00:00:56Noble Gold Investments is the official gold sponsor of The Charlie Kirk Show, a company that specializes in gold IRAs and physical delivery of precious metals.
00:01:06Learn how you could protect your wealth with Noble Gold Investments at Noble Gold Investments.com.
00:01:54So, there, this story, if you guys haven't heard about it, there is an autonomous zone that has developed right at the border where they're trying to construct the border wall.
00:02:04And there was a tree in place that a bunch of sort of like, if you just put your mind back in the summer of love, the Chaz Chop.
00:02:16You have a bunch of crazed leftist Antifa types camping out at the border trying to block the demolition of a tree to take out this tree that would get in the way of a border wall.
00:03:24So, you have actually this area, they're trying to build a double border wall because it's called a quick hitter spot.
00:03:29So, this means that you have cartel activity, human smuggling, drug smuggling activity happening in this corridor at a higher rate than anywhere else.
00:03:36So, it's a high priority to get this double border wall up.
00:03:38But these activists, they've kind of almost posed themselves as environmentalists.
00:03:42And as this has dragged on, it's been going on since July 27th.
00:04:46So, they hadn't, you know, they knew that the guys up top were good, you know, me and our camera op were good, but they didn't know Brandon yet.
00:04:52So, the Border Patrol guys down there sent him under the tape to the private property.
00:04:56And these guys are like, What you don't belong over here, yeah.
00:04:59And they immediately start assaulting him.
00:05:01You know, they broke his meta glasses, they tried punching him, tried breaking his camera.
00:05:05So, naturally, he says, I'm getting out of here.
00:06:24Got this goon over here just yelling at me.
00:06:26And now we got these construction trucks coming to tear down this tree that all these far left activists are protesting over because they don't want the tree torn down so that they can't finish building the border wall.
00:06:42And I told him, I'm like, you guys are all posing as environmentalists when the only thing you care about is the wall because you have nothing better to do with your time.
00:07:15It's like a patchwork of federal reservation lands and of private land kind of in this place.
00:07:20So, The private land owners that happen to own all this land along the easement, they are in support of these protesters and in support of their directors.
00:07:28Why would they be in support of a bunch of drug smugglers that can get in?
00:07:41It's just the fact that no media has really known this has been going on since July 27th.
00:07:46And the fact that this has been able to go on since then, it needs to be addressed.
00:07:50And that was the whole point of coming down here, to shine a light on it and say, hey, You guys need your help down here.
00:07:57These Border Patrol guys should be all arrested.
00:07:59Yeah, it well, it seems fascinating to me.
00:08:01You said there are people coming in from all over, and I assume you've seen are you just running into the same people almost anywhere you go in the country when you look for these Antifa types?
00:08:11Like, how many people are actually involved in this movement, such as it is?
00:08:16I wouldn't say you run into the exact same people, but it's the exact same organizations, the exact same money, the funding, the mutual aid movements.
00:08:23Is I mean, we have videos there, it's you know, from Minnesota to Arizona in solidarity.
00:08:43You know, I covered a protest in LA on May Day.
00:08:46All of their funding, everything that they had supplied, came directly from the guys in Minnesota.
00:08:50So I would have, I would say, you know, I can't 100% confirm that their stuff is coming from Minnesota, but there are people from out of state, from Minnesota, from Portland, from Seattle, from these other Flashpoint areas that have been flying into this area.
00:09:03All right, I want to play SOT 20 because this is what I'm zeroing in on that this is unacceptable.0.93
00:09:08You film this, and it's all these Antifa types running around.
00:09:11They grab a couple of them, then they just let them go.
00:09:14I don't, for the life of me, understand what the heck's going on here.
00:10:18And this is why I said I need to make some calls because, like, this is, that's unacceptable that any law enforcement officer in this country gets treated that way.
00:10:30When you were down there, did you talk with law enforcement, Border Patrol?0.98
00:10:36Did they express frustration that they haven't been able to do what needs to be done to deal with these freaking thugs that are obstructing law enforcement?0.96
00:10:48I've talked to countless Border Patrol agents down there, both me and my camera, I know Brandon spoke to some as well, and every single one of them are frustrated.
00:10:56They feel like they don't have the support.
00:10:58They feel like they're being played with, right?
00:12:07We mentioned this when we had the ICE stuff last year with the shootings that they are basically intentionally trying to create some sort of violent crisis with their activists.
00:13:02Moment, it reminded me of the 2020, uh, or the you know, those videos, the meltdowns, or like the women at inauguration.
00:13:07Yeah, when we were filming, it's sad we clearly had to remove some swearing there because it just sounds like they're screaming directly after that.
00:13:14They started to all chant in unison, never forget, as if this was like 9 11, right?
