New Culture Forum - May 22, 2020


A New Cold War? What has Covid-19 revealed about China, China-West relations & Globalisation?

Ed West - Why Conservatives Have Lost Almost Every Political Argument Since 1945 Dominic Frisby Daylight Robbery -- How Tax Shaped Our Past & Will Change Our Future

Episode Stats


Length

39 minutes

Words per minute

144.2

Word count

5,754

Sentence count

118


Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
00:00:00 Hello and welcome to Counterculture. Now here we are in months number two of this lockdown and the
00:00:15 crisis seems to be going on interminably. Of course one thing is for sure the ramifications
00:00:22 of the Covid-19 crisis are going to go on for many many months and certainly years. What does
00:00:29 this mean first of all for our relationship and our attitude to China
00:00:33 and more generally what would it mean as well for the whole idea of globalization
00:00:39 both in practice and in theory now Civitas think tank has just produced a
00:00:46 new report called the year of the bat globalization China and the coronavirus
00:00:53 crisis. And I'm delighted that today I'm joined by the two authors of that report. That's Dr.
00:01:00 Neil McRae and Professor Michael Rainsborough. And here in the studio, Rafe Haidle-Mancouve,
00:01:08 the New Culture Forum, the historian and commentator, who I should add, by the way,
00:01:13 had a rather nasty accident, broke his ankle a few weeks ago. But as you all know, because you
00:01:20 tell by the comments that you send in he's been with us thank you very much for doing that being
00:01:25 so so heroic and coming in Rafe can I ask start by asking you a very particular question to get
00:01:32 the ball rolling gentlemen in your report there was a one fact that sort of hit me which was that
00:01:39 that 80 per cent of the world's pharmaceuticals are produced in China.
00:01:48 How did we arrive at that situation?
00:01:52 Michael.
00:01:53 We have a question to ask, and that's one of the central issues which we point to in
00:02:03 terms of how globalization has got us into this state that we find ourselves in so reliant on
00:02:11 china for our some of our fundamental medical supplies and medical needs how did it get to
00:02:17 this um it's probably a long story which you'll um get into some later um but um i think the
00:02:24 shortened version is really that um as a result of um what we call globalization um particularly
00:02:32 in its economic manifestation which um saw uh the evolution of a um of um rapid economic um
00:02:43 transactions um a world of hyper connectivity particularly in terms of
00:02:48 the movement of capital and labor all of which technology has facilitated but um that's what
00:02:55 that produced was was an economic system where it became very easy for multinational companies
00:03:05 facilitated of course by the global governing elites were able to outsource their manufacturing
00:03:14 capacities to China which of course is a repository of very cheap labor thereby maximizing the profits
00:03:24 of multinational companies but also as a result of allowing China to participate
00:03:32 on equal trading terms and in some ways preferential trading terms within the
00:03:36 WTO which to which China was admitted in 2002 it allowed Chinese companies to compete also and
00:03:45 that in itself has also led to the rise of Chinese corporations which have been competing
00:03:54 quite ruthlessly on the world stage and which also managed to suck in a lot of labor and capital into
00:04:01 china um i think it might be worthwhile at the moment maybe uh neil you could help us here
00:04:08 we've lived with this term globalization for a very long time and i think that people actually
00:04:13 it would be useful to spell out what was if you like the theory behind it what was it actually
00:04:18 about because one thing that i think is interesting from your report the civitas report is that you
00:04:24 talk about it theoretically and you know almost for almost from a sort of slightly from a left
00:04:29 wing point of view and then there's the economic one can you just explain that to us sir neil
00:04:35 i think globalization is something which has been very much pushed by the progressive liberal
