00:09:15I'm 40. I'll be 44 here in a few months. But I was even seeing this idea of marriage as a
00:09:21capstone, not as a foundation for life, even when I was in my 20s. So I got married young. I was 22.
00:09:28And I remember I got engaged and I was back home for Christmas and I was at a friend's house
00:09:34from high school and I was talking to his parents. And I said, yeah, I got engaged.
00:09:39And this guy's mom just looked aghast and said, why would you do that? And I was like,
00:09:44what do you mean like i love this this girl we're gonna get married she said you need to get a job
00:09:49first i'm like okay well so even then this was 20 20 over 20 years ago you're seeing this yeah and
00:09:58and wherever you are too in different parts of the country so we were conducting focus groups in
00:10:03philadelphia and raleigh north carolina and we heard this from especially the the men who talked
00:10:10about the need to grind and to work really hard before they would think about marriage or long-term
00:10:16partnership. And part of the reason was that they felt like that was just how it works, but also
00:10:23that to be valuable as a partner, they needed to demonstrate they could provide. And so, you know,
00:10:29we've come so far when it comes to all these traditional gender norms being re-evaluated
00:10:36and reassessed. But when it comes to the criteria for men, like how they're evaluated when it comes
00:10:43to romantic partnership, the provision, the capacity provides still looms really large.
00:10:49Yeah. One of the big points you make in the book is that women and men don't really understand each0.98
00:10:54other. Like when you talk to young men and young women, they really struggle to imagine what life
00:11:00is like for the opposite sex. Do you think there was a time when the sexes understood each other1.00
00:11:05better? Or is this just a continuation of something that's always been around?0.60
00:11:11I mean, I think it's, it's so difficult, right? And it always has been, there's been,
00:11:15you know, books written, uh, men are from Mars, women are from Venus.
00:11:20Yeah. The right men are from Mars, women are from Venus that it talks about all the different ways
00:11:25that men and women communicate the way they express feelings. Obviously some of this stuff
00:11:30is tied up in cultural norms. But I think there was more avenues to learn that you spend time
00:11:38with someone who's a member of the opposite sex, you experience or you learn from them, right?0.95
00:11:44That, oh, this is something that happened to me on the way to school or on the bus. And through0.99
00:11:50these repeated interactions at school or after school, hanging out at house parties, maybe at
00:11:56church, that slowly you would, these kind of mysteries would be revealed that you'd be like,
00:12:01okay, got it. Yeah, this is very different. How you think about clothes or fashion,
00:12:04how you think about athletics, how you think about dating and sex, all these things like that,
00:12:09there are profound differences between boys and girls. And I think part of the problem today is
00:12:15this reveal, this understanding that grows out of regular interaction has been reduced.
00:12:22There are fewer opportunities that young people have to learn about each other through these sort of shared interactions simply because they're having fewer of them.
00:12:31There's a social deficit that young adults today participated in all these different activities less when they were growing up.
00:12:38They were less likely to have a part-time job.
00:15:06But it's also warping young people's understanding of each other and themselves.
00:15:12What they're seeing online is not representative.
00:15:14They're seeing, because of the algorithms that feed on insecurity and anxiety, they're
00:15:20seeing some of the most negative content and portrayals of the opposite sex and their motivations
00:15:25and interests, especially around dating and relationships.
00:15:29So if you're, for instance, a guy who's perhaps a little shorter than average and you're a
00:15:35little concerned about your height when it comes to dating and whether women will be
00:15:39interested, what almost immediately is going to be fed to you on social media is women,
00:15:44attractive women saying, you know, oh, I don't date anyone shorter than six feet tall, or,
00:15:50you know, these extreme videos of like, oh, you know what, if you break your legs,1.00
00:15:53you can get a couple centimeters height if you do it in this way. And that is incredibly distorting
00:16:00because like, that's crazy. But that's the kind of content that these folks get. And it creates
00:16:05something called illusory norms which is the idea that extreme behavior because of how often you see
00:16:12it becomes your your reality becomes normalized and there's something inherently dangerous about
00:16:20that yeah i thought this is the most interesting chapter because i've seen this as well when i get
00:16:24on social media youtube or instagram immediately you've just seen all this content about dating
00:16:30and like you said yeah it's like if you're a dude like you see this stuff that's like
00:16:34well, if you're not in fine, like what's that, that if you're, I want a guy in finance six,
00:16:39five, you know, there's this idea that if you, if you're not over six foot and you don't make
00:16:43six figures, then you're not worthy of romance. And then women see something like, you know,0.99
00:16:48it's like, well, if you have to be like a certain weight and you have to have a certain
00:16:52proportion, certain physical attractiveness. And if you're not that, then it's over for you.
00:16:57Right. And I think too, you know, when you think about this kind of content,
00:17:02it also sets expectations. And so perhaps, you know, for a woman who's like five foot two,
00:17:08she's like, I really, really didn't think about height that much. I just want someone,
00:17:11you know, maybe a little bit taller than me, but she's saying like all these, you know,0.96
00:17:14attractive, popular women sort of saying, no, no, no, you need, you need a man who's at least
00:17:18six feet and like, oh, okay, got it. Maybe that's, that's a normal thing to want. That's1.00
00:17:22a normal thing to expect. And the same thing around safety, talk a lot about concerns women
00:17:28have about personal safety when it comes to dating and the rise in women who are concerned
00:17:34about sexual harassment, sexual abuse, sexual assault, which rose dramatically 2016, 2017.
