die, that rather than death being an inevitable part of the
00:20:05 human condition, it is fundamentally an error. In other words, that the doctor
00:20:12 has replaced the priest with a sort of implicit guarantee of eternal life and
00:20:18 this of course leads to the preposterous structure of our current medicine in
00:20:23 which, as I'm sure you're aware, as much is spent on the average patient in the
00:20:28 last year of their life as in their entire previous medical history and of course that cost frankly to
00:20:37 be blunt is thrown away you know the desperate attempt at resuscitating an 85 year old the
00:20:43 absurdity of doing that has only got to be stated and it is again you see i think it is much of this
00:20:49 is a reaction uh against two things it's a reaction obviously against nazism and the treatment
00:20:57 of the disabled and so on there and secondly uh it's a reaction against something else uh nazism
00:21:03 of course is sort of the right even though they call themselves the national socialists but the
00:21:09 left right through the 1920s and 30s was tainted with a different um brush if you like it was the
00:21:17 brush the brush of eugenics how to improve the breed and this is very interesting this really
00:21:23 is very very interesting peter which was the country where eugenics survived longest
00:21:30 sweden sweden i think much of the swedish reaction against that background when you look at the
00:21:40 crisis as it's panned out uh it does appear that people are lining up on different sizes
00:21:46 there's a kind of left-right dynamic but there's also a sort of brexiteer remainer dynamic would
00:21:53 you say that's true i think it's absolutely true i think it's important to remember that this is
00:21:59 true in two already deeply divided countries that's to say in britain and in america in america
00:22:06 you get exactly the same divide between pro-trump and anti-trump democrat and republican it is
00:22:14 It is Republicans who are leading, and libertarians, of course, who are leading the charge for getting out of the lockdown.
00:22:20 It is Democrat governors like Cuomo and all the rest of it who have been holding the thought and saying, you know, life is more important.
00:22:28 So in one sense, all we're seeing is a crisis latching on to existing political division.
00:22:35 On the other hand, I do think that the right-left positions do lend themselves to different approaches.
00:22:44 Clearly, the right tends to prioritise matters economically.
00:22:48 The left tends to be, well, frankly, in favour of everything that's being done now.
00:22:54 It's no accident that the moment the crisis happened, you had Jeremy Corbyn jumping up and dying saying,
00:23:00 saying yeah yeah yeah i've improved right in other words what the left wants to do is to turn the
00:23:05 whole of human existence into a crisis that demands state management it believes people
00:23:12 should be paid by the state it believes that the state is better at doing things than private
00:23:18 industry despite the fact of course peter that this crisis has demonstrated absolutely directly
00:23:25 did the opposite. If you remember, at the beginning of the crisis, we had two sets of shortages.
00:23:31 We had the great run on the supermarkets, and then we had all the problems with ICU
00:23:36 beds, with ventilators, with testing, with everything else. The supermarkets sorted
00:23:42 themselves out within 10 days. The problems in the NHS, if anything, have got worse. In
00:23:49 In other words, big business can sort it out, big government can't, and I think that repeatedly
00:23:56 the problems that have happened in Britain have been because of the peculiar big government
00:24:01 nature of the NHS.
00:24:03 If you look at why Germany has coped so much better, if you look at why South Korea has
00:24:09 coped so much better, I mean let's just take the specific instance of testing.
00:24:14 reason that we've done catastrophically badly in Britain is because it's been absolutely
00:24:20 centralised. The NHS is the parody of 1940's big government, with Public Health England insisting
00:24:27 only it could set standards, only it could actually carry out the test, only it could actually
00:24:33 validate a positive or negative test. America tried that line for about 10 days, and then of
00:24:41 course, as you said now, America doesn't have the same obsession with federal institutions that we
00:24:47 have with the NHS and the drugs agency was just pushed out of the way and America privatised
00:24:53 testing. At which point you move, Peter, this is a staggering figure, the Adam Smith Institute did
00:25:01 the work, you move from a hundred tests a day to hundreds of thousands being available, with
00:25:08 an order of magnitude shift which we've not yet managed to do and germany never had the problem
00:25:14 in the first place because it's not a centralized country healthcare is dealt with in two different
00:25:20 ways it's dealt within the separate lander within the separate state governments on the one hand
00:25:26 but also there's a very very large privately insured health base to the country which of
00:25:33 course is run in very different fashions and the the the great german clinician um um
00:25:43 virologist who has been in charge if anybody has been in charge of presenting the german case
00:25:48 has specifically picked this out he said your problem in britain is you have this big government
00:25:54 we don't yeah and of course socialists can't admit this and then the final thing is in britain of
00:26:00 of course, the Remainer media have never forgiven Boris.
00:26:06 This is, you know, just yet another opportunity.
00:26:10 And it has to be said, of course, that an area in which the memorization
00:26:15 of careful criteria of elaborate statistics of funny names
00:26:20 actually comes over rather well in the press conference
00:26:24 isn't something that's going to show off Boris Johnson's best qualities, isn't it?
