The Fiamengo File - November 24, 2016


When Feminists Control The Past - TFF Episode 53

Jordan Peterson and Freedom of Speech - TFF Episode 52 Save Us from Social Justice - TFF Episode 54

Episode Stats


Length

12 minutes

Words per minute

133.77

Word count

1,710

Sentence count

43

Harmful content

Misogyny

11

sentences flagged

Hate speech

4

sentences flagged


Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
00:00:00 George Orwell told us in his novel 1984, quote,
00:00:05 He who controls the past controls the future.
00:00:09 He who controls the present controls the past, end quote. 1.00
00:00:14 Why do we allow feminists to control the past? 1.00
00:00:19 That's my subject on today's Fiamengo File.
00:00:22 I'm Janice Fiamengo of the University of Ottawa. There is perhaps no subject of study in all
00:00:34 of academia today whose takeover by feminist dogma has had more unfortunate consequences
00:00:39 than that of history. Feminism has a lot of traction today, largely because we as a society
00:00:47 have come to accept that our history has been one of men dominating women. It's the one thing I can 0.84
00:00:54 rely on all my students to think they know, that up until about 20 years ago, men had all the rights, 0.99
00:01:03 women none. In an earlier video, I talked about the widespread idea that when women won the right 0.93
00:01:09 to vote in the early 20th century that all men had been voting for many many years which isn't true
00:01:17 but the vast majority of people believe it is and as a result of that perception even when
00:01:24 some aspect of our current social situation is clearly unjust as in the cases of preferential
00:01:31 hiring rape shield law or domestic violence policies just to name a few the injustice
00:01:39 is considered acceptable or at least not terrible because of the idea that it is a corrective to
00:01:48 make up for centuries during which women were mistreated and men had it way too good again
00:01:54 it isn't true the vast majority of men never had privilege but academic historians the people who
00:02:03 should be helping us toward a right understanding are all too often in thrall to the feminist
00:02:10 narrative how this came to be is a fascinating story of cultural takeover the academic discipline
00:02:18 of history was traditionally the study of the great events that shaped societies at the macro
00:02:24 level. It was the history of battles lost and won, of the development of forms of government
00:02:31 and legal norms, and of large-scale economic changes. Then out of the social ferment of the
00:02:38 1960s came an interest in a different kind of history, one that focused not on the epoch-making
00:02:44 lives of great men but on the everyday lives of ordinary people not coincidentally this history
00:02:51 also included a lot more women and was guided by an explicitly ideological commitment with cultural
00:02:58 marxist and feminist roots it was called social history and it turned its attention to the so-called
00:03:05 marginalized and the oppressed telling their stories as an act of protest against a society
00:03:11 that had supposedly sidelined them so much of what we now think we know about women and men
00:03:19 in the past has filtered down to us from this kind of social history the history always of
00:03:26 women struggling heroically against oppressive conditions that supposedly benefited all men
00:03:34 it's a simplified distorted view of the past that severely compromises our ability to come to fair
00:03:40 conclusions about how we got to where we are today and we desperately need an academic revolution
00:03:48 that will provide us with a more accurate perspective now this subject is too large to
00:03:53 be addressed in one video and unfortunately i'm not a trained historian with the expertise to do so
00:04:00 but today i want to look at one example of how general perceptions of history shaped by feminism
00:04:07 have very little to do with reality. Most of us have been led to believe that before feminists 0.96
00:04:15 tackled the issue of rape, we lived in a rape culture. Well, even more of a rape culture than 1.00
00:04:22 they say we now live in. In other words, in the past, according to feminism, rape was considered 1.00
00:04:29 normal, men weren't punished for it, and when it was recognized, women were blamed for supposedly 0.98
00:04:36 asking for it. There were no protections for women. But a book by a scholar named Karen Dubinsky,
00:04:44 with the title Improper Advances, Rape and Heterosexual Conflict in Ontario 1880-1929,
00:04:54 it shows that this couldn't be further from the truth. Dubinsky's examination of court records
00:05:01 from the late 19th and early 20th centuries reveals that the protection of women from male
00:05:07 sexuality and the punishment of male offenders were primary considerations in our supposedly
00:05:15 patriarchal, brutal, misogynistic past. Now, the interesting thing is that Dubinsky herself
00:05:23 is a feminist historian, and her feminism shows through strongly in her language and
00:05:29 emphasis in the book for example she places a lot of stress on women's supposed lack of control
00:05:36 over their sexual lives which she sees as an aspect of the patriarchal oppression of women 0.92
00:05:42 so at the beginning of the third chapter of her book for example she states quote
00:05:47 in a culture that denied full political and economic citizenship to women it is not surprising
