New Culture Forum - March 22, 2021


What Is The Future For White Majorities? How Are Demographics Changing Britain?

Laurence Fox: Why Im Standing Against Sadiq Khan To Be London's Next Mayor Is It Dangerous To Make Misogyny A Hate Crime? Why Is Sarah Everard's Murder Being Politicised?

Episode Stats


Length

44 minutes

Words per minute

151.76

Word count

6,726

Sentence count

150


Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
00:00:00 Hello and welcome to counterculture I'm Peter Whittle now before we talk about this week's
00:00:18 subject just a reminder please do subscribe won't you it's very simple it's free you just go to the
00:00:25 subscribe button on our channel and then next door to it there's a bell sign and
00:00:30 if you click on that you get notifications of all our shows as they
00:00:35 come up so please do we're on 110,000 subscribers now and 12 million views
00:00:40 nearly but please do add to that won't you now the subject this week we're
00:00:47 talking about is one that many viewers of our channel have asked for for a long
00:00:52 time. Demographics you might have already had through this letter recently it's
00:01:01 from the government it's the census 2021 obviously every 10 years the last one
00:01:07 was in 2011 this will tell us a lot about the makeup of Britain when the
00:01:14 results come out later this year or early next year but what actually is the
00:01:20 effect of demographics on cultural makeup of the country and also its
00:01:26 political makeup what are the overall effects what is the lookout for Britain
00:01:31 and Europe in particular with changing demographics and you know should we care
00:01:37 about this I know that a lot of you care about this to discuss these issues I'm
00:01:42 very pleased we have somebody who is a pioneer in this particular area and that
00:01:48 is David Coleman, who is Professor of Demography at Oxford University. Also, Eric Kaufman, who is
00:01:56 Professor of Politics at Birkbeck College, the author of numerous books, including White Shift,
00:02:02 that he came onto the channel and talked to us about some time ago, and Emma Webb from the Civitas
00:02:10 think tank um thank you very much for joining us can i start by asking you david do you think
00:02:18 i said there that you know many of our viewers say when are you going to talk about demographics
00:02:22 do do you think this is an untouchable area in the what you might call the popular mainstream
00:02:29 i don't think it is there's enough um chat about it around around the edges of it and
00:02:37 and even more centrally, to say that it's not untouchable.
00:02:43 It is difficult.
00:02:45 Those in academic life who speak about it in anything other than a bended knee, as it were,
00:02:53 tend to get a lot of flack.
00:02:56 I've had a lot of flack.
00:02:58 I imagine Eric must have had quite a bit of flack as well.
00:03:00 Perhaps he can tell us about his wartime experiences in a moment.
00:03:06 I've had petitions against me which fail
00:03:11 and were not actually in my university
00:03:13 taken very seriously I think
00:03:15 I suspect it's done me some harm
00:03:19 in terms of preferment
00:03:22 and I know that one or two academics
00:03:25 certainly one in America
00:03:27 refused to appear in any programme
00:03:30 which featured me
00:03:33 this is a respectable academic
00:03:35 but when you say, I mean, when you say, unless you talk about this on bended knee, what would bended knee be then?
00:03:45 Oh, what I mean is avoiding or certainly tiptoeing around any kind of critical comment or comment that might be regarded as critical
00:03:58 About the consequences of ethnic change, about the average behavior of any ethnic group, if it's possible to speak about average behavior, about the reputation of different ethnic groups, about specific problems like to do with integration, to do with alleged higher levels of crime,
00:04:26 to do with, as we know, problems of attitudes towards women and girls,
00:04:33 particularly poor white girls, as we saw in these scandals in Rochdale and elsewhere,
00:04:44 which were covered up wholly or in part in order to avoid giving offence
00:04:49 and possibly to avoid the authors of the reports
00:04:54 getting a very bad reputation of being racist.
00:04:59 The term, the accusation, racist,
00:05:02 has until recently, and perhaps even still,
00:05:05 more or less trumped any kind of argument of a more rational kind.
00:05:10 Sometimes the accusation is justified.
00:05:12 Very often it's not, but it serves a shutdown discussion.
00:05:16 Yes.
00:05:17 Eric, you know, when you wrote White Shift,
00:05:19 which was actually just looking, so far as I could see from it,
00:05:23 it was actually looking at it in a very, very clear and objective way
00:05:26 about the differences and what was going to occur for white majority countries
00:05:33 as they stand now.