00:04:44 middle-class establishments in the west these are people who are ashamed of their own
00:04:51 countries to be quite frank i mean look at their attitudes towards people with patriotic
00:04:58 traditional attitudes so they would prefer a post-nation order where countries and democratic
00:05:11 systems no longer have any real power now i think if you look at the world health organization which
00:05:20 we mentioned quite a lot in our report i think that demonstrates globalist ideology and its folly
00:05:29 so if you look at tedros of the leader chief of the world health organization from the western
00:05:36 liberal perspective he's the ideal person to head the organization he's African with first-hand
00:05:46 knowledge of third world problems and he fits a decolonization agenda now from China's perspective
00:05:54 he's even better Tedros owes his position to Beijing and the support of its client states
00:06:02 across Africa. But he's compromised by corruption in Ethiopia, where Tedros was known to have
00:06:09 covered up outbreaks in Poland. Now he's dependent on China, so he keeps his authority only as
00:06:17 long as he complies with the Chinese Communist Party line and parrots its propaganda. And
00:06:24 we saw this, of course, with his sycophantic speech when visiting President Xi back in
00:06:31 january now china knows that liberals in the west that the political establishments in the west
00:06:40 won't criticize their man because of their obsessive sensitivity about racism and this
00:06:47 is the card that the regime in beijing plays at every opportunity so this in short is globalization
00:06:56 the west in practice ceding control to china i see i mean is that would you go along with that
00:07:06 i mean do you think what seems to me is that china has sort of come if you like into prominence
00:07:14 now because of this but this has been going on for a very long time i mean the dominance of china
00:07:19 absolutely it's a process which for the last 30 years we in the west have been fooling ourselves
00:07:25 into thinking that by allowing China to access to our markets and into the WTO,
00:07:30 that China would naturally liberalise itself, whereas certainly it's been the contrary.
00:07:35 And China has actually more or less fulfilled its strategy,
00:07:40 which has been stated many times to be global domination by 2049.
00:07:45 It's the next 30 years, really, that really matter,
00:07:48 because what we've seen, really, is China's strategy has always been
00:07:51 to try to firstly preserve the regime.
00:07:53 It's a one-party state.
00:07:55 You know, communism is not necessarily the ideology of ideologies, as we've seen with the opening up to the market economy.
00:08:01 It's more a question of preserving the regime, trying to ensure that it's master of Asia first,
00:08:07 but then reorienting Eurasia away from the Atlantic and America onto its own axis.
00:08:11 We've seen that with the one belt, one road policy.
00:08:14 And so certainly what we're seeing right now is China fulfilling its grand strategy.
00:08:18 And its grand strategy is basically to take command over two things, really.
00:08:23 One is to take command over big data, and so you're seeing that through its use of 5G networks around the world,
00:08:29 and also really to ensure that it has a hold over all those countries which America currently regards as being in its purview.
00:08:37 And it's up to the West now, really, to try to offer up a solution in terms of trying to get places like Australia and South Korea and Taiwan to act as a containment buffer zone,
00:08:48 because really we're entering into a period of Cold War. It's the second Cold War we're having now with China.
00:08:52 and yet we in the West have been too naive to realise that.
00:08:55 People in China are fully aware that we're in a Cold War
00:08:57 but only people such as Trump have been alert to this
00:09:00 and it's taken the coronavirus to actually awaken people
00:09:04 to the reality of what China is like in terms of its deceit,
00:09:07 its lies, the way that it's infiltrated the WHO and so forth.
00:09:12 So I'd like to just take up one point there actually
00:09:15 because you mentioned there something called Belt and Road policy, Rafe.
