The Ben Shapiro Show - October 05, 2026


Watch Tucker Carlson Get Dismantled on His Own Show

Topics
Hosted by
Mentioned
The Real Reason the Right Is Fighting Over the Economy The Dumbest Clips You'll See All Week

Episode Stats


Length

31 minutes

Words per minute

194.75

Word count

6,112

Sentence count

487

Harmful content

Misogyny

1

sentences flagged

Toxicity

29

sentences flagged

Hate speech

62

sentences flagged


Transcript

Transcripts from "The Ben Shapiro Show" are sourced from the Knowledge Fight Interactive Search Tool. Explore them interactively here.
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Topics generated with Qwen2.5-3B-Instruct.
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 Has the UK benefited from it?
00:00:02 We did the right thing.
00:00:03 Is it a better country than it was? 0.90
00:00:04 To have defeated Hitler, yes. 0.60
00:00:06 So the UK is a better country now. 0.88
00:00:08 It's a healthier country now. 1.00
00:00:09 But otherwise, we'll be speaking German. 1.00
00:00:11 Who cares?
00:00:15 So you might be asking yourself right now, what the actual f?
00:00:20 Is that Tucker Carlson?
00:00:21 You know, the guy from Fox News saying it would be better if Hitler had won World War II?
00:00:26 Yes, it is.
00:00:27 And in a moment, we'll examine why he would say something. 1.00
00:00:30 So disgusting and also stupid. 1.00
00:00:37 Okay, we need to begin with a simple fact. 1.00
00:00:39 There are lots and lots and lots of people in the United States who want to watch the system burn.
00:00:44 So, over the weekend, Tucker Carlson released an episode of his bizarre show with Jacob Reese Mogg, who is a member of Parliament in the UK for years.
00:00:52 He's a member of the Conservative Party.
00:00:53 He was a leader of the House of Commons, Lord President of the Council from 2019 to 2022.
00:00:58 And Mogg is a pretty normie Conservative, which is why Tucker got into it with him.
00:01:03 And the clips are legitimately insane.
00:01:06 So we'll begin with the revisionist history section of this interview.
00:01:10 So Tucker has this thing where he thinks that America was evil for dropping the A bomb to end World War II.
00:01:15 Presumably, he would have preferred if the United States had a million casualties in invading the Japanese home island.
00:01:21 But here is Tucker, Henry's mog.
00:01:23 I guess the question is if you are willing to kill non combatants who committed no crime, if you're willing to murder the innocent, then in what sense are you better than the people you are fighting?
00:01:37 That once a war is engaged, the whole point of what I'm talking about, to go back to the eight part of your question.
00:01:44 I will come back to it because it's to avoid war.
00:01:47 And you avoid war by being strong.
00:01:49 Once you're in war, you are justified in winning the war.
00:01:54 So you can behave like an animal once the war starts.
00:01:56 If the risk to you is sufficient, you can use nuclear weapons. 0.90
00:02:00 I think that is morally justifiable.
00:02:03 Again, Tucker has suggested that nuclear weapons were created by demons. 0.58
00:02:07 And also, that America lost its soul when it used the A bomb to end World War II.
00:02:12 Again, just going to point out that if the United States had actually had to invade the home islands of Japan without use of the A bomb to end the war, meaning six more months of war, that would have meant more dead Japanese and more dead Americans just by the fact.
00:02:26 And then, of course, as you saw, Tucker Carlson essentially says that it would have been better if Britain had just surrendered the continent to Hitler and maybe just cut a deal with Hitler where it became a vassal state.
00:02:39 Here's the exchange.
00:02:40 Hitler did not want to go to war with the UK.
00:02:43 He thought we wouldn't do anything about Poland as we'd done nothing about Czechoslovakia.
00:02:46 He thought we'd do nothing about Czechoslovakia.
00:02:48 Do you acknowledge that?
00:02:49 As we'd done nothing about Czechoslovakia, he thought we'd do nothing about Poland.
00:02:52 Do you acknowledge that Hitler said repeatedly in public and through diplomacy, I do not want war? 0.78
00:02:56 You seem to be putting more trust in Hitler than I would. 0.80
00:02:58 Just saying he said that. 0.93
00:02:58 He said also. 0.93
00:02:59 He signed an agreement with Neville Chamberlain.
00:03:01 Did he say that?
00:03:02 I really don't care what he said because he signed a piece of paper with Neville Chamberlain saying he would not invade.
00:03:07 I'm very surprised you're verging on defending Hitler.
00:03:10 I think this is not really what you want to be doing.
00:03:12 Yeah, I guess I'm just a secret Nazi.
00:03:16 Well, well, I don't think it's much of a secret what Tucker Carlson actually believes, as we'll get to in a moment.
00:03:24 And again, Riesmog is saying something very basic here, which is on foreign policy, because we're going to get to Russia Ukraine in a second, on foreign policy, the way that you prevent war is to show that you are strong, whereas Tucker Carlson believes the way to prevent war is to surrender to the Nazis.