00:14:12This is crimes against humanity coming into our country.1.00
00:14:16And these idiots are worried about a cottonwood tree.1.00
00:14:19Well, and that's, they're not actually worried about the cottonwood tree.1.00
00:14:21That's the thing is, yeah, they may care a little bit about nature.
00:14:25They may care about the cottonwood tree, but that is the tool that they are using for their activism to actually get this border wall shut down.
00:14:32It's just that with leftists, you see this time and time again through 16 through now, is they attach themselves to Any movement to any topic that they see to further their revolution or their goals.
00:14:43You know, 2016 BLM, then the pro Palestinian movement with the riots and everything going on.
00:14:48And they just kind of hop from one thing to another because this didn't work or this advanced our cause at least this much.
00:14:54Okay, what's the next thing to advance our cause?
00:14:56And that's exactly what they're using here.
00:14:58Well, I mean, and it goes to a deeper, more fundamental level.
00:15:01I mean, you couldn't get conservatives to do this at all.
00:16:15I'd rather get in five firefights than have to cover one of these events again.
00:16:18And why, you know, that sounds crazy is these people are so unpredictable.
00:16:22They're so volatile that any second can just alter your entire day or your entire life, right?
00:16:30They're just so unhinged to the extent that you don't know what they're going to do.
00:16:34At least in a situation where I'm in a firefight overseas or something, one of these more sketchy situations that it seems like on the surface, there's more control there.
00:16:42I have security, my security, they're professionals, right?
00:16:45In this situation, it's me, Brandon, and our camera operator.
00:16:48In the middle of nowhere, an hour and a half from the city.
00:16:51That's surrounded by law enforcement, though.
00:17:22That's pretty cowardly, but you can't really blame them when you've seen what's happened to all of our ICE agents around the country and the way that they're already talking about how to persecute these people.
00:17:30Yeah, that's really what's going on here the admin is probably trying to take a soft.
00:17:34Touch approach to not create a news cycle.0.91
00:17:38But the problem is, when you do this, you get this whole other news cycle where you get a Chaz Chop situation right at the border.
00:17:45We want to avoid viral videos of, I mean, certainly like someone getting shot, but Antifa members getting arrested, getting charged, getting in prison.
00:19:10If you're a single conservative man in his late 30s to early 50s in Southern California, listen up.1.00
00:19:15Selective Search has an exclusive network of women ready for the real thing.
00:19:20Here's the best part their candidate program is 100% free and confidential.
00:19:25Some of our closest friends, the show, have used Selective Search, and let me tell you, they're meeting great, great women, high quality women.
00:21:44Well, we're seeing the rule that you're supposed to believe survivors, but only when they tell you that they've been raped.
00:21:52If a putative survivor tells you she's not been raped, that's merely all the more proof that she's been raped so violently that she's in trauma.
00:22:03And cannot possibly process her experience accurately.
00:22:08And because the Jane Doe, and I hope she will be eventually unmasked, sent an amazing trove of evidence suggesting that she viewed this episode as voluntary, as consensual.
00:22:24I would like to submit the proposition that if you have been subjected to the second most violent felony that a female can ever experience in her life, which is rape.
00:22:35Second only to murder at a frat house, you do not solicit an invitation to go back to that rape den for more.
00:22:45And yet she was so happy when she finally got the invitation to go back and she called her alleged rapist her friends.
00:22:55And as you say, Andrew, it was only when the president of that frat house disinvited her for her own good because her reputation was being.
00:23:07And we can talk about how, what a discovery, a pleasant discovery to learn that the idea of slut is still allowed on campus.0.99
00:23:18But she proceeded to, you know, try and maintain as much contact with her alleged rapist as possible.0.90
00:23:27But if you believe Kathy Hochul, the governor of New York, if you believe Letitia James, if you believe Alexandra Ocasio Ortiz, most appallingly, if you believe the president of Cornell, Who we're supposed to assume has some shred of rationality and some, you know, reality based touch with his community, if you believe him, this was rape from the start.
00:23:52And what we need to do is beef up the campus rape bureaucracy even further.
00:23:58I feel like a way to more honestly frame this would be to stop calling it the Cornell 7 and start calling it the Cornell 1.
00:24:07Well, I think there's a lot of bad behavior, but that is.
00:24:10There's a clear difference between dissolute, immoral behavior and actively decided to get the legal system involved, turn this into a giant nationwide story to, I feel we all agree, avoid confronting the reality of one's own behavior.
00:24:44Her texts are out there where she is exonerating her alleged rapists, where she is saying, love you to one of them, where she is saying, we all know that none of this was illegal, what went on that night.
00:25:01And yet all of that evidence is being systematically removed.
00:25:05Once reported, it then disappears from the record.
00:25:08And you have this absolutely conventional, trite, You know, by the book formulaic narrative coming out, which was that this was a rape, despite the evidence that's already on the record.
