New Culture Forum - July 15, 2021


Widdecombe, Webb & Woberts - Episode 1

Alexander Adams - Why The Left Hates Good Art Legendary Pollster Frank Luntz: The British Public Are Deeply Disillusioned

Episode Stats


Length

35 minutes

Words per minute

192.05

Word count

6,878

Sentence count

162


Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
00:00:00 Hello and welcome to the New Culture Forum's brand new current affairs show,
00:00:14 Widdicombe, Webb and Wobberts. My name is Emma Webb and I'm your host and I'm delighted to
00:00:20 introduce to you the former Shadow Home Secretary and former Brexit Party MEP, Anne Widdicombe,
00:00:26 and comedian Abby Roberts. Anne and Abby will be joining me every show to discuss the madness and
00:00:32 mayhem in our politics, news and culture. And if you would like to get in touch and send us
00:00:37 questions please do so in the live stream and we'll discuss them throughout. It's been quite a
00:00:42 mad week this week with our failure to win the Euros against Italy, with the imminent so-called
00:00:49 Freedom Day and also with some very interesting new statistics about British attitudes towards
00:00:56 wokeism and freedom of speech. So shall we begin by discussing the football and what we saw
00:01:03 recently with particularly attacks on the Home Secretary Priti Patel for what she had previously
00:01:11 criticised taking the knee and then condemned the racism after the football. What are your thoughts
00:01:16 on that? Well, I thought the attack was completely baseless. I mean, I criticise taking the knee.
00:01:21 doesn't make me a racist, means that I think it is offensive. I mean, not only stupid, but offensive
00:01:26 to actually indulge in a gesture to an organization which wants to defund the police.
00:01:34 I mean, it's just as well we had the police around when there were all those attacks after
00:01:37 the football match, you know, just as well we had them around. So any organization that wants to
00:01:42 defund the police and proclaim anarchy, basically, is not worth taking the knee to. And Priti Patel
00:01:48 is fully entitled to say that and it is in no way contradictory of that to condemn racism no way
00:01:55 what do you think abby of footballers that have sort of come out condemning those who have
00:02:02 have criticized taking the knee suggesting that they are somehow responsible for the sort of racist
00:02:07 abuse that some of the players received after failing to get those penalties in the goal well
00:02:11 i don't know if you heard my sigh um when you asked when you came to me um what can i say thanks
00:02:17 a lot America for giving us your politics you know wrapped up in a nice and a nice bow marked
00:02:24 you're completely crazy to you know a political organization like BLM that wants to defund the
00:02:31 police you know end capitalism oh does that sound a bit like communism yes it does and we should be
00:02:37 saying no thank you very much we don't want that in our sport we don't want that in our schools
00:02:41 we don't want that anywhere near us and frankly if you want to you know stop racism do it in your
00:02:48 everyday life when you come i mean how many of these you know these liberal lefties um with
00:02:54 their rainbow flags have actually in their job stood up for somebody who had racism which i have
00:03:01 done i've lost work i've lost a job this is about 20 years ago um a girl that was um was getting
00:03:06 abuse you know she was black i said that's enough and i was fired and i want people oh hang on why
00:03:12 were you fired i was fired because i stood up for her no but on what grounds were you fired they
00:03:16 never did it for that what grounds were you oh well they said it was because um you know i was
00:03:20 oh they said something like oh we don't come along and interfere in your job and i said yeah but you
00:03:24 were you were blatant you were openly being racist to my colleague so what i'm saying is
00:03:30 rather than doing all this you know take the knee all very well and good but just your politics in
00:03:35 your everyday life treat people as you would like to be treated i still say the answer and i know
00:03:42 that you know a lot of people don't agree that i still say the answer is to be colorblind i do not
00:03:46 notice whether the person i'm talking to is black white or bright green i do not notice as far as
00:03:51 i'm concerned i'm talking to that person as a person as a human being exactly and that's what
00:03:55 i thought that's what we all i thought hang on a minute i thought that's what we all were when we
00:03:59 liberals you know liberally minded that's a person i'm you know in i mean last year i remember
00:04:04 someone saying to me that martin luther king was now no longer relevant what i guess that's the
00:04:09 irony though isn't it because that's the point that people who have been criticizing taking the
00:04:13 knee that's exactly the point they're making they're saying this is inextricably associated
00:04:17 with an organization and a movement that tells people that the solution is to not be colorblind
00:04:23 to see race and then the consequence of that is that people do see race so yes the whole the
00:04:29 whole argument that taking the knee is divisive for that very reason they don't seem to understand
00:04:34 that those positions are coherent,
00:04:37 that it's possible for the Home Secretary
00:04:38 to condemn racists
00:04:41 and also to, say, taking the needs divisive.