00:05:35 What was the reaction, therefore, to your book amongst your peers
00:05:41 in the academic world?
00:05:43 Was it one of censure?
00:05:45 well well i think when when you write a book that's you know got 600 pages in it that gives
00:05:52 you a bit of protection i think i think that i mean broadly i was pleased with the media response
00:06:00 including the sort of central you know the center ground uh even things like the literary review and
00:06:07 the ft and the los angeles review of books so so but it was the you know the it was places like
00:06:13 the Guardian and Vox where you get this sort of knee-jerk reaction. How can you say anything
00:06:17 that's nice about something like white identity or about the desire to slow down ethnic change?
00:06:24 How can that be seen as anything other than absolutely horrendous? So yeah, you did get
00:06:29 that response. But I mean, one of, I was, so for example, I was on Ezra Klein's show, which,
00:06:36 which is a sort of quite a long form radio program. And I have to say, I was reasonably
00:06:41 pleased with the tenor of the questions uh but i think here in britain with the guardian review
00:06:47 and there were some the uh um wonder review of books you know there were some attack pieces but
00:06:54 i think that's to be expected whenever as david said whenever you touch this subject of ethnic
00:06:59 change in a way that's not sort of approved you'll get it from that section of what i call
00:07:05 the left modernists you know the cultural left will go after you. I think actually Eric you have
00:07:11 made the point that in fact the left broadly speaking always welcome the idea of ethnic
00:07:20 change because it sort of very much aids and abets their belief in social transformation isn't that
00:07:28 right? Yeah, it's a particular strand, which is the modernist left, the cultural left. So it's
00:07:37 distinct from the old left, which might even be the old labor working class left, which traditionally
00:07:43 has been, for example, wanted restricted immigration. In the US, the biggest immigration
00:07:49 restrictionist lobbies were like the American Federation of Labor, the Knights of Labor,
00:07:54 some of these workers' organizations. But that's kind of really changed starting mid-20th century.
00:08:02 The leadership of the unions really began to be drawn into the new left. The sort of cultural
00:08:07 turn of the left away from class towards identity categories has really taken hold
00:08:14 in organizations, even those that are supposed to be representing the working class. So
00:08:18 So the left now is defined as the Labour Party, as the Democrats in the U.S., they're increasingly defined by what Rob Ford would call identity liberals, metropolitan university towns who are concerned with these identity categories and with offenses or the purported offending of these categories and stretching the meaning of terms like racism and transphobia and so on.
00:08:45 So that's really where the left increasingly is intellectually. And so they are going to be very hostile to anything that is not completely right on in terms of being on board with cosmopolitanism and ethnic change.
00:08:59 Do you think actually, Emma, that it's actually interesting what Eric says there, because in a way you'd think that with the kind of incredible preponderance now of identity politics in everything, actually people would speak about this quite a lot.
00:09:15 Do you see what I mean? That you'd think that they actually wouldn't shy away, but in fact, obviously they are.
