The Power of Patronage ｜ 4⧸20⧸23
Episode Stats
Words per Minute
153.96463
Summary
As the culture war rages, conservatives rush from issue to issue, chasing whatever the media dangles in front of them. Each time they come armed with facts and logic, well-constructed arguments designed to do battle in the marketplace of ideas, and yet Republicans continue to lose.
Transcript
00:00:00.000
We hope you're enjoying your Air Canada flight.
00:00:10.720
Fast-free Wi-Fi means I can make dinner reservations before we land.
00:00:25.260
Wi-Fi available to Airplane members on Equipped Flight.
00:00:30.000
As the culture war rages, conservatives rush from issue to issue, chasing whatever the
00:00:45.460
Each time, they come armed with facts and logic, well-constructed arguments designed to do battle
00:00:50.640
in the marketplace of ideas, and yet Republicans continue to lose.
00:00:55.000
The mainstream right has fully embraced the idea that in a democracy,
00:00:59.280
political battles are about making the most logical case to win over the majority,
00:01:04.240
but this is a terrible way to understand political loyalty.
00:01:07.880
In a democracy, people lend their political support to those who would deliver benefits
00:01:14.320
Don't get me wrong, there are plenty of true believers on the left, but the reason they
00:01:19.520
are so deeply invested in progressive ideology is that it delivers the goods.
00:01:24.780
The political contest in the United States is asymmetrical for several reasons, but one
00:01:30.280
of the most glaring is the way both sides approach the idea of patronage.
00:01:35.240
Patronage is the most ancient and powerful bond of political organization.
00:01:40.660
The patron provides protection, material rewards, and access to the client base, and the clients
00:01:47.220
provide loyalty and support to their political patron.
00:01:50.520
The left embraces this model and is proud of its ability to deliver for its clients.
00:01:56.460
The right rejects this model as a violation of its principles, and thereby denies itself
00:02:01.680
one of the most powerful tools with which to build power.
00:02:05.360
When progressives identify another front in the civil rights revolution, they don't just
00:02:10.460
see an opportunity to exploit identity and advance ideology, they see an opportunity to profit.
00:02:16.300
From the redefinition of marriage to the redefinition of woman, each battle requires massive amounts
00:02:23.360
of funding. New infrastructure is created as universities open academic departments dedicated
00:02:29.560
to studying the latest ideology, and NGOs are founded to employ the latest crop of activists.
00:02:36.560
Media campaigns are launched, concerts are held, movies are made, and foundations generate
00:02:42.200
research to bolster awareness about the latest progressive crusade.
00:02:47.340
Yes, there is a religious fervor in the advancement of progressive ideology, but behind that wave of
00:02:53.720
revolutionary zeal is a network of activists and academics that are cashing checks.
00:03:00.200
These clients owe their status and income to the progressive machine, which is why they will
00:03:05.880
lie down in traffic, or more often attack opponents in traffic, for the cause.
00:03:12.040
Benefits of the patronage model reach far beyond the activist class.
00:03:16.940
The left has established a vast network through its capture of most public institutions,
00:03:22.020
of which the most powerful is arguably the education system.
00:03:26.640
Teachers unions understand that the left keeps its leaders in power and its members employed.
00:03:32.160
Due to this direct infusion of power and cash, unions are motivated to ensure that their members
00:03:39.360
stay ideologically aligned. Public education is completely dominated by leftist radicals and
00:03:46.380
progressive doctrines. Few conservatives can obtain a degree from a college of education while
00:03:52.500
expressing their views, and any who manage to do so know that one ideological misstep in the
00:03:58.120
classroom will mean the end of their career. As a result, leftist propaganda is present in almost
00:04:04.140
everything a student hears, sees, and reads in class. Students are graded and promoted on their
00:04:11.900
ability to reliably repeat progressive narratives. The left's investment in patronage ensures them the
00:04:19.340
loyalty, not just of one generation of teachers, but of most students who will pass through the public
00:04:29.820
No Frills delivers. Get groceries delivered to your door from No Frills with PC Express.
00:04:35.360
Shop online and get $15 in PC Optimum points on your first five orders. Shop now at nofrills.ca.
00:04:43.260
Government employees have an obvious incentive to seek the expansion of government power and bureaucracy.
00:04:48.900
With the growth of government comes an increase in jobs, benefits, and status for public employees.
00:04:56.600
An ideological commitment to government expansion allows the left to win the loyalty of most public
00:05:01.980
sector employees, and politically motivated hiring follows, ensuring that those who make critical
00:05:07.840
decisions inside of the federal bureaucracy are progressive loyalists. Key agencies like the State
00:05:14.780
Department, FBI, and CIA become staffed by individuals who owe their status and livelihood to the Democratic
00:05:22.000
Party. And it's this political patronage that builds the left's monolithic control of the deep
00:05:28.860
state. While the influence of political patronage is easy to see in the public sector, its influence is
00:05:36.180
felt deeply in private corporations as well. Alright guys, so there's a new movie coming out that I think
00:05:41.780
you're gonna really want to see. I was lucky enough to see a special sneak preview. It's called
00:05:46.760
Nefarious. The best thing is that it's based on a book by the Blaze's very own Steve Dace. And Steve
00:05:53.200
is really passionate about it. He was kind enough to have me come to an advanced screening. I'm sure
00:05:58.660
you've seen the posters or maybe even the trailer, and it all looks great. It's kind of in between a
00:06:03.280
horror movie and a psychological thriller. It's very much in the vein of C.S. Lewis. You know the book
00:06:09.080
The Screwtape Letters, of course. Steve calls it interview with a demon. A psychiatrist is called
00:06:15.280
to a prison, and he has to meet with a convicted killer who's about to be executed. The killer claims
00:06:21.080
that he's a demon named Nefarious. And of course, the psychologist, he's an atheist. He doesn't believe
00:06:26.020
any of the supernatural stuff. But he's got to decide, you know, is this guy insane? Is he pretending
00:06:31.280
to be insane? Can he be executed for his heinous crimes? Obviously, I'm not going to give anything
00:06:37.060
away, but let's just say that the psychiatrist is in way over his head. It's a supernatural thriller
00:06:42.640
that's perfect for your friends who love scary movies, but also has a really important message.