00:17:40And it was not related to any government statistics about sexual assault. So it's not as if the world
00:17:47has become a more dangerous place, but because of a lot of content that younger women are seeing,0.55
00:17:52it feels like a less safe place. Interesting. The other thing that I see too,0.99
00:17:57and i hate this stuff it's the content just about relationships themselves like you'll have
00:18:02married people get on talking about how marriage is so terrible and what their husbands do that
00:18:07annoy them or what their wives do that annoy them i mean it's just this airing of grievances for
00:18:12likes it's performative right like so people are talking about the ways in which you know
00:18:18they're having to do more or their partner's not doing enough as a way to get validation and
00:18:24affirmation right so their comments will be filled with and sort of saying you know oh
00:18:28that's awful i feel bad for you like but they'll also be like yeah get rid of that guy
00:18:32another part of the of the internet will show the opposite right that these unbelievably
00:18:39sensitive and considerate and thoughtful guys who just in every moment you know are doing things
00:18:47perfectly there's not the representation of the middle that that right like oh yeah my partner's
00:18:53great. Sometimes they're annoying, um, but mostly great. And this is just how life is day in and day
00:18:58out. And, and like the vast majority of relationships are some, right? Like ebbs and
00:19:02flows. Things are, are good, but things, there are, there are struggles, there are problems,
00:19:06but sort of that experience is less represented online. And so people have this really skewed
00:19:12understanding of how relationships are supposed to work and what their expectations for a romantic
00:19:17relationship. Cause the other part of the problem is, is people are getting young people are getting
00:19:21this content before they have any relationship experienced. So what they're seeing has no sort
00:19:26of countervailing force to sort of say, to correct these sort of misperceptions, right? So if I'm in
00:19:32a relationship and have been for years, and then I sort of see this stuff, I'm like, oh, okay, well,
00:19:36that's not my experience. But think about, you know, a teenage boy or girl who are seeing this
00:19:40stuff. It's like, wow, girls really think like this or boys behave this way. That's kind of awful.
00:19:45and and i think we really haven't come to terms with how damaging this has been and how it's
00:19:53changed people's understanding of romantic relationships and and how they should work
00:19:58yeah so yeah i think that's interesting so you're seeing the extremes are you seeing the extremes
00:20:02of like terrible relationships and people see that and they're like oh i don't want to do that
00:20:07but then they also you see the extremes of like really awesome relationships right it's the family
00:20:12that's, you know, going on great vacations and they love each other. And someone might see that
00:20:16and be like, well, I'm never going to be able to do that. So I'm not even going to try.
00:20:20Right. And like, why does my partner not do that?
00:20:22Yeah. The other thing too, with social media, and you talk about this in the book,
00:20:25is that young people, they're going to social media for relationship advice,
00:20:30like soliciting it from strangers, essentially. And you see this in Reddit, particularly people
00:20:36will do posts like, Hey, my significant other is doing this thing. What should I do?
00:20:42And you highlighted a study where you started seeing this trend where more and more people were saying, you know, you should just leave that person, even for the most, you know, trivial, dumb stuff.
00:20:54But yeah, the popular response is just get rid of them.
00:20:57So there were two studies in Reddit that were really interesting.
00:20:59So the first one, as you mentioned, this computer scientist looked back over all this Reddit relationship advice data.
00:21:07So people asking questions, like basically fielding questions to Redditors and trying to get some advice on their relationship.
00:21:15And there's a variety, the guy classified them, you know, various types of advice that would be given.
00:21:22One of which was, yeah, just dump this person, get out.
00:21:26Which wasn't that common back in 2010 when you started looking at it.
00:21:29But by 2025, it had increased to become the most common type of relationship advice people were getting.
00:21:36And so that to me is kind of emblematic of the larger culture where we view relationships and we view people as disposable.
00:21:46Like this idea that there's endless optionality, that you can always find something better, something that will work better for you.
00:21:54And so you don't need to invest as much in your current relationship or your current partner because if things aren't working out and things are difficult, you can just easily move on.
00:22:03And again, this, this, this view is not that uncommon out on social media in general. In fact, I just saw the other day, the woman who does call her daddy, that podcast, she talks about getting a divorce. And she said that one of the problems is that, you know, women who are married don't think that they can do any better. So they stay in the relationship when they can always do better. Those were her words.
00:22:25and so that's the same mentality right that it's not worth investing in someone it's not worth
00:22:30working through things because there's always a chance that you could find something better
00:22:34yeah and before you know if you before the internet you would have gone to a friend like
00:22:39what do i do and they'd be like well you just got to work you know work it out like that's just
00:22:42right and figure it out and it would be someone that who's invested probably in both people it
00:22:46could have been a parent could have been a mutual friend a sibling but someone who probably was
00:22:51invested in you guys staying together, that cared about both people. And I think one of the problems
00:22:58is that increasingly we're viewing relationships transactionally. So if it doesn't deliver
00:23:03things for me, these are the things that I need, then I can opt out. And that's just a different
00:23:08mentality to how we thought about relationships, especially when you got married young, when the
00:23:13goal was to build something together. We're going to take a quick break for your words from our
00:23:16sponsors. If you run a small business, at some point, you also become the payroll department.
