The Fiamengo File - November 03, 2016


Men Need Not Apply - TFF Episode 50

Academic Totalitarianism - TFF Episode 49 Black Women in Academia - TFF Episode 51

Episode Stats


Length

12 minutes

Words per minute

137.84

Word count

1,708

Sentence count

48

Harmful content

Misogyny

14

sentences flagged

Hate speech

3

sentences flagged


Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
00:00:00 If white men are really the most powerful members of our society with
00:00:06 privilege and institutional clout, how come they are consistently treated the
00:00:13 worst and nobody worries in the least that they might resent it? That's the
00:00:19 obvious question of this week's Fiamengo File.
00:00:24 I'm Janice Fiumengo of the University of Ottawa.
00:00:31 In my last video, I talked about the three main reasons why academics will sell out their
00:00:36 colleagues and students, enabling the suppression of free speech and the corruption of the merit
00:00:43 principle in the name of social justice.
00:00:47 The result is that on university campuses across the Western world, bad behaviour by
00:00:52 groups claiming to be marginalized is rewarded, and injustice against high achievers is sanctioned.
00:01:01 It's grievance politics, as usual.
00:01:05 At Missouri University in the fall of 2015, student activists held the entire campus hostage,
00:01:13 made outrageous demands including that the students should take a leading role in implementing
00:01:19 affirmative action for Black faculty and students, and eventually forced the university president
00:01:25 to resign, with a mea culpa and a plea for healing, with no discipline taken against
00:01:33 the students for their arrogant and threatening behavior.
00:01:37 What precipitated their demands and the accompanying bullying, including a planned strike by the
00:01:42 entire university football team, were three incidents, two of which were unproven allegations
00:01:48 of racial slurs that, even if true, had nothing to do with racism at the university, and the
00:01:55 third of which, the infamous swastika in feces in a residential stairway, was only tangentially
00:02:02 connected to the oppression of black students. On this thinnest of pretexts, in other words,
00:02:09 the student radicals engaged in weeks-long grandstanding and disruption for which they
00:02:14 been rewarded with a great deal of sympathetic attention and accommodations far far away on the
00:02:22 campus of the university of melbourne a very different event occurred an outright truly
00:02:29 systemic infringement on the basic rights of academic men and as far as i could find there's
00:02:36 been no protest at all the university of melbourne in australia announced last may 2016 that it would
00:02:44 be advertising for three senior positions in its mathematics department and that these positions
00:02:51 would be closed to male applicants why because in order to offer female students the mentors
00:02:58 and role models they supposedly require though lack of role models never prevented female students 0.99
00:03:04 from flooding into departments of medicine law philosophy or other male dominated fields but 1.00
00:03:10 whatever in order to encourage prospective female students the number of female math profs 1.00
00:03:16 must be increased and that this couldn't be done merely by hiring the best applicants into those 0.89
00:03:23 positions or even by using the equity hiring model whereby a woman is hired whenever she can be shown
00:03:30 to be equally as good as a male applicant that's a process that's been going on in academia across
00:03:36 the western world for decades only a process apparently in which men were entirely excluded
00:03:44 could yield the desired result now the implied insult to female mathematicians the admission 0.52
00:03:53 that on a level playing field or even on a playing field distinctly stacked in their favor 0.79
00:03:58 women simply can't compete with their male colleagues, well, that would be embarrassingly
00:04:05 clear if it weren't for the fact that the announcement about the positions was accompanied
00:04:11 by repeated references to sexism in the field in order to make the point that it's not that 0.99
00:04:18 female mathematicians can't compete with the very best male minds in the field, but that supposedly
00:04:24 all these brilliant women have been prevented from competing due to the ingrained prejudice 1.00
00:04:31 they purportedly encounter. So, in order to avoid insulting women, the insult was turned on the men 1.00
00:04:38 in the Melbourne Department of Mathematics. So, not only must those men sit by while members of
00:04:44 their sects are outright denied the opportunity to compete for these three prestigious positions,
00:04:51 And not only must these male academics consent to the hiring into their department of colleagues
00:04:57 who may well be less brilliant and capable than other candidates, thus weakening the reputation
00:05:02 of the department and its ability to attract the best graduate students and contribute to
00:05:07 high-level mathematics research. And not only must they consent to the hiring into their departments
00:05:14 of three individuals conscious that they were hired not because they were the best but because
00:05:21 they were women and whose awareness of that uncomfortable fact may well lead to a grievance
00:05:26 complex manifesting in complaints of discrimination and sexual harassment which women with grievance 0.96
00:05:33 complexes are all too prone to make even in situations where they are not in the minority 0.51
00:05:39 and surrounded by colleagues, some of whom may not successfully hide the resentment they might
00:05:45 well-foundedly feel. Not a recipe for a well-functioning mathematics department.
00:05:51 But in addition to all of that, the men in the Melbourne Maths Department must accept the slur
00:05:59 on their reputations without protest. They have to accept that they and their male colleagues