00:06:47.740
It's the kind of movie that you'll be thinking about long after you get out of the theater.
00:06:52.100
Nefarious opens nationwide the weekend of April 14th. So make sure to mark the date and get your
00:06:58.160
tickets now at whoisnefarious.com. That's whoisnefarious.com.
00:07:04.420
The left has been so effective in the realm of law and culture that it's illegal to offend
00:07:10.720
leftists. Corporations spend billions of dollars in compliance costs to avoid legal action when it
00:07:17.860
comes to discrimination or the creation of a hostile workplace. And it is, of course, progressives
00:07:23.480
who create the ever-shifting definition of what constitutes discrimination or a hostile workplace.
00:07:29.360
This means that leftist political commissars, also known as human resource departments,
00:07:35.660
are a legal requirement for all major corporations. Armies of progressive activists are employed by
00:07:42.560
corporations to monitor every interaction between employees and purge wrongthink from their staff.
00:07:49.580
Those HR departments deliver mandatory re-education to all employees, ensuring that the latest progressive
00:07:56.740
dogma is memorized and repeated back to them by anyone who wants to keep his job.
00:08:02.540
Again, these jobs and the status that they grant are complete creations of the leftist patronage
00:08:08.740
machine. And every corporate HR director knows this. Their bond of loyalty to the Democratic Party
00:08:17.440
In order to defeat wokeness, the right must understand not just its ideological origins or
00:08:23.940
popular arguments, but its material incentives. Most people aren't simply cynical actors adopting
00:08:30.520
ideology for a paycheck, but they will naturally invest in the system on which they depend for
00:08:36.840
status and employment. Everyone needs to pay the mortgage and feel important. If woke ideology
00:08:43.060
remains the best way to climb the social hierarchy while landing a paycheck, people will pledge their
00:08:48.740
loyalty without worrying about logical contradictions. Facts might not care about your feelings,
00:08:55.140
but in a democracy, facts lose to feelings and cold hard cash every time. In a democracy,
00:09:02.960
vote buying is the best strategy, but it's usually illegal, so proxies are created through make-work
00:09:08.560
jobs and government benefits. Many on the right will be offended by this truth, but it remains
00:09:14.600
the truth nonetheless, and any group of political actors who ignore that truth do so at their own
00:09:21.180
peril. The classic conservative response to this truth has been to limit the size and scope of
00:09:27.340
government. If the government doesn't have jobs or cash to hand out, then the left can't use those
00:09:32.820
resources to gain power. This makes sense in theory, but in practice it's been a disaster. Despite
00:09:40.140
conservative efforts, government has exploded in size, and its influence over American life
00:09:45.760
is enormous. Even if government can be curtailed, the progressive patronage network has expanded well
00:09:53.100
beyond the bounds of its original host, and wokeness is now firmly implanted in private corporations
00:09:59.040
and the NGO complex. Containment has been an unsuccessful strategy, and the right must
00:10:05.520
acknowledge the political reality of patronage if it wishes to survive. Creating a competing patronage
00:10:12.600
network won't be easy. While Democrats eagerly redistribute funds to their base, conservatives
00:10:18.400
have been told that their ideology only allows tax dollars to go to arms manufacturers and bank
00:10:24.020
bailouts. While reducing the power and funds available to our current regime would be ideal,
00:10:30.600
it's not a long-term strategy for building and maintaining our own patronage network.
00:10:35.760
Mainstream conservatives are already good at funding some institutions, like think tanks,
00:10:40.780
but they must expand their ambitions and take on more substantive endeavors.
00:10:45.140
The efforts of individuals like Corey DeAngelis and Chris Ruffo to decouple our educational spending
00:10:51.320
from the progressive patronage network is a good start. If that funding can be redirected into a
00:10:57.420
network of schools that are committed to an explicitly conservative worldview, it would strip the
00:11:02.860
left of one of its greatest weapons while creating a blueprint for how patronage could work on the
00:11:07.880
right. Progressives spent many decades creating and expanding their patronage network, and it won't be
00:11:14.340
undone in one fell swoop. But if the right is to succeed, it must understand the inescapable power
00:11:23.260
Thanks for watching, guys. If you enjoyed this video, go ahead and click like, and if you haven't
00:11:30.780
subscribed yet, now is a great time to do so. If you'd like to get these broadcasts as podcasts,
00:11:36.600
make sure you go ahead and subscribe to The Oren McIntyre Show on your favorite podcast platform,
00:11:41.680
and when you do, go ahead and give it a rating or a review. That really helps with all the algorithm
00:11:46.580
magic. If you'd like to follow me on Twitter or Gab if you want to watch these videos on Odyssey or
00:11:52.820
Rumble or you want to follow me on Substack, the links to do all of that are down below in the
00:11:57.440
description. And of course, you can read all of my columns and catch all of my shows over at The
00:12:02.980
Blaze. Thanks for watching, guys, and as always, I'll talk to you next time.