New Culture Forum - May 23, 2020


Dominic Frisby Daylight Robbery -- How Tax Shaped Our Past & Will Change Our Future

A New Cold War? What has Covid-19 revealed about China, China-West relations & Globalisation? Why are Dissenting Views on Lockdown & How to Combat Coronavirus Marginalised in MSM & Social Media?

Episode Stats


Length

29 minutes

Words per minute

182.31

Word count

5,408

Sentence count

—


Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
00:00:00 Hello and welcome to So What You're Saying Is, I'm Peter Whittle. Now my guest today has managed
00:00:22 to combine a successful career as a stand-up comic with his expertise in economics and taxation
00:00:30 dominic frisbee has performed at the edinburgh festival he had a show there called let's talk
00:00:35 about tax he was also a columnist for money week and he's written a number of books on subject
00:00:43 most recently it is daylight robbery how tax shaped our past and will change our future
00:00:50 um dominic good morning to you um hi peter thanks very much for for joining us um i have to ask
00:00:58 it's a pretty uh how do you manage to make taxation funny i mean that's a real skill i
00:01:04 would have thought well i have to say of all the shows i've done peter this wasn't the funniest
00:01:09 um it was more it was a i had a sort of latin motto for it which was uh always interesting
00:01:18 occasionally amusing right so the but the it's such a big and interesting subject i was convinced
00:01:26 back in the late noughties and early part of this decade that if we were going to save the world
00:01:32 um from the large state and all the things that come with it we needed to reform our system of
00:01:38 money and everything hinged on that it's only our system of fiat money where governments can create
00:01:43 money and set interest rates and so on that gives them the control and the power that they do within
00:01:47 a society and if we're going to save ourselves we need independent money once upon a time once again
00:01:53 and um and i wrote one book about this life after the state and then while i was writing
00:01:58 writing that bitcoin was invented and that here was a new sort of technological solution and i'd
00:02:03 always been a big gold bug prior to that and then um in the years after i'd written bitcoin i was
00:02:10 thinking more and more about it and then i started thinking it's not just our system of money but
00:02:14 it's also our system of tax yeah and tax is the way that rulers taxes power is something i say in
00:02:22 the book and if you have a whether it's a government or a king or an emperor whatever
00:02:27 whoever the ruler is or whatever the ruler is if they lose their tax revenue they lose their power
00:02:33 it's it's not just that that tax is power tax is also how you shape a society um and you
00:02:40 you you know you determine the destiny of that society by the way you tax it whether it's people
00:02:47 will be prosperous or poor free or subordinated all these things are determined by our system of
00:02:53 tax and i just started reading reading reading more about the history of tax and this it's
00:02:58 surprisingly little is like tax is sort of like a subset of economics yes um at university it's
00:03:03 not a subject in itself but when you start thinking about the fact that you know there has never been
00:03:10 a society without taxation of some kind the very first taxes were levied in ancient mesopotamia
00:03:16 of course we didn't pay with cash or money like we do now tax was you know a share of your produce
00:03:21 or a share of your labor but even so there still um existed this sense of tax and probably there
00:03:26 was this idea of a sense of duty to the greater collective even in the hunter-gatherer societies
00:03:31 that preceded civilization and then you can start you going through history and you you suddenly
00:03:36 realized that almost every great event in history has behind it there is some kind of tax story
00:03:43 without which that event would have unfolded in a very different way and so every war is funded by
00:03:50 some kind of tax either during or after the in after the event every um revolution is usually
00:03:57 some kind of uprising against some kind of injustice perpetrated by the tax system every
00:04:02 rebellion every revolt every um uh um every conquest is about taking control of the tax base
00:04:11 the land the labor the produce the profits but even apparently unconnected events like you know
00:04:16 the birth of christ mary and joseph were only in bethlehem because augustus caesar was levying a
00:04:21 census or or he was according to which version of the story in st luke he was actually levying a tax
00:04:28 now mary and joseph wouldn't have been in bethlehem were it not for this tax and have
00:04:32 they not been in bethlehem christianity would never have evolved in the way that it did so
00:04:35 even at the birth of christ and at his death you know the the crime for which he was crucified was
00:04:40 forbidding to give tribute to caesar so at the birth and death of christ there's a tax story
