The Fiamengo File - October 27, 2016


Academic Totalitarianism - TFF Episode 49

Why Academics Bow to the Mob - TFF Episode 48 Men Need Not Apply - TFF Episode 50

Episode Stats


Length

16 minutes

Words per minute

125.85

Word count

2,093

Sentence count

66

Harmful content

Misogyny

6

sentences flagged

Toxicity

1

sentences flagged

Hate speech

2

sentences flagged


Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
00:00:00 Is it really an academic's, quote, obligation to persecute a fellow academic for disagreeing
00:00:09 with feminist doctrine, as Professor of English Jeffrey Jerome Cohen has recently declared
00:00:15 on his blog?
00:00:17 And why do so many professors seem eager to shame and blame anybody who steps out of line?
00:00:25 That's my subject on today's Fiamengo File.
00:00:34 I'm Janice Fiamengo of the University of Ottawa.
00:00:37 Actually there is nothing that should surprise us in the willingness of the majority of academics
00:00:41 to allow freedom of speech to be suppressed and even to lead the charge in suppressing
00:00:47 it in the name of a culturally sanctioned social cause.
00:00:52 has been this way for a long time. Recently, a Facebook friend sent me a link to an article
00:00:59 called Snakes and Ladders on Alan Franson, Misogyny, and the Problem with Tenure. I'm
00:01:07 embarrassed that I didn't know about Alan Franson sooner because he's a really interesting
00:01:11 dissident academic. Dr. Franson was a highly successful and now retired English scholar,
00:01:18 a specialist in medieval literature at Loyola University in Chicago.
00:01:23 He has provoked near-apoplexia with his ridicule of feminist politics
00:01:29 and his defense of modern men on a webpage entitled
00:01:34 Modern Men and Masculinity, the Struggle to Become a Masculine Man.
00:01:40 That's his right, surely, to defend men from feminist propaganda,
00:01:45 especially during his retirement? Well, not according to other academics in English lit
00:01:53 who have been clucking and bleating and uttering exclamations of outrage at what are claimed to be
00:02:01 his, quote, misogynistic screeds, which are apparently, quote, peppered with the most
00:02:07 hackneyed and useless men's rights activist jargon you could imagine, end quote.
00:02:13 Actually, Franson makes thoughtful, well-reasoned arguments about men and the effects of feminist
00:02:21 dogma on his personal blog. But you can't say the same, in terms of well-reasoned arguments,
00:02:27 about his opponents, who mainly confine themselves to sanctimonious expressions of horror, proving
00:02:36 perhaps that English studies may be the silliest and most trivial discipline in all of academia.
00:02:43 One academic, a man named Jeffrey Jerome Cohen, professor of George Washington University,
00:02:49 has made it his personal crusade to spread the word about Franson, encouraging as many others
00:02:56 as possible to join in the academic pile-on. Cohen has written a blog post entitled Calling Out
00:03:04 Misogyny to crow about his success in instigating the war on Franson. My favourite part of the post
00:03:11 is his just slightly disingenuous statement that, quote, we should be cautious about public shaming
00:03:19 and bandwagoning, of course. Yeah, of course. But not if it's a senior male professor attacking
00:03:28 feminism. In that case, public shaming and bandwagoning is not only necessary, but righteous. 0.64
00:03:36 Like all the others he encouraged to take to Twitter to insult and revile Franson,
00:03:43 Professor Cohen never does bother to bring forward any evidence that Franson has,
00:03:49 as he claims, quote, filled his website with hatred against women, end quote.
00:03:56 It's enough that Franson dared to criticize feminism. Cohen seems particularly exercised
00:04:04 about a paragraph from Franson's website in which Franson employed the phrase FemFog to define the
00:04:13 academic culture of obeisance to feminism. And here it is to give you a flavour for his blog.
00:04:20 It's reproduced from the site MGTOW HQ. Quote, Let's call it the FemFog for short, 0.98
00:04:29 the sour mix of victimization and privilege that makes up modern feminism and that feminists use 1.00
00:04:37 to intimidate and exploit men. Some men are so intimidated by feminism that they are afraid
00:04:45 to develop a critical attitude towards it. Feminism is enormously powerful. Enormously 0.90
00:04:52 powerful movements should always be regarded with skepticism and wariness, especially when
00:04:58 they are aimed at taking power from you. As Jack Donovan writes, the aim of feminism is to remove 1.00
00:05:05 men from power. The aim is not to share power with men. Men today live in femfog, a thick mist of 1.00
00:05:13 anti-male propaganda. Many men don't know how to fight it, and some don't even realize that they