00:04:43 55% of the British public think Black Lives Matter
00:04:45 made racial tensions worse than this country.
00:04:48 But it's all about identity politics.
00:04:50 Yeah.
00:04:51 And the politics of grievance
00:04:52 and the politics of looking for grievance
00:04:54 on behalf of other people,
00:04:56 not just on your own part.
00:04:57 And also, where does it end?
00:04:58 I mean, I tweeted earlier today,
00:05:00 maybe slightly unwisely,
00:05:02 that maybe women now should,
00:05:03 basically go against
00:05:07 what's happening in trans activism
00:05:08 which is a raising female biology
00:05:10 maybe women should get down on both knees
00:05:12 Oh not at my age
00:05:14 I'll help you up
00:05:16 but you know for solidarity
00:05:18 because basically what I'm saying is you take one knee
00:05:20 then you take two knees, I mean what's next?
00:05:23 You'll be lying prostrate on the football pitch
00:05:25 and I frankly say
00:05:27 just get on with playing football
00:05:28 and win the World Cup
00:05:29 We've got a comment here from
00:05:32 a lady called Sharon who says it's absurd to say that Priti Patel is stoking racism she's been a
00:05:38 victim of racism all her life she merely opposes this Marxist BLM taking of the knee it was
00:05:43 interesting because actually Calvin Robinson also this week had hell from Billy Bragg when he did
00:05:50 this I think it was a Channel 4 interview and Billy Bragg same suggestion that the people who
00:05:56 have been criticising taking the knee now have no right to you know cheer on a multi-racial team
00:06:02 it's absurd and what's more we've got to stand up to it i mean what worries me about this all the
00:06:07 time is that that people don't stand up to it uh and and they're afraid then to speak and they're
00:06:13 afraid to take those positions well that actually is what is at the root of a lot of the trouble
00:06:18 it's that people will not stand up to it and if people simply turned around and said rubbish get
00:06:22 a life do you think that the consequence of this is going to be that people will find it harder to
00:06:28 criticize taking the knee because now they've made this sort of rhetorical sleight of hand where
00:06:33 it's now associated with the racism they've suffered and they're saying well this was why
00:06:37 we were taking the knee in the first place yeah and i think billy bragg i mean he needs to apologize
00:06:41 for all his protest songs because they're the worst the worst i don't know if you ever heard
00:06:45 them. I'd never even heard of Billy Bragg.
00:06:47 Bought Dylan he ate is all
00:06:49 I'm going to say.
00:06:51 So we've got another comment here from
00:06:53 Barry who says, why don't football
00:06:55 teams just do another non-devisive
00:06:57 gesture like linking arms that's
00:06:59 nothing to do with BLM?
00:07:01 Interestingly, Millwall did
00:07:03 actually, and it wasn't very reported on,
00:07:05 it was very reported on when Millwall booed
00:07:07 the fans booed taking the knee
00:07:09 but apparently earlier this year
00:07:11 Millwall fans
00:07:13 actually cheered when the players linked arms
00:07:16 and held up a sign that said
00:07:17 inequality with the I.N. slashed out.
00:07:20 So it's quite clear that the fans are not booing
00:07:22 because they're some racist troglodytes.
00:07:24 They're booing because they think
00:07:26 that the taking of the knee
00:07:27 is associated with Black Lives Matter.
00:07:29 And probably because they hate gesture politics.
00:07:31 It's not even just the association
00:07:32 with Black Lives Matter.
00:07:34 It's that you're doing something
00:07:35 that is frightfully fashionable and in.
00:07:37 But actually, what does it mean?
00:07:39 Yes.
00:07:39 What does it mean?
00:07:40 What does it mean in your everyday life, precisely?
00:07:41 And, of course, we saw all the terrible riots last year in America by BLM protesters, you know, trashing shops and businesses and scaring people and being violent.
00:07:55 So we don't want that. We don't want that, you know, association.
