The Fiamengo File - November 18, 2016


Jordan Peterson and Freedom of Speech - TFF Episode 52

Black Women in Academia - TFF Episode 51 When Feminists Control The Past - TFF Episode 53

Episode Stats


Length

20 minutes

Words per minute

120.51

Word count

2,449

Sentence count

97

Harmful content

Toxicity

4

sentences flagged

Hate speech

1

sentences flagged


Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
00:00:00 Where is the chorus of academics standing up for free speech and against
00:00:06 the persecution of Professor Jordan Peterson? That's my subject on today's
00:00:11 Fiumengo File.
00:00:19 I'm Janice Fiumengo of the University of Ottawa and I'm speaking to you today
00:00:23 from my office so you may hear some sound of voices out in the hall. As many
00:00:28 of you probably know psychology professor jordan peterson of the university of toronto
00:00:33 has been much in the news lately and all over youtube for objecting to the repressive reign
00:00:39 of political correctness on university campuses it's as a consequence of free speech and the
00:00:44 ability to speak that people can put their finger on problems articulate what those problems are
00:00:50 solve them and come to a consensus and we risk losing that his focus has been the relatively
00:00:58 new canadian bill to include gender identity and gender expression as protected categories in human
00:01:05 rights legislation and in the criminal code whereby the failure to use pronouns consistent
00:01:12 with individuals preferences whether male or female or neither male nor female or both
00:01:18 could be interpreted as a human rights violation. Professor Peterson has argued that this legislation
00:01:25 and its likely application go one step further than other anti-discrimination legislation,
00:01:33 not only in restricting what one can say, but in actually mandating what one must say.
00:01:42 In the first video of his that started all the fuss and in subsequent interviews,
00:01:47 Professor Peterson has pointed out the various contradictions and incoherencies in the proposed
00:01:53 amendments and the definitions associated with them. The vagueness and the downright confusion
00:02:02 of a lot of the language. The insistence on accommodating people's needs, for example,
00:02:08 as if needs could be easily determined and never in conflict. And the logical incoherence
00:02:15 of a theory of gender that sees a trans identity as innate and unalterable,
00:02:23 but other gender identities as purely a cultural construct. And he objects to elevating into fact
00:02:32 or law something that isn't self-evidently either. And he talks about the fear that is now so much a
00:02:41 part of these discussions, whereby professors who once felt it their right and duty to pursue
00:02:48 all manner of truth with their students now self-censor in order to avoid complaints or
00:02:55 the wrath of the administration.
00:02:58 He has expressed his concern that soon, if not already, basic conversations about whether
00:03:04 gender identity is really separate from biological sex or even whether there is such a thing
00:03:11 as biological sex will be absolutely forbidden. His videos were not only a way of talking through
00:03:19 his questions and thoughts, but also a kind of testing of the waters to determine if his fears
00:03:25 were irrational. And in the event, it turned out that Peterson's analysis of where we are
00:03:33 with human rights legislation in Canada was all too prescient.
00:04:03 They did grab me and pull me in and try to punch me.
00:04:13 Officer, I didn't see anything.
00:04:15 I didn't see anything that happened.
00:04:17 There's no reason to hit me.
00:04:19 I didn't see anything.
00:04:33 Free speech is the alternative to violence, and there's lots of people who like violence
00:04:47 and who are waiting for the opportunity to use it.
00:04:50 And I'm hoping that we can talk our way out of it.
00:04:53 The response to the University of Toronto downtown campus was hysterical and vitriolic.
00:05:00 denunciations of Peterson as a transphobe, claims that trans people had been made to feel unsafe,
00:05:07 claims that Peterson's speaking about the matter of pronouns was an existential threat to the
00:05:14 transgendered. This is the typical gambit of what a friend of mine calls the psychotic left.
00:05:24 Their claim that, whatever the topic, it is always a matter of life and death,
00:05:29 and that merely taking a non-compliant position contributes to horrific suffering and even to
00:05:36 the slaughter of innocents. And most chilling and indicative, the University of Toronto
00:05:44 administration has sent Peterson two letters, the second of which has told him in no uncertain terms
00:05:51 that if he fails to fall in line, his university will not stand behind him. Here's part of the
00:05:59 letter. Quote, The Law of Ontario, specifically the Ontario Human Rights Code, protects against
00:06:07 discrimination based on gender expression and gender identity. Depending on the context,
00:06:14 if personal pronouns are being used, the refusal by a teacher or colleague to use the personal
00:06:21 pronoun that is an expression of the person's gender identity can constitute discrimination.
00:06:29 Your statements that you will refuse to refer to transgendered persons using
00:06:34 gender-neutral pronouns if they ask you to do so are contrary to the rights of those
00:06:40 persons to equal treatment without discrimination. You should also be aware that many members of the