00:04:45 there's also incredible tax stories at the birth of islam and at the birth of judaism as well and so
00:04:51 you know first men on the moon nasa was a tax-funded operation you and once you start
00:04:55 looking at the world through this prism of taxation suddenly why events happened in the
00:05:00 the way that they did and why things are as they are now and how things are going to be in the
00:05:04 future all becomes a lot clearer so that's why i sort of obsessed with the subject not that funny
00:05:10 but it's quite interesting um i think this perspective you know of looking at history
00:05:15 through taxation i mean it's fascinating but but where do you think the kind of uh distinction came
00:05:22 between left and right in the attitudes to taxation in the sense that you know in a way
00:05:28 what you're describing is a kind of collective responsibility isn't it um but there is this view
00:05:36 now that somehow you know if you're on the right you're anti you know you you tend to be anti
00:05:41 taxation or wanting to get it low on the left you know you're very very well pro-tax or you have
00:05:47 less of a problem with tax when did that kind of develop that that sort of distinction well
00:05:55 Well, there's been a battle throughout history between those who would pay tax and those who would who would collect it.
00:06:03 But I think what you're talking about is the sort of birth of, you know, until maybe the 20th century, taxes were used in the UK, you know, to pay for wars, to pay for a police force, to pay for the defense of the nation, basic order.
00:06:19 um and it was only really you know with i suppose the both birth of social democracy was 1911 the
00:06:27 national insurance act yeah david lloyd george and winston churchill and and but the national
00:06:33 insurance was basically copying the friendly societies because the friendly societies had
00:06:37 were and the church were responsible for delivering health care welfare education all these things
00:06:43 that are now delivered by government and they were so successful at the level they were operated
00:06:46 lloyd george and winston churchill were trying to copy them at a national level and so we had
00:06:51 national insurance but really i i see 1914 as the beginning of the time when things started to go
00:06:59 wrong right okay that makes sense the first world war and you know until the first world war there's
00:07:05 a famous passage at the beginning of ajp taylor's um book is you know an ordinary englishman barely
00:07:11 noticed the existence of the state in his life we didn't have passports for example
00:07:15 we could travel freely from country to country and it was within with and i see tax by the way
00:07:22 as as almost as a measure of freedom maggie that was famous for saying you can't have freedom
00:07:28 unless you have economic freedom and more taxed you are the less particularly with income tax
00:07:36 the less of your own labor you own and so you know at one sense you have you know one extreme
00:07:42 have anarchy where there's no taxes at all and everyone's free and they have total ownership of
00:07:47 their labor and then at the other extreme you have you know maybe a totalitarian state north
00:07:53 korea or something where none of your labor is owned and and none of your produce you could also
00:07:59 say in in in in a way that slavery is like the most extreme taxation of at all because you don't
00:08:06 own any of your own labor you don't own your own body you don't own anything so you know we could
00:08:11 hark back to you know ancient athens for example one of the most enlightened civilizations in
00:08:17 history where taxes were voluntary but they still had slaves yeah so they might have been so keen
00:08:23 on the tax system but anyway that's that's a sort of slightly separate argument but the birth of
00:08:27 this idea that we are paying taxes to uh pay for health care and welfare and education all these
00:08:35 things which the government provides not the church or the friendly society or any other
00:08:40 private body sort of started in in 1911 then it's like all these things they don't start on a date
00:08:47 it things evolve and and of course you know the birth of the welfare state after the second world
00:08:51 war um and what tends to happen with taxes and this is why it's kind of opposite to today and
00:08:57 and um in covert 19 in the coronavirus leaders find it very difficult to levy new taxes in times
00:09:07 of peace yeah and there's history is littered with examples of this the most recent famous example is
00:09:13 perhaps margaret thatcher's poll tax which actually brought her down and she was actually
00:09:18 introduced the poll tax because she was trying to bring accountability to local councils but
00:09:22 unfortunately it wasn't the local councils that was held accountable it was her and and
00:09:28 politics brought her down and even things like you know george osborne's pasty tax or ed milliband's
00:09:34 mansion tax then you know they were ridiculed for them leaders find it difficult to levy new taxes
00:09:38 they often need some kind of crisis usually a war in which to levy them and so the first world war