00:23:22I don't know anybody who got into business for that part, but it has to get done right because
00:23:25getting payroll taxes wrong is expensive. Gusto is online payroll and benefits software built for
00:23:30small businesses. It's all-in-one, remote-friendly, and incredibly easy to use. So you can pay,
00:23:36hire, onboard, and support your team from anywhere. It handles automatic payroll tax filing,
00:23:41direct deposits, health benefits, workers' comp, 401k, you name it, and there are options for
00:23:46nearly every budget. You get unlimited payroll runs for one monthly price with no hidden fees
00:23:50and no surprises. When you bring somebody new on, built-in tools takes care of the offer letter and
00:23:54the onboarding docs. And if you hit a tough HR situation, you get direct access to certified HR
00:23:59experts. Plenty of people agree that it works. Gusto is ranked number one on G2's highest
00:24:03satisfaction product list for 2026 and over 500,000 small businesses use it. AOM is a small
00:24:08operation right now, but if AOM ever becomes a media empire and we need to hire a huge team,
00:24:12I'll be using Gusto. Try Gusto today at gusto.com slash AOM and get three months free when you run
00:24:18your first payroll. That's three months of free payroll at gusto.com slash AOM. One more time,
00:24:24gusto.com slash AOM. That's G-U-S-T-O dot com. So a lot of our Christmas decorations are over 10
00:24:30years old at this point, and the lighted garland we put up every year has seen better days. When
00:24:35you're having people over for the holidays, that's the kind of thing you notice. So Kate and I have
00:24:38been on Wayfair looking for new pre-lit garland. For all things hosting, Wayfair delivers high
00:24:43quality customer trusted products for your home so you can host and celebrate without the stress.
00:24:48What's made the search easy is the reviews. You can use filters and see customer photos and there
00:24:52are more than 20 million verified five-star reviews so you can see how a garland looks in
00:24:56somebody's house before you buy it. Wayfair helps you create a home that stands up to real life.
00:25:00Their Wayfair verified products are hand vetted by product specialists using a 10-point quality
00:25:05inspection, which matters when you want lights that last more than a couple of Christmases.
00:25:10And there are thousands of options across every style and budget, so you're not stuck picking
00:25:13between two sad choices. When refreshing your home this holiday season, Wayfair delivers exactly what
00:25:18you need. Head to Wayfair.com to shop all things home. That's Wayfair.com, W-A-Y-F-A-I-R.com,
00:25:26Wayfair.com. Wayfair, every style, every home. With winter coming, I needed a new jacket I could
00:25:31wear on campouts and hikes, so I went with the hometown down jacket from Steo. Every mountain
00:25:36town has a brand the locals wear, and Steo's the one in Jackson Hole. It's designed and tested in
00:25:42Jackson Hole, Wyoming, right at the base of the Tetons by locals who ski, bike, climb, and fish
00:25:47there every day. They've been doing it since 2011, so 15 years in. This is the gear that locals live
00:25:52in. Steo makes clothes for the whole mountain day, from first chair to dinner, and then also the dog
00:25:57walk when it's cold. And because they live through Wyoming winters, they know warm. The hometown down
00:26:02jacket is 800 fill down, but it feels more like your favorite hoodie than a puffy. It's what I'll
00:26:06be wearing on campouts this winter. And if you ski, they've also got their Environ jacket, pants,
00:26:11and bib. That's their all-mountain workhorse, whether you're on fast groomers, hiking to the
00:26:15side country, or waist-deep in powder if you're lucky. If you're a skier or you're outdoors in
00:26:19the cold during the winter, you need to check out Steeo. Ski season's almost here. Gear up now the
00:26:24way the locals do. Go to steo.com slash manliness for 20% off your first order. That's steo. That's
00:26:31spelled S-T-I-O dot com slash manliness, steo.com slash manliness, steo designed and tested in
00:26:38Jackson Hole. After a tough workout where I've sweated a lot or after a sauna session, I like
00:26:42to have some electrolytes. Plain water doesn't put back everything you lost. And the electrolytes
00:26:46I've been using are the electrolyte sticks from Quince. They replenish the essential minerals
00:26:49you lose through a tough workout or a long travel day. And all you have to do is add water.