00:06:47 university community are concerned and distressed about the declarations of your discriminatory
00:06:53 intentions. The university has received communications from individuals, student
00:06:59 groups, and employee groups that find your comments to be unacceptable, emotionally disturbing,
00:07:06 and painful." With this letter, the university administration confirmed
00:07:13 Everything Professor Peterson had said in his first video. Not only must everybody
00:07:20 accede to pronoun demands, but one must refrain from even mentioning the whole matter. Yes,
00:07:27 even to discuss the subject in an unacceptable way may be some kind of human rights violation.
00:07:36 I don't really have anything original to say here because Professor Peterson has himself
00:07:42 said it all very well, but I wanted to speak in his support for what that's worth, and to say
00:07:49 that his case confirms fears I've had for a very long time about how we as a society have given
00:07:57 over our freedom to revolutionary social justice agents. This whole debate is and is not about
00:08:07 pronouns, in my opinion. Like most people, like Jordan Peterson himself, I'm not interested in
00:08:15 hurting anyone's feelings or harming their dignity. But far worse than that is making laws
00:08:23 to punish people who think incorrectly on a subject that, as Peterson himself argues, is far
00:08:30 from settled. Forcing people to say what they deeply believe to be untrue, for example, that
00:08:37 there are 32 genders, that there is no biological sex, forcing people to employ new pronouns on
00:08:44 pain of social mobbing, the ruination of reputation, job loss, or investigation by a human rights
00:08:52 tribunal. Is that really how we want to deal with controversial issues as a society? That's the
00:09:00 question. And the answer is, as Jordan Peterson's case has shown, the answer is that it's too late
00:09:08 to have that conversation. We already are that society. The laws are already in place.
00:09:17 In fact, the Supreme Court of Canada already ruled nearly four years ago that the prohibition
00:09:24 on hateful or discriminatory speech is more important than any other value in our society,
00:09:33 and almost nobody protested that or even noticed. February 27, 2013, was the date on which the
00:09:43 Supreme Court rendered its judgment upholding two of the four findings of hate speech made
00:09:50 by the Saskatchewan Human Rights Commission against Bill Watcott, an anti-gay member of
00:09:57 the Christian Truth activists. Watcott was convicted of, quote, promoting hatred against
00:10:04 individuals based on their sexual orientation, end quote, because he had put flyers on car windshields
00:10:12 in 2002 and 2003, warning against what he perceived to be a homosexual agenda
00:10:20 in Saskatchewan's primary schools to encourage children to become gay, essentially.
00:10:25 He also pointed out that certain personal ads in gay publications appeared to be clearly seeking 0.97
00:10:31 boys for sex. In his flyers, he used harsh language, words like sodomy and filth, 0.99
00:10:40 which the Supreme Court affirmed to be in contravention of the Human Rights Code.
00:10:46 This was a landmark ruling, breathtaking in its lack of proportion, clarity, or reasonableness.
00:10:54 The Supreme Court justices defined hate speech incredibly broadly, not by its content or by its
00:11:02 intent, but by its likely, quote, effect, in exposing a specific group or individual to hatred.
00:11:12 In defining it thus, the Supreme Court entered a bizarre realm of supposition and unsupported
00:11:19 allegation, given that an effect is impossible to predict in advance or even to prove often after
00:11:27 the fact. But the justices didn't care. They tell us in their judgment that a conviction for hate
00:11:34 speech does not require any, quote, proof of harm, merely a hypothetical likelihood. And as you know,
00:11:43 SJWs find likelihood of harm nearly everywhere. As if to bolster what they knew to be an extremely
00:11:50 weak argument, the Supreme Court justices detailed the potential consequences of hate speech in
00:11:57 dramatic terms. This is what they said, quote, hate speech lays the groundwork for later broad
00:12:04 attacks on vulnerable groups that can range from discrimination to ostracism, segregation,
00:12:11 deportation, violence, and in the most extreme cases to genocide, end quote. All this from a 0.98
00:12:20 few hundred crude flyers put on car windshields? I really doubt it.
00:12:26 This is wild, hypothesizing, pretending to show causation.
00:12:32 Yes, hate speech may lay the groundwork for these serious harms, especially when
00:12:39 it is promulgated by powerful leaders and institutions, but hate speech does not
00:12:44 inevitably or even generally cause them. Far more frequently, in the case of a single individual
00:12:51 such as Bill Watcott, an utterance simply ends with itself. It is staggering to contemplate that
00:13:00 the Supreme Court of Canada, supposedly encompassing some of the most serious and experienced
00:13:05 legal minds in our country, considers that the mere possibility, no matter how slim,
00:13:12 that general harms may follow a statement is an adequate ground for prohibiting that statement,
00:13:19 especially when freedom of expression is the fundamental pillar of a free society. It is the
00:13:28 fundamental pillar, and we've blown it all to smithereens. The justices never seriously
