The Fiamengo File - October 20, 2016


Why Academics Bow to the Mob - TFF Episode 48

A Treason of the Intellectuals - TFF Episode 47 Academic Totalitarianism - TFF Episode 49

Episode Stats


Length

14 minutes

Words per minute

131.55

Word count

1,875

Sentence count

39

Harmful content

Misogyny

4

sentences flagged

Toxicity

5

sentences flagged

Hate speech

3

sentences flagged


Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
00:00:00 Is anyone in academia willing to rebuke an SJW mob? These people have tenure and
00:00:08 institutional authority, but most of them seem scared speechless. Let's explore
00:00:14 the reasons why on today's Fiamengo File.
00:00:21 I'm Janice Fiamengo of the University of Ottawa. In last week's video I outlined
00:00:27 the history of heidelberg university in the 1930s to showcase how remarkably easily seemingly
00:00:34 intelligent people can accept barbarism and can even come to be its ardent supporters
00:00:41 we're seeing something similar today as university presidents and others in positions of academic
00:00:46 authority fall all over themselves to show their support for anti-intellectual thugs on campus
00:00:54 Last May 2016, for example, we saw the remarkable spectacle of a university president
00:01:01 eager to show his solidarity with the Black Lives Matter protesters who prevented
00:01:08 Libertarian pundit Milo Yiannopoulos from giving a speech at DePaul University in Chicago.
00:01:15 Marching to the front of the room just moments after Yiannopoulos began his talk,
00:01:20 black lives matter activists commandeered the stage and one of their number rested the microphone
00:01:27 from the moderator's hand screamed obscenities at milo and waved her fist in his face yet the
00:01:35 president of depaul the reverend dennis holtschneider was far more interested in distancing
00:01:43 himself from Milo than in offering a clear condemnation of Black Lives Matter tactics.
00:01:52 Writing a letter from Normandy, France, President Holtschneider expressed his disdain
00:01:59 for Milo's positions and tactics at great length, not only objecting to particular arguments,
00:02:05 but especially going out of his way to belittle and blame the journalists for his encounter
00:02:12 with the students and the smug snootiness of his remarks about milo are worth emphasizing
00:02:20 quote generally i do not respond to speakers of mr yiannopoulos's ilk as i believe they are more
00:02:28 entertainers and self-serving provocateurs than the public intellectuals they purport
00:02:36 to be," Holt Schneider sniffed derisively, and went on to address Yiannopoulos as if it were
00:02:43 he, not the Black Lives Matter folks, who made a habit of screaming obscenities, threatening,
00:02:50 and dancing on other people's platforms. Quote, their schtick, he says, referring to people like 0.93
00:02:58 Yiannopoulos is to shock and incite a strong emotional response they can then use to discredit
00:03:07 the moral high ground claimed by their opponents. This is unworthy of university discourse but not
00:03:14 unfamiliar across American higher education. There will always be speakers who exploit
00:03:20 the differences within our human community to their own benefit, blissfully unconcerned
00:03:27 with the damage they leave behind." Far from expressing any anger on Yiannopoulos' behalf,
00:03:36 Mr. Holtschneider makes it clear that he's angry at Yiannopoulos, going so far as to suggest that
00:03:43 there is something morally despicable about Yiannopoulos' strategy to, quote,
00:03:48 discredit the moral high ground claimed by BLM by showing that they have no moral high ground,
00:03:56 and he explicitly lays the blame for the damage of the evening at Yiannopoulos' door as if it were
00:04:03 he, not radical Black activists who made it impossible for intellectual debate to take
00:04:09 place, and as if it were he, not the grievance-fuelled protesters who exploit differences
00:04:16 within the community for their own benefit. When it came time to refer to the Black Lives Matter
00:04:23 protesters, Holtschneider just couldn't seem to summon nearly the same level of outrage or even
00:04:31 dismay. All he could manage was the statement that, quote, those who interrupted the speech
00:04:37 were wrong to do so. Well, even a kindergartner could have gone that far. And he had a vague
00:04:44 assertion that he was, quote, ashamed for DePaul University when I saw a student rip the microphone
00:04:51 from the hands of the conference moderator and wave it in the face of our speaker," end quote.
00:04:58 Wait a minute. Ashamed for DePaul? It's an extraordinarily broad and indeterminate reference.
00:05:06 Purposely so, I suspect. Clearly, the president has trouble naming the instigators. I suspect he
00:05:14 doesn't want to mention that it was black students who sat on a stage with nothing of 0.78
00:05:19 intellectual substance to say and confident that nothing would be done to them they were pretty 0.96
00:05:27 certain their president was a wimp and they were right holt schneider's statement that he was quote 0.56
00:05:34 ashamed for depaul university gives him plenty of wiggle room leaving open the possibility that the 0.90
00:05:40 real target of his shame was the racist policies of the university or the racist inequalities of
00:05:48 society in general those convenient targets for liberal castigation when women or minorities
00:05:55 behave badly how very politically correct of president holtschneider so programmed is he by
00:06:02 sjw propaganda that he must speak as if violent radicals who would terrorize the university
00:06:08 community are the real victims of a gay writer whose oscar wilde and provocations and witty
00:06:16 arguments are somehow worse than their overt anti-intellectualism and threats of physical 0.91
00:06:23 harm. So the question is, how did Mr. Holtschneider get to be president of DePaul and why aren't his
00:06:31 colleagues standing up in droves to demand that he take a clear stand in favor of free speech
00:06:37 and against SJW intimidation and criminality? Why are there so many like Holtschneider on our
00:06:45 campuses as i've indicated already there are a variety of reasons often acting in concert
00:06:52 including the following one holt schneider and his ilk may well be true believers devotees of
00:07:00 radical social justice ideology there are a lot of them out there physics teachers for example