00:03:38 And it is the projection of strength that avoids war.
00:03:43 And this is what we should be doing now.
00:03:44 We should learn from history that if your enemy thinks you are weak, then you find you get into war by accident.
00:03:52 If you show that you are strong, then the invasion doesn't take place.
00:03:58 Okay, so why is this important?
00:04:00 Because then Tucker gets into it with Rees Mogg with regard to Russia and Ukraine.
00:04:04 Rees Mogg is a defender of Ukraine. 0.55
00:04:06 He believes that Russia is the aggressor state, which of course it is.
00:04:09 So we begin with Tucker asking, why is the UK confronting Russia?
00:04:14 Do you disagree that they could if they wanted to today and this war?
00:04:18 Of course they could.
00:04:19 Well, I think if they took it to another level, they would risk.
00:04:23 Maybe if you keep pushing them, they'll do it.
00:04:24 And maybe that's the basis of this conversation, which is why are you pushing them to do it?
00:04:28 No, I'm not pushing.
00:04:30 I'm pushing us to be prepared because they are making attacks on the West.
00:04:34 And we know this.
00:04:35 They are making cyber attacks.
00:04:36 They are making.
00:04:37 But do you see a connection between what the West is doing and Russia's attacks on the West?
00:04:42 Or is this just.
00:04:43 What would be the other explanation for why they're doing it?
00:04:45 I think the reason for Russia going into Ukraine, what allowed them to do it, was our weakness earlier over the Crimea.
00:04:53 And that made it look as if we didn't really care.
00:04:56 And Tucker's entire mission here is to suggest once again that the enemies of the West are right and the West is wrong for defending itself.
00:05:03 Reese Mogg asked Tucker Carlson, Do you even believe in the territorial integrity of nation states?
00:05:08 And Tucker says, I do in America, but not really anywhere else.
00:05:11 Do you believe in territorial integrity of nation states?
00:05:15 In my own, for sure.
00:05:16 I'm not sure the territorial integrity of someone else's state is worth risking my life for.
00:05:22 The question is, should, first of all, can you guarantee it?
00:05:25 America did. 0.50
00:05:26 So do you think that was wrong? 1.00
00:05:28 Okay, so again, I mean, Reese Mogg is just stepping all over Tucker. 0.97
00:05:32 And of course, Tucker is just unbelievably ignorant about the stuff that he purports to speak about.
00:05:37 Here's Reese Smog talking to Tucker about Tucker's theory that NATO caused Russia to invade Ukraine. 0.97
00:05:43 You're not listening.
00:05:44 No obligation to you.
00:05:46 You seem to be devoid of nuance, that the two questions are not the same.
00:05:50 Just because you've signed a treaty does not automatically commit you to fighting a war.
00:05:55 And then it gets really spicy for Tucker because Tucker can't help but become a full scale defender of the Russian regime, which, again, is a tyrannical and dictatorial regime run by Vladimir Putin, his friend.
00:05:55 Okay.
00:06:08 So Tucker humiliates himself.
00:06:10 By suggesting that Russia has a larger economy than Britain's, which is just not true.
00:06:14 It still doesn't explain why Russia would want to pick a fight with Britain.
00:06:19 It's got a much larger economy than Britain's, by I think.
00:06:23 No, no, no, it hasn't got a larger economy than Britain.
00:06:25 It's got a smaller economy than Britain's.
00:06:27 It's got a much larger military.
00:06:29 It's got a much larger economy.
00:06:31 It has much more wealth and resources.
00:06:33 It's a much larger manufacturing sector.
00:06:35 It's GDP is smaller than the UK's.
00:06:38 Yeah, but it's about 2000.
00:06:39 GDP is not, I mean, the only measure of an economy.
00:06:41 It's a really important measure of an economy.
00:06:44 It's one measure.
00:06:45 We can do it.
00:06:45 Russia is an economic failure.
00:06:49 It could have a huge economy, but it's got a small economy because it's deeply corrupt and it hasn't managed to use its resources effectively.
00:06:59 And so, although the population of Russia is bigger than that of the United Kingdom very significantly, its GDP per capita is so much lower that the total GDP of Russia is smaller than that of the United Kingdom.
00:07:12 Right.
00:07:13 Its inherent wealth dwarfs that of the UK.
00:07:16 It's the largest country in the world.
00:07:18 But leaving aside that, I'm not in charge of central government.
00:07:20 Yeah, but inherent wealth isn't very useful, is it?
00:07:22 There are lots of African countries that have huge resources that have never been able to use them.
00:07:26 It depends what your timeline is.
00:07:26 Well, if you go over hundreds of years, they haven't used them.
00:07:29 Russia has consistently been a poor country in spite of its resources.
00:07:33 Sorry.