00:26:29 it's a crisis it's a crisis design for uh uh keir starmer on the guardian um and of course
00:26:39 they have exploited it as brutally and ruthlessly as we would expect do you think that this uh this
00:26:45 divide do you think this you mentioned a a political divide latching onto an issue i
00:26:52 mean do you think this is going to be the pattern for the future generally that in fact
00:26:56 this divide this cultural divide will basically come to light with every issue this country faces
00:27:03 i think it's very likely to because of course it's part of and the divide itself is the reason so i
00:27:10 know this i'm going to utter a complete irishism the divide is why the divide exists in other words
00:27:16 the reason for the brexit vote was precisely the dominance of the liberalism gone mad
00:27:23 of a liberalism in full intellectual decay, which is represented by the BBC, The Guardian,
00:27:30 and so on. The kind of liberalism that values international cooperation and globalism
00:27:38 above any kind of rational defence of the nation. And this is also something that is very striking.
00:27:44 And I think the response of the government, the response of the conservative government,
00:27:48 has been extraordinarily feeble in one sense. I think one of the problems is that the man in
00:27:55 charge of taking the response, much more than the Prime Minister, the Secretary of State for Health
00:28:03 Hancock, is himself an utterly unideological politician. He was George Osborne's bag carrier
00:28:11 and it seems to me to be quite clear that he has been captured by the institutional structures of
00:28:17 the NHS. We should be putting forward, as some conservative MPs are doing, this is, if we are
00:28:25 to make the fuss about it, that we are doing, Covid is the ultimate consequence of globalisation.
00:28:32 The thing that demonstrates that the reaction against globalisation was absolutely spot on,
00:28:38 and all the deficiencies that we've seen are incapacity in testing. The fact that though we
00:28:44 We have some of the world's greatest pharmaceutical companies in terms of research and marketing.
00:28:50 We can't actually manufacture the damn things.
00:28:52 The fact that we can't even manufacture bits of cheap plastic, which is, you know, all PPE is.
00:28:58 I mean, these are utterly shocking facts.
00:29:01 And they are a consequence of extremes of globalization on the one hand and total cheap-faring approach to public provision on the other.
00:29:11 You know, you always buy in the cheapest market.
00:29:13 Whereas what's very frightening, if you look, for example, in America, America has a kind of margin that says, OK, labor costs are higher in America.
00:29:24 So if the federal government is going to buy something, it can pay, say, 10 percent more if the product is American than if it's imported.
00:29:32 But here, you know, we've had this. It's very interesting how right and left have come together in the worst possible way in Britain.
00:29:39 The cheese pairing is an extreme example of Thatcherism. And the completely level playing field is globalism gone mad. And we've reaped a terrible reward. And again, so much of what is happening, it seems to me, the, as it were, the counter tune, the counter themes that we should be playing are very much what Boris Johnson was talking about in the latter part of next year, the need to level up.
00:30:08 We obviously need to restore enormous swathes of British industry.
00:30:14 Well, that's exactly what the North needs, to know what the Middle East needs.
00:30:19 But of course, in order to do it properly, we need a desperate realignment of education.
00:30:26 We need a revival, something we've never done very well, of technical education.
00:30:31 And of course, here now, my being very disloyal to the university sector,
00:30:37 which i suppose i'm still sort of apart and the fact that the university sector is in crisis
00:30:42 should enable a confident government to force reform upon it and it's absurd that we continue
00:30:49 to prioritize this whole sort of bottom two-thirds of our universities weakish generalist universities
00:30:57 whereas in fact we should be reverting to something much like the old colleges of advanced
00:31:03 technology and you know this is one of the great disasters of Maje's government and that it
00:31:10 abolished those in favor of turning everything into a generalist university and Kenneth Baker
00:31:17 is brilliant on this subject we should we should be going and we should be consulting him we should
00:31:22 we should be introducing the measures that he's talked about when you did the lecture
00:31:28 in December about one-nation
00:31:31 Toryism
00:31:33 and Disraeli
00:31:34 that was just
00:31:36 one lecture but you've been writing a lot about
00:31:39 this in The Critic
00:31:40 and it appeared to be
00:31:43 a kind of golden opportunity
00:31:45 at that point
00:31:46 for something entirely new
00:31:48 you mentioned earlier then
00:31:50 today about the so-called
00:31:52 Red Wall and the new support
00:31:55 there was to the government, this was an enormous
00:31:56 opportunity I think you said for Boris Johnson
00:31:58 has that been wiped out only if the government lets it be wiped out you remember there is a
00:32:06 famous phrase that was one of those nasty apparatchiks that lay behind the beauteous
00:32:12 calm of the Obama government never let a good crisis go to waste this is a very good crisis
00:32:17 but you can only use a crisis if you seize control of it and I don't think they have done I mean
00:32:24 That what we should be doing is we should be saying, look, these are the things that the government, rather than being so defensive, should be saying, frankly, these are the things that have gone wrong.
00:32:35 This is what we identify as having gone wrong.
00:32:38 And what's gone wrong is all the things that we were unhappy about anyway.
00:32:43 Big government.
00:32:44 We made a terrible.
00:32:45 If I were Johnson, I would do a mea culpa speech.
00:32:49 I would say, you know, we got it wrong.