00:05:21 are fogged up end quote it goes on like that an attack on feminism as an ideology of man blaming
00:05:31 it's not an attack on women and neither professor cohen who finds it quote appalling nor the author
00:05:38 of the original article that i read writer and academic joe livingston well they just can't
00:05:44 accept that a smart fellow like Franson and a progressive gay scholar to boot, they can't
00:05:51 accept that he can really think that way or think he could get away with it. 0.92
00:05:58 He must have gone mad, Livingston speculates in the article.
00:06:03 Well, I've got news for the two of them. There are quite a number of academics, male and female,
00:06:09 who think the way franson does but the enforced monopoly on moral rectitude in the academy
00:06:17 has kept people in ignorance of it now it's out there and these upholders of politically approved
00:06:24 thought are thrashing around in impotent indignation you see the problem for cohen and
00:06:31 livingston and others is that franson is retired and therefore he's largely beyond the reach
00:06:37 of the thought-censors they'd so much like to muster. Professor Cohen is quoted as lamenting
00:06:44 that with tenure, quote, it is easy to drift into some scary places without reality checks
00:06:52 to bring you back, end quote. Does he mean the reality check of being disciplined for holding
00:06:58 incorrect views? I'd be willing to wager that what brought Franson to anti-feminism
00:07:04 was the reality check of actually reading a lot of very bad published feminist scholarship.
00:07:13 I've done it. I could give you loads of examples. 1.00
00:07:17 Franson's emergence as a writer of anti-feminist posts,
00:07:22 that came not because he had tenure and therefore didn't have to engage with the world,
00:07:27 but because he had a mind of his own, and now he has the opportunity to air his views.
00:07:34 I'll bet it's intensely annoying to realize that a former colleague is now beyond the reach of the usual control mechanisms of academia, the social shaming, the potential Title IX investigations.
00:07:50 But even when Franzen was a professor, he almost certainly couldn't have been fired for his incorrect attitudes, and that's starting to bother the academic Puritans amongst us.
00:08:02 Joe Livingston, for example, laments that, quote, the tenured, particularly men, are exempt from the kind of character scrutiny to which ordinary employees are subjected, end quote.
00:08:17 It's remarkable to find self-described progressive people calling for character scrutiny for professors.
00:08:25 It sounds like something out of Victorian times, you know, like, we hope Professor Sandwell is a respectable man, moderate in his habits, prudent, correct in his opinions and regular in church attendance, and so on.
00:08:41 It's clear from the remarks of Professor Cohen and the author of the article that these individuals would love to be able to sanction their colleagues for thinking incorrectly about feminism.
00:08:54 I've noticed that even the once standard expressions of support for free speech are now
00:09:00 falling away from these kinds of comments, revealing an ever more nakedly expressed demand
00:09:06 for ideological conformity. Well, as I mentioned last day, we shouldn't be at all surprised by any
00:09:14 of this. History shows us that there have always been plenty of intellectuals like Professor Jeremy
00:09:20 Cohen willing to give obedient and even zealous support for totalitarianism. For many intellectuals,
00:09:28 nothing is more satisfying than to fall in line with an attractive orthodoxy so long as
00:09:34 lots of their fellow intellectuals are doing the same and that rewards and power come their way
00:09:39 as a result. The German universities of the 19th and early 20th centuries had been at the forefront
00:09:47 of higher education with a strong tradition of free inquiry and the pursuit of truth
00:09:53 they were celebrated worldwide in fact for their openness to debating ideas all of that changed in
00:10:00 the 1930s as national socialism became the official ideology of the german nation after
00:10:06 the election of the national socialist party in march of 1933 nazism also became the reigning
00:10:13 ideology of the German universities. Some few professors protested this development, a few even
00:10:22 resigning their positions, but many more reluctantly or eagerly adapted themselves to the new realities,
00:10:31 taking advantage of the opportunities for security and advancement that were offered to them.
00:10:37 Stephen Remy's book, The Heidelberg Myth, The Nazification and Denazification of a German
00:10:44 University, published in 2003, makes a case study of Heidelberg University to show how readily