00:07:59 well actually interestingly that leads on to another subject that has been big this week and
00:08:05 that is the study from the center for policy studies where um the famous legendary pollster
00:08:12 frank luntz um he found that or set out a sort of prophetic warning that we have imported
00:08:18 our identity politics from the u.s something i think that we all knew but he did a deep dive
00:08:24 with some polling and focus groups into the minds of the British public to see what their views were
00:08:31 on this it's quite interesting I've got some of the stats here he found that apparently 38% of
00:08:36 the British public don't actually know what woke means and over a third over a third know nothing
00:08:44 about cancel culture however he also found that 57% of 18 to 29 year olds think that Britain is
00:08:54 institutionally racist sorry 15 no no 57 57 and and this is particularly interesting for free
00:09:03 speech 28 of people had he found had stopped talking to another person because online or in
00:09:09 because of views that they hold but amongst amongst 18 to 29 year olds it was 52 so more
00:09:18 than half of millennials have stopped talking to someone because of their political views so his
00:09:23 warning was that, as you say, Abby, we've imported this dangerous way of thinking from the United
00:09:30 States. And they're happy to admit it. They've not only done it, but they're happy to admit that
00:09:33 they've done it. It's become completely normalised in my generation, I guess. Normalised too. Well,
00:09:38 and also, let's be honest, I mean, I was thinking today, you know, it's weird looking at Cuba
00:09:42 running away from communism and the West seems to be running towards it and implementing all the
00:09:49 things that we were terrified by under in mao's china you know they're denouncing yeah they not
00:09:54 speaking to somebody because oh my goodness i don't want to be seen speaking to them because
00:09:57 that might mean i get a knock on the door to take me away i mean people say oh but you're just being
00:10:02 over dramatic no not really because that's how it all starts you know yeah i mean what it's about
00:10:06 is totalitarianism it's about the suppression of free speech so no we're not going to have police
00:10:11 on the doorstep to throw us into the lubianca but we can have police on the doorstep to query what
00:10:16 we've said and what was behind our thinking and what it actually has happened yeah and our
00:10:21 neighbors as well saying well we saw her doing whatever she's doing you know we might want to
00:10:25 report her i mean that's not that's not the snitching so we've got a question here from
00:10:30 marcus who asks is britain doomed if the majority of young people are embracing woke values how can
00:10:36 the tide be turned well it's doomed if we sit back and do nothing about it yeah if all we do is wring
00:10:41 our hands and say it's disgusting and you know you're not going to get us anywhere we've actually
00:10:45 got to stand up to it now one of the things that I think we can be pleased
00:10:49 about there are signs we're doing that I mean you know GB news has come along the
00:10:52 new culture forum has come along and there are actually signs that Toby
00:10:58 Young's free speech that actually signs that there is now a kickback against it
00:11:04 but we don't need to give up and we really need to be brave about this and
00:11:08 people need to be brave about this and their places of work and to say no with
00:11:12 all due respect that's right and we do and i'm afraid i'm ashamed to say as a comedian that
00:11:18 maybe me and maybe two other comedians are very vocal vocally i mean i'm known as the woke finder
00:11:24 general um amongst my friends and i talk radio here she comes quick hide um oh no no don't hide
00:11:31 actually just keep speaking because obviously that would be a bit weird if i'm trying to cancel
00:11:33 as well but um i'm i'm very very shocked that there is not there are not more people in the
00:11:40 arts particularly comedy because it sort of likes to push push back and rightly so um i am amazed
00:11:48 that there's not there are not more people willing to say well i don't agree with that you know so i
00:11:52 am spartacus now i'm spartacus where are there other spartacuses well probably spartacus got
00:11:56 crucified there and i think that people are just afraid of what's going to happen yeah but i mean
00:12:04 let's be honest okay that's the that's that's an extreme version i wouldn't be you know suggesting
00:12:09 that but um for myself obviously but i know i was thinking this the other day is that when someone
00:12:13 said to me oh but you know people might lose their job or they might you know you might get bad reviews
00:12:17 in a comedy show i'm like do you know the men like soldier nitsin went yeah take me to the gulag
00:12:22 take me to the gulag and they did and they did take me to the gulag event we shouldn't be laughing
00:12:29 about this ann come on it's a serious trouble and they took him to the gulag and he was there saying
00:12:34 this is for freedom
00:12:36 it's worth doing this because
00:12:38 of who comes after me
00:12:40 generation who come after me
00:12:42 Solzhenitsyn and Sakharov if you remember
00:12:44 the physicist Andrei Sakharov
00:12:46 they if you like to put it another way got away
00:12:48 with it because of who they were
00:12:50 because they had big names
00:12:52 because they had huge international reputations
00:12:55 but if you were
00:12:56 Mr or Mrs Ordinary Russian
00:12:58 nobody was going to stand up for you
00:13:00 if you were Ivan Denisovich
00:13:01 I'm glad you can say it I can't
00:13:03 Russian is my second language.
