The Fiamengo File - October 13, 2016


A Treason of the Intellectuals - TFF Episode 47

The Unisex University - TFF Episode 46 Why Academics Bow to the Mob - TFF Episode 48

Episode Stats


Length

14 minutes

Words per minute

133.36

Word count

1,908

Sentence count

64

Harmful content

Misogyny

1

sentences flagged

Hate speech

7

sentences flagged


Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
00:00:00 It's been a bad year for universities, with speakers shouted down, students intimidated,
00:00:08 and individuals hounded into submission for trivial or non-existent transgressions.
00:00:15 So how can so many smart people stand by while academia is destroyed by fanatical bullies?
00:00:23 That's my subject on today's Fiamengo File.
00:00:31 I'm Janice Fiamengo of the University of Ottawa. In 1927, the French intellectual Julien Benda
00:00:38 published Treason of the Intellectuals. It was an attack on those intellectuals who had,
00:00:45 in his opinion, betrayed the life of the mind by immersing themselves in contemporary politics.
00:00:52 He called his moment in history, quote, the age of the intellectual organization of political
00:01:00 hatreds, end quote.
00:01:03 Of course, Benda couldn't have known how prescient his words would be.
00:01:07 The roiling ethnic grievances and passions that Benda deplored eventually resulted in
00:01:14 the horrors of the Second World War. 0.96
00:01:16 And now we are seeing something similar.
00:01:19 a corruption of academia by sanctioned hatreds. We've all heard some of the outrageous stories
00:01:26 of cowardice and betrayal of principle. Today I will briefly review two of them, one very well
00:01:32 known, the other less so, and make a plea for men and women of conscience to stand against
00:01:39 this corruption. Now most of you will remember the Tim Hunt scandal from just over a year ago,
00:01:46 in late June of 2015. The Nobel Prize-winning scientist whose investigations into cell
00:01:53 division had played a key role in cancer research. That noble man lost his honorary
00:02:00 position at University College London and was forced to resign from the British Royal Society
00:02:05 following a Twitter campaign orchestrated by a third-rate journalism instructor with a very
00:02:10 dubious cv connie st louis of city university london tweeted out only half of what sir tim
00:02:19 had actually said during a luncheon toast at a science journalism conference implying that he
00:02:25 was a misogynist well we all could have predicted the self-glorifying outrage of feminist scientists
00:02:33 who took to social media to pat themselves on the back for being such plucky women in a harsh male 1.00
00:02:40 dominated world. But one person in the drama exceeded even my jaundiced expectations of
00:02:49 academic opportunism. That was Tim Hunt's self-declared friend, fellow scientist,
00:02:57 Nobel Prize co-recipient, and President of the Royal Society, Sir Paul Nurse, who refused to
00:03:05 defend Hunt in the immediate aftermath of the scandal except to say that he was a
00:03:12 lovely man and who asserted that Hunt's chauvinism had to be condemned because his statements had
00:03:22 harmed science." Well, I would have thought the harm to science was in supporting a culture 0.96
00:03:30 willing to sacrifice brilliant male researchers on the altar of feminist rectitude i would have
00:03:37 said that the harm to science was in the obvious double standard that sir tim was hounded out of
00:03:44 his position for what turned out to be the most mild-mannered of comments while connie st louis
00:03:51 never even had to explain why her online cv was full of misrepresentations and why she tried to
00:03:59 destroy a man who had done more for science and for the social good than she would do in ten
00:04:06 lifetimes. This is cultural suicide in the guise of protecting women. And yet the guardians of 0.93
00:04:15 science don't even seem to care. The issue Sir Paul wanted to talk about in interview after the
00:04:24 scandal was not what the appropriate response should be to his so-called friend's words.
00:04:30 What he wanted to talk about was his, Sir Paul's, devotion to the great god of diversity.
00:04:38 Perhaps because he was terrified of being struck down in the same way Sir Tim had been and
00:04:43 quite willing to sell him out as an act of propitiation, Sir Paul shrugged off the attack
00:04:49 on his friend and focused on puffing the royal society for its so-called progressive views he
00:04:57 mentioned that although the society quote can come across as old-fashioned end quote because members
00:05:04 stay on for life it's really very feminist he tells us quote half of the council are now women
00:05:11 and we have a lot of initiatives to improve diversity we have a diversity committee 0.58
00:05:19 and allow mothers or fathers to work half time end quote well i'm glad to know that aren't you
00:05:28 what a progressive idea to promote science encouraging scientists to work half time don't
00:05:36 go at it too hard. Don't devote all your time and energy to your work as men like Sir Tim used to do.
00:05:43 That's behind the times. Go on, change some nappies, and while you're at it be sure to serve
00:05:50 on the Diversity Committee. We can see that Sir Paul's evident ability in science has been
00:05:57 superseded by his adeptness at parroting the Women in Science party line. 0.56
00:06:04 Well, but at least Sir Paul's betrayal could be explained as a bid for self-preservation.
00:06:12 And I also wonder if what sometimes happens with these scientific white knights is that having spent
00:06:18 most of their nerdy lives peering into a microscope, the impulse to chivalry in an
00:06:24 instant like this, even when the damsel in distress is not particularly damsel-like,
00:06:29 is nearly irresistible. But it's more difficult to understand another example of suicidal political
00:06:37 correctness on my side of the Atlantic, this time at San Diego State University this past April 2016,
00:06:47 when in one of the most remarkable and underreported episodes of campus intimidation,
00:06:54 the president of the university, Elliot Hirschman, issued a groveling apology to pro-Islamic radicals
00:07:03 who claimed he hadn't done enough to, quote, protect Muslim students on campus.
00:07:09 The students were so concerned about the supposed vulnerability of Muslim students that they confined