00:25:27And we'll see, you know, whose side wins at this point.
00:25:32The fabulists who are committed to the idea that there is a patriarchy, because this is something that goes way beyond the betrayal of universities of their academic mission.
00:26:25Well, you mentioned this destruction of males.
00:26:29I think it's very apt because Kathy Hochul, the governor of New York, has assigned Letitia James as the special prosecutor to investigate the criminality of this case, alleged criminality.
00:26:41And we have a clip of this special prosecutor, Letitia James, the most biased political prosecutor anywhere in the country, probably.0.99
00:26:50I mean, Chris Mays gives her a run for her money here in Arizona.
00:27:31I really wish you would go away silently because I can't listen to you anymore.
00:27:35But so, this woman who is on record saying things like too male, too pale, too stale is now in charge of the investigation into seven fraternity brothers at Cornell.0.97
00:27:47So, that right there tells me she should recuse herself because she is incapable of being unbiased and letting justice go where the facts lead.0.54
00:28:08Well, this was something that was, I hope, not an adumbration of the just grotesque violation of the law and of due process and legal procedure down in Duke, where a clearly psychotic black stripper was invited to a party at, I think, was it the rugby players?0.77
00:28:46And she spun this story about completely brutal, violent assault on her.
00:28:55None of the evidence bore this out the DNA evidence, the semen, you know, rape test kits none of it was borne out.
00:29:04And yet the district attorney in, Durham, North Carolina, proceeded to go after these lacrosse players in spite of the clear exculpatory evidence.
00:29:20And this was brought into our typical meta narrative that America is both racist and patriarchal.
00:29:31And the real sin that these lacrosse players had committed was being too pale and too male.
00:29:38Finally, Justice was done, but after years of struggle, they had their lives ruined, Heather.
00:30:18He is citing that he was too intoxicated to give consent.
00:30:22Ingalls reportedly told Cornell investigators that he was too intoxicated from alcohol and ketamine to give consent.
00:30:28Quote During Cornell's investigation, Ingalls said he was too intoxicated to consent and suggested that Jane Doe actually assaulted him, according to school records.
00:30:51She chose to partake in multiple threesomes.1.00
00:30:54But yet, so she has all her body, her choice.
00:30:57But yet, it is made to be believed if you look at the protesters and all this stuff that it's the seven dudes from Cornell and the Fred House that took away her choice.
00:31:09This is the complete double standard that we're supposed to banish traditional sexual mores that are actually.
00:31:17The only thing that is going to prevent more of these drunken bacchanals, which is sexual modesty, even, God forbid, chastity, and male chivalry.
00:31:29And we're supposed to believe that that's all oppressive and patriarchal, and that men and women, males and females, are absolutely equal on the sexual battleground field, and that the female libido is just as active, just as voracious, omnivorous as the male libido, all of which is completely untrue.
00:32:04He may be drunk, she may be drunk, but in traditional terms, and this is what the Ingalls suit is pushing back against, the male is responsible both for himself and for the female.
00:32:15She's viewed as a helpless victim, somebody without any agency.0.65
00:32:20Now, I'd be willing to sign on to that idea.1.00
00:32:24You know, I'm not a big fan of strong women together.1.00
00:32:27I think there are very real psychological and physical.0.97
00:32:32And frankly, cognitive differences between males and females.
00:32:36So let's go back to that because it would actually restore a thousand millennia long understandings about the complexity, the challenge, the difficulty, the mystery of sexual interaction.
00:32:54But if we're not going to go back to that, then this double standard that exonerates females and makes males their protectors is a complete.
00:33:05Hypocritical violation of the feminist norm.
00:33:11So, you know, this is a narrative that is unfalsifiable.
00:33:15We're told, Blake and Andrew, that we're supposed to believe survivors, but only when they're claiming their victimhood.
00:33:24If they say they're not victims, then you just chalk that up, you know, as I say, to the rape culture and they're being brainwashed into thinking that they're not victims.
00:33:44Everybody acted poorly and it's, it's terrible to see.0.96
00:33:49But here's the facts Jane Doe admitted to her sorority big sister that she was acting, the rumors of her acting like a, she used the word slut, were unfortunately true.0.84
00:34:01She texted one of the men she eventually accused of gang rape that none of the sexual stuff was illegal.0.87
00:34:07And honestly, I really like being with you and Matt.
00:34:1110 days later, she was so excited to go back to the same frat house where she was allegedly assaulted for the Halloween party that, Hart, I'll bring my SIGs tomorrow.
00:34:25And then she only decides after she gets disinvited by the president of that frat that it so I guess it happened October 19th, the alleged incident.0.79
00:34:35And then on November 3rd, she changed her story to, I was raped.0.87
00:34:47And now I understand sometimes things happen, there's a processing that happens there.
