New Culture Forum - May 23, 2021


What's The Future For Conservatism? Do Small Right Wing Parties Have A Future?

School Chaplain Reported To Terrorist Watchdog For LGBT Policy Sermon Joshua Humphreys - We Must Cherish Western Civilization

Episode Stats


Length

41 minutes

Words per minute

166.94

Word count

6,881

Sentence count

247


Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
00:00:00 Hello and welcome to Counterculture. I'm Peter Whittle. Now recently we had the local elections
00:00:19 which by and large were a big success for the Conservatives and a bit of a disaster for Labour.
00:00:24 them but what has happened therefore to the smaller parties that were standing and indeed
00:00:31 what is the broader question when it comes to what you might call insurgent parties where is
00:00:37 the next one actually going to come from because certainly in the past decade British politics has
00:00:43 been characterized by a number of parties coming up and then maybe disappearing and also for that
00:00:50 matter what is the future for conservatism as an idea. Now to discuss this I'm very pleased you
00:00:57 have with us today first of all Robin Akin formerly BBC journalist and a journalist now
00:01:07 for the Daily Telegraph. Also we have Patrick O'Flynn who is a former political editor of the
00:01:15 daily express of course writes for the spectator and the telegraph amongst others and rave hadleman
00:01:22 coo commentator and historian of course from the new culture forum um can i stop asking you patrick
00:01:29 because this was slightly inspired by a piece you wrote in spectator which was where is the next
00:01:34 insurgency going to come from i just wonder what do you think now in light of the elections where
00:01:41 Where do you think it's going to come from now?
00:01:43 Well, I think the election results underline my basic point,
00:01:46 which was the kind of new generation of smaller right-wing would-be insurgent parties
00:01:53 haven't found an issue to give them traction,
00:01:56 as we remember UKIP had with the push to Brexit
00:02:00 and the Brexit party had with the push to get Brexit actually over the line.
00:02:05 And they've taken various punts which haven't come good so far.
00:02:10 obviously Nigel Farage the one really really famous person with an enormous following on the
00:02:17 right has stepped away for now whether it's for good we'll see and Richard Tice is the successor
00:02:23 there and Richard's really taken a punt on taxation and over taxation and the potential
00:02:29 for tax cuts being an issue where traction will follow and that simply didn't happen
00:02:35 in in those elections. Lawrence Fox and Reclaim you know didn't really generate much broad support
00:02:44 either and I think that those parties there needs to be an amalgamation before they can even
00:02:51 get going at all and whatever you think about Reform UK and Richard Tice they are the only one
00:02:57 that features in opinion polls. I don't think any of the other parties you know the Heritage Party
00:03:01 things like that, have ever even had any recordable support in an opinion poll. So although
00:03:07 reform is on two to four percent, it owns the banner. And if the parties of both the
00:03:15 cultural and the economic right want to get going, they probably all need to agree that
00:03:21 there's a banner in the sand that they want to rally what potential support there is around.
00:03:27 and i don't even think they've they've reached that kind of base camp yet were you surprised
00:03:32 actually just when we think back to elections in london i was surprised pleasantly surprised but i
00:03:38 was surprised that you know that people always said oh these parties won't do very well in london
00:03:44 but then the tories actually did remarkably well actually in london didn't they yes and i thought
00:03:49 to be fair i ended up giving um sean bailey my second preference having you know really not
00:03:55 liked him when he was uh almost praising the metropolitan police for taking a knee
00:04:00 and there were various other ideas which i didn't think were terribly good ones attached to him
00:04:04 but he showed a bit of gutsiness i thought as the campaign uh wore on um and he did indeed do very
00:04:11 well and i think particularly in the in the outer boroughs and the idea that sadiq khan might win
00:04:16 on the first ballot uh was swept away but i think that reflects something uh that i've learned over
00:04:22 the years that the outer boroughs of London, the opinion as a whole in those places is not
00:04:29 markedly different from the kind of less fashionable southern towns or even, dare I say it,
00:04:35 the Red Wall, particularly on cultural and social issues. Although that is actually slowly
00:04:42 disintegrating isn't it Rafe, the kind of what they call the doughnut, it's demographically
00:04:48 changing as well isn't it demographically it's changing but I think the broader issue we have
00:04:55 to be asking here is is there any need for these right-wing parties that's the view of a lot of
00:05:00 people will be asking especially our viewers and those who voted UKIP and voted Brexit party
00:05:05 will be saying well what's the need UKIP and Brexit achieved what they wanted to achieve
00:05:09 we've now got this stonking majority with Boris Johnson in parliament holding the left to check
00:05:14 The left are now impotent. We see these headline-grabbing soundbites about, well, such as in the Queen's speech, about cancel culture being attacked in universities, about limiting asylum seekers crossing the channel.