00:09:20 yeah i think it's it's a bit the way i'm going to phrase this is a bit too shallow and doesn't
00:09:26 really doesn't really describe it well enough but i think that there is a sort of double standard
00:09:32 and people like james lindsey have pointed to um marcus's ideas about repressive tolerance
00:09:40 and the idea that um certain things um that are not as i think um eric would would call the the
00:09:49 new left or left modernism that anything that isn't that it's just not simply not tolerated
00:09:54 and so when in discussions around white identity or the white working class particularly white
00:10:01 working class boys there is a lack of objectivity or a lack of reason when it comes to the way that
00:10:09 we talk about these things and I think that for many of that group the the new left if we should
00:10:16 call them that um i think that for them the facts don't really matter because it's the narrative
00:10:22 it's the it's it's uh it's entirely based on emotions and feelings and subjectivity
00:10:28 and so there is a not only a lack of tolerance on the other on on the the alternative side of
00:10:35 the debate there where everybody even if you walk on eggshells you're still going to fall foul of
00:10:40 of the discussion there's no way around that um but there's also um almost an intentional
00:10:46 blind spot from their perspective where we can talk about every other identity
00:10:51 except the the identity that they see as being at the top of the pyramid so anything that is at the
00:10:57 top of that hierarchy uh that is is not regarded as as being an oppressed group it's it's not only
00:11:03 you that you can't discuss it or you can't speak about it favorably but it's almost as if it
00:11:07 doesn't exist at all yes yes um do you think uh that can we lay a few sort of facts out on the
00:11:16 table actually i mean basically it seems that and you please correct me if i'm wrong i'm being very
00:11:21 broad here that essentially over the next century white majority or countries that are white
00:11:28 majority will cease to be is that actually something that is verifiable in in as it were
00:11:35 projection and fact or is that just a political view eric well david's written on this too as
00:11:43 well but but i and i can let him talk about britain but certainly for north america you know
00:11:49 the u.s and canada are meant to lose their uh white majorities around 2050 uh might be slightly
00:11:56 later in canada and then a bit later in australia but new zealand canada u.s certainly around that
00:12:01 time and then towards the end of the century for Britain. But, of course, a key question around
00:12:06 when we're talking about ethnic majority, which is a community that is united in a belief in
00:12:11 common ancestry, there is a capacity for assimilation through intermarriage. So one of
00:12:16 the questions, of course, in the U.S. case is, is somebody who is part Hispanic and part European
00:12:22 in origin? A lot of those people will identify as white, so it's very hard to pinpoint exactly
00:12:28 when this point will arrive.
00:12:31 So there's a messiness about the definition of these groups,
00:12:35 a little bit, certain fuzziness around the edges,
00:12:37 but certainly with existing census categories,
00:12:41 I would say mid-century for North America, New Zealand,
00:12:43 and later in the century for Western Europe.
00:12:47 David, I don't know your thoughts on that.
00:12:49 Yes, David, can you come in there?
00:12:54 Certainly. I agree with what Eric is saying.
00:12:58 I'm reluctant, though, ever to use the word will in the context of a population projection, even though it may seem overwhelmingly obvious that what you say will indeed come to pass.
00:13:09 But numerically speaking, white majorities will cease to be majorities sometime in the course of this century or earlier in the next century.
00:13:21 things do change
00:13:24 events happen
00:13:26 Brexit and the coronavirus
00:13:30 might have an impact
00:13:32 on the migration levels
00:13:34 for example
00:13:35 which drive this process
00:13:36 so far it's having an effect
00:13:40 mostly on European minorities
00:13:43 who count as white
00:13:45 something else might happen
00:13:47 in the future
00:13:47 which would affect migration
00:13:49 from countries where the population does not identify as white.
00:13:55 So I think it's overwhelmingly likely, but it certainly isn't certain.
00:14:01 It certainly can't be verified unless you can hire a TARDIS
00:14:05 and zip off into the 21st century and see what's going on there.
00:14:12 The point you made about what you might call ethnic drift is an important one.
00:14:17 It is indeed driven mostly by intermarriage, but it's also a change of identity comparing some parents and some children.
00:14:30 Whether it still operates to the same degree, I don't know.
00:14:34 But between the census of 2001 and later, there was a tendency for the children of women who classed themselves as mixed.
00:14:51 Their children were often classified by the parents, of course, because they weren't their only babies at the time, as white British.
00:14:58 this trend may reverse
00:15:01 if the white British
00:15:03 loses its cachet
00:15:05 which it is rather rapidly at the moment
00:15:07 but that has been the trend in the past
00:15:09 Could you sort of
00:15:11 speculate, I'm sure you're about
00:15:13 to say you don't like to speculate
00:15:15 but we're having this census now
00:15:18 we'll know about
00:15:21 what it reveals maybe later this year
00:15:23 early next year
00:15:25 what David would you expect to see
00:15:27 from this when it comes to ethnicity for this country?
00:15:31 What would your general idea be, do you think,
00:15:38 about changes that we might see that this might reveal?
00:15:44 A repeat in a slightly less dramatic way of the shocks
00:15:48 which follow the publication of results from the 2011 census,
00:15:53 but that is to say a much more substantial advance of ethnic minority populations in
00:16:00 major cities in Britain and also in other places as well. It may not be as substantial but I don't
00:16:09 know but migration has been proceeding at a very high level of the order of sometimes over 300,000
00:16:17 net per year. I think the average over the last few years is about 280,000. There was
00:16:23 a short time when half of that was from the European Union and half from outside it. Now
00:16:29 the balance has shifted, especially since Brexit, where the net migration from the European
00:16:35 Union, insofar as you know what migration is nowadays, is much reduced. And that's been
00:16:41 more than compensated by an increase from non-white countries.