00:13:06 But anyway, we'll talk about that later.
00:13:09 But, you know, I, yes, I say to people, what have you got to lose?
00:13:13 I mean, you've got a lot to lose, but really, I mean, is, you know, on balance, you know, we're talking about...
00:13:20 Do you think maybe the tide is turning against this world view?
00:13:24 No, I don't think it's turning, but I think, as I said just now, there are signs of a pushback.
00:13:29 And we've really got to keep the momentum going behind that pushback.
00:13:32 and everybody's got to do it.
00:13:34 It's no good to use my Solzhenitsyn and Sakharov analogy,
00:13:38 just the big people doing it.
00:13:39 Yes.
00:13:40 Everybody's got to do it.
00:13:40 Everyone's got to join in.
00:13:43 Sanjeev asks, isn't the core problem our education system?
00:13:46 So is that something that, obviously,
00:13:49 it's actually quite interesting from the Centre for Policy Studies research.
00:13:52 He found that young people were actually more likely
00:13:56 to think that the country was institutionally racist
00:13:58 than non-white British people.
00:14:01 so suggesting that there is something that is coming from our education system that we're
00:14:06 educating people to view society in this way do you what do you think you know in answer to
00:14:11 sanji's question is the core problem our education system is there something we can do to with the
00:14:16 education system to try and well what we know is that if teachers do push back against it and try
00:14:21 to give a balanced view and invite pupils to comment uh we do know that the next thing is
00:14:27 they're in trouble there are protests you know and so it's actually it needs quite a lot of
00:14:34 courage if you're just one teacher in a very big system it needs quite a lot of courage but it is
00:14:40 what we need and this is the long march through the institutions is where we are now yeah that
00:14:45 march has taken place we've got people at the head of all institutions now or in positions of
00:14:52 huge influence in all institutions now who do not take our view who take the
00:14:57 view that there is only one right answer yes now you know the essence of
00:15:02 university teaching in my day was there are many answers and you can decide
00:15:07 between them but there are many answers never any just one right answer yeah
00:15:11 and that is yeah it's very worrying I would say that the well I was gonna say
00:15:15 god where are the unions when you need them the teachers you know sorry to
00:15:18 a hand that's going to be offensive to your ears
00:15:20 I've got the unions but seriously
00:15:22 where are all the blooming teachers
00:15:23 just when teachers' unions are needed
00:15:25 they're all scurrying, they're all in the
00:15:27 staff room, hiding behind
00:15:30 the settee, they should be out
00:15:32 saying no, this is
00:15:34 not acceptable, like you said
00:15:35 education is a range of views
00:15:38 and how to think
00:15:41 education is about rigour
00:15:43 rigour and thought
00:15:43 not what to think, how to think
00:15:45 the situation in Baton is a perfect example of the fact that
00:15:47 I mean, even when teachers have attempted to, you know, speak out during the Batley and Spen by-election,
00:15:54 none of the main candidates were willing to say anything other than a kind of mealy-mouthed response.
00:15:59 Deadly silence. I mentioned it in my Express column. Very good column, by the way, every Wednesday.
00:16:03 Every Wednesday. You don't mention it.
00:16:07 But it's true, Batley and Spen. I mean, who would have thought that we'd...
00:16:10 And there's a campaign, you know, raising money for the teacher because nobody else...
00:16:17 So the public, I think, has raised something like 60 grand now,
00:16:21 which I think is wonderful.
00:16:23 So if only we could have that part, the public, doing more.
00:16:27 Silent minority is silent.
00:16:29 That's the problem.
00:16:30 Majority, sorry.
00:16:31 The silent majority is silent.
00:16:32 They need to speak up.
00:16:33 The main resistance in Batley came from the bin men.
00:16:37 The bin men of Batley, you mentioned the unions,
00:16:39 were the ones who were pushing back against it.
00:16:41 The British people would be behind this.
00:16:43 The bin men.
00:16:44 The bin men and this teacher.
00:16:46 But isn't it outrageous that, you know, it's been months and this teacher is still in hiding, fearing for his life, his family.
00:16:52 Well, he ought to come out.
00:16:53 In modern Britain.
00:16:54 Yeah, he ought to come out of hiding now.
00:16:55 Yeah. And, you know, we talk about gesture politics taking over the airwaves.
00:17:00 What about a teacher who's scared for his life?
00:17:04 I mean, he's got a fatwa on his head.