00:09:19 this is something which you know frankly I you know I did not know about until it came up in
00:09:25 the Italian context you know which you go into in the book can you explain gentlemen can you
00:09:29 explain one of you quite what this is this Belt and Road policy that China offers
00:09:34 Neil do you want to take that off well Belt and Road is really the means for Chinese
00:09:47 state imperialism. Now, China is very keen to deny that it has any imperial aims. China likes to
00:10:01 differentiate itself from the colonial past of the Western powers. But there's no doubt that
00:10:10 the Belt and Road Initiative, which is about China investing in infrastructure projects in
00:10:15 countries around the world it's near what it what what actually do they offer what is it do they
00:10:20 they what they build build roads they build viaducts what do they do well they build roads
00:10:25 they build bridges schools um all kinds of um uh fabric of uh society which poorer countries
00:10:36 struggle to afford and uh china gives it its engineers and its expertise and its money and
00:10:49 of course it wants that money paid back and countries all across africa central america
00:10:57 even italy are in hock to china because they they participated in this belt and road initiative
00:11:05 and now they're realizing it's like a much grander scale version of the the the public
00:11:12 finance initiative that built hospitals under tony player it's like that multiplied many times over
00:11:19 what was the actual situation uh because you know italy was particularly badly hit wasn't it but
00:11:26 this this was something to do with the belt and roads policy wasn't it in fact there was a kind
00:11:31 of reciprocal arrangement wasn't there that what what meant that originally is that many thousands
00:11:37 of chinese workers came to this particular part of it italy isn't that the case that's right and
00:11:41 basically what we're seeing is china is trying to raise basically divide and rule it's an it's an
00:11:46 age-old it's an age-old concept and certainly you know for example we saw during the coronavirus
00:11:51 crisis when uh italy pled for uh for for a ppe from the rest of europe and it wasn't forthcoming
00:11:57 china then stepped in to show that it was the great benevolent power able to supply things
00:12:01 that europe wouldn't and it's this idea really to try to show itself as an alternative because it
00:12:07 wants to basically put forward an alternative world order to the current world order you know
00:12:11 for 200 years we've had the benefits of britain in the 19th century and then america in the 20th
00:12:15 century creating a global world order based upon the rights of man and democracy and so forth
00:12:20 but this is china trying to show how it can be an alternative and a successful one and it's
00:12:25 basically using trade it's using foreign aid it's using investment and infrastructure and it's also
00:12:31 taking advantage of the mistakes of the west to try to to bulwark itself and and put itself onto
00:12:36 that pedestal and and italy during the coronavirus was just one example of that so it's up to us to
00:12:41 actually shine a light onto this because for too long um we've basically been too scared to call
00:12:47 china out china's very good at what it calls wolf diplomacy the ability of it to basically
00:12:53 bully other countries into accusations of racism or xenophobia if there's any accusation about
00:12:59 chinese corruption or china being in any way involved in nefarious activities and so it's
00:13:03 time for us to actually devise a united strategy to confront this uh on that point actually yes
00:13:09 sorry yeah sorry um yeah just to sort of pick up on those strands which uh neil and rafe have um
00:13:18 made um just to hopefully just put this into context and to relate it um a little to your
00:13:24 previous question um you know how we got here and uh how the west has um yielded its yielded
00:13:32 its uh pre-eminence to china um in such a complacent manner globalization is really two
00:13:39 two things one is a kind of a tangible manifestation of um of a sort of um technological
00:13:49 reality um and economic reality um you know we have free trade we have ease of travel we have
00:13:56 um the realities of uh the worldwide web all of which enhances global um connectivity and
00:14:05 these are things which we can see all around us and probably won't change all that much necessarily
00:14:12 and maybe these are things which most of us particularly in relation to free trade and ease
00:14:17 of ease of travel we don't necessarily want to give up but the second component of globalization
00:14:23 is the ideological political interpretations which are overlaid that so because people
00:14:31 commentators think that the world is embarked on a process whereby you have this greater economic
00:14:39 connectivity, free movement of labour and capital. The political
00:14:45 interpretations overlaid that by a lot of commentators, particularly after the end of the
00:14:51 Cold War, were that the world was embarked on this road to a kind of harmonious convergence
00:14:58 where we would all end up as um well in the world in the world of francis fukuyama who was one of
00:15:04 the first entrants in this debate would have it we embarked on um a liberal end of history and that
00:15:11 as a result of the yeah debates of the ideological rivalries of uh rivals of um you know the communist
00:15:19 soviet union and of course the earlier defeat of fascism um that somehow we were all embarked on in
00:15:26 towards the single endpoint and that that china would actually be part of that um part of that
00:15:32 process and that we are embarked on a sort of post-ideological um world as someone like tony
00:15:39 blair would have it but as rafe has quite rightly said um the chinese communist party has um
00:15:46 completely different ideas and looks at that sort of rather fuzzy-minded um vacuous cosmopolitan idea
00:15:55 as something to be ruthlessly exploited not to be part of it's interesting uh you you you you
00:16:02 mentioned the the naivety uh i think rave mentioned earlier as well some countries are sort of waking
00:16:09 up um neil um you've written in the reporter about australia can you tell us sort of quite what what
00:16:16 they've been doing there in relation to china chinese influence well it was the australians
00:16:23 that many people in the West, certainly in the Northern Hemisphere, drew our attention to what
00:16:31 China was really up to. Now in Australia and New Zealand for a long time they've had a large
00:16:40 scale immigration from China and the Far East in both of those countries and there was nothing
00:16:48 particularly bad about that at all, and it was all celebrated, as the West tends to do, as
00:16:57 multiculturalism. But what we've seen in the last 15 years or so, certainly this has got worse
00:17:07 under President Xi, is that Chinese people who move abroad are expected to act as foot soldiers
00:17:18 or Chinese communist propaganda. Now that's quite different from the Chinese diaspora
00:17:26 of the past, many of whom would be quite critical of China's recent past under Chairman Mao, and of
00:17:33 course Chairman Mao was a mass murderer who ran a very very oppressive regime, and then there was
00:17:41 a sort of liberalization from the late 1970s onwards and Chinese people generally felt
00:17:47 reasonably free to talk about their country in both positive and a negative light.