00:16:45 And so it may be the situation has accelerated,
00:16:49 and we will see even more interesting shocks than last time,
00:16:54 which illustrates, by the way, the inadequacy of a census
00:16:58 to keep tabs on population change in a 21st century society.
00:17:02 It's quite absurd that we haven't shrugged off the census
00:17:05 much earlier and gone over to a population register.
00:17:08 But there's, as you know, there's all kinds of reactionary prejudice against population registers in the English-speaking world.
00:17:17 And the expanse is likely to deter any action in that direction in the foreseeable future.
00:17:26 Eric, you know, I think one of the shocks that maybe David was referring to there, you can tell me if I'm wrong,
00:17:31 But was it, for example, in London, my home city, for the first time ever historically, the white British population was 45 percent.
00:17:42 In other words, it was, is that what is known as a minority majority or, but it was certainly therefore a minority.
00:17:48 But you see, even though we're saying shock, at the same time, it wasn't treated as a shock.
00:17:55 It was immediately treated, if I remember, by the media as either something to celebrate or indeed that, well, so what?
00:18:04 Should we care? I mean, what would you say this census will show about London?
00:18:10 Do you think my feeling is probably it will show that the white British population has maybe gone down to the 30s?
00:18:17 well i think it's a bit complicated because of when the census is taking place and and a lot of
00:18:24 the east european population will have declined so maybe the white british share might not have
00:18:31 gone down much but i think the the white share will have dropped so the white share also dropped
00:18:36 i mean including white european uh that percentage uh declined and i think that will be what declines
00:18:43 the most in london um yes but i think yeah i i think the bigger question of course is the greater
00:18:50 metro if i have to guess i don't know i mean it'll be interesting to look at the metropolitan
00:18:54 london area including outside the m25 to see if there are pockets of rapid change outside the m25
00:19:01 um because from the north american experience you know we would expect to see something like
00:19:07 that occurring sort of a suburban ring diversifying is something that we've seen a lot of
00:19:14 The other thing is, of course, this then leads to, I mean, it feeds very much into the politics of populism and polarization because, and there's been quite a bit of psychological research on this, that some people are innately, I mean, this is 50% heritable, 50% genetic.
00:19:30 Some people are innately positive about these kinds of changes, and some are negative about, they see these changes as loss, and they see diversity and difference as disorder.
00:19:43 So you're getting a very sort of split reaction to these sorts of changes.
00:19:47 And that's that's feeding a lot of the political device that we're seeing.
00:19:52 And then once you get a reaction to those changes on the populist right, if you like, that then leads to a counter reaction on the sort of identity left.
00:20:01 And then you're into a sort of second tier moral polarization layered in on top of the polarizing reaction to the changes.
00:20:09 So it's sort of a, it's definitely a recipe for a totally new kind of politics.
00:20:15 Emma, you know, carrying on from Eric's point there, you know, I remember that when the point was made about London being minority white British for the first time, there was this, I think it was on Newsnight, the point was, what does this matter?
