New Culture Forum - May 29, 2020


Why are Dissenting Views on Lockdown & How to Combat Coronavirus Marginalised in MSM & Social Media?

Dominic Frisby Daylight Robbery -- How Tax Shaped Our Past & Will Change Our Future Mahyar Tousi - Conservative Social Media Commentator

Episode Stats


Length

45 minutes

Words per minute

196.27

Word count

9,028

Sentence count

98


Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
00:00:00 Hello and welcome to Counterculture. I'm Peter Whitfall. Now here we are in week 10 of this
00:00:14 lockdown. It's supposedly easing. But maybe you're one of those people who didn't even think that we
00:00:21 should have a lockdown in the first place. Maybe you thought we should go the way of Sweden. But
00:00:27 But if that is the case, and it's certainly true, it seems, that voices are increasingly
00:00:33 marginalised.
00:00:35 Voices that dissent on the current mainstream media line on the lockdown.
00:00:41 This is certainly the case when it comes to social media.
00:00:44 There's more and more of a sense, more and more instances of people being de-patformed
00:00:49 or possibly even censored for having dissenting views about the situation.
00:00:55 Now, we're going to be discussing this today, and I'm very pleased that with us we have
00:00:59 three guests. First of all, Tom Slater, who is deputy editor of Spiked Online. Zubi, the
00:01:07 rapper, the author, and host of a very successful podcast with a huge social media following.
00:01:15 And Rafe Hadel-Mancouf, the New Culture Forum, historian and commentator. Thank you very
00:01:21 much for joining us to talk about this we can't get away obviously from the
00:01:25 subject Tom I want to start with you if I could this week we heard something
00:01:32 from the Education Secretary Matt Hancock saying that basically being able
00:01:38 to hug somebody new I think was the inference was something that was going
00:01:44 to be increasingly a pipe dream what do you make of that I thought it was actually
00:01:51 ridiculous but i think it speaks a little bit to the ridiculous situation that we find ourselves in
00:01:56 and you know the fact that matt hancock has effectively become kind of like secretary of
00:01:59 state of human touch he made this announcement on the basis of you know who are you going to be
00:02:03 allowed to hug outside of your household he previously told couples who lived apart that
00:02:07 to make their choice and then stick to it in relation to either moving in together
00:02:11 or not seeing each other at all but i think all of this is just a consequence of this never-ending
00:02:16 lockdown it seems that we've entered into you know as you were saying we're 10 weeks into what was
00:02:20 originally supposed to be a three-week period to the end of protecting the nhs from being
00:02:25 overwhelmed that aim has been met and yet we're seeing no real signs of easing i think the matt
00:02:30 hancock thing is just the perfect example of how for whatever reason lockdown is being so clung to
00:02:35 by the by this government they're so terrified about easing up to it they've got so much invested
00:02:39 in it that they're even going out making ludicrous statements like you know it might be 18 months
00:02:43 before you're even allowed to hug a friend or acquaintance so i think it was it was a strange
00:02:47 example but it just gives you a little bit about the mad situation we find ourselves in
00:02:53 do you agree with that i mean it just appear now to be an extraordinary amount of confusion
00:02:59 at least amongst people i know what exactly is the situation are we even still in lockdown or what
00:03:05 is this is this something you you sort of sense yeah i think i think that what has happened is
00:03:12 we've reached this sort of period of inertia the longer that this lockdown goes on for the more
00:03:19 that people become emotionally invested in it politically invested in it um all of these things
00:03:25 the more that fear sets in and you're also having a lot of people who are sort of quite comfortable
00:03:30 with it right you have some people who have gone through terrible situations where they've lost
00:03:34 where of course you know people have lost family members and lost friends but you've also got
00:03:39 people who have lost jobs and are feeling pain in different ways. But on the flip side, you have a
00:03:44 lot of people who are, you know, still earning their income, and they're still employed. And
00:03:48 in fact, they get to work from home, and they don't need to commute, etc. So it's very easy
00:03:52 for people who are in that situation to, you know, talk badly or talk down to people who want this
00:03:58 thing to end. For economic reasons, it's very easy to throw out the Oh, you don't care about
00:04:04 people's lives, or you want my grandma to die has almost become a meme at this point, not just in
00:04:08 uk but in lots of different countries and um you know like tom was saying we have to remember
00:04:15 that the the goal posts have been moved multiple times now for people who have actually somewhat i
00:04:22 don't want to say benefited from this but who haven't really been impacted financially and in
00:04:28 terms of their jobs and their careers and in fact they're now able to spend more time at home more
00:04:34 time with their children don't need to commute and all that then it's very easy to see people
00:04:40 like that who are very pro lockdown i'm not seeing anybody who has lost their job become unemployed
00:04:48 taking a massive pay hit who is pushing the idea that we should go on with this lockdown forever
00:04:54 I think, Rafe, isn't it the case that, you know, they say this lockdown has exposed inequalities.
00:05:03 Actually, it sort of has in a way, isn't it? I mean, there are people who, as you would say,
00:05:08 do really do not care. They're in very nice surroundings and they can work from home.
00:05:12 But this is not the case for, what, millions?