00:17:55 But what's been imposed on Chinese people now by President Xi, both in China and Chinese
00:18:04 people who move abroad is that they must stay loyal to the regime now you might think what
00:18:12 sort of power can beijing have over a student in canberra now i say canberra because that's where
00:18:20 professor clive hamilton um is based and that was where he wrote his book silent invasion which is
00:18:27 is about the bullying of Chinese people abroad by Beijing.
00:18:34 Now, you think, what sort of power do they have?
00:18:36 Well, most Chinese people in Australia or indeed anywhere else in the world,
00:18:42 they have family.
00:18:44 They have family members back in China.
00:18:47 And the regime has shown that it's quite willing.
00:18:51 If it can't directly punish somebody abroad,
00:18:54 they will punish that person's family.
00:18:56 And so these sort of bullying tactics have been going on for quite a while now.
00:19:03 And it was Professor Clive Hamilton that drew the world's attention to this.
00:19:08 In Australia, they used to be very like they are still in Britain, a very naive, as Rafe said, very naive kind of view about China.
00:19:17 But now Australia has woken up to Chinese state interference in its democracy, in its attempt to stifle freedom of speech in Australia and all kinds of things that it's doing, which are actually quite corrupt.
00:19:36 So Australia has woken up to this now. And it's interesting how Australia was one of the first countries to demand an international inquiry into the COVID-19 crisis.
00:19:50 And of course, the Chinese have behaved in very typical fashion, threatening the Australians, threatening to spot all trade, threatening to bring their students back.
00:20:02 And that is the way that bullies behave.
00:20:06 Isn't it the case, too, you talk in your report about the, should we say, question mark over the very origins of the virus, you know, and this seems to be something which is, on the whole, not discussed until President Trump actually brought it up and said, you know, he has evidence.
00:20:28 This is sort of treated, isn't it, like an almost like some sort of conspiracy theory or rather there is an attempt to treat it in that way.
00:20:36 That's right.
00:20:36 And, of course, well, just to go back to Australia.
00:20:38 Australia is in a very precarious position.
00:20:40 It's a huge island with an immense amount of natural resources
00:20:44 and a very small population.
00:20:46 And its greatest ally, America, is much farther away than China is.
00:20:49 And so Australia now has finally wakened up to this.
00:20:52 But that mustn't, you know, distance mustn't let people in Europe
00:20:55 think that we're any less at risk than Australia is.
00:20:59 But certainly Australia needs to be backed up by the West, by Europe,
00:21:03 in calling for an investigation on this and it's embarrassment of China which is basically the
00:21:10 first tool I would say of our response and how we handle China is to say if you want to be a player
00:21:15 on the world stage you need to play by global standards and you've been very sloppy in your
00:21:20 handling of the coronavirus and it's shame that the Chinese really can't abide and Australia is
00:21:25 trying to stand up to China and it needs to have support from the West and from other European
00:21:29 countries in a concerted effort and one of those things is to have a full investigation
00:21:33 of what actually happened in wuhan province and without that investigation we can't progress and
00:21:39 china is digging its heels in but there needs to be a concerted united effort by the west to demand
00:21:44 an investigation and it's an opportunity for the who to redeem itself after its shoddy and
00:21:50 disreputable um antics of the last little while to actually be there to also call for this
00:21:55 investigation what do you think uh michael what do you think the chances of of the west taking
00:22:02 that approach raves just described there in other words being forthright about it and being you know
00:22:08 going to an extent on the defensive basically uh asking for some form of accounting from china
00:22:14 you know i think that if i remember one german newspaper built actually said there should be
00:22:19 reparations for this virus as it were i mean do you think that's feasible do you think they're
00:22:24 going to be take that seriously uh probably i would have thought i think the fact that
00:22:33 issues are being raised uh pressure is on china and not by governments i think
00:22:44 i think is a sign that people are rethinking the relationship between um the west and and china
00:22:52 now i think as you have had certain governments australia being one of them um the united states
00:22:59 also being the other and of course um uh the u.s presidency of donald trump has been on china's
00:23:04 case particularly in trade terms for for quite a number of years now um and um all of this is
00:23:11 establishing a kind of a momentum that may actually see china being put on the defensive i
00:23:18 I think it has already.