00:07:34 The fact that anyone takes Tucker Carlson seriously as an intellectual interlocutor is just insane.
00:07:41 I mean, Jacob Rees Mogg, being like the most British person who ever Britished, And basically, in very kindly fifth grade school mom fashion, explaining to Tucker how economics works on a basic level is insane.
00:07:55 Basic level is insane.
00:07:56 But Tucker didn't even stop there.
00:07:58 Tucker then claimed that the UK punishes people for free speech, but Russia does not.
00:08:03 And again, Reese Mogg looks like he doesn't know how he's found himself in a room with an ambulatory psychotic.
00:08:10 I just don't understand, given what you've already just conceded, that the government of the United Kingdom is punishing and prohibiting people and ideas it doesn't like.
00:08:24 Russia is not doing that.
00:08:25 So how is.
00:08:26 What?
00:08:27 You can't say what it means in Russia.
00:08:27 To you.
00:08:29 It's doing it in spades. 0.92
00:08:31 It's beating people up, it's restoring them, it's murdering.
00:08:32 In this country?
00:08:34 No, your citizens are.
00:08:34 Well, it's.
00:08:35 Russia has poisoned people in this country.
00:08:39 Russia has put fewer people in jail in the last year for social media posts than the UK has.
00:08:47 They just accidentally fall out of windows in Russia.
00:08:51 And nobody dares say it in Russia because they're not related to it.
00:08:54 Neither of us live in Russia, but if you're a Briton, if you live in this country and your ancestors have lived here for thousands of years.
00:09:00 The threat to your freedom comes from your government, not Russia.
00:09:03 I'm not in favor of the way free speech is being policed in this country.
00:09:09 So, why not try to overthrow your government?
00:09:11 Well, I hope to stand at the next election.
00:09:13 We have a democracy that functions.
00:09:15 But if they're oppressing you, if you can't say what you think, that's oppression.
00:09:18 Again, just insanity.
00:09:20 Total insanity. 0.99
00:09:21 So, what the hell is Tucker doing here aside from making a total and complete ass of himself? 0.99
00:09:27 The answer is actually pretty simple. 0.98
00:09:29 Tucker hates the West as currently constituted.
00:09:32 He believes that at some point in the past, the West fundamentally betrayed itself, and he is intent on ripping it down.
00:09:38 And he's not the only one, of course.
00:09:39 This is why I've said many, many times that Tucker is the horseshoe right, and he joins hands with the left in hatred for the West.
00:09:46 Again, the left believes that the United States, again, fundamentally went wrong.
00:09:50 There's something deeply ill at the root of American society.
00:09:53 Not that we have some problems, but there is something that needs to be completely destroyed.
00:09:58 Here's Ben Affleck over the weekend at the premiere of a movie called Animals saying there's collective disappointment with American politics.
00:10:04 I think that there is a, whatever side of the aisle you're on, one of the interesting things that people can agree on is that a collective disappointment with the way that American politics has trended.
00:10:17 There's nobody alive now who thinks, hey, we're really doing it right and things are going great and I love this political system. 0.97
00:10:24 Okay, but again, Ben Affleck is kind of the idiot clique of the left wing political sphere. 0.96
00:10:29 Abdullah Syed might be the next senator from Michigan. 0.99
00:10:32 Here he was on higher learning with Rachel Lindsay.
00:10:35 Again, I'm not sure.
00:10:37 A more oxymoronic title for a show has ever been put forth than Higher Learning with Rachel Lindsay.
00:10:43 Here's El Syed explaining that if you're black in America, you have never had access to capitalism. 0.65
00:10:48 If you're black in America, you've never actually had access to real capitalism. 0.90
00:10:52 You had your labor extracted from you via the most fundamentally unethical, immoral act of placing somebody in slavery. 0.79
00:11:05 And then we've excluded black folk in different ways. 0.92
00:11:09 We still exclude black folk in different ways.
00:11:11 From full participation in capitalism via access to capital, via access to good schools, via access to healthcare, via access to all these things. 0.90
00:11:18 Yeah, America is fundamentally broken and always was fundamentally broken.
00:11:21 Meanwhile, Zorhan Mamdani appeared with horseshoe commentator Theo Vaughn, whose mullet has grown deep into his brainstem at this point, considering that he has very little brain function, unfortunately.
00:11:33 Zorhan Mamdani explains that when he feels isolated, his solution was to join the Democratic Socialists of America.
00:11:39 I mean, the place that I found as my political home. Was an organization called the Democratic Socialists of America.
00:11:46 And this was a place where I would just go for meetings and I would meet people who felt the same way.
00:11:50 And first, you would realize that you're not alone.
00:11:54 You're not nuts.