00:05:15 That's right. I mean, if anything, historians are going to look back upon this period as one
00:05:19 of great hysteria caused by governmental panic fomented by the media as well i mean really we
00:05:26 have to ask ourselves why was the lockdown put into place it wasn't to lower the number of deaths
00:05:31 or the number of cases it was to flatten the curve it was to spread the exact same number of cases
00:05:37 evenly or to a degree that it wouldn't overwhelm the nhs that was the sole reason for it and as
00:05:43 we've seen the nhs has not been overwhelmed not only were the nightingale hospitals not necessary
00:05:48 but even hospitals now have much more capacity than they could they're eerily quiet as we've heard
00:05:53 in scotland and elsewhere and yet this lockdown continues the reason that it continues is because
00:05:58 the government is scared of being seen to have made an error and so we have an unnecessary
00:06:02 lockdown that's continuing is causing untold damage you know in hindsight it's a wonderful
00:06:06 thing we're not saying that you know we have we have you know we had a crystal ball back then
00:06:11 but i certainly said twice on this show in april that this was a question of philosophy in terms
00:06:16 of morals it was a deontological versus a utilitarian concept basically what is more
00:06:20 important do you save lives now and risk untold damage in the future or do you actually quantify
00:06:28 this and say what is life worth what is is it the quality of life or is it actually just extending
00:06:33 life for the sake of extending life and i think we've we've shown now that with the number of
00:06:38 deaths from people not attending a and e down by over 57 with the forecast of 50 000 people dying
00:06:45 from cancer in the years to come i mean we are seeing a catastrophic result from this not not
00:06:49 to mention scenes we haven't seen since the great depression of people queuing up for
00:06:53 food banks in america and and in the uk this has been disastrous for people at the lower
00:06:58 end of the scale whose whose livelihoods are now basically in shreds and there are questions that
00:07:02 need to be asked as to why none of these questions are being asked by the media and people have to
00:07:06 turn to channels like this and to and to and to basically you know the the underground networks
00:07:12 on on social media to get these questions explored to any depth at all tom if i can ask you i i don't
00:07:20 really like this whole thing of constantly sort of going for a big villain mainstream media but
00:07:26 the fact remains doesn't it that particularly when it comes to the broadcast media much more
00:07:31 than newspapers there seems to be a certain official line and you very rarely hear dissenting
00:07:37 voices i mean do you recognize that situation oh 100 and i think we really saw this in the
00:07:43 run-up to the lockdown actually being announced where every day at those press conferences it
00:07:47 often felt like a lot of the journalists there were advocating for that policy they were just
00:07:52 asking when are we going to go the way of italy when is this going to happen for whatever reason
00:07:56 they got very invested in it i think because the narrative by that point was that britain was being
00:08:00 reckless that boris was bungling it and as a result of that i think discussion of the lockdown
00:08:05 has been incredibly narrow you know you haven't really heard um the broad range of views even
00:08:10 within the kind of epidemiological community and i think that's been a real real shame because again
00:08:15 a lot of these issues have been missed and also i think the kind of myopia of the um of the media
00:08:21 focusing purely on the question of lockdown afterwards these kind of weeks of just banging
00:08:25 on about who was sunbathing in the park and the rights and wrongs of doing that to the point where
00:08:30 they missed real problems with how the lockdown was implemented you know like the care homes
00:08:33 crisis that we've been talking about in recent weeks in which you know in order to clear the
00:08:37 decks in the nhs all of these care home patients were being sent back to care homes without even
00:08:42 the need for a negative covid test which many care home managers have traced back to to very
00:08:47 serious outbreaks so i think not only isn't that extraordinary sorry isn't that extraordinary that
00:08:52 should be the case that they don't even have to test i mean this is extraordinary isn't it
00:08:57 it's one of the biggest clear-cut scandals in this so far and one of the things that hasn't
00:09:01 really been owned up to is that it's been it was part and parcel of how the lockdown was pursued
00:09:06 you know at the beginning of this there was this big discussion about saying you know surely it
00:09:10 felt like the the first thing to do would be to make sure that the elderly and the people with
00:09:13 comorbidities would be best insulated the way it's panned out is if anything they were put more at
00:09:18 threat by how this lockdown was implemented and the fact that it took the media so long it felt
00:09:22 like to catch that and to make it the big story i think was also revealing. Zupi what was your
00:09:29 reaction to the lockdown in the first place i mean did you think it was the way to go or you know
00:09:35 that before we got to a certain point that's we were basically going what you might call the
00:09:39 swedish way and there was this moment of panic i mean what were you in favor of it from the start
00:09:45 or not yeah so what i'm going to do is i'm going to make sure that i don't try to do the hindsight
00:09:52 2020 thing right we all know that it's easy to see say now things that should have happened in
00:09:57 january or february etc my personal view is that the initial lockdown with the initial reasoning
00:10:05 and the original logic to flatten the curve to make sure the hospitals don't get overwhelmed
00:10:10 and we're not getting thousands of people flooding in with this disease and people are dying
00:10:15 not because the disease is even killing them but because they're they just can't deal with
00:10:20 all these patients at once that made sense okay so that made sense because if you're going to do a
00:10:26 severe lockdown if you're going to tell someone it's like if you're going to tell someone they're
00:10:29 going to go on a you can only chicken and broccoli on this diet okay you need to be really strict
00:10:35 you can do that as long as you give them a short frame of time right if you say okay for this week
00:10:40 you can only chicken and broccoli right if they say okay for two weeks you got to stay at home
00:10:45 and only go out to get groceries etc people can deal with that but people cannot deal individually
00:10:51 nor collectively with an indefinite strict limitations for an indefinite period of time
00:10:57 so i think that's the problem we've reached the stage now many weeks later where the initial goal
00:11:03 was reached okay and that made sense but now the the goal posts keep shifting the reason for the
00:11:09 lockdown keeps changing and as this is happening people are becoming people are losing jobs people
00:11:15 are losing money people are becoming depressed anxious suicidal people are becoming lonely there
00:11:20 are all of these other problems happening immediately let alone what is
00:11:24 going to be happening six months twelve months many years down the line from all
00:11:28 of this and what I think is I think there are a lot of problems going here
00:11:33 I think there are a lot of problems of omission and I think that there are a
00:11:36 lot of problems when it comes to incentives when it comes to the way
00:11:40 people behave and do what they do I like to look at things in the terms of
00:11:43 incentives and I think if you look at politics or you look at the media for
00:11:49 example, the incentives are, they are essentially incentivized for this lockdown period, right? I
00:11:56 think if politicians were not currently being paid, or if a lot of these people in the media
00:12:03 who are super pro lockdown, were not currently being paid, I would be curious to know what their
00:12:09 position on this would be, right? It's very, as we said, easier, it's very easy if you're in certain
00:12:15 situations. It's very easy for Piers Morgan to push for this
00:12:19 lockdown to go for happened another year. I'm not saying
00:12:22 this to target him. But I know he's been very vocal about it,
00:12:25 right. But it's easy. He's he's comfortable. He's very rich.
