New Culture Forum - May 18, 2020


Ed West - Why Conservatives Have Lost Almost Every Political Argument Since 1945

David Starkey - Covid - 19 -- Britain's Disastrous Response Will Have Devastating Consequences A New Cold War? What has Covid-19 revealed about China, China-West relations & Globalisation?

Episode Stats


Length

32 minutes

Words per minute

194.55

Word count

6,290

Sentence count

64


Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
00:00:00 Hello and welcome to So What You're Saying Is, I'm Peter Whitlaw. Now my guest today is the author
00:00:23 and journalist Ed West. Ed has written for numerous publications, The Times, The Telegraph,
00:00:30 he's a regular at The Spectator, he's currently the deputy editor of UnHerd, and he's also an
00:00:37 author. He wrote a book a few years ago called The Diversity Illusion, What We Got Wrong About
00:00:42 Immigration and How to Set It Right. His new book is called Small Men on the Wrong Side of History,
00:00:50 the decline for an unlikely return of conservatism um thanks for coming in thanks very much thank
00:00:57 you um the the title is actually a quote uh from obama isn't it about al-qaeda about al-qaeda
00:01:07 yes so um but how does it chime with your book then who is a small man well the reference was
00:01:14 to basically the overview of the book is that conservatives even though they do tend to win
00:01:20 elections have sort of lost every political and cultural argument for the last few decades and
00:01:25 this is a series of defeats going back um about 50 or 60 years i mean the small men wrong side
00:01:33 history the i the quote got me because of this basic idea that progressivism has which is that
00:01:40 we're moving towards you know a future where they're going to win and everything's going to
00:01:43 to turn out their way and they often say that people who disagree them on the wrong side of
00:01:49 history you know in the future you're going to be seen as losers and bigots and there'll be films
00:01:53 about how you guys are the baddies and that's how conservatives are cast and that's a sort of idea
00:01:58 that progressivism gets from Christianity which is I mean one of the themes of the books and it's
00:02:03 not a particularly original thought is that the left is basically a heresy of Christianity and
00:02:07 that's where their ideas come from and they're continuing that and as Christianity has declined
00:02:11 that's the pretty much the main reason why the left has become so much more
00:02:15 dominant because it's become a sort of default religion for most people
00:02:18 especially with university educated people anyway and you're saying as well
00:02:23 in the book are you not that basically it's not going to change I mean that's
00:02:27 the you know that it's to begin with at least it's quite a sort of pessimistic
00:02:32 it's very outlook I'm quite a pessimistic person it's yes there is at
00:02:37 the end well because the problem is with the one of the many problems with the modern media is
00:02:42 everyone thinks they're losing right so everyone watches the news and thinks and there's studies
00:02:46 of this even the other day where both democrats and republicans by quite wide margins think they're
00:02:50 losing everything um so there is signs of conservatives and coming back i mean the
00:02:56 brexit and trump were signs where conservatives actually won argument small c conservatives
00:03:01 and so obviously liberals and progressives and media think oh well how can you say you know
00:03:06 you're losing you're doing really well so well this is a sort of in many ways it's almost like
00:03:11 a last gasp because on both those counts the demography is against the conservatives you know
00:03:16 brexit is simply older same with trump voters amongst younger americans they are they are much
00:03:21 more um progressive than older ones and they're much less religious but there is a the also the
00:03:27 counter thing where identity politics is repulsing a lot of people as well um amongst young white
00:03:33 Americans they seem to move into Republicans only amongst men for various reasons at the moment
00:03:40 and that's in reaction to just the sort of sort of I guess overshoot of progressive politics has
00:03:45 become too obsessed with identity it's become basically like a religion and a lot of people are
00:03:50 so that's when I say the unlikely return of conservatism that's my sort of small note of
00:03:55 optimism yeah so that basically people just simply get fed up and rebel against this
00:04:00 yeah i think it's a little bit i mean because once young people especially liked being
00:04:05 counter-cultural so i mean i'm a bit reluctant saying conservatives like counter-cultural but
00:04:09 they are in certain ways in that you know after everyone in the arts likes to think they're
00:04:14 rebelling against this you know this powerful patriarchy or this sort of elite they're against
00:04:20 but you know it's no denying that the arts in britain are left dominated you can't say anything
00:04:25 that's left to left wing that's going to shock anyone it's just but people still hang on to this
00:04:30 construction and likewise a comedy the reason comedy has become quite tiresome