00:09:45 brought income tax well it was actually the napoleonic wars that brought income tax to
00:09:50 every man in the uk but then it sort of disappeared it was only the highest um earners that paid
00:09:55 income tax the first world war brought income tax to every man in the uk and also not just
00:10:00 tax itself at higher levels higher rates of tax and here's a beautiful tax story for you because
00:10:10 many women joined the workforce in world war one and then started paying taxes this was a major
00:10:17 justification in the argument to their being given the vote so there's even a tax story behind
00:10:23 universal suffrage uh simon herford said uh to us recently that in fact the state as we understand
00:10:31 it you could pretty much see its origins in the first world war um and the point is i know it's
00:10:38 a cliche um but you know taxis never disappear do they after that i mean you know it's they they are
00:10:46 only ever going to increase um this is what happens they they get implemented with the crisis
00:10:53 yeah and then after the crisis has passed they never go back to the levels they were before the
00:10:57 crisis began they come back a little bit but they never go back to where they were world war ii
00:11:02 ordinary americans didn't pay income tax until 1942 the revenue act of 1942 you know broad income
00:11:09 tax to ordinary americans and they've been paying it ever since yes and even the financial crisis of
00:11:14 2008 you know gave us zero interest rate policies and quantitative easing and all these things
00:11:20 which are just a stealth tax they're just another form of taxation another form of of wealth it's
00:11:24 extraction passing you know it's not an official tax but the the effect is the same how can you
00:11:30 can you explain that a bit more please dominic you know when you say that something like quantitative
00:11:35 easing is a stealth tax i mean can you explain how how that's so because the more money that
00:11:41 the government prints the value of the money that's in your pocket is debased so effectively
00:11:45 the value of the money that's in your pocket some of that value is transferred to the state but
00:11:50 it's diluted right and the money was printed to you know whatever was useful to bail out banks
00:11:55 and so on but the thing is um with this is just uh it seems i was just thinking about this recently
00:12:00 it seems with we've had quantitative easing going on for a long time you know people are talking
00:12:04 about it for obvious reasons again now but it's going on but we don't seem to have had that
00:12:08 inflation no because um inflation isn't properly measured um if you look at money creation the word
00:12:17 inflation used to mean the inflation of them of the supply of money in other words the blowing up
00:12:23 the inflating of the money supply with the consequence of higher prices now that meaning
00:12:28 has been distorted over time so that inflation just comes to mean higher prices now if you look
00:12:33 at the how the bank of england measures inflation it only measures um the the prices of certain
00:12:39 consumer goods uh um which are prone to the deflationary forces of improved productivity
00:12:46 if you actually start to measure money supply and for every 100 pounds of new money that is created
00:12:53 only something about like about 13 13 pounds goes into the basket of goods that are measured by the
00:12:59 bank of england's measures of inflation and the federal reserve uses similar measures it doesn't
00:13:04 measure the money that goes into mortgages into into real estate in bond prices and and in all
00:13:10 the other areas where newly created money makes its way we just haven't seen that inflation in
00:13:15 the real economy but the consequence of this inflation has been this extraordinary wealth
00:13:21 divide that has emerged in the uk i mean it's always been pretty bad but it's been exacerbated
00:13:25 since 2008 not just the uk but america and europe and it's this you know there's lots of people
00:13:32 that have benefited tremendously from this money creation that's got on you know the financial
00:13:37 sector the the the london property market which mostly houses the financial sector same goes for
00:13:44 new york but the people who haven't benefited it are the people that are furthest away from the
00:13:48 issuance of new money this is a process called the kantion effect um where those furthest away
00:13:54 from the issuance of new money benefit least right now so this is this is why what we've seen since
00:14:01 2008 is is just a tax by another name it's a way of expropriating wealth it's it's the reason
00:14:07 bitcoin was invented you know because it wanted to create a system of money that you can't debase
00:14:13 and that can't be that you can't you know um extract through quantitative easing now what
00:14:19 worries me about COVID-19 and the and the state's reaction to COVID-19 is the money printing that's
00:14:28 gone on is extraordinary even by the standards of 2009 and it's like 2009 normalized money printing
00:14:36 and now it's just become it's like an accepted economic policy but the consequence the the