00:34:53But it doesn't, and I think this is the point where you can really help us here, Heather.
00:34:59It feels like, based on the facts, she regretted this sexual orgy thing that she did.
00:35:07And then she, in order to save face, in order to help her reputation, she changed her story.0.90
00:35:12And she's going to ruin seven boys' lives.
00:35:16I think a big picture, though, that we want to drive home is if she successfully pulls this off, if this leads to criminal charges, if this leads to changes in law, if this brings back the old Biden, Obama era, Title IX policies.0.99
00:35:32You should lay out what are we bringing back if we allow this story to grow out of control with the narrative they're trying to sell us?
00:35:38Well, you know, if males had any sense, they would start acting sensibly themselves because they are going to be facing and probably still are.
00:35:49A complete miscarriage, a perversion of justice.
00:35:53We're going to go back to these awful tribunals where the male is not allowed to confront his accuser.
00:36:24Here's what they should do if they had any sense.
00:36:27Don't get involved with a girl who's drunk, and when you're drunk as well, walk her home after a date, kiss her goodnight, give her some flowers, and walk away.1.00
00:36:42If the Title IX rape administrators really believed that what was going on on campuses is rape and not, as you say, Blake, simply regretted sex.0.98
00:36:55Regretted hookup sex, drunken hookup sex, where the female afterwards thinks, gee, he doesn't appear as moved by this as I am.0.91
00:37:03You know, I'm going to play the rape card.0.78
00:37:06If the Title IX administrators believed that females were operating in this tsunami of sexual violence, they would tell the females do not get drunk, get in bed with a guy who you may or may not know very well, and take off your clothes.0.84
00:37:21Instead, dance with the guy and go home, go to your bed at night.
00:37:25That would end this epidemic overnight.0.98
00:37:29There would be not a single rape left because this is drunken, regretted hookup sex, as you say.1.00
00:37:36And the fact is, if it is going on and females are so stupid to walk into it anyway, they don't believe they shouldn't be on college campus.1.00
00:37:45Heather McDonald, the great Heather McDonald.1.00
00:38:09People were sharing their craft, connecting with local contractors, and talking about how they were building their businesses and growing their teams.
00:38:16It opened my eyes to how people in the trades are using TikTok to share their skills, make connections, and find new opportunities.
00:38:22I remember thinking, this is exactly what we need more of people sharing what they know and creating opportunities for others.
00:38:28And I never expected to find a community like this.
00:39:17Here to unpack this and to see if there is causation is Mike Benz, one of the guys that is the best at connecting the dots and best at following the money trails.
00:39:27Mike, welcome back to the show, my friend.
00:39:31You have called Brazil the Truman Show because it was basically astroturfed in so many ways.
00:39:38A lot of funding that you have tracked down.
00:39:40Tell us what you mean when it comes to Brazil and USAID.
00:39:44In 2018, when Bolsonaro swung into office in October of that year, there was a massive effort to basically stop his ability to govern and then to ultimately fund his ouster in the form of Lula and the Workers' Party that stretched for the first two years of the Trump administration and then the first two years of the Biden administration.
00:40:11And it is really a clean example of the foreign policy establishment not only being able to use a government agency to hijack U.S. foreign policy, but to do it behind the president's back because the way USAID is structured allows it to be even more flexible, deniable, and less oversight than even the Central Intelligence Agency.
00:40:34So if you want to get rid of a president in a foreign country, USAID is usually the best way, and I can walk through all the ways that was done in Brazil.
00:40:58Like, when they say we're funding civil society efforts in Brazil, how does that translate to a politically legible outcome we could recognize here?
00:41:17There's something that's really important, I think, for people to understand about the technical difference between the intelligence community and USAID, because it's something that is kind of a very nefarious underpinning of how USAID was able to get away with this.
00:41:32When the Central Intelligence Agency started getting in trouble in the 1960s and 70s and went through a number of reforms to its processes and practices, something called a presidential finding.
00:41:46Became required, which meant that every single covert action that the CIA does has to be approved in writing by the President of the United States.
00:41:56That way, there's no miscommunication about the President not authorizing a CIA covert action.
00:42:02USAID does not have that constraint on it.
00:42:06So, if USAID wants to do the equivalent of a CIA covert action but not tell the President about it, they can do that.
00:42:15And that's what What really distinguishes them both from state and CIA.
00:42:20So they were really able to go behind President Trump's back when it came to the situation in Brazil for the first two years of Bolsonaro's term and then went haywire during the Biden era.
00:42:33But on the civil society front, civil society is a kind of play, if you will.
00:42:41It preys on obviously the word civil, but really what's distinct from is governmental.
00:42:47So just in the same way that you have sort of criminal and civil.