00:17:06 You know, let's not kind of like, you know, mince words here.
00:17:09 The Salman Rushdie thing, this is what's happening to this teacher.
00:17:11 So, I mean, the fact that, you know, we're folks so obsessed with these kind of, you know, gestures and, oh, you said this.
00:17:18 And did you really mean this when there's a man in hiding, I think says a lot about where we are.
00:17:23 As I say, you should come out of hiding now.
00:17:24 Yeah.
00:17:25 Come out of hiding and face it down.
00:17:27 Face it down.
00:17:28 So Maggie asks, she says, the Centre for Policy Studies said that people are fed up with big business as well as politics.
00:17:36 Are these woke corporations damaging their brand?
00:17:39 That's an interesting question, isn't it?
00:17:41 I can say all the corporations are so woke, I'm surprised that anybody's against them
00:17:46 who's woke.
00:17:47 Yes, exactly.
00:17:48 I mean, again, we come back to the free market.
00:17:51 It's like, well, maybe, I mean, these institutions, they're going to find out, aren't they?
00:17:58 Because people don't want to buy their stuff.
00:18:00 Stop banking with Barclays or eating Ben and Jerry's ice cream.
00:18:04 But it only needs a handful of people, it seems to me, on Twitter to protest.
00:18:08 immediately you know the boards of all these big companies are bowing down to
00:18:12 them instead of just saying go and get a life to do you think this is partly the
00:18:16 Twitterfication of real life that all of these corporations think that Twitter
00:18:20 is the real world even though the majority of people are probably not on
00:18:23 any form of social media at all I think it's it's just instantaneous panic
00:18:28 basically and it's panic on the part of whoever's picking up the phone and
00:18:31 dealing with public relations on the day and I'm quite certain that's what
00:18:35 happened in the ikea case with gb news i'm certain that's what happened there that somebody picked
00:18:40 up the phone answered it for oh oh oh you know this is terrible yes you know we're going to
00:18:44 review it because he thought that was the safest thing to say yeah and of course it wasn't and
00:18:49 and ikea very quickly backed off but they only backed off because there was a backlash yes there
00:18:55 has to be a backlash every time but you're right that in those in those businesses institutions
00:19:00 There are in place that little, you know, the Long March, the useful idiots and the setting sums, I think of them as, you know, that are there and they've got their little sort of hooks in.
00:19:13 And I think that's what we're fighting against, isn't it?
00:19:15 Charles Moore recently said in his Spectator column that the National Trust apparently, some whistleblower, a member of staff from the National Trust said that during their interviews,
00:19:27 they actually ask the way in which the candidate voted in the referendum and if they say Brexit
00:19:34 then they don't get the job they ask that well any candidate with any guts would say none of
00:19:39 your business mate that's what I would say none of your business secret ballot none of your
00:19:44 business yeah how dare you ask me yeah exactly more people need to shall I go to the Daily Mail
00:19:49 and tell them you asked me you know I mean come on yeah so Rob says nice sentiment from Abby but
00:19:56 nine out of ten university academics are now left-wing and fewer than 10% of school teachers
00:20:00 vote Tory they are the problem not the solution nice sentiment I haven't heard that for a long
00:20:07 time um well yeah and what can I say I think we need to I think we need to have build I think we
00:20:16 need to build new institutions then I think well we either have to get drain the swamp I actually
00:20:22 think we need to use law and i very rarely say that because i don't think if it moves legislate
00:20:27 you know i i just don't think that at all but i think this is an occasion we're doing it of course
00:20:30 for the universities where we're actually making law now that says you have to guarantee free
00:20:35 speech yeah and i think similarly in schools obliged by ofsted you know and therefore obliged
00:20:41 in turn by government specification they should have to look at all sides of an issue you know
00:20:48 that is what they should be doing and they should be taught as you say not what to think
00:20:52 how to think rigor rigor i mean in my day they were so rigorous yes and my day was so long ago
00:21:00 what are your thoughts abby on the higher education freedom of speech bill do you
00:21:03 think it's a good thing or a bad thing i think it's a fab thing i think it's wonderful i mean
00:21:12 i think yes i think it's wonderful but the fact that we have to legislate to have free
00:21:17 speech in our institutions is is uh yeah it's a little a little bit worry worrying um but um
00:21:23 now i mean i i like i like i said as many views as possible in the sunlight let's have a look at
00:21:30 them and any ones we find is stated we can go well you don't really don't really sort of don't
