New Culture Forum - May 09, 2022


The West Must Show Strength to its Enemies & Belief In Itself (New Culture Forum Conference)

How To March BACK Through The Institutions & Regain Control The New Puritans: How Social Justice Captured the Western World

Episode Stats


Length

27 minutes

Words per minute

153.46

Word count

4,282

Sentence count

269


Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
00:00:00 So, thank you Peter, first of all, for the kind invitation and that very generous introduction.
00:00:05 I'm really pleased to be here preaching to the converted.
00:00:10 It is so good to see so many young people here, many of you under 50.
00:00:17 Good, we're awake.
00:00:18 So, it's a real pleasure to be here to talk to you about the West.
00:00:22 As Peter said, for those of you who don't know me, I co-host a political discussion show on YouTube
00:00:29 with my friend and colleague Francis Foster, in which we try to have honest conversations
00:00:33 about many of the issues we'll be hearing about today.
00:00:38 And in fact, many of the guests that you will see here today have been on the show.
00:00:43 And also, the other thing that many of you probably know about me is I'm originally from Russia,
00:00:47 and my wife's Ukrainian.
00:00:48 So, I've been sleeping on the sofa for about eight years now.
00:00:57 We'll just get this up, because I wanted to quote one of my former countrymen, Alexander Solzhenitsyn,
00:01:05 who I think many of you will probably know.
00:01:08 Now, before I talk about Alexander Solzhenitsyn, I want to make clear I'm not in any way comparing myself to him.
00:01:14 Alexander Solzhenitsyn had a very different life.
00:01:17 My parents sent me to a boarding school in England.
00:01:21 He was in a Soviet gulag where he had to endure starvation, dire brutal punishment and a complete
00:01:26 deprivation of his liberty.
00:01:28 So at least we have that in common.
00:01:33 So one of the things that Alexander Solzhenitsyn talked about was what makes a society successful,
00:01:40 what makes a society function well.
00:01:42 And I think one of the most important points he made was that society's success does not
00:01:49 depend only on its government structure, but also on the nature of its spiritual development.
00:01:58 Sorry about this.
00:01:59 So he said that if a nation's spiritual energies have been exhausted, it will not be saved
00:02:02 from collapse by the most perfect government structure or by industrial development.
00:02:08 A tree with a rotten core cannot stand.
00:02:12 It cannot stand if it has a rotten core.
00:02:15 Now, the other thing I would say about Alexander Solzhenitsyn,
00:02:17 I think he did make a bit of a mistake because once he got out of the camps
00:02:21 and went to the West, he got to America
00:02:25 and he saw that while Western society was great, it was not perfect.
00:02:30 And so he began to lecture at various universities
00:02:33 and he began to lecture Americans about their society
00:02:37 and telling them things that they did not want to hear.
00:02:40 I'm not going to make that mistake, that's why I've come to Britain,
00:02:42 where you love hearing how terrible you are.
00:02:47 So I'm going to tell you about that instead.
00:02:51 I joke, of course, I'm not here to lecture you.
00:02:55 I'm here for very different reasons, as Peter mentioned.
00:02:57 This is a picture of my wife and I only a few days ago.
00:03:00 As you can see, she's pregnant, not me, because we're old school.
00:03:07 So, I'm not here to lecture you as a foreign visitor about your country.
00:03:19 I'm here for very personal reasons, for very important reasons.
00:03:24 In a few weeks my wife will give birth and we will have a child and if everything goes
00:03:27 well we may have another child and if everything goes really well they may have children too.
00:03:31 And all of them will live here in the West, just like me.
00:03:36 And I want us in our society, and for them, to live in the prosperity and safety that we all now enjoy.
00:03:42 That is why I'm going to tell you some things, let's be honest, that you all know,
00:03:47 but also some of them you will not want to hear.
00:03:50 So, I apologize to you in advance for both of those things.
00:03:53 Now, what is it that I want to say? Does anybody know what this is?
00:03:59 Very good, sir. It's a wooden plane made out of wooden leaves.