00:11:56 You are actually part of something much bigger than yourself, and you can be as well.
00:12:02 And it feels like when people go through life, the further they get away from school, the more isolated they start to become from the world around them.
00:12:10 And that is also a function of a society where people are what they call increasingly atomized, just separated out.
00:12:20 And so much of the fabric that we used to have, it started to.
00:12:23 Come apart at the seams.
00:12:25 And for me, being a member of this organization, it was something that opened my eyes to how to make sense of it and also what I could do to change it.
00:12:33 And that was something that it didn't just help me with my anxiety.
00:12:36 It also just helped me with my sense of my place in the world where it was like, okay, I feel this way.
00:12:41 Here's a candidate that feels the same.
00:12:43 I'm going to go and knock on doors for them.
00:12:45 Just going to point out that again, Zoram Amdani, Theo Vaughn, Tucker Carlson, Abdul Al Sayyid, they're all on the same train.
00:12:51 And the train is that the West is bad and fundamentally flawed.
00:12:54 We'll get to more on that in a moment.
00:12:55 You need better wireless coverage at the best possible price.
00:12:58 More than 120,000 wireless customers participated in a recent industry survey.
00:13:03 PureTalk was the only wireless company in the country turned five out of five stars in every single category.
00:13:08 Coverage, support, value, data.
00:13:10 Unlimited high speed data with PureTalk is just $34.99 a month.
00:13:13 Those numbers are great.
00:13:14 I know because I use PureTalk myself.
00:13:15 I make calls, I send the text, the videos, the whole thing.
00:13:17 Unlimited data.
00:13:18 I can tell you firsthand the coverage is awesome right now.
00:13:20 You can also save 50% off your first month when you switch.
00:13:23 So 50% off, $34.99 a month for the unlimited plan with five star quality and experience.
00:13:29 What do you have to lose except for, you know, the high prices?
00:13:32 Go to puretalk.comslash Shapiro.
00:13:34 Stop overpaying for subpar wireless service.
00:13:36 Stop buying the nonsense that you have to walk into some sort of wireless store and they'll offer you a smorgasbord of options.
00:13:42 Then you just get the most expensive one.
00:13:43 Don't do that.
00:13:44 Instead, check out puretalk.com.
00:13:45 That's puretalk.comslash Shapiro.
00:13:47 Save 50% off your very first month of coverage.
00:13:50 Again, puretalk.comslash Shapiro.
00:13:52 Go check them out.
00:13:53 puretalk.comslash Shapiro.
00:13:55 Welcome to puretalk.
00:13:56 So, why are so many people, the people who I once called disintegrationists, In my best selling book, How to Destroy America in Three Easy Steps, because they want America to disintegrate and they would like that to happen.
00:14:08 Why are they so intent on destroying the country?
00:14:10 To understand the answer to that question, we have to understand another question that Tucker Carlson and people like him on both the right and the left keep asking pretty publicly.
00:14:18 Where did everything go wrong for America?
00:14:21 Where did everything go wrong for the United States?
00:14:23 Now, the answer to that question for most Americans is simple.
00:14:27 It didn't all go wrong.
00:14:27 It didn't.
00:14:29 America is a pretty fantastic place.
00:14:31 It's the envy of the world.
00:14:32 It's a place of opportunity and unparalleled prosperity.
00:14:35 And it's a country that currently presides over the entire global order.
00:14:38 So it didn't all go wrong.
00:14:39 Some things have gone wrong and many things have actually gone right.
00:14:42 That's what a normal person might say.
00:14:45 The art of politics for people who don't want to destroy the system lies in keeping what is good and taking away what is bad.
00:14:51 We used to call that conservatism.
00:14:54 G.K. Chesterton, the conservative theologian once said, quote, the truth is that nobody has any business to destroy a social institution until he has really seen it as a historical institution.
00:15:05 If he knows how it arose and what purposes it was supposed to serve, he may really be able to say, Okay, but the revolutionaries in the moment, the Tucker Carlson's, the Abdul Al Said's, the Zar Mamdanis, that's not what they think. 0.99
00:15:27 They think that their fathers and grandfathers were idiots who sold their birthright. 0.98
00:15:32 Their birthright must be restored by ripping down all the systems. 1.00
00:15:39 That's the story told by all the revolutionary movements in America.
00:15:42 Things were going all right for the most part until everything went wrong for us and people like us.
00:15:48 So here's the basic idea.
00:15:50 Forget Tucker and Abdul Al Sayed or Zorhan Mamdani.
00:15:53 We are living in a uniquely terrible moment. 0.99
00:15:55 Things suck, but they don't just suck right now. 0.93
00:15:58 They are doomed to suck forever because the systems are fundamentally broken. 0.97