00:12:28 He's still being paid. You know, yeah, it's easy to say it
00:12:32 should go on forever. You know, but talk to the business owner
00:12:35 talk to the gym owner, the restaurant owner, whoever who
00:12:38 has lost their job and has now had no income coming in for a
00:12:41 long period of time. And they are getting stressed and they
00:12:44 need to feed their children etc because we have to remember it almost seems like it's taboo but
00:12:50 the reality is that this this disease this virus is dangerous particularly to people who are over
00:13:00 the age of 65 70 if you are young and healthy the probability of this thing killing you is
00:13:09 close to zero it's like it seems like nobody wants to talk about this in some countries
00:13:14 the average age of people who are dying from coronavirus is higher than the average life
00:13:20 expectancy like like really think about that this does not mean that we we want you want grandma to
00:13:27 die you want of course not but the idea that you're going to go run forever with this one
00:13:32 size fits all model and you're going to treat 15 year olds and 25 year olds and 35 year olds
00:13:37 the exact same way as you're treating 85 year olds is asinine it doesn't it doesn't make any
00:13:42 sense you can have a more of a staggered approach you can have different approaches here i think the
00:13:47 thing is is that before i ask you i think the thing is really is that uh the point you make
00:13:54 there about the kind of the difference uh you know in fatalities and infection is very important but
00:14:01 that point used to be made at the very beginning you know i this is what this is what worries me
00:14:06 when there's a kind of intensification of the situation that point used to be
00:14:10 made at those briefings this is actually a mild disease I remember people saying
00:14:16 that I'm sure you do too this is a mild mild disease unless you are in these
00:14:20 groups they sort of drop that now it's sort of almost we're all basically what
00:14:26 what I want to ask Rafe is that given what Zubia said given what Tom has said
00:14:32 Why, therefore, how do you account for what is the most extraordinary level of support
00:14:37 that when you look at the polls, people actually, I think you're saying like a third,
00:14:43 want this thing to go on indefinitely?
00:14:45 I mean, do they expect it to be the case that this virus is simply going to be eradicated or what?
00:14:51 Well, two things there.
00:14:52 One, we've already heard there's little incentive for people to go back to work
00:14:55 if they're being paid in the furlough.
00:14:58 and certainly in America, people are only more now than they would on unemployment than they would
00:15:03 when they were in employment. But what it really is, it's the culture of fear that was created by
00:15:08 the government and the media to instill fear into people to stay at home. And this really is a
00:15:13 failure of behavioral science because the British government never actually expected such a great
00:15:18 take-up of the lockdown. They thought about 20% of people would not actually adhere to the lockdown.