00:04:03 In World War II, in the Pacific theater of war, mainly between the United States and Japan,
00:04:08 they needed to control the ocean.
00:04:12 And to do that you need naval bases or you need some kind of places where you can drop off supplies.
00:04:16 And both the Americans and the Japanese took over a bunch of small islands in the Pacific
00:04:21 and they began to drop off weapons, ammunition, medicine, clothing on these islands.
00:04:27 And the deal they did with the native tribes that lived there,
00:04:31 they lived there, fairly technologically primitive tribes,
00:04:34 is they would share the advances of western civilization,
00:04:38 medicine, clothing, etc., food, tinned food, with the natives.
00:04:42 And the quality of their lives improved dramatically
00:04:46 in a very short period of time.
00:04:49 And then the war ended.
00:04:51 And the Americans and the Japanese packed up
00:04:53 and took all their medicine and their clothes and their supplies and left.
00:04:59 And the quality of lives of the people that lived there dropped massively.
00:05:03 So what do you do?
00:05:05 Well, think about it from the point of view of the natives.
00:05:08 All they saw was these weird shapes come in and land on their island,
00:05:14 and some soldiers who marched around,
00:05:17 and they thought that the prosperity and the safety and the medicine
00:05:21 and the clothing that they enjoyed could be reproduced.
00:05:25 How do you reproduce that?
00:05:27 Well, what you do is you imitate.
00:05:29 You build planes out of wood.
00:05:31 You make wooden rifles, and you march around with them.
00:05:35 You imitate the things that you've seen
00:05:38 because you think that is what produces medicine and clothing and prosperity, etc.
00:05:44 Now, it's a strange thing, but are we that different now in the West?
00:05:49 We talk about all these things.
00:05:51 We talk about capitalism, democracy.
00:05:53 We talk about freedom and free speech.
00:05:55 But are we really committed to those?
00:05:57 are we imitating take capitalism what does capitalism mean right what
00:06:01 capitalism means to me if you ask an economics professor they'll tell you
00:06:05 capitalism is about a society in which there's a free exchange of goods and
00:06:09 services right what does capitalism actually mean to most of us it means
00:06:14 that you have the opportunity to use your talents and your skills to produce
00:06:19 things that you share with other people and if they are value to others you will
00:06:23 be rewarded for this and we have the understanding that this will be done
00:06:26 in a relatively fair system, right?
00:06:29 Do we have a relatively fair system?
00:06:32 A system in which multinational corporations pay less tax than Jimmy Carr,
00:06:37 while young people have to wait until they're 40 to buy a house?
00:06:42 Is that capitalism the way it was intended?
00:06:46 We talk about democracy.
00:06:48 At the last presidential election in America,
00:06:51 a major newspaper, the oldest newspaper in the United States,
00:06:55 published a story about the son of one of the candidates
00:06:59 that was unflattering.
00:07:02 And the same corporations that don't pay any tax,
00:07:05 what did they do?
00:07:07 They prevented that story from being shared
00:07:10 because it was quote-unquote Russian disinformation.
00:07:13 And we know for a fact
00:07:15 that if this had been a story about the other candidate's son,
00:07:19 that would never have happened.
00:07:21 Is that democracy?
00:07:23 We know for a fact, because the research shows it, that many of the people who voted for his father
00:07:30 would not have voted for his father had they known about the story.
00:07:35 And we now know, of course, that the story is largely true.
00:07:38 Is that democracy or are we just imitating?
00:07:41 We talk about freedom, but the moment we get scared, we are very happy to give away our rights to the government.
00:07:47 And we talk about freedom of speech.
00:07:49 And yet, this country arrests thousands of people every year for things that they say on social media.
00:07:55 Now, most of you will be familiar with this case.
00:07:58 Harry Miller, who tweeted something, a transphobic limerick, apparently, on Twitter.
00:08:04 And he had the police call him up and ask him to check his thinking.
00:08:08 When we interviewed him on Trigonometry, I said to this police officer,