00:42:55When you're dealing with NGOs, when you're dealing with non governmental organizations that sweep across all the different layers of a society, they call that civil society to distinguish it from the public sector and to distinguish it from for profit companies.
00:43:11In every USAID operation, there's something that they refer to as a kind of whole of, well, they call it the whole of society framework, which is about mobilizing government actors, for profit private sector actors, non profit civil society actors, and media.
00:43:28And media can either be for profit or civil society, depending on whether it's a for profit or non profit.
00:43:35And so you get all four of those categories of institutions together, and you have virtually every institution in society.
00:43:44And that is a standard part of the playbook.
00:43:46And I can walk through, if you'd like more detail, about how that whole of society apparatus was mobilized to capture civil society in Brazil.
00:43:59You're basically saying after Bolsonaro was elected, USAID mobilized through Brazilian civil society, pumping money and strategy.
00:44:09I mean, are American officials flying down to Brazil, orchestrating this, architecting this?
00:44:16Is it that direct, saying, hey, we're going to get the left wing back in power and here's how we're going to do it?
00:44:21Well, it depends on what year you're talking about, I suppose.
00:44:26For 2018, 2019, 2020, during the Trump years, this was done through USAID funding.
00:44:33The National Endowment for Democracy, the Wilson Center, the Atlantic Council, the Carnegie Endowment for International Peace, and a raft of the, what's something called the Consortium for Elections and Political Process Strengthening, CEPS, which are three of those that I just named are giant umbrella NGOs that themselves fund 20 to 30 sub NGOs underneath them.
00:44:59For example, in Brazil, the CEPS network, I think, stretched to about 50 disinformation.
00:45:06Related NGOs themselves, the TSE court, the Alexandra de Moraes court.
00:45:12I believe four of the nine flaggers on the court that had an inside WhatsApp line directly to Moraes were funded by USAID.
00:45:24The concept to form a task force on disinformation out of the TSE, the Alexandra de Moraes court, was basically.
00:45:35Invented by USAID grantees who ended up making up, I think, like something between 40 and 50 percent of the initial task force members.
00:45:47They became USAID, which was funding all the different NGOs that trained and staffed and flagged all of the disinformation online.
00:45:59And then I literally testified in front of the Brazilian Senate Foreign Relations Committee and showed pictures from the USAID grantee websites of them training.
00:46:12They actually sent some of their delegates, including the same people they used to censor the 2020 election in the United States, including the Stanford Internet Observatory, the Atlanta Council Digital Forensics Research Lab, who were all sent down there and made basically members of the court task force.
00:46:33You had insane situations where USAID was getting feedback from its grantees about how it was training the judges, and USAID.
00:46:45I'm trying to think about what I'm at liberty to say.
00:46:50There are documents that you can FOIA that would show how USAID would instruct its grantees to actually remove the USAID logo and change its guidance to the TSE court to remove references to Bolsonaro in its targeting of censorship because they were afraid that these USAID grantee directives would leak and it would show how politicized and how top down it was from the U.S. government.
00:47:18I think it's safe to say, Mike, you are the best.
00:47:22There is around at connecting dots that nobody else is connecting.
00:47:26It's crazy what you found, the way you've dissected the British censorship apparatus, especially.
00:47:31I was so impressed by when you were laying out, oh, this is how the UK government actually funds these orgs, and then they lobby to censor people in the US, and you get that transatlantic traffic, so to speak, where that's how they control speech.
00:47:45They go to Britain when they can't do it in America, they go to America when they can't do it in America.
00:47:48Well, and fundamentally, I feel different about the transatlantic thing than I do about the Western Hemisphere thing, because this is our hemisphere.
00:47:57And I'm a non interventionist guy, but this is why what I think Marco is doing throughout Latin America is really, really important.
00:48:05But what you're saying is that there was a concerted effort, right at the break, you said this, to remove USAID markers, to remove mentions of Bolsonaro, because they knew what they were doing was blatantly, brazenly political and biased.
00:48:50It reminds me of a sort of acme cartoon where, I don't know, someone gives Wile E. Coyote a present and there's a bomb inside or that sort of thing.
00:49:02Parting gift from USAID when he was the policy and budget director in the 1980s was a USAID hand grenade.
00:49:09If you recall, he held that up on Piers Morgan.
00:49:12It was a hand grenade from USAID with his name engraved.
00:49:15And I think that's just a very apt way to understand the agency's operations in disguise.
00:49:21But in Brazil, what you had was, now again, Brazil is the second largest, sort of, you know, Andrew, what you were saying about the importance of the Western Hemisphere and various.
00:49:52It's the, I think, world's largest producer of beef and other food products.
00:49:58And what it does in terms of its trade has a significant impact both on the U.S. and on U.S. businesses.
00:50:08And Financial firms, in terms of their investments, because there is just a lot of money to swing around that hangs in the balance.