00:23:19 And I think it's the fact that it is resorting
00:23:21 to these rather sort of bullying tactics
00:23:24 is in itself a sign that it is feeling the heat a bit.
00:23:29 But it is, as Neil says, it is going to react in this way
00:23:34 because it has got away with that sort of action
00:23:39 in the past where it can browbeat some other nations
00:23:43 when it doesn't get its wonderful.
00:23:46 So I don't think that reparations is in any way
00:23:53 going to be a starter.
00:23:54 I think the Chinese state is simply
00:23:56 going to block all ideas of that.
00:24:00 I think it is going to continue to be obfuscatory on that.
00:24:06 I think it is going to be obstructive
00:24:09 about the origins of the virus, which, as you cited
00:24:13 in your question, we don't quite
00:24:15 know where the virus came from.
00:24:18 There seem to be emerging two plausible scenarios for that.
00:24:22 One was that it originated in the wet markets in Wuhan.
00:24:27 But there is another potentially plausible idea
00:24:31 that it originated out of these experiments with bats
00:24:35 from the Wuhan Institute of Virology.
00:24:38 But here's the thing.
00:24:40 Because we are dealing with a secretive Chinese state,
00:24:44 we don't actually know and maybe we'll never know the actual truth of this but what all of these
00:24:52 questions do i think or at least i hope will supplant in the minds of people is that china
00:24:59 is not our friend you know not our friend as in a friend of the liberal democratic west
00:25:05 and if more people are waking up to that point then i think that is a good thing because in the
00:25:12 end to preserve a liberal world order you need strong liberal states. You don't need
00:25:20 multinational institutions which are capable of being manipulated by authoritarian regimes like
00:25:27 China. I think also one particular part of this sort of, well you could call it infiltration if
00:25:32 you like, is the extraordinary influence that China has managed to get in universities in the West.
00:25:38 And I think, as well, you mentioned in the report, Neil, about, I think, Jesus College, isn't it, in Cambridge, has a China centre, which is sort of, you know, I think Charles Moore wrote about this, which is extraordinary.
00:25:52 You know, if it was said about any other country, it's extraordinary. It's just sort of lionising China and lionising what's happening.
00:25:59 How do we actually sort of, how do we curtail the influence that China buys in this way, you know, in our institutions, Rafe?
00:26:10 Well, the problem is that this, becoming in China, which nearly all of our universities are, certainly the leading universities, Russell Group, they're all very, very active in collaborations with Chinese universities.
00:26:34 And this is all related to two key things.
00:26:41 One is that money, there's a steady flow of full fee-paying Chinese students.
00:26:50 And secondly, there is the globalist progressive mindset of university administrators.
00:27:00 These university administrators are exactly the sort of people who I was talking about earlier, who are a post-nation mentality.
00:27:14 They are embarrassed by tradition, by provincial, patriotic kind of view.
00:27:24 They don't consider themselves to be British universities.
00:27:30 And that is a crucial point. They would rather have their universities filled by foreign students, including Chinese, than have to edge have to provide higher education to the working class.
00:27:49 I think there is a lot of this is pure snobbery. We're above being a British university. Now, this is quite obvious, quite evident. If you look at the intranet outpourings of any university, the stuff that staff and students are bombarded with every day.
