00:00:16Visit timhortons.ca slash triangle for details.
00:00:20All human institutions, customs, traditions, and ways of being
00:00:24originate to serve the needs of specific peoples.
00:00:27The collective experience, struggles, and beliefs of a tribe create a pattern of being or a code that organically rises to meet their specific challenges and perpetuate their way of life.
00:00:39These institutions and systems are territorialized, meaning that they are deeply embedded in the specific cultural context of the tribe and serve its unique needs.
00:00:49The seafaring civilization centers cultural values of exploration and trade.
00:00:55The agricultural civilization centers consistent rhythms of sowing and reaping.
00:01:00The conquering society centers martial prowess and honor.
00:01:04Every system emerges with the concrete goals and well-being of a particular people as it's in.
00:01:11Territorialization is critical because it ties the goals and operations of a system
00:01:16to the needs of the people who are embodying a way of life.
00:01:20The idea of metrics which evaluate the efficiency of any given system are foreign to a territorialized institution.
00:01:29Systems don't exist for their own sake, but are only valuable insofar as they serve the ends of the tribe.
00:01:35Those ends are determined by the specific way the people live their lives and the telus to which their culture is oriented.
00:01:42There's a hard limit to how and for what purpose a system can operate.
00:01:46The limit is the day-to-day continuance of a particular flesh-and-blood people.
00:01:53Systems which are properly territorialized will be governed by the particular folkways of the people they serve.0.83
00:01:59Trade may be governed by the market, but marriage is governed by the power of the tribal patriarchs,
00:02:05worship is governed by the priesthood, warfare is governed by the aristocrats,
00:02:09and the power of the state is wielded by the king.
00:02:12Each of these domains has its own sacred place in the order,
00:02:15But importantly, they also draw their power in very different ways.
00:02:20An outsider might be confused by the purpose of each system,
00:02:24finding its origins perplexing or its operations inefficient.
00:02:28But no one needs to explain the purpose of these systems to the tribes that gave birth to them.
00:02:33This is the way things are, a natural outgrowth from the traditions of the people and the challenges they face.
00:02:39The territorialized code arose from the people and serves the people.
00:02:43No one else needs to understand or validate it.
00:02:47In traditional societies, the entire system is designed to maintain the tribe as it is,
00:03:28One of the easily observable patterns of history is that successful organisms seek to expand,
00:03:33and this is just as true of the biological humans who carry the code as it is for the code itself.
00:03:39As the tribe becomes successful, it needs more territory and resources to expand its population.
00:03:45But the need for expansion is not just material, it's also spiritual.
00:03:49To expand the tribe must acquire territory and resources by conquest, whether it be military, diplomatic, cultural, or economic.
00:03:57Glory, status, and wealth call to the ambitious members who recognize the opportunity for greatness as the civilization breaks out of homeostasis.
00:04:06The code may provide barriers to this expansion, attempting to limit the production of wealth, the acquisition of territory, and the influx of outsiders that will inevitably change the tribe it was created to maintain.
00:04:18But there's no denying that the great civilizations remembered by history are the ones that slip the bonds of the code and are overcome by the desire for greatness.
00:04:27Is mere existence enough, or is the point of life to do more than maintain that which you were born to?
00:04:33Like the uncontacted tribes of the Amazon, a people might exist in the same way for thousands of years if they maintain stasis, but is that truly the desirable end?
00:04:43Either way, that's not a question civilizations ever really ask themselves or one which they make a definitive decision on.
00:04:51If greatness calls, men follow, some to their doom and some to their glory, but the call is one of nature and not one that is chosen through deliberations.
00:05:00As the society expands, it finds that the code is no longer sufficient.
00:05:04Those systems arose from the specific circumstances, challenges, and beliefs of the tribe.
00:05:10Conquest means that the tribe now has to face very different challenges,
00:05:13but it also must learn to incorporate the population living in the territory it now controls.
00:05:19Some conquerors exterminate the conquered, some enslave them, some make them subjects,
00:05:23and a few even integrate them into the whole.
00:05:25With the exception of extermination, these methods require that the systems the tribe initially developed for itself
00:05:31must be adapted to govern or assimilate the new additions to the population.0.64
00:05:36Homeostasis has been broken, and a very different process is underway.0.95
00:05:39To scale up their civilizational systems, the conquering tribe must alter their nature0.77
00:05:44so they're not exclusively rooted in the way of being of the original population.