00:13:35 recognize the danger of mandating what people can and can't say they simply affirm the rightness
00:13:43 of legislation to quote reduce or eliminate discrimination the very idea that one can quote
00:13:51 eliminate discrimination by harshly punishing individuals for expressing their honestly held
00:13:58 opinions and fears is an extremely questionable assumption that the supreme court doesn't even
00:14:04 bother to try to defend. This judgment isn't about defending arguments or interpreting legal
00:14:12 precedents. It is about overturning the values that have traditionally been the basis of Canadian
00:14:19 society and replacing them with new values made up by social justice ideologues. The judgment
00:14:27 states, for example, that freedom of expression can and should be balanced against, quote,
00:14:32 respect for group identity. Now, when did respect for group identity become a right
00:14:40 of any sort, let alone a right that competes with and even overrides the right to freedom of
00:14:47 expression? And how can respect, as opposed to measurable equal treatment, how can respect
00:14:55 possibly be legislated? But it gets even worse as one reads the judgment. At one point,
00:15:01 the Supreme Court justices assert that, quote, the benefits of the suppression of hate speech
00:15:09 and its harmful effects outweigh the detrimental effect of restricting expression, which by its
00:15:17 nature does little to promote the values underlying freedom of expression, end quote.
00:15:25 In other words, Watkot's expression did not promote free expression and is therefore better
00:15:33 suppressed. This grammatically garbled contention that free speech matters only when it is speech
00:15:41 of a certain type, the type that promotes, quote, the values underlying it, well, it's totally
00:15:49 specious. Freedom of expression is itself a value. If expression is made conditional on
00:15:56 promoting a particular set of values, then it is clearly not in any sense free or valued in itself.
00:16:05 One can only conclude that the authors of the judgment are either not clear in their own minds
00:16:12 what freedom of expression means, or they seek to confuse readers as to its nature.
00:16:20 But most egregiously of all, the Supreme Court judgment states emphatically
00:16:25 that truth is no defense against a charge of hate speech. Here it is.
00:16:34 Truthful statements can be presented in a manner that would meet the definition of hate speech,
00:16:42 were told in their Orwellian formulation. And not all truthful statements must be free from
00:16:51 restriction. When even truth must be weighed against the potential of words to bring an
00:17:00 individual or group into social disrepute, the mind boggles at the implications, the possibility
00:17:09 for judicial abuse and the chill on open discussion that will result. That was nearly four years ago,
00:17:18 and as I said, nobody protested or even really noticed. So we are already at the point where
00:17:26 one can be found guilty of contravening human rights law for speaking the truth depending on
00:17:32 who complains. With a system already fully in place for enforcing orthodoxy, the vast
00:17:42 uprising against these laws necessary to make a change seems unlikely to happen because it's way
00:17:50 too dangerous. Indeed, Jordan Peterson's case shows that the contest is essentially over and
00:17:57 the enforcers have won. All it would take to push back against such thought control
00:18:04 at the University of Toronto would be for a significant minority of other professors
00:18:09 to come forward to say something like, if Jordan Peterson is going to be disciplined, 0.95
00:18:15 then you'd better discipline me too, because this is ridiculous. I support Jordan Peterson's right 0.77
00:18:22 not to be forced to call somebody G. That's how it would happen in a movie.
00:18:30 But this isn't a movie. And the silence of the professors is deafening. To my knowledge,
00:18:36 only Gad Saad has come out in strong support of Professor Peterson. The other professors are either
00:18:43 on the side of the radicals or too scared to say boo, and with good reason.
00:18:48 so for what it's worth let me say here that if Jordan Peterson is going to be hauled before a
00:18:55 human rights tribunal I want to go too I'm already being taken before one on a different matter so
00:19:01 maybe they can lump in a charge of misgendering too and trust me you guardians of our human rights
00:19:07 whatever fine you give to Jordan Peterson we'll pay it for him we ordinary people who don't like
00:19:14 your way of, quote, eliminating discrimination by persecuting decent people for standing on
00:19:21 principle. Professor Peterson talks in the first video about people being driven to the brink of
00:19:27 madness by our politically correct culture. These are people he's actually seen in his clinical
00:19:34 practice, people whose work environment is forcing them to take up ideological positions that they
00:19:40 don't even believe in and he's talking about teachers feeling that they really
00:19:45 can't teach anymore because they have to constantly self-censor and as all the
00:19:51 reaction to his videos attests what he was articulating was not just a fear and
00:19:56 not just a good hunch about the future but a very clear diagnosis of the
00:20:02 present reality we will all now have to knuckle under or stand up and be
00:20:10 punished. Either way, it's becoming increasingly difficult or impossible to avoid the madness of
00:20:18 our culture.