00:10:51 the vast majority of the university's highest ranking professors aligned themselves with the
00:10:56 new regime. Some had already joined the Nazi Party prior to the regime takeover in 1933, and
00:11:04 Many others were quick to express their sympathy with the regime's nationalist ideals. They were
00:11:09 happy to abandon objective scholarship in favor of preparing German minds for the Nazi project.
00:11:16 The author shows how even before the government imposed dismissal of all Jewish civil servants in
00:11:23 April of 1933, radical student leaders had already begun to harass and boycott their non-Aryan
00:11:31 colleagues then between 1933 and 1938 heidelberg was purged of nearly one-third of its instructors
00:11:40 mostly jewish instructors other instructors went into a kind of inner exile of silence
00:11:48 and many ambitious younger scholars took the opportunity to advance into the newly vacated
00:11:55 positions professors of law biology medicine sociology german literature and history embrace
00:12:03 the new mandate that all research and teaching must serve the german volk just as many professors
00:12:10 today are happy to bend their research and teaching to serve radical social justice ideology
00:12:18 including misandric feminism and anti-white propaganda so how does this happen and are
00:12:26 intellectuals particularly prone to such willing ideological servitude well to some extent they are
00:12:34 many intellectuals while enjoying a privileged position in society and often convinced of their
00:12:40 mental and even moral superiority are also quite aware often resentfully so of the tenuousness
00:12:48 of their billet intellectuals are often not particularly prepossessing individuals they
00:12:54 know a lot about one extremely narrow area of research and often that's all they know many
00:13:01 develop their intellectual capacity far out of proportion to other capacities including social
00:13:07 skills leadership skills you know communication skills and knowledge of self and others often
00:13:13 their area of expertise is so specialized that they can discuss it with only a small group of
00:13:19 other specialists and it is often a subject that the general public finds mystifying or even off
00:13:25 putting that makes the intellectuals feel weak and unimportant unlike the other major pillars
00:13:32 of our social world the soldiers builders creators merchants healers and political and religious
00:13:40 leaders the elite intellectual class maintains its status only so long as society's secular
00:13:47 and religious rulers validate the intellectual work these academics do despite what they
00:13:54 conventionally say about their status as dissenters even as rebels against the status quo they are
00:14:00 intensely aware that their high status depends on the indulgence of the ruling elite of political
00:14:09 leaders and the media they are therefore very sensitive to shifts in the political ideological
00:14:15 landscape what these intellectuals have detected and what they or their forerunners contributed to
00:14:22 creating has been a weakening a disastrous weakening of faith in the pursuit of knowledge
00:14:28 as a sufficient rationale for the existence of universities. As the kinds of truth universities
00:14:36 once upheld—religious truth, first of all, then humanistic truth, objective scientific truth—as
00:14:44 those truths came under fire by postmodernists and social radicals in the 1960s, they came to be seen
00:14:52 as inadequate. University learning, it was thought, had to be about more than the traditional
00:14:59 disciplines. It had to be about a larger morality. And because other forms of morality had been
00:15:06 jettisoned by the social elite, the new morality was social justice—the elimination of racism
00:15:13 and sexism and colonialism. So academics fell in line with the social justice cause,
00:15:21 some because they wanted to, some because they felt they had to,
00:15:25 some because it was easier to go along than to resist, and the career inducements were many.
00:15:31 Gradually, social justice became not just one good to be balanced against other goods,
00:15:38 such as knowledge and open debate, but it became the primary, preeminent good, superior to all
00:15:46 others and we come to the point where social justice trumps everything else including freedom
00:15:52 of conscience freedom of expression the presumption of innocence the equal treatment of all students
00:15:59 and of course the pursuit of knowledge it's a grim situation in which all manner of ridiculous
00:16:07 inequities, and injustices can and do flourish. In the next videos, we will look in more depth
00:16:16 at the appeal of social justice ideology, the power it exercises over individuals on campus,
00:16:23 and the terrible consequences for university life and academic work.