00:05:49The process of deterritorialization begins.
00:05:51territorialized systems come with natural limitations that check their power different
00:05:57powers and functions in society exist within the context of the social institutions or classes
00:06:03that gave birth to them and they create specific spheres of social influence for those institutions
00:06:09or classes the social spheres that govern the function of the systems operate in very different
00:06:15ways the priest aristocrat merchant and farmer all have very different ways of life attitudes
00:06:21and approaches to social organization. The spheres of influence they operate reflect this
00:06:27natural diversity. This means that the spheres of power create natural checks and balances for each
00:06:33other, not only because they are jealously guarding their own power, but because the nature
00:06:38of the organization itself is particular to each sphere. Priests would be terrible at running the
00:06:44army because they don't understand how those systems operate. Warriors would be bad at running0.95
00:06:48the church for the same reason. The particularity of these territorialized systems does not scale
00:06:55when it's time to adapt them to entirely foreign peoples. Suddenly, the army, church, market,0.89
00:07:01and state that grew slowly and organically from a particular people all must simultaneously be0.98
00:07:06thrust upon an alien people for whom it was not designed. The lack of interchangeability in the
00:07:12territorialized system is now a liability because the time and effort necessary to slowly expand
00:07:18the organic nature of the social spheres just doesn't exist. If the social systems of the
00:07:24conquerors are to scale, they must break these systems out of the social constraints that once
00:07:29bound them. They must be deterritorialized. In the modern liberal order, the most0.66
00:07:35universalizable medium for civilizational expansion has proven to be economic exchange.
00:07:41As I explained in my previous book, The Total State, How Liberal Democracies Become Tyrannies,
00:07:46what is often called classical liberalism attempted to remove existential questions of
00:07:51identity territorialized in the good of specific people and instead created a minimum universal
00:07:57morality or code which could enable economic exchange. By maximizing the amount of cooperation
00:08:04possible between civilizations, liberalism reaped vast economic benefits, but those benefits came
00:08:11at a cost. The scale required by this new system could only be achieved by creating mass bureaucratic
00:08:17organizations designed to create homogenous operations across all participants. By ensuring
00:08:23machine-like precision from human organizations, the liberal order was able to maximize the
00:08:29efficiency of the system, but in the process it also had to transform the individual human and
00:08:34the code they once lived under. Modernity is defined by the process of deterritorializing
00:08:40functions of human civilizations that once existed in sacred or traditional spaces and
00:08:45re-territorializing them in the marketplace. The elevation of a ruler was once a function
00:08:51of a hereditary or aristocratic selection. In a mass democracy, it becomes a contest over who
00:08:57can raise and spend the most money while selling the candidate like a product. Finding a young
00:09:02person, a spouse, was traditionally a duty performed by families in churches. Now, most
00:09:07romantic partnerships are selected as a product on a paid dating app. Music, literature, and art
00:09:13were previously created by those receiving support from sacred spheres like the church or aristocratic
00:09:19patrons. Now it's made at scale to be sold on Amazon or streamed on Netflix. Modern churches
00:09:25often function more like corporations where the pastor provides a TED talk that can be streamed
00:09:30on your smartphone than a place of sacred worship. The phenomenon can be seen most clearly in the way
00:09:36that the function of the family has been broken down and re-territorialized piece by piece
00:09:41into the marketplace. The mother is one of, if not the, key role on which a civilization is built,0.90
00:09:48but her job is not easy to quantify in an economic sense. Traditionally, mothers cared0.98
00:09:53for children and maintained the household, but there were so much more involved. Mothers were
00:09:58responsible for being the primary educators of their children. The constant presence of mothers1.00
00:10:03in their neighborhoods during the day allowed them to know everyone and enforce a community
00:10:08standard of behavior. This de facto neighborhood watch allowed for a high-trust society where
00:10:13children could roam without fear because an adult was always close, watching out for threats and
00:10:18correcting bad behavior. The homemaker didn't just stay at home watching television, she organized
00:10:24social functions, community meetings, church functions, and cultural events. A mother volunteered0.95
00:10:29at the local thrift store that funds the Mutual Aid Society, ran the Vacation Bible School,
00:10:34and helped to make sure her neighbor, who was overwhelmed by several children,
00:10:39had an extra hand when things got tough. None of these duties show up directly in GDP numbers or
00:10:44economic spreadsheets, but they serve an invaluable function in society. Most importantly,
00:10:49those tasks are performed with a human and caring touch that can't be replaced by market forces.