00:14:42 debasement the the loss in the purchasing power of our money that it's going to lead to is
00:14:46 extraordinary. And this time, because so much of the newly printed money is making its way into
00:14:51 the real economy, you know, how many people are on this COVID break at the moment on 80% of their
00:14:57 salary just going, actually, do you know what, I'd rather this is my son is 19 years old, he's on his
00:15:02 year off, he's getting paid 80% of his salary to do nothing. He's going, do you know what, I'd rather
00:15:07 not go back to work and just be paid 80% of my salary. He does a bit of moonlighting, he makes
00:15:11 up the other 20 percent but it's just it this time it's making its way into the real economy
00:15:16 and and the the the we will see a tremendous loss in the purchasing power of fiat money in the years
00:15:23 ahead what in my opinion what i mean this is you know talking about the covid 19 i mean we've had
00:15:30 these reports out a one particular report this week talking about what we can possibly face a
00:15:36 contraction of the economy by 35 percent uh the you mentioned the napoleonic wars earlier this
00:15:43 apparently would be the biggest one since the napoleonic wars um this contraction i mean i
00:15:48 think it's even since 1709 right 1709 with a great freeze of 1709 that's right indeed um here we are
00:15:57 you know we we're going to have this extraordinary economic situation in i don't know three months
00:16:03 six months going on forward how will it affect taxation will our taxes all go up hugely that's
00:16:09 what most people want to know um i think it's going to be very difficult to uh raise taxes
00:16:20 raise income tax raise um you know vat all these kind of uh vat is about 20 of government revenue
00:16:28 i think i can't remember the exact number and income tax and national insurance accounts for
00:16:32 for about 50 percent of government revenue um i think we'll see a couple of things in the in the
00:16:38 wars you used to see windfall taxes or profits taxes on companies that had benefited a great
00:16:45 deal from the war you know munitions factories and this kind of thing it wouldn't surprise me
00:16:50 if we see some windfall taxes on those businesses that have made good as a result of this crisis
00:16:55 whether it's supermarkets amazon those kind of things so i think that's a possibility and you
00:17:01 know the there will be a lot of people who who are in favor of that but the
00:17:06 greatest area that the two big stealth taxes in our life are inflation and debt
00:17:14 debt is a tax on the future yeah and you know by golly have we not levied a lot
00:17:23 of debt now there are three ways that you can pay back debt you either pay
00:17:27 back the money or you pay back the money in in money that's lost its purchasing power or debt
00:17:34 jubilees and defaults and I think we'll see a sort of mixture of all three but the I can't see how
00:17:42 they actually put up rates except for the possibly for the very rich this idea of a land value tax
00:17:48 which by the way broadly speaking I'm in favor of might get a bit of traction now I'm in favor
00:17:55 a land value tax if it replaces other taxes but i'm unfortunately what i think we're likely to
00:17:59 see is a land value tax of some kind in addition to other taxes um the mansion tax that ed milliman
00:18:05 mentioned is a sort of bastardization of the of the of the land value tax um but i don't see how
00:18:12 they put up taxes except for those people that have made good as a result of this are you when
00:18:17 when we're talking about about the future we're talking about when when is it where the lockdown
00:18:24 ends you know when this when we move to the second stage of this situation which is what it will be
00:18:30 um i know that you describe yourself as obviously you're a libertarian uh you a believer in small
00:18:35 government uh that seems like an even further far off prospect now surely uh with what's happened
00:18:46 over the past few weeks and months there's been sort of a huge sort of entry of the state hasn't
00:18:52 that yes i'm afraid there has and you know i see brexit as and also in a way donald trump and all
00:19:01 those things that happened in the sort of 2016 to 2018 time frame as a sort of victory for those
00:19:07 who are in favor of smaller government and less intrusion you know most libertarian not all but
00:19:13 most libertarians i know were in favor of of of brexit um some there are i can think of a few
00:19:20 examples of people who weren't and so it's like the small government argument the the the i often
00:19:28 see this as a not such a battle between left and right as a battle between author to authoritarian
00:19:33 and and libertarian and the authoritarians you know are the technocrats and the bureaucrats and
00:19:39 the experts who keep telling you what to do and who know better than you and so on and so forth
00:19:43 um actually the sort of you know there's there's quite a strong libertarian sentiment on the left
00:19:48 I think Jeremy Corbyn, socially at least, is pretty libertarian, for example, even if he's not economically.