00:20:30 this point does this matter um all i can say is that for a lot of people who watch our channel
00:20:36 but i suspect also not just who watch the channel i think yeah it matters a lot you know i mean
00:20:42 what's your view on it do you because if this was any other country in the world wouldn't it be a
00:20:48 cause for some concern yeah i remember going to a talk on the pew statistics um i think they were
00:20:56 from 2015 or 16 on demographic changes and religious change and the panel was there was
00:21:05 just come it was completely unanimous in its agreement that this change was a good thing
00:21:11 and I think to pick up on Eric's point about people innately I guess you would say feeling
00:21:19 particular attachments and not being comfortable with change I think that what's missing in the
00:21:25 public debate is this is the sympathy for that perspective and the immediate assumption that
00:21:32 that um that way of thinking is irrational or in some way immoral um and i think that we would
00:21:41 limit the the sort of potential for as eric was saying these particularly polarizing populist
00:21:49 movements if we were to give those views a fair hearing because they are rational and i think
00:21:54 people really do feel a sense of loss and they don't necessarily feel a sense of loss
00:21:58 because they're racist or xenophobic or prejudiced against the incomers but because they see the
00:22:04 disruption of their own communities and you know people people develop bonds over years and over
00:22:12 generations with their neighbors in particular areas and i think the metropolitan elite within
00:22:16 london don't realize that because they are a transient population themselves um they are the
00:22:23 um the anywheres of david goodhart and so i don't think that they really fully understand the
00:22:29 perspective of people who feel such so much of an attachment to place and to the population in that
00:22:34 place not on the grounds of ethnicity but like eric was saying on the grounds of um a shared a
00:22:43 shared history um and i think as you're saying about as populations change and people intermarry
00:22:49 the particularly anti-British sentiment that is developing within certain aspects of our culture
00:22:57 I think I'm interested to see you know whether people would choose to identify themselves with
00:23:03 that history or with the history of the non-white parent for example because British history is
00:23:12 being seen as something that's toxic and in that case you kind of lose that shared foundation that
00:23:17 sort of um shared civic attachment that would create a more cohesive um cohesive community
00:23:24 yes i think i mean the point really is absolutely right but when when people do talk of course this
00:23:31 is a good you know this is a good thing huge change huge ethnic change uh this seems to be
00:23:36 something that characterizes the discussion of this thing in the west and i would say in in kind
00:23:43 of the self-hating west you know otherwise i mean does it does it would india have a discussion like
00:23:51 this would would russia would saudi arabia eric well um there are i mean there are countries that
00:24:01 you know they're much more blunt about this in in other places in most cases you know in south
00:24:06 africa you'd have pogroms against i mean black on black pogroms but i mean i you know what i
00:24:13 would say is that there is a lack of nuance in this entire debate over ethnic change because
00:24:19 the view is you're either open or closed so it's not a debate about faster or slower you're either
00:24:25 open to change you're close to change if you don't like if you don't like the speed of change
00:24:29 then you're close to change if you know and similarly with the idea of majority ethnicity
00:24:35 you're either someone who wants some sort of white pure ethno state and no more change
00:24:40 or you are open yeah so it's sort of taking
00:24:44 collapsing it into a black and white dichotomy is the way in which we're
00:24:49 having this discussion instead of saying some people want it
00:24:52 slower some want it faster maybe we need to slow it down to allow
00:24:56 for intermarriage and identity shift to occur and then
00:24:59 if you want perhaps we'll be comfortable with with
00:25:01 with a speeded up you know that sort of nuance or maybe there's an optimal level
00:25:07 of diversity? Not too much, not too little? No. I mean, you can't be in, you cannot say there is
00:25:12 too much diversity or you are again in that closed bad category. So there is just a complete shutdown
00:25:18 in logic when we discuss this. I mean, part of this is about a lack of understanding of the
00:25:23 psychology, which is again, well-established in the literature that attachment to is not the same
00:25:29 as dislike of. So, you know, if I'm really attached to my family, that doesn't make me
00:25:35 any more disliking of the neighbors than if I'm not attached to my family. And that's shown in
00:25:41 study after study. So yeah, you can be attached to your ethnic group, to the character of your
00:25:47 neighborhood, et cetera. If it's changing, you don't like that. It's mainly due to a loss of
00:25:52 something you feel you've lost in terms of attachment to rather than hatred of. And I
00:25:58 think those two are collapsed together as well. And that's also a big problem. And I don't know
00:26:03 how we get past this in the current moment? I think David Goodhart wrote a brave article for
00:26:08 Prospect, suggesting too much diversity a few years ago. But the thing is, with that, actually,
00:26:17 he did indeed and got into a lot of trouble for it as well, I think, David. But I mean,
00:26:21 I think the point really is, is that when there is what I think is called or was called super
00:26:26 diversity uh it leads to a breakdown in all sorts of social bonds such as trust you know amongst
00:26:34 not just intergroup but actually within different groups it's it it public uh volunteering for
00:26:42 example becomes less all of those sort of things tend to happen uh when you have that much diversity
00:26:48 um can i ask again you talk you mentioned david david goodhart there uh christopher caldwell
00:26:54 wrote a book about 15 years ago called Reflections on the Revolution in Europe, which was basically
00:27:02 saying, can Europe be the same with different people in it? I mean, something that Eric alluded
00:27:09 to earlier, which is that this is seen by most people as a cultural thing, something the elites
00:27:14 simply don't understand. They always see it in economic terms. Do you think, David, that Europe
00:27:21 can be the same, but with different people in it?