00:05:29 We've heard before about potential reforms to the civil service and to the BBC.
00:05:34 So it seems on a superficial level as if there's no need for any more right-wing parties.
00:05:39 Of course, the reality is this is all, in my opinion, a fairly insubstantial policy in terms of the Conservative Party.
00:05:46 We know full well that Boris Johnson is really a metropolitan liberal, as you've seen by his choice in Girlfriend,
00:05:51 the most tree-hugging Tory you could possibly find.
00:05:55 There's no true conservatism in the Tory party.
00:05:57 Unfortunately, the Tory party's great success, the reason it is the world's most successful political party,
00:06:03 is it knows how to evolve and adapt.
00:06:04 It's never been very closely tied to ideology, unlike the left, which is one of the reasons for their problem.
00:06:09 And they've parked their tanks seemingly on UKIP's ground.
00:06:13 And so they seem to be addressing all of the concerns and grievances of small-c conservatives in that red wall.
00:06:20 The reality is very different, but it really takes these smaller parties to reveal to the public just how thin these Tory party pledges are.
00:06:29 Because, for example, on the university level, anyone who's banned from speaking at a university has to take this through the courts to get any financial address.
00:06:36 Who's going to go through that hassle?
00:06:39 And we've seen with Tim Davies, apart from cancelling the mass report, there's no proper reform taking place at the BBC, as Robin knows.
00:06:47 So those are the problems which are really afflicting and affecting the reclaim reform and the heritage, etc.
00:06:53 Would you say, Rafe, that it's a bit of a synthetic kind of conservatism therefore at the moment?
00:07:01 Yeah, very much. I mean, the way I see it is that Boris and the Tories benefited this time round,
00:07:10 still in the backwash of the success of achieving Brexit, you know, having delivered on that,
00:07:17 But then the success of the vaccination programme. I think, in a way, the election we had last week was masked some of the underlying real issues. So I think there's a real question mark about the authenticity of Boris's or the Tories social conservatism.
00:07:41 I mean, everyone is saying that it is social conservatives in places like Hartlepool who
00:07:48 are attracted by this anti-woke Tory party.
00:07:52 Well how anti-woke is the Tory party?
00:07:55 That's the real question.
00:07:56 I mean, it's a question of authenticity.
00:08:02 People are talking about Starmer and Labour having this very awkward coalition of social
00:08:09 conservatives in places like Hartlepool and then the woke social warriors down in London right but
00:08:15 the Tories have a similar problem in a sense we know that you know most most gut Tories or a lot
00:08:22 of gut Tory supporters are what one would term social conservatives is Boris going to deliver
00:08:29 on that and we didn't see that last week because there were other issues in people's minds I mean
00:08:34 I think the vaccination program, I think if you'd agree, I mean, it seems to me, Patrick,
00:08:38 that the success of the incumbent government or the apparent success and the vaccination program,
00:08:47 no, let's not be mean-spirited.
00:08:50 There has been a success with the vaccination program, hasn't there?
00:08:53 And I'm sure that that was a big factor in the Tory success last week.
00:08:59 Well, I'd agree with that to an extent.
00:09:01 There's been a vaccination bounce, definitely.
00:09:04 There's also, you know, getting Brexit done.
00:09:06 People watch Boris Johnson come through a heck of a lot of abuse and the establishment trying every trick in the book.
00:09:13 And whether people say he doesn't believe in a lot or not, he had enough belief to deliver and in a way salvage British democracy from the elite to deliver a meaningful Brexit.
00:09:24 And then, of course, he won his landslide.
00:09:26 So I think people think Boris Johnson is a big deal, Prime Minister.
00:09:30 You know, he's not just a stopgap.
00:09:32 He's not a Theresa May.