00:16:02 That's because there is some historical inflection point, a point at which Marty McFly's mom and dad met the wrong way, thus unleashing a chain of inevitabilities that have culminated in Marty McFly's car crashing and him not being able to go to the lake with Jennifer.
00:16:15 Right.
00:16:15 And that's why we have a terrible moment because something bad happened in the past.
00:16:18 Now, most Americans, why don't we believe that there was this terrible moment?
00:16:21 Well, because we were lied to.
00:16:23 We are infused with a false consciousness that has hypnotized us into accepting a decayed present and a dead future.
00:16:30 So, the goal of these revolutionaries on all sides is therefore to disabuse Americans of the false consciousness, to awaken them, to woke us about the reality of our terrible moment by exploding the supposedly false story of our past.
00:16:44 And, of course, the radical movements want to strip away this veil of illusion, to unmask the satanic conspirators who purposefully and maliciously let us awry and continue to do so today.
00:16:55 So who are these satanic conspirators who keep saying that things are going fine?
00:16:58 Or more importantly, that even if they're not going fine right now, the institutions are not fundamentally broken.
00:17:03 We've just screwed around with them.
00:17:05 Who are the bad guys?
00:17:05 The people who are doing well right now.
00:17:08 If you're doing well, you're an exploiter.
00:17:10 If you are doing poorly, you're a victim.
00:17:11 So the people who have benefited from the selling of our birthright, those are the ones who are in control.
00:17:16 They've manipulated us. 0.96
00:17:18 They must be destroyed.
00:17:19 This is the common thread to all the revolutionary movements happening right now in the West. 0.53
00:17:23 America and the West were betrayed.
00:17:25 The people who benefited from that betrayal lied to you about everything.
00:17:28 So they and the systems they created supposedly must be destroyed.
00:17:32 Okay, so let me give you a few examples. 0.94
00:17:34 Some of them, non Tucker, you can see what I'm talking about here.
00:17:37 Okay, so there's a Marxist strain in the United States and in the West right now that wants to see the West destroyed.
00:17:43 So what do Marxists at core argue?
00:17:45 Well, they argue that long ago, human beings lived in a romantic commune with nature and one another.
00:17:51 And, you know, they would wander the forests and the fields and they would hunt and they would gather and they would live rich and rewarding social lives.
00:17:57 And then, say the Marxist philosophers or pre-Marxist philosophers like Jean-Jacques Rousseau, things went wrong.
00:18:02 People realized they could farm, right?
00:18:04 This is the inflection point.
00:18:05 And once they realized the power of agriculture, they began to fence off property and call it private property and monopolize resources, thus leading to the rise of jealousy and tyranny and oppression.
00:18:15 People fell for the trick.
00:18:16 Humanity's been going wrong ever since.
00:18:17 So Rousseau's heirs, including people like Karl Marx, made the same argument.
00:18:21 That argument is made today by people like Bernie Sanders, who insists that every innovation is actually a robbery from a mythical commons.
00:18:27 And that the only reason that you're not a communist and don't understand this is because you were implanted with a False consciousness.
00:18:33 Marx said this.
00:18:34 He actually wrote, the press, the pulpit, the comic papers, in short, by all the means at the disposal of the ruling classes, it is the secret by which the capitalist class maintains its power.
00:18:43 Basically, you've been indoctrinated. 0.51
00:18:46 In the modern era, that's the same argument that you see El Syed making in that clip.
00:18:52 It's the same argument made by Nicole Hannah Jones, creator of the 1619 Project.
00:18:55 America went wrong from the start because it believed in meritocracy and individual rights and free markets, and those are outgrowths of greed and venality and racism.
00:19:05 So, all of those things have to be destroyed. 0.87
00:19:08 This is why Nicole Hannah Jones, back when she wrote the 1619 Project, said, If I ever think everyone has the same opportunities in America and where black people struggle, it's because of their own pathology. 0.94
00:19:18 I support regressive individualistic policy that doesn't change the structure or hierarchy or inequality in our system.
00:19:23 So, again, who's the evil enemy?
00:19:25 Who's manipulated us all?
00:19:26 Well, you'll never guess.
00:19:27 So, Marx argued that in order to achieve the overthrow of all of these structures, right, a free market rooted in private property, who are the big problems here? 1.00
00:19:37 The Jews, right? 0.83
00:19:37 There's an argument that Karl Marx made in a famous essay called On the Jews. 0.83
00:19:41 He said, Let us not look for the secret of the Jew in his religion. 0.88