00:21:34 really like that you might have to revisit that it's interesting that one of the criticisms they
00:21:38 say it will put a sort of a burden on universities a burden of bureaucracy and so on without
00:21:44 recognizing that this is absolutely central to the functioning of a university if you can't have a
00:21:49 free exchange of ideas that's why i think the criticism when people uh have have criticized
00:21:53 the bill because they say that um you know that we will add this extra it would add this extra
00:21:59 burden of bureaucracy that it will create a culture of complaint when we already have a
00:22:03 culture of complaint in universities um the the solution is not to legislate the solution is to
00:22:09 is to argue within the university settings for for for free speech for academic freedom but you
00:22:15 can't actually argue for those things unless at this point unless you legislate in order to protect
00:22:19 a space in which people can argue exactly otherwise you'll shut down if you say we want
00:22:23 free speech or shut up and then that's the end of that argument yeah i know i mean the the arguments
00:22:27 against it on those grounds are specious i mean they're just being made because nobody actually
00:22:32 wants to say i don't believe in free speech and so they introduce bureaucracy and there's this
00:22:36 reason and there's that reason what those people actually mean is they don't believe in free speech
00:22:41 they believe their view should be the preferred view yes yes exactly so while we're on the topic
00:22:48 of authoritarian drift my segway my segway darling freedom day so-called freedom day
00:22:57 on the 19th is it going to happen will it be a real freedom day who'd have thought in 2021 in
00:23:03 united kingdom we'd have freedom day i mean the day when you get some of your civil liberties
00:23:10 back so much we had to doff our caps as we walked the tanks rolled by you know it's like you know
00:23:15 with boris johnson with a huge moustache but i mean i just think the freedom day what are we
00:23:20 doing when we didn't we have that last month june the 21st wasn't that sort of nearly freedom day
00:23:25 and now it's going to be freedom no no no it's not going to be freedom the one before the one
00:23:30 before was nearly nearly this is now nearly freedom but it's but it's not really going to
00:23:36 be freedom day because they've they've already backtracked on possibly having more it would be
00:23:41 freedom day if they stuck to what boris actually said when he announced it which was you must use
00:23:47 your own judgment and he used the analogy that i used in the express every wednesday very good
00:23:52 column he used exactly the same analogy which is that there is a difference between a rammed tube
00:23:57 train and an empty railway carriage and therefore we should be able to allow be allowed to use our
00:24:03 common sense if he put a full stop there that was fine but ever since then he's gone on elaborating
00:24:11 as to what decisions we should make and handing the power to individual organizations to decide
00:24:17 what decisions we should make yeah so you know if that's freedom i'm a dutchman yeah exactly
00:24:24 that's probably racist actually how dare you but also handing the power to Susan what's her name
00:24:29 Mitchie who is you know a communist thank you Richard Madeley for for asking that question
00:24:35 which was you know I thought was a great question to ask when he interviewed her but also Sage so
00:24:38 you've got a person you're right you're handing the decisions to somebody who quite likes the idea
00:24:44 of people not having that well it may not only be Susan Mickey or Mitchie however you say her name
00:24:50 who thinks that because apparently according to a you gov poll 71 of the english people support a
00:24:57 delay two thirds two two thirds of brits plan to keep wearing masks an ipsos mori poll found that
00:25:05 19 support and a nationwide curfew at 10 p.m permanently uh 30 35 said that they would have
00:25:15 gone around the asylum they would have a 10-day quarantine uh period after traveling abroad
00:25:20 forever and one in four want nightclubs and casinos to be permanently closed oh my god
00:25:26 do you think those polls are fair do you think that is actually what the british people think
00:25:35 i think a lot of people want to go i don't know about some of the others but i think a lot of
00:25:39 people want to go on wearing masks but my view is that's fine let them as long as i don't have to
00:25:44 You know, as long as we really can make our own judgment, given the situation around us.
00:25:49 And I don't mind wearing them in hospitals. That is a judgment which I would concur with.
00:25:53 But I do not want to be told by the people who want to wear masks that I should happen to wear one.
00:25:58 Yes, precisely. And also, I think with this mask thing, this is what worries me.
00:26:02 Again, we're back to the Boris Johnson handing over responsibility.
00:26:06 Because they've said you can sort of choose, guess what?
