00:00:00Other lawyers and even members of the HRTs themselves regard Canada's human rights tribunals with head-shaking disbelief.
00:00:09A gong show, one lawyer called them. A crap shoot, said another. Now I'm going to meet one myself.0.99
00:00:17That's my subject on today's Fiamengo File.
00:00:26I'm Janice Fiamengo of the University of Ottawa.
00:00:28In this video, I'm not going to speak about the human rights violation charge against me, though I will do so in time.
00:00:37Instead, I'm going to speak in general about Canada's human rights tribunals and what they mean for freedom and justice in this country and across the West.
00:00:48And to all those who donated to my legal defense, I am more grateful than I can say.
00:00:54I've always had a horrified fascination with our tribunal system which proposes to eliminate what
00:01:01it calls hate or discriminatory attitudes by fining people and shaming them publicly.
00:01:08The tribunals work on the principle that you can actually force people to respect others by
00:01:14punishing them over even trivial misunderstandings or honest expressions of opinion. They elevate
00:01:22certain individuals and groups into protected classes of people who know they can get money
00:01:28out of others by claiming to feel hurt or threatened by something that was said or done.
00:01:34The whole system makes people afraid to say what they really think. It creates a climate of
00:01:41suspicion and opportunism, of revenge and resentment. In two infamous cases, Ezra Levant
00:01:49was prosecuted for publishing the Danish cartoons of Muhammad, and Maclean's magazine had to defend
00:01:56itself for publishing Mark Stein on the potential consequences of large-scale Muslim immigration to
00:02:02Canada. Both of these respondents eventually won their cases, but at enormous cost in time and
00:02:10money. And this is how the tribunals work. Even when the respondent is not found guilty, they've
00:02:17still been punished. And other magazines and individuals will think twice about publishing
00:02:22anything that might be deemed hateful. Ezra Levant and Mark Stein are of course media
00:02:29personalities with large followings and powerful resources. But we don't hear about all the other
00:02:36cases involving ordinary people, people who lack the money and or the public profile necessary to
00:02:43defend themselves and who have been quietly having their lives turned upside down by our
00:02:48human rights watchdogs, who are certain that they know how to create a social utopia.
00:02:55So as I sat in the lobby of the building where the mediation session was going to take place for my
00:03:01case, a session that failed, I felt as if much of my adult life had been leading to the moment in
00:03:08which I would stand before the Ontario Human Rights Tribunal. I've been a thought criminal
00:03:14for a long time. According to its cheerful website, the Human Rights Tribunal of Ontario,
00:03:21which is one of seven tribunals that fall under the Social Justice Tribunals Ontario,
00:03:29states that it, quote, resolves claims of discrimination and harassment brought under
00:03:34the Human Rights Code in a fair, just, and timely way." What that means is that if you're a small
00:03:42business owner or a manager in an office or school or the president of a condo board, etc.,
00:03:49a disgruntled employee or client can bring a complaint against you and your small business,
00:03:54alleging that you discriminated on the basis of race, sex, disability, religion, or what have you.
00:04:00There's a substantial list of the prohibited grounds of discrimination on the Ontario HRT website.
00:04:07And for that, you can spend at least a year, in many cases much longer, defending yourself before a quasi-legal tribunal.
00:04:18If found guilty, you can be required to undergo re-education training, pay thousands of dollars in compensation to the complainant,
00:04:26or spend tens of thousands of dollars to change your business to bring it into compliance with
00:04:32the code. In most cases, the rulings are final and cannot be appealed. Human rights tribunals
00:04:39use legal-sounding terms like complainant and respondent and have legal power to compel
00:04:47compliance, including compliance to pay the fines they levy, but they do not operate according to
00:04:53traditional legal principles. Unlike in regular courts of law, they do not begin with the
00:04:59presumption of innocence, and the complainant need not prove discrimination beyond a reasonable
00:05:05doubt. Instead, tribunals use the balance of probabilities model, which means discrimination
00:05:11merely has to be shown to have been more likely than not. In other words, 50% plus one. As the
00:05:19Human Rights Legal Support Center explains to prospective complainants, it can be hard to prove
00:05:26discrimination absolutely, but that doesn't mean you shouldn't try. The website counsels as follows,
00:05:34quote, discrimination may be hidden or subtle and can be the product of unspoken beliefs,
00:05:41biases, and prejudices. This means that in many cases, discrimination can only be proved by
00:05:48drawing inferences and conclusions from the circumstances surrounding an instance of negative
00:05:55or unfair treatment. To prove discrimination, you must be able to show at your hearing that it is
00:06:01more likely and not that in all of the circumstances, discrimination was a factor
00:06:06in the events or actions. End quote. Note the waffly language. Discrimination is not always
00:06:14overt, i.e. the person accused doesn't have to actually state their supposed bigotry overtly.