00:06:06 are seen as sexists who discriminate against women, and that they're supposed to be deferential
00:06:12 and even grateful to the likely inferior colleagues hired for giving them the opportunity
00:06:18 to redeem themselves morally. No evidence is offered that there has ever been sexist discrimination
00:06:27 at the University of Melbourne. Very little evidence is even offered of sexism in STEM
00:06:33 generally. But still, most readers of the news about Melbourne will be so used to hearing
00:06:39 that there is sexist discrimination across STEM fields that they'll be willing to believe there
00:06:45 must be some truth to the allegation about the Melbourne Mathematics Department, and that cloud
00:06:51 will always hang over Melbourne's department, no matter how many women they hire. In fact,
00:06:58 the more women they hire, the greater the chance that they'll experience further complaints of
00:07:03 sexism and harassment.
00:07:06 The only so-called evidence produced of sexist discrimination against women in STEM is one
00:07:13 small study out of Princeton University whose results have not been replicated and whose
00:07:19 conclusions are open to multiple interpretations.
00:07:24 In the study, identical applicants for a position as a senior lab manager were presented to
00:07:29 study participants, and there was a statistical bias in favour of the male applicant. Study
00:07:36 participants of both sexes preferred the male applicant to the female, demonstrating, according
00:07:42 to the authors of the study, that there is an ingrained perception in STEM that male candidates
00:07:49 are more competent than equally qualified female candidates. The problem with the study is that
00:07:55 its parameters are too specific to be generalizable all across STEM fields in the manner the study
00:08:02 authors claim. And we absolutely don't know that the study participants are perfectly representative
00:08:08 of all their colleagues in STEM. I noticed, for example, that the mean age of the study
00:08:13 participants was 50 years old, which seemed to suggest that if there is a general gender
00:08:19 bias operating, it might be the result of the generally older generation being tested.
00:08:25 Regardless, I'm not convinced that the reason the male candidate was chosen by both male and female
00:08:30 study participants was because of a biased perception that male candidates are always
00:08:36 more competent. Perhaps in a situation in which most science students are male, it was thought
00:08:42 that a male lab manager would be preferable. For other kinds of positions, the study participants
00:08:48 may well have had a different preference. Perhaps if the position had been for a tutor, a female 0.97
00:08:53 applicant might have been preferred. And the elephant in the room is always the question of 0.57
00:08:58 where a bias, if it is a bias, may have come from. Perhaps in the experience of the study participants,
00:09:04 male lab managers had performed better than their female peers in actual lab situations,
00:09:10 making their preference not an example of irrational sexism, but an example of a rational
00:09:17 experience-based conclusion. But never mind that one study. What the article doesn't mention is
00:09:25 that there is plenty of evidence to contradict the findings of this one study, or at least to
00:09:31 demonstrate that the picture of gender relations in STEM is far more complicated than is being
00:09:37 claimed. In fact, a new study by Cornell psychologists has found in experiments with
00:09:43 professors from 371 colleges and universities across the United States, that science and 0.82
00:09:51 engineering faculty preferred women two to one over identically qualified male candidates for
00:09:59 assistant professor positions. This is a much larger study with much more generalizable results
00:10:06 directly related to the subject of academic hiring into tenure stream positions. If the
00:10:13 If the results of this much larger and more applicable study are correct, then Melbourne
00:10:19 University has just made a decision that discriminates against men to favor women in an academic
00:10:27 culture that is already biased against men and in favor of women. 0.99
00:10:34 It's incredible. 0.69
00:10:36 I think the men in the Department of Mathematics at the University of Melbourne could be pardoned
00:10:41 for feeling that despite the fact that it was men
00:10:44 who created and pioneered the study of mathematics,
00:10:48 men who made all the major discoveries in the field,
00:10:51 men who've done the incredibly difficult
00:10:54 and often uncelebrated work
00:10:55 of pursuing the most advanced mathematics research,
00:10:59 and men who opened the doors of such study to women,
00:11:03 usually with great generosity and good grace,
00:11:06 far more than women have ever exhibited 0.61
00:11:09 and opening the doors to men in female-dominated fields.
00:11:12 Despite all this, men are not much valued
00:11:16 at the University of Melbourne or anywhere else.
00:11:21 You can imagine how much sympathy they'd get
00:11:25 if they started demonstrating, protesting,
00:11:27 and threatening in response to this example
00:11:30 of systemic discrimination.
00:11:32 What if they went on strike, like the football team at Mizzou?
00:11:37 What if they stopped doing the work
00:11:39 that is so contemptuously taken for granted?
00:11:43 Well, we know what would happen.
00:11:46 Rather than being fetid and supported
00:11:48 like the students at Mizzou for their imaginary grievances,
00:11:52 these men would be promptly fired
00:11:55 and all of them replaced by female mathematicians.
00:11:58 And wouldn't the leaders of U of Melbourne be pleased?
00:12:02 It would likely take years for it to be generally recognized
00:12:05 the quality of mathematics research had declined at the school and many more years for it to be
00:12:11 publicly admitted. Far too late for these men, or even for their sons, likely. Some privilege, some
00:12:22 justice.