00:08:13 I said, you're a police officer. And he said, yes.
00:08:15 And I said, you're telling me you need to check my thinking.
00:08:18 my thinking? And he said, yes. And he said, do you have any idea what that makes you?
00:08:26 Now, one of my great heroes, a big lefty comedian by the way, George Carlin, he said that political
00:08:31 correctness is fascism pretending to be manners. I agree with that. How many of you know where
00:08:37 political correctness, the term itself, comes from? One man, excellent. It comes from the
00:08:44 Soviet Union 1917 the Russian Revolution and had nothing ever political correctness had
00:08:52 nothing ever to do with politeness with preventing offense with ensuring that people's feelings
00:09:00 were protected.
00:09:02 Political correctness had one purpose and one purpose only to enforce the party line
00:09:08 of the day. So that people like my ancestors in the Soviet Union would say something that
00:09:15 was true and they would be told, well, comrade, this is factually correct, but it's politically
00:09:21 incorrect. Why does it matter where it comes from? Well, I'll tell you why it matters.
00:09:28 This is a man called George Kennan. He was the US ambassador to the Soviet Union under
00:09:34 Harry Truman. And he is the man largely responsible for the policy of containment of the Soviet
00:09:42 Union. He influenced decades of American strategic thinking and Western thinking about the Soviet
00:09:47 Union, having spent a lot of time there. And this is what he said. He said, we must have
00:09:52 the courage and self-confidence to cling to our own methods and conceptions of society.
00:09:58 After all, the greatest danger, the greatest danger is that we become like the thing that we're trying to cope with.
00:10:06 We become like our enemies.
00:10:10 A bad word, enemies, isn't it?
00:10:12 It's unpleasant.
00:10:13 We don't have enemies anymore, do we?
00:10:17 Do we?
00:10:18 Because we're nice people.
00:10:19 We like to trade.
00:10:21 We like to have peace with others.
00:10:24 We have no enemies.
00:10:25 We live in this globalized world, right?
00:10:28 and the best thing about it is everyone everywhere in the world
00:10:32 thinks exactly like us right?
00:10:36 now if I ask you that question you all know what the answer is
00:10:39 but deep down we behave like that's true
00:10:42 is it true? is it true that we have no enemies?
00:10:46 is it true that everyone everywhere in the world thinks like us?
00:10:50 I'm gonna introduce you to some of my Russian friends I'm gonna play a video
00:10:54 for you in a second
00:10:55 before I do I want to tell you who the people are that you're about to see
00:11:01 so some of them you will recognize in a second Vladimir Putin is one of them
00:11:06 the president of Belarus Alexander Lukashenko is another
00:11:10 and the other people you see mainly from television are two men
00:11:14 in particular called Vladimir Solovyov and Dmitry Kisilov
00:11:17 now these are the sort of
00:11:20 These are the sort of Piers Morgan and Andrew Neil of the Russian media space.
00:11:27 They host the two most popular TV shows in Russia.
00:11:32 And I'll remind you, 80% of the Russian public get all of their information from television exclusively.
00:11:40 They are not on Twitter. They are not on Facebook. They get the information from this.
00:11:47 If you think that we stop on Ukraine, think about it 300 times.
00:11:55 I remind you that Ukraine is only a single stage of the strategic security of the Russian Federation.
00:12:08 We have patience. We just start in the tough direction of Washington and London.
00:12:16 Poland is playing. There were three sides of Poland. The fourth will be the last one.
00:12:21 The border with Russia is nowhere to end.
00:12:24 It will be time and in Poland nothing will be left. It will be in the Baltic.
00:12:28 I think that the state of Lytva and the state of Poland is too slow.
00:12:33 Too slow.
00:12:35 They don't understand that they can talk faster than Ukraine.
00:12:41 They are shouting, they are bombardiers, who are able to use nuclear weapons, but we have no other way.
00:12:49 Our planes are able to release more than half a thousand nuclear tanks, which will be guaranteed to destroy the United States and all the NATO countries.
00:12:58 This is by principle, why do we have the world, if there is no Russia?
00:13:03 And now the Russian triad is carried out in a special mode of combat.