00:27:21Go to quince.com for free shipping on your order
00:27:23and 365 day returns. And when Quince asks you where you heard about them, let them know that
00:27:28it was the art of manliness. It's the best way to support the show. These statements have not
00:27:32been evaluated by the Food and Drug Administration. This product is not intended to diagnose, treat,
00:27:35cure, prevent any disease. And now back to the show. Another thing you highlight what social
00:27:43media is doing to the sexes to kind of put them in different worlds is they've gotten really0.99
00:27:50different on their politics. How is social media contributing to dividing men and women0.78
00:27:57politically? Yeah, when it comes to basically any given issue, what women and men see is
00:28:04incredibly different. One of the most interesting studies that I cite in the book showed that,
00:28:10and I think they were looking at TikTok, showed that the algorithm knows your gender before it
00:28:14knows almost anything else about you. And so it is feeding you content based on your gender from
00:28:19the earliest moments that you're spending time on these sites. And so even if you're looking at
00:28:24the same issue or the same event, you're learning very different things. And I think the Me Too
00:28:31movement is a good example where so much of what women were seeing online, they were seeing these
00:28:37sort of horrific stories of abuse, some recent, some years old. They were seeing women supporting
00:28:43other women, acts of affirmation and validation. But men weren't seeing the same stuff. When men
00:28:49would log on, and I know this because I talked to a lot of these men about what they understood
00:28:54about the Me Too movement. And they said like sort of what they would see is like some of the
00:28:57most extreme responses that would, you know, wholly blame all men for sexual abuse, sexual
00:29:05assault, sexual harassment in society. The most sort of negative, hostile posts would be the
00:29:11the stuff that comes across their social media feed often. And so what they were seeing was
00:29:16very, very different. And so many of the young men I talked to wanted to diss themselves from it.
00:29:22They said like, well, this is not, I don't, you know, I don't do any of this stuff. This is not
00:29:25how I behave. And this one guy I remember talking to said like, this is about celebrities and I
00:29:30don't do anything, you know, related to this and I don't care about celebrities. And so their
00:29:34understanding about the social problem was incredibly different. And the same is true
00:29:39for almost any political issue too like how it's framed the kind of content people are seeing is
00:29:46just very very different and so you live in this a little reality bubble and so your understanding
00:29:50of the world is shaped through this content yeah i think you highlighted statistic that
00:29:57for the most part gen z young men have kind of stayed the same politically they haven't gotten
00:30:04more or less conservative or progressive or liberal. It's been about the same, but young
00:30:09women, it was like a 20% increase in being progressive or liberal or whatever.
00:30:14Yeah. So this is based on this really interesting Gallup trend going back to like the late 90s.
00:30:19I first wrote about it in 2022 and then extended it in the book. So right around 2016, 2017,
00:30:25you see this marked increase in liberal identity among young women. And that basically continues
00:30:31for about a decade. And so now there's about a 20-point divide in ideology between young men
00:30:39and young women, but it's all because of the movement among young women. And the story for
00:30:43young men is quite different. Since basically Obama's second term in 2012, what you see among
00:30:50young men is a steady erosion in democratic identity. So the millennial men were basically
00:30:57Democrats. They really liked Obama, especially at first. And then slowly you see this sort of
00:31:04decline in views and support of the Democratic Party. And it's not that they were rushing to
00:31:09the GOP either. What you have instead is this rising disaffection that young men feel politically
00:31:16homeless, that there isn't a party that really represents their views or interests, and that
00:31:20both parties in one way or the other represents a certain kind of elite. So for Democrats, it's
00:31:25the cultural elites of academics and people in the media and artists. And the Republican Party
00:31:32represents the financial elites. And so many young men feel that they have no outlet for their
00:31:39politics and their concerns. And so we found that I think it was about four in 10 young men have a
00:31:45negative view of both the Democratic and the Republican Party. And I think that's actually
00:31:50one of the things that drew them to Trump initially, that Trump emerged outside of the
00:31:56political establishment. I talked a very big game about dismantling and going after political elites
00:32:04and upending the economic and political system. And so there's a way in which that was an incredibly
00:32:10appealing message to a lot of young men who thought that the system was broken and wasn't
00:32:14working for them. Young women didn't have those same concerns. And although many criticized the
00:32:19Democratic Party, they largely felt that the Democrats were on the right side of most of the
00:32:24issues that they cared about. Yeah. And so as men and women get more and more different politically,
00:32:30I mean, for a lot of people today, their politics, like, governs a lot of the decisions, you know,
00:32:35the things they do, even the products they buy. So that's going to be a deal breaker.
00:32:39Yeah, who they date. Yeah. So it's interesting that in the Trump era,
00:32:45politics has become personalized and it's become not simply a reflection or indication of the
00:32:53issues you care about or your position on them, but a sign of your character. And so I think like
00:32:59that has made things incredibly difficult socially and romantically. You have sort of
00:33:05self-segregation going on, especially among young women who report that supporting Trump is a deal
00:33:11breaker for them. And that I think it was like more than half of young women or young college
00:33:16educated women say that they have no close friends who are Trump supporters. And so it's not just
00:33:21happening online. It's happening in the real world where you're seeing politics become a dividing
00:33:27line in terms of how people, who people are talking to, how they're spending their time.0.97
00:33:31Another thing you mentioned in the book is that with Gen Z, there's been an increase in the number
00:33:36who identify as lgbtq like i think about a third of gen z women identifies that so that's going to
00:33:44add another obstacle or layer of complexity to heterosexual coupling yeah the the trend is
00:33:51almost entirely occurring among young women so the the shift occurs about the same time i think
00:33:58like 2013, 2014, you see this rapid rise in LGBTQ identity among young women, but it's almost all
00:34:07among people who are identifying as bisexual. So there's more young women identifying bisexual
00:34:11than used to. But when you look at the behavior of these women, many, if not most, are still0.99
00:34:19dating men. And so one of the things I talk about in the book, I talk about this in the broader
00:34:24context of identity seeking. So much of our time and energy has become focused on ourselves and
00:34:31sort of establishing sort of our unique contributions, experiences, perspectives.