00:15:23 We don't remember that today, but that was the expectation. And really that's basically to assume
00:15:28 things would be going along on basically sort of a swedish model originally in terms of people
00:15:33 going about their business and that's why we had a very laissez-faire sort of relaxed attitude to
00:15:36 the whole thing and back in april twice on this program i said that the government is creating
00:15:41 a culture of fear and my my fellow panelists said oh no no you know people who are normally on the
00:15:47 right also bought into this idea that no no this is absolutely essential but we knew at that time
00:15:52 that the majority of people who were dying had one of four comorbidities and it was diabetes
00:15:57 heart disease uh asthma or lung respiratory problems or alzheimer's dementia uh the average
00:16:04 age was in the was in the median age was in the 80s 91 of people dying had those symptoms
00:16:09 uh and also you know in the uk higher purport and in america high proportions of people from a black
00:16:14 minority ethnic background as well um with and with high levels of diabetes and so forth accounting
00:16:18 for our higher higher death rates in london than elsewhere um and yet somehow that's all been
00:16:23 forgotten in the extension of this when really as it's been said the priority should have been not
00:16:28 to close down schools perversely when the youngest are not those at risk but to actually protect the
00:16:33 not the nhs protect the care homes and the british government the the conservative government is very
00:16:38 good on sloganeering you had take back control very effective you had let's get brexit done
00:16:44 very effective and unfortunately on this case the third slogan also worked very well stay home save
00:16:49 lives protect the NHS and that was a very effective slogan it was too
00:16:53 effective and that's why we're in the state that we're in now do you think as
00:16:57 well that I mean apart from this fear that is basically being extremely
00:17:02 successfully you know instilled if you like by the government at the same time
00:17:06 there's been an underlying change I wonder whether you think this Tom do be
00:17:12 in British culture I know that we had Frank for radio on the program recently
00:17:17 and he's written a lot about the culture of fear and he you know basically that we are to an extent
00:17:21 now ruled by fear that that this is actually in a way this is the guiding principle of our society
00:17:30 in a way that maybe once resilience was you know do you do you think there's a point there
00:17:35 i think that's definitely contributed to it and it's definitely contributed to as we say the kind
00:17:40 of level of public support that we see for the lockdown now i think it's worth bearing in mind
00:17:44 that whilst we do see very high public support for lockdown at the same time you are seeing more and
00:17:48 more people start to break it i think it was perfectly summed up by you know an interview i
00:17:51 think it was on south end beach a couple of days ago where a gentleman who was out drinking with
00:17:56 his family said that he thinks that we should be more locked down at this point so there's a there's
00:18:01 an element of people trying to have their cake and eat what they're telling pollsters in the
00:18:04 privacy of their own home is slightly different but i think it has been it has the government
00:18:08 have very much tapped into that pre-existing culture of fear means through which um which
00:18:14 has already kind of pre-existed my fear as well is that it exacerbates other negative trends that
00:18:18 already exist in society you know there's been a big problem with um atomization in society you
00:18:23 know as of um actually in february um just you know about a month before really the crisis hit
00:18:28 uh the ons put out a study on social capital saying that people felt more and more isolated
00:18:32 in their communities than ever before people feel more atomized young people even are less
00:18:36 outgoing than they used to they tend to drink less they tend to have less sex than they used
00:18:40 There's all of these kind of social trends towards atomization, towards being more fearful, towards being more fearful about other people as well, which also pre-existed.
00:18:48 And I'm worried that, you know, as the months of not just lockdown, but social distancing wear on, you can see a kind of exacerbation of a lot of those very negative trends as well.
00:18:57 Zubi, you're actually based outside of London, aren't you? You're based in the south of England.
00:19:03 There is a difference apparently as well in how people are experiencing this, you know, if you're in London.
00:19:09 or are people carrying on like pretty much the same where you are or yeah i mean where i am i'm
00:19:16 in south hampton and if it weren't for that you can tell of course the streets are more quiet lots
00:19:22 of the shops are closed of course about the social distancing guidelines happening in supermarkets
00:19:26 and things like that beyond that you wouldn't necessarily know that much was going on um to
00:19:34 their credit, for example, the police have not been heavy
00:19:37 handed here. They haven't been I haven't seen them. I go out
00:19:41 I've been out every single day this year, right? Even when the
00:19:43 lockdown was real fully enforced, I was being a bit of a
00:19:46 rebel, I was still going out for going out to the park and
00:19:48 stuff. And you know, people people have been out the whole
00:19:50 time. And people are socially distancing outside, which is
00:19:54 actually healthier than being stuck inside. And yeah, I mean,
00:19:59 here, the impact hasn't been been massive, not in terms of
00:20:03 cases or deaths or in terms of the lockdown measures people are generally
00:20:08 abiding by things but it doesn't feel like a total complete lockdown like I
00:20:13 know they have in some other places yeah go ahead yes can say that but the
00:20:18 thing is with a lot of your followers maybe you've written books about fitness
00:20:22 obviously and and I can say that you know this is one of those times where
00:20:28 have you found the feedback is from people becoming depressed not wanting to do this
00:20:35 or are they actually sort of incentivized yeah it's a it's a little bit of a combination i think
00:20:42 some people are real i think that you know fear we've been talking a lot about fear and i think
00:20:48 fear can happen in two ways and i think with a situation like this you want people to be
00:20:53 scared into their wits, not out of them. And I think you guys were talking about how the campaign
00:21:00 was perhaps too effective. And I think that what's happened, what we're dealing with is an
00:21:05 overcorrection. Okay, so the initial model of models came out, the initial predictions came out,
00:21:12 and they wanted to scare people into their wits so that people would not be reckless.