00:13:09 If we can move our army again to western border, they are cruel, they are afraid of them, they are afraid of them, they are afraid of them, they are afraid of them, they are afraid of them.
00:13:16 We can never stop on the path.
00:13:20 What's such a sanctions? Who said that we should stop the border?
00:13:23 The Soviet Union, for example, can look like a scenario about the war of the Baltic.
00:13:31 Yeah, Russia is the only country in the world that is really able to turn the USA into radioactive smoke.
00:14:01 talking about how Europeans are cowards who need to be conquered with a whip.
00:14:06 He is the leader of the Russian Liberal Democrats.
00:14:11 I should say, former leader, he passed away in a very timely way a couple of weeks ago.
00:14:16 His name was Vladimir Zhirinovsky.
00:14:19 So, am I telling you this to scare you?
00:14:22 George Kennan, come back to this, he said,
00:14:25 He said, the Soviet Union is impervious to the logic of reason and highly sensitive to the logic of force.
00:14:34 Right?
00:14:35 But here's what he also said.
00:14:37 He said, if you make it clear that you are strong, you will not need to use force.
00:14:45 If you're confident in who you are and what you stand for, you will never need to have a showdown in which people's egos get involved.
00:14:54 And George Kennan is the architect of the Cold War which prevented nuclear war between our two countries and which prevented the Soviet Union dominating the world.
00:15:09 Now you don't believe me, do you? Because my wife is Ukrainian. I'm biased on this.
00:15:19 right and George Kennan he's an evil American imperialist all right this is
00:15:25 what Vladimir Lenin said stick your bayonet in if it's soft keep going if
00:15:34 you feel steel pull back now is Lenin relevant to he was alive a hundred years
00:15:43 ago the Russian Revolution was a hundred years ago
00:15:46 has any of you been to Moscow? did you go to the mausoleum?
00:15:51 where is the mausoleum? Red Square, where is Red Square?
00:15:55 in the heart of the capital of Russia
00:15:58 here it is. what does that mean?
00:16:02 his body lies there as a reminder to all Russians
00:16:06 of our history. it hasn't been buried anywhere
00:16:10 it's in the heart of our capital. what does that mean?
00:16:13 Look at our country here, in the UK.
00:16:16 Winston Churchill, in Parliament Square, down the road from here.
00:16:21 Why is he there?
00:16:22 Is Winston Churchill there because he was a great man who we love and respect?
00:16:25 Sure.
00:16:27 But he's not only there for that reason, is he?
00:16:29 He's a symbol.
00:16:31 The statue is a symbol of defiance in the face of tyranny.
00:16:36 Of courage in the face of bravery.
00:16:39 Right?
00:16:40 A symbol.
00:16:42 As is the act of defacing it.
00:16:46 Right?
00:16:48 The people who did this did not do this to insult Churchill.
00:16:53 The people who did this did this because they are demeaning the very things that our country stands for.
00:17:01 The very ideals that we hold to be important were defaced.
00:17:07 Why is that?
00:17:08 Do you think the people who did this want Britain to be great?
00:17:11 Right?
00:17:15 So what's the answer?
00:17:18 What is the answer? Do we fight?
00:17:20 I already showed you the answer.
00:17:22 We must have courage and self-confidence to cling to our own methods and conceptions of society.
00:17:28 That's what Kenan said.
00:17:30 We don't have to fight.
00:17:32 We don't have to fight.
00:17:34 All we have to do is remember who we are.
00:17:38 Now look, people on our side of the argument get upset by these words
00:17:43 and by the discussion around them.
00:17:46 I think that's a mistake.
00:17:49 I think that's a mistake.
00:17:51 Because I think these issues are important.
00:17:54 I've experienced racism.
00:17:57 When I was at school, someone told me to, I quote,
00:18:00 go back to Russia, you Paki.
00:18:03 It's hurtful. I haven't spoken to that teacher since.
00:18:08 Worst geography teacher ever.
00:18:12 You will never eradicate racism from the human heart
00:18:19 by doing this thing that we now call fighting racism.
00:18:24 You will never eradicate racism from the human heart
00:18:28 by doing something called anti-racism.
00:18:31 But you can and should eradicate racism from the human heart
00:18:36 by doing something called embracing the very Western idea