00:09:33 he's not a Gordon Brown he's not even a David Cameron he is potentially a Blair or Thatcher
00:09:38 an epoch definer and these are early days and and they're they're tempted to to roll with him
00:09:45 for a bit so I think in terms of the smaller parties of the right they need to be sort of
00:09:51 rooting out what the issues are what the issues are that he's not going to to cover and I suspect
00:09:58 actually that the immigration control is going to come back as a big issue we people have talked
00:10:03 about you talked about his him being a London liberal basically well you know on his his
00:10:09 immigration policy towards migration from India Hong Kong Chinese I think you're going to see
00:10:16 an upsurge in immigration without necessarily the public infrastructure being expanded to cope with
00:10:22 that. And we'll be back into just the issue that lit the touch paper for UKIP. And certainly none
00:10:29 of the other parliamentary parties, which are all in the grip of no borders fanatics, are going to
00:10:35 be taking him on on that. So I think there is a gap there. It looks to me like Richard Tyson reform,
00:10:40 it's not their natural territory. We'll see. I mean, I'm a member of the SDP, which is a bit
00:10:47 left on economics but but to the right on on on culture and very kind of um skeptical about mass
00:10:54 migration but again getting that to a position of having any traction uh does seem a long way off
00:11:00 too patrick's exactly right on this point and i don't know why richard thais didn't seize that
00:11:04 in hartley pool it seems to be very clear to everybody that it's those sorts of issues
00:11:08 which are far more cutting than pursuing a neocon thatcher idea of smaller state and lower taxes in
00:11:14 that region of the world former Labour voters aren't going to be attracted by that offer
00:11:17 similarly I was never quite clear why you know Reclaim would follow an anti-lockdown policy as
00:11:23 their central thing when most people in the country were actually happy with the levels
00:11:28 that things were at and if you're not appealing to the majority of people you're always going to
00:11:32 have a very slow a very very very low uptake I had huge hopes back in December when when Johnson
00:11:38 was I never I was always aware of Johnson never being a true conservative but I had great hopes
00:11:44 when I saw this red wall of new grassroots Tory MPs who were plugged into the needs and concerns
00:11:50 of their voters plus Dominic Cummings and the vote leave team who were very shrewd and knew
00:11:55 full well the path to success and had it not been for Covid and Barnard Castle Cummings would still
00:12:03 be there would still be untouchable and would still have had time to implement his policies
00:12:07 In terms of the long march through the institutions, which I think is a 10 or 15 year project, just as it was a 10 year project for Tony Blair to turn things in his way.
00:12:17 It requires the same amount of time. And we did have that opportunity earlier this year with Dominic Cummings steering things.
00:12:24 And the purge of Carrie Simons and her team against the vote leave, in my mind, was tragic because it really is going to show this Versailles court at number 10,
00:12:35 disconnected completely from the population in the north of England.
00:12:39 And that's why I think all of these headline-grabbing
00:12:43 social conservative soundbites are meaningless, really,
00:12:46 at the end of the day,
00:12:47 because you aren't going to see any great change on immigration,
00:12:49 which is the policy that should be adopted by right-wing parties
00:12:52 if they have any hope.
00:12:54 It's interesting, as you say about reform
00:12:57 not being particularly inclined to take on immigration,
00:13:01 but I don't think reclaim is either.
00:13:03 I mean, no one's particularly taking it on.
00:13:08 No, well, I mean, I think that Priti Patel is offering some good cover to the government on that
00:13:16 because I think most observers take her as pretty authentic on that issue.
00:13:25 I don't read Priti Patel as anything other than a fairly hard-line Home Secretary
00:13:34 who wants to deliver on limiting immigration.
00:13:39 I mean, like Rafe, I was very disheartened, actually, when Dominic Cummings was defenestrated.
00:13:47 basically because I think he's one of the few people
00:13:55 of the last three or four decades
00:13:59 who really gets what a problem the BBC is.
00:14:03 And I thought his tactic,
00:14:07 which he enforced at the beginning of last year
00:14:10 when he was starving the Today programme
00:14:12 of government ministers,
00:14:14 that was a very effective thing to do to the BBC.
00:14:16 It was very effective.
00:14:18 And, I mean, I wrote about this also and about the way in which the BBC really set out to get Cummings.
00:14:29 I felt that there was a definite campaign to delegitimize him over the Barnard Castle thing.
00:14:41 And I suspect that the reason for that, part of the reason for that,
00:14:45 I mean, there were journalistic reasons to go after him.
00:14:49 I accept that.
00:14:50 I also think that within the BBC, they saw Cummings as somebody who was a real threat to the corporation.
00:14:57 And it was no coincidence that the BBC mounted that fierce campaign against Cummings over those months,
00:15:05 over something which really, frankly,
00:15:08 when you look at the substance of the allegation,
00:15:13 they were piffling.
00:15:14 And any father in his position of a young child like that,
00:15:18 I thought was entirely legitimate what Cummings did, actually.
00:15:22 But, you know, there was rejoicing, I am sure,
00:15:25 in BBC corridors when Cummings was given the he-fail.
00:15:28 And I think it's an enormous shame.