00:07:17 the Jewish university president, to a police car for somewhere between one and two hours before
00:07:25 essentially forcing him to declare his repentance. What was their beef? Well, these students involved 0.65
00:07:34 with various campus Muslim organizations that promote the claims of Palestinian victimhood had
00:07:39 been outraged by a poster campaign at San Diego State linking the names of certain radical students
00:07:47 with Palestinian terrorism, saying that they had allied themselves with terrorists to spread
00:07:52 hatred of Jewish students. I can see why they were upset, and the remedy was pretty straightforward.
00:08:01 Counter the claims, put up their own posters, and look into suing the poster's creator for
00:08:08 defamation. These students, however, wanted something splashier than that. They wanted
00:08:15 a statement by the president denouncing the posters as a grave threat to Muslim innocence
00:08:21 and calling for the posters' removal. When President Hirschman was slow to respond and
00:08:27 then declined to carry out their demands, as surely it was well within his right to do so,
00:08:33 perhaps he has more pressing matters to deal with like running the university,
00:08:37 well, the students then escalated the situation. An open letter was written, professors became
00:08:43 involved and the president was widely criticized for failing to express appropriate outrage over
00:08:50 Muslim victimhood. Then the climax of the episode came on April 27th when a crowd of the concerned
00:08:58 students surrounded a police car carrying Hirschman to his car after a university meeting.
00:09:05 The fact that he had police escort at this point suggests that he was already feeling the heat
00:09:10 of their well-orchestrated anger. But the presence of the police didn't even deter
00:09:17 these students. They refused to allow the police car to proceed, some by spreading out Islamic 0.98
00:09:24 prayer mats and calling on their God of mercy. After about an hour, some reports say closer to
00:09:30 two hours, Hirschman was finally able to emerge from the car, offering to meet with some of the
00:09:37 students at a later date which was more than i think i would have done but they told him that
00:09:42 he wouldn't be allowed to leave unless he issued an apology on the spot this he did saying quote
00:09:51 if we have done things inadvertently that have upset or hurt people we are sorry for that end
00:09:58 quote there must actually be more to this scantily covered story than i was able to discover
00:10:05 Certainly, it is flabbergasting that the president of a university so clearly mistreated and insulted would emerge from a car where he had been essentially held captive, stand surrounded by students who wouldn't allow him to pass, and augment his humiliation with an apology to his captors.
00:10:30 Why did he not order them off his campus? More to the point perhaps, why did the police themselves
00:10:36 not arrest the protesters for their evident crimes of obstruction of a police vehicle,
00:10:43 intimidation of a university official, unlawful confinement? Did the police actually
00:10:49 pressure or advise the president to placate the angry mob? Or did the president himself
00:10:55 instruct the police to do nothing on the grounds that it would look too bad to arrest Muslim
00:11:00 students and their allies. Whatever went on to produce that apology, it was an unsettling image
00:11:08 of total submission to a mob. But are we particularly surprised by any of this? No.
00:11:18 So why do so many university presidents seem to be reading from the same playbook?
00:11:24 Why are so many academics quick to placate campus bullies and liars, thus guaranteeing that
00:11:30 even more bullies will arise and that their bullying tactics will become even more aggressive?
00:11:38 Don't any of them have any principles or a backbone? The real question, alas, is why we
00:11:45 would expect anything else. If one looks to history, one learns that totalitarian movements
00:11:51 have often found not only obedient but also enthusiastic adherence amongst members of the
00:11:58 intellectual class it turns out that intellectuals are prone to willing ideological servitude as are
00:12:05 of course many other members of society but intellectuals are particularly vulnerable once
00:12:11 they betray their mandate of disinterested inquiry when i got my first tenure stream job at the
00:12:18 university of saskatchewan i thought i was entering a paradise of free inquiry in which
00:12:24 faculty members would vigorously debate ideas instead i entered a timorous culture in which
00:12:31 individual faculty members lived in terror of being accused of racism or sexism allowing
00:12:37 themselves to be bullied into supporting programs and policies they didn't even believe in by a few
00:12:44 aggressive colleagues playing their social justice cards. Living in that department, I realized for
00:12:50 the first time in my life how communist totalitarian movements swept through those societies that found
00:12:57 themselves behind the Iron Curtain after the Second World War. How it happened that people
00:13:02 betrayed their neighbors, even members of their own families, in order to ingratiate themselves
00:13:08 with the regime. I understood the incredible power of group thinking, the deep desire of human
00:13:14 beings to be part of what C.S. Lewis called the inner ring, and the willingness of many to do
00:13:20 just about anything to consolidate their positions there, even if it meant betraying their friends,
00:13:27 as Sir Paul Nurse did to Sir Timothy Hunt, or selling out the students they had pledged to
00:13:33 teach and lead as Eliot Hirschman did when he apologized to radicals who held him hostage in a
00:13:40 car on campus. These are deeply dispiriting times for those who care about academic integrity and
00:13:48 fairness, and I want to call on all people of good conscience to take back our campuses.
00:13:56 In the next video, I'll look at the situation of the German universities in the 1930s as they
00:14:01 They readily fell in line with Nazi ideology.
00:14:05 And I'll consider what this tells us about the situation now unfolding at our universities.
00:14:12 If you're as dismayed by all of this as I am, please don't stay silent.