00:18:41 that we're all born of equal worth and of equal dignity.
00:18:48 It's a Western idea and a very unusual one around the world.
00:18:53 What about inequality?
00:18:57 Can you eradicate it by chastising people?
00:19:01 for being successful I don't know I don't think you can but what you can do is make
00:19:09 people feel like the society in which they live is fair and if you do your best and you
00:19:15 apply yourself you will succeed and you will be rewarded right in other words we have to
00:19:21 get the boundaries that are in place to prevent people from succeeding on their own merit
00:19:28 of their way so people don't feel like the main factor determining whether you
00:19:32 as a young person are going to have a good life and have a place to settle
00:19:37 down in and buy a property is how rich your parents are right and whether they
00:19:42 can give you a deposit and finally identity this division that we've seen
00:19:50 in the last six years where we call each other snowflakes and Nazis and all of
00:19:55 this other nonsense that will never heal our society right what if we embrace the very western
00:20:03 idea that you're not judged by where you come from or the color of your skin or what's between
00:20:12 your legs or who you love you're judged on your actions and your thoughts and your ideas
00:20:19 what if we did that
00:20:21 one final thing
00:20:26 I'm not a religious man
00:20:27 but I can't help noticing
00:20:29 that every major religion
00:20:31 particularly the Abrahamic ones
00:20:33 and every major spiritual practice
00:20:35 and frankly every happy person you've ever met
00:20:37 they have one thing in common
00:20:40 they all practice gratitude
00:20:43 they're all grateful for what they have
00:20:46 we are the luckiest people in the history of the world
00:20:51 and if we're grateful for that
00:20:54 and if we remember that
00:20:56 then our children and our grandchildren may as well
00:20:59 thank you very much
00:21:16 Ladies and gentlemen, we've got time for a couple of questions.
00:21:31 After each speaker, we want to have comments or questions, if you could keep them brief.
00:21:36 We've got time for just two, I think.
00:21:39 Has anyone got anything they'd like to ask?
00:21:42 There you go.
00:21:43 Okay. Thank you very much for your speech today.
00:21:46 I think they're largely in agreement with what you say, though I was wondering what we could
00:21:50 do on a practical basis. So for example, if some of us here work in any modern day corporation,
00:21:55 one of the points you've highlighted, who pay very little tax, and you're asked by your HR
00:22:01 departments to state your pronouns in your email signatures and among various other things. So I
00:22:07 think among this audience, we know our culture is strong and we need to fight for it and we want to
00:22:12 to fight for it, how do we fight that fight against the onslaught of war culture, political
00:22:19 correctness, etc.? Thank you.
00:22:22 Well, this is one of the reasons I talked about how we don't actually need to fight.
00:22:26 I don't necessarily see that all the fighting that we've been doing is making things better.
00:22:32 I think we have to embrace, and you know, if you don't mind me saying this, people like
00:22:37 me and people like you who look different and who may be historically come from different
00:22:42 parts of the world we have an added responsibility in this moment to say the things that I've
00:22:47 just said to say the things that you've just said and I think that by doing that we make
00:22:52 it easier for others to speak their mind on this thing as well so while I can't give you
00:22:56 you know that what you I can't give you the language to go to your HR and say why you
00:23:03 don't want to put pronouns in your bio. I think actually it's about expressing a
00:23:07 positive vision. We've not done enough of that. We've not done enough of that. A
00:23:11 positive vision of who we are. And that's a problem. You know, Peter and I, when you
00:23:15 had me on the show a few weeks ago, one of the things we talked about is when
00:23:21 was the last time you heard someone say, this is a free country? On TV. You know,
00:23:28 we don't do this, it's a free country. Or don't tell me that, it's a free country.
00:23:31 I remember when I came to this country in 1995, the other kids at my school used to tease me because I spoke with a funny accent like this, you know.