00:06:22Often the discrimination can only be, quote, proved by, quote, drawing inferences from the
00:06:28circumstances, end quote. In other words, it doesn't have to be proved at all. It is inferred.
00:06:37If I infer something, I'm presuming it. I'm speculating. I'm even guessing. I'm not drawing
00:06:44a strictly logical evidence-based conclusion. And given that Canadian society is supposedly
00:06:50permeated by racist and sexist and other forms of discriminatory hatred, it is all too likely
00:06:57that in the SJW mind, any instance of negative treatment can be inferred to spring at least
00:07:03partly from discriminatory beliefs or prejudices. This is a recipe for finding human rights abuses
00:07:11everywhere. Unlike regular courts of law, tribunals don't provide legal counsel to the accused.
00:07:20In most cases, a respondent, someone accused, simply has to go in there and take his chances
00:07:27with accusations of racism or sexism or any other kind of horrible bigotry with all the attendant
00:07:34shame, discomfort, and uncertainty. The respondent spends months waiting, wondering, questioning
00:07:41himself, answering others' questions. He'll have to try to prove that in his heart he doesn't
00:07:48harbor hatred against Croatians or the disabled or cross-dressers or whatever, even while dealing
00:07:55with an adjudicator who suspects he likely does, because we know what a problem bigotry is in our
00:08:02society. The vast majority of adjudicators are not judges but are rather social justice advocates
00:08:11who studied law less because of a passion for law itself than because of their desire to change the
00:08:17world to make it better for victims. Take a look yourself at the list of social justice tribunal
00:08:24members to get a sense of who decides the cases. The vast majority of them are involved with one
00:08:31or more of feminist, environmentalist, anti-racist, anti-poverty or disability rights activism and so
00:08:38on. They're hardly impartial. The Human Rights Tribunal is a place where self-proclaimed victims
00:08:46without having to prove beyond a reasonable doubt that a law was broken can get compensation for
00:08:52their claimed grievances and where social justice advocates peer into the tainted souls of the
00:08:58accused to consider whether it is more likely than not that prejudice may have played some
00:09:04role in their actions. Proof that the entire tribunal system is slanted toward the complainant's
00:09:12rights rather than those of the accused is found on the website, which is almost entirely focused
00:09:18on complainant issues, such as how to file a complaint or how to calculate the interest on
00:09:24any money awarded, and so on. Yeah, that's right. The defendant may have to pay interest on any
00:09:32money he or she is forced to pay to the complainant based on the time that has elapsed between the
00:09:37date of the alleged discriminatory incident and the date years later when the Human Rights
00:09:43Tribunal finally makes its ruling. It's a system that invites people with complaints to come forward
00:09:50and try their luck because they very well might profit from the experience or at least work out
00:09:56their spleen at no cost to themselves except their time. A complainant can pull out of the process
00:10:04without penalty at any time if it looks as if the case isn't going their way. They can simply
00:10:10abandon the whole thing. And no compensation for the time and money lost or the personal
00:10:16stress involved is ever offered to the respondent. And if you're the respondent, you aren't allowed
00:10:23to sue the complainant for whatever terrible, untrue things they alleged about you due to the
00:10:30tribunal's non-retaliation rules. So, what do you think? Is this a system that is likely to produce
00:10:37peace and harmony in society? Or is it likely to produce fear and resentment, opportunism and
00:10:45false claims of discrimination. You already know what I think. So am I exaggerating? Am I
00:10:51misrepresenting the kinds of cases the tribunals deal with and the kinds of judgments they render?
00:10:58In my next video, I'm going to tell you about two typical cases that came before the Ontario
00:11:02Human Rights Tribunal in the past decade to give you a flavor of the tribunal's vision of justice.
00:11:09What I found confirms the satirical witticism that SJWs are people who read Orwell's 1984,
00:11:17not as a warning, but as a manual. Please stay tuned.