00:21:17 What's happened is the disease turned out not to be anywhere close to as bad as they were initially
00:21:23 predicting. If you remember, when this started, people were saying the death rate was between
00:21:27 3% and 5%. It's turned out the death rate is across the whole population, perhaps between 0.1
00:21:33 and 0.2%. And that's a big magnitude of difference. The way you treat those things
00:21:39 is very different. If this thing was killing 5% of the population, including young children and
00:21:45 healthy people, etc., then I would probably say that we need far more drastic measures than what
00:21:50 we're currently doing but the reality is that that's not the case and again coming back to
00:21:55 incentives the problem is that we we live in this weird time you you see this now in the i see it
00:22:02 online in media and stuff where people get criticized for what doing what they call a u-turn
00:22:06 and anyone who drives knows that sometimes you need to do a u-turn right a u-turn is a useful
00:22:13 maneuver you're going down the wrong road you need to turn around and go back because it's not what
00:22:18 you thought it was and i think people like i said people are dug in now where no one wants to be
00:22:24 criticized especially politically let alone on a personal level people don't want to be criticized
00:22:28 for going oh actually you know what we we overreacted so we can we can change what we we
00:22:36 initially were going to do this but we need to do this instead and no one wants to do this because
00:22:40 they want to save face you have all the the psychological sort of social aspects are are
00:22:47 happening now even in terms of the stay home save lives right people are repeating this like robots
00:22:51 because they think that's what makes them a good person right being if you're a good person you
00:22:57 want to stay at home and protect lives and it's easy to maintain that position if you want to
00:23:01 talk about the disease not actually being as bad as it is as as people thought it would be if you
00:23:07 want to talk about demographic differences in terms of how severe it is if you want to talk
00:23:13 about the economic impact if you want to talk about the need for jobs and for people to be
00:23:17 working and to be doing these other things then you are very quickly demonized and villainized
00:23:22 and i'm fortunate in that i don't really care about any of that stuff i'm not very sensitive
00:23:27 i'm not very sensitive to what people think about me in that regard but most people are i think we
00:23:32 know people are thinking it they don't want to say it out loud yes rave but just just to come
00:23:38 back to zuby's point about about the modeling that we had and the reason for the change i mean
00:23:41 we have to remember the very reason for the lockdown was because of the modeling from imperial
00:23:45 college and neil ferguson and it really highlights what has become a fetishistic and rather perverse
00:23:53 obsession with worst case scenarios and this is something which you know we first noticed
00:23:58 well i first noticed during the brexit campaign when the media were obsessed by the worst case
00:24:02 scenario of a no-deal brexit no medication coming in aeroplanes having to have you know airlifts of
00:24:08 vital suppliers into the uk even though everybody knew that this was a hugely unlikely event that
00:24:13 probably would never happen in a thousand years yet this became the front page analysis and this
00:24:18 became almost a fait accompli everyone assumed in on least on the remain side there were huge
00:24:23 number of the of the fbpe brigade who thought this was an inevitability and when the government
00:24:29 spent so much time saying to people during brexit that that was an extreme case scenario unlikely to
00:24:34 happen somehow they fell prey to their own evidence in during the coronavirus campaign
00:24:39 when they also believed this worst case scenario which patently didn't have any chance of coming
00:24:44 true if you looked at neil ferguson's track record he always tended to exaggerate to an nth degree
00:24:50 because in his view it was basically better to err on the side of caution despite the calamity
00:24:54 result of that and i think historians will look back upon this modeling from imperial college as
00:25:00 britain's second dodgy dossier of the 21st century if you remember it was our dodgy sexed up dossier
00:25:05 that's enabled you know caused america to go into iraq with weapons of mass destruction and here
00:25:10 again we've got a dodgy dossier causing american and trump to to do their lockdown so not not very
00:25:16 um you know not not not very glamorizing events for britain but um that really was the the case
00:25:22 for the lockdown and all the modeling in america and britain has long proved neil ferguson's models
00:25:27 to be out out of step and yet the lockdown continues it continues actually uh before we
00:25:33 move on to the other point of our discussion uh i was struck by the uh statistics about london
00:25:40 um you know obviously you're in southampton we're in london here uh tom did you see these about
00:25:47 basically london being virtually uh the the rate of infection so small now almost to be zero in
00:25:54 in terms of the R number, as it were.
00:26:02 And yet, there is no sense whatsoever in London
00:26:06 that this thing is going to be eased in any significant form.
00:26:10 So they say now the justification
00:26:12 seems to be the second wave that is undoubtedly coming.
00:26:17 But again, there's not real evidence for that.
00:26:19 Is that right?
00:26:20 Well, the thing that's been so striking
00:26:22 about those figures that we've seen coming out of London,
00:26:24 you say the fact that there's been you know no new cases or negligible amount of new cases for a
00:26:28 number of days now is how little you know how little that really broke through in terms of
00:26:33 being headline news you know obviously places reported it but it just it wasn't the big
00:26:37 statement you would expect it to be especially because at least as far as i understood it you
00:26:41 know the government's approach going forward aside from wanting to get tests and trace in place and
00:26:45 other things was to do this on a slightly more regional basis you know so that if if a certain
00:26:49 place is cleared then therefore you would move more towards easing the lockdown the fact that
00:26:53 that that hasn't really been discussed at all i think speaks to how nervous the government is
00:26:57 about moving on this at all and if i might just come back to just some of the points about um the