00:19:44 Let us look for the secret of his religion in the real Jew. 0.64
00:19:47 What is the secular basis of Judaism? 0.99
00:19:49 Practical need, self interest. 0.97
00:19:51 What is the worldly religion of the Jew? 1.00
00:19:52 Huckstering. 1.00
00:19:53 What is his worldly God?
00:19:54 Money. 0.82
00:19:55 He says the emancipation of the Jews is the emancipation of mankind from Judaism. 0.62
00:20:00 So the Marxist left is still singing the same tune. 0.86
00:20:02 If you wonder why the Marxist left today has turned anti Semitic, this would be the reason.
00:20:05 They argue that the Jews in both America and Israel are the beneficiaries of a racist system, that they are the propagators of all the institutions that continue to foment racism. 0.63
00:20:18 And it should not be a surprise to anybody that Black Lives Matter's group were on the same side as Hamas on October 7th.
00:20:25 Now, I'm using the Marxists as an example, but they are not the only example. 0.82
00:20:29 Again, the revolutionaries who want to tear down the entire system. 0.59
00:20:32 So, a group from the right, the so called Catholic Integralists.
00:20:36 Again, the entire idea here is there was some historical juncture at which the entire thing went haywire and sideways.
00:20:43 So, this is a fairly small group of intellectuals who argue that basically the West went wrong with the End of the Holy Roman Empire.
00:20:50 The world was gradually falling under the sway of the universal church.
00:20:53 Everything was great.
00:20:54 The Holy Roman Empire was thriving.
00:20:56 Everything was awesome. 0.95
00:20:57 And then the Protestant Reformation broke everything.
00:20:59 So, according to Catholic integralist Adrian Vermeule, who's a professor at Harvard, he says, Now, what is at stake indeed is far more elevated than power.
00:21:07 What is at stake is no less than authority.
00:21:09 The full authority of a reasoned political order composed of both temporal and spiritual powers in right relation to the natural and divine law that would put a mere Rome to shame.
00:21:18 That limitless ambition is why liberalism finds a genuinely political Catholicism intolerable.
00:21:23 Why a liberal order will only accept a version of Catholicism that submits to be ruled.
00:21:27 So basically, he's saying Catholicism ought to win and liberalism ought to lose.
00:21:31 And the argument that he makes is that history, again, went haywire with the Protestant Reformation.
00:21:35 So, in this view, Enlightenment progress has to be denigrated.
00:21:39 Free markets, the single most obvious material feature of the Enlightenment era viewpoint of the Anglo American Protestant world, has to be downplayed or demonized as ineffective and dehumanizing.
00:21:52 So, Patrick Dunin, another Catholic integralist, laments free markets as inherently unfree and ugly.
00:21:57 In terms that are basically the same as those of Karl Marx.
00:22:00 He writes, Our main political choices come down to which depersonalized mechanism will purportedly advance our freedom and security.
00:22:06 The space of the market, which collects our billions upon billions of choices to provide for our wants and needs without demanding from us any specific thought or intention about the wants and needs of others, or the liberal state, which establishes depersonalized procedures and mechanisms for the wants and needs of others that remain insufficiently addressed by the market.
00:22:22 Indeed, it's really not a surprise to find this kind of language emanating predominantly from advocates for Catholic integralism, because if we recognize that, say, free markets.
00:22:30 And individual liberty are actually kind of awesome.
00:22:33 That the extraordinary freedom and prosperity of the West are downstream from the Protestant Reformation.
00:22:38 You're going to have to admit that historically speaking, Catholic universalism wasn't working all that well.
00:22:43 And so instead, it's important to pretend that free markets, even though they enrich us, are basically robbing us of our spirit and our souls and our true freedom by creating new ones.
00:22:52 Okay, now back to Tucker Carlson.
00:22:54 It's a long digression just to show you that all of these revolutionary movements have the same structure.
00:22:59 We'll get to more on that in a moment.
00:23:00 You need your sleep, which is why you need the best mattress in existence.
00:23:03 And the best mattress for you is not the same as the best mattress for me.
00:23:06 You need a mattress that's made just for you, which is what Helix Sleep achieves.
00:23:10 Helix's quick sleep quiz considers your sleep position, comfort preferences, and support needs, and then matches you with one of more than 20 mattress models.
00:23:17 Every Helix includes free U.S. shipping, a 120 night sleep trial, a limited lifetime warranty, and that happy with Helix guarantee for seamless returns and exchanges.
00:23:25 Head on over to helixsleep.com slash Ben for 20% off store wide during Helix's fall sales event.