00:15:30 Although, just as a final point,
00:15:32 I would say that the installation of Robbie Gibb
00:15:35 as um one of the uh one of the um unitary board members at the bbc last week or two weeks ago
00:15:43 i thought that was an encouraging sign because i don't think robbie gibb robbie gibb knows where
00:15:48 the bodies are buried in the bbc he knows what he's about that bloke when he was head of bbc
00:15:53 westminster he made it known that you know he wanted there to be a different approach to to
00:16:01 Tory issues and Tory politics and I have some hope that the reform programme within the BBC
00:16:09 has not entirely expired with the departure of Cummings. It sort of it feels to me like they
00:16:17 row back you know actually again going back to this synthetic point you know that they were
00:16:22 really going to be tough on the BBC you know and and and there was talk of decriminalising the
00:16:28 the license but I think that's been kicked into the long ass hasn't it now I mean do you think
00:16:34 just go back to that point that Rafe made actually Patrick do you think that it was wrong for the
00:16:39 smaller parties this time to coalesce which they all seem to do around the lockdown issue you know
00:16:45 you saw these demonstrations and reclaim and reform and it sort of seemed to me that you know
00:16:51 when it came to actually support for that in the country it was quite obstinately always around
00:16:57 about 20 30 percent yes and i think as time went on probably dipped below uh that and i i think
00:17:04 that showed that just as there is a liberal left twitter bubble there is also a right twitter
00:17:11 bubble as well which was very galvanized around anti-lockdown even to the point of punting
00:17:18 conspiracy theories about uh covid on its fringes um that's not said there is a serious point
00:17:26 about the dictatorship of the majority that we should all talk about post-COVID just because
00:17:33 you know 65% of people might say they want to legally ban you from stepping outside your front
00:17:39 door is that a legitimate reason for a law to be passed to prevent you doing that and you know
00:17:46 what core of individual rights supersede that and what how severe does an emergency have to be
00:17:53 for the government to do that and none of that really got talked about so there was certainly
00:17:57 an intellectual point about liberty there but in terms of it having mass purchase no it didn't
00:18:07 and I think it's kind of undermined the potential breadth that something like Reclaim can manage.
00:18:15 I don't think necessarily Richard Tice's credibility was harmed particularly and he seemed to
00:18:20 uh articulate anti-lockdown in a slightly more uh nuanced way but no it wasn't a winning horse
00:18:28 that's for sure it sort of seems to me really that uh they're sort of out on a limb these parties
00:18:36 but you mentioned a banner issue in fact immigration is that the only one is that
00:18:43 if you're looking to the future once this euphoria has gone away from the election
00:18:47 to the Tories. What issues, I mean, to me, it seems that people are, actually, you mentioned
00:18:53 in your article, Patrick, there's not enough disgust around, I think, is what you said.
00:18:58 Yeah, there isn't enough. I see disgust everywhere. Well, I think in general, there's not, because
00:19:05 I think actually that Boris Johnson is a kind of brilliant centrist. He, I mean, even
00:19:11 on environmental stuff, where again, the right Twitter bubble thinks he's bankrupting the
00:19:17 country and it's all nut nuts and and and this stuff if you look at the polling i was looking
00:19:22 at the underlying issues polling today concern about the environment is now number three and
00:19:27 he's got it covered and he's got it covered in a way that the voters see annoys the tory right
00:19:32 his ultra keynesian response to the the covid crisis annoyed the tory right but that largely
00:19:38 seemed to to to come through okay and yet he annoyed the liberal left massively by delivering
00:19:44 brexit i think he he is he has got a blend of issues in a sort of pragmatic disraelian way that
00:19:51 that do constitute a sort of conservatism and it's the sort of and general sense of patriotism and
00:19:57 being happy with the flag and all that that labor aren't and it's the conservatism that that keeps
00:20:03 labor out and prevents the country from from really going into a socialist tailspin and that's
00:20:09 always been one version of conservatism and you know he's a he's a master of it but do you but do
00:20:16 you not feel that robin that people are i get feeling of intense anger and an exasperation i
00:20:23 mean this isn't just me looking in the mirror i i do on the issues of free speech on the issues
00:20:30 of trans on the issues all these things day in day out yeah oh it's never ending i agree with
00:20:38 you. And I think that there is a, albeit a minority, a growing minority, which is fed up
00:20:46 to the back teeth with wokeism. And these issues, the ones you mentioned, these are the things which
00:20:54 really animate a real sense of anger amongst a minority of people. And they tend to be on the
00:21:04 right you know it's absurd isn't it that free speech is regarded as a right-wing issue i mean
00:21:10 just saying that it's it it's such a it's such an oto's construction that of course it's not
00:21:21 right you know free speech is an issue for everybody and i think that the the salience
00:21:27 of that issue will in time animate the left also because it's interesting that i mean
00:21:33 across the water in Washington, there are now voices even within the Democratic Party
00:21:40 who are raising concerns about, for instance, what happened with Trump and Twitter and the
00:21:47 other big Silicon Valley companies which have banished the man. And that is something which,
00:21:58 whatever you think of Trump. I actually happened to be, I was rather a fan of Trump, so I was
00:22:03 outraged by it from the beginning. But people on the left can see the dangers of that, surely.