00:34:37And in one way, I think there's nothing wrong with wanting to figure out who you are and
00:34:42understand your place in the world. I think that's incredibly normal and it's a part of growing up.
00:34:47But one of the things that I think is problematic is the way in which this is happening.
00:34:52So typically you'd go out and meet people and you'd learn about their experiences and how they think and you'd be like, okay, I think about things differently or I'm attracted to this person but not that person. What is it about this person that I find attractive or interesting?
00:35:05And so through these lived experiences, engaging with real people, you'd come to figure out things about yourself. But that's happening less or less often. And so what's stepped in is, again, social media.
00:35:19So people are seeing representations online of people that they like or admire and they're sort of understanding themselves and making decisions about themselves based on the sort of voyeuristic information that they have.
00:35:34And I don't think that's a great way to understand anything about yourself.
00:35:37I think we learn the most about ourselves in relationship with other people.
00:35:41And so I think so much of our time and energy has spent in articulating and identifying ourselves as unique and distinct when that doesn't necessarily make us feel connected, feel like there's a place where we belong.
00:35:56This is an incredible question that we asked as part of this section where I just wanted to know whether people grew up thinking that their parents thought of them as special or unique.
00:36:08And there is a profound generational division.
00:36:11If you're over the age of 50, most people said that when they were growing up, they
00:36:16did not think their parents thought of them as special, but rather average or ordinary.
00:36:20But if you're under the age of 50, and especially if you're under the age of 40, folks said,
00:36:25yeah, growing up that they thought their parents thought of them as special.
00:36:28And again, that's a really different way of thinking about yourself in relationship to
00:36:34at worst it can increase narcissism and there's a whole bunch of studies about when parents overvalue
00:36:40their kids it can lead to narcissistic tendencies but also think it leads to change expectations
00:36:46like you think that that people should be accommodating for you because you are different
00:36:50because you are special and that can create a lot of problems when you're thinking about
00:36:54relationships particularly romantic ones yeah if you think you're you know sort of the center of
00:36:58the universe it's going to be harder to engage in the kind of give and take compromise that
00:37:04relationships depend on. Right. And to be clear, I don't think there's anything inherently wrong
00:37:09with Gen Z, but it's really an artifact of the way that they were raised. So this generation1.00
00:37:15was far more likely to grow up in smaller households with older, better resourced parents,
00:37:20parents having kids later on in their life tended to be more financially stable and secure.
00:37:25And so they could dedicate a lot more resources to their kids, right? They spend more time and
00:37:30attention. And I think one of the unfortunate downsides of that is you don't have the same
00:37:35opportunity to compromise and to accommodate other people. Like I'm a middle child. I have
00:37:41two brothers. And it was constantly like you were having to like, share space, I shared a bedroom,
00:37:47you're sharing bathrooms. And you have to kind of learn to live with other people, and that the
00:37:52world doesn't revolve around you. There's lots of people in the household. And I think that's,
00:37:56that's incredibly valuable that you don't always get to eat what you want or when you want, you
00:38:01don't get to watch the movie that you always want to watch. You know, we went to Blockbuster growing
00:38:06up and we could rent one movie. And so the three of us had to compromise. And again, those experiences
00:38:11are incredibly valuable because when you, when you learn this, when you're young, it becomes
00:38:15natural as you get older to operate this way. And if you, you don't have that experience and if you
00:38:19expect that, well, you know, growing up, my parents always accommodated me, then that's sort of what
00:38:24you expect. Yeah. Yeah. When you have a lot of siblings, you get used to nudging. Oh boy,
00:38:29you share your, you got to share your toys. Yeah. Like I'm not touching you. I'm not touching you.
00:38:34And yeah, I mean, that's, but that's a good step, right? Like that's, that's kind of,
00:38:38we need more of that. You know, even if you, you don't have a large family, you can provide your,
00:38:43your kids opportunities to do that. One of the most dispiriting data points in the entire book
00:38:48for me, people may differ is the decline in regular family dinners that it once was a mainstay
00:38:54of family life, that you'd have dinner every night. Even Gen X, this notoriously feral1.00
00:39:01generation, would come home for dinner. But what was once common for baby boomers in Gen X1.00
00:39:06is far less common among younger millennials and Gen Z. And there's a number of reasons for that.
00:39:12But I think those experiences are incredibly valuable for kids. It allows them to participate
00:39:18in meal prep or cleaning the table or loading the dishwasher, just being present and contributing to
00:39:23this critical family activity. Yeah. I also think too, I mean, there's probably more only children
00:39:30with this younger generation. And so that means you don't have a sibling of the opposite sex.