00:28:13 Now, universities are needing to rapidly and urgently reassess their relationships with Chinese institutions because, let's face it, they're not really dealing with an independent Chinese university.
00:28:33 All universities, just as the major commercial enterprises of China, are arm's length under the control of the Chinese government.
00:28:46 And the Chinese government has made it quite clear, and we quoted this in the Year of the Batch report, there was a leaked document from the Communist Party meeting that said that China must not allow or encourage any sense of Western liberal democratic ideas to flourish.
00:29:13 China has its own way
00:29:16 and that is
00:29:17 well it's basically
00:29:19 they'll call it this of course but basically
00:29:21 it's a totalitarian
00:29:23 authoritarian surveillance
00:29:26 state. That is
00:29:28 what our universities
00:29:29 are dealing with
00:29:32 they are dealing with
00:29:33 a brutal regime that persecutes
00:29:36 its minorities
00:29:37 that bullies
00:29:39 other countries particularly poor
00:29:42 countries and it produces cheap goods well that's great isn't it we all enjoy cheap goods but those
00:29:50 cheap goods are produced in sweatshops and some of them quite likely are produced in forced labour
00:29:58 camps now why aren't universities taking an interest in the provenance of china and chinese
00:30:08 products and Chinese trade. Why are they not making an issue about well-known abuses of human
00:30:18 rights in China, such as organ harvesting from Falun Gong practitioners and from the Uyghur Muslims?
00:30:26 Why not? That's a question that I can't answer, but it's a question that needs to be asked.
00:30:33 It's all the more remarkable given how hypersensitive universities are now
00:30:37 in this era of wokeness where you know there will be a huge protest if somebody wears a sombrero
00:30:42 and yet there's a remarkable silence when it comes to things like female genital mutilation
00:30:46 or indeed the atrocities that you're seeing in china not to mention the concentration camps
00:30:51 there you know with three million people you know muslims in china who are interred there
00:30:56 on the one hand you could say that providing access to chinese students in the west provides
00:31:00 them an opportunity to see freedom and democracy in action and to actually experience what life
00:31:05 is like under a free under a free government uh but at the same time you have to understand how
00:31:10 many of those people who are coming over are here to engage in industrial espionage people forget
00:31:15 actually that this is part and parcel of the chinese policy is to infiltrate itself and
00:31:20 embed itself within within western societies and learn and learn the secrets of science and so
00:31:24 forth so one of the things that could be done you know universities need to have um the income of
00:31:30 foreign students to stay afloat these days but if you're going to have that at least have some sort
00:31:34 of checks in terms of what sort of access you're providing to overseas students when it comes to
00:31:39 sensitive information and then of course there's another area of the confucius institutes which
00:31:43 are intended to act like a benign version of the british council they're attached to british
00:31:47 universities but in fact there's all sorts of evidence that these are actually cells
00:31:52 working for the chinese government you you make various uh recommendations in the report uh michael
00:32:00 uh neil uh can you what are the what are the sort of chief ones what what actually do you think
00:32:07 should happen apart from our change of attitude apart from a change of attitude yeah um so
00:32:15 change of attitude is um and we can talk about that for sure um i think in terms of pragmatic
00:32:23 policy responses, it would be things like we need to, and by we I mean, I'm probably saying
00:32:32 the British policy making circles in particular, need to absorb the idea that China is first and
00:32:39 foremost not a friendly power and should be treated as a rival power, not Britain's best
00:32:50 partner in the West, as George Osborne once phrased it. That should entail a re-evaluation
00:32:56 of things like the agreement to allow Huawei to participate in the building of the 5G network,
00:33:06 which should lead to, I'd suggest, deepening, trying to deepen relationships between the UK
00:33:11 and more China-sceptive powers, particularly in East and Southeast Asia. I think we should also
00:33:18 consider lessons from the Australian example where Australia introduced counter-interference
00:33:28 laws in order to counteract the influence peddling of places like China, which compels
00:33:40 public officials and institutions to disclose their funding and their foreign links. So
00:33:47 So it would be those sorts of things that I'd suggest that we could take on board,
00:33:53 as well as the broader points about the general idea that we should realise
00:34:00 that the world is one, not of this idea that we're all engaged on this process
00:34:10 of this multicultural Shangri-La, we're not embarked on any of that kind of thing.