00:22:09 I think the salience of that issue will rise. I mean, just on this question of the minor parties
00:22:14 of the right, to me, I think there isn't at the moment an issue around which they can coalesce
00:22:22 properly i think in time the tax issue which has been identified by reform and by richard tice
00:22:29 that's an issue which might in a few years time have more salience because
00:22:35 i mean we there's a big punt isn't there on the economy at the moment we don't know what's going
00:22:41 to happen to inflation we don't know what the treasury is going to have to do about raising
00:22:46 taxes to cover all this money we've spent on furlough and all those kind of things
00:22:49 Now, if at some point the tax rises begin to rub and they begin to rub on ordinary middle class folk, that's a point at which you could get an issue which really gave something for a party of the right to run with.
00:23:10 We're not there yet.
00:23:11 The problem with the small right wing parties is that the Tory party is appearing to tackle cancel culture issues, is appearing to tackle work issues.
00:23:19 They have the union flag behind every MP when they speak on television.
00:23:23 You're seeing these headline-grabbing soundbites.
00:23:26 And, of course, we know that that's not the reality.
00:23:28 But also, at this current time, he's got Brexit done.
00:23:31 The vaccination program is going pretty well.
00:23:34 The people are grateful for the furlough scheme and the fact that people haven't got high on employment rates.
00:23:39 The economy is doing, hopefully, very well.
00:23:41 We're supposed to have the biggest rebound, I think, in Europe.
00:23:45 In my view, unless immigration and work issues,
00:23:49 work issues on their own, I don't think are big enough of an issue
00:23:51 to get people to vote for a party, right?
00:23:53 Work issues are an annoyance for a lot of people, a huge frustration.
00:23:55 But I can't see that on its own.
00:23:58 Tied with immigration, possibly there's an opportunity there.
00:24:00 But I would imagine, unless immigration gets completely out of control,
00:24:04 easily be 10 years or so before you get the growth of an issue
00:24:09 similar to Europe, which caused UKIP's rise.
00:24:13 There's 10 years now of Tory rule.
00:24:15 What used to annoy me for the past 15, 20 years was
00:24:18 in every manifesto of the Tory party, there was a pledge to lower immigration.
00:24:23 At the end of that four years, they had broken that pledge phenomenally
00:24:28 and they again made a similar pledge.
00:24:30 And I thought, at what point are people going to realise they are lying blatantly?
00:24:33 So even immigration, you know, I do wonder about whether that's actually,
00:24:36 even that's going to be sufficient of an issue.
00:24:38 And I think as well, the Tories clearly have a talent for shape-shifting.
00:24:42 And if there is a bit of traction picked up on tax cutting, then Rishi Sunak may discover he's more of a tax cutter than Boris Johnson was. Liz Truss will step to the fore. Sajid Javid might be recalled. And they'll suddenly all believe in galvanising incentives by lowering taxation.
00:25:03 and will you know the small business community might say thank you very much to the little party
00:25:08 that put it on the agenda but come polling day in a general election uh all of history tells us
00:25:15 it's better the devil you know and they'll go back to the conservative party thing is is that
00:25:20 with the tory party you can't keep away from it can you i mean the thing is with them is is that
00:25:26 they have got this ability to give the impression look at the queen's speech you know in fact it's
00:25:31 Not unlike the STP, you know, tacking right culturally,
00:25:35 tacking left economically, but very skin deep.
00:25:39 And they managed somehow to give this impression.
00:25:42 But actually, when it comes to it, I mean, it is really,
00:25:47 there's not very much there.
00:25:48 And I think there will come a point, maybe, surely,
00:25:50 where people sort of see that and sort of,
00:25:52 what do we hear all the time?
00:25:54 You know, going back to UKIP there,
00:25:55 it was, why do you trust the Tories all the time?
00:25:58 Why do you keep trusting the Tories?
00:25:59 if you look over to france i mean you know you can see an issue there
00:26:04 you know where there seemed like whole parts of the army
00:26:08 writing letters to the government saying that the country is disintegrating
00:26:12 yeah this issue which is the one of radical islam islamism
00:26:16 whatever you call it what you want has taken a real backseat
00:26:18 yeah no absolutely this is one that actually could arise again is it not
00:26:22 well it it is but i mean you only have i mean you have to stand back sometimes
00:26:28 and just admire the sheer slipperness of the Tory party on these issues.