00:04:35 is because people there's nothing really to make a joke about there's nothing to
00:04:38 to be alternative about because you know most companies now is people laughing
00:04:43 communities laughing at people further down the social scale yeah you know the
00:04:47 gamins I mean this is kind of yeah I think punching down I think yeah I mean
00:04:51 they sell we're punching up saving not really because I go to comedy clubs I
00:04:53 mean all my favorite comedians are basically center-left although I did see
00:04:59 you know your guy Constantine with you and he was pretty funny but you know I'll go to a comedy
00:05:03 club and it's just a comedian talking to other sort of university educated centre-left people
00:05:08 about how stupid low middle class people in the Midlands are I mean that's the underlying message
00:05:12 so that's not really you know that's not really rebellion so naturally amongst certain
00:05:18 uh younger people there is a sort of rejection of that and so where are they going to go I mean
00:05:23 inevitably they go to whatever's anti that when whether you call it right wing I'm not entirely
00:05:27 sure but the thing is is you you mentioned the answer there was you know the arts being left
00:05:32 wing there's actually been a report out a couple of weeks ago it was in the times it's which not
00:05:39 only sort of proved this to be true it's something we know to be true but that in fact it's become
00:05:43 incredibly um restricted and people actually being shut down as it were you know if they voted
00:05:51 brexit or if they've got any views on transgenderism this this came out and i think the richard
00:05:56 Morrison wrote a piece in the times he's the arts editor for the times saying basically you know
00:06:01 this is a problem in the left sure i mean the survey said one in six people in the arts so
00:06:06 they can't say i assume a large amount of that is due to the transgender issue because there's no
00:06:10 way one in six people are right wing in the arts it's going to be much lower than that i think it's
00:06:14 i mean like four percent of artists vote brexit uh and so this comes down to you know one of the
00:06:19 problems you get there is the viewpoint diversity thing which is a kind of contended issue but if
00:06:24 look at the universities in the 60s in both britain and america there was a sort of left-wing
00:06:29 dominance because liberal-minded people tend to be higher in openness the personality trait which
00:06:35 correlates with artistic ability so the art is always going to be slightly left dominated that's
00:06:40 fine so the universities were like three to one two to one so about a third of people voted either
00:06:45 conservative over here republican i mean now in the states it's something it's in the region of
00:06:50 15 to 1 in certain fields 50 to 1 in some in Britain about 9 to 10 percent of university
00:06:57 professors now vote conservative and they're going to be much older on average and the ones
00:07:01 coming through none of them are going to be and so there is the point about on the basic front is
00:07:05 that in any area where you don't have a viewpoint diversity the quality is going to be worse i mean
00:07:10 they've been studies on wikipedia pages when they're when they're made by people with two
00:07:14 different political views the quality is much better because they yeah they sort of test each
00:07:18 other but also you just get to the point where our universities basically
00:07:22 returning to their original function which was religious organization all
00:07:25 universities started off as religious you know Oxford and Cambridge Church of
00:07:30 England it wasn't till the 1830s we had a university here that you didn't have
00:07:35 to be Anglican to go to in the States all the different universities were
00:07:38 started by churches so the idea that you can go to university and have three
00:07:42 thought is quite a novel one and kind of against our nature because I think and
00:07:48 certain sense you know humans don't like disagreement it's something we have to
00:07:53 like discipline ourselves to to make ourselves put up with it so unless we
00:07:58 make an effort to have that viewpoint diversity then inevitably these
00:08:01 institutions will become not just bias but they also become political issues as
00:08:06 well you know that the right will dislike them and the left will side with them
00:08:10 and that's also happening in the states where far more Republicans now think
00:08:13 universities are a bad thing which is an unusual unprecedented thing you mentioned
00:08:18 actually in the book or you make the comparison that what's happened with conservatism and by
00:08:24 that I'm distinct from the Tory party yeah Tory party didn't quite well so which is bad for my
00:08:29 foot exactly but what you say is that this is not unlike the reformation maybe I mean if you could
00:08:37 explain that a bit I think I know what you mean but that essentially it's a generational change
00:08:43 right so you know europe's had i make two comparisons historically one is the christian
00:08:47 takeover of rome and i'm when i'm talking about these historical comparisons i'm not making direct