00:27:02 economy that have been made because and how people think you're really heartless when you bring this
00:27:06 stuff up i think there's this i forget who said it but someone said on twitter the other day people
00:27:10 are carrying on like the economy is just something for rich people like golfing like it's something
00:27:14 which has no impact on people's everyday lives and i think we need to be really clear about not
00:27:19 the economic impacts here you know the worst recession for 300 years um unemployment
00:27:24 unemployment benefit claims going up 70 in april um but also how much this has international
00:27:30 effects in terms of lockdown you know there was a report out by the international labor organization
00:27:34 made the point that um informal workers in low-income countries their relative poverty is
00:27:39 like is potentially going to jump by 56 percentage points and also even the effects of lockdowns in
00:27:44 the west in terms of hitting those countries exports it's going to have a really punishing
00:27:48 impact and the fact that you know you even raise that as a question and people think that you're
00:27:52 just doing it on behalf of rich capitalists i think has been absolutely ridiculous but i think
00:27:57 as you know the the economic effects of this starts to become more visible here in the uk
00:28:01 hopefully that discussion will start to to take up a little bit more yeah i think in the future
00:28:06 people are going so i was i was saying i think in the future people are going to look back at the
00:28:11 the damage that was done to this and they're going to question they're going to look at this the
00:28:16 fact that this disease has a 0.1 percent kill rate and they're going to think what on earth
00:28:22 why was so much devastation caused to people and to the economy for something with a 0.1
00:28:30 kill rate and 0.1 percent is of course seasonal flus infection fatality rate and we've known
00:28:38 basically we've had experts in germany and elsewhere stating that it will be somewhere
00:28:42 between 0.1 to 0.4 0.3 for you know weeks now well since early april and what i was surprised
00:28:50 by when matt hancock yesterday came out with this statistic that 17 of london is based upon a sample
00:28:57 survey had already been infected with 17 which in our population would mean about 1.53 million people
00:29:04 have been infected already with coronavirus given that there are only 6 000 deaths in london
00:29:09 attributed to coronavirus means that we there is a infection fatality rate of 0.37 far from the 0.9
00:29:18 that you know neil ferguson and others and yet none no one in the media even bothered to highlight
00:29:23 this fact and it's to me it's amazing that you've got a clear evidence here of how relatively benign
00:29:29 it is unless you're in one of the risk groups and yet the media are skirting over this and that's
00:29:33 one of the there is no opposition right now i mean everybody believes you have to get behind
00:29:37 the government in a time of crisis but there needs to be forums where you can have open debate and
00:29:42 it's the inability to question every time you see the briefings the daily briefings i'm amazed at
00:29:47 how placid our media journalists are yes i i should actually uh mention for the benefit of
00:29:54 people watching outside of the uk of which there are many and you often complain about this matt
00:29:59 hancock is our health secretary here right so he's in the front line in terms of uh government
00:30:05 pronouncements uh what rave said there sort of brought us on to uh something i think is very
00:30:10 important which is essentially that there does appear now to be um an attempt by certain social
00:30:18 media platforms to to next or censor i guess certain sort of views um i know you've written
00:30:26 tom about this quite recently i mean there was a case this week where we're recording this on
00:30:30 on a Friday this week where a particular interview with UnHerd was taken down by YouTube wasn't it
00:30:36 could you just tell us about that so I thought that was a really striking case YouTube in general
00:30:41 have been I think ahead of the pack in relation to kind of social media censorship around
00:30:45 coronavirus and I think the UnHerd example shows you how far they're really going with this so this
00:30:49 this was an interview UnHerd did with Professor Carol Sikora he's a professor of medicine he used
00:30:54 to be an advisor to the World Health Organization he was actually in favor of the lockdown at first
00:30:58 He just happens to be a bit more optimistic about the state of play at the moment and quite keen for the restrictions to be lifted, not least because the effect it could have on cancer patients, which is his particular area of expertise.
00:31:10 So nothing. This isn't David Ike here, you know, talking about 5G masks.
00:31:14 This is a this is someone of certain who has his credential and also very much of the mainstream.
00:31:19 That video was taken down. It was eventually reinstated.
00:31:21 But there's been other cases recently. There's another epidemiologist called Knut Vickowski who had a video taken down.
00:31:28 A couple of weeks ago, there was two medics in California who were discussing in a kind of little press conference, their own data, arguing that California should lift its lockdown.
00:31:37 That was taken down. And this all stems from the fact that YouTube, pretty much at the beginning of this crisis, announced that it would take down anything that it deemed to be spreading misinformation about coronavirus,
00:31:46 but which included anything which went against the World Health Organization guidelines.
00:31:50 and considering the fact that you know even up until february the world health organization
00:31:57 were repeating the line from china that there could be no human to human transmission they
00:32:01 are not shall we say completely you know like having completely the right information at the
00:32:07 right time at the best of time so i think that has been really really concerning and i think
00:32:11 what we've really been seeing um is the kind of acceleration of a lot of big tech censorship
00:32:16 which previously existed which this current crisis has just given them more impetus and more impetus
00:32:21 for governments but pressure on them i think um for for them to really clamp down on what can be
00:32:25 discussed i think uh uh zuby you obviously you had a quite a well-known uh run-in with social
00:32:33 media you had taken off twitter for a while weren't you about something else entirely but
00:32:37 which obviously you know completely different which almost feels like another age now it was