00:32:51 We let our, I mean, I would sack Hancock and he will have to go.
00:32:57 And I would be frank, I would say that what happened was we were captured by not the carers, not the nurses, not the doctors.
00:33:07 We were captured by this dire self-regarding bureaucratic machine, the big governmental aspect of the NHS.
00:33:15 And it's been disastrous.
00:33:16 And we would then, you know, he should then be saying, we've also suffered terribly from the fact that we've let our industrial base rot, that we buy too much from abroad.
00:33:28 I mean, we're brilliant at R&D.
00:33:31 GlaxoSmithKline and all the rest is one of the very greatest of the drug companies.
00:33:37 The new Cambridge campus and the new Oxford campus, they're right at the front of development.
00:33:43 But whereas in Germany, or indeed in Switzerland, the German and Swiss drug companies aren't just research, they're not just marketing, they're not just finance, they're supported by an infrastructure.
00:33:58 We've let the infrastructure go.
00:34:01 And it is the appalling thing that's happened in Britain in area after area.
00:34:07 You look at the destruction of our chemicals industry with the disintegration of ICI.
00:34:12 The notion was always, oh, manufacturing is something that really, well, it's sort of best left to rather simple little places with people on very low wages, you know, like Malaysia, like China, whatever.
00:34:25 Here, we just have the really very, very sophisticated top level stuff.
00:34:30 And then we have what? Well, we have a service economy to keep the, you know, to keep the helots from actually starving.
00:34:36 and i'm sorry that model has shown itself to be deadly and there's another there's a final point
00:34:44 a service economy cannot survive in a post-covid world and i mean if you look at the economy of
00:34:56 london the economy of london is an economy which depends on huge numbers of people as new york
00:35:02 Huge numbers of people living very close, hugger-mugger together, socialising an awful lot, going to the theatre an awful lot, going to restaurants an awful lot.
00:35:12 All of those things, all of which are the things that will be up to us before this.
00:35:20 So we're going to have to do something. And if the government doesn't seize the initiative, somebody else will.
00:35:25 There's only one choice after this. Either we go down a fully managed economy, which is what the left wants, of course, which is what Starmer is just as keen on, it's really important we realise this, is just as keen on as Corbyn was, or we go for a strategic realignment of capitalism.
00:35:50 and also presumably there is a great opportunity there for someone who wants to take it
00:35:56 to actually rebuild and make us a country that actually makes things again i mean
00:36:03 absolutely and again you know i think probably the first thing i would do would be to scrap hs2
00:36:11 and to say right we're going to do something that that that is shattering and radical we are
00:36:21 going to pick up something else that George Osborne talked about. We are going to create
00:36:25 series of new research in but research and industrial parts in the north. We're going to
00:36:34 universities important existing clusters of industry and we're going to throw money at them.
00:36:40 uh it david just finally that otherwise at the moment we're throwing money at people for doing
00:36:50 nothing we might as well throw money at people for doing something do you uh you you started by
00:36:58 saying it's an economic suicide um but then we've arrived at a position where we see possibilities
00:37:06 But what do you think is the real chance of someone grabbing that opportunity and building manufacturing?
00:37:16 Do you think there is the will there?
00:37:19 Probably not.
00:37:22 I think there's an absolutely fundamental problem, two, in terms of personalities.
00:37:28 As far as one can see, Boris post-COVID is not the same as Boris pre-COVID.
00:37:34 he looks to me to be a semi-broken man he has had a serious illness he is manifestly not fully
00:37:41 recovered he is a father with a newborn child and with a soppy sentimental and greenish wife
00:37:49 these are lethal combinations for the sort of radicalism optimism can doery that we need
00:37:58 um i am not optimistic well uh the way it looks at the moment it looks like i would agree with you
00:38:08 uh i think uh it is very very worrying indeed um but david thank you very very much uh for giving
00:38:18 us your perspective on it and um i do hope that perhaps maybe at the end of the year when things
00:38:25 have moved on a huge amount more you will come back and talk about it then maybe towards the
00:38:30 end of the year i think that whatever happens the situation is going to be the same but not the same
00:38:35 if you know what i mean i would love to return and i would love to be able to sit here and say
00:38:41 i was wrong if nothing would give me greater pleasure um i do not like to see my country
00:38:49 being damaged i do not like to see the hopes that we've all had shattered i do not like to see
00:38:57 doors that seem to be opening slammed shut locked and bolted i find it profoundly depressing yes i
00:39:06 find i find the behavior of those on the left who want to spend the whole of the time saying oh
00:39:13 britain is worst over the bottom of this league table and whatever i find that sort of self-hatred
00:39:19 fills me with disgust yeah um it's it's utterly demoralizing yeah it's utterly demoralizing
00:39:32 um david thank you very very much and uh look i hope uh i hope to see you soon and uh also
00:39:41 well i know everyone's saying stay well at the moment but you look like a picture of you look
00:39:47 like a pitch of health to me but anyway okay thank you thank you very much thank you i'm enjoying
00:39:53 my misery thank you uh that's all for so what you're saying is uh now but uh do uh join us
00:40:01 next time i look forward to seeing you then thank you bye