00:08:52 comparisons because i think they're quite uh difficult history but they're sort of analogies
00:08:56 to explain uh the our current situation so with the reformation a sort of moral revolution took
00:09:04 part um took place certain people believed in this new system so protestantism which had variations
00:09:12 across Europe, which was quite revolutionary, overthrowing the authorities, making new
00:09:16 authorities, turning back on certain old established views, you know, celibacy and transubstantiation.
00:09:24 But certain people held on to these.
00:09:27 And so across Europe, you had this kind of division, which is suddenly new.
00:09:32 And then it was a lot of it to do with pamphlets.
00:09:34 There were these pamphlet wars attacking the other side.
00:09:37 And it became more and more bitter as people's identity became strongly attached to Catholic and Protestant, which were new identities.
00:09:44 I think, especially since the Brexit vote, we've seen Remain and Leave identities become much, much stronger than Tory and Labour votes.
00:09:52 I mean, people, by any measurement, are much more likely to strongly, especially Remain, funnily enough, they have a much stronger group of identity.
00:10:00 Why is that, do you think?
00:10:01 uh i don't know i suppose it's because i mean my i think a certain type of person
00:10:10 after below a certain age in britain and across the west they see their membership of being a sort
00:10:17 of educated liberal-minded uh a sort of worldwide group that you know they they have more in common
00:10:26 with someone who's a liberal in germany than they will their neighbor who's a conservative
00:10:31 and didn't go to university and i think it's the maybe it's the lack of awareness that this is
00:10:35 actually our identity because they're supposed to be beyond the identity because nationalism is a
00:10:39 bad thing because nationalism killed 70 million people in two wars but i think the lack of
00:10:44 awareness means that people don't realize that this is a new identity and it's actually much
00:10:48 closer to you know the reformation here religious identities where protestant in england would go
00:10:53 and fight with protestants in holland or germany against catholic english people because that
00:10:58 identity was much stronger than national identity so you know people can adopt these things
00:11:05 so then political identity becomes now the replacement for national identity so in America
00:11:11 America is far ahead of us but we've caught up quite quickly which makes me
00:11:15 slightly pessimistic because the Republican and Democrat identity in America is now so strong
00:11:20 and their hostility towards the other group polls you know showing people they want a member of the
00:11:25 the other party marrying into their family you know all these kind of things they think the other
00:11:29 the other party are less evolved they think they've haven't got the country's interest they're a danger
00:11:33 to the country and there are all these indices of um you know the political warmth and political
00:11:38 coldness how do you rate your own party how do you rate the other party democrats and publicans
00:11:42 don't like their own party anymore than they did 30 years ago but their hostilities towards the
00:11:47 others has gone up so much and i do think this this kind of ideology this tribalism is so much
00:11:53 in us that we can allow politics to take the role that religion or national
00:11:58 identity once did yeah this is actually quite a personal book isn't it
00:12:04 memoir is is pitching a bit strong yeah but essentially you your own experience
00:12:10 sort of goes through the whole thing i mean when did you become a conservative or were you
00:12:18 i mean you know there's this idea of jonathan hates the idea that somehow there is this
00:12:23 conservative mind and there is a left-wing mind right yeah i'm very skeptical about that but
00:12:28 do you were you born were you born would you call yourself right wing or conservative or what i
00:12:33 think both are probably fair enough um were you born that way or was it conditioning i meant i
00:12:40 mentioned a lot of what you know i mentioned what the psychology world says about this yes and i do
00:12:46 try to step back a bit partly because lots of psychological findings don't have to be nonsense
00:12:50 and that's how the crumbling is but i'm not a psychologist but they said there is an argument
00:12:54 that uh right so conservatism is a political philosophy but it's also a sort of a sort of
00:13:01 state of mind as well so conservatives do tend to have these personality traits more conscientious
00:13:07 i was going to say what do you think they are what are the basic traits then so the the main
00:13:11 thing is that the five you know the five big personality traits um there are two where there
00:13:17 there are differences between Liberals and Conservatives. Liberals tend to be more high
00:13:21 on openness, which means they try new things. You know, Liberals in America, for example,
00:13:25 there's a study last week, they're six times more likely to try cannabis than Conservatives.