00:19:55 And I think that's why Brexit formed this weird alliance between the sort of libertarian left, the sort of Jeremy Corbyns,
00:20:02 if he'd actually admitted that he was a Brexit sympathiser and the Claire Foxes and Paul Embrys and people like that on the left.
00:20:08 And then on the right, the sort of Jacob Rees-Mogg's and Steve Bakers and these kind of people.
00:20:13 there was this weird kind of you know the old school benite left and the sort of old school
00:20:18 thatcherite right was weirdly aligned over brexit and it was the sort of right middle but you stood
00:20:24 didn't you yourself dominic uh as a brexit party candidate don't you well it was very big i wanted
00:20:31 to be an mep but they didn't want to they thought it would be a bit bold to have a comedian as an
00:20:35 mep this early the brexit party's evolution so i said i'll stick me down as an mp but then when
00:20:41 the time came to be an mp i just took so you know i was doing edinburgh at the time and people were
00:20:46 writing horrible things on my posters and my daughter was reading them and just wasn't worth
00:20:49 the aggro basically right um but the um but yes so so the so even though that sort of libertarian
00:21:02 small government um side of things perhaps won the argument we've like almost lost or won the
00:21:09 battle we've kind of losing the war now because we're just seeing as a result of covid this huge
00:21:14 land grab by by the state by people who know better than you and and it's it's like and and
00:21:23 nobody's very few people are fighting back against it and i quite frankly i don't quite know what to
00:21:26 do about it but you know as a result of covid government is going to play a much bigger role
00:21:32 in our lives even bigger role lives than it previously did and you know one measure of this
00:21:37 is you know how much what percentage of gdp is government and the uk is somewhere 40 to 45
00:21:43 percent maybe you know it depends how you measure it the us is probably a little bit below uh 40
00:21:47 percent you know somewhere like um uh france is like 56 you know on the wrong side of 50 and
00:21:55 soviet russia which is you know pretty totalitarian was only about 75 government was
00:22:00 only about 75 percent of gdp there were still black markets and things like that but you know
00:22:05 I find it very difficult to see how as a result of this COVID, certainly by the time you factor
00:22:10 in inflation and debt, government is less than 50% of GDP. So it's going to occupy a much greater
00:22:16 part of our lives. Why do you think it seems that, you know, I'm talking very broadly here on it,
00:22:22 but even people like Reagan, for example, who came in great believers in the small state,
00:22:27 and by implication lower tax um somehow the state always did seem to expand anyway i believe that
00:22:36 actually under the republicans in the 1980s it it just got bigger anyway it did under thatcher yeah
00:22:42 um it's i i think the problem is fiat money yeah it the like there's no discipline in government
00:22:51 spending when government can print the money it needs or manipulate interest rates or you know
00:22:56 get into endless cycles of debt just there isn't that same discipline that there is under a
00:23:01 under a system of money that that is independent and that governments can't print and debase
00:23:05 i think so until we change our system of money that's going to keep on going um it's a pretty
00:23:11 basic uh uh question really for someone who with your expertise in this area but um do you think
00:23:18 that the the argument has sort of been one where whereby people now realize that there is no such
00:23:24 thing as it were as government money that it is actually tax taxpayers money i mean for a long
00:23:31 time people sort of thought oh well no the government will pay you actually sort of have
00:23:36 to sort of make clear that in fact this is actually money coming from tax or when you're not talking
00:23:41 about uh admittedly not talking about um borrowing here but we're talking about tax money do you
00:23:47 think people now understand that more than maybe once they did that this is actually no no no i
00:23:54 don't think they do and i mean there's actually one school of thought that believes that the
00:23:58 government spends and then it taxes after it spends just you know this this you know richard
00:24:02 murphy's left-wing economist argues that and there's you know there's there's some justification
00:24:07 for that but the what you get that the big argument for high tax states and they go look
00:24:14 at scandinavia but what you have in scandinavia you don't have in the uk is that far greater
00:24:19 levels of taxation are levied locally right and the money is then spent locally so in so as a
00:24:26 result there's much greater accountability and taxpayers actually see where their money is spent
00:24:31 and are better able to hold those who spend their money to account than they are um with a centralized
00:24:37 system like you have in the uk that's that's why the scandinavian model works so well because
