The Fiamengo File - November 10, 2016


Black Women in Academia - TFF Episode 51

Men Need Not Apply - TFF Episode 50 Jordan Peterson and Freedom of Speech - TFF Episode 52

Episode Stats


Length

10 minutes

Words per minute

139.77

Word count

1,405

Sentence count

26

Harmful content

Misogyny

7

sentences flagged

Toxicity

1

sentences flagged

Hate speech

3

sentences flagged


Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
00:00:00 Is it tough being a black woman in academia? According to one blog post author, it's really
00:00:08 lousy getting so many interviews and job offers. Yeah, you heard that right. That's my subject on
00:00:15 today's Fiamengo File. I'm Janice Fiamengo of the University of Ottawa. In my last video,
00:00:25 i explored the upside down world of victim politics in which self-proclaimed victims take
00:00:31 advantage of their victim privilege to make outrageous demands and behave badly while the
00:00:38 so-called privileged suffered discrimination without recourse as has happened recently in
00:00:45 the mathematics department at melbourne university which is discriminating against men quite
00:00:50 outrageously in its hiring while i was researching that case at melbourne i came across a 2015 blog
00:00:59 post entitled how are you diverse how the academic job market highlighted my racial insecurities
00:01:10 the article highlights some of the ironic effects of preferential hiring policies on those it
00:01:16 favors on the women sexual minorities and people of color whom universities have been incentivized 1.00
00:01:22 to hire over the past decade the author of the article a young black female phd named keisha
00:01:30 ray talks about the 59 job interviews she was given in her search for academic employment
00:01:37 and the experience of promoting herself as a candidate whose hiring would contribute to
00:01:42 diversity in the academy how are you diverse she was actually asked point blank the answer would
00:01:50 seem rather obvious she comments given her evident blackness and femaleness but nonetheless she
00:01:56 answered that question at some length for many interviews over time the persistence of the 0.66
00:02:03 question caused the reality to dawn on ray that very likely the high number of interviews she
00:02:10 was receiving reflected attempts by hiring committees to meet state-imposed diversity
00:02:17 requirements. And the realization that hiring committees were not really interested in her,
00:02:25 Keisha Ray, but in proving to their school's diversity committee that they had considered
00:02:31 hiring a Black woman. Well, that experience, that realization was not pleasant. She writes,
00:02:37 quote when you are when you are aware that departments are increasingly being required
00:02:43 to at least show they have made an attempt to hire diverse faculty you start to question
00:02:49 why you are really conducting an interview am i here so faculty can show their dean or
00:02:56 hr department that at least they interviewed someone diverse or the question that all diverse
00:03:02 people ask themselves in situations like this am i here to fill a quota in many interviews i believe
00:03:10 the answer for me was yes end quote this is a really interesting blog post for its exploration
00:03:18 of how preferential hiring practices almost inevitably reduce an applicant's value to a
00:03:25 racial or gender category having little to do with individual talents and achievements
00:03:31 Ray admits, in fact, that she wasn't that well qualified for quite a few of the positions she
00:03:36 was interviewed for. And she also discusses the frustration of never really knowing whether her
00:03:42 suspicions were correct or whether her actual qualifications were attracting potential employers.
00:03:49 Added to all of this anxiety was the grating assumption by friends and acquaintances that
00:03:56 as a black woman she had hit the jackpot in the identity category sweepstakes no matter how good
00:04:02 she really was many people would inevitably assume that her interviews and job offers had little to
00:04:08 do with merit and everything to do with the fact that she was female and black she notes that quote
00:04:15 the sentiment that my diversity gives me an advantage over the competition makes me question
00:04:22 if my only qualification for some academic positions was my diversity." It's a frustrating
00:04:31 position for the author, who is still convinced that racist and sexist bias exists in academia,
00:04:38 while having to confront the irrefutable perception amongst friends and acquaintances
00:04:43 that she has unearned privilege. Despite the frustration of the experience, though,