00:13:30 They're more open-minded, they're more likely to go travelling, they're more likely to do all
00:13:33 these things and find out about wealth. Conservatives tend to be more conscientious,
00:13:38 so they'll turn up on time to stuff like that. Notice I was early today, I hate being late
00:13:44 that stuff right the other three the other three traits um extraversion neurosis agreeability they
00:13:51 don't tend to neurosis yes well i think i think there is some green party voters are the most
00:13:57 neurotic but i don't but i don't think there's a huge uh left-wing divide on that or right-wing
00:14:01 divide so there is so anyway so yes and you mentioned also there's a great agreeableness
00:14:07 agreeability right so how would that how would you illustrate that how uh i mean this is this
00:14:14 I mean, these are just what the world of psychology said.
00:14:17 These are the five personality traits they measure,
00:14:18 and they do various tests on people.
00:14:20 But what I'm saying is, are they sort of,
00:14:23 does that mean that conservatives are more agreeable people?
00:14:26 I know, conservative liberals are about the same on agreeable levels, right?
00:14:29 Oh, right.
00:14:29 It's just the two.
00:14:30 It's just openness and conscientiousness,
00:14:32 where there is some consistency.
00:14:34 Like, for example, you can tell someone's political,
00:14:38 with a quite high accuracy, just looking at a desk.
00:14:40 If someone's got a really neat desk,
00:14:43 they're much more likely to be right-wing than if someone's got a missed desk so I mean not a huge
00:14:48 accuracy but more than 50 percent so there are you can tell a certain you know it's like the
00:14:52 odd couple you could in that film you could probably say one of them is going to be Republican
00:14:55 one Democrat right um so I've partly I mentioned the memoir but because I I think it's like jaded
00:15:02 about politics and I find reading political arguments after a bit tiring so I just wanted
00:15:06 to make it a bit of a personal story to make it you know a bit lighter but also I sort of person
00:15:12 wanted to have a bit of understand why I was never a liberal because I wasn't one of these
00:15:18 cool people who I really envy who are liberal and you know and when they're young and then
00:15:23 become conservative that's the right way right so that's like the Christopher Hitchens of this
00:15:27 world you know sort of you know they're sort of like the ex-smokers aren't they you know do it
00:15:33 when you're young and grow up so I was never I was always quite conservative right when I never
00:15:38 really saw the appeal of liberalism did you I mean for example sort of youthful
00:15:46 adolescent rebellion right against the parents or against authority whenever
00:15:50 quite often I feel that some on the left have sort of never left that behind
00:15:53 right yeah yeah but did but did you did you sort of rebel no my parents
00:15:59 incredibly lax and easygoing you know my mum used to buy me fags when she went on a day when I was a teenager
00:16:04 I just had nothing to rebel against in that sense I did go to a very strict
00:16:08 comprehensive school though I think that had a I do mention you know that in book
00:16:11 because I think that had a big sort of psychological effect me because I came
00:16:15 to think well actually authority is quite protective because if that if there
00:16:19 wasn't for this authority this school lots of comprehensive at the time 90s