00:26:36 And that sounds like a very pejorative thing to say,
00:26:39 but what I mean is the way to success in British politics
00:26:45 is to occupy the centre ground, isn't it?
00:26:48 To actually construct a coalition which is going to give you a majority
00:26:55 in the first-past-the-post system.
00:26:56 And the one thing you mustn't do is scare the horses.
00:27:01 That's the thing.
00:27:01 You can't frighten the horses.
00:27:03 So issues like immigration, issues like Islam, radical Islam,
00:27:08 if the Tories were to come out too vigorously on those issues,
00:27:17 there would be a backlash.
00:27:19 And that's the thing which they want to avoid.
00:27:21 And, you know, the success of the Tory party is, you know, pundits are always saying this about how it's the most successful political party in the Western world.
00:27:32 That's true. It is, actually. And it's shown itself to be resilient and it shapeshifts all the time.
00:27:39 It tacks with the wind, whichever the way the wind is blowing.
00:27:42 So in other words, totally lacking in principle is what you're saying.
00:27:44 Well, he's sort of, you know, I mean, the thing is, but do you not, you know, the thing is, if politics is about, if being in power is, you know, the whole point of it, isn't it?
00:27:55 And they are, and they have been, and they probably will be for the next decade.
00:28:01 Well, you know, that's what political success looks like.
00:28:07 Churchill once said, it's very hard for a nation to look up to somebody who always has his ear to the ground.
00:28:11 but that has been the secret to success for Boris Johnson certainly
00:28:16 and it's that shape-shifting nature of the Tory party
00:28:19 which I think smaller parties should use to their advantage
00:28:22 because it's a mistake to view these parties as rivals or alternatives to the Tory party
00:28:28 our electoral system simply alone means that there's absolutely no chance
00:28:32 that they're going to get into power
00:28:33 rather than alternatives I view them more as regulators
00:28:36 or as quality control commission
00:28:41 Just as UKIP, if it wasn't for UKIP,
00:28:43 there would have been no EU referendum, right?
00:28:45 Brexit Party was there to keep their feet to the fire.
00:28:47 And so on things like, if they are going to shapeshift on immigration,
00:28:50 let it be these parties that threaten their majority,
00:28:53 and only then will you see change.
00:28:54 And that's really the dynamic, you know, that I...
00:28:57 In both of those cases, the UKIP and then Brexit Party,
00:29:00 in some ways, I mean, the Brexit Party came up like that, didn't it?
00:29:02 Largely because of Nigel Farage.
00:29:04 But it came and it did what it was meant to.
00:29:07 you know it kept you know it basically kept them honest didn't it but um the interesting thing here
00:29:13 surely is that you say that uh it's got to be these pressure groups essentially uh but then
00:29:20 you look at the left and they do have an array of parties actually with traction with representation
00:29:28 well i think it may be that the log jam is more likely to be broken on the left because the labour
00:29:33 party is going to have to start justifying its position as one of the big two parties and it's
00:29:39 it's going to lose a fifth general election in a row I think it will lose at least as badly as it
00:29:44 lost in December 19 which will take the sixth general election in a row out of their remit and
00:29:49 you have you know the Greens now getting traction representing this tribe that Robin was talking
00:29:55 about the urban graduate liberal left in rather an exciting way for them and they're not lumbered
00:30:03 all this Labour Party baggage. So it may be that something breaks on the left and then
00:30:09 it filters across to the right somehow and opens up new opportunities in ways that we cannot at
00:30:15 the moment foresee. But I think that's a more likely thing is Labour, it won't disappear,
00:30:22 but it might become a party of 150 seats maximum and there's room for other things.
00:30:27 I think this is a fundamentally important point, right?
00:30:31 UKIP and then the Brexit Party
00:30:32 became closest to breaking this two-party system that we had.
00:30:37 You know, if you look at the Brexit Party,
00:30:40 had Theresa May remained in power
00:30:42 or had Rory Stewart succeeded her,
00:30:44 there would have been over 100 seats for the Brexit Party.
00:30:47 Boris Johnson was the only Tory party leader candidate
00:30:49 who was assured to secure a majority.
00:30:52 All of the rest would have basically started
00:30:54 perhaps the inevitable decline of the Tory party.
00:30:57 Now, would that have been a good thing or a bad thing?
00:30:59 What we have to realise is, despite what we've seen in the local elections, a minority of
00:31:03 people in this country vote for centre-right parties.