00:05:56 that women were denied cultural and legal control over their sexuality then as now women and men
00:06:05 did not face each other as equals in the bedroom any more than they did in the factory the street
00:06:12 or government institutions end quote obviously the implication of those sentences is that women
00:06:21 suffered political economic and legal disabilities that men did not and that most men white men
00:06:28 anyway did have full political and economic citizenship and did have quote cultural and
00:06:36 legal control over their sexuality end quote in short men had more power than women 0.91
00:06:43 But the many examples that Dubinsky provides simply do not support her feminist contention.
00:06:52 What the examples show is that then, as now, women were protected under the law and men
00:06:59 harshly punished even for consensual sexual relations. Dubinsky describes how in the early
00:07:07 1880s a politician named john charlton introduced a bill that became law in 1886 for what was then
00:07:16 called the crime of seduction which has fascinating parallels to our own era in its total rejection
00:07:24 of the notion of consent according to this definition of the crime a man could be prosecuted
00:07:31 for consensual sex under three different scenarios first if he had sex with a girl under the age of
00:07:39 16. second if he had sexual relations with a woman under the age of 21 if he had promised marriage
00:07:47 to her which he then reneged on or third if she was his employee now in condition number two women
00:07:56 could claim that their consent was contingent on the man's promise of marriage and that
00:08:03 she had been taken advantage of without her consent if the man changed his mind about marrying
00:08:10 her or if he had never really intended to. The maximum penalty for the crime of seduction was
00:08:17 two years in prison. Dubinsky argues that the records of criminal prosecutions for seduction
00:08:24 show how the state quote entrenched the legal and parental regulation of women and punished women
00:08:35 who transgress cultural prohibitions of female desire end quote that's feminist speak obviously 0.94
00:08:42 for it harmed the women but the examples show that although yes to some extent female sexuality was 1.00
00:08:51 being regulated. By far, the greater social burden was being borne by men, who were often harshly
00:08:59 punished for engaging in consensual sex. In one example, a 15-year-old girl named Mary Ellen T.
00:09:08 became involved with one Patrick C., an Oshawa iron worker and boarder at Mary Ellen's family
00:09:15 home interestingly we're not told how old he was her father figured out that something was going
00:09:23 on between them and one night he spied on them having sex in the kitchen as he later told the
00:09:28 court it was clearly consensual sex not coerced and it was sex that had been going on for some
00:09:34 time the next morning the father went immediately to the police who arrested patrick mary did not
00:09:41 even testify at the trial that found Patrick guilty of seduction. Dubinsky ends the account
00:09:48 by saying that, quote, it appears that in this case, prosecution acted to punish Patrick C.
00:09:55 as well as his wayward girlfriend by ending what appears to have been a mutual desired relationship
00:10:02 and by exposing her intimate life to public scrutiny, end quote. Well, that's one way of
00:10:10 putting it, but I would be inclined to say that it was clearly Patrick who suffered the far more
00:10:15 severe exposure of his intimate life to public scrutiny and on whom the real penalty fell.
00:10:23 After all, Mary went back to her life in her father's house while Patrick went to jail.
00:10:28 So uninterested is Dubinsky in the male side of things that she doesn't even tell us the length
00:10:36 of the prison term to which Patrick was sentenced. In other examples, a woman or her parents could
00:10:44 take a man to court in order to force him to marry her after she became pregnant. All she had to do 1.00
00:10:52 in these cases in order to pursue a charge of criminal seduction was to allege that the man
00:10:58 had at some point promised to marry her. Although such cases didn't always result
00:11:05 in a successful prosecution, the threat itself, obviously, was often powerful enough to make the
00:11:12 man agree to marriage. So this is clearly a case where, far from having control over their sexuality,
00:11:20 men were at the mercy of women's claims and were often mandated by their society to fulfill the
00:11:29 wishes of a woman and her family. Indeed, as Dubinsky alleged, men and women did not face
00:11:36 each other as sexual equals because only a man could commit a sexual crime and only a man could
00:11:45 be forced to pay the penalty in jail time. So who had the least power here? Far from
00:11:53 being victims of punitive social attitudes and predatory men, women had considerable
00:12:00 social and legal clout in Victorian Canada. And there were significant measures then as
00:12:07 now to protect women. It's too bad that this isn't more widely known. As I said earlier,
00:12:16 we desperately need a revolution in scholarship that will give us a more accurate picture of 0.70
00:12:22 women's and men's lives in the past, one that isn't governed by the model of the victimized woman
00:12:29 and the privileged man.
00:12:32 If you work or study social history,
00:12:35 please be part of dismantling the feminist narrative.
00:12:40 We owe it to ourselves and to future generations
00:12:44 not to lie about the past.