00:16:23 were just crumbling sort of they were dystopian you know post hellish places
00:16:28 where the kids were throwing stones at teachers and our school was incredibly
00:16:31 well run and loads of people got really good results and it was thanks to the
00:16:34 headmaster and it's kind of 1980 you know 1990s he's my mayor Giuliani style
00:16:39 yes zero tolerance policy and I think that probably influenced my politics I
00:16:44 think that's quite a good thing isn't it right yes I mean I suppose the point
00:16:48 really is I remember growing up not feeling hugely rebellious not in that
00:16:54 way anyway but I suppose as well freedom you know he's not about chaos
00:16:59 necessarily is it freedom you could justify by saying that freedom is in
00:17:03 your head you know yeah basically how much you have in your head i suppose it's about testing
00:17:07 boundaries as well isn't it right so that's that's um because chaos ultimately there's no
00:17:11 there's not much fun in chaos well we're sounding remarkably like jordan peterson here aren't we
00:17:15 i mean this is what this is where what he obviously he talks about what about your own life
00:17:21 i mean do you for example being a conservative have you felt like a leper social leper i mean
00:17:29 Have you felt that you are, you know, the man on the outside in your own social life?
00:17:35 A little bit. I do live in a very Remainery part of London as well.
00:17:39 I managed to find one other Brexit voter amongst in the area.
00:17:43 After about three or four years, we finally worked out.
00:17:46 Yeah, I mean, there are loads of... I mean, partly I started writing this book.
00:17:51 It was actually after reading The Writers of the Minds.
00:17:53 I thought that was a very... that sort of inspired me to think, you know,
00:17:56 why do i get annoyed about people who i think are just wrong about politics and i think we shouldn't
00:18:01 there's no point getting annoyed because they just think differently but i'm just so used to
00:18:04 these social situations where people will will be in a social setting and they don't really know me
00:18:09 and they don't know politics and people would just naturally assume like hey what about those
00:18:13 conservatives those idiots and everything and i would just keep my mouth shut normally and it's
00:18:17 quite a normal thing and i think um if you're a certain age and and in certain circles in london
00:18:25 then that's just sort of the thing, right?
00:18:26 You're going to be the only conservative.
00:18:27 There might be one other guy who's secretly conservative as well,
00:18:30 but they keep their mouth shut as well.
00:18:33 So I sort of get the impression slightly
00:18:35 that you almost wish you weren't conservative.
00:18:37 I wonder about that.
00:18:38 If I could take a magic pill, I think.
00:18:40 Why? Because life would be easy or what?
00:18:42 I think it would be.
00:18:42 I think there's definitely some stress
00:18:45 in having an unpopular opinion and having a minority opinion.
00:18:49 No one likes to be unpopular.
00:18:51 I mean, this is one reason I think Taleb's point about journalists being very conformist people
00:18:58 and very not very sort of thinking outside the box people in politics.
00:19:05 And, you know, I come to the thing where journalism is very left-winging
00:19:09 because I think, you know, journalists want to be popular, right?
00:19:11 So they always want to see, I want to have the popular opinion,
00:19:13 the high status opinion that everyone's going to value me for.