00:31:07 The majority of people in this country vote for the left.
00:31:10 So the first part of the post system gives us this false idea that this is still a naturally
00:31:15 conservative country, when we know full well that 60% of this nation vote for left-wing
00:31:20 parties.
00:31:21 The Conservative Party's success is the fact that there's a fragmented left between the
00:31:26 the SNP, Greens, Plaid Cymru, Labour, and so forth.
00:31:30 If you could take up all the parties who voted in the local elections,
00:31:34 fewer than 37% voted for centre-right parties,
00:31:39 and you had 64, 65 voting for parties on the left.
00:31:42 And this is the same with any general election.
00:31:45 It's the fact that the Tories have this ability to secure a majority government
00:31:49 with 36 or so percent of the population voting that gives a Tory majority.
00:31:54 So if there wasn't to be any electoral reform, for example, and you were going to open it up to the fact, because it was grossly unfair against natural justice for UKIP in 2015 to secure 3.8 million votes, which is equal to the combined votes of the SNP and the Lib Dems.
00:32:11 They got 64 seats between them and there was one MP for UKIP.
00:32:17 That's unfair.
00:32:18 So you can understand why you would want to have proportional representation.
00:32:21 But if you do that, then say goodbye to any future right-wing government in this country.
00:32:26 You'll just have successive Labour and left-wing coalitions.
00:32:30 And that's a sad reality.
00:32:31 I do take issues slightly with this idea, you know, people vote for left-wing parties.
00:32:36 They might not perceive them as left-wing because the fact is that, what is it, 65-70% of people, for example, didn't want the songs at the proms to go.
00:32:48 I think that's far more of a guide, actually.
00:32:51 Sure, but I don't know anyone who wouldn't say that Labour, Lib Dem, SNP, Plaid Cymru and the Greens aren't left there, right?
00:32:56 No, but isn't the point there, Rafe, that some of these issues we've been talking about, like free speech, for instance, or immigration, some of the people, so if you vote for the Greens, you're not necessarily somebody who wants to see an end to female lavatories, not necessarily.
00:33:19 Although the Greens and their activist base are probably the most militant pro-trans party.
00:33:26 So to an extent, some of the voters might not be voting for that reason.
00:33:33 So if you say, well, 60% of the voters vote for left-wing parties, what I'm saying is that that is true at a factual level.
00:33:46 So can't be argued with. You're right.
00:33:48 But there are issues which cut across all parties and underlie the headline voting patterns.
00:33:57 So that what we're talking about is cultural politics, aren't we?
00:34:01 And so these can't be pigeonholed.
00:34:04 You know, it isn't the case that only people who vote Tory are worried about free speech.
00:34:09 It's not only Tories who worry about gender issues
00:34:15 and this idea that we can be whatever the hell we want to be
00:34:19 just at the drop of a hat.
00:34:22 That's absolutely correct, but these are still left-wing parties.
00:34:25 It's a minority of people who vote for those parties
00:34:28 who are not from the left.
00:34:30 For example, I think it was one-third of Green Party voters were pro-Brexit.
00:34:35 25% of S&P voters were pro-Brexit.
00:34:39 These are substantial minorities, but they are still minorities, and they don't carry the day when it comes to the manifestos of those parties.
00:34:47 So yes, absolutely, free speech is not a right-wing issue, or transgender rights, but my point is the very battle that's going on within Labour right now between social services and the woke.
00:35:00 That's being replicated in other parties where the distinction is even more extreme.
00:35:04 And I'm sorry, but I don't believe that people who may be slightly concerned about these issues
00:35:09 are going to carry the day when it comes to the manifestos
00:35:12 that will be implemented by these future left-wing governments.
00:35:14 If you accept that, for example, Labour might always be at 150 or 200,
00:35:20 it becomes a kind of zombie party, never quite get there.
00:35:23 Isn't it the case that one thing that could happen is that they could adopt a policy of total electoral reform?
00:35:29 It could then be in their favour?
00:35:30 They could do. They could think there will come a parliament and an election where us, plus the SNP, plus the Liberal Democrats, Greens, Plaid, SDLP, we'll get 326 seats, we'll change the electoral system, and then it's under new rules.
00:35:47 And that could have, I don't quite agree that then we're kind of anchored with the left of centre majority in parliament,
00:35:53 because I think political opinion in those parties, if they did implement some of the more extreme woke ideas,
00:36:01 might shift to the Conservatives and other parties of the right in bigger ways than they have done yet.
00:36:08 But we're into a new world then, that's for sure.
00:36:11 In previous decades, I might have agreed with that.