00:50:18And, you know, famously, Lula has transitioned his economy in significant part to the Chinese rather than to the Americans.
00:50:26But I think, given the overlap between sort of the Chinese diplomatic and financial sphere and many of the folks around the Biden foreign policy and national security world, there's a weird natural synergy there in terms of what happened.
00:50:41But in terms of, I mean, obviously the U.S. has been involved in Brazil since at least the 1960s when there was the sort of military coup that the U.S. played a fairly significant role in.
00:50:55But what we've seen over the past decade is a kind of reversal of the Cold War, where instead of having, you know, sort of right wing regime changes of left wing administrations for oil, You have a kind of reverse where you have left wing regime changes of right wing governments for like clean energy.
00:51:33We've been able to uncork a right wing revolution, as it were, throughout Latin America.
00:51:38Is there anything additional that the Trump administration should be doing to make sure this doesn't come back if we get another Democrat government or just to?
00:51:46Remove remaining pieces of this apparatus where they might exist in the DC blob or around the world?
00:51:53And then finally, after answering that, if you have a second, do we have to watch out for anything in Brazil?
00:51:58It looks like odds are very good the runoff will go Bolsonaro's way, but are there tricks that the Lula regime might use to do something a little sinister and shady?
00:52:10First, I think on your first question, I think naming and shaming and putting things on a jumbotron actually has a very powerful chilling effect, even without the permanence of legislation.
00:52:21Even without an executive order or, I don't know, some compelling lawsuit outcome that legally bars that from happening again.
00:52:29When people see their predecessors getting dunked on and posterized, they don't want to be that next person when they go into government and be kind of the next person in line as soon as another four years goes by to be dunked on.
00:52:48And I do think that having transparency around the USAID files, being able to publish them publicly is of.
00:53:45And a huge part of that, which kind of gets to the second part of Blake's question, is it connects to everything else.
00:53:53USAID did not act as an island, it coordinated with the State Department, it coordinated with the National Security Council, it coordinated with the Department of Work, it coordinated with the European Commission.
00:54:03It coordinated with NATO and the Brits and the German Ministry of Foreign Affairs and the like.
00:54:14And so, removing that doesn't just get rid of the agency itself.
00:54:18It gets rid of a lot of touch points into a lot of rogue, completely independent actors on U.S. national security and foreign policy.
00:54:27But what I would say is the one thing that does concern me is if you take away that.
00:54:35Such a powerful soft power element, the compulsion to replace that with hard power through having the military do what used to be done, having the military do ham fistedly what used to be done relatively slickly by USAID has its own set of drawbacks.
00:54:56Do you think, and that makes perfect sense, we've got 20 seconds here, are you concerned about the runoff on October 25th in Brazil?
00:55:06The TSE court has a tremendous amount of power.
00:55:09You know, they could, in theory, do what was done in Romania and what was threatened to be done in Germany, where, you know, they could technically find some reason to try to annul or to try to mass ban everything.
00:55:22But I think at this point, the diplomatic pressure would be extremely intense and it may be better to go gracefully.
00:55:28Mike Benz, Executive Director, Foundation for Freedom Online.
00:55:52There's nothing worse than turning a great trade into a break even because you didn't act in time.
00:55:58Taking chips off the table isn't quitting, it's protecting what you've earned.
00:56:02Visit Noble Gold Investments.comslash Kirk and find out whether helping to protect your profits with gold makes sense for you.
00:56:09And to celebrate America's 250th, open a new qualified account and Noble Gold will send you a free 10 ounce silver bar.
00:56:16Noble Gold Investments dot com slash Kirk.
00:56:19The information is free, but the knowledge is priceless.
00:56:25We know what we know, obviously, about whatever the Russians have provided, which is it seems that there was a worker at the lab that was infected, and there's concern that that, you know, could have spread at least internally.0.71
00:56:37So you've seen them do quarantines and deaths of that nature.
00:56:41There's very limited travel between the U.S. and Russia, obviously, but like anything else, something like that gets out and could quickly spread.
00:56:57So, a lot of you have probably heard about this plague outbreak.
00:57:01Well, we got to figure out how bad it is, how concerned we should be out of Russia.
00:57:06But if you were like me, are we going to have another plague?
00:57:09You're literally having PTSD, you're getting like a twitch, mysterious disease, covet all over style country, lab outbreak by yeah, tyrannical dictatorship.
00:58:42What this institute is, is a facility that is involved in an extensive Russian surveillance network.
00:58:51For Yersinia pestis, bubonic or plague in general, and its primary focus is on Mongolia.
00:58:59It has nothing to do with the Ukrainian border, and it does turn out that there was just a series of isolations of plague in Mongolia through August.