00:32:41 due to something to do with identity politics and things but but basically you have you've fallen
00:32:47 foul of them um i mean you know does this mean that we therefore sort of would tailor what we
00:32:54 maybe should say or not say i mean you know what what should we actually do about this kind of
00:33:00 encroaching censorship is something that's been discussed now for about three years we had a
00:33:05 smith lecture on it here actually um that basically this was something that was happening
00:33:10 and it's happening either surreptitiously or quite openly look i think this is my my general
00:33:18 position on a lot of things that are happening right now in modern western society boil down
00:33:25 to sort of two things number one people need to stop being cowards i'm not talking about
00:33:31 individuals right i think everybody on this call in this conversation is more courageous than
00:33:38 average right and i think the masses of people need to speak up against various issues not just
00:33:46 this one thing not just the sort of slow erosion of freedom of speech and freedom of thought and
00:33:53 ability for people to you know act as if they are in a western country rather than a you know a
00:34:00 soviet communist dictatorship or somewhere with blasphemies laws or somewhere like that when they
00:34:05 see these encroachments happening people need to number one be made aware i think sometimes people
00:34:10 are just simply not aware because people are busy but people need to en masse say look we're not
00:34:16 gonna we're not gonna stand for this we're not gonna allow these platforms to just arbitrarily
00:34:23 make up random rules that apply inequally to different people and just are subjective and
00:34:29 everything like that i mean if people are going to support free speech then they need to support
00:34:34 free speech like i can understand with this very particular situation where you have a pandemic
00:34:40 you have a virus going around etc and you don't want people spreading misinformation i understand
00:34:46 that however as it's already been alluded to the world health organization has spread misinformation
00:34:52 on scale entire governments the the chinese government has spread misinformation on scale
00:34:59 the media in the uk in the usa etc i'm not saying they did this intentionally but if you go back and
00:35:05 see what they were writing in february in march there's been a lot of misinformation out there
00:35:10 a couple months ago they were saying don't wear masks masks don't work and wearing them takes
00:35:15 them away i mean what that doesn't even make sense you're saying don't wear masks because
00:35:19 they don't work and because medical staff need them why would medical staff wear masks if masks
00:35:24 do not work like it doesn't even logically make sense but they keep sort of changing what they're
00:35:29 saying and look free speech is messy allowing people to speak is messy letting people put out
00:35:35 whatever they want is is going to be messy but as long as they're not being criminal or or threatening
00:35:41 or you know there are i understand i'm i'm close to a free speech absolutist i can understand sort
00:35:46 of the usual caveats with that but when it comes to someone simply having a different opinion
00:35:51 on this situation or even i've seen science medical professionals and scientists who have
00:35:58 different opinions who are being interviewed and those interviews are being taken down that is very
00:36:03 concerning right that that should really be it shouldn't just be concerning to us that should
00:36:07 really concern everybody and for the people who are a little bit more far gone and are more sort
00:36:12 of tinfoil hat types etc that will make them think even more like if the interviews are being taken
00:36:18 down that makes them go ah that that must be that must be the truth right this forbidden knowledge
00:36:23 that they keep taking down that must be the truth and the end then the truth is if if the information
00:36:29 is incorrect then someone can put out a response and say explain it right that's much more effective
00:36:35 than just taking down what is deemed to not be acceptable or towing the narrative i think we
00:36:41 really i just feel like society as a whole needs to be very careful about stuff like that i don't
00:36:47 people really think about how much how dangerous it is on this point it is
00:36:54 extraordinary if you have these extraordinarily powerful companies now
00:36:58 like YouTube and Google and Twitter almost semi-political you know
00:37:03 institutions I know they're not there that is the whole problem isn't it that
00:37:08 they can always fall back and say well this is against our company guidelines
00:37:12 this is against our values but in fact wouldn't it isn't it the case that they're just too big now
00:37:18 to be thought of in that way absolutely i mean and what we've seen particularly during this
00:37:23 coronavirus crisis is how they've basically worked hand in hand with state governments
00:37:29 and different governments have different policies and youtube and facebook seem very happy to apply
00:37:34 different policies even if those policies are at odds with each other which throws their entire
00:37:38 logic out of the window and certainly you know the more that they censor online is the more
00:37:43 conspiracy theories i mean secrecy and censorship is the best way to foster conspiracy theories
00:37:48 you know conspiracy theories are like viruses you know and bacteria they thrive in dark corners
00:37:52 you need to give them the open air of sunlight and freedom to have a robust debate it's the public
00:37:57 forum whether it's university no platforming or whether it's you know online you need to have an
00:38:01 open forum for for robust debate particularly when you have i mean you have misinformation
00:38:07 as Zuby quite rightly said, coming out from governments and lack of transparency.
00:38:11 It's the lack of transparency from the government over these issues
00:38:14 because they're too scared of being exposed for having been confused in the early days,
00:38:18 which is fomenting a lot of this.
00:38:20 And it's offensive to learned scientists to be grouped in with the David Ikes of this world
00:38:26 when these are people whose modelling, you know,
00:38:29 Lincoln Oxford University and others, has been accepted by the government in the past
00:38:32 and yet now they're deemed to be beyond the pale.
00:38:34 What do you think of this idea, Tom, that somehow there's some relationship here to the kind of culture of safe spaces that we've also become used to, this kind of overprotective quality we have?