00:26:10 the mask fetishists because that's what they are I've seen people with masks that match their
00:26:14 clothing I'm like that's like matching your lipstick to your Guantanamo Bay jumpsuit
00:26:18 for heaven's sake what are we doing here this is this is madness do what we're gonna have is we're
00:26:25 gonna have people who love wearing masks and then me and Anne and you and everyone watching who won't
00:26:31 be wearing masks I'm gonna plagiarize that comment thank you great at last my work is
00:26:39 going to be out there what do you think of the fact that so the i mean you mentioned u-turns or
00:26:44 boris saying one thing and then reality being otherwise it seemed that they weren't going to
00:26:48 go ahead with the vaccine passports then they started talking about this nhs app which looked
00:26:53 like it was a vaccine passport by the back door and now they're saying that they advise large
00:26:57 venues to use a form of vaccine certification um and that and this is quite interesting they
00:27:04 actually said that and this is this is a direct quote um if sufficient measures are not taken to
00:27:09 limit infection then the vaccine passports could become mandatory so they're basically saying that
00:27:13 come freedom day the restrictions are lifted but if you don't continue to voluntarily enforce them
00:27:20 then we will deprive you of your civil liberties by having vaccine passports and apparently the
00:27:26 reason why the according to a government source the reason why they they want to have this vaccine
00:27:31 certification is actually to try and i'd say encourage what i mean is coerce young people
00:27:37 into having the vaccine of course regardless of the fact that nine in ten adults have antibodies
00:27:43 regardless if they've had the vaccine or not so they want to coerce the young into having the
00:27:47 vaccine so one of these government sources again this is this is a direct quote said if we can show
00:27:53 show real benefits of getting vaccinated in terms of everyday life then it could be a could be quite
00:27:58 a useful tool so what they're really saying is that it could be quite useful to us if we deprive
00:28:04 people of their civil liberties so that they do exactly what we want in order to get those civil
00:28:08 liberties back yeah i think they're doing something slightly more subtle than that to be fair
00:28:13 um let me take two two analogies one with cctv cameras now uh you're far too young to remember
00:28:20 and i suspect you are too but when cctv camera and i was in government at the time so i remember
00:28:25 very sharply when they started coming out there was huge resistance to them and people said they're
00:28:29 the spy in the sky uh and certain councils said they'd never have them and refuse to have them
00:28:35 blah blah blah blah then we had the horrible murder of jamie bulger and we had those images
00:28:42 of the cctv who actually managed to film the two boys who were taking him out and suddenly
00:28:48 everybody said oh it's got a purpose and we couldn't quite suddenly government couldn't
00:28:53 afford all the demand that was coming in for cctv another one again you won't remember we used to
00:29:01 have a thing called bank check guarantee card so that if you wrote a check you had to present this
00:29:05 card uh and people some people said i'm not having one of those my name on my check is good enough
00:29:10 and the bank said okay you don't have to have them but it became so impossible to pass a check
00:29:14 without one that just about everybody with an account had one now i think they're trying something
00:29:20 similar here they're saying okay you don't have to you don't have to have the vaccination
00:29:23 but if you do and if you have a certificate you know it's going to bring you benefits now actually
00:29:29 i don't object to that anything like as much as i would object if they said you've got to have a
00:29:34 vaccine i really don't object to it i i do not object to an incentive but if they're if they're
00:29:39 making life so impossible that you can't partake in life impossible so you can't go into a night
00:29:44 or a restaurant or a pub inevitably because ross uh ross i think his name is ross clark he wrote
00:29:52 brilliant um article in the telegraph i think it was today um about the direction of travel like
00:29:58 you say with the cctv cameras where it's towards vaccination that it's towards he thinks that this
00:30:04 is drifting in the direction of having electronic id cards um and he he joked that you you know
00:30:10 about going into a theatre and saying, well, sir, your seat is, you know, number 10, but let me just
00:30:17 have a look at your ID to check whether or not you've said anything on social media that we find
00:30:20 distasteful. Yeah. Whether it is going to drift in the sort of, yeah, like the Chinese CCP style
00:30:26 social credit system, that this will become some kind of permanent electronic ID. Look, I don't
00:30:32 think we need to go too far down the conspiracy theory route. I mean, I think that is always a
00:30:37 danger. I mean, I object to the curtailment of liberty, but there's always a danger that you
00:30:42 will go down some 1984 route, and you'll see things that are going to happen in the future,
00:30:48 which probably aren't going to happen at all. I think, you know, I carry a vaccination certificate
00:30:54 when I go to Ethiopia. I have to. I have to be vaccinated against yellow fever. I do not object.