00:27:25 I can just about imagine that it could be.
00:27:29 Sometimes I listen to people from an Asian or African
00:27:34 or some other kind of background on the radio,
00:27:38 and I think what admirable people these are.
00:27:44 They're cleverer than I am.
00:27:46 They speak English better than I do.
00:27:48 if I were blind
00:27:53 I wouldn't be able to tell what ethnic group they belong to
00:27:56 which is different from my own
00:27:58 so on those occasions I feel rather optimistic
00:28:02 that it wouldn't matter
00:28:04 but those individuals are I think only a relatively small minority
00:28:10 of the overall, an educated minority
00:28:13 of the ethnic group populations
00:28:15 And there are others, particularly from South Asian Muslim backgrounds, who are very keen to remain together and who do not wish to embrace, or at least many of whom do not wish to embrace Western attitudes from the point of view of tolerance, sexual equality, and all the rest.
00:28:41 that they're happy to lead a life, as it were, in first world safety, security and health,
00:28:49 but one in a much more traditional cultural world.
00:28:55 But that has huge implications, doesn't it, Emma?
00:28:57 Yeah, I think that probably the situation has become a lot more complicated since that book was written,
00:29:04 partly because obviously we're talking about a concern about cultural change as generations come
00:29:13 and go and you know the population is substantially you know diverse from various different countries
00:29:20 and that it doesn't really have much continuity with the culture that came before but I think
00:29:27 what we're now seeing with this um new left or left modernism that eric mentioned earlier
00:29:34 i think that has complicated the situation because there isn't very much continuity between
00:29:40 that which is becoming a very prevailing culture amongst um particular segments of society
00:29:47 particularly influential segments of society there isn't much continuity between that and
00:29:51 what came before um and i think that discourse makes it much more difficult to even discuss any
00:29:58 of these issues um and so yeah i think that has muddied the water a lot um because it's a culture
00:30:07 that's being taken on by also the white british population in various ways and is kind of seeping
00:30:14 in to um to the the broader culture and so i think it's just more complicated than it was previously
00:30:22 yes it's sort of it's very uh interesting because the fact is something that uh david mentioned
00:30:27 there that you know the idea was somehow that huge diversity would make society very very open
00:30:35 but the fact is is that at least the european uh experience of it has meant that many of the
00:30:42 the groups coming are socially very very conservative uh or religious and that's had a
00:30:47 different effect eric has it not you know yeah i mean i i myself am less concerned about some of
00:30:57 the values that the the challenge to western values that sort of discourse i think that's maybe
00:31:04 there may be some of that but i think that ultimately um you know you'll probably get
00:31:10 you know, individualism and capitalism and democracy will roll on somehow. But I think
00:31:15 it's much more about this idea of the narrative of a people being continued, the traditions,
00:31:23 the memories, the folkways that are in some way connected to ancestry. And so if you have a
00:31:33 substantial part of the population that traces their ancestry and collective memories to another
00:31:38 part of the the world and that's simply going to mean a less distinctive uh society and a lot of
00:31:45 the what we would call the everyday markers of nationhood the folkways and and and uh the memories
00:31:51 and traditions would tend to erode now of course you're always going to have super diversity in
00:31:56 the cities and a certain space for the cosmopolitan to exist uh it's a question of balance and i just
00:32:02 feel that that's not where we are there is no balance it's really only one is good and the
00:32:07 other is the bad old monocultural past. So how we get back into some kind of respect for the
00:32:14 ethnic majority and its tradition, and now it's an assimilative ethnic majority, but
00:32:18 it's currently not got any real respect in the high culture. And instead, it's completely
00:32:24 dominated by the left modernist ideal where diversity is the highest goal. How we get out
00:32:30 of that cul-de-sac, I'm not quite sure. I think it's going to be a bit of a battle.
00:32:34 Yes, and in that context, I'm wondering whether the word English or England would go out with the population.
00:32:50 It's clear that people who come from all sorts of backgrounds may be happy to involve themselves British,
00:32:58 either British straightforward or British hyphenated, Black British, Asian British, whatever.
00:33:04 There is a much greater reluctance to call themselves English, and I would guess a greater reluctance on the part of those who can logically claim English ancestry to regard them as English.