00:59:14So, those isolates where there's been an outbreak in marmots, among other things, and a couple of cases of bubonic plague where people have been infected by.
00:59:26So they went, they did isolation and monitoring, they came back with strains, those were processed.
00:59:35This laboratory where Daria Shipilova worked as a laboratory technician was the one, and a laboratory technician specifically working on plague, was the one that would then process the samples from the primary isolates in Mongolia.
00:59:55And I'll tell you just the punchline right now.
00:59:59All of my analysis, deep dive, applied artificial intelligence algorithms, et cetera, et cetera, all says that this is just some single person event.
01:00:14There were 200 primary contacts, so first point of contact, because she was in hospitals for four days.
01:00:21And all of those have been isolated, and they're now at the end of the period of typical incubation for pneumonic plague.
01:00:30And there is no new cases that have been announced.
01:00:33There has been some quarantine activity in five hospitals in the region, presumably because the people she would have been in contact with would have been hospital workers.
01:00:46Everything I'm seeing is appropriate infectious disease control protocol applied in an area that has significant expertise and some history with plague because of the endemic plague that's present.
01:01:06And what's odd here is a few other things having to do with the communications and the statements made that they're sure that the Institute has investigated itself and it's sure that there was no breach of protocol and that she did not get infected by anything she was working with in the Institute.
01:01:28But they're not revealing any PCR results, they're not revealing any sequence results.
01:01:34So, the things that would allow the outside world to cross check this story are not available.
01:01:41And that's typical in these kinds of situations there is some degree of cover up by the folks that are closest to the event because they don't want to take ownership.
01:01:52You know, this is an authoritarian environment.0.88
01:01:54And if you're in charge of that institute and this happened under your watch and it's a black guy to the republic, there's probably going to be career consequences.0.99
01:02:06The default action always in this kind of situation is to deny, deny, deny.1.00
01:02:11And that happens here in the United States too.
01:02:14How long have we been talking about, let's say, Ralph Barak's lab?
01:02:18So I think we can't cast stones in this one.
01:02:22So you do mention they're not having ideal communications.
01:02:26Even if you're pretty confident this is not a reason for us to panic yet, is there any justification for this to be something we should worry about?
01:02:34This is so pneumonic plague, it is significantly more fatal than bubonic plague.
01:02:41It can spread person to person through respiratory droplets, even if.
01:02:47Is this something we should worry that a state actor, Russia, China, Iran, any random country, might be working on to make it as a bioweapon something that we should look out for?
01:02:59So there is a long history that extends to World War II and really before that.
01:03:04But it was attempted to be weaponized and it was deployed as a plague by the Japanese forces.0.64
01:03:12I think it was in China that they did it.0.91
01:03:14So every major nation that was involved in.0.94
01:03:19Bio warfare development historically has had a plague program.
01:03:25Most of them have also developed plague vaccine candidates, and that includes the US and the UK.
01:04:06The only reason you would be worried is if you happened to be in that particular 600 person town and you were somebody that knew this unfortunate young woman and she had coughed directly on you.
01:04:19That would be about where you would have to have some concern.
01:04:23So, Dr. Malone, it looks like, you know, there was a bunch of technicians or scientists that were quarantined in a lab.
01:04:31There's also a rumor of a broken tube, a test tube of some sort in this site, but I'm getting conflicting reports.
01:05:04The laboratory has said that whatever she died of, it had nothing to do with anything she was working with, et cetera, et cetera.
01:05:13One, there's two, as far as I'm concerned, viable hypotheses going here.
01:05:18One is that she was processing some new isolate that was particularly pathogenic and she didn't have good laboratory hygiene for a BSL 3 laboratory.
01:05:32The other is that she had been traveling and she might have traveled into regions where plague is endemic, but that wouldn't explain pneumonic plague.
01:05:41So I think we're pretty tight down on something happened in the laboratory.
01:05:49And by the way, most of those quarantines were not from the laboratory, they were from the hospitals because she was out into the community for four days without a diagnosis until she died.
01:06:01So that means that she was in contact with a lot of hospital people, not so much her laboratory colleagues.
01:06:07Dr. Malone, when you say that if she was out in, let's say she made contact with some marmot, right, you're saying that couldn't have been the cause of this?
01:06:18Because that would have typically what that would have led to is getting infected by fleas.
01:06:27And that results in bubonic plague, not pneumonic plague.
01:06:31So, what we do know in terms of her proximity to plague is that there was this September.
01:06:40Campaign to identify new isolates from Mongolia in the region where it's now emerged because of marmots crossing over a mountain range.
01:06:50And those samples would have gone to another laboratory and then been isolated, processed, and passed off.
01:07:00And she is reasonably likely to be the one that would receive those samples.
01:07:06So it could be that she experienced contact in some way.
01:07:11With a primary sample out of Mongolia that might have been more pathogenic.