00:31:00 I had to be vaccinated in the old days, not now, against cholera for many countries. I did not
00:31:05 object i don't object to having to show in certain circumstances that i have had something um which
00:31:14 is required i i know i'm a lone voice in this gathering but but i think as long as it's not
00:31:21 made compulsory if all they're doing is producing incentives i really don't have a problem yeah
00:31:26 my one is slight issue with that is is with um i mean obviously i'm not a doctor i haven't got
00:31:31 medical knowledge but yellow fever and um things like japanese encephalitis and although it's
00:31:36 cholera oh i haven't been vaccinated against that have you not had the japanese it's wonderful i
00:31:40 highly recommend it just get that disease out of my head i have read in medical journals the
00:31:46 argument which is that the reason that i mean even those vaccinations are not mandatory i mean you
00:31:52 could you'd be a fool to go to a country not have yellow fever or cholera or japanese encephalitis
00:31:56 you can't enter ethiopia without a certificate but the difference is those diseases if you get
00:32:01 them will likely kill you whereas COVID-19 with this this virus we're talking about will likely
00:32:08 not kill you that's international travel rather than domestic. Overwhelmingly statistically won't
00:32:12 kill you yes exactly well statistically so that's that's my problem with all this is that we seem
00:32:17 to be hitting a little tiny tiny little pin with an enormous mallet and if it's about it's called
00:32:23 a sledgehammer and a knot sledgehammer and a knot thank you very much thank you for saving that
00:32:28 if if if you're making a risk assessment though if as i say nine out of ten people have antibodies
00:32:35 then what is the purpose of having a vaccine passport if the risk to those who are vaccinated
00:32:40 is so small yes from the unvaccinated because i think it's a question of of your medical privacy
00:32:46 right because this is about setting a precedent of having having a certification that shares your
00:32:53 medical information. That's the door we're opening. With companies. That's the Orwellian
00:32:58 door. Are you not worried that that sets a dangerous precedent? Yeah, because so much
00:33:03 has happened over the last, I mean, for me personally, so much has happened, not personally,
00:33:06 but just sort of viewing it as an outsider. So much has happened that we wouldn't have
00:33:12 thought would happen. That's why I'm more trepidatious, if that's even a word, than
00:33:18 is about the not going, looking ahead and thinking, hang on a minute, you know, because
00:33:25 who would have thought, I mean, who would have thought that someone like Canada would
00:33:29 be burning churches in 2021? But here we are. So my argument is, maybe we should start
00:33:35 having a little look at what potentially could be down the road.
00:33:39 Just as I have criticised the government throughout for disproportionality, that's what I've criticised
00:33:43 them for. I think now your fears are becoming disproportionate.
00:33:47 Do you think?
00:33:48 Yeah, I do.
00:33:49 What happens if they're not?
00:33:50 I mean, what have I got to lose by having those serious concerns?
00:33:55 Which I see people who are not, you know, the Mothra Ravie Ludi Party.
00:33:58 You are very welcome to your serious concerns.
00:34:01 I do not wish to curtail your free speech.
00:34:03 I merely wish to say that I think that just as I believe the government and the scientists
00:34:09 got things out of proportion, you are now getting things out of proportion.
00:34:13 even though we've had promises that have been gone back on.
00:34:18 Oh, that's new in politics, isn't it?
00:34:20 People going back on their promises.
00:34:22 Where have you been living for the last two decades?
00:34:26 It goes with the territory of being in politics.
00:34:29 Now, now, we're running to the end of the show now.
00:34:32 I've never thought about five to win, but after 16 months,
00:34:36 seriously, 16 months of this authoritarian regime we've had,
00:34:42 I think I could be allowed for being a little bit hot under the, if I had a collar, but I haven't.
00:34:47 I'm wearing a rather revealing sweetheart neckline, which I know you've had your eye on, Anne.
00:34:55 But I'm just going to, I'm just going to do what's the word, yes.
00:34:59 What a way to win.
00:35:01 Final words, Anne, final words.
00:35:06 Final reflections.
00:35:07 Look, freedom is important.
00:35:09 So is proportionality.
00:35:10 and I think that the government has got it wrong and is getting it wrong again because they're
00:35:17 effectively handing the power that the law had to individual organizations to decide just according
00:35:23 to them what is going to happen I think it should come back to what Boris originally said which is
00:35:27 wholly within the discretion of the individual that is what I think should happen that to me
00:35:32 would be proportionate and would be actually trusting grown-ups to use their own savvy
00:35:38 and on that note folks thank you very much for joining us thank you ann and abby
00:35:43 and please join us next week and subscribe in the bar below thanks very much