00:19:15 um so the if you're quite conservative the the only option is to kind of go down the road of
00:19:22 becoming like the ogre and there's obviously a market for that and you can become an ogre but
00:19:26 um i mean personally i didn't really want to be an ogre didn't you nearly work for bryant
00:19:31 right yeah so i do come to that so i yeah interviewed by steve bannon um yeah before
00:19:37 i've never even heard of him and he just said it was like 2014 and he was just shouting down
00:19:42 the phone a lot a lot very very they just never stopped talking and um it was a very well-paid
00:19:48 job and i just kept saying well ed you know we're going to put our own guy we're going to overthrow
00:19:54 the republican party and we're going to put our own guy in the white house we're going to have
00:19:57 our own nationalist guy from outside the deadwoods of the republican elite and it's 2014 i thought
00:20:03 what is this guy on about he'll never get some completely outsider no one's no one's ever heard
00:20:08 of into the white house and then yeah hey presto yeah so i was completely wrong but no i i turned
00:20:13 it down because i just thought um it's through james allen pal who i like a lot who i think is
00:20:17 a really good writer but you know with uh with once mainstream journalism becomes this kind of
00:20:26 group thinky thing uh the only alternative amongst sort of alternative conservative
00:20:32 media has become much more sensationalist and that's the only sort of way to sort of get attention
00:20:39 you know and i just didn't really want to be part of that i think that's um i found that morally
00:20:43 troubling a little bit so yeah i turned that down but yeah that was part of my journey you
00:20:48 you also say in the book actually you know it's quite strong actually you say that uh conservatism
00:20:53 small c conservative views or instincts are actually sort of considered quite repellent
00:20:59 uh to to many people that's really very very strong isn't it i mean yeah but i think it's
00:21:05 true though i mean i'm always surprised by um uh well firstly i think a lot of people
00:21:10 uh people are repelled by what they don't know and so once people
00:21:16 enter these social circles and i think this is quite a new thing because they were mixed more
00:21:20 mixed 20 years ago uh well they just don't meet anyone who's conservative and they don't the ideas
00:21:26 are even so alien to them then when they hear them they're just like hold a minute what you think
00:21:33 you know you think people should be restricted from coming to this country because they're you
00:21:38 know not from this country or something you know all this even kind of basic stuff becomes repellent
00:21:45 and i think that is basically because they don't meet that many well uh we recently did a show
00:21:51 with uh young people on the right you know who are coming up yeah and um basically they sort of
00:21:56 i felt they'd slipped through the net almost okay but what they related i mean was it just that
00:22:01 everybody in terms of education around them was entirely left-wing right yeah so that this is a
00:22:07 change isn't it yeah yeah you're saying it's much more and that people are not going on to change
00:22:13 their views your friends for example your own friends around your age yeah they're not there
00:22:18 And I think that's a social thing because they don't, once they don't meet any conservatives,
00:22:23 even if they do have slight inclinations, especially once they sort of settle down,
00:22:28 they don't identify as conservative, certainly. And they sort of keep conservative ideas at
00:22:34 arm's length because they just don't meet anyone socially. So there's no way for those,
00:22:38 you know, I think ideas and politics are transmitted on a sort of one-to-one basis,
00:22:43 much more than most people don't get their ideas from reading a political
00:22:47 tract it was either friends of theirs people they trust people they look up to
00:22:51 social proof I think happens much more that's why I think culture is much more
00:22:56 important I mean that's why you know what you do is so important I think you
00:23:00 are on the right track about this all the time
00:23:02 I think we were before the time
00:23:04 no because exactly because it doesn't matter how many you know political
00:23:08 arguments you can make in a dry textbook if the cultural values are the ones that
00:23:12 transmits and people remember films they remember books and those are now you know much more on the
00:23:16 left than they used to be and uh yeah I mean I think that's a problem for us basically
00:23:22 you wrote as I mentioned in the introduction a book called the diversity illusionary
00:23:27 that was actually pretty much before its time I think it wasn't it um I got the impression it was
00:23:34 sort of you know it was rather it was neglected sort of ignored is that I think so I mean every