00:04:51 Ray never questions that so-called diversity based on race and sex is necessary. In fact,
00:04:58 she remains committed to the idea that the presence of Black women in academia is a good thing
00:05:04 in itself. But she's also adamant that, quote, if this is the nature of the academic market,
00:05:11 and despite my accomplishments, I am merely a box to be checked by a search committee,
00:05:17 then my value is not as a productive colleague, but rather as a quota."
00:05:25 I sympathize with Ray's predicament to some extent because I have myself had the experience 0.74
00:05:30 of being interviewed for positions and offered jobs at a time when I knew that being female was 0.95
00:05:37 a major element in my desirability as a prospective hire, and I'll live with that knowledge forever.
00:05:44 Often, academic job applications at the time when I was applying in 1999,
00:05:50 they came with a form that one had to fill out to ascertain whether one was female,
00:05:55 of colour, Aboriginal, Métis, etc. And that was always alongside the university's stated
00:06:02 commitment to diversity. This kind of thing has been going on for a long time.
00:06:08 Now, where my sympathy for Rae flags is in her refusal to recognize that, uncomfortable as it
00:06:15 might be to have interviews and job offers coming her way because she is, quote, merely a box to be
00:06:22 checked, it's far worse to be denied interviews merely because one is not a box to be checked.
00:06:31 ray had three job offers which is three more than many qualified and talented white men 0.86
00:06:39 she'll have the chance to prove her worth and to make her colleagues forget that she was hired
00:06:45 partly because she was black and female a lot of white men will never have that chance and i doubt
00:06:51 ray will ever give them a thought cry me a river white boy as the saying goes she remains convinced
00:06:59 that black women are discriminated against in academia and that her own experience of
00:07:04 positive discrimination merely adds another layer to her oppression. If she ever had to stop 1.00
00:07:11 believing in her oppression, she would have to confront some even more uncomfortable truths. 0.76
00:07:18 Basically, Keisha Ray and others like her want to have it both ways. She wants to conduct her 0.99
00:07:25 job search in an academic culture committed to atoning for its supposed sins by seeking to 1.00
00:07:31 hire people like her. She wants to continue to see herself as one of those more sinned against
00:07:37 than sinning, but she also wants to be valued quite apart from these unchosen features as an
00:07:46 individual with unique skills and intellectual capacity. It reminds me of the period when I
00:07:52 worked at the university of saskatchewan which was in the midst of the same kind of hiring that
00:07:57 ray experienced in 1999 to 2003 there was a protocol drawn up by members of our union about
00:08:04 how we should all think about and practice what was then called equity hiring which was racial and
00:08:13 gender preference according to the protocol we were supposed to convince ourselves and
00:08:19 everyone else that even while we were hiring candidates because they were female or non-white
00:08:25 or whatever that we were really hiring them because they were so very good there was actually
00:08:32 a clause in the protocol that after the hiring we were all supposed to spread the word around
00:08:38 the university about how excited we were to have hired x because of all her intellectual merits
00:08:46 and we were not to speak of x as an equity appointment it was double think and a lot of
00:08:53 people were pretty good at it but in reality it can't be both you either compete on a level
00:09:01 playing field in which hiring committees seek to be gender and color blind in which the only thing
00:09:06 you bring to the job competition is your intelligence and ability or you compete on an
00:09:13 uneven field in which your skin color and or sex gives you a special advantage that has nothing to
00:09:20 do with merit so choose if it's the latter if you like the advantage you gain through the social
00:09:27 justice framework then naturally you'll never know how much of a role your race and or gender played
00:09:35 in your hiring and that uncertainty will be your companion throughout your career people will assume
00:09:41 you were hired, at least partly because you fit a category and you can't tell them they're wrong.
00:09:48 You could work to abolish preferential treatment, but if you don't, you can't ask your society
00:09:56 to pretend it isn't happening. So cry me a river, black girl. 1.00