00:23:31 Now again, I'm on the road right now.
00:23:32 I am not sleeping as well.
00:23:33 Maybe you can see it on my face.
00:23:34 I'm a little tired.
00:23:35 One of the big reasons for that is that I do not have my Helix Sleep mattress here.
00:23:39 Again, I wish I did, but when I get back home, I'm looking forward to plopping down on that Helix Sleep mattress.
00:23:44 It is firm but breathable, made just for me and my wife.
00:23:46 It's awesome.
00:23:47 Go check out your version over at helixsleep.comslash Ben and get 20% off store wide.
00:23:53 That is helixsleep.comslash Ben, a mattress made just for you so you can sleep the way you need to.
00:23:57 Helixsleep.comslash Ben, get 20% off store wide.
00:24:01 So, what is Tucker's answer to the question of when things went wrong?
00:24:05 Right?
00:24:05 That's the question.
00:24:06 When things went wrong.
00:24:07 His answer is World War II, which is why he is laser beam focused on World War II.
00:24:12 So, here's his story about where the Marty McFly moment happened.
00:24:16 Where the parents met because dad was supposedly bird watching, but was actually putting binoculars up so that he could be a peeping Tom.
00:24:24 Okay, where did things go wrong? 0.54
00:24:26 So, according to Tucker Carlson, at one point in history, America was a land of white people like Tucker Carlson.
00:24:33 The definition of white kept on expanding.
00:24:34 It embraced Irish and Scotch and Italians and Germans and Swedes.
00:24:38 And sure, a lot of the people who immigrated to America were Catholic and not Protestant.
00:24:41 But, says Tucker, the story of America was never a creed.
00:24:44 It wasn't the Declaration.
00:24:45 It wasn't about the Constitution.
00:24:47 It was a people. 0.67
00:24:49 And those people were fundamentally betrayed by American leadership, which turned away from its people toward other shores, siding with communists and Jews and globalists instead of ignoring the problems of Europe or even siding with Germany, which again was full of white people instead.
00:25:04 America's triumph over Nazism in World War II, so goes the argument, turned us from a white Christian country into a multiracial global empire in hot to free market capitalism and secular humanism.
00:25:14 Now again, this is not an argument unique to Tucker.
00:25:16 This is an argument that Pat Buchanan used to make.
00:25:18 He used to argue that World War II was a tragic mistake by people who resisted Hitler.
00:25:23 So he wrote a book in which he said, quote, historians will look back on the 1914 through 1918 and 1939 to 1945 as two phases of the Great Civil War of the West, where the once Christian nations of Europe fell upon one another with such savage abandon, they brought down all their empires, brought an end to centuries of Western rule, and advanced the death of their civilization.
00:25:41 Now, what's weird about that, again, is that the outcome of that particular period was an America that was heavily Christian dominating the world.
00:25:51 Dominating the world. 0.92
00:25:53 The only two powers that were left after World War II were the Soviets and the United States.
00:25:58 The United States was a heavily practicing Christian country.
00:26:01 And the United States was not only dominant, it then proceeded to dominate the Cold War and win.
00:26:07 Okay, so that's a weird narrative.
00:26:10 It's a strange narrative.
00:26:12 So, what brought about the war, according to Buchanan?
00:26:14 He said, While Irish and German Americans were the most vocal about staying out of World War II, Jewish Americans clamored to have the United States smash Hitler's regime.
00:26:22 After World War II, Jewish influence over foreign policy became. 0.62
00:26:25 Almost an obsession with American leaders. 0.94
00:26:27 Okay, so that's the story.
00:26:28 Hey, wonder why the obsession with World War II and why Tucker talks about Israel and the Jews more than a rabbi?
00:26:33 This is why.
00:26:34 So, Tucker Carlson, his entire worldview is America went wrong during World War II.
00:26:40 And so, everything since then has been bad, which of course is not true.
00:26:43 In fact, many, many things have been quite good.
00:26:46 So, his history is wrong.
00:26:48 The way he tells the history is wrong.
00:26:50 The way he talks about the modern world is wrong.
00:26:51 And the way he talks about the current situation and past situation of the United States is wrong.
00:26:55 But again, that's the narrative.
00:26:57 So, Tucker then paints Winston Churchill as the chief villain of World War II.
00:27:01 And he makes the same case, while, of course, hosting pseudo historians like Darrell Cooper, who say that Churchill himself manipulated the world into World War II on behalf of Zionist paymasters, which, of course, is historically false.
00:27:14 So, Tucker constantly says that while the Allies defeated the Nazis, Western civilization was lost.
00:27:20 So, where's the victory?
00:27:21 Now, again, as I say, that argument requires enormous revisionist history and historical ignorance. 0.55