00:39:36And so you miss out on an opportunity to learn about the opposite sex. Cause like I have, I have0.62
00:39:41a sister and I was able to see what it was like to be a teenage girl. And like the problems that
00:39:47came with it, you know, her friends were, you know, could be mean and catty, you know, I had
00:39:51tampons in my bathroom and I had to figure out like, Oh, what's this thing? Like you learn about
00:39:56interacting with the opposite sex or you get to see like what problems they have. I didn't even1.00
00:40:01see with my kids. So I've got a boy and a girl and they're in their teenage years and you can
00:40:06see that they see each other and the problems that they face and they have to learn how to
00:40:11sympathize. And they also just learn how to interact with each other. You know, my son has
00:40:17to learn like, oh, you can't be too like rough and tumble with your sister because you're bigger
00:40:22and stronger than her. And like, you know, so I mean, yeah, I think that's another thing that's
00:40:25happening. I think it's such a good point. So I have two boys and it's not just like the experience
00:40:32of them interacting, but all their friends are boys. So there's no kids in our house, but like
00:40:38an unending line of rambunctious boys. And that's a very different experience. And, you know, if we
00:40:46had a boy and a girl, we'd have a mixture of girls coming over to play and boys coming over
00:40:51to play. And I think like those experiences would, would, I would imagine be quite informative.
00:40:56Yeah. Let's go back to the friendship recession. I mean, I think this is one of the big points
00:41:01of your book is that the romance recession is downstream of the overall friendship recession.
00:41:08So tell us about the role that social, you know, just general social life plays in our romantic
00:41:14life. Yeah. And I think I said it at the outset that I think we make a mistake when we think of
00:41:22dating and romantic interactions as separate from social interactions in general. Dating is talking.
00:41:29And so the more you have practice introducing yourself to people you don't know well,
00:41:34talking to strangers, the more you'll be able to do this later on and when the stakes are a little
00:41:39bit higher. And so I think the more practice we can get talking, engaging, listening, reading body
00:41:46language, expressing interests and curiosity about someone, you know, the kind of questions that
00:41:51you're asking, I mean, that is incredibly helpful. And there are so many ways we have sort of
00:41:58short circuited this process, even the sort of the technologies that we use, because I can figure
00:42:04out with my phone where I'm going at any given time, I'm looking for a restaurant or whatever,
00:42:10I don't need to ask for directions. And in fact, I think there are a lot of people would be kind
00:42:15of weirded out if I asked them for directions while holding my phone. Like, what are you doing?
00:42:20But whether it's DoorDash or Lyft or Uber, we can rely on ourselves and these tools that we have.
00:42:29We don't need to rely on other people. And so we have made things more efficient for ourselves in
00:42:33one way, but we've given ourselves fewer opportunities to have to rely on other people.
00:42:37And I think there's something that we lose in that process. One of the biggest problems we have
00:42:42in our society, in my view, is that we have, I think, swallowed this fiction that we don't need
00:42:49people. We don't need each other. I can do things by myself for myself. And I don't care who you are,
00:42:55you need people, right? Like, we need people. And I think some of the technology, the direction of
00:43:01technological change that I'm most concerned about is basically teaching
00:43:06people that you don't. The rise of AI chatbots, companion chatbots, is
00:43:12teaching a younger generation that, no, you actually, you know, if you're
00:43:15feeling down, if you're struggling with a personal issue, Claude can help you
00:43:19out. You don't need to ask a friend or ask a parent. You can rely on this
00:43:23technology. And so that, to me, is something that I'm very cognizant about.
00:43:29My kids are eight and 10, so we're not there yet.
00:43:33But whether it's social media or AI, I do think there's a way in which technology limits our ability to establish these kinds of social connections.
00:43:41Yeah. I mean, going back to that idea that everything's become privatized.
00:43:56And so what we do or a lot of young people do is they go to the apps like, okay, there's an app for that. There's always an app for something to fix a problem. And so young people are doing that. How's that working out for them using the apps?
00:44:09I think when the same way with social media, there was a lot of interest initially in social
00:44:15media and quickly it became not an experience of connecting with other people, but scrolling
00:44:22endlessly content from strangers. You had with dating apps, there was initially some stigma
00:44:29around their use, but quickly there was growing acceptance. But part of the problem lies in just
00:44:35how efficient they make the process because it's so easy to meet someone and message someone even
00:44:42the act of asking someone out doesn't carry the same meaning if there's a girl who lives down the
00:44:48block from me and i walk over and i ask her out like that's an event that takes some amount of
00:44:54courage on my part the risk of rejection is there um and i think like that is an important experience
00:45:02whatever the outcome. With online dating, you can ask 10 people out in a matter of minutes
00:45:09and then not be invested particularly in any of these outcomes. And by and large,
00:45:14they're mostly strangers so that there's very little risk involved. No one's going to know
00:45:19if you were shot down a dozen times. And so I think there's a way in which that is not helpful
00:45:25because it means that we're not invested in these experiences. And you see this with all
00:45:31these dating disaster stories. And the worst of them are, I think, the result of people not
00:45:37caring about the other person, that they recognize that they can simply on another night at another
00:45:43place replicate the same experience. And so it doesn't really matter. And there aren't the same
00:45:48kind of accountability structures involved as if you were dating like your roommate's friend,
00:45:53right? Like if you leave early, if you're talking on your phone the whole time, you're going to hear
00:45:58about it. And that incentive is incredibly important because all of us are more likely
00:46:03to be on our best behavior when there are repercussions for us, you know, acting in
00:46:10ways that we can be criticized for. And so I think like that really matters. And it's why
00:46:14you ask people how they would like to meet. Ideally, it's never online. I mean, I understand
00:46:19that like there are barrages that got started on dating apps and that's great. But the way most
00:46:24people want to meet is through their existing social network, through their network of friends
00:46:28and families and colleagues because it's much easier to develop trust.