00:34:17 that the international system is one of competing sovereign states where nations struggle for
00:34:21 survival and um that is that is the reality and it can't be changed and that sort of thinking
00:34:27 has actually been lost and it's been lost in some of the um some of the important um
00:34:34 aspects of government thinking well i think i think really we have to look at this really in
00:34:39 terms of a new cold war as i said before and if you think about it it was in 1946 that churchill
00:34:45 gave his Iron Curtain speech. Up to that point everybody thought of the Soviet Union in friendly
00:34:49 terms and we're at that sort of a stage now. People are beginning to awaken to the fact that
00:34:54 we're in the foothills really of what is going to be a very long-term strategy of containment
00:35:00 that we need to engage in to ensure that China doesn't exceed its current ambitions or fulfill
00:35:06 them in any way. And that means we need to have a decoupling of ourselves from China. There has to
00:35:11 be a concerted effort to ensure that our supply chains are put into strategically independent
00:35:17 areas where we aren't reliant on china things like battery technology and things you know china has
00:35:22 got all the lithium and all of these all these resources we need to ensure that we have abilities
00:35:27 to actually produce things on our own without reliance on china for any of that and there needs
00:35:32 to be a united effort by the west to ensure that china's ambitions in the area are stood up to now
00:35:40 rather than people continually kowtowing to to to its to its you know higher high echelons uh
00:35:47 yes really i just want to ask neil to finish actually uh you know carrying on from that point
00:35:54 you talk about the twilight of globalization in this report uh if we are in the twilight and
00:36:00 what actually would come briefly what would come after then if we if this is going if this is the
00:36:06 way we've lived for what 30 years now maybe is going to end what are we going to have a
00:36:12 protectionist world or what kind of what are we going to have this is all very difficult to predict
00:36:19 because i think what we found with covet 19 is that both sides of in the culture war have
00:36:28 try to use this or try to place this crisis as being a turning point in their favor and I'm not
00:36:37 sure that that will happen. I think that what we're more likely to get is more polarization.
00:36:44 Now I've been reading a lot of articles from what I see as the other side of the debate
00:36:53 over coronavirus and for example there was an article by Matthew Dancona, George Osborne's
00:37:02 buddy at the Evening Standard, arguing that it's not China that's the problem but it's
00:37:09 Tories who complain about China. There was an article in Atlantic magazine recently where the
00:37:16 writers urged the West to follow China in controlling speech and information and policing
00:37:23 the internet. Now, that, of course, is the road to serfdom. But my worry is that this is the way
00:37:31 a lot of younger people think, certainly middle class students who don't really value freedom
00:37:39 of speech. They don't really value democracy or equality before the law. They've abandoned
00:37:46 Enlightenment values, as have their universities. And I think that somehow or other we've got to
00:37:53 try and bring up a new generation that does appreciate Enlightenment values, that does
00:38:00 appreciate liberties. And I think there are some green shoots coming up that suggest that might
00:38:07 happen and i think if you look at the the the middle class woke sort of millennial generation
00:38:14 they think everything is going their way and will continue to go their way but i i think that it's
00:38:20 likely that another generation will come along and reject their nonsense you know uh this really uh
00:38:30 reminds me of president trump's speech in poland a few years ago i think probably the best speech
00:38:37 he's done where he was basically saying asking the question does the west have the will to survive
00:38:44 does does the west it all comes down to that you were talking there people you know believing in
00:38:50 enlightenment values it comes down to this doesn't it whether we actually think um that we should
00:38:55 survive i think that's the crucial point um can i ask you uh because we're turning off now how can
00:39:01 people read your report can they download it or is it in hard copies what should they do
00:39:09 michael i think yeah i i understand more information on this but um as far as i'm aware
00:39:17 um it is available for down download or it can be downloaded um and um hard copies are also
00:39:25 available um i imagine via the civitas uh website right okay yeah yeah i think civitas so basically
00:39:32 go to the civitas website and you can download the the report there so it's really worth while
00:39:38 reading very very important thank you very much rave thank you michael and thank you neil very
00:39:43 much uh that's uh that's counterculture for this week i hope you uh keep well and uh we look forward
00:39:51 to seeing you next time. Thank you very much.