00:33:16 And it may be that that word will become less and less used as time goes on.
00:33:26 As the white British or white English populations retreat to the suburbs and then to the country,
00:33:35 and as some have suggested in rather a fantastical view of the future,
00:33:41 retreat into the status of the hobbits in Tolkien's book
00:33:46 where in the future they are going to be a small secretive group
00:33:51 of people seldom seen and seldom heard.
00:33:55 And that's also spurred on by this, you mentioned earlier,
00:34:00 the sort of self-hatred.
00:34:02 If you look at what's going on at the moment with various councils
00:34:05 and the public space, they want the public space to respect
00:34:10 What they say are the values of the council, the values that we now hold, and they're the values of diversity. And so I think that attitude that has obviously become much more prevalent since the Black Lives Matter protests and the attitude that we have and that we teach towards our history, I think that is also accelerating people's reluctance to identify with those memories that Eric mentioned.
00:34:39 and will disrupt the continuity even if the population didn't change so rapidly because I
00:34:46 think people are very it's almost fashionable to disassociate yourself as much as possible so
00:34:53 even if you look at like the recent Adam Curtis documentary the way that Adam Curtis in it's a
00:35:01 you know a huge hugely popular documentary series the way that he portrays English folk culture
00:35:09 or even the desire to try and preserve folk culture he portrays that as almost as if it's
00:35:14 fascist to try and preserve it um that is if there's something um wrong and dark about those
00:35:21 things um and so i think that that cultural aspect will also have a serious seriously important
00:35:29 impact in that sort of continuity of collective memory and how we choose to identify ourselves
00:35:35 I know something that rather chimes with this is my own parents tended to refer to themselves as British until about the last 10 years of their life.
00:35:45 And suddenly they started talking about themselves as being English.
00:35:50 And it was very noticeable.
00:35:52 And I think that that has happened more when people feel that something is being lost, you know.
00:35:58 And also if anybody can be British, then almost like nobody is.
00:36:03 but you are english that was very clear to them what that meant but the only thing i would say
00:36:09 though um peter is that we're now seeing in the youngest members of the of say south asian groups
00:36:18 a slightly growing tendency to identify as english if they're in english right i mean it's not large
00:36:26 but it might be 20 or so uh whereas the generation it would be in the small single digits so i don't
00:36:33 think it's inconceivable that English too could become a sort of more civic kind of identity,
00:36:40 in which case the ethnic majority category would then retreat into something like in the U.S. where
00:36:47 it's sort of white American, for example. But I think, yeah, I think the lack of sympathy for
00:36:53 this group really goes back to the origins of left modernist ideology in the sort of 1910s,
00:37:00 actually, in the U.S., when Randolph Bourne and some of the bohemian intellectuals who came up
00:37:06 with these ideas really urged immigrants from, say, Jewish, Italian, and other immigrants to
00:37:14 retain their culture. So they wanted preservation, but for the exotic immigrant cultures, and they
00:37:20 urged the Anglo-Protestant majority of America to be cosmopolitan and to slough off. So ethnicity
00:37:29 is great for minorities and for immigrants. It's terrible for the majority. And that's a
00:37:34 contradiction. This is what I call asymmetrical multiculturalism. And so, for example, you will
00:37:39 see in Canada, where I'm from, for example, a complete romanticization of every myth and memory
00:37:45 of, say, the Aboriginal peoples, of immigrant populations, and the complete opposite for any
00:37:51 tradition of the kind of Anglo-majority. And so this is sort of a standard contradiction that's
00:37:58 embedded at the heart of this ideology and there's really no way around it i mean you can't and it's
00:38:03 very interesting because i think there was a piece in the london review of books of some writer went
00:38:08 out to the east end and found some fourth generation east end woman and was was talking about it and
00:38:14 until she started talking about immigrants and loss and suddenly he realized and he admitted
00:38:19 he realized that actually there's a contradiction in his belief system which was about exoticizing
00:38:25 authenticity except when it's your own and then you sort of reject it right so it's kind of a
00:38:30 really um schizophrenic kind of ideology that that that we've we've arrived at and i don't know how
00:38:37 we we get out of this really i think it's uh that you you could actually say that that is almost
00:38:43 many people say that's the basis of multiculturalism that actually multiculturalism was about
00:38:48 celebrating almost any you know culture but not the host culture i think multiculturalism as well
00:38:55 Although I think it arose as a coping mechanism to deal with demographic change in the first place.