00:23:40 author thinks that about their books right? It was review to it but it was actually quite
00:23:44 a hard-hitting book wasn't it about? Yeah I mean I don't think it's not my career much
00:23:49 good. I mean that again that was like I was 35 when it came out I was really 33 when I
00:23:54 wrote it and amongst I mean most of my social network would just think oh great yeah immigration
00:23:58 diversity brilliant and I think I was probably very unusual in thinking I didn't think this
00:24:03 is like a very good idea what we're doing you know where does this end what's what are
00:24:06 the cost benefits uh you know why why make all these risks and I think that obviously that's my
00:24:12 conservative instinct you know I think if you're going to make a radical change most likely that
00:24:16 radical change is going to be a bad thing you know small changes are usually fine but um
00:24:21 yeah I mean it's got some it's got various good you know nice quotes from people down the years
00:24:28 and uh but yes it's um it's quite a brave book actually I think I know it was actually looking
00:24:35 at the whole thing of diversity as well which i'd say i mean you read this what six years seven years
00:24:41 ago yeah um i would say that diversity now is almost it becomes such a thing it's almost like
00:24:46 a fetish is it's yeah it is just there all the time in every part of life you know this is being
00:24:53 pushed diversity strength so and now project back to the histories yes exactly strange yeah i find
00:24:59 it very strange but I mean I think I mean I suppose you say the arguments ahead of its time
00:25:05 but I think maybe the dials even move further I mean maybe and people will read that in five
00:25:08 years time they were in their 20s or just think wow this guy's insane even even more so than you
00:25:14 sure because the arguments are just dying out I mean I mean my I suppose my problem with diversity
00:25:22 is that once you make diversity like a good in itself there is no end point right so there's
00:25:29 always more diversity because you can't have any immigration restrictions that reduce diversity
00:25:33 and you can't say anything you can't do anything that will reduce diversity it will always go up
00:25:37 and up and up and what at what point do you say okay enough like there is no end point and no
00:25:42 one's really thought that um through as a sort of yeah as a future so i mean like if it's like
00:25:47 that now i mean i don't know i mean i was thinking the other day there was a i think back in the
00:25:53 goodness gracious me the sick the sketch show in the early twin now i might have misinterpreted
00:25:58 but they have a sketch where it's The Great Escape and they're making a film and there's
00:26:05 Asian guys in The Great Escape.
00:26:09 And this is not to do with 1917 because I think 1917 there were Sikh soldiers and that's
00:26:13 fine.
00:26:14 So that's not a good point.
00:26:15 But I just wonder, will future generations even understand that joke about like sort
00:26:21 of making something that's historically inaccurate and anachronistic for the sake of diversity
00:26:26 because now it's just sort of screened um as a sort of part of our national story i find it
00:26:30 very strange a very strange thing well it is sort of uh i mean i think the bbc uh this week
00:26:36 talked about repurposing classics i mean this orwellian word repurposing i didn't even know
00:26:42 there was why don't they just uh you know produce new stories yes i mean there are lots of writers
00:26:47 out there who would love to write something yes and you know you can make um i mean it's been done
00:26:52 you know make an austin novel but set in the modern age the same storyline that's been done
00:26:56 before it's not a huge thing but yeah you're right it's sort of retconning history it's very strange
00:27:02 yes you're saying or it seemed that you were saying that the that basically the book the
00:27:07 diversity illusion this this the arguments in this are you know will seem very old-fashioned
00:27:14 in five years you said it maybe yeah maybe maybe because you know the argument's been lost already
00:27:18 so you know a generational thing but in the new book you do see chinks of light right yeah i don't
00:27:24 know if they're chinks alike or is that just you want to appear optimistic or what um i do think i
00:27:31 mean because there will always be a you know polls in in politics so whatever's the establishment
00:27:35 there'll be something against that and i think once uh once conservatism starts so conservatism
00:27:43 one of the key points of it is institutions right so we believe in institutions it's you know
00:27:48 monarchy is a great example the law courts parliament even bbc as much as we have our
00:27:53 disagreements with it these are all institutions and all the you know the little platoons all