00:24:42 there's far greater accountability because things are done more locally there's various other
00:24:47 reasons why it works well as well just because they're smaller countries so tax smaller countries
00:24:52 tend to be more efficient you know the smaller the size of the organization the more the more
00:24:56 efficient it tends to be so even things like their health services will be more efficient than ours
00:25:00 simply because of the scale but yes like the and this is one of the reasons i argue for land value
00:25:09 taxes it it makes the relationship between how much you are taxed and how much the government
00:25:14 spends much more transparent and there's much more less scope for stealth taxes and and all
00:25:21 the government spending that goes on for which they're not held accountable um for yourself
00:25:28 personally i mean you obviously you you know you you're a comedian um do you see that sort of career
00:25:35 going on or are you going to sort of concentrate much more on this side of things or or say as you
00:25:43 are uh well i'm kind of going to say as i am because this the sad state of affairs peter for
00:25:50 me is that like covid19 has killed comedy like every single comedian has basically just on
00:25:57 whatever date the lockdown came i think was a tuesday yeah i forget the date but maybe say
00:26:02 march the 30th whatever date it was comedy just stopped and all those guys particularly the guys
00:26:07 a lot of comedians live hand to mouth and their income just dried up and we don't know how long
00:26:12 comedy is going to be over for now laughter is a basic human function same as eating or breathing
00:26:18 or or you know drinking we need to laugh but live comedy has just died a total death but i'll carry
00:26:25 on going and making my songs and so on but with the exception of 17 million f-offs which is very
00:26:31 popular if i post a video on youtube of me talking about the housing market or something like that
00:26:38 um it tends to get many more views than me singing one of my comic songs brilliant though i think my
00:26:44 comic songs are so i think there might be more demand the market might ultimately decide that
00:26:50 there's more demand for my financial stuff than there is for my comic stuff but for the time being
00:26:54 i'm going to carry on doing both because um i really think i'm onto something with my songs
00:26:59 and i've written some belters and there's more there's more to come but making one of those
00:27:03 videos it's it's it's a big undertaking you know i've got a i've got a i work with a friend we
00:27:09 compose the music together then we've got to go into the studio record the song yes usually there's
00:27:13 a chewing and throwing while we re-record it then i've got another get another guy in to film the
00:27:17 video then we've got to edit the video it's a big undertaking they usually cost me quite a lot of
00:27:21 money and at the moment they're a big loss making exercise that i do for love but i do think i'm
00:27:27 on to something with them and and we'll wait and see what happens maybe one day i'll be playing
00:27:31 the o2 your book uh which is very you very kindly uh put the title behind you
00:27:40 it's a great cue card for me uh daylight robbery that is um that's available presumably on amazon
00:27:47 is it and uh yeah you can buy it on amazon or waterstones or any other yeah if you want to buy
00:27:54 a signed copy you can uh just email me dominic frisbee.com through the website there but the
00:28:00 bizarre thing is this is like how like penguin charge me a tenner to buy a copy of my own book
00:28:08 and then if i then send it out that cost me three pounds 55 so that's 13 pounds 55 before i've
00:28:14 actually made any money and amazon sell it for 12 quid so i've been done undercutting the author
00:28:22 so you know but anyway if you want to buy a signed copy i sell it for the full retail price and you
00:28:27 a part of my website but what i would recommend if you like audiobooks um i've spent my life doing
00:28:32 voiceovers i'm a pretty good reader and a lot of the audiobooks garnered a lot of praise so if you
00:28:38 like audiobooks buy the audiobook all right great oh very nice tip there yeah definitely to have it
00:28:43 read by the by the author um dominic look thank you so much for coming on and talking about it
00:28:48 um and the paperback as well will be out this year won't it well i think yeah it was supposed
00:28:54 out in the spring but it's all got delayed so i think it's out in the autumn in the autumn
00:28:57 there is a paperback that you can buy on amazon don't ask me how this is but it costs even more
00:29:02 than the hardback so the mysteries of amazon pricing maybe it's one of those sort of famous
00:29:08 airport editions they do now you know where they're big paperbacks anyway thank you very
00:29:13 very much normally and uh all the very best and i hope you keep well and keep safe and um yeah
00:29:19 and maybe see you again on the show quite soon i hope so thanks very much for watching
00:29:26 so what you're saying is and we will see you again next time thank you bye