00:39:05 And so in that sense, I think that perhaps that is one reason why the majority is kind of excluded from it.
00:39:13 And now that we have all of these new ideas that basically believe that whiteness in anything Western or anything Western or male is bad,
00:39:23 and evil or has the potential for violence and you know the ideas of systemic whiteness and
00:39:29 white supremacy being baked into the fabric of society that's where things are at now but i think
00:39:34 that when multiculturalism first arose it basically arose as a coping mechanism to deal with mass
00:39:39 migration in the first place as some kind of way of managing it with because we didn't have the
00:39:43 confidence to say you must integrate into the culture that is already here well actually it's
00:39:49 interesting if you look at old newsreels from the the first waves of immigration into britain
00:39:55 uh they were remarkable almost naively sweet and welcoming you know there were these people
00:40:00 telling the new immigrants these are our songs and this is how you sing them and and and at the
00:40:07 time probably that was seen as terribly kind of you know exactly what megamarker wanted yes
00:40:12 imperialistic and all the rest but now you look back and you think well actually they were trying
00:40:16 to welcome and and also this was sort of a way of kind of integrating um just uh finally i'd like
00:40:24 to ask you know what is the end game of this i mean when you say diversity is the main value
00:40:30 it's odd how diversity can be a value seems to me diversity is a thing it's not a value as such but
00:40:36 anyway they say diversity is the ultimate thing when will we reach the point where everyone's
00:40:43 happy or you know when is what is the end point of diversity david i think that boredom and
00:40:51 annoyance may have something to to do with this uh you mentioned earlier on um the role of black
00:40:58 lives matter in in um accelerating and accentuating um racial consciousness and uh um elevating um
00:41:07 the sin of racism to an even higher level of wickedness than previously it occupied which i
00:41:13 don't necessarily disagree with um um on top of that you've got you've got the megan and harry
00:41:19 business uh and there's been i think a considerable uh backlash in britain to that uh partly as a
00:41:27 consequence of what they themselves said uh and partly because of the of the i think very
00:41:32 unthinking endorsement which many of you must have read about uh from lots of people overseas
00:41:38 from the president of the united states downwards um and i wonder in in that context if it's
00:41:44 possible to reach as it were peak anti-racism um and and to reach a position where the positions
00:41:52 adopted are so unsustainable and so absurd, so annoying, that a last-ditch successful
00:42:02 rebellion, as it were, is possible in terms of the media and the things that people feel
00:42:09 able to say.
00:42:11 Yeah, I mean, it's very interesting to see, you know, of course, we look at the wokeness
00:42:17 uh and the cancel culture and all these phenomena um my own view is that that these attitudes were
00:42:25 have been there for for decades in the high culture and actually what's new in some ways
00:42:32 is the pushback and we don't even realize it maybe because we're we're part of it but if you
00:42:38 look at the number of organizations that have sprung up to oppose cancel culture the the
00:42:44 Harper's letter and the Heterodox Academy and Free Speech Union and the rise of this issue
00:42:51 into politics in a way that wasn't as true of political correctness when it came on the scene
00:42:57 in the early 1990s. It did not make its way into politics the way it's made its way into politics
00:43:04 now, where you've got the Trump administration going after critical race theory. And that is
00:43:10 now a major campaign at the state level. You've now got more attention being paid to media bias,
00:43:18 to what's happening in the universities. This is now a major political issue. And I think it's
00:43:22 only going to become a bigger political issue in a way that we haven't seen before. So I think
00:43:27 we're headed for a greater politicization of these cultural issues. And only through that are we
00:43:34 to get back to some kind of sanity i think yes well said yeah i i agree it's bleak though isn't
00:43:43 it um we're gonna have to walk through the fire to get to the other side right well on that note
00:43:49 look thank you very very much thank you david thank you eric thank you very much
00:43:54 uh don't forget to fill out your census form um i think that actually it's the 21st of march
00:44:01 it's when it is yes indeed where you actually basically have to put down who
00:44:07 is in your house at the time so there we go anyway this is a subject we will
00:44:12 return to certainly by the end of the year thank you very much indeed thank
00:44:17 you