00:36:13 The problem is we have not only a cultural divide in this country, we have an age demographic divide.
00:36:19 And the fact that the younger generation, particularly the university educated, I mean, what was it when Corbyn was elected?
00:36:26 If those under 25 had been the only ones to vote, there would have been 500 seats of the Labour Party.
00:36:32 And that's my concern is that what you're saying is correct.
00:36:35 But as the years go on, there's inevitably going to be a lurch to the left, as we're seeing, because of, you know, I call them indoctrination camps.
00:36:44 You might call them universities.
00:36:46 And the teacher training colleges, we know, where fewer than 10 percent of teachers vote Tory.
00:36:50 And I think this is where the Tory party can't be complacent.
00:36:53 And I think it is complacent.
00:36:55 It's resting on its laurels that it has this huge majority.
00:36:57 But if it doesn't tackle the time bomb of the younger generation's political allegiances,
00:37:03 then the Tory party is on short time.
00:37:05 I think apparently, as well, Ed West has pointed out that, in fact,
00:37:10 you know this whole thing, you know, you're left-wing when you're young
00:37:12 and you become more conservative.
00:37:14 Apparently that's not happening this time.
00:37:16 They're sort of staying into the 30s and 40s.
00:37:19 That might be because they're delayed in becoming owner-occupiers.
00:37:23 Yeah, it's time they grew up.
00:37:25 I mean, and housing policy, therefore, could become crucial.
00:37:31 And whether the Conservatives are so in the pocket of the big developers for various reasons that they're always talking a good game and never delivering.
00:37:38 You know, that's an issue that, you know, if I was Keir Starmer, I would come up with a really massive house building policy concentrating on council houses as an issue that could perhaps unite the metropolitan left and working class communities.
00:37:55 policies as well, for instance, which he hasn't come up with any policies at all, has he?
00:37:59 Can I sort of finish by asking you one thing, might seem very a superficial consideration,
00:38:04 but maybe not. What do you think the effect on this, of GB News will be? Do you think
00:38:10 it'll have any effect on this kind of discourse and these outcomes we're talking about?
00:38:15 Well, I'm devoutly hoping so, because I think, you know, from my perspective, I think that
00:38:21 The left has owned the game, the broadcasting game,
00:38:25 for decades, and there has not been a platform
00:38:30 for, I was just gonna say right-wing news.
00:38:36 What I mean, really, is news that fairly reflects
00:38:40 the issues which concern people like us on the right.
00:38:44 And GB News, we have yet to see it,
00:38:49 see it. We've yet to understand it. And I think the problem for me, I think, with GB
00:38:55 News, I, you know, I fail to see how it's going to make money. That's really...
00:39:01 That's a different program. But, you know, but I have great hopes that it is going to
00:39:09 redress the balance to an extent. Well, I mean, put it this way, the last election,
00:39:12 this election, turned on the news, a friend said to me, turned on the news and they thought,
00:39:18 am i in an alternate universe because the news was about this great labour surge in wales right
00:39:25 they had sort of basically you know uh very much gone never sized up what do you think about do you
00:39:30 think it's going to make a difference enough to make a difference to our general political culture
00:39:35 i think there's a potentially very large audience for it and i hear that andrew neill is deadly
00:39:41 serious about not being rushed and getting it right um i i know they're aware don't just become
00:39:47 the fox news of of the uk i think that's quite right they need credibility uh and just by being
00:39:54 more balanced than the existing broadcasters they will be quote more right wing because the liberal
00:40:01 left gender completely dominates not just the bbc but sky and itv news channel for news completely
00:40:08 so um i think they have a very large potential uh market share but but i do hear what robin says
00:40:14 about are they going to make money and i've read articles from people fairly expert in their
00:40:19 business who can't work out how they would no i agree completely i think it's exciting i'm looking
00:40:24 forward to it with eager anticipation and i think it's it's crucial that they avoid um going down
00:40:31 any anywhere near the sort of path that fox news has done if they're going to have any credibility
00:40:35 in this country because this country is a lot more centrist than than america is as a whole
00:40:39 and so if they are to also sway minds and hearts it's important that they actually
00:40:44 do have that balance and I think that's why Andrew Mule's going about it in exactly the right way.
00:40:48 I think the point being is that they might start covering stories that basically make
00:40:54 the centre-right agenda wider. Anyway, we shall see. I think it's the autumn that's coming, isn't
00:41:00 it? But Robin, thank you very much. Patrick, thank you. Rafe, as always, thank you. That's
00:41:05 it for this week. Please do remember to subscribe, won't you? But we shall see you next time on
00:41:11 counterculture. Thank you.