00:07:07 who've gone rogue and decided they'd rather have their students think about why there aren't more 0.83
00:07:12 black women doing physics than understand the periodic table in the closing of the american
00:07:18 mind alan bloom described how in the late 1960s professors lost faith in the significance of their
00:07:26 disciplines and sought meaning for their lives as professors in contemporary social causes such as
00:07:33 combating racism and colonialism it was a lot sexier a lot more emotionally stirring and heroic
00:07:41 to say that you were attacking the power structures that kept women and people of color in servitude
00:07:48 than to say you were advancing understanding of changing 19th century courtship patterns or
00:07:54 advancing understanding of the use of fugal structures in early renaissance church music or
00:08:00 looking at the significance of color symbolism in milton's paradise lost in a society in which
00:08:07 traditional religious commitment has been largely abandoned, intersectional feminism offers many of
00:08:14 the comforts of a cherished faith, especially the purity of redemption and the zeal of true belonging,
00:08:23 with none of the serious learning and humility demanded by a genuine theology of repentance.
00:08:30 the second reason in cases where holt schneider and his ilk are not true believers and it's
00:08:36 impossible to know what percentage are they are canny and cynical careerists who know that there
00:08:43 is nothing to be lost by adhering to the dominant orthodoxy of the day and a great deal in the way of
00:08:50 career advancement and praise to be won just as in times past people like holt schneider would
00:08:57 have been faithful attenders every Sunday at the Anglican Church, today they are faithful attenders
00:09:02 at the Church of Intersectional Feminist Piety, eager to kneel at the communion rail or even,
00:09:09 as in the case of university presidents, to be invited to administer the academic sacraments 0.95
00:09:15 wearing a gorgeous liturgical chasuble. According to a 2012 survey published in Inside Higher
00:09:23 education and conducted by the ucla higher education research institute a full 63 percent
00:09:30 of professors at institutes of higher education identify as liberal or far left with the vast 0.81
00:09:38 majority of the rest identifying as middle of the road very few conservatives women were further to
00:09:45 the left and their male peers clocking in at 67.5% liberal or far left, which means,
00:09:52 among other things, that male academic leaders wanting to appeal to their female colleagues
00:09:58 will be especially inclined to support social justice positions. And it also means that as
00:10:03 more and more women are hired into academic positions, the consolidation of support 1.00
00:10:08 for social justice ideology will increase. One might be tempted to take heart from the fact
00:10:15 that the percentage of liberals and far leftists in higher education isn't even higher. After all,
00:10:23 a full one-third of professors do not identify as liberal or far left, but this makes no difference.
00:10:30 The one-third of non-leftists tend to be far less convinced of their righteousness
00:10:37 and far less inclined to agitate for their positions than those in the liberal and far-left
00:10:42 majority. And this last point brings me to the third reason why so very few are demanding that
00:10:49 Holt Schneider and his pals offer any resistance to the SJW bullies. The combination of fear and
00:10:57 the natural disinclination to speak out felt by those who disagree with the SJW ideology.
00:11:06 conservatives and middle-of-the-roaders tend to be well conservative and middle of the road in their
00:11:13 behavior as well as their political ideology they distrust revolutionary fervor they tend
00:11:20 to be cautious by temperament preferring civility over passionate demands many of them simply want
00:11:28 to be left alone to pursue their research and teaching and of course they are deeply afraid
00:11:35 some with good reason. Many academics are untenured and or reliant on the goodwill of
00:11:42 their colleagues and administrators in order to be given classes to teach or to be approved for
00:11:47 tenure and promotion. More generally, they depend on their colleagues' goodwill to
00:11:53 advance in their careers and to flourish, to be invited to conferences to get their research
00:12:00 funded and published by the major granting agencies and academic journals, or simply to be
00:12:06 in the know and in the swing of things in their departments, they feel their vulnerability and
00:12:13 they know that their politically committed friends will be ruthless in preventing their advancement
00:12:20 if they step out of line. Those who are secure in their positions, tenured and looking comfortably
00:12:27 toward retirement like me, well, they'll still hesitate at the thought of the social discomfort,
00:12:34 the cooling of friendships, the potential ostracization that will almost certainly follow
00:12:39 a confession of ideological treason. Fear of being shut out of what C.S. Lewis called the
00:12:46 inner ring keep many towing the ideological line. Adding to this fear is the fact that
00:12:53 many academics were social losers in their youth shy socially challenged nerds who spend a lot of
00:13:00 time sitting alone in their rude rooms reading books you know or doing math problems dreaming 0.52
00:13:06 of one day maybe being a little bit popular having some cool friends therefore the last
00:13:13 thing these people want now is to find themselves on the outside again subject to the ridicule and
00:13:21 disappointment of their cool sjw colleagues this is not a very respectable reason to stay silent
00:13:30 but it is a strongly felt one thus for a variety of reasons both serious and trivial the great
00:13:38 ideal of the university is a place for the pursuit of truth and the free exchange of ideas
00:13:43 that ideal is being lost replaced by deadening intellectual conformity
00:13:49 fearful obedience and mob rule by which those who shout the loudest and burnish their victim
00:13:56 credentials most assiduously will get their way and the few who break ranks whether consciously
00:14:04 or even by accident will be sacrificed to their fury to borrow a phrase this is the
00:14:11 This is the way the university ends, not with a bang, but a whimper.