01:07:16That is a pure speculation hypothesis, but it fits all the investigations.
01:07:22And we have had to dive deeply into Russian literature, thank heavens for Russian translation programs, in order to get to this.
01:07:31We've been through many, you know, the scientific literature there, the publications from this institute, et cetera, to put together this story.
01:07:39So, just to kind of make sure I'm summarizing and hearing you right, this is in a region with a lot of plague, right?
01:07:51So this laboratory exists to essentially research the new isolates, as you call them, new variants of plague that may be existing within the animal population.
01:08:19The United States, we get less than seven cases a year, mostly bubonic plague, and less than 8% is pneumonic plague, and no documented person to person spread since 1924.
01:08:31So there's a lot of this, this does not feel like coronavirus, but there is a lot of, there is a lot of secrecy.
01:08:39And it, you know, you hear, you think of Chernobyl, you think of the way that Russia dealt with that whole thing.
01:08:46I would, I would rather the secrecy, I think the, you know, the usual, the easiest explanation is incompetence.
01:09:27Anytime, I mean, there's a fundamental lesson here.
01:09:30Anytime you have central control and planning, and you still have centralized control and planning in modern Russia, even though it's not former Soviet Russia, anytime you have that, you have a huge gap between what is the ground truth and what is the official narrative because it's got to filter up through multiple places, and everybody that's touching that information has a stake in it.
01:09:57And so by the time it gets up to officialdom in Moscow and the official public health agency, I think it's Rasporto Nabazar or something like that.
01:10:12It's been highly filtered and it really doesn't reflect what's actually known at the ground level, which is what that initial report was from a local reporting ground truth, such as, for instance, that apparently the physicians in the area are all abuzz about plague.
01:10:31So, the official party line is this was not plague.
01:10:38It had nothing to do with anything that she was working with.
01:10:42And I think that we're going to see that become a modified limited hangout and we're going to see it updated gradually over the next few weeks.
01:10:49Well, so you talk about the beginning of this interview how fear sells, right?
01:10:54I think there's no greater sinner in this regard than CNN.
01:11:26Russia so far is saying this is contained.
01:11:28How can the United States actually verify that?
01:11:33So, the U.S. would be using intelligence assets available to them and obviously trying to work with the Russian government because you're right, things don't make sense.
01:11:39But it's the Russians' constant way of managing these things that causes more problems than anything else.
01:11:44Well, the Kremlin's saying don't give in to speculation.0.89
01:11:46The vial theory, for example, if this is a worker trained to handle plague, the bacteria the doctor just mentioned, and it broke, they would have known to immediately been decontamination, go into isolation, and would have prophylactically been given these antibiotics and wouldn't have stumbled in the hospital four days later.
01:12:00At least that's sort of what's coming out now or something along those timelines.
01:12:03So, the facts just don't really add up right now.
01:12:05And that's the problem there's more answers or there's more.
01:12:24So what you basically had there was an acknowledgement that CNN is not actually doing journalism because they could have done the same work that we did.
01:12:36And it's just myself and my wife working here out of Madison, Virginia.
01:12:40Publishing stuff and running our algorithm.
01:12:48They should up their game, but there's no reason to because fear cells and these kinds of insinuations seem to be their stock in trade, as well as for many of the other mainstream media.
01:13:01I'm calling these people media entrepreneurs.
01:13:04They're basically selling clicks, likes, and follows in whatever way they can.
01:13:10And I think we should probably, being a Christian broadcast, We should try to extend empathy to these poor souls.
01:13:26I'm a little pressed too, but we do need to be Christian about this as much as possible.
01:13:33Well, so I think that was important, though, to play because that does sort of outline how this has been covered and why a lot of us are like, uh oh, is this COVID 2.0?
01:13:42Is this a Chernobyl like incident in Russia?
01:13:56Now, it seems like this worker, the test tube, even just from that clip, this test tube theory did something, did a vial break in the lab.
01:14:05That seems to indicate it probably didn't, right?
01:14:08Because to his point, if it would have broken in the lab, she would have been treated prophylactically in advance with these antibodies, and she wasn't.
01:14:17She stumbled into a hospital four days later.
01:14:46The default response of an institute, by the way, that in this case investigated itself, is going to be to say, no, no, no, we didn't do anything wrong.
01:15:03It doesn't make sense that she would breathe an aerosol because she should have been anything that she did should have been operated within a biosafety cabinet.
01:15:13So, Dr. Malone, we have still doesn't make sense.
01:15:15Yeah, we have 90 seconds here, so it's going to be quick.
01:15:18But, you know, pneumonia can kill within 24 hours.
01:16:16But I think the gaps are most easily explained as the usual kind of incompetence in messaging and failure of transparency, which, once again, I don't think we're in any position to cast stones on that front.