00:27:57 these tiny things but once they become these institutions inherently dominated by progressives
00:28:02 as they almost all have then conservatism becomes sort of unraveled and it becomes a bit more
00:28:08 I suppose revolutionary and it becomes so all these a lot of the sort of Trump followers
00:28:14 both in his administration and his supporters are sort of anarchic really they want to sort of
00:28:20 blow things up a little bit they're radical conservatives and a lot of that makes me feel
00:28:25 uncomfortable we get a little I mean populism in the continent is is a bit like that and
00:28:30 I think that has a slightly nastier edge to it and it's a bit unconstrained that's the thing it's a
00:28:37 would you institutionalize so I do worry that what is going to come in in succession on the
00:28:43 rights to you know mainstream conservatism would you therefore class someone like Dominic Cummings
00:28:47 as being in that category I mean he's not by you know he doesn't like institutions he wants to
00:28:52 change them more you know but he he's on the right is he I mean he's I think he's essentially right
00:28:59 isn't he I would say his his analysis of institutions I mean he wants to shake them up
00:29:05 and he wants to I get the impression he wants to sort of you know do the march
00:29:11 to the institutions but backwards right so and no one's ever really tried this
00:29:15 we've had 10 years in of Tory MPs in Downey Street and I mean there's always
00:29:20 no institutions or department which is not overwhelmingly dominated by non
00:29:24 conservatives I mentioned I but they've you know you know how many conservatives
00:29:28 were appointed to panels or organization I think of Roger Scruton they sacked him
00:29:32 after like a hatchet job yeah like in comparison all these bodies are entirely dominated by sort
00:29:39 of labor supporting appointees and i just think maybe i think dominic cummings is a sign of
00:29:45 in the future maybe people on the right say well we should do that as well and uh you know i hesitate
00:29:50 to think it's a good idea because i think it's just going to get really it could get a bit nasty
00:29:54 the whole thing but then if one side of you know a political debate are doing something the other
00:29:59 side are inevitably going to do it aren't they i suppose one way would be to build your own
00:30:03 institutions right so that's yeah so that's one thing that's happening in the states yes with
00:30:08 some of the universities they're building their own i mean the problem is we already have that
00:30:12 with a sort of example of that in the media in the states and it's just not a very uh not very
00:30:19 attractive prospects of a fox news dominated i mean this is why i'm very skeptical the idea even
00:30:24 privatizing or defunding the BBC because I just think what replaces it will be more like CNN
00:30:30 which is much more politically repellent I think the BBC has quite a lot of controls in it I mean
00:30:36 it's inevitably going to be quite centre-left because that's the establishment voice and the
00:30:40 BBC is always the establishment voice but it does have control does try to be restrained while I
00:30:45 think a private version of BBC would just be it would just be basically catering to the self-regard
00:30:50 of you know the sort of metropolitan urban educated people just the way cnn does and it's just
00:30:57 although the prop the need to keep going without a license fee could change that i mean you know
00:31:04 this is the whole point if you don't if you get rid of the license fee then you're not protected
00:31:08 yeah i mean they can easily they're like easily i reckon amongst young people 30 or 40 percent
00:31:14 the population who would ingest like buzzfeed style garbage on their television and so you
00:31:20 just have that instead and then probably really like a fox news equivalent i think that might be
00:31:26 your dislike of fox might be the gentleness of conservatism right yeah so this is again
00:31:31 where i think of myself a small man on the wrong side of history because i think of that gentleness
00:31:36 and conservatism might be like obsolete it might it might not function anymore that kind of old you
00:31:41 just act like we're in a club
00:31:45 I think that might be on the way out
00:31:46 Well I should say
00:31:48 before we sign off, the book
00:31:50 it's actually very amusing
00:31:53 and it's not full of doom
00:31:54 is it? No, no, it's fine
00:31:55 We shouldn't be doom laden
00:31:58 Small Men on the Wrong Side of History
00:32:00 again, this is it, you can get it on
00:32:02 Amazon and
00:32:04 it's a great read, I'm sure it will resonate
00:32:07 with many of you watching
00:32:08 Thank you very much for coming in
00:32:11 Thanks very much. That's it for now. Please do, as I always say every week, please do subscribe, won't you?
00:32:17 And we'll see you next time. Thank you. Bye.