00:10:55Moving those critical roles into the market creates a larger labor pool, lowers wages,
00:11:00increases economic activity, and financializes every aspect so it can be taxed.0.61
00:11:04The mother now works a job so she can pay several other people to do the work of raising her
00:11:09children. Previously, it was one woman laboring outside the market providing education, supervision,1.00
00:11:15counseling, nutrition, and security. Now an entire team of employees provides the same service at a0.99
00:11:22much lower quality and at a much higher price, but every interaction is now financialized,
00:11:27quantifiable, and taxable. This deterritorialization of motherhood doesn't just boost gross domestic0.68
00:11:34product. It helps the overcode to scale by further separating the individual from a collective way0.89
00:11:39of life. A mother carries with her a whole set of expectations surrounding the rearing of her
00:11:45children. She doesn't just want her son to be a functional widget in a broader society, she cares0.97
00:11:50about his specific well-being. Her daughter's not just an employee or a student, but a precious
00:11:55vessel that carries the identity of her people into the future. A mother will insist on a moral0.91
00:12:00education based on specific religious beliefs, will expect a particular quality of food to be0.77
00:12:06provided, and will be discerning about who her child spends time with. The particularity associated
00:12:11with the direct motherly care creates friction for a system seeking to maximize cooperation
00:12:16because it insists that too much of the social process remain heavily territorialized.
00:12:22The attempt to create a scalable facsimile of the family is the natural process of expanding the overcode,
00:12:29and it's also a feature of most totalitarian governments.
00:12:32This doesn't need to occur via some form of market capitalism.
00:12:36Communist countries prize their ability to turn children against their parents, as did some fascist regimes.
00:12:41This is not solely the consequence of any economic or government system.
00:12:45It's the inevitable result of scaling overcodes, and while the project can provide basics like supervision, education, and nutrition, it does so at great cost.
00:12:56Humans are not the same. Some need more structure in education, some need less.
00:13:00Some need constant challenges, while others require constant affirmation.
00:13:04The more homogenous the process becomes, the further it can scale, but the worse the quality becomes for each individual.
00:13:10The family constructed by the overcoat also lacks very important qualities which were previously provided by the mother.
00:13:17Obviously, the mother provides real love and compassion that simply cannot be delivered by any employee,
00:13:23leaving the child lacking a real, primal sense of belonging and well-being.
00:13:27But the shortcomings manifest well beyond this dynamic.
00:13:30Food, clothing, and shelter are basic needs.1.00
00:13:33But the mother was providing a whole host of intangible social goods that don't get translated into the market during de-territorialization.0.99
00:13:41Yes, the mother now hires someone to watch and make food for their child.
00:13:46But who watches the streets and learns every car so they know if a stranger is stopping to pick up one of the neighborhood kids?
00:13:52Who plans vacation Bible school or organizes the bake sale to raise money for the family that had their house burned down?
00:13:58Who has the time to volunteer at the Kiwanis Club or arrange the community mixer where young people meet potential spouses?
00:14:44They can never reduce or increase the severity of the punishment
00:14:47due to their personal knowledge of the individual child.
00:14:50Every decision is designed to serve and protect the system, not the individual humans who live under its operation.
00:14:56The overcode stops serving people, and people begin to serve the overcode.
00:15:00As we discussed previously, territorialization acts as a limiting factor that ties the system, the code, to the specific people it's supposed to serve.
00:15:09The logic of the system might encourage it to sacrifice the well-being of the people for its own sake,
00:15:14but the grounding of the code in a particular culture prevents that logic from being taken
00:15:19to its conclusion. The homeostasis provided by territorialization protects the tribe,
00:15:24but it also limits the scaling of the code. Once those limitations have been removed by
00:15:29deterritorialization so that the system can scale, there's nothing stopping the overcoat
00:15:34from sacrificing the people it once served in order to achieve its own goals.