00:23:41 And I would say, stop teasing me.
00:23:43 And they'd say, no, it's a free country.
00:23:50 So I learned it is a free country, or at least it works, right?
00:23:53 But we don't hear that enough.
00:23:55 If you watch American media, when was the last time?
00:23:58 I remember growing up, this is un-American or this is America was the thing that people said all the time.
00:24:04 When was the last time you heard this?
00:24:06 This is America or this is un-American or this is British or un-British.
00:24:12 We've got to remember who we are and we've got to be proud of it.
00:24:15 Not in some kind of aggressive way, but we've got to have a positive vision to offer people.
00:24:19 Your last three kind of points you had, basically leftist axioms.
00:24:26 and I was wondering if you're going to accept their axioms
00:24:29 how do you kind of stop ending where they lead
00:24:33 because I kind of see like if you have leftist axioms
00:24:36 it kind of results in kind of where we've gone
00:24:38 and so I'm not saying there's something wrong with the axioms
00:24:41 but like how you know do you see like inevitability of
00:24:45 things following from axioms like that like inequality
00:24:50 like if you accept inequality do you not think it's inevitable
00:24:53 that people would then say, wasn't communism great, for example?
00:24:56 Yeah, you're right to pick me up on that point,
00:24:58 because I was actually going to mention it,
00:25:00 but I felt that I didn't have the time.
00:25:02 So, I come from a society that tried to make everybody equal, right?
00:25:07 I know that everybody being equally poor is not a good idea, right?
00:25:12 So, but what I don't accept,
00:25:15 and this is, I think, the problem for people like us,
00:25:17 is we've got to a position where people go,
00:25:20 racism is bad and we go yeah but this is one of the least racist societies in
00:25:25 history which is true right and we feel that our society is under attack
00:25:29 somehow right and I do think the way that some people talk about these issues is
00:25:33 exaggerated it's not proportionate to the truth of our societies but I also
00:25:38 think these are important issues these are important issues I think you'd agree
00:25:44 with me that if we could have no racism in society that would be a good thing
00:25:47 I think you'd agree with me that a fairer society in which people are rewarded on the basis of their merits, their skills and talents is better than the sort of crony capitalism society that we have now.
00:25:59 So I don't think we need to reject these as leftist axioms.
00:26:04 I think we need to offer a positive vision of how we want to get there as well.
00:26:09 And that's how you bring more people into this room.
00:26:13 Because we've spent too much time excluding people.
00:26:17 both sides have, from this room, whichever room it is, right?
00:26:21 The left talk to the left, the right talk to the right,
00:26:24 the centrist, well, we talk to ourselves, right?
00:26:27 We need to talk to each other,
00:26:29 and we need to agree on the things that we agree on.
00:26:31 It should be okay for us to agree with people
00:26:34 that we don't normally agree with
00:26:35 when they say things that are important.
00:26:38 Thank you very much.
00:26:39 Thank you very much, Constance.
00:26:41 Lovely.
00:26:42 Thank you for having me.
00:26:45 Thank you.
00:26:46 Hello, if you're enjoying the New Culture Forum channel and you believe in our mission,
00:26:51 may I invite you to join our membership scheme at the link below or on our website
00:26:58 newcultureforum.org.uk. Our work is more important now than ever and we have great plans ahead for
00:27:05 the future, but we can't do it without your support. From as little as £3 per month,
00:27:11 you can help ensure that we continue on our mission as a member you'll receive a range of
00:27:17 benefits including access to exclusive content invitations to our private events including
00:27:24 here at our studios free copies of our books and much much more including of course our famous
00:27:32 ncf mug if you aren't able to become a member then please help us by clicking this button
00:27:39 and subscribing to our channel. It's completely free, just remember to also
00:27:44 click the bell icon so that you can get notifications when we post new videos.
00:27:50 Thank you.