00:46:32And so much of the problem we have is that we're throwing strangers together with little
00:47:05And it's one of the really startling findings from the survey that we did that for men,
00:47:12but not women, the number of close friends you have is strongly associated with whether
00:47:18you're in a relationship at all, or whether if you're single, the recency with which you've
00:47:23gone out on a date. And I think this makes some sense if you think about for men, how important
00:47:29it is to meet someone through your social network. If you have a big group of friends and peers
00:47:36that you can meet prospective partners through, that is incredibly valuable. Because for women,1.00
00:47:43they are far more likely to go out with you if you have a shared social circle. And so I think
00:47:50like that, that is important. I think also too, there's just like the confidence and the social
00:47:55skills that come with having more active social life. And where I think male friendships don't
00:48:01quite benefit men the same way female friendships benefit women in terms of preparing them for,
00:48:08you know, the ways romantic relationships operate, the need to communicate, the need to
00:48:12share your feelings, you know, talk about problems you might have. This is very common among women.1.00
00:48:19we have surveys where we actually asked about the degree to which women and men talked about
00:48:25various things with their friends. And women are far more likely to, you know, emotionally disclose
00:48:29to express support and consideration for each other. Men are more likely to hang out and engage
00:48:36in activities where they don't necessarily engage in this way. I mean, it's not that one way is
00:48:41right and one way is wrong. Men very much value their friendships and their relationships with
00:48:45with other men just as much as women do. But I do think there's a way in which it doesn't prepare
00:48:50men as well often to do the kind of communicating you need to be effective in a, or successful in
00:48:55a romantic relationship. Yeah. Well, okay. So you're making the case that we need to
00:49:00not make romance so privatized and bring back the community. What would that look like in the 21st
00:49:08century? Because I mean, you can watch old movies. Like you've ever seen the quiet man with John
00:49:12wayne and maureen o'hara no so it's set in ireland it's one of my favorite movies but you know it
00:49:17shows this elaborate courtship ritual and the community was involved super involved family
00:49:23and the whole community i don't think you're saying like it should be like that so what would
00:49:27community involvement in romantic life look like today this this is i think one of the things that
00:49:33is challenging in terms of like how do you make this actionable i do think that like societally
00:49:40We need to be serious about what a future looks like for us when fewer Americans are married and having kids.
00:49:49One of the things I talk about in the book and I've written about before is that when you look at the social and civic contributions, the people who are doing the most are married parents with college degrees.
00:50:02That group is volunteering more often, they're donating, they're attending community meetings, they're working through local government to solve problems, and then we're all benefiting from this work. All members of the community benefit from it.
00:50:18And it's not to say that, you know, singles are not doing, you know, they're not engaged or they're not social. But if you just look at all these measures of civic participation, it's better educated married parents are just doing the lion's share of it.
00:50:32And so if you say like, well, what happens when there are fewer of these households? I do think that we have to think about like, what is our role? How can we encourage people getting in healthy long term relationships? I think that it's something that is worthwhile to aspire to.
00:50:50And I think there's a number of ways you can think about it from schools hosting dances
00:50:55and making, you know, co-ed activities sort of more front and center, particularly social
00:51:18And that does not seem like we're heading in the right direction. So I think that whether it's churches, whether it's families, whether it's schools, you know, institutions should prioritize providing opportunities for young people to spend time together, to talk to each other in real physical spaces, to provide third places for young people to get together and spend time and to make sure that we are clear with young people that if you want to live a long, healthy, meaningful life,
00:51:48it's going to take more than cold plunges and you know gym workouts like you you need people in it
00:51:54you need to fill your life with people and again like i think there are so many different ways we
00:51:59can model that we can mentor we can talk about it and then like provide young people with spaces to
00:52:03do this yeah the i'm a big dance booster for young people because growing up like dancing was such a
00:52:09big part of my life like our school had i don't know at least three dances a semester formal or
00:52:16semi-formal than just sort of casual dances and then with my church there would be like a dance
00:52:21at least once a month yeah and like i'm with 14 and having to ask a girl to dance and it was like
00:52:26oh my gosh my palms got sweaty and then you had to learn yeah where do you put your hands so you
00:52:30you know you don't make her feel uncomfortable and then you had to have a conversation for
00:52:34three minutes for however long the song was i mean that was a big part in my learning how to
00:52:40interact with the opposite sex but like what you were saying i'm seeing less and less of it you
00:52:44know less dances at schools and churches and even when there are dances there's often no slow dancing0.59
00:52:49which i find really strange so yeah we need more real dances and yeah making them like big events
00:52:55right i understand like the the the kind of inclination not to want people to be left out or
00:53:00if some people don't want to go but i i do think there's a way that culturally they are they feel
00:53:04less significant than they like the prom was huge when i was in high school like it was a big event
00:53:09people talked about it you know we had planning committees and and i think that's that's good
00:53:14like we should be encouraging young people to to to think about and get these experiences of
00:53:22you know talking with someone asking someone out and man you realize that if you are rejected and
00:53:27you know for men it's hard to get through life without experiencing rejection but but everyone
00:53:33whether it's social romantic will experience some kind of rejection at some point and being able to
00:53:38move beyond it and sort of realizing, wow, my world isn't falling apart. And that was kind of
00:53:43crappy, but I'm fine now. It's far better to have that experience at 14 than 24. Yeah. Well, I think
00:53:49the smartphones are part of the problem because I think a lot of kids are reluctant to dance because
00:53:54like they don't want to get filmed. They don't want to look cringe. Yeah, no, I have both heard
00:53:59this anecdotally. And then in the book, I talk about there were reports that DJs at dance clubs
00:54:05were noticing that there wasn't anyone on the dance floor.