00:38:52 this is not to diminish one has to say this i'm falling into the trap you know but obviously death
00:38:57 is tragic and it is for the you know people who've lost people but we're talking broadly here we have
00:39:03 to by their very nature we're talking culturally broadly and there does appear to be a sort of
00:39:08 connection doesn't there to a general drift towards not you know to risk averse this to
00:39:15 over protection i think so and i think one of the things that the word i keep going back to
00:39:20 is one coined by used a lot in the us which is this concept of safetyism so it's this kind of
00:39:25 sense which has developed in our societies particularly kind of percolated on campuses
00:39:29 which is that you should be able to go about your life without there being almost any adversity
00:39:33 whatsoever and that adversity could come in the form of you know people saying views you disagree
00:39:37 with or on a much broader scale in relation to this pandemic where there is going to be a point
00:39:42 in which we're going to have to accept a certain level of risk for young people that level of risk
00:39:47 is going to be significantly lower but at the same time if life is going to get back like to
00:39:52 anywhere towards normal and it has to for the sake i think of economic and social life as much
00:39:56 as anything else um people are going to have to be able to make these trade-offs i think the big
00:40:00 the big kind of contradiction here though is that people are acting as if something like lockdown
00:40:04 forever is in any sense a safe option like it is a risk-free option there are loads of risks and
00:40:11 if anything the consequences of it are far more knowable than some of the epidemiological questions
00:40:16 which is still very much the subject of fierce debate so i think that culture of safetyism has
00:40:20 informed the tendency to you know glean to lock down and to be very cautious about moving onwards
00:40:26 but the kind of great paradox of it is the fact that lockdown is not a safe option either and the
00:40:30 fact that that hasn't really been said enough i think is quite striking yeah is that something
00:40:34 you agree with zuby yeah i think tom nailed that look i uh you know me i don't really mince my
00:40:40 words man i think society is just so soft right now right i really think people have just collectively
00:40:45 individually and collectively i just feel like you know we are too this this might sound crazy
00:40:51 maybe i'll do it i'll do what peter did and i will caveat this by saying three members of my
00:40:56 immediate family work for the nhs and i personally know four people who have died from this so i am
00:41:01 not speaking everything i'm saying here is not based on this idea of i i just don't know what's
00:41:06 going on and i'm talking from some ivory tower i understand it at the same time it's like we are
00:41:14 We are too afraid of, how would I put it? It's almost like we're too afraid of death in a way, right? And we should have a fear of death. Every human life is extremely important, but why do we not reduce the speed limit on motorways to 20 miles per hour, right?
00:41:35 think about that what why do we not do that that would that would totally more people die on the
00:41:40 road than die from a lot of other things i don't know the exact numbers but probably including
00:41:46 this coronavirus um pandemic so and we let that happen annually every single day every single day
00:41:54 people are dying of lots of things we don't keep a running death count that's being announced by
00:42:00 the media of all the things that people die from in the uk in the usa etc on a daily basis
00:42:05 We don't even know what those numbers are. So, of course, when you say 10,000 people have died of X with no context, that sounds horrible.
00:42:13 That sounds terrible. And it is horrible and terrible. But in the same time, 30,000 people have died of Y.
00:42:20 But you just you just didn't hear about that. So and I feel like this real and this really affects the way that people behave because they don't have a context.
00:42:29 if you're going to give someone a number you need to they need something to compare it to
00:42:34 right how many people die in the uk of heart disease every year how many people die in traffic
00:42:38 accidents how many people die of suicide how many people die of lots of other things if you know
00:42:43 those numbers then it's a lot easier to look at these coronavirus numbers and put them in place
00:42:49 and sort of treat them in a more reasonable fashion because you can't just nerf the entire
00:42:54 world you can't just wrap everybody in a protective bubble and lower all the speed limits to 20 miles
00:43:00 per hour and make sure no one does any dangerous work you know ban ban uh skateboarding ban drinking
00:43:07 ban cigarettes ban everything that could potentially harm somebody people understand that we can't do
00:43:13 that and i i feel like that's sort of been lost in the mix here people have been so myopically
00:43:19 focused on this one thing i mean have you noticed it seems like no one dies of anything other than
00:43:25 coronavirus these days apparently right you know i mean it's like and it's like you need to widen
00:43:30 the conversation yes and the irony of course is that many more thousands may die from other
00:43:35 other diseases and ailments than die from coronavirus and so perversely a society afraid
00:43:41 of death may end up killing more people in the long term as a result of that and one of the
00:43:45 reasons for that is that society today lives in the now and has no understanding or appreciation
00:43:50 of history as pandemics go this is the mildest pandemic we've ever had and yet it's had the
00:43:56 most severe economic consequences people like to draw comparisons with 1918 that's the wrong
00:44:00 comparison the comparison is with the pandemic of 1952 and then what we saw for example if you
00:44:05 look at in the united states the death rate was very similar and yet there was no lockdown at all
00:44:10 there was just a concerted effort by the government to try to find a vaccine for it and it's this
00:44:15 peculiar world we live in now where life where life for the very sake of life is deemed to be
00:44:22 much more important than actually understanding what the value of life and the quality of life
00:44:26 is and you know as i said at the beginning this goes back down to the fact that we're unwilling
00:44:30 to have a proper moral discussion uh of the sort that is posed by the old quandary you know of the
00:44:36 trolley the trolley car theory and if you have a trolley car descending down the rails and you
00:44:40 have a person who's going to be killed by that trolley you have the ability to turn that trolley
00:44:44 to another direction but it may it may kill rather than three people on the first track it
00:44:48 may kill one do you change that or not and that's the ultimate decision we've had to face in the
00:44:52 society and nobody has actually been brave enough to to expose that in public apart from toby young
00:44:57 and as soon as toby young dared to try to posit this theory about are we causing more damage or
00:45:02 not he was essentially you know um well blacklisted from any future media broadcasts yes it is uh
00:45:09 also there was of course you mentioned 1952 there was also the asian through i think of 1968
00:45:16 uh similar sort of numbers but i think what we can agree on really is that the situation
00:45:21 of the pandemic is not unprecedented but the response is unprecedented um thank you very
00:45:29 very much we'll have to leave it leave it there um but i hope that maybe we can reconvene in six
00:45:34 months and who knows uh we might be out of the lockdown by then but uh but thank you very much
00:45:41 gentlemen for coming and um that's it for uh counterculture this week and we will see you
00:45:47 next time please do subscribe won't you and thank you once again to my guests thank you