00:27:27 Nazi Germany was not a Christian paradise.
00:27:30 Nazi Germany targeted Catholics.
00:27:32 Nazi Germany was a barbaric, tyrannical dictatorship intent on mass murder and expansion and attacks on other Christian countries, including, for example, Poland or the Czech Republic or Austria.
00:27:44 The Molotov Ribbentrop Pact had the Nazis siding with the barbarically anti Christian Soviets to carve up Europe.
00:27:50 It sided with the non Christian country Japan and then went to war with the United States.
00:27:55 After World War II, there was the Cold War, and that ended with the United States removing the most notoriously atheistic anti Christian regime ever devised in world history. 0.52
00:28:05 Again, in the 1950s, the United States was one of the most highly church going civilizations on planet Earth.
00:28:11 And by the way, since World War II, America's prosperity has led the globe out of abject poverty, increased life expectancy, and living standards domestically in unprecedented ways.
00:28:19 Now, all of this has to be ignored or explained away by people like Tucker as false consciousness brought about by propaganda, right? 0.97
00:28:24 America has actually sucked. 0.99
00:28:25 You didn't know it, but America has sucked since World War II. 0.99
00:28:28 The propaganda, that's done by, well, you know who. 0.98
00:28:31 You know who.
00:28:31 Wink, wink, nod, nod.
00:28:33 American foreign policy wasn't actually controlled by white Christian Americans predominantly. 0.83
00:28:37 In fact, it was controlled by you know who.
00:28:40 So, what's Tucker's end goal here?
00:28:42 It's the same as Nicole Hannah Jones is or Adrian Vermeule's or any other revolutionary who's seeking to overturn the system.
00:28:48 First, you demoralize.
00:28:50 See, here's the thing America is responsible for the greatest movement away from poverty, away from tyranny in all of human history.
00:28:59 American citizens have it better than anyone else, anywhere, anytime in human history.
00:29:04 And so, the chief goal of all these radicals on all sides of the aisle is demoralization.
00:29:08 So, Bernie Sanders tells us we're all poor and suffering victims of the supposed billionaires and millionaires.
00:29:14 And that the solution to all of that is a centralized government redistribution.
00:29:18 Catholic integralists will tell us we live in a godless, unrooted society, isolated and atomistic, and the reason for that is capitalism.
00:29:24 And the only cure is that we should get rid of the liberal principles of the Declaration and the Constitution and return to a sort of new Holy Roman Empire and listen to the Pope in Rerum Navarum. 0.86
00:29:34 The Tuckers of the world argue we live in an overrun, impoverished, spiritually barren society. 0.80
00:29:38 The only cure is a turn inward toward exclusivity and homogeneity, nothing to do with ideas. 0.99
00:29:44 It turns out we never won World War II.
00:29:46 We never won the Cold War. 1.00
00:29:47 Bin Laden, hell, he might have been right. 0.99
00:29:49 Abdullah Sayed might be right about 9 11. 0.99
00:29:51 We never landed on the moon.
00:29:52 We never overcame racism.
00:29:53 We never alleviated poverty.
00:29:55 Defeating transgenderism is a nothing burger. 1.00
00:29:57 Fighting DEI is a losing battle. 1.00
00:29:59 Our foreign policy has been outsourced to nefarious Jews. 1.00
00:30:01 Our domestic policy has been completely thwarted by evil people at the top who want to deracinate you. 0.83
00:30:08 And who's to blame for all of this, according to Tucker?
00:30:10 Well, I think.
00:30:11 Wink, wink.
00:30:11 What an amazing video you just watched!
00:30:13 Wasn't that amazing?
00:30:14 Well, you know, if you think so, head on over to dailywire.comslash subscribe to watch the full show ad free or check out this crazy story here.
00:30:22 Every significant movement in history has started with protesting.
00:30:24 Now I've tried it.
00:30:25 It's Uncle Tom.
00:30:26 This is our generation's civil rights.
00:30:27 I have no idea what the protest is about.
00:30:30 Bingo.
00:30:30 Given the current climate, should a figure as polarizing as Clay Saunders even be allowed on campus?
00:30:36 Ah, can you hear me okay?
00:30:37 Saunders is a close personal friend of Chancellor Friedman.
00:30:39 This is a decision I cannot fight. 1.00
00:30:41 Islam will conquer the West. 1.00
00:30:43 Assalamualaikum. 1.00
00:30:48 Are we paying attention?
00:30:50 They've taken over the building.
00:30:51 They're downstairs and they've blocked the doors.
00:30:54 I seek forgiveness from Allah the Almighty.
00:30:58 We cannot run and hide.
00:31:00 Muhammad is the messenger of God.
00:31:04 There is no God but Allah.
00:31:06 What do you say? 0.99
00:31:08 He turned those SOBs into a fine red mist. 1.00
00:31:13 As we move, one man will cover while the other guys go. 1.00
00:31:16 They call that leapfrogging.
00:31:17 Stretch them out and listen.
00:31:20 You need a course in safe weapons handling.