00:54:09People would be sort of standing around the periphery
00:54:11and they'd have their phones out recording
00:54:34And the concern that something dumb that you say or do could wind up online and fodder for your embarrassment for, you know, not days, but months or years, I think has to be terrifying.
00:54:48I am so glad to have grown up without them because I feel like it really constrains folks.
00:54:54I mean, dancing is so freeing. I can't say I am in any way a good dancer, but I think the ability to express yourself and be yourself without fear of being surveilled is incredibly important. It means you're freer to take kind of social risks that you otherwise might not be.
00:55:13I include this story too. When I was a senior in high school, we were playing soccer and this is
00:55:20Western New York. So November, so it was pretty cold. The teams all had like warm up suits. So
00:55:25you had a jacket and you had warm up pants, which you take off before you run on the field. And I
00:55:31remember the game was just about to start. And I remember seeing out of the corner of my eye, this
00:55:35player on their team run on the field in his underwear. So he had his soccer socks on and
00:55:41his jersey on, but he was just wearing boxers. And I figured out pretty quickly what had happened
00:55:47is he took off his warmup pants and shorts in the same motion and then didn't realize it and ran out
00:55:53on the field in his excitement and realized pretty quickly what happened and got dressed. But that
00:55:58was only seen by the few folks that were there, you know, both teams and maybe a few people who
00:56:04were watching. There was no video evidence. There was no photographic evidence. And so like, yeah,
00:56:09it was probably embarrassing. Maybe it was mortifying, but like it didn't last, right?
00:56:13Like it disappeared. And I think when you think about how young people learn, being able to make
00:56:19mistakes freely, it has to be an important part of adolescence and growing up. And I think
00:56:25we've done young people a disservice by not allowing them to do that. And so I think like
00:56:30the more we can provide them opportunities to have experiences without these phones,
00:56:35whether it's bans in school, I know in Australia, they banned smartphones until I think age 16.
00:56:42I do think it's really important that we allow them to experience some part of their life without
00:56:48the worry of being documented. Yeah. All right. So more dancing, less smartphones. And I think
00:56:54too, as parents, we should probably tell our kids, like, you don't have to document everything
00:56:58online. And if you see someone doing something kind of silly, like just let them be silly.0.96
00:57:03and you don't have to share it on snapchat or whatever we got to get rid of little brother0.52
00:57:07we're all little brother now we got to get rid of right right yeah don't worry about getting clout
00:57:11from sharing something's misfortune or someone's mistake it's it's not worth it and and we ought
00:57:15not to do it so yeah if you're a young guy listening to this and you're trying to like
00:57:19you know improve your romantic life it sounds like instead of spending more time in the gym
00:57:24in monk mode doing the looks maxing cold plunges thing get out there and just make more friends
00:57:29get out there involved in your community join a club join whatever that's probably be your
00:57:35better bet to finding romantic love yeah and and at the very least like you will have more fun doing
00:57:44it if you're hanging out with your buddies if you're playing you know kickball ultimate frisbee
00:57:49soccer flag football whatever it is if you're pursuing hobbies with other friends or other
00:57:53folks in your community at the very least you will have an enjoyable experience in doing it
00:58:46And I think that's a sort of critical lesson to impart to young people.
00:58:52And you learn that through these, whether it's a social club or a civic organization or a part-time job, that your life is connected to the lives of people around you.
00:59:03Yeah. And you kind of end the book with the idea that we need to bring back this culture that we once had, but maybe have less of today where we see our identity as relational too. Like oftentimes when people talk about identity today, they talk about sexuality, psychology stuff, their interest in hobbies, but it's also who we are relationally because you're a friend, you know, a husband, a son, a dad.
00:59:29Totally. Right. Like I can immediately bond with, you know, a dad with unruly kids because like, boy, I had that same experience and I can empathize and I understand what they're going through. And now that my kids are sort of on the tail end of elementary school and they're new parents moving into the neighborhood with young kids and I'm able to like, you know, engage and offer support or perhaps sympathy for their screaming toddler.
00:59:55And I think that is incredibly valuable, right?