00:15:39The philosopher Nick Land is largely responsible for popularizing the term
00:15:43accelerationism in relation to this process. Traditional societies once acted as a limiting
00:15:49factor against deterritorialization, but the destruction of these human limitations has
00:15:54created a closed, self-exciting feedback loop. As an illustration, consider the function of an
00:15:59air conditioner. The process of heating a home is simple, and once it's begun, the air conditioner
00:16:04wants to continue that process indefinitely. If the system is allowed to continue to do what it
00:16:10was designed to do, it will increase the temperature in the home from a frosty 30 degrees to a
00:16:14comfortable 60 degrees to a sweltering 90 degrees before killing the family inside at 140 degrees.
00:16:21The key factor that allows the air conditioner to work for the sake of the humans inside the home
00:16:26is the thermostat. The thermostat interrupts the heating process by providing negative feedback
00:16:31and switching off the system once the home reaches the optimum temperature for humans.
00:16:36The system itself does not care about the humans and would cook them alive while doing its job without any negative feedback.
00:16:43It's the thermostat that territorializes the process, allowing it to operate freely until it reaches the limits of what's good for the family inside.
00:16:52Without that negative feedback, the process will kill the people it was designed to serve.
00:16:57The code was originally designed to serve a particular people, but it was deterritorialized so that it could expand along with the civilization.
00:17:04First, the code was altered in small ways,
00:17:06but as it became the overcode to govern a wide variety of peoples,
00:17:12By moving the sacred into the realm of the market,
00:17:15the overcode was able to create a vast network of people it could govern,
00:17:18but in the process it had to homogenize those peoples,
00:17:22stripping them of individuality and making them less human.
00:17:25The negative feedback that once limited the overcode to a specific people
00:17:29has been eliminated, and now the system operates only in its own interests.
00:17:33This closed loop only experiences positive feedback, creating a runaway cycle that accelerates with each turn.
00:17:40Many people think of intelligence as a purely human trait, something produced by a brain serving the needs and desires of a person who possesses it.
00:17:49For land, intelligence exists in an organism, system, or process that continuously corrects for feedback to produce an outcome that's different from that which would otherwise naturally occur.
00:18:00When the word cybernetics is used, it conjures images of science fiction robots, but that's not its original meaning.
00:18:07Cybernetics is the science of studying control and communication in both animals and machines.
00:18:12It's the investigation of feedback loops and how they allow both machines and biological organisms to self-regulate, correct for errors, and reach goals.
00:18:20As a man in a boat travels down the river, he is constantly making small adjustments with the rudder to keep the boat from crashing into the shore.
00:18:27The sailor is responding to feedback and is constantly learning how to better pilot his vessel.
00:18:32This is a cybernetic process in action, and for land, any entity, be it man, machine, or system engaged in this process, is gaining intelligence.
00:18:42From morning hockey with a cup of coffee to Timbits and road trips, Timbs and Canadian Tire have always gone together.
00:18:49Now it's official. You can now earn Canadian Tire money at Timbs.
00:18:52Link your Triangle Rewards and Timbs Rewards accounts to earn twice with every Timbs run.
00:18:57Terms and conditions apply. Visit timhortons.ca slash triangle for details.
00:19:02This conception of intelligence allows us to understand the behavior of non-human systems
00:19:07that seem to take on lives of their own. We all have seen this phenomenon before as we watch a
00:19:12bureaucratic organization sacrifice the well-being of the people who work for it and the people it
00:19:18was supposed to serve to increase its own size and power. The problem is one of incentives.
00:19:22Everyone who is being served by the public school system knows that an increase in managers and administrators doesn't benefit children in the classroom in the same way an increase in teachers would.
00:19:32Even most of the people working inside the school system know this.
00:19:35But since the 1950s, the number of principals and administrative staff in public schools has grown by 10 times the number of new teachers.
00:19:42The structure of the bureaucratic organization itself creates a feedback loop which trains the entity to grow its base of managers, even if every individual involved believes that the increase in teachers would be more beneficial.
00:19:56The organization has taken on a life and a logic all its own.
00:19:59The organization no longer serves the people.
00:20:01The people are simply fodder for the goals of the organization itself.
00:20:05This dynamic served as the central theme of the total state,
00:20:08where I explained why our government works in a radically different way
00:20:12than is described in the Constitution or in popular education.
00:20:16That phenomenon is not restricted to governments.
00:20:18It's simply an example of a process that's altering every aspect of our society.
00:20:24Everywhere we look, self-interested systems are tearing apart
00:20:28and